Hi BlaqkShadow
My name is Angels in my Ear and I'm reviewing for "Invalid Item" . I want to welcome you to WDC and thought I would give you some feedback on your work. I strive to give honest reviews and I hope you find this review helpful.
Initial Impression: This is a cathartic piece about love lost and the quest to recover.
Title: The title of a piece is what entices the readers to choose your piece. It hints at the content without giving it away. While your title does that to some extent, it is a bit too generic. There are many pieces with this name I'm sure. Also, your description is actually too descriptive. Again, you want to interest the reader without telling what the piece is about. You will find that many readers will see a completely different meaning than what you intended. This way, they can try to figure it out themselves.
Technique: I find this piece has the lyrical quality of poetry. It has a fairly even meter, although there are places where it falters. However, I had difficulty following the rhythm because your rhyme scheme is all over the page. You start out with an a,b,c,b then change to a d,e,f,g where none of the lines rhyme then you go back to rhyming lines with a,a,b,b, This inconsistent rhyming pattern is confusing and throws the reader off of the rhythmic music of your piece. I know that is a bit technical so I will show you what I'm referring to.
The harsh wind wraps around my face, (A)
The cold chills me to the bone, (B}
I can see the ocean from where I'm standing (C)
I'm far away from home. (B)
High above the road beneath me, (D)
Too high to jump, enough to fall,(E)
Just one wrong move and I'm history,(F)
Another stain on the past of fools. (G)
My minds a blur yet clear as ice,(A)
I can't think straight, but I don't think twice.(A)
Suggestions: Not only would I change to a consistent rhyming pattern, (You can choose whichever works a,b,a,c or a,b,c,b which are the ones I prefer), but I would break this into quatrains. (Stanzas of 4 lines each). This consistency will help the reader focus more on content than format.
Final Comments: I really hope I haven't discouraged you. When I began writing on this site, I had no formal education past HS writing classes. These technical reviews taught me a lot, and I was actually asked to be a poetry editor for an e-zine after learning and applying these concepts. You actually have a knack for meter, which ironically is what I find most difficult for many poets. If you work on those things I mentioned, you have great potential and a great poem. If you have questions on any of the things I mentioned, please don't hesitate to e-mail me. I'd love to see this poem reach the potential it has.
I find it is through honest and thorough feedback that we grow as writers and my only goal is to help you do so. I hope that you find a home here at WDC. There are so many things to do that it can be a little overwhelming at first, but keep exploring. If you're interested in finding a friends that can help you find your way around come visit us at "Invalid Item" We love to help you get motivated, challenge you to new heights, and help you make new friends. I'd love to hear from you
| | Invalid Item This item number is not valid. # by Not Available. |
"Shadows and Light Poetry Contest"
"Roots & Wings Contest" |
|