*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/hanna/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/4
Review Requests: OFF
270 Public Reviews Given
293 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 3 -4- ... Next
76
76
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello StoryMaster,

I've only discovered this page recently, and I find it a great idea, helping members promote their work and those who look for something to review can take a quick look too.

The only thing that annoys me is the fact that it doesn't say what kind of work it is. It gives the genre but not if it's prose or poetry. It makes browsing longer.

Perhaps in your page rules you could ask members to specify in the PLUG what it is.

Hanna

77
77
Review of O'Henry  
Review by Hanna
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hello RVP,

What a coincidence! I was reading your O'Henry when you posted your comments to my story!

I must tell you I had a good laugh, a very healthy laugh!

You see, I'm Israeli and anything that would advance the peace talks in the Middle East is welcome!!!

And I was thinking about poor O'Henry... I'm sure he's turning in his grave, although he had a good sense of humour...

Ok. To serious business now. I like the way you write, Light and flowing. I have a few comments though. Hope you can take a bit of critique.

To begin with - to make reading easier, please put in spaces between the paragraphs. Your story looks like a solid block and if a reader stops for a second, it's hard to find the last line read.

Then there are the tenses. The story is told in the past tense. some of your sentences revert to the present tense. It must be consistant.

Typos:

"The dream began with (the) my wife and me in the White House war room,"
"and a big toothy grin on their face(s)."

Repetition of a word in one sentence. Better to use comma and not repeat the word:

"As it turns out, an O’Henry is a universally known, (universally) practiced and (universally) adored tradition known as “The Nooner”! When an O’ Henry is
called, it is the..."

To conclude - this is a great piece, especially thinking of the late Khomeini or some of the religious figures in the world!

Well done!

Hanna
78
78
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello Verm,

I stumbled on this article while searching Google for information regarding the makings of an Abstract Poem.

I'm a novice poet/writer and I try my hand at various forms of poetry.

I agree with everything you said about people who write prose, formate it in short lines and stanzas and call it poetry. I've reviewed many of those, both here and in my MSN group. Somehow when I comment on it, I get a cold shoulder...

I found absolutely nothing on the net to tell me what abstract poetry is, except for a lot of talk about abstract nouns. I'm not sure I like this kind of poetry, but I'd like to try it.

Thanks for sharing your article. I enjoyed reading it.

Hanna

I have a bit of a memory problem, but I have a remote feeling that we've met before...
79
79
Review of FRUSTRATION  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hi Tee,

Well, I've read your story.

I normally give my honest opinion when I review any work, but I'm afraid that perhaps you won't like what I have to say.

You're an Englishman, aren't you? I could tell by the language...

Let me know if you want me to comment on your story.

Reading your comment to my poem, I had a feeling your writing would be complicated... and there are only 2 items in your port. Shame, for I would have liked to read more.

Hanna

80
80
Review of Verge of April  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
Eliot,

Love the poem, but I still don't understand why April is the cruelest month!

April is spring time. New beginnings. Transformation of nature. Passover. This Hanna was born in April... April... When planet Mars comes into view and energizes the lambs...

When I used to live in the northern hemisphere, April was my best month. Now it's just an autumn month.

If your departure accured in April and left bad sentiments, find an event in this month which will erase the bad taste... lol Just kidding.

Very good poem. Perhaps after writing for the next 50 years I'll get to write half as well as you!

Hanna
81
81
Review of Christening  
Review by Hanna
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Eliot,

This is a great love poem, love for the woman, the new born and the spirit of God.

In the bible it says that man comes from dust and into dust he shall return. In your poem I found the more acceptable version of this - we all come from the flesh... Where we end is a different story!

Hanna

82
82
Review of Myths of Poetry  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi Eliot,

This is the first article I've read that makes total sense to me, as a writer and a reader.

I'm not really a poet. I lack the proper tools of language. I'm a story teller and I usually find the form of poetry confining. But at least I know now, thanks to you, that what I've been doing so far was not wrong, that the "I" in some of my poems was not always me personally although readers thought it was...

I've read a few of your poems. I'm in no position to critique them, I can just tell you what I feel as a reader. There were a few poems I didn't understand and some that were too short to impress an image upon me.

I think I'm about to learn a lot about poetry from you, if you'll let me.

There is nothing about you in your port. Trivia - where you live, your age, occupation?

I'm running a writers group with MSN, and I would like to post this article in my group, if you'll allow it. I often post articles about writing for the members.

Thanks for killing the myths...

Hanna
83
83
Review of Warned  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
I like this poem a lot. It flows nicely, but I think you need a few periods... There are only a couple of commas and I had to catch my breath!

Good luck in the contest!

Hanna
84
84
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello StoryMaster,

Very good idea!

I always hated the limited options we had and often battled with copying from Word to Notepad, not being able to get the right spacing and fonts.

Does this new system mean I can copy/paste straight from Word? That would be an absolute blessing!!!!

Thanks a million!

Hanna
85
85
Review of A World of Hatred  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



Anti-war preaching is my game, especially when written so beautifully as this poem.

Really enjoyed it.

Congrats on your win! Well done!


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

86
86
Review of October's Lie  
Review by Hanna
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hello Viv,

Finally I know where the nickname comes from... I often wondered...

The story is very good. Well written and flows smoothly. The inner thoughts and conflicts are presented well and the end leaves the reader with hope.

Well done!

Hanna

PS: I too had once a "Thing" against October, and for 5 years, each October I got terrible elergic reactions which could not be helped by a doctor. With time it went away. The human mind is very powerful and our bodies work in mysterious ways...
87
87
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello Nona,

Absolutely charming! I like the idea of playing with letters. I did it all the time with my kids (wooden cubes with letter on each side).

If I may make a suggestion - the only word you chose was IN - I can't see any attruction in this word for a child. The word ME, I think, would make it more appealing. Only a suggestion.

Hanna
88
88
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi Nona,

This little poem is nice, but as soon as I started to read it, I felt that it sounded more like captions under some nice photos of a horse, mouse and a colt. It is obviously meant for toddlers, and I think they still need the pictures.

Hanna
89
89
Review of Borrowed Time  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)


Hello Bill,

I must say that it’s been a long time since I’ve enjoyed a story as much as I’ve enjoyed this one.

It is simple with the right amount of tension going through it and every added detail regarding the mystery is in the right place.

There are a few minor errors, some punctuation, some repetitions, and some pure old grammar.

I’m posting the story again. You’ll find my remarks in the body of it, in a different font color.

Well done. Unicorns were always my favourites!

Hanna

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **




Borrowed Time


“It wasn’t my fault!” yelled Jim, in a sudden outburst. He stood up and paced around the fire like a crazy man. “God, if only I could’ve changed what happened!” He stared at us like a man who had just been sentenced to death. “Oh, I know what you guys think. You think I was the one who caused all this!” He ran up to me grabbing the open flaps of my jacket, pulling me up. “I killed you, man, I really killed you! You’re supposed to be dead! Why aren’t you dead?” He quickly released me looking embarrassed. He walked back to his camp-chair and sat back down shaking his head and rubbing his hands through his hair. “I’m sorry! So damn sorry.”

“Take it easy, Jim. No one’s blaming you.”

I looked across the smoking campfire at my three friends. Our annual bow-hunting trip had brought us all together again. Every year we came back to the same spot, Hunnington Lake, in the High Sierras. I guess we were hoping we could make sense of the whole thing; catch another glimpse of the magic we had all experienced.

It wasn’t something we talked about much; at least not until we got up here in the mountains. In my mind it felt like a dream you try to remember, but can’t seem to get the sequence of events in the right order. Of course I knew it was real, no matter what we said. Hell, I still had the mark that was left from the encounter, a forelock of brilliant white hair. But what had happened that day tied us all closer together; an unbreakable bond that brought us back here year after year. We kept our secret. Who would believe us anyway? We hardly believed it ourselves....

Doug was the youngest of the group, Doug Winston, a postal worker about thirty-three years old. He was the quiet one of the bunch.(repetition. Try:among us) We called him the Indian. He kept to himself mostly, a bachelor, very private about his life. Doug prided himself on his outdoors-menship (manship){//c}. He was the best hunter and tracker that I have ever seen; it was in his blood. It had been his idea for all of us to go bow-hunting. He felt that killing a deer with a gun was for hunters that didn’t know how to hunt. He painstakingly taught us all how to track and kill game the natural way, “the way God intended,” he had said. We all became excellent marksmen under his tutelage. We called ourselves the Merry Men.

Then there was Jim Johnson, my insurance salesman for the past twenty years. He was about forty, white-blond hair, and full of dirty jokes he couldn’t wait to share. He was a three-time divorcee that couldn’t seem to hang onto his money or his women. Jim was smart though; he could brilliantly manage anybody’s portfolio, except his own. He always appeared to be hyperactive, high-strung.

Finally, there was Big Bob McCallister, in his fifties, heavy-set, weighed over 300 hundred pounds and stood six-foot-four; he had a personality like a Kodiak Bear when he was drunk, but made up for it with a genuine heart of gold. He owned and operated a thriving auto-shop business in Madera. Bob and I grew up together and we looked after one another like brothers.

The whiskey bottle was passed around again and we talked of old times and earlier hunts. Every now and then I would catch one of them glancing at my tuft of white hair; it was the only evidence that remained.

“Man, I love it up here,” said Bob. “This is the life! Good friends, good whiskey, and plenty of good food.” He drank heavily and gave me the bottle.

“You’d like it anywhere as long as the food was good,” said Jim, still sulking.

“Well, if we run out, you’ll be the first to go, tow-head!” It wasn’t a good idea to make fun of Bob, especially about his size. He could be quite ornery when riled.

Doug smiled. “I brought plenty of steaks; more than even Bob can eat.”

There was a sound in the surrounding darkness and everyone stared in that direction.

“Probably just a raccoon,” I said, taking a big slug from the bottle and passing it to Doug.

It was close to midnight and ten yards out from the campfire you couldn’t see a thing; we sat huddled in the orange and yellow cocoon of warmth that came from the glow of the flames. Jim reached into his backpack, pulling out a flashlight. He turned it on and swept the perimeter with the beam of light; there was nothing there, just the outline of pine trees.

“Maybe it was a deer,” ventured Jim, “coming out to greet us; just so we don’t have to climb those steep mountains in the morning.”

“Well, that’d be awful darn considerate of him,” teased Bob. “What are you gonna shoot it with, Jim? You don’t even have your fancy, super-duper bow strung yet. You gonna throw an arrow at it?”

“Hell, I heard once that Indians used to throw rocks at the deer; if they’d hit them in the head, it’d drop the sucker dead right there on the spot. I bet I could do that.”

“Yeah, right! We all know what a great shot you are, Jim,” chuckled Bob.

Nobody laughed. Everyone knew it had been Jim’s poor aim that had set-off the sequence of events all those years ago. Actually, it had been more my fault for jumping into his line of fire. But I couldn’t let him kill the beast. If given the choice, I’d do exactly the same thing again.

“It wasn’t his fault!” I said, defending Jim. “If you remember, I walked into his line of fire.”

“Yeah, well any fool could’ve seen that it wasn’t a deer!” Bob said, accusingly. “Hell, the thing was white!”

“Oh, I get it,” Jim said, looking hurt. “After all this time, the truth finally comes out. You guys really do blame me for what happened!”

“I’ve never blamed you, Jim,” I said. “Never.”

“Well, well, the celebrity speaks,” said Bob, bitterly. “You know what, Bill? What happened to you wasn’t one of your fantasy stories you’ve made so much money on. It was the real deal! I’ve never been able to forget it, and if it had been one of us lying on the ground with an arrow in the head you’d feel the same way too.”

“Come on you guys!” Doug implored. “We’ve gone through all this before. We’re here to have a good time. Now, let’s just drop it. What’s done is done.”

I couldn’t let it go. I knew we needed to hash this out. I could feel the pent-up frustration in everybody.

“You upset over my success, Bob? It bothers you that people like to read my books?”

“You never wrote a story in your life, rich guy, until after what happened to you! When that creature touched you, it gave you something -- something special.”

“It gave me back my life, Bob. You know that. What the hell’s gotten into you, anyway? You jealous of me?”

Bob tipped the bottle again, drinking deeply, then spit a mouthful into the fire. The strong whiskey shot blue flames up into the sky.

“I ain’t jealous of nothing. I’m just saying that all our lives have changed since then. Hell, there’s not a day goes by that I don’t think about it. It’s like some damn dream I can’t wake up from or something; I keep reliving it over and over again (over and over is enough. Delete). Sometimes I wake up in the middle of the night in a cold sweat yelling your name, screaming, ‘Look out! Look out!’ But you don’t hear me and then your (you’re) struck by Jim’s arrow. You have this look on your face, a startled kind of look, blood’s( delete S) gushing out of your head and then you crumble to the ground.

“Then, where you stood in the dream, the creature now stands, staring right into me, straight through to my soul. Its eyes fix(ed - add) on me, growing larger and larger until they fill up my mind with its thoughts. Then it shows me things, evil, terrible things; I see all the faults and weaknesses of mankind.” Bob sighed heavily, then wiped his face with his shirt sleeve.

“This thing’s not over. I sense it wants something from us,” he said, suddenly calm. He stared into the fire. “Something we took from it and now the damn thing wants it back!”

“Jesus, Bob,” I said, softly, “I had no idea you were struggling so much with this.”

“You all right,(alright) big guy?” asked Doug, walking up to him and slapping him on the back.

“Yeah -- yeah, I’m fine. I just want an end to all this. No more dreams . . . no more damn dreams.”

“I remember seeing it run off and disappearing through the trees,” Doug said, remembering.( he says he remembers, then this is not needed) “It was so majestic and beautiful as it ran.”

“Then I heard Bob yelling for help, and I saw Bill lying on the ground, his head cradled in Bob’s lap. There was blood everywhere and Bob was applying pressure to the wound with his hunting cap. Jim was about twenty yards back, down on his knees, crying like a baby.”

Doug looked sadly at me. “We picked you up and carried you back to the campsite as best we could. But we were two miles into the wilderness, and by the time we reached camp there wasn’t anything that we could do for you. You had lost so much damn blood.” He grew quiet for a moment. “But I agree with Bob. The creature definitely wants something from us. I can feel it.”

“The creature!” yelled Jim jumping up. “You can’t even call it by its name! That bastard has cursed me!”

“Calm down, Jim,” I said.

“Oh, sure, I’m calm. You all wanna know why I can’t keep a wife?” he continued. “I’ll tell you why! It’s because ever since that day -- I can’t get it up to save my life -- or my marriage. I’m impotent! There! You happy! (question needs a question mark) Now I’ve said it!” Jim sat back down. There was a trail of spittle running down his chin. He tightly folded his arms and kicked at one of the stones surrounding the campfire. “It’s like I’ve been cursed, man! Cursed! Everything I do turns to crap.”

“Take it easy, Jim,” I said. “I don’t blame you. It was just one of those things.”

“Do you know how many times I’ve sat at home alone, (add comma) loading and unloading my gun?” Jim was raving and there was no stopping him. “But I don’t have the guts to do it! You wanna know something funny? The only time I feel like my old self is when I’m here with you guys. The rest of the time, my life just sucks. I’ve even been to see a damn psychologist(s), but their opinion is that I have had a trauma of some kind and I have to work it out. Hell, a trauma! If only I could tell them the truth; tell them what really happened! They’d throw me in the loony-bin for sure! Maybe if you had stayed dead it would’ve made it so much easier for me to take my own life. I wish I had never laid eyes on that four-legged monster. The son-of-a-bitch haunts me! He’s destroyed my life! Just like I tried to destroy his.”

“Why did you try to kill it, Jim?” I asked him, softly.

“I . . . I don’t know! I thought that if I could’ve killed it, we would’ve had the body for proof. Otherwise, who was gonna believed us? At the time, it was too fantastic for even me to believe. So I . . . I took the shot! And everything in my life changed. Nothing will be the same again!”

We sat there in stunned silence. The fire was burning down so I grabbed a couple of logs and chucked them in. The red hot embers shot into the sky, and for a moment, I could have sworn they formed an outline of the magical beast.

“I remember when I first saw it,” I said, dreamily, staring into the smoke and fire. “We had just crested a large hill and I saw movement in the dense undergrowth off to my left. I took the lead and circled my way around signaling to the three of you that something was up ahead. I quietly moved through the thicket, then I saw it, a beautiful white stallion. I thought that it might be a runaway or something, belonging to some rancher. God, it was magnificent! Pure white, with a mane so long it almost covered its entire neck. Its head was down, grazing upon some new grass. I wanted to capture it. If I could just get close enough, I could get my belt around its neck. Suddenly, it raised its beautiful head and looked directly at me, and that’s when I saw the horn.

"I couldn’t believe what I was looking at! I thought at first it was a fake. There are no such things as unicorns, except in fairy-tales. I remember thinking, the horn, it must be glued on; it’s gotta be somebody’s idea of a prank. I’d never seen a more magnificent animal in all my life. It stared at me, nostrils flaring, sniffing the air for danger. I dropped my bow and held my arms open to show I meant it no harm. Its eyes looked right through me. I don’t(know – missed the word. Add) why, but I got the feeling that it had been waiting there for me. I slowly fell to one knee before it, extending my hand so that it could smell me. It took a step forward, shaking its head up and down, snorting, as if it would rear-up at any moment. I didn’t move, just the offered hand I held out in front of me. Then it took another cautious step toward me and I could feel its hot breath on my hand, smelling me. He was now in the open and that’s when I heard Jim approaching from the right. The unicorn heard him too, and turned, ready to bolt. I saw Jim pull back on his bow about to shoot, and that’s when I jumped in front of his line of fire. I remember it felt like I got hit in the head with a hammer, and that’s all I remember.”

“It was nightfall when we finally got you back here,” Doug said. “Jim built a fire while Bob changed the bandage he had made from torn strips of your shirt. The arrow had only grazed you, but it was a hunting arrow, and the head was razor sharp. It hit you square in the forehead at your hairline, then bounced off to the side, slicing your head open like a melon. Like I said, there wasn’t much we could do. Bob wanted to load you up in the jeep and race a hundred miles down the mountain to the nearest doctor. I checked your pulse, but I couldn’t find one. You . . . you were dead.”

“But the unicorn!” I said. “What about the unicorn?”

“The damn thing followed us all the way back here,” explained Bob. “We heard it approaching. It walked right into camp, bold as you please.”

“It reared,” added Jim, “pawing its front legs at us until we backed away from your body.”

“Then it came right up to you,” Doug said, “put its head down and smelled your hair. It looked at us for a moment as if it was studying us, then touched you with its long horn -- right where the arrow had struck. At first nothing happened, then a bright light shot right out of its spike! It looked like blue lightening or something; it covered your entire body from head to toe. We couldn’t believe what we were seeing. It was magic.”

“We heard you moan and start to move,” finished Jim. “Damn -- if you weren’t alive!”

“The Unicorn backed away,” Bob said, “then turned and slowly walked back into the forest. It looked tired or drained somehow; its head was hanging low. I knelt down beside you and looked at the wound. It was completely healed. No scar or anything; just that white spot of hair where the horn touched you. It was damn amazing.”

“At the time,” said Doug, “we didn’t think too much about it. Hell, we were so excited that you were alive that’s about all we could think about. It was like you were given a second chance. It wasn’t ‘til later that my dreams made me remember what had really taken place, and by then it was just too unbelievable to even consider as being real. So I kept it pent-up inside. I think that we were all afraid that if we talked about it, (add comma) the magic would go away and you’d be dead again.”

“I remember waking up with you guys kneeling all around me,” I said, smiling. “I felt like Dorothy in the Wizard of Oz.” They laughed at my joke. “I swear, just before I woke up, I actually felt like Dorothy did when she opened that door and you know, everything turned to color. It was like my entire life had been in black and white up until then. From that moment on, I could sense the life in everything around me. I didn’t know how I got back to camp though or what had happened, but my hands and feet tingled like when you get shocked. I didn’t notice the white lock of hair until I got home the next day.”

We all felt better after we had talked it out. I suggested we turn in for the night. Everyone agreed and we climbed into the large tent I had brought with me. When we finally shut the propane lantern off we laid there in the dark completely quiet. Then somewhere in the night, off in the distance, we heard a horse whinny.

The next day we broke camp and prepared to go hunting. All the good cheer we had felt the day before seemed to have left us. Everyone was somber as they got their gear ready. I felt as if we were soldiers preparing to go into the final battle, each knowing that some of us would never return.

“Everybody set?” I asked, my voice sounding flat and far away.

“You know he’s out there waiting, don’t you?” Bob asked me.

“Yeah, I know. I feel him too.”

We hit the trail and climbed our first mountain. I led the way; knowing before I ever left camp where I was going. I think we all did. It took us half a day to get there; right back where the whole thing started. The four of us stood on the hilltop, resting and waiting.

“Do you think he’ll come?” asked Doug, quietly.

“This is crazy! Crazy, I tell you,” whined Jim. “What are we doing here?”

“Just keep quiet, Jim,” said Big Bob. “He’ll never come if you keep blabbering.”

“I think he’s already here,” I said. “There!” I pointed to a little meadow about a hundred yards below us. The unicorn whinnied and reared-up upon its hind legs.

“He’s calling us,” I said.

As we entered the meadow, the Unicorn was prancing in small circles, flipping its head up and down, stopping only to rear and snort loudly at us.

“Drop your weapons,” I said. “He’s frightened.”

We dropped our gear upon the edge of the meadow, then walked forward into the middle of the clearing.

“My, God, look at him! He’s incredible!” Doug said.

“Yeah, but what the hell does he want?” asked Bob, cocking his eyebrow.

“I think I know,” I said. “Stay here.”

As I approached, the unicorn turned and flung its head toward the forest. He wanted me.

“I have to go,” I yelled back at my friends. “He wants me to go with him. To his world!”

“No way!” shouted Bob. “You ain’t going nowhere!” He ran toward me, and the others followed. The unicorn bolted away, then stopped at the edge of the forest.

“It’s the only way to end this thing,” I said. “Like this unicorn, I don’t belong here anymore. I’ve been living on borrowed time. I was supposed to die that day. He’s come to take me home.”

“Ah, jeez, Bill,” said Jim. “I don’t think I can stand to lose you again. You’re talking crazy. This whole thing is crazy!”

“I’m sure it’ll be all right, Jim,(add comma)” I said, calmly. “I belong there now. All the stories I’ve written have been about his world. It’s real, all of it! He can’t leave until I go with him. This is the way to end it. Can’t you feel that?”

“Yes, but I don’t want to lose you,” he said, sadly. “Not again, not ever.” Jim hung his head down, then quickly reached out and grabbed me in a tight squeeze. “Friends forever, huh Bill, you and me?”

“That’s right, Jim. Nothing can ever change that.”

“I understand what you’re doing,” said Doug. “It all makes sense somehow.” Then he gave me a big hug and slapped me on the back. “It’s been good to know you, my friend. Thank him for me. He gave us a few extra years of your friendship -- and for that, I am truly grateful. I’ll miss you, bud.”

“You’re the reason this all started, Doug. If you hadn’t gotten us interested in hunting in the first place, we would’ve never come up here. Everything’s for a reason. How ‘bout you, Bob? You got a hug for an old friend?”

“I don’t have to go along with this insanity,” Bob said, stubbornly. “ I can stop you. I can knock you out and carry your ass right back down that hill.”

“Is that what you really want to do, Bob?” I asked him.

“I’ve done it before! I can do it again!” He broke down; tears running down his face. “I will never understand you. I’ve read all your books by the way, every last one of them. The fantasy place you describe, what’s it called -- Terracon? Do you think that’s where your(you’re) going?”

“I know it is, Bob. Don’t ask me how, but I know that’s where I’m going. You talked about your dreams last night. Well, I didn’t tell you about (my dreams)(change to MINE). After the accident they became so real and vivid. It was as if I was living in both worlds simultaneously. Perhaps, my friend, when I sleep in Terracon, I will dream of this world. Maybe, I will dream of you.”

He picked me up in a bear hug so powerful that I couldn’t breathe. Then he released me and cradled my face in his big hands.

“I just want to remember your face,” he said, staring at me. “No matter what happens, I never want to forget your face or that white lock of hair.”

“I know I’ll never forget you, big guy.”

We said our good-byes then, and I turned and walked toward the waiting unicorn. I sensed an urgency in his movements. His eyes were telling me to hurry and mount him.

“I’ll be coming back!” I yelled. “Look for me! I’ll be coming back!” Grabbing a handful of long mane, I swung my leg up and over. I turned and looked back one last time, waved to my friends, then we bolted forward, disappearing into the low hanging mist beneath the forest branches.



90
90
Review of Who Am I?  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello October,

Wonderful poem! I liked it a lot.

I was wondering for which age group it is meant, for I found some words which would be difficult for the very young ones like BRAY (I had to look up this one myself) and FLOCK which they learn usually at grade 3.

Going to read some more of your work.

It's always good to read nice children's stuff.

Hanna

91
91
Review of Inherited Medals  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
Sunflower,

This is a great poem. It talks about the simple man who became a worrior and all he wants is to go home and live in peace... and I know the feeling because I've been in the army for 6 years and saw enogh wars to last me a life time.

There was one sentence I didn't quite make out:
"In the end the medals and commendations
Don't matter
As iconoclasts."

First of all, it is a sentence, like you would write in prose. The icons don't matter as iconoclasts? or they just do not matter on their own? Iconoclast, as far as I know is a person who destroys religious images and beliefs. So what did you mean here?

Other than this, I really enjoyed the poem.

Hanna


92
92
Review of Peacenik Prose  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hello Sunflower,

Your war folder was the first I opened. I'm totally commited to anti-war issues.

I love the ideas you portray, but I can't say I like the way you constructed the poem.

The first stanza has 5 lines which are written like a limerick with the same rules of rhyming, not so much in the meter though.

Then the rest of the stanzas vary in size and rhyme occasionally.

It is hard to read the poem fluently because it has no rhythm. Even a free style poem needs to have some inner tempo which I couldn't find here.

I'm sorry, because I really like the subject and what you had to say is important. I am usually honest with my reviews, but that is only my personal opinion, and you don't have to agree with me.

Going to read some more of your work. If you do think this poem could use a bit of "face lift", I'd be more than happy to help you.

I was wondering where you heard the word "peacenik"? This is something Israelis would use... and I am Israeli.

Hanna

PS

If you care to visit my anti-war folder, here is the link:
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#748771 by Not Available.



93
93
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

I would like to make a comment to the "How to Deal With An Unconstructive And Negative Comment"

Being a manager of a writers group with MSN, I often meet young beginning writers. They all jpin in order to improve their work, but some of them can not take criticism of any kind.

I'm looking for articles I could post in the group which would explain how to deal with comments that are constructive, but not favorable. Some works do need a lot of work and they are not "bad" but do point out mistakes. How must a writer deal with it?

What you wrote here deals with reviews from none-members. Could you find for me something I could use?

Thank.

Hanna

94
94
Review of Final Journey  
Review by Hanna
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hello Jale,

This is a very emotional poem, and I read it like a story. Very powerful and real.

There are few things I would like to say about the structure. The rhythm is not kept throughout the poem. Some lines are too long to enable a smooth reading. Lack of punctuation is noticable since the poem is quite long.

Here are some comments:

The line - ":A baby born to unwed child" - I presume you meant an unwed young girl or young mother, but the word "child" makes no sense in this line.


The lines: "With a lump in my throat and tear in my eye
It's time to buy the farm"

I would suggest shortening the long line to something like:
"Lump in throat and tearful eyes"

And I have no idea what you meant by: "Its time to buy the farm". Is it an American expression for the time to leave this world?

In the last stanza - the line: "And life once know and treasured" - I think you meant - "And life once KNOWN" and not KNOW.


With a bit of work this could be a great poem. These are only my observations of course.

Hanna
95
95
Review by Hanna
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)

Hello jale,

This is a very good Anti-War poem. It is one of my favorite subjects.

I would like to give you my honest impressions of it, and please don't think me rude for trying to critique, because although my English is not so good, I have a very strong sense of rhythm (not alway applied to my own poems for lake of words limits my writing... ).

The poem is not written in the free form - it is rhymed - second and fourth lines in each stanza. The one but last stanza rhymes both A/C and B/D. It stands out.

When reading the poem aloud, which I always do, the rhythm is often broken by either too long lines or too short. Perhaps most people don't mind it, including you, but I thought I'd mention it. for example:

The landscape all shrouded
by dense smoke mixed with mist
One warrior glares skyward
shaking his filthy, clenched fist

Second line: The word DENSE can be deleted to balance the line.


Crackling piles of dry brittle bones
Snap beneath worn ragged boots

Dry and Brittle - basically mean the same. One of them can be deleted.

Worn and Ragged - also mean the same, one can be deleted, so the stanza would read better with one word added to the first line and another to the second, like this:


The sound of their march,
A sickening loud crunch.
Crackling piles of dry bones
Snap beneath their ragged boots,
Accented sporadic by distant groans.

In the stanza before last, you have used the word AND twice in the beginning of the line.

To my mind, it adds nothing to the poem, thus can be omitted. One line was too short and I've added the word BABY to even it, and the last line was also short and I've added the word FINALLY. Here is my suggestion:

Somewhere across the land
A mutant newborn baby cries
by his anguished mother's hand
The wretched infant finally dies

I hope I'm not too presumptuous... Only suggestions.

If you like war stuff visit my Anti-War folder -
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#748771 by Not Available.



Going to read some more of your work. I want to see what it is you refer to as DARK...

Hanna
96
96
Review of Caleb  
Review by Hanna
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello Texasranger,

A very original poem. Normaly one would write about his loss in the first person, but you chose to write it as coming from the other realm, and I liked it a lot.

The poem is very well written, flows easily and makes an excellent read.

I have "stumbled only once on a v ery long line, but that was ok with me, although O normaly liky symmetry...

Thanks for sharing your feelings with us.

Hanna



I wonder what you would think of my poem "feeling Guilty" which I wrote about my late parents. It is highly emotional and I never had a chance to edit it.

 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#750039 by Not Available.
96 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 4 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/hanna/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/4