Jeffrey Meyer's (centurymeyer35) Reviews

Review Requests: ON
932 Public Reviews Given
937 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I prefer to offer an in-depth review of others' writing. I will note the things I like, things that may not work as well for me as a reader, and supportive suggestions.
I'm good at...
Mechanics and meaning. I'm no expert, but I can tell where a comma does and doesn't belong, and I can see where a meaning might be excellently conveyed or a bit muddled thereby. I'm also good at recognizing the overall spirit of a piece as a whole, despite mechanics, grammar, and such.
Favorite Genres
General fiction, some sci-fi, drama, some poetry
Least Favorite Genres
Fan-fiction, politics
Favorite Item Types
Character-driven stories
Least Favorite Item Types
Articles. Essays are okay, but they're not my favorite.
I will not review...
Stories about giants or shrinking--I just don't "get" them. I am also unlikely to review 5,000+ word pieces unless the GP compensation is commensurate with the effort I will have to put into it.
Public Reviews
176
176

Review of Time For An Intervention  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
This jerk is ANYTHING but noble! I enjoyed the way the tables got turned on him. This kept me guessing, with each asinine things he said, how he would get his comeuppance. Good job keeping me reading and keeping me engaged.

Personally, I'm convinced: if Adam had to have the kids, they would have stopped at Able, period!

--Jeffrey
177
177

Review of Eccentrics Galore  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Oh my goodness! I actually laughed out loud to that. That was wonderful! You know, I just saw something on the History Channel about a town that that WAS almost exclusively "sideshow acts" in the circus heyday. I think it was in Florida. Anyway, that lent a nice root of reality to your piece.

The ending was perfectly timed and delivered. Loved it!

--Jeffrey
178
178

Review of Childhood  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Nightblue,

Childhood is so variable. As you state throughout the poem, there is a lot of contrast in experiences, moods, emotions.

I would challenge you a bit, for this poem, to make me feel it more. Remind me of what my childhood was like by putting some of yours on the page. Put me on the ground rather than the 30,000 foot view.

Also, moving forward, don't be afraid of longer lines in poetry. You can build more interesting rhyme and rhythm structures, and/or simply convey a more robust message. Now don't misunderstand, brevity is often a poem's strength: concise, punchy. But for a poem like this, it is this readers opinion that you have room to expand it horizontally.

This is a fantastic topic for poetry, my friend. I certainly hope you write on!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

180
180

Review of Things i never said  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Tessgii,

It's the words we bite back and the tears we don't cry in front of people that haunt us worse than any ghost of the past. Everybody knows it; everybody feels it. And for that reason, everyone can identify with this sad poem.

There were some beautiful lines in here:

~ "Why you made it so easy to let me go" That's almost a riddle unto itself. What is unclear to the speaker in the poem is not why it was easy to let go, but why the other person designed it to be so or caused it to be so easy to let go. That's a step further into hurt, and such a great line.

~ "In the cracks of my chest" The pain of losing someone is still too clear to me, even though it has been years. It does feel like something is broken in one's chest, and ache or a hollowness. Your line conveys the brokenness of emotions with that unequaled pain of loss; but it doesn't get flowery with heartbreak or other trite phrases. The reader is left to feel what those cracks truly mean.

~ "They weigh more than I can hold" This is a line that takes some thought. If the unspoken words weigh more than the speaker in the poem can hold, then she must say them at some point. The reader is left to interpret this. Does she get these words out in therapy? To a friend? Through self-harm? Personally, I see her standing in her living room and screaming and sobbing at the walls two or three days a week, when it all gets too heavy. But that's the magic of poetry: room for interpretation.

Your mechanics are good and consistent throughout this poem. You use punctuation in the same way throughout, and your stanzas are broken nicely into individual images or thoughts that allow us, as readers, to take a breath and a snapshot before moving forward.

This is a very good poem, Tessgii, restrained and controlled, but evocative of all the sudden partings readers have been through. Bravo!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

181
181

Review of Illogic  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.0)
Very cute. However, it can be beefed up a little.

I know, I know: it's just a joke, and you can lose your listener's attention if you carry on too long. I agree—BUT...

...This isn't an oral joke, it's a written one. You can definitely build a cute little story around this. It's a great opportunity to practice a flash fiction piece: 300 words or fewer. Just as writing a review is good practice, drabbles (100 words or fewer) and flashes are excellent opportunities to practice the craft, too!

This is a funny piece of writing, but every piece of writing is an effort that deserves attention. Even if it's not an update of this piece, I hope you Write On!

--Jeffrey
182
182

Review of We would’ve  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Tokeo,

We usually write poems about what we didn't get to have, what we lost. This poem lamenting someone else's loss is quite beautiful. I'm not sure if this was just a relationship separation or something worse; to me, it rather seems that one person is saddened by someone having taken their own life. In either context, it is a very strong poem.

The repetition of "We would've" keeps the reader tightly reminded that these things never happened, but they had a chance to happen. There was a permanent loss somewhere which makes me think of suicide—"stolen away from me", "didn't have the time"—that prevented all these wonderful things.

Quite a wonderful, if sad, poem.


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

183
183

Review of Many Careful Owners  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Bill,

This story is strongly reminiscent of Stephen King's Christine, wherein a car has a malevolent consciousness of its own and eventually kills its owner. Rather too much, perhaps, if I may be so bold.

You've written this piece well. Mike is a believable character. His phone. Where was his phone? It's lines like these that give reality to characters. Every reader has lost their phone and gone searching for it in urgent frustration! And the urgency of the conversation, with the phone dying further allows us to identify with Mike.

His descent into obsession is gently conveyed, which is nice, since his demise is gentle, too. But you portray his final moments as well as you portray his frantic search for the phone in the beginning. You've a knack for making your characters believable as everyday people.

Your mechanics—spelling, punctuation, formatting—all seem to be in good form.

One thing you might want to look at is that the wife lists the add as only one previous owner. She would have known there were at least two, wouldn't she? That's about the only thing I would fix in this, aside from the very close semblance to Christine. Perhaps introducing some type of manifestation of the previous "many careful owners" would provide some more original context? Maybe a good reason why the car is evil and murderous to those who restore it? In any case, it's something for you to ponder, at least.

This a well-written story with engaging action and an identifiable character. Good work, Bill.


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

184
184

Review of Sisyphean Attempts at Self-Improvement  

for entry "Pathological
Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Jeff,

I like this admission of guilt that contains no shame whatsoever. I think this lurks in all of us, the urge to embellish or even downright make things up. I don't think the origin is always nefarious—possibly not even usually so. When I was a kid, it was to get attention or stay out of trouble. But the former is what was, and is, most embarrassing: the need to have a similar story, an anecdote to fit the occasion. I still remember, over 40 years ago, when my father called me on it at the family table. I still feel that shame.

But I also remember the painful need to be relevant, and I still feel it.

Dio wrote: "You can hide in the sun till you see the light." Your poem seems to speak more to the, well—pathological cases of lying, the need to lie to address some broken inner need. Why move out of the darkness? Because your lies are even more effective when you tell them in the sunlight. "...With malicious eye askance to watch the working of his lie on mine, mouth scarce able to suppress his glee at one more victim gained thereby." Eliot seems to have known your character well.

I like this poem for its ability to be applied across a range of lies from white to black. It makes the reader consider his own communications and ponder his own level of honesty...and the depths of his own pathology.

There were a couple places I might suggest some slightly different choices:

~ "Prevarications" is a correct word for this, but somehow it felt like too expensive of a word for the rest of the poem. It seems to me to be a five-dollar word among three-dollar words—haughty, I guess, is the word I'm looking for.

~ Immediately on the heels of the above, "genuine honesty" is repetitive. Honesty is, by definition, genuine. I rather think the modifier could be pruned without damaging the line.

Overall, this is a very thought-provoking poem. As I move into my day with a big meeting to start with, I will bear it in mind to keep my anecdotes and relations on the up-and-up. Glad I got to read it this morning, Jeff.



This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

185
185

Review of letGo  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Freewrite,

Wow, this is packed tight. Each word here is important; nothing is wasted. I frequently offer others advice on economy of words in poetry, but you exemplify it here.

The stages of a life from the very cradle are offered as packets to teh reader. I think I get them all; I get the jist at least, but I feel like that's not enough. Some of the stanzas (or my own mind) are a little too dense for me to wring every meaning from them. For instance:

a tag striking those who come and are now named
a sound in the background where it is printed
a register unheard issuing the form
Intro show


I think this is about the birth certificate being printed for a baby. Mostly because of "Introo show." Otherwise, it could be a toe tag in the morgue from a death in the delivery room—mother or child.

Other lines are exquisite in their brevity, because they still manage a wonderful description. "Out and about for the arc-lightened joining..." What a way of describing meeting at night. Whether this is with a group or just two people is touch unclear in my mind, but the line really stood out for me.

This poem about the arc of life is very well-written, if just a bit too lean for me. But if this is outside your comfort zone, I can't wait to see read what is inside it!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.



NOTE ON MY RATING: I gave 4 stars because I really feel like the parts I didn't get are because of my own inability to dissect it. It didn't seem fair to ding you for that. JM
186
186

Review of Craving KitKat  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Wildfire,

This was a wonderful story of surface-level paradoxes and insightful investigations. When I first started it, the many paradoxical statements, such as: "part fully grown, tougher than nails, strong in her own right, temptress and vixen, yet part playful, silly, wide-eyed innocent, with a good bit of wild-child" reminded me at once of "She's Always a Woman to Me" by Billy Joel, and "Heaven and Hell" by Black Sabbath. And that kinda fits the character, doesn't it? Half metal, half mood music.

In my opinion, you were right up next to the too-many-comparisons line, but still on this side of it. You could probably find two or three opportunities in the second half to edit them out, since the reader has already had several examples in the first half. That having been said, however, those comparisons define the character so well! We only know she has red hair, a small frame, and an attractive rear end. That's all the physical info we get. But you give her such wonderful definition through Henry's perceptions and understandings of her and through sketches of her backstory that she becomes a fully-formed character.

Henry, on the other hand, is furniture. He's supposed to be. He's KitKat's support, a safety, a known quantity. All we need to know is that he is there—is there, will always be there. He is the negative space that defines her asylum. His character is written perfectly for this.

So much of this story is written in negative space, in inversions. The abused individual finds safety in a crowd of perceived abusers. The wild one needs freedom to survive, but is willing to be domestic if she is not expected to be. Wild will settle for calm so long as calmness is not demanded. Paradoxes and inversions. It's really quite fascinating, and not a little confusing. Really neat writing.

I think the way you unspooled the story was great thematic structure. After each dichotomy, we got a little more explanation. The went from a jerk to a tease, to a victim, to a survivor...to a person. The story itself bloomed backward, what was awesome, from a writer's point of view. I've written a lot of flashback stuff. But this kept the reader in the present, even while the backstory was being revealed.

Your mechanics--spelling, punctuation, presentation: everything was on trim from what I can see. Good choice on the large font with adequate paragraph spacing. It made a huge difference for my old eyes, no joke.

Her flippant "I'm more" mirrored by Henry's "you're everything" is a wonderful close. She's not tame, she's not broken. She's safe; she's loved; and she's safe to love him.

My favorite line in the whole piece was this: "It was the pink suede elephant perpetually in their personal space." What a perfect adaptation of that trite old phrase. Simply perfect!

This was a great story that was very cleverly written. It was enjoyable for a reader in me and the writer, as well. So glad I found this today. And I'll be even more glad if you decide to Write On!



This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.



187
187

Review of Writing and Me  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Chrysii,

First of all, welcome to our community! I hope I'm neither the first nor the last to extend our pleasure that you've chosen us with whom to share your writing journey. This is a community of writers and word-players.

There are many activities, prompts, and contests to stimulate your creativity as well as challenge your craft. I'll offer a couple of my own preferences at the bottom of this.

There's nothing like doing something to learn it, and that includes writing. The people on this site are all here to support, encourage, and help each other. That ranges from gentle comments and guidance to scanning your stuff with a microscope. I am confident you'll find the level of support and comradery you desire here on WdC.

There's a few things that will help you settle into the community: reviewing and interacting. Your Newsfeed will give you all kinds of opportunities to interact with others based on a variety of topics regarding writing. Reviewing other writers' output does two things: it allows you to explore new methods you do or do not like; and it allows you to practice writing be writing back to the original author what you thought of their story. That sounds a little convoluted, but you'll that it's pretty simple.

Here's some activities and areas I strongly recommend for you as a newer community member:
~
"Daily Flash Fiction Challenge - This is good for learning how to be very succinct. You have to tell a story in 300 words or fewer.
~ "The Writer's Cramp - This is great for getting good at thinking fast—an entire short story in 24 hours. (This is one I'm struggling with right now...but it's fun!)
~ "I Swear I'm Cool Somewhere! - This is a fun forum for letting your imagination go, but capturing the good time on paper (or on the screen, as it were).
~ "The Adam West Conspiracy - This is a contest I host. You're welcome to take a look and see if you want to play along.
~ "The Contest Challenge - Last one. This is kind of a hub for several different contests.


I hope to some of your writing soon. Whatever pace you choose, though: Write On!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.



188
188

Review of Julia  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Sam,

This is masterfully done, sir. Well written and perfectly paced, it is a complete and compelling story in just 300 words.

It's so safe, locking oneself away inside one's own head and heart. Cutting the world off. And it's okay for a day or two every now and then. But the main character here has lost the key to let herself back out. I've been there, so this touches me on a personal level.

A fellow author on here is offering guidance on writing certain parts of my stories in "negative space." The meat of your poem is the emotion of loss as expressed by a character that does not appear in the story. That's brilliant use of negative space!

This hit me very hard: "But you don't." That one simple sentence communicates sadness, exasperation, and even a bit of accusation. It's very powerful. In this same vein, the lack of any info as to why Julia is in this place allowed me to simply accept it without asking any questions about it.

This is just a fantastic flash fiction piece, Sam. Bravo!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.



189
189

Review of Psalm of the Seafarer  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Xenos,

You capture the willing outcast very well in these extended verse-lines. I don't like people, in general, because they are as mean and small as the people of the town and docks you expose here. Sailing on my own seas of writing and reading, I am safe, and insulated...but alone.

The potential religious implications are intriguing. Of course the symbology of being the only one who can stay above the water by his own power is clear. Also, we see the character "fishing for men" at the docks to follow him in the ways of the sea. The sea itself provides everything for him, as God is said to provide for the wanderer who spreads His word. But the others are not worthy, and stay behind with hunger for the Seafarer's peace. The hunt for his Magdalene is interesting through this lens, suggesting that love of the flesh and service to a higher power, such as the sea, are at odds with one another—also portrayed in other literature and histories by the vows of chastity taken by monks of various orders.

The ending is rather abrupt, and offers no resolution. If this is part of a longer work, that makes sense. But the incomplete search for the Princess of the Waves and the simple restatement of his oneness with the Sea leaves little for the reader to extrapolate.

There's a couple of things I think could make this a little better.

~ I think your presentation of verse might be better achieved by using a more classic mode with line breaks offering rhymes at the ends of each line. The reader finds the rhythm and the rhyme, and has a hard time focusing on the story because he is constantly trying to catch that rhythm throughout the lines.

~ Your rhythm is irregular throughout. It holds to a loose framework, but it's like a flight of steps where some risers are less even than others: the reader trips and stumbles over some of them. Perhaps working with classic line breaks, as mentioned above, would help identify areas of opportunity to even out that flow.

~ There's some punctuation that can be tightened up. Although, at the same time, most of it is spot-on. But some of it did trip me a little, so I wanted to mention it for your own reference.

This is quite the tale of tragedy-turned-triumph. We wonder where he goes, where he flows, and how much about "alone" he knows. Perhaps we'll find out in later installments.

Whether we find out more about the Seafarer or not, Write On!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

190
190

Review of Daily Flash Fiction Challenge  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This is one of the best contests/activities on the site. It offers a fun environment to practice tight writing and the delivery of a punchy point in limited prose; and that is a skill we can take forward as we build larger stories and avoid the risk of wandering off the storyline.

--Jeffrey
191
191

Review of Hey, is that your new phone?  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Bill,

You know, after this story, I almost sent this review via carrier pigeon! This is as creepy as an episode of Black Mirror.

The opening few incidents are interesting, in that they capture the reader's attention. They make the reader ask: "Okay; and...?" Aside from the title, there's nothing apparent to tie these little vignettes together. However, I feel like that is a strength here. It keeps the reader wondering. Well...this reader, anyway.

This story is arranged in a non-linear chronology. We see the effects before we know the cause. As I noted, that draws the reader in deeper so the beginning can be told. I did that once, but as I reread the story, I realized it was just confusing. Yours, however, is very clear at the end.

I particularly liked this line: "Portfolio value: zero dollars" The basic portfolio of life nets out to zero if you base your fulfillment in dollars and cents. So what if you lose it, in that case, perhaps.

I think the analogy is clear here that the phones themselves are a trap for us. The phones are the virus. They may not actually be leading to our physical deaths, but they are leading to social detriment (the friends going off the cliff), health issues (symbolized through the insulin overdose), and even financial problems (the investor's plummet). And we are spreading the virus with each new phone, each time we download a new widget or hook up a new gadget. We're showing our friends, supplying them to our children, making them more and more a ubiquitous part of our days, like pants and shoes. It's a spooky thought when one stops to ponder it...but it's easy to drive the thought away by simply swiping left and watching another cat video, patiently awaiting our own turn to fall into a proverbial tar pit.

I really don’t see any areas I would recommend changing or adding to in order to improve this story. It’s tightly written, grammatically sound, and punctuated with precision. The theme is delivered convolutedly, but it becomes deadly clear in the end; I think that is great thematic presentation. The conclusion is sound, both wrapping up this story, and leaving a forward-looking picture for the reader to extrapolate for themselves.

I just reviewed another piece about a young woman scrolling on her phone in almost complete depressed apathy. It could have been a lost vignette from this story! The fact that this can be tied to a lot of other stories about phones being the root or the catalyst to problems might or might not be intentional, but the reader is able to —and perhaps helpless not to—apply that. For that reason, this story will stay i the back of my mind. That's a huge part of great writing—the reader will remember your work no matter what other piece he reads.

Write on! (but...maybe use a regular computer to do so... *Wink*)


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

192
192

Review of Daily Flash Fiction Entries  

for entry "A Day in the Life
Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
iKïyå§ama,

What a wonderful blog about the apathetic state brought on by world-weariness. I never watch the news, because only about 8% is germane to me anyway. It's just a who's who of killings and ravings.

Opening this by ignoring the spider on the wall calls to our atavistic disgust and fear of the totally alien spider. It freaks a lot of us out and sends some of us screaming. The speaker here isn't fond of them but is simply too exhausted to do anything about it. It is implied that this exhaustion is not a physical thing, but a mental thing.

The addiction to virtual connection is frighteningly demonstrated. Using the ubiquitous cat videos as an example of this fixation was perfect because they are representative of the useless garbage we focus our attention on these days. (For me is chihuahua videos, all of them saying the same thing, but all of them reminding me of my own little guy—who's sitting right next to me anyway!)

But let us take a closer look at that sneaky webslinger on the wall. Whether intentional or not, Spidey is representative of the insidiousness of this scroll-ful culture: it spins webs and ensnares us in mind-numbing, fearmongering, echo chamber-like content, stealing our active social lives and sucking the blood from our joie de vivre.

And when we've read the last news story and the cats' balls of yarn are all unraveled, what is left of us? Why, nothing, really. We are exhausted from the baffling bull**** on our screens, and we are left unfulfilled, apathetic, and just plain tired.

You packed one helluva punch in just a few words, my friend. Very well done indeed!


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.

193
193

Review of Into another realm  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Carly,

Careful, Mr. Tumnus is on the way! Hopefully there's some nice Turkish Delight waiting for you up ahead.

I haven't been to Narnia in decades, and even then I only got through a few books. But I loved them! This trip back through the wardrobe was a pleasant visit back to fourth grade.

I do have one question, though: why in the world did Sam want to meet you inside a closet, for heaven's sake? Unless he's already on the other side and waiting for you. But did the door you came through open to the same place?

Dammit! Now I have questions! I need more! I could see this becoming a series of flashes. Well, looks like you've got me at "Hello." *Wink*


This review offered by
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*
194
194

Review of The Sculptor's Enigma.  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
R,

This rings so true with me! The third line, "A God to the man who sculpted him," that cuts so close to the bone. I believe that if there is a god-figure it is in the heart of each of us, displayed only int eh good we do; and the devil, so to speak, is manifested by the evil we do. "God" and "devil" are just shorthand for stated of being and ways of behaving. Therefore, we have sculpted God for ourselves!

Now it should be understood that I find no fault with faith. Each person believing in their own version of the god-figure is beautiful, in fact. It is the imposed theocratic efforts "to keep them shackled in the chains of religion" that I can't tolerate.

Let me comment on the writing briefly.

~ The middle part, which is certainly prose rather than poetry, is begging to be reworked to fit the rest of the poem. It's where the turn is, where the absolute most important part of the poem is (except for that wonderful third line).

~ You might also consider letting the second to last line go away. "Stupid" just doesn't fit the rest of the vocabulary in the poem. It sounds argumentative and petulant compared to the rest of the pointed, deliberate verbiage.

~ This is totally this reader's opinion, right here. Consider single-spacing some of your lines together, like stanzas. Let them capture complete thoughts—not terribly unlike that middle paragraph, only grouped as lines.

This is an angry, direct commentary about religion and the fallacy of the origin of God vs Man. I strongly identify with it (having just published a book of poetry called God and Man), and I commend the construction of the argument/statement.


This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


195
195

Review of Something's Down Here  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Very nice! I like the uncertainty of the boys' demise. I always love stories that start in the middle of the action. Making my own backstory is half the fun for me.

This is a mostly dialog-driven piece, which really makes it impressive. Driving action using mostly just talking is a skill I DO NOT have; I love to see it used well by others.

Good job fitting a tightly-written scene into such short parameters.

This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
Jeffrey
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


196
196

Review of Is Human Intuition A Gift or A Curse  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (2.5)
Derrick,

This is a horse of several colors! Part essay, part blog, part poem, it reads with a thoughtfulness that tends toward a sad imagistic outlook at the end.

This line: "we have good times by wasting good times" stood out to me as particularly profound. Money is made to be spent; food is made to be eaten. Are not good times meant to be wasted? Or are we using the wrong vocabulary in this conversation? Perhaps the only waste of a good time is not to have, not to spend like emotional currency. As one singer put it: "Hold on loosely, but don't let go."

Your sly use of the quote by Queen was nice, and it touched on a different topic—living forever. I would advance, however, that that discussion could be pared out of this poem. It is not germane to the discussion of intuition.

I am going to challenge you: adjust this somewhat. Adapt it into the editorial that it wants to be. Give us your thoughts in a narrative format so that we are not distracted by looking for meter or rhyme. It is perfectly "acceptable" to end an article with a bit of verse for a powerful close, and I think the end of this piece would do just that.

As a poem, I think there is a lot of massaging that needs to be done; but as a conversation or collective statement, I think you are well on your way to making a good point. (One other thing, though, make sure you're trying to make just one point; save immortality for another piece where you can focus exclusively on it.)

You propose an interesting topic, here, to which I don't have a ready answer. Intuition allows us to borrow trouble from tomorrow so we can add it to the worry of today; but lack of intuition leaves us to step into quicksand without ever having suspected it was there. I suppose every gift has a b-side of curse with it. Perhaps the summation to the point is that what we do with our intuition is what makes it a curse or a gift. I'm no philosopher, but that sounds right to me. At least...that's what my intuition tells me. *Smile*



This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


197
197

Review of Pay Attention  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Alexis,

Wow, I am immediately reminded on e. e. cummings by this. This poem is not a giver—that is, it doesn't give its meaning away plainly. One has to think through this one for a moment. Well...I did, at least. And what I take away is a very interest message, quite counterintuitive to what we are often led to think: don't hold onto this moment. Embrace the moment as it comes, experience it as much as you can, and then let it go so that the next moment is fresh.

The use of the word "vanity" is interesting in this poem. It could represent the gloating graspiness we all seem to share, that urge to hoard things and say, "This is my memory!" Poetry is not always just a painting, though; sometimes it is a sharp tool. I would not be entirely surprised to find that the "vanity" spoken of in this poem is aimed at an individual of whom the casual reader is unaware.

I particularly like your use of negative space in the presentation of the poem. It has a fleeting feeling, a flowing feeling. The end seems to want to be let go, as though it's slipping downward like sand in an hourglass. Catching the eye is as important as catching the mind, as you demonstrate so well here.

The message I take from this is very intuitive and very true: don't try holding on too tightly to something you are enjoying right now, because you risk missing the enjoyment of things to come.

Very well done, Alexis.


This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


198
198

Review of Haiku  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Vera,

You present two very different poems here, both of them nice.

The first much more closely follows the Japanese "rules" of haiku, juxtaposing two images to create a statement. The rising of the sun symbolizing emerging life contrasts against the falling leaves, yet there is beauty in it. Very nice.

The second haiku less closely follows that pattern. In fact, one might question of this is really haiku at all, due to the repetition of an entire line. You may want to be careful there; that really does transgress the rules of the form.

This is a very enjoyable couplet of haiku. Enjoy the summer. And while you're at it—Write On!

This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


199
199

Review of The birthday virus speaks  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Angelica,

Well, I reckon this charachter is 25 now. I wonder if the birthday virus will find her this year?

This virus strikes us all when we're young. We talk about our birthdays and think about our birthdays and prepare for our birthdays incessantly. Yes! I can seem like a virus at times! Sometimes, we also look for signs (which may or may not be there) that we can read to portent success and tidings. I think the dialog this character holds with herself is very healthy, and the way she subconsciously unlocks her creativity through pseudo-numerology is a very clever ploy on the writer's part!

I love that the voice can be silenced with sweets. "There's a skinny guy inside me, screaming to get out...but I can usually shut him up with a handful of cookies!" I think that's my motto. *Shock*

Excellent work using nothing but dialog. I find this to be a challenge, so I recognize the effort you put in to keep it a smooth journey for the reader.

Even though I'm a year late to the party: Happy Birthday! *Wink*


This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.


200
200

Review of Paradise Awaits?  

Review by centurymeyer35Mail Icon
In affiliation with The Power Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Sci,

This is another admonishment to us individuals that the harder the work is, the greater the reward usually is. You have gone one step further, though, and I appreciate this: in the last line of the story, you use the character of Vivian to point out that, even though the trek was indeed very arduous, and the city is very beautiful, is not paradise. Just because the work is hard does not mean the prize will be perfect. I think we tend to fool ourselves into believing we will get more than what we want when we work for something. And as you demonstrate here, that just isn't the case.

There are some elements of your writing I encourage you to review and potentially edit, toward the goal of improving.

~ While I frequently advise writers to use a larger font, this choice may be a little over the top. Pear in mind that this is opinion; there's no rulebook anywhere saying what font you should use. But Size 5 Courier Bold makes the letters so big that the user has to scroll a lot to read the piece. I will admit, on the other hand, that it is easier to see. Again, this is an opinion.

~ More important than anything, the dialog is very stilted, very stiff. It reads as though English is not one's first language? Specifically, there are far too few contractions and pronouns. For instance:

“We’re going to continue toward our next destination,” answers Harold. “We should have enough gas to get to our next destination. After that, we don’t know how long it will take us to find more gas. It depends on how advanced this city is now.”

      Would read more smoothly as

“We’re going to continue the journey; we have to,” answers Harold. “We should have enough gas to get there, but after that, I don’t know how long it will take to find more. It depends on how modern this city is.”

I suggest using contractions more frequently, such as we're instead of we are, for example.

~ There was a part of the conversation with the family that seemed very odd to me. The conversation centering around the children's puberty and potential for sexual activity and parenthood seemed very, very far from a) any conversation that children that age would initiate, and b) so unrelated to the main story that it felt awkward and forced. I'm not advising that one censor this kind of conversation; there's nothing wrong with the topic at all. This conversation simply doesn't feel like it belongs here.

Sometimes writing itself can be just as much of a journey as the one Tracy and her family took, but in the end, I hope you will achieve the goal your reaching for, whatever it may be. To reach that goal, my friend: Write On!


This review offered by
** Image ID #2341538 Unavailable **
——————————
*Strong**Floral1*"The Power Reviewers Group*Floral1**Explode*

Please note that my reviews are intended to be
respectful and encouraging.
If you feel I have been rude, cruel,
or otherwise inappropriate,
please report this review to a moderator.