*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/forums.php/message_id/3070600
Printer Friendly Page Tell A Friend
(683)
Rated: 13+ · Message Forum · Writing.Com · #100931
A message forum for general discussion. Please come and chat with others!
<< Previous  •  Message List  •  Next >>
Reply  •  Post New
Feb 20, 2017 at 8:18pm
#3070600
Re: Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters
by A Non-Existent User
I'd agree much more with you if we were discussing film or TV, where a person's colour is a visual.
However, in literature, you have to draw attention to the colour of a person's skin, and if they are just black, or Chinese etc without there being a meaningful purpose, then it does become token.
Bringing women into your argument isn't quite relevant, as for the most part, names identify male or female so specifying the gender isn't important. But as you say, as an engineer you were a bunch of engineers, not a bunch of black guys. But in a story, if you say 'the black engineer' then you're no longer just a bunch of engineers. One is being identified by colour as well. Unless there is a reason for the character being black, beyond representing census figures, then it's token. If there is a reason, then it's important to research properly and choose a story/character that accurately reflects being a black person in that situation.
I'm not saying writing shouldn't be diverse. Absolutely it should, if it's not to be boring and limited. Yet it doesn't show diversity if the black engineer's blackness is merely a matter of his skin colour. It does, if it shows his personal journey and how being black affects his life. Diversity is a lot more than just labelling people by colour.
You asked about my work. 98% female, and 100% white. These figures in no way reflect the larger society which is 69% white 14% Maori and the rest Asian etc. Writing about a male Maori teacher wouldn't be representative of the demographics. Yet one of the best teachers I ever worked with is a Maori male, and both those aspects have a huge impact on who he is. He is the chief of his iwi, he became a teacher because he sees it as his duty to be a positive role model for young Maori, and to break the negative stereotypes and racial slurs against Maori. He had some interesting struggles on his way to becoming a teacher. This is where the diversity lies, in the actual stories. If these aren't explored, then it's tokenism.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
MESSAGE THREAD
White writers writing POC characters · 02-14-17 7:03pm
by Bobbi
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-14-17 7:32pm
by Legerdemain
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-14-17 8:36pm
by Steev the Friction Wizurd
Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-14-17 8:48pm
by Bobbi
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-14-17 10:34pm
by Amyaurora
Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-15-17 9:01am
by KenF
Re: Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-17-17 8:27pm
by A Non-Existent User
Re: Re: Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-18-17 7:27pm
by Eric the Fred
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-17-17 8:17pm
by A Non-Existent User
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-18-17 7:36pm
by A Non-Existent User
Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-20-17 9:23am
by KenF
Re: Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-20-17 9:48am
by Elisa the Bunny Stik
*Star* Re: Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-20-17 8:18pm
by A Non-Existent User
Re: Re: Re: Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-21-17 9:16am
by KenF
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-19-17 11:31am
by Elisa the Bunny Stik
Re: White writers writing POC characters · 02-21-17 12:45pm
by Steev the Friction Wizurd

The following section applies to this forum item as a whole, not this individual post.
Any feedback sent through it will go to the forum's owner, Writing.Com Support.
Log in to Leave Feedback
Username:
Password: <Show>
Not a Member?
Signup right now, for free!
All accounts include:
*Bullet* FREE Email @Writing.Com!
*Bullet* FREE Portfolio Services!
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/forums.php/message_id/3070600