*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/nrholder
Review Requests: OFF
60 Public Reviews Given
95 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... -1- 2 ... Next
1
1
Review of Two fisted Poem  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Overall Impression:
A great beginning about travels, life, sharing, and experience which latter changes into following the emotion felt while watching a tragic news report of a man senselessly shot.


Favorite Part:
I love all the lines which begin with, "I lived." They describe a person who has seen much and remembered many lessons.


Suggestions:
I don't like the switch. I enjoy the writing below the switch but think it should be a seperate work. Either that or draw a more obvious link between the two works and use a consistent writing/rhyming style. The way it's written, it appears to be two poems merged together and the confluence is broken.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
2
2
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Fyn! This is review 1 of 5.

Overall Impression:
A moving poem which allows the reader to walk through a lovely picture. It beings sofly and ends strong.


Favorite Part:
"inhale the eons,
feel the ages,
hear the whispers,
of hand upon stone."

I've thought about this many times. Looking out at a boulder or tree and thinking, "if only it could talk."


Suggestions:
I want more. I want to see more of this picture, of what's around me, and how I feel. What were you doing, seeing when you thought of writing this?

Also, what's the relationship between the words and the stone fence?


Grammar & Errors:
metaphore = metaphor


Other Remarks:
Good job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
3
3
Review of Iron and Ore  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A poem about a brief moment in time spent on the rail tracks collecting iron, and playing.


Favorite Part:
The first stanza is nice. I enjoy the simile between the ore and the eyes.


Suggestions:
Your imagery and description is well done for the first half. I feel like you lost it about the fourth stanza.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Good job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
4
4
Review of Invisible Bond  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
Touching story of a sister, a brother, and a good friend.



Suggestions:
Consider revising your story progression. You tend to jump around a bit.

Also, the story is about the friendship between Nazia and Fariha. I think you should focus more on their relationship rather than that or Fariha and her brother or the school day.


Grammar & Errors:
Keep writing!


Other Remarks:



- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
5
5
Review of One Day At A Time  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A poem/prose about being locked inside and fearing opening your heart.


Favorite Part:
"A Solitude of Ocean...
That never felt the Heat of Sun."


Suggestions:
Consider revising your rhythm. It breaks now and then causing the read to pause and re-read.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
This work hits close to home especially now. I feel a similar way presently. Keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
6
6
Review of The Love Tree  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A raw and graphic, near angry rant, prose about feelings of hatred toward a hurtful lover.


Favorite Part:
I enjoy the blunt bitterness of this work and it's simplicity; written staggered like the anger you feel.


Grammar & Errors:
And under its poisonous drops[,] I crack and wither[]
Decaying, my sweet stench nauseating[.]
This, this my love[,] is all yours.
And every dried drop of blood[.]
This is what I owe to you[;] this is what you’ve made for me.
Do it, do it, take it[!]
Take my heart, consume me again[.]
It’s whole[.] [T]he body has died but the soul remains.
Savour every mouthful my love[.]
Lick the blood from your lips[.]
Taste my bitterness[;] all that remains[.]


Other Remarks:
Keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
7
7
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
Light and fun Winter Wonderland parody with Harry Potter.


Favorite Part:
You've done well matching the rhythm and rhyme of the original tune!


Grammar & Errors:
There's no place to run
Soon their friends


Other Remarks:
Good job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
8
8
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
Creating images of various faces which are special because they are all unique.


Favorite Part:
"portrait sketched, then drawn anew, by fickle hand of time"
I read this to mean that we wear a face for a time, believing in it, then we realize something new and change our "face" - outlook, belief.


Suggestions:
While I have no specific issue with the repitition of, "a diamond in the rough," I wonder if you may gain a better impact using a different method. Perhaps an ending which pulls together the inspiration of this work.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
9
9
Review of Gathering Dust  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A poem of unrealized dreams, lost time, and empty lives. Good rhythm and an interesting read. Sits close to my heart and my outlook on many peoples lifestyle.


Favorite Part:
"Lives piled like worthless lumber"

Great simile!


Suggestions:
Consider adding more. I want more *Smile*


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Great job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
10
10
Review of Painter Babu  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
About remembering a influencial artist who made a mark on a man's life, and his realization of the meaning of one particular painting.


Favorite Part:
You're writing style is very fluent and easy to read.


Suggestions:
Perhaps add more about your background with Babu and this mysterious woman of which you speak near the end.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Great job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
11
11
Review of Two Poems  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A brief traditional poem of some simple rules the author believes in. Easy to read and good suggestions.


Favorite Part:
"Inject all with sweet love-doses."

Fun statement to read and think about.


Suggestions:
More please!


Grammar & Errors:
Need a period after the first line.
Need a period or semicolon after the third line.
Need a period after the sixth line.
Need a period or semicolon after the seventh line.


Other Remarks:
Hope to see more!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
12
12
Review of Beach Scene  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A vivid picture of a night at the beach. It captures that moment of wonder and beauty fantastically.


Favorite Part:
I have two:

"Smooth, foamy surf, sensuously settles ashore."
The sexiness of the tide and it's gentle caress of the shore. Nicely done.

"A sandcastle fights, forging its final stand."
As the day ends, dreaming of earlier and the fun that was had.


Suggestions:
Consider spacing your stanzas to separate your rhyme pairs.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Great job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
13
13
Review of The First Snow  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A pretty verse about waking up to a snowy morning. I enjoy your imagery and the peacefulness of the morning you describe. The first two stanzas are well written.


Favorite Part:
I enjoy the 3rd stanza the most. A still morning; the snow untouched.


Suggestions:
I understand your description of seeing fresh snow in the morning because I've actually seen it. Consider adding more detail for those who haven't.

Also, I'm confused about this being "my last season."


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Well done and keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
14
14
Review of Worlds apart  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A short, sad traditional poem written from one sibling to another who's been lost.


Favorite Part:
"Deep in heart those pangs of pain
Strolling down my memory lane."

Memories can make us laugh and they can make us cry. It's especially hard when that's all you have left.


Suggestions:
At times your rhyming seems forced. Consider revising a few word choices.
There are surely some memories which you could share with vivid imagery to add a personal touch.


Other Remarks:
Very sweet. Keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
15
15
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (3.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
An interesting statement about working on creating your own mark on history rather than following others in their path.


Favorite Part:
I like the idea of making our own success story instead of trying to live another's.


Suggestions:
This could be a great work and illustrate the desire of everyone to create a "footprint" in time. It makes a good point but I believe you could emphasize the statement by adding the paths people usually walk, the attempts they make. Consider, instead of a blunt opinion, leading your reader into feeling that they either have made their own footprints or why they want to.


Grammar & Errors:
"people[,] just ordinary people[;]"
"extraordinary[.]"
"thing[:] FOOTPRINTS..."
"sidewalk[,] as we walk along[,]"
"In reality though[,]"
"and wait; wait..."


Other Remarks:
Keep working!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
16
16
Review of LITTLE LOST SHEEP  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
Wow! Amazingly sad poem about the loss of a mother and the feeling associated with it.


Favorite Part:
I have two actually.
1) "Retaining faith I desperately strive to keep"
2) "Call me selfish, for I know you‘re in God‘s care"

The first line I understand deeply within myself. I know what it's like to lose someone/something and feel the resentment and hopelessness. Faith used to be easy and now that sense of security has been shattered.

The second for two reasons. One, since I believe in an afterlife, I believe funerals are for the living. So I like the recognition of selfishness. Two, because it's a great contrast to the first favorite line.


Suggestions:
None.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Fantastic work! ((Sherri))


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
17
17
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (5.0)
A wonderful place hosted by a wonderful teacher. Created to help newbies learn to enter contests and become familiar with the usage of WritingML to emphasize their work.

Also a great place to discover contests and other helpful resources to further your journey through newbie-hood and beyond.

Not to mention, every entry receives a review. Can't go wrong there!

Highly recommended. Check it out!

- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
18
18
Review of Vieviel  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.5)
Overall Impression:
A wonderful beginning to a sure-to-be wonderful story.


Favorite Part:
The very first paragraph describing memory is fantastic! I love your choice of words and simile.


Suggestions:
None at the moment. Looking forward to reading the rest.


Grammar & Errors:
Only one noticed:
"I have a home separate from my family’s, you can stay there and no one will know you are here." - I have a home separate from my family. You can stay there...


Other Remarks:
Great job! Can't wait for more.


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
19
19
Review of The Ordeal  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A story about the initiation of one Elf into an elite order. An "ordeal" of facing your worst fears to recognize strength and truth. Well written and easy to read.


Favorite Part:
Her fear of being afraid is a nice undertone throughout the work. Something which we have all felt.


Suggestions:
This feels as though it is part of a larger work or should be. Consider expanding the story.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Well done!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
20
20
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
Very angry work at those who are blissfully optimistic and cheerful.


Favorite Part:
There are a couple parts which make me chuckle and say "wow! now that's harsh."

"...newspapers crowing the dove's extinction."
"I pine to take a needle and extract their souls..."

Both of these demonstrate a very dark desire and underlying hatred.


Suggestions:
Only to ad some more information about why you feel this way.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Though I consider myself, on one level, to be an idealist, I know how you feel. I too have looked out sometimes and wanted to rip off those smiles.


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
21
21
Review of THE LEGACY  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A delicious, very easy to read story about an author with a great in-progress novel who happens to find herself in a real-life situation which is unusually similar to what she's writing.


Favorite Part:
"In my book the lawyer is innocent, but no one believes him. In my life the lawyer was guilty, but no one believes it. They think I did it."

Great turn. I love the way you state the difference between the two worlds.


Suggestions:
I would only ask that you think about resolving the "real-life" plot of your husband and the stolen money. I'm left with the feeling at the end that it's unfinished.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Great job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
22
22
Review of Hesitance  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (3.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Nicely worded poem about fear and insecurity while walking semi-confidently toward a better life.

Though brief, it has a certain impact; however, I think you should consider lengthening it to include what bound and freed you. Perhaps add some more detail about the light you see.

Keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
23
23
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (4.0)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
An interesting first-person look at one tooth fairy's unfortunate ordeal making a delivery to that one dreaded household. Creative and fun.


Favorite Part:
The second-to-last paragraph is well-written and I found the finality and the hint of rebellion amusing. I also enjoy the sarcasm used throughout.


Suggestions:
The first half of the story was easy and fast. However after Timothy got hold of the angel, it became a little drawn out. I don't mind the detail but consider condensing a bit.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Fun story! I prefer the second idea for a title.


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
24
24
Review of Mary said...  
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Thank you for entering the "Invalid Item ! This review is being provided as part of your participation. Good luck and keep writing!

Overall Impression:
A very well written pantoum about a horrible disease.


Favorite Part:
The last stanza does a very good job of describing a fond memory and a wonder. As if the very person who is afflicted has written this while remembering her old self and then lost in a thought, wonders what happened to herself.


Suggestions:
Only one: Consider revising "non-local." I understand your meaning but I think a more fluid word would be better.


Grammar & Errors:
None noticed.


Other Remarks:
Good job!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
25
25
Review by Nicholas Holder
Rated: E | (3.5)
Reviewed Item:
"A Child Is The Love You Live


Overall Impression:
A brief description of how a father feels toward his children and crying out to let them know where his priorities lie.


Favorite Part:
I enjoy the repitition of "A child is the love you live." This hammers in that it's a constant thought.


Suggestions:
In a descriptive poem, I think you could add more...well description. Describe what love you share and add a personal touch about each child that is intimate and personal. It will add images and emotion that not only others can feel, but also something which will ring in the hearts of your children.


Grammar & Errors:
None.


Other Remarks:
I truly hope you keep writing!


- Nicholas Holder
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
26 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 2 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/nrholder