Members help other members with technical questions and problems using Writing.Com!
That item was transferred to you by Countrymom, the original owner, and you recently transferred it to Carol St. Ann -- and the awardicon image shows on the item there, but isn't shown on her Community page in with other awardicons of the same type. Those are the symptoms of a hidden awardicon.
When you had the item, might you have hidden the awardicon because it would look like you'd awarded your own item?
I think if Carol checks her Awardicon page, she'd find it in the hidden awardicons listing, and could use the option when viewing the awardicon to unhide it.
Hope that helps.