*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/hanna/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
270 Public Reviews Given
293 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 ... Next
51
51
Review of Glass Shoes  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
I couldn't have said it better.

You describe the unfortunate women with a sharp pen, no subtleties and no admission of guilt, which is the case with most abused women.

It pains me to think of these women, and I know that as the world gets to be more sophisticated and advanced in technology and philosophy, the status of some of us humans will never change. A chilling thought proven right by what we hear and see all over the world.

Hanna
52
52
Review of Ellipsis  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi there Josephine,

I like the quote you used, for poetry is mostly in the gut... But punctuation helps deliver your message!

I like your poem a lot. The title ELLIPSIS threw me off at first, but having read the poem, I think I know what you mean by it.

I could not find any connection between the first lines -

"I read them and don’t understand

the lines, but

still they are so beautiful"

and the following lines:

"still

beauty, roses

melting in the sun of fifty thousand lightbulbs

with no purpose

but to just keep switching off and on."

You speak of something you've read and switch to roses and lightbulbs. Each topic stands on its own, but how are they connected? One topic normally leads to the other with at least a hint of a tie. It made me stop reading and wonder what you were talking about.

The rest of the poem is exceptionally well written. I love the use of the black ink staining and marring every item in sight. Original concept. And the unpleasant end - although chilling, a strong note to finish a powerful poem.

Thanks for sharing it and I hope to read soon more of your work.

Hanna


53
53
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi JVD,

For a person so young you dfinetly have a poet's heart. I like your rhymed sentences at the end of the poem.

I'm not going to lecture you, just give you a few pointers.

In traditional poetry (Rhymed and metered) if you use the rhyms, it sounds awkward with an uneven meter. Try to count the syllables in each line and make the number more equal.

In a poem, unlike in prose, each word has a greater weight and must be considered carefully. Doubling of words is absolutely not necessary. example: Long long; Realy realy.

When words or phrases keep repeating in a poem, it makes reading boring. In your poem you mentiones twice that warm autumn day and twice the Pj's and the formal school clothes. Go over those lines and see if the poem can survive without the repetition and perhaps use alternative words.

I hope you find my comments useful. If you think I'm wrong or you just want to leave your poem as is - it's ok.

Hanna

54
54
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi James,

This is a poem that can be adopted by anyone. Whether you fight in an army to defend your country or stand up to all sorts of injustice in this world, it is true for all circumstances.

In my own country, there's a bitter war going on (Israel) and this poem truely reflects what all Israelis feel and have felt for decades.

The poem flows beautifuly and the rhyming is good. I truly enjoyed reading it.

Thanks for these encouraging words.

Hanna
55
55
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hello Louis,

I like the ideas you've put into the lyrics, but I would like to make a few comments, if it's ok with you.

I don't know if you have music to the lyrics, but it is hard for me to think of any rhythm or tune to go with the very long lines and the VERY short chorus.

You have started the first stanza in the past tense ("There WAS a man...") and in the second line you switched to the present tense. Like in poetry and prose, you must stick to the same tense all along the piece.

"Walk to the shore through the town, his whole life he's lived." - I don't quite understand this line. Perhap some words are missing?

The second stanza deals with a rich man in the big city, but I think you can do better than that in describing the emptines and lonliness of a rich man. In what you said, the man hasn't done anything wrong. He's just rich. Has he given up on love and family while pursuing money? Has he been mean? I think there's a lot to be said in a manner that would compliment the man in the first stanza.

I hope this review is taken in the spirit given - that of a genuine wish to improve your work.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
56
56
Review of Celestial Seas  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
TL,

This is mighty good. Well balanced, flows easily and has an undertone of love and warm feelings.

I love the traditional form of poetry and you've added a lot to its format by having a few lines repeated.

I would consider changing the font colour - it's too light on the background.

Well done.

Hanna
57
57
Review of It Hurts Me Too  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hello Neal,

I like this poem a lot. It comes from the heart and made me wonder if answers exist anywhere since we all seem to have only questions.

The poem was written in the free style form, but was rough in a few places. The first noticeable hurdle was lack of punctuation which got in the way of fluent reading.

I took the liberty of putting in punctuation and changed a couple of line breaks - moved words to a new line.

In a few places I suggested change of words or deleting words. You'll find it in the body of your poem highlighted in red.

I hope you won't consider this chutzpah, because I don't mean to hurt your feelings, just giving my honest observation. Hope you'll do the same for me.

Hanna


She called me last night and asked
what is breathing.
But I had no answer because I ask
the same question everyday.
What is breathing?
and (delete)I have no answers even for
myself.
So I told her to just hang in there,
but she sounded real shaky,
like she wanted to cry.
But (delete) she’s been crying for days and
she doesn’t feel any better.
Then she asked what is faith,
but I had no answer because
I don’t have any.
So I just kept quiet,
and then she asked, is it
a foundation for something
or merely a stage for
broken actors?
So I told her, just hang in there,
But even I sounded a bit shaky.
And she said she wasn’t sure
how much longer she can hang in there.
So I said, I know, because
I don’t know how much more
I can take either.
And she knew this (c:red}(change to THAT) but it’s (change to IT WAS) ok
because no matter what,
we’re there for each other.
And I said this and she started to cry.
And (delete) I don’t like to hear women cry,
because it’s so soft, yet
the pain is so hard
and it hurts me too.
So I did my best to hold her through the phone,
and she knew this too.
So she eventually stopped crying
and said thank you.
And out of habit I said you’re welcome,
but inside I felt guilty, because I didn’t feel
helpful (change to I HELPED HER) to her (delete)
and because I wanted to ask her
the same questions she asked me.
But I didn’t call her,
she called me.
58
58
Review of Fairies  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hey Bill,

Just learnt about the rictameter form and wrote one for kids.

I like your poem. I somehow expected more verses... So much more can be said about that kind of "fairies"...

How are you doing? Long time no talk!

Hugs,

Hanna
59
59
Review of A Dream  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi Waves,

I know now why you liked my children's poems. This poem of yours is my style as well...

The poem is well written, rhymes and meter flow smoothly and the images are very vivid.

The lines I like best are:
"A dream of jellybeans and rainbows
Live in her heart where love glows."

May I ask why you chose to limit the poem to ages 13 and above? I think younger readers could enjoy it too.

Well done.

Hanna

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.


PS: You're invited to read more of my poems.
60
60
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello Cara,

I read your first chapter with great interest, for the period and subject interest me.

Forgive me if what I'm going to say will sound harsh - I have no intention of hurting your feelings, all I want to do is make you understand that what you have posted can only be considered as first draft and needs a lot of work.

I'm going to list here some of the issues that need attention. In the body of the chapter you'll find relevant comments.

To begin with - you are writing a novel. The first chapter should be gripping, allowing a reader to be transferred to another world, atmosphere and way of thinking. From what you wrote, I couldn't tell where I was, in which period of time or part of the world.

I like the story beginning with the birth of Rhiannon, but you should put in the beginning a couple of paragraphs telling where we are, describing the period, place and people.

Your writing is not accurate. Hints and half thoughts do not contribute to the flow of a story. If slave women were forbidden to have children, say so. As a matter of fact, it is not so clear that the girls were slaves.

You use a lot of repetitions in sentences. When one weeps, it's enough to say: She wept. No need to say: "She wept and wept and wept". Even in regular speech you won't say it like this.

Pay attention to details like time factor - you can't say it was autumn in one paragraph then later say it's summer. Remember movements and actions and don't contradict them later (The eunuch backed away to the wall, then later backed away again. To where?)

I see great potential in this story. You need to go over it carefully, revise it and think of every sentence you write, construct it clearly and make it "glue" to the pervious lines and foresee as well the next lines.

Another advice - use a grammar and spelling check, avoid too many adjectives and write grammatically correct sentences.

I hope I've been of some help. I'd love to read this again after a revision and naturally I'm looking forward to reading more.

Hanna

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
61
61
Review of Moving Day  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi Patty,

First, let me tell you that you're not alone in this situation. I went through the same ordeal, not once, but three times. And I dread the moment my last chick will spread his wings and take off.

Your poem describes your feelings quite well, although I find it written in a light note considering the gravity of the issue. I know that sometimes, in order to overcome painful moments, one tends to use humor to soften the impact. I do it all the time.

You used a rhyming pattern with no meter and in most parts the poem flows nicely, in others, some lines are too long.

You started two consecutive stanzas with the word "SO". I would change it in one of them.

Overall, a good poem which I enjoyed, and more than that, sympathized with the poet. Well done.

Hanna

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

62
62
Review of Belief  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hey MB,

A good poem which flows well and a good development of thought.

A couple of comments:

In the first verse, the first lines are much longer than the lines in the rest of the poem. A few minor changes will correct it:

"There are some philosophers(Delete the word SOME)
who would have you believe,(Change to WHO'D)


In the fourth verse:

"Never not tired,
never not stressed."

(NEVER means NOT EVER. There is no need for the word NOT, for it makes it a double negative.)

The lines I like best in the poem are:
Believe in yourself,
that’s all you need do.
Believe in yourself,
I know you'll pull through."

Well done.

Hanna
"
63
63
Review of For Srebrenica  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Hello MB,

first, let me say to you that if you want 'gentle' criticism, you're wasting your time being a member in a writing group. Perhaps this sounds harsh, but it's the truth, facts of life.

I haven't been writing for long; not all my life like some members here. If not for constructive reviews I got from some members, I would have been trading water and learnt absolutely nothing.

The trick when reviewing a piece that needs work is not to insult the writer but let him see his mistake and suggest ways to correct them. Being honest is the first thing you can spot in a review, and at the bottom line, it's up to you whether you accept the comments or not.

Your poem, in my opinion, needs a lot of work and raises a lot of questions.

I won't write a review for it unless you ask me to.

I'm going to read your other pieces.

Hanna
64
64
Review of The Dialogue 500  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Hey Bill,

Great contest. Important for any aspiring writer. Only stumbled upon it this morning. Guess I was away from the contests boards for a while!

Here's a little something for the kitty.

Hugs,

Hanna
65
65
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (1.0)
Hey Fyndorian.

I read you piece about the covered bridge. I'm calling it a "piece" for when I was done reading I had a feeling I had just read a short story. No offense meant, but it doesn't read like a poem. It doesn't have the rhythm or the formating of a poem. It is an interesting story, but you failed to give it what it needs to become a poem.

I took the liberty of transforming the poem into a story: I didn't change a single word. It takes two and a half pages and reads much better (see below)

I hope you're not made at me for suggesting the change, but this is my honest opinion.

I tried to send this message earlier, but I'm not sure it went through, so if you get it twice, just read one!

Hanna

The Covered Bridge--April, 1927


Seemed like mud was slowly creeping into everything that Spring.
While in the distance flattened, yellow winter grass held just a hint of green,
underfoot was slick with spongy, clinging mud.

People left tracks behind them; water oozing into heel-marks
like a snoopy neighbor into my kitchen.

Downstream a ways... ‘bout where that old granddaddy bass was always hiding
in the deep shadows, just shy of the falls, that's where the covered bridge crossed the river.
It was new in my granddad's day.

Built strong and solid, built to last, with nary a nail, mind you... But all wooden pegs pounded into that Vermont oak.

Came through the great storm of ‘09 with nary a loose board nor shingle.
Folks here ‘bouts said that old bridge would be here when we was all long dead and gone.
Oh, there was another bridge, nothing of consequence though,
just a new-fangled concrete and iron contraption built to accommodate those new motor cars
we had coming through once the road was extended to Manchester.

Looked right sturdy enough and all, but most of us, well, we still preferred to use the covered bridge.

That particular morning dawned about the same as it had for the past week or so,
the grey clouds pressing down like an unsettled argument.

The Battenkil swollen with snow melt, had flooded out most of the acreage west of town over towards New York state.

We spent the early hours that Sunday morning over to Mrs. Mulligan's for coffee.
She only had one boarder in for the night, a reporter fellow up from Bennington
to write a story about young George Plimpton taking over the Equinox from his Pa.

Don't know why that young man didn't stay there, less he was mindful
of saving a penny or two.

Course, the food was much better at Kate Mulligan's, there is that.
Guess he was sleeping in being as he was city folk and all, at any rate we didn't see hide nor hair of him that morning at all.

Most near half the town was in Old St. John's Episcopal Church that Sunday.
I remember Rev'rend Morrow's sermon like it was yesterday. . .
He'd gone on at great length, as usual, about staying close to the Almighty
in the face of the many changes that seemed to be tearing at the old ways.

My thoughts wandered during that long, final hymn, never was much for singing,
and well, those long oaken benches, so finely waxed and polished by the Ladies Guild Society every Saturday, were starting to feel mighty hard.
There was Mrs. Wentlock... Complete with her pink, floppy excuse for a hat that never missed a service come rain, snow or indigestion.

Couple of rows beyond her, Old Mr. Dodge, he of the powerful voice, rheumatism and nagging wife, looked down at her and smiled in between verses.

Across the aisle, Michael and Sarah Watlington, the newcomers and newly wed,
not quite accepted yet.

We didn't get too many strangers moving in.
Folks drove by on the new road, tourists
on their way to Mt. Bromley
or up to visit and stay at the Equinox
up on the hill.
And some came to see the original and still thriving
L.L. Bean factory, but they came and visited a while and left.
Nope, here in town, children grew older, married and moved away;
we lost the Almhurst brothers in the Great War along with Edward Dodge and Jerry Freemont,
the old folk grew older still ‘till they died. . . Town never did seem to change much.

The double oaken doors opened after the service and people spilled like beans into the churchyard.

No one lingered that day as they usually did comparing new calves, young ‘uns or the price of soybeans.

Most folks just took one look at the sky and scurried for their wagons.
Shafts of lightning tore through the jagged clouds and thunder reverberated
like one of Rev'rend Morrow's sermons.

The sky opened, rain pouring down like a split sack of salt. Some headed back into the church, while others ran for the shelter of the bridge.

The clamor of wind and water all but drowned out the thunder that grew louder still.
Then, as if it were trying to shrug off the storm, the bridge shuddered, shivered.

People ran panicked grabbing children, horses, each other. The ground ‘neath the near end
gave way in a slide of rocks and mud. The old timbers screeched wood against wood
as the force of the water took our bridge down the river.

Those on the shore just stood there; caught in a flash of lightning. Then someone shouted. . .
Pointed. In the midst of the swirling bits of wood and debris was a body being swept towards the falls.

Newcomer Michael kicked off his boots and dove into the muddy water. Fighting the Battenkill with every stroke, Michael reached the man, grabbed his slicker and dragged the unconscious man to shore.

Ayuh, poor old Mr. Dodge, I thought, but no, his body shook and he set to coughing up half the river. Shouts from downstream: Mrs. Dodge had been swept over the falls. Jubilation over the one rescue faded into silence.
Mrs. Wentworth, arms around three crying children, grey hair streaming down her shoulders,
lifted her hatless head and walked the children over to their mother. Sarah Watlington draped a blanket around her husband and wiped his hair back from his eyes,
before resting her head on his shoulder.

Some folks headed back into the church never noticing Rev'rend Morrow sitting all by himself
on a rock in the churchyard, head in his hands, his shoulders shaking.

Later that afternoon over a mug of ‘medicinal' coffee,
I thought back to the empty raw place where the bridge used to be; had always been.
A part of our town, indeed, a part of our lives had been swept away.

A good many years back I'd even toyed with the notion of marrying Emma Dodge,
(Hathaway back then) myself. Funny though, Rev'rend Morrow picking today to sermonize on change.

Course, you never know what's going to happen one day to the next.

Well, at least we have the new bridge I thought, drifting off to sleep in front of the fire. . Elsewise.... how'd we get ‘cross the river?

66
66
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hi Fyndorian,

A lovely fantasy tale with a valuable lesson. In my own writing for children I always try to put in some kind of lesson.

I would like to comment on the poem itself.

1. There is no panctuation in the poem. I know that most poets hate it, but once you post your work to the board, it should be as perfect as you can make it, including panctuation. It is even more important in a long poem that tells a long story.

2. Breaking for stanzas was done in an odd way. There is no patern and the number of lines in each stanza varies. I wonder why? It doesn't help the fluency of reading.

3. Rhyming - not consistant throughout the poem. The story is there, interesting and original, but the vessel upon which it rides seems to be faulty.

4. Too many repetions of words in successive lines:
"lived alone in the forest deep,
All alone with her dreams and her charms," - The word ALONE in both lines.

5. There's no need to put so many spaces between the first 5 stanzas and the song of the dragon-mother. It confuses the reader.

6. I think you must find a better way to start telling about the dragon after the first verses which tell about the girl and the wizard. Perhap separating the new story with a couple of **** to take the reader elsewhere.

To sum up my review - I think that with a bit of work this could be a great poem. I'd love to read it again sometime.

Hanna

PS Is this poem aimed at children? If it does, you should mention it in the category.
67
67
Review by Hanna
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Fyndorian,

I totally enjoyed this story. It is well written in the first person and has enough suspense in it to carry the reader to the end.

I would add a couple of details to the story - first, the age of the kids. I remember my own daughter played with Barbbie and Ken untill well into the end of High school (she's 27 now and won't let me get rid of them...)I think it would help visualize the scenes and help understand the characters.

Another detail which I thought was missing - a physical discription of the characters. Not much, just an idea of what they looked like.

I found one typo which you should fix: "Barbie's reputation was on the line! Gary or Joe, one of them, I forget which," - should read "forgot".

Great writing, Fyndorian.

Hanna

PS I know you're new at this site, but I would advise to write a few words to introduce yourself in the Bio Block.
68
68
Review of Placesettings  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi Fyndorian,

This is one very good free verse poem.

I like the use of cutlery as metaphors and the summation that plenty of delicate, intricate details make up one person.

Well done.

Hanna


69
69
Review by Hanna
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hey Sara,

I like this poem very much. It talks of real things in real time.

I liked New York 35 years ago on my only visit and I do think that New Yorkers are different from other city dwellers in the States. Like a breed of their own...

Let me comment on the following verse:

"There is more going on than you care
to consider. Too much happens
at every moment and it must all
be chronicled, put on paper
and put into song,
sung in churches and halls."

There is a repetition of the word PUT and I would suggest changing the second on to "recorded", thus making the sentence more meaningful: "Put on paper and recorded into songs.

In the last line, in order to give the idea more buoyancy, and since churches and halls are basically the same indoor places, I would change the HALLS into OPEN PARKS. The lines then would read:

"put on paper
and recorded into song,
sung in churches and open parks."

It was interesting to read that you consider greed as the main disease of society. I tend to agree with you though... but not too many people can identify it.

Well done Sara. I always admire free verse poetry that flows like a river downstream, without any obstacle.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


70
70
Review of You  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Hello Sisy,

This is the best summation of what was and is wrong with the way God works up his so called "miracles". Very pessimistic, I'd say. But most of the times I share your views, especially when I think about the Holocaust and the crematoriums.

There's one typo which you could correct - "You choke the love cupped in you hands," - should be YOUR hands.

You were pretty angry when you wrote this. I was also angry this week, watching on tv for long hours the Chronicles of Auschwits, on the week of commemorating its 60th anniverdary of the liberation from the Nazis. I guess that whoever lives under that awful shadow of memory will never fully regain the true belief in God.

Hanna
71
71
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi MC,

It's been a while since I've seen you enter a contest. Good to read your work.

As usual, the meter is your favourite 7 and it's perfect. Your poem can be used to advertise Mango!

Here are a few observations:

Rhyming

SOUR and PURE don'r rhyme.
SURE and MORE don't rhyme.

In the following line there is a grammar mistake:

"What a variety of taste!" - The word VARIETY suggests plural, so it should read TASTES.

It was a great prompt for a contest, don't you think?

Good luck.

Hanna
72
72
Review by Hanna
Rated: 18+ | (2.5)
Hello Tee,

Princess Victoria - first chapter comments:

First I'll give you the grammar /spelling/text comments:

1. "Unprecedentedness" - Unprecedented – adjective. You can't make it a noun by adding "ness." It simply doesn't exist in this form.

2. "This Victoria of ever glaring nubility - It doesn't sound good when you tell about your heroine and say "This Victoria". It somehow diminishes her value in your story.

3. Second paragraph in the story: I'm sure you haven't noticed, but the first sentence has 116 words, 10 commas, one semi-colon and one period which makes it a mile long sentence.

4. Typo – Gustos – should be: gustoes

5. "She insists: he would be unassuming, unchauvinistic, unyielding; never be ruled by expediencies, always placing the harmony of a relationship of love above his personal wishes and sentiments, because his heart and mind would be bent upon a definite cause to nobility." - I don't understand this paragraph. Who is HE? If your trying to deliver Victoria's beliefs and standpoints, you should say so.

6. "Well! Good enough! Eternally for her, but only shortly for her father."

7. You've lost me here. What is good enough? And it should be ETERNITY (noun), and A SHORT PERIOD. Why the inverted commas? Did she say the sentence?

8. The next paragraph has some dialogue. Unknown people ask Victoria about her preferences in man. That is fine, but you can't conduct a dialogue when one participant is unknown. Who said: "Really?"

9. In the poem: Typo - flessh – should be FLESH

Grammar - mesmerical! – Doesn't exist in this form. Should be MESMERIC.


General remarks:

I don't want to hurt your feeling, but if you are serious about writing this novel, please listen to me. I'm going to be blunt and honest.

When you start a novel, it must be clear in your head who the target audience is. According to this decision, the form and language of the novel are determined. Judging by the language you've used, I think you'll find very few people capable of understanding the kind of sophisticated, out of the dictionary words that make up your story. A story should flow, reading should be easy, and if one has to stop to look up every second word, the pleasure of reading is gone and soon the book would be discarded. Perhaps I'm not qualified to say what hard language is (English is not my first language), but I read a lot and I review a lot. Your sentences are long and heavy with unknown words.

Another comment regarding language – you tend to use too many adverbs and adjectives which burden the picture you're trying to create. In some instances you've made up words that don't exist.

Let's talk in general about the first chapter of a book:

The first paragraphs should introduce the main character and should be so gripping that a reader would want to go on reading. Some information as to where the story takes place, the period and a general description of the main characters would have increased the interest in the story. After having read the first chapter, I can't say I know any the answer to these questions.

What we have in the story is a strong-headed woman/girl who wants to marry for love and reserves the right to choose her future husband. You wrote so much around it that I had to ask myself why the long sentences in a language that adds nothing to the story.

I wanted to ask you why you chose to tell the story in the present tense. There is nothing wrong with doing so, but it means that the story is happening while you're telling it. This has its disadvantages. The POV was that of the narrator (the author), and in a romance novel I would suggest either using the main character as POV or another character. It will give the story a better angle and opportunity to go deeper into the mind of the character.

My honest advice to you is to rewrite this, for the story has a lot of potential. If the period is way in the past, perhaps a touch of old English will do. You must write in a manner that would leave no unanswered questions, create an unseen tension which will reveal slowly the Obstacle in the story and develop the plot around it.

It would be better to do a bit of changes at this stage and not wait until the novel is done and then sit on a "White Elephant".

As I said earlier, these are my suggestions and I know you'll regard them as such.

Hanna
73
73
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
Sorry, I meant to send you some GP's with my post to the forum. You deserve it!

Here they are.

Hanna
74
74
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hello Writersmind,

I like your poem and what you're trying to say.

As a poem, I think you should consider a few pointers:

1. Punctuation is wrong in many lines – some unnecessary comas, a period in the middle of a line and again commas instead of semi-colon.

2. The poem doesn't read smoothly. Perhaps dividing it to stanzas would help. I took the liberty of doing that as a suggestion. I haven't changed any of the words, just the punctuation. Read it and see if you like it.

3. Keep in mind that a free verse poem must have as well some rhythm that comes both from formatting and choice of words.

Overall, you managed to express the conflict, choosing subtle expressions, which is very good.

Hanna

***************************

In the endless ocean
Of everlasting dust,
There are cries;
Not only of agony but of love.

For left behind are families
With nothing but their lives to lead;
All waiting for an answer.

While torn and ragged,
Covered in arms,
They must trust our leaders certainty.

Thunder is the ongoing sound
Of what seems to be;
Yet lightning strikes them dead.

Entangled in weeks old clothes,
Drenched and stained,
In what they wished was only rain.

Families fear the days to come
While gripping tight to sanity,
With nothing but their dreams and hopes,
Plagued with such uncertainty.

If not for the ones
We call, "Armed Forces",
There could be no such thing
As freedom of choices.

Now don't forget
Their blood, sweat and tears,
While always knowing
That America is here.

For if "United we stand
And divided we fall,"
Then remember,
This is war and the price of freedom

75
75
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello SG,

I've read this story about a year ago when I posted my own Noodle story... Pity that contest never took off... Have you ever read my story?

Your story is nice but lacks action and advanture. I think you can axpand it a little.

If you're keeping it in your port, you'd better explain as a prologue the first chapter which was given as a prompt, otherwise a reader wouldn't know what you're talking about. I should do the same...

Hanna
96 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 4 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/hanna/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3