|
So I started reading The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern. You've probably heard of it: there was buzz all last year before it came out, and in fact it had the largest advance for a debut novel in all of 2011. It bridges that nice world between historical fiction and magical realism, but not terrible magical realism like The Uncoupling, don't worry.
I've had it on my to-read list for a while, waiting for it to show up on the library shelves. Last week, it did.
I'm about 100 pages in right now, from train rides this morning and tonight and half of my lunch hour this afternoon. I figured I would give it a shot before this weekend, since I only have a day and a half before leaving for a business trip to Florida, and I wanted to see if it's worth lugging with me on the plane. Now, I think I might read too much of it before getting on the plane to justify the space in my carry-on.
This is the thing: it's not a great book. The writing is choppy in places and clunky in others (though I suppose not as clunky as your usual present-tense narrative), and there is a weirdly high number of pointless comma splices (which is to say, astylistic comma splices, assuming you subscribe to the theory that a comma splice can be stylistic, which I personally do not*). And on every page, I just think I'm reading The Prestige.
I can't say that The Night Circus is derivative, because I haven't read The Prestige, only seen the movie. But it's all there: the dueling magicians, the fact that their illusions are real (sorry, spoiler alert, but that movie came out like five years ago), the dark setting at the turn of the industrial age.
So why do I like it? I don't really know. The places where it isn't clunky, the writing is solid. The plot is interesting, if not original, and I really do care about what is going to happen. I enjoyed it so much on my train ride in that I lugged it along with me to lunch, instead of listening to the second half of Hunger Games 3. (So far: better than Hunger Games 2, not nearly as good as Hunger Games 1.) This is impressive, considering that the book is enormous and my iPod Nano is tiny. But I did. I lugged. And I read, and read, and read, until my banh mi sandwich was ready. (Luu's Baguette, 26th Street: best banh mi I've had in New York City.)
The sandwich was so phenomenal that I didn't read much after that. So, to recap: Hunger Games 3 < The Night Circus < banh mi sandwich. But that's unfair to poor Erin Morgenstern. Not many books can pull someone away from a perfectly-made banh mi.
Has anyone else read this book? Can I expect something different from The Prestige in the coming chapters? A deus ex machina like in the movie?
(I recently read a new release called Deus Ex Machina. LibraryThing predicted I would love it. I did not.)
*For me, a run-on or a fragment can be stylistic, but I have never in my life seen a "stylistic" comma splice that worked. Never. Nor can I imagine a theoretical case in which it would be necessary or even better than properly punctuated sentences.
|