*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/blueasice
Review Requests: OFF
93 Public Reviews Given
93 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I like to keep the format clean and easy to read. How I'll specifically break down your story is a detail that I'm currently reworking, however.
I'm good at...
Most familiar with these genres: romance, YA, fantasy, mystery I focus most heavily on character development, subtly in details, flow, overall composition/structure, diction, and syntax.
Favorite Genres
Romance, Mystery, Fantasy
Public Reviews
Previous ... -1- 2 ... Next
1
1
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*RainbowL*Hey, there!*RainbowR*

Not the typical format used in conest forms (at least from the one's I've seen).

*RibbonP* You did really well writing out the rules; they are clear and to-the-point, and I'm not left wondering what I exactly need to do.

*CupcakeB* Overall, I like the idea for this contest; it'll help me to get more involved with the contests and such here on WDC *Smile* Thanks for it!
2
2
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Overall Impression: The imagery is good in this piece. I get the vibe of a country-like setting and varying levels of ubiquitous grasses. The format of the poem really stands out. As first lines go, I think yours really serve to pull in the ready. The express awesome imagery that I just love to think up in my head.

Suggestions: Some of the syllabub counts sounded off, usually a bit short. Such as the last two lines of the first stanza. When I read them, I kept on wanting to add a word and felt like something was missing.

I find it overall hard to understand exactly what it is you're saying. The meaning isn't quite clear and feels as if it is hopping around.

Other than that, though, I find it to be a great poem and enjoyed the read *Bigsmile*

Write on!
3
3
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Hey there! I clicked on this poem because the title caught my attention.

I really liked this poem. Not too long, not too short. I agree with the sentiments expressed. Not every thing we wish to work out does, especially when it comes to relationships with people. Sad but true. And it only gets better if we look to the future. I really liked the format you used, the 'Here today, gone tomorrow' line connected with each other first lines in the other stanzas for a nice tie-together. My favorite stanza is probably the last one, as it brings in the whole main idea and closes right.

As for suggestions, the only awkward part I thought was there as I read was the second stanza. The syllabubs seemed to fall short in comparison to the others. I may have that wrong, though. Other than that, though, the rhyme scheme was spot on, and the overall message shined through. Definitely an enjoyed read.

Thanks for sharing! *Bigsmile*

An "Invalid Item Review
4
4
for entry "Chapter One
In affiliation with Newby Novelists  
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Title: "The Tome of Agrimar
Chapter:"Chapter One
Author:April Dawn

Plot: Great pacing; flows smoothly with little awkward points; a half-ling named Kendra meets a guy named Talon who is injured.

Style and Voice: Consistent style as far as I could tell; see line-by-line as I comment a few times on adverb usage.

Referencing: While Kendra's dialogue is a bit modern, I think you get away with it considering this is your own world and it doesn't read awkwardly.

Setting: On a highway; there is good description, though the road scenery tends to mesh into one continuous setting reel.

Characters:Good introduction of characters. Dialogue supports personality and persona.

Grammar: See line-by-line; grammar suggestions are made in-between [ ]

Just my Opinion: I thought this was a very good opening chapter. The set up of a great plot is in motion, and I am curious as to who this Talon person really his. What's his story? And the romantic in me always has to wonder if he's too old for Kendra, lol. I like your writing style. S'got potential.

Line By Line:

"Hey! Wait for me!" A small pair of feet pounded against the ground, sending up clouds of dust in their wake. The bare expanse of a dirt road extended far ahead of the running figure, and off in the distance could be seen the retreating silhouette of a mule-drawn caravan.

Great opening. The dialogue makes the reader question: Who needs to wait for who? What's going on? The description afterword is clear and descriptive.

"Come back!" piped the squeaky, feminine voice of Kendra Shakaby. The distance between her and the buggy was only increasing, and the small woman slowed to a panting stop, her hair tumbling in front of her face as her head tilted down toward the ground, hands on her knees. She blew at the pesky strands, only succeeding in getting them caught between her lips, and with a sputter, she brought her hands up to pull her long unruly brown hair back into the ponytail from which it had escaped.

Also good imagery.

That settled, Kendra straightened her plain tunic and adjusted the belt of her pants, and finally rested her hands on the straps of her large pack as she gave a discontented huff and looked off into the empty distance. "Well, who needs them," she said, turning around purposefully and taking a strong stride forward along the road in the opposite direction. "I was ready for another adventure anyway."

Just as a suggestion: "...Kendra straightened her plain tunic and adjusted the belt of her pants, and finally rested her hands...." with this sentence, perhaps take out the first 'and', and replace with a comma.

It wasn't long before the short, rugged young woman had picked up a spring in her step and was whistling to herself as she walked the long dusty expanse in solitude. The sun was shining, the birds were chirping, and a vast stretch of unexplored road stood between her and her unknown destination. Everything was looking splendidly magnificent. Kendra looked up at the sky and took a deep whiff of the fresh country air, releasing a satisfied sigh as she admired the beauty of some passing clouds.

I guess that is simply her character, but, if she were that irritated, wouldn't she at least grumble about whoever left her behind? That's what the reader is wondering.

Suddenly, she was tumbling forward, her foot caught on something in her path and with a startled yelp, Kendra fell in a tangled heap sputtering out a mouthful of dirt. "What on Rok... oh!" The sparkle of a crystalline masterpiece caught her eye. Fumbling clumsily with her hair that had fallen back in front of her face, Kendra scooted over to examine the “sparkle”.

The first sentence is a bit of a mouthful. Those 'tripping' scenes can be stuff. My style would intermix into something like:

'Suddenly, her foot caught on a solid, protruding object and tumbled like the dust into the ground. Sputtering a mouthful of dry dirt and a frustrated, "What on Rock...!" Her attentions turned toward the strange something that had caused her fall. "Oh!" Fumbling with disobedient locks of hair, she scooted back to examine the 'sparkle'.

Or something like that, lol.


After wrestling the ponytail back into submission, she picked up the unique, rather lovely looking, figurine tenderly between her fingers and held it in front of her face to admire. It was a tiny statue of excellent workmanship, carved in the form of a silver dragon. It had ruby claws and sapphire eyes, the jewels alone suggesting it to be of great value. Surely no one would have left such a wonderful treasure on purpose. With the dirt of the road tumbling easily away from the smooth, unmarred glass, it had clearly been well cared for. "Someone must be missing you," Kendra said to the dragon, bringing up the edge of her tunic in an attempt to brush off a little dust. "I'll make sure you're well looked after, until we find your owner."

It's not a must, but I would separate Kendra's dialogue away from the description dialogue.

Within moments[,] the statue was brushed clean and sparkling like new. Kendra gave the figure another thorough examination before nodding happily and placing the lost item in her roughsack with a smile. She then picked herself up off the road and patted the dust out of her pants before continuing onward, her imagination swimming with all the possible events that could have landed that lovely little dragon in her pack.

Perhaps it had been lost as its owner was caught in a fight for his life, neither victim nor attacker noticing its fall from the sack as they focused on survival. No. Such a struggle would cause it to become stained or broken, as it was certainly a delicate creation.

Maybe a thief had filched it off a wealthy traveler and, not respecting the great value of such a craft, lost it in a tussle with one of his companions over some greater treasure. Simple, believable, but not nearly exciting enough.

Kendra fancied it had been the coveted masterpiece of some great wizard traveling in disguise as a mere peasant. It would, of course, have been bespelled in order to summon the dragon depicted with a secret word. The wizard would also have cursed the item, so that any who stole it would bring bad fortune upon themselves, until the statue was returned. The figurine would also most certainly be the heirloom of an ancient King, destined to be passed on to a young, unknown heir to the throne, to whom the wizard was bringing the statue. The wizard probably found the boy he was to pass the statue on to, and the boy, not believing the wizened man's story, would have tossed the item aside, too ignorant to attempt to fetch a price for it. Now, Kendra was bound to find that boy or the wizard and become entwined in a wonderful adventure.

I like the musings here of the statue's origins.

Time had passed as Kendra wandered the dusty road, lost in her musings, leaving the sun falling low over the horizon. The blinding light irritated her eyes, and a growl from her stomach irritated her daydreams. "I suppose its time to make camp for the evening," Kendra said to herself, swinging her bag off her back and tossing it off to the roadside, following the sailing mass and meeting it as it tumbled to a stop in the grass.

The question still lingers: what was Kendra left behind from? While it may/may not be important to the overall plot, it helps place Kendra as a person; without, Kendra seems random and her placing unrealistic.

A final thump placed the sack against a large rock hidden by overgrown weeds, and the young woman, just a few strides behind in lazy pursuit, could have sworn she heard a muffled "ouch".

She stopped mid-step as she leaned forward, legs stiff, trying to see what her bag must have bumped into. What Kendra had mistaken for a rock was not a rock at all, but a pair of boots. Taking another few careful steps forward, she saw that the boots were attached to a sprawled out body, which upon examination proved to be in rather nasty shape. It was an older man, his clothes torn and matted in a mixture of mud and blood.

A flutter of black feathers revealed a large bird that Kendra had not noticed until that point. It had been settled on the man’s chest[,] and[,] when he shifted slightly with a soft groan, the black mass jumped up with a squawk and landed by the mans head, grabbing a lock of his hair in its beak and giving it a tug.

"Hey, shoo! Shoo!" Kendra said, rushing forward and waving her hands, sending the bird away in an angry flurry of feathers. "He's not dead yet!" The young woman glared after the retreating bird and watched it land on a low branch of a nearby tree, settling down to watch her in return. Convinced the dark animal would now keep its distance, Kendra gave a satisfied nod and hurried over to the side of the injured figure.

Good flow here. I can see what's going on.

"Sir," she said, placing a hand on his chest to feel a slow but steady heartbeat and the rise and fall of his ragged breathing. When she received no response, she leaned forward to look into his face and repeated loudly, "SIR!"

With another groan, his eyes squinting tightly in apparent pain, the man raised his arm to weakly try and push Kendra away. "Leave me be!" he croaked, and Kendra gave a yelp of surprise as the bird took a swipe at the back of her head. Kendra rubbed her grazed scalp and glared once again after the bird as it returned to its branch.

I like to try and always avoid adverbs. Even in simply rewriting 'weakly' into something like '... raised his arm to try and push Kendra away with a forceful but weak shove...' (or something of the sort) can reveal things about the particular character without the author ever having to 'say' it.

"Well, how’s that for gratitude," the small woman huffed. "This bird here was determined to eat you, mister. I just saved your life. I was going to dress your wounds too, but if you're so sure you don't need any help[,] I could just leave you to care for them yourself."

With a cough and an attempt to sit up, the man glanced skeptically over at his would-be helper. "The raven is my friend."

"Your friend?" Kendra raised a brow and looked back at the large black bird which ruffled its feathers and cackled at her. She snorted. "You need to get some better friends. Ones that won't try to eat you when they think you're dead."

I'd replace 'looked' with something like 'glanced' just to avoid/make sure you don't overuse 'look'.

The bird cawed and spread its wings threateningly, as if it understood what she was saying, and Kendra responded by sticking out her tongue. Meanwhile, the injured man had already begun attempting to care for his own wounds, and he let out a hiss of breath, a stifled moan, as he peeled off the caked on cloth that had been his shirt.

'threateningly' could be replaced with a simile of sorts to relay the same info. i.e. 'The bird cawed and spread its wings like claws' or 'like a cougar flashed its sharp teeth'.

As for the last line, I think you missed a word there. Were you going for, '...he let out a hiss of breath and stifled a moan as he peeled off the caked on cloth...'; if the sentence was purposely written as is, then still take a look at my suggested rewrite as the original is a bit confusing.


“I have neither the time nor patience to entertain children[.][T]he man ruffled through his own bag and pulled out a flask. He yanked out the cork with his teeth and hissed as he poured the alcohol over his wounds. A particularly deep and nasty looking one just under the rib cage drew Kendra’s gaze. She was frowning, but not with concern. Her brow was furrowed as she glared angrily at the man with her arms crossed over her own chest.

'looking one' could be 'rip'

'She was frowning' would sound less passive and be active by rewritting, 'She frowned'.

The 'was' is unneeded in the next line.


“I'm no child,” she replied with a huff. “For your information, I happen to be twenty-three years old, and I've been living on my own for the past six years, thank you very much. I am a very capable adult, though my size and appearance may be deceiving. It’s because I’m a halfling. We are often mistaken for children by those unfamiliar with the race.”

“I am familiar with the race,” the man muttered, his eyebrows raising as he watched the young woman stick her tongue out at the raven again when it cackled. “I’ve just never met one quite so…” his voice trailed off, unable to think of an adequate descriptive word. Oblivious, Kendra continued her face-off with the raven and started spouting a fountain of questions.

"How'd you end up like that anyway? Did someone attack you? Were you in a battle? You were probably jumped by a band of highway men, weren't you? How many were there? I'll bet they took everything you had on you, didn't they? It's a good thing I came along. I've got plenty of supplies in my pack. You should have been paying closer attention to your surroundings. It's real easy to tell where they like to hide if you pay attention. They being the highway men, of course. Your bird was probably distracting you. You're lucky I found you before he started eating you. He would have plucked out your eyeballs first, maybe even while you were still alive. That would have been painful. I saw some birds do that to a rabbit once. Plucked its eyes right out of its skull while it was still kicking. It's their favorite part, you know. They like to get them fresh off the corpse."

Despite it being a big chunk of dialogue, it's quite funny to read.

"Are you sure you're twenty-three?" the man interrupted, his voice harsh and annoyed. Kendra missed the implied insult and merely nodded, counting out the months on her fingers before speaking her reply, "Twenty-four in another five moons."

The man looked her up and down skeptically, and she could just imagine what he must be thinking. She'd heard it all so many times before. How her short, lithe frame made her appear to be nothing more than a child. How her incessant talk and curiosity pestered and annoyed, like a child. How her lack of fear and distrust in others made her seem so much like a child. How her vivid imagination and tirade of creative stories made her so very childish. To be quite honest, she was downright tired of being treated like a child. She placed her hands on her hips and tilted her chin up in defiance.

For clarity, I'd put a '-' as such, '...pestered and annoyed - like a child.' Adds emphasis (at least to me).

"Go ahead and say it. I look like I can't be more than twelve, right? You think I'm just a nuisance little girl that doesn't know anything about the world. Well, for your information, I've taken care of myself just fine for the past six years, and I've helped out quite a few people like yourself, too. In fact, I can handle myself just fine in a fight, too, and I'm not so dumb and inattentive that I'd get overtaken by a bunch of stupid highway men, and I certainly wouldn't call a lousy bird like that my friend."

She's repeating herself here almost word for word (the underline), and the syntax reads a bit dodgy. This paragraph you could probably shorten a bit more, make it more to-the-point.

The raven ruffled its feathers and cackled angrily, leaving Kendra convinced that it did indeed understand her. She simply took the opportunity to stick her tongue out at the bird again. A sigh escaped the man’s lips as he rubbed the bridge of his nose. "I wasn't attacked by highway-men, and the raven was not trying to eat me, little one. Now, if you are really intent on sticking around, I'd appreciate some peace and quiet. I've got a long road ahead of me, and I could really use some good rest."

Her momentary anger forgotten at the mention of a long journey, Kendra found herself spouting another round of curious questions. "So what did happen[,] then? Where are you going? Are you on some kind of quest? I've never been on a quest before, but I bet I could help. Do you--"

The man silenced her with a glare as Kendra realized she wasn't being quiet like he'd asked, and she covered her mouth apologetically. "Oh, right. Well, um... here. I'll make up some food for us[,] and we can talk more in the morning. How's that? And if you want, I can take a look at those wounds to make sure they're healing properly. My father was a healer, and he taught me a few tricks of the trade. I've actually got a bit of a knack for it. He was surprised I didn't want to take up the profession myself. One time-- sorry. That's right. Shutting up now."

That's a really long adverb, lol. 'Apologetically' could be written perhaps as 'she covered her mouth with an apologetic grin'.

Kendra retrieved her bag and started digging through it for her meal provisions, something she could put together quickly since she hadn't stopped to hunt or gather anything along the road. She was just about to go gather some wood to start a fire, when she realized she hadn't even introduced herself to her new companion or asked his name. The young woman turned quickly on her heel to face him once again[no need for the comma] as the raven flew down from its roost in the tree to land on his shoulder.

"By the way, my name's Kendra Shakaby. Sorry, I forgot about introductions. What's your name?"

The man didn't bother looking at her, reaching a finger up to stroke the raven's chest feathers and feeding it some kind of nut as he spoke. "You may call me Talon."

Kendra smiled, not caring or not noticing that he'd avoided giving her an actual name. "Alright, Talon," she said, turning back to resume gathering firewood. "I think we're going to get along just great."

Perhaps keep it as one or the other - 'not caring' or 'not noticing'; putting both jerks the reader from the POV and the story.

An "Invalid Item Review
5
5
Review of A Poem  
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


I really like the premise of this poem. The repetition you used with the line, 'You make my heart sing' is pretty crafty, too. I like the rhyme scheme you used as well. Rhyme scheme is fun, lol. I only have a few suggestions.

Old classics become [anew] - 'anew' here is one word, not two.

Throwing battle wounds[,] leaving evidence over - while grammar isn't always a hard fast rule in poetry, I felt there should be a comma (where indicated) as it makes the syntax a bit clearer.

Thought this was a pretty cool poem. Thanks for sharing *Smile*

6
6
Review of Soulmate  
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Hey there! Welcome to WdC. I clinked to read this poem because I liked the title. Plus, I'm a romantic, so I can't really resist sweet things like this.

I like the sincerity of this piece and how it describes the emotions in different ways. The speaker is giddy on their feet, and it's adorable. Great work with the structure you use, how you format the stanzas. My favorite would be the first. Wonderful way to begin.

My only suggestion is with the word 'feeling' in the second stanza. It's a little vague, and you could probably fish for another word that ties in better with 'Afraid'. Perhaps 'jabbing' or 'squeezing'; think of how it feels in your stomach when you feel afraid.

Great work; thanks for sharing *Smile*
7
7
Review of Burden  
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


These commas are just my thoughts and others may think differently!

A sweet piece on how the speaker feels for their significant other. I liked the rhyme scheme. Short and sweet works well for this piece. Great job *Smile*

As for suggestions go, I think perhaps the title could be tweaked. It doesn't necessarily reflect well with the poem (and the description of it); you could easily change it to something like "Lifted Burden" and that would make more sense.

Also: Let it be known[,] I'm stuck like glue,
No matter what[,] I'll always love you.
- I suggest the commas here.

Hope you enjoy Wdc!


My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
8
8
for entry "Prologue
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Title: "The Tome of Agrimar
Chapter:"Prologue
Author:April Dawn

Plot: A set up to the world the novel is set in; pacing wasn't an issue here, but there wasn't much grab. See line-by-line.

Style and Voice: its a narrative with a bit too much passive syntax; (I do make a comment on this later)Perhaps write this as if your main character is writing it. Give the prologue a bit of subtle personality.

Referencing: n/a

Setting: On a broad scale, a world filled with a variety of creatures, including humans.

Characters: Lady Rokhr, a white dragon;the prologue isn't driven towards character development/presentation

Grammar: See line-by-line; grammatical suggestions are made in between [ ] (if there is nothing in between, it means to get rid of the punctuation that was there)

Just my Opinion: Combined with the fact that I know you can write and I am intrigued with the set up, I can see easily that I want to read more. However, I don't believe this prologue demonstrates your awesome ability. A lot of that is because it's a narration and most people (including me) trip up when we're telling a back story in this way. It takes skill to make the 'telling' parts 'show' rather than 'tell'.

I am intruiged of where you plan to go with this *Smile*

Line By Line:

Dragons are among the oldest and wisest of races. They originate from a world unknown, their history so long and far gone that even they do not remember. For time immeasurable[,] they have had the ability to travel between worlds, through time and space itself. Many would settle on worlds filled with life, to rest and hunt and simply survive. Most cared little for the lesser races, finding them merely interesting, amusing, or simply useless.

Not quite the grab this paragraph could be. Relax a little in the writing, show the readers you have a written personality. I haven't read the rest of this yet, but there's no show of dialogue, so I assume this is an informational/background sort of prologue. If you want to keep readers interested enough to go on further, you need to make sure these paragraphs have a personality in them (i.e. write them as if your main character was telling this).

the first underlined phrase read awkward to me. I suggest just switching the two words for easier flow.

Also needs the indicated comma

Find another way to say 'worlds' as you've already said it in the previous sentence.


Then came the Lady Rokhr. She was a great, strong, majestic and powerful white dragon. She grew in knowledge and wisdom greater than that of her peers, and she took a great interest in the beings of the worlds they traveled. She found that in their short lives[,] humans, elves, dwarves, and other sentient beings provided wondrous spectacles and lessons. Their lives were filled with passion.

Despite the intrigue, its not a descriptive paragraph. Instead of using 'She was', describe her as a dragon.

"Then came the Lady Rokhr. Great, strong, majestic, and swathed in bright white, she hungered for knowledge and wisdom, tasted more of it than her peers cared to, and she found her greatest interest in the beings of the worlds they traveled."

Now I don't have the same image of Lady Rokhor in my head as you do, but the idea is to use strong verbs rather than helping verbs (i.e. was, had, will)


Rokhr wished to learn more and did what no dragon before her had ever done. She deigned to take on the shape of her lesser and walk among them. She studied their growth, their life, their freedom. She was filled with compassion, and decided to create a world of her own to fill with the sentient inhabitants of the many worlds, a world over which she would stand as protector and cultivator.

Cool idea; I like it *Smile*

For the underlined, same idea I was talking about above. Perhaps write, "Her bosom swelled with compassion, in so much that she decided to create a world of her very own - one filled with numerous sentient inhabitants that she's studied - a world over which she stood as protector and cultivator."

The dragon brought together human, elf, dwarf, halfling, merfolk, centaur, minotaur, unicorn, griffon, goblin, and orc. She filled her world with countless plants and animals, carving a great variety of lands- forests, plains, deserts, swamps, bogs, oceans, lakes, rivers, mountains. And she taught them. She gave them technologies and magicks.

Word choice: filled; try replacing that with a different word as you've used it already and so soon. Else it sounds repetitive.

Those who followed her devoutly became known as the Order of Rokhr. The people worshiped her as their creator and protector. Already in her old age when she concocted her plan, she could not remain their protector for long. A few generations grew under her tutelage, and her world began to flow in harmony and order. Hers was a time of peace, but her wisdom and experience assured her that it would not always be so.

Generally, avoid adverb usage unless needed (yeah, I just used one). For 'devoutly', the sentence could be rewritten as "Her devout followers became known as the Order of Rokhr." Although that might not be the most clear way to rewrite it.

These many races would eventually war amongst themselves, but she knew all would remain balanced- the evil weighed equally with the good as her world tipped the scales in favor of equilibrium. There was only one thing that could threaten her creation[] and that was her fellow dragons. Should one decide to toy with her world after she’d passed, she needed to place something there for protection.

Mostly narrative here and a build up to the main point of the prologue.

And so, the Lady Rokhr provided her followers with her most cherished creation. Using great magic and the life of her own eggs, she created a strong race of Lesser dragons. These dragons were not as great and powerful as herself and her kin, hence the Lesser. They would not possess the ability to travel between worlds[,] and it was their purpose to serve and protect the other races.

'Hence the Lesser' is unneeded as it's obvious to the readers. You could write, "...powerful as herself and her kin, but they would not..." ect.

Her nest provided a great variety. They came in all colors- white, black, red, blue, green, yellow, silver, gold. They breathed ice, fire, lightning, acid, mist. Some were small and dumb as the animals. Few of these had a powerful breath and many sported feathers. Some were quite large, and possessed an intelligence equal to that of the unicorns and griffons. And a select few had the size and strength of the Lady Rokhr herself.

Finally, the Lady Rokhr reached the end of her days. As she felt the life seeping from her bones, she joined her soul with the very planet, delving deep into its center, so that she might provide life and rejuvenation to the many races for years to come.

I really like the premise in and of itself. I like the world set up. But it only really tells (and it is a narrative, so that makes sense). This is your first page or two to the rest of the novel; it needs to capture the reader's attention. That being said, I don't think this prologue is really necessary. You could have this history interspersed throughout the novel, and it would be just fine. Just my thought, though. It'd be best for you to read what other's have to say before you take my comments fully to heart.
9
9
Review of Veiled By Beauty  
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Snow3* Hey there! A big welcome from the WDC Angle Army. You're a spotlighted author!

*FlowerT* Looking in your port, this title drew me to click on it and read.

Your poetry skill is beautiful. I always love a poem that flows so smoothly and even rhymes(!).

I like how you separated the stanzas and wrote them in a question format. I like your rich use of imagery and how the meter read so cleanly. A really great read!

Although, I do wonder at the correlation between the title and the poem. I think, had I written the poem, the title might have been a bit more... watery *Wink*; but I suspect this poem has a deeper, metaphorical meaning that is personal to you. And, thus, the title.

Great work!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
10
10
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (3.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Snow3* Overall impression

*Snow3* Death scenes can be a great way to start a story; they tend to reveal things about the MCs of the novel; I can see Haven is a caring person (to some degree), and that she and the old woman had a peculiar relationship. Nelda, I assume, was going to teach Haven what she knew. But then she died. Although, it appears she may have transferred her 'powers' into Haven.

*Snow3* Given it's so short, there's not a ton I can say. I an intriguing, however, at the possibilities of what can happen.

*Paste* *Cut* Suggestions/Working Out Those Bugs*Tools*

*Snow3* There weren't too many grammatical errors, thankfully, but I'll note the ones I did find:

*Snow3* It wouldn't be long now[;] she had seen death - needs the indicated semicolon. Or, if you so prefer, replace the semicolon with a period and then capitalize 'She'.

*Snow3* crossing her chest [and] zinging through her torso. - needs the indicated 'and' in place of the comma. Flows better

*Snow3* Some other spots that could use work: You use a lot of passive voice, which tends to 'tell' rather than show. I couldn't see much of what was going on; the only intrigue you accomplished through me as the reader was through plot.

*Snow3* Some people were touched by death, but Haven knew this was going to leave a mark. - this sentence reads weak; it could be strengthened through rewriting it in an more emotional sense. Kinda like it's in 1st person, but without the first person tags. You want a 'mark' to be left on the reader about Haven and her character.

*Pencil*Extra Comments*Pencil*

Overall, a good prologue/first page. I would've read further (I'm a sucker for good romances, as long as I find it believable and realistic; too many romances these days are all about the physical aspects of the lovers, which tends to annoy me and turn me away from the story).

I like your set up of your plot; I wonder what the paranormal twist/ aspect will be and what it means for Haven. Who could her 'love interest' be? Good job *Smile*

Keep up the great work! The more you practice, the better your writing becomes! *Bigsmile*
11
11
Review of Redecorating  
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Overall Impressions:

*Piano* Once again, you have pulled me into your story through your keen use of the English language.

*Piano* I get the feeling this the start of a bigger project, or - if not - it certainly has the potential to become so!

*Piano* Is there a correlation between the David and Mark characters in this piece to the ones in that chapter I also reviewed of yours? I'm guessing not, so must really like the names David and Mark.

*Paste* *Cut* Suggestions/Working Out Those Bugs*Tools*

*Piano* It was the social strain [-]/[:] the massive sensory intake, the emotional involvement, the excitement. - either the hyphen or the colon is needed for grammatical purposes and better read flow.

*Piano* David felt it like a growing energy. - it feels to me the antecedent(s) of 'it' is more of a literal 'growing energy' than like. Perhaps rewrite this as a metaphor rather than a simile?

*Piano* take the guy[] but some - I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure the sentence does not need the comma at the conjunction here

*Piano* as the ref started [the] match[,] and the two - I think you missed the word 'the', so I added it back in, and there also needs be the indicated comma

*Piano* opponent at the waist [and] knocking him to - when I read the sentence, my mind automatically supplied the word 'and' here, rather than reading the comma. To me, it flows better as a part of the same after thought in the sentence rather than another after thought.

*Piano* and then[,] unwilling to admit defeat[,] he'd followed through - needs the two indicated commas

*Pencil*Extra Comments*Pencil*

As a reader, you have hooked me sufficiently into the story; I am very impressed with your ability to write. You must have had lots of practice *Wink*; overall, a great read indeed. Write on!
12
12
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (2.0)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Please keep in mind, theses are only my opinions and suggestions. What you choose to do with my advice is up to your digression as the author and owner of your work

*Snow3* Overall impression

*Snow3* You have ability to write well. Your sentences have complexity, and your ideas show depth on your part.

*Snow3* I really liked your attempt at serious imagery, and the care you took to reel the reader into your story.

*Snow3* I'm gonna go ahead and guess that you have the want to become better at this craft. If so, I hope you take a serious look at my suggestions (without getting discouraged, as my comments are always driven towards helping you improve *Bigsmile*)

*Snow3* How you imagine starting and writing the story is on the right track - beginning with the action. There's just some clutter that needs sweeping (and I'll delve into that in the below section).

*Paste* *Cut* Suggestions/Working Out Those Bugs*Tools*

*Snow3* The landscape was baron. - the first sentence to any piece is so vital to hooking readers. Try to make this sentence active, rather than passive (i.e. using an action verb rather than passive ones like 'was' or 'had').

*Snow3* Amongst the mist[,] a tall - needs the indicated comma

*Snow3* Looking up but not yet discovered the corporal slowly and cautiously crept back to try to move into shelter behind some fallen debris on the battlefield, and out of site of this mechanical monster. - an extremely confusing sentence. I'm still not sure exactly what happened there. Rewrite the sentence so its clear what is happening. Clarity is super important, not only in any writing you do, but especially in any action piece.

*Snow3* deafening[;] the - needs the indicated semicolon

*Snow3* the machine raised one of its huge feet before making a gigantic step over where he was hidden before slamming the foot down to the ground once more. - you repeat 'before' twice in the same sentence. Try mixing up the syntax (sentence structure) for better flow and clarity. It's better not to repeat the same word in a single sentence, or a single paragraph (unless its a word like 'a', 'to', ect.)

*Snow3* Clutching his rifle tightly[,] he tried - needs the indicated comma

*Snow3* by that thing[,] he was surely - needs the indicated comma

*Snow3* this time faster[-] the same pattern. - (this is more of a style preference on my part) the hyphen makes for a smoother, creative read. It helps create that 'faster' feel for the reader.

*Snow3* be the wind[;] it was a code - needs the indicated semicolon

*Snow3* Two options for this one:

Behind the wreckage[,] once the light had passed[,] he saw

Or

Behind the wreckage[,] once the light had passed he saw

Personally, I prefer the second option, as the crossed out section is redundant and clutters the sentence.

*Snow3* obviously - You have to be careful with the word 'obvious'; all the times you use it in this piece I suggest editing out. The reader doesn't like being told things are 'obvious'.

*Snow3* With glances[,] the young soldier - needs the indicated comma

*Snow3* somehow[-] no luck - the hyphen here creates a break from the many commas and pushes forward the action

*Snow3* seemed - This, too is a word you use often. While it's not quite as dangerous as the word 'obvious', it's not a word to use repeatedly. When it comes to action scenes, I generally avoid 'seem', preferring to reserve it for the more emotional sections.

*Snow3* the machine[;] it moved none. or replace the semicolon with a period.

*Snow3* young so[i]lder - you missed the 'i' in the fifth paragraph down

*Snow3* of the machine[,] but he couldn’t - needs the indicated comma

*Snow3* Clutching his chest[,] he woke into a nightmare - needs the indicated comma

*Snow3* his heart pounding in his chest like a drum, sweat dripping from his body soaking his old bed clothes below. - here is an example of a sentence structure you utilized throughout the piece. I believe you have a basic, if not more, understanding of comma usage; but perhaps you should consult with your English teacher or a friend/family member of yours who know their grammar really well. Once you understand how to use commas, you just did to practice using them in your writing, and it'll become second nature to you.

Also, while we're discussing syntax, given that this is an action-oriented piece, short, to-the-point sentences are best. Short paragraphs not only look better (at least to me), but read better as well. Readers are less likely to loose their spot in a small paragraph. Action offers lots of opportunities for small paragraphs. Some options for when looking to break a paragraph is: action switches to a different character (i.e. from 'the young soldier' to 'the Corporal' to 'the machine'), when the focus on setting/character/action changes, or when the purpose of a grouping of sentences change (i.e. going from describing the scenery to introducing a character)

*Snow3* creates *Right* crates

*Pencil*Extra Comments*Pencil*

Overall, this piece needs a lot of revision work. But that doesn't mean its terrible! *Wink* You have a great grasp on your concept and your characters, I think. You just need to work on how you present/write what you see so vividly in your head.

Practice is the way to improvement! Write on!
13
13
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (3.0)
*BalloonR* Welcome to WDC from "Newbie Welcome Wagon! *BalloonR*


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Overall Impressions:

*Piano* The is short and sweet; I always love a good heartache and emotional confusion.

*Piano* The MC Persephone's pain felt realistic and believable. (If you're basing her off a book series or Greek mythology, I can't critique her authenticity to its specific cannon, so I treating her as just a character)

*Piano* The emphasis added to the flow and personality of the piece and added to the emotion. Good job there - although, in the future, try italicizing rather than using ALL CAPS. Same effect, more professorial look.

*Paste* *Cut* Suggestions/Working Out Those Bugs*Tools*

*Piano* Her ruby red shoes that were so unlike her were a stark contrast to the grayish colored earth. - Keeping in mind I don't get if 'rudy red shoes' being 'so unlike her' are a reference to a certain cannon, I think the sentence flows better without the indicated, crossed-out section.

*Piano* She looked at the dead dirt path ahead of her. - the first sentence of any story is super extra important. You want to grab attention straight away. I felt this sentence did not hold up to its duty. It blends in too well with the rest of the paragraph and feels as if I'm jumping into a random page in a book. What to do? As a style preference,I think even just taking the first sentence and separating it from the rest of the paragraph would help.

She looked at the dead dirt path ahead of her.

Her ruby red shoes that were so unlike her were a stark....


*Piano*For that Persephone, the idea of being surrounded by nothing but cold dead earth would have caused the girl to weep until there was nothing left to weep, and, in fact, that is what happened. - this sentence is not only wordy, but confusing and redundant. The purpose of the paragraph is met without the sentence and can be cut.

*Pencil*Extra Comments*Pencil*
This was a really great read overall. Don't be dismayed by all these suggestions; they are simply my sincere opinion, and you can utilize them however you wish.

Keep up the great work *Bigsmile* Write on!
14
14
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Overall Impressions:
*Piano* The Imagery was amazing in this piece, as too the metaphors and general language you used. Beautiful.
*Piano* My favorite section (I say section because it would be useless to copy and past a third of the story onto this review) would be when you described the woman and the man, the wife and the husband. Without them saying a word - simply through action - we as the readers see (and assume) so much into their personal lives. Lovely.
*Piano* Simply put, I love your writing *Smile*

*Paste* *Cut* Suggestions/Working Out Those Bugs*Tools*
*Piano* Their travelling days were over, and they were now left to get buried under rejected sheets of screwed up paper printed with discarded words, crumb coated plates and half-drained mugs. - this sentence to me caught as a little odd to read. Grammatically speaking, its correct, but to me the sentence was a tad too wordy.

*Piano*He would cut it another day. He could do away with it completely if he wanted to. Just not today. - as indicated, I think your point of 'him' not wanting to do it is more powerful a statement riding that middle sentence. It's short and to the point, and that in and of itself seems to reflect the man.

*Pencil*Extra Comments*Pencil*

Thanks for sharing such a beautiful piece! I enjoyed reading it.

- Azure Ice
15
15
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
I would like to join *Smile* Seems like a great way to keep up community involvement
16
16
Review of What Binds Us  
Rated: E | (3.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*BurstB* These are just my honest opinions. Others may think differently, including the author. I hope this review is helpful! *BurstB*

*Piano* The story concept overall is sweet and well thought out. It remains true to the title and the description. I liked the characters, more especially Bianca, and she was the most alive character to me.

But, for all that is good, there is always room for improvement *Smile*

*Piano* Nothing was cooking but the kitchen smelled of fresh herbs - The cross-out indication I feel is an unneeded part of the sentence and contributes nothing to the sentence nor the overall feel of the kitchen.

*Piano* You liked to list many herbs at one time. While specifics in description is good and adds to feel of the story, I felt listing the exact herbs was a bit much and didn't help me smell the kitchen as much as it could have. So perhaps you can generalize the smell of herbs or create a metaphor for what they smell like.

*Piano* 1 in 3 chance - write out the numbers ('one' and 'three'); same goes for any number in a writing piece.

*Piano* Also, when you jump to Carmine's side of the story, you need to separate it in some way from the rest of the story. I use italics. This will help the reader know what time and place we are at when you jump back and forth btwn stories.

*Piano* thump thump thump. - My personal style would urge me to do this:

"Thump.
Thump.
Thump."

*Piano* Also, some of the paragraphs are really large and that can deter a reader from beginning or finishing a story (at least it can for me). Try a separating the paragraphs into smaller chunks. Where a new person talks, a new person moves or reacts, or something in the scenery has changed are some suggestions for where you might want to separate paragraphs.

*Piano* I liked the sense of heritage of the characters; it was really sweet and made me feel for all of them. A good character bond.

Keep up the writing and don't give up! You've got a whole new community of willing helpers waiting to stretch out their hands and assist. Write on!
17
17
Review of Red Velvet Box  
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Snow3* Overall impression: the piece is decent; I like the overall story idea you have here, but there is work to be done (as there is with every and any aspiring writer *Wink*

*Snow3* The piece is titled the Red Velvet Box, but you never actually mention the box until the latter end of the story. Same with the description of the story - none of these feelings the woman has for a man is mentioned until later. This is confusing for me as a reader, as I opened this story with an expectation regarding the red velvet box and mooning woman.

How to fix such confusion? Integrate the red velvet box from the very beginning, make it a more central symbol. Your title and description need to match the actual focus of the story, and I felt you could have done better with this.

Dabbling more with the focus of the story, the mother-issues background was neat for building the MC in my head, but it didn't contribute much to the story as a whole and therefore should be downsized. Obviously, the past with the mother is important - but how important is it to the symbolism of the red velvet box and her hidden love? Same idea with Kate's past on her father and the town's people. What's important to the central focus of the story (which I assume to be the red velvet box and the MC's longing for love)

*Snow3* I always cringe when I saw walls of text, from published novels to website pieces. I dislike giant walls of text. There were large paragraphs to read in this, which is negative to the overall presentation of the piece. But it's pretty easy to fix.

My general rule is to create a new paragraph when the speaker's changed, the subject has changed, or the flow has changed. For example, in the first paragraph, I would have indented "Then I remembered" onto it's own line.

I didn’t know that they were hers until I smelled them.

Then I remembered.

Her smell brought back mixed feelings.


*Snow3* In surmise, pay close attention to what your central focus is for the story. Back stories are good - and with yours I saw a person in the MC and felt for her - but you need to dictate which back stories contribute to what you are trying to say in the end. Too much back story in too many places can confused the reader.

Hoped this review help. Keep writing; the more you practice, the better writer you'll be! *Smile*
18
18
Review of The Daisy  
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Snow3*Overall impression: Absolutely loved it! The diction, the formatting, the general idea - all of it! There's nothing I can suggest to make this better than it already is! Amazing *Starstruck*

*Snow3* I love the ingenuity of Says the first petal to Is the second's prattle. And the next stanza has such a rhythm to it, I felt like I was singing Ring Around the Rosey in my mind, which creates a perfect, light heart atmosphere for the poem.

Thanks for sharing!

19
19
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: E | (3.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Snow3*Overall impression: I liked the poem, overall. The theme is timeless and was told in a beautiful way. The format worked well with the piece. The title, as well, matches the theme and purpose.

*Snow3* Things to change: thier - should be their

These two lines: "I follow your light in the sky

I am lost at sea[;] I was going to die"
I felt could be reworded differently, and there should be a semicolon present where indicated. The switch in tense use isn't grammatically incorrect, but it messed with the flow some. This can be fixed through some rearranging of words and/or phrases to your digression.

Welcome to WDC; I hope you continue to share you work with us and stay for a long while! *Smile*
20
20
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Music2* Overall Impression: Lots of imagery! *Heart* It was beautiful what the imagery added to the piece. To me (and all my lack of poetic know-how), this piece sounded very professional, written by someone who is either already published or who certainly has the ability to be.

*Music2* I liked most the imagery (made that pretty clear, didn't I *Wink* and the subject of the poem. Though I admit, I had to reread it a few times to understand what was being said, and even then I'm not quiet sure I got the full jist.

So that would be my only negative point for this piece - that I can't fully understand it. Keep in mind, though, half the time I never understand poetry, especially the really-good ones.

*Music2* I give you a round of applause for your stunning talent. Keep up the amazing writing! *RibbonB*
21
21
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Music2* Overall Impression is a sense of connection. I relate well with this piece, since I started out writing when I was rather young.

*Music2* I liked the format, how you used a single age to skip through the years. Reminds me of a song by Martina McBride, and it was one of my favorites.

I also liked the rhetorical questions, the bridge between a wonderful concept and a solid purpose.

*Music2* It was a great, short read. I have no suggestions. Thanks for sharing *StarStruck*
22
22
Rated: E | (4.0)
A cute, little piece of the Holiday flair. Not much to review here, but a lot of the things you write are in genres I tend to avoid *Blush* ; I like your writing style, and this story was good and simple for a child's piece. Keep up the good work!
23
23
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Not quite sure your perspective on this piece, what it was meant for, but here are my thoughts on it:

The story line itself was lovely. I like the idea. My only issue with it is the dialogue. It seems both a bit mature for a kid (depending on his age, which isn't stated anyway) and I image all of it would have been happening in his head, rather than him speaking aloud. I guess it's just my style, though. It seems awkward to read it like spoken dialogue rather than inner dialogue.

But - other than that - I really like it!
24
24
In affiliation with Let's help each other grow...  
Rated: E | (2.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Music2*Overall impression is I love the story line, the idea of it. I like the female character, though the male lead feels a little flat (but that's not a giant problem given the length of the piece); but the innocence of the story line is wonderful.

*Music2*There were a few problems, however:

You see[,] I have - needs indicated comma

(*InfoB* This is totally just my writing preference/style, but I do believe it would help improve this piece): There needs to be more 'action', more things going on between Scott and the girl. Too much of the story is the girl thinking about things, and I want to see things happening in real time. Show their loving relationship, rather than tell us how it was in the past and how is he. I don't feel like I can really care for how sweet Scott is because I haven't really met him. And I'd like to.

*Music2*So, I really emphasize the need for showing rather than telling. It'll bring out the emotions that are hidden in this wonderful story line.

Thanks for sharing your writing! Keep at it!
25
25
Review of YOLO. Why?  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Totally agree! I never understood that term - why is was so cool. Every time I hear that, I think of high school kids partying with alcohol at someone's house. And then people get drunk. And then people never remember what 'fun' they had? How fun is that? Lol.

That being said, I loved your poem/thoughts on YOLO. *BigSmile*
27 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 2 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/blueasice