*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/johnashen/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
226 Public Reviews Given
1,311 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 ... Next
51
51
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
First a few technical nitpicks :

1st *Paragraph*
*Bullet* prayed for one thing. That thing: that the child (The 2nd part is not a complete sentence, but a clause dependent on the 1st sentence. The "one thing" equals the entire second part, so use a colon here.)
*Bullet* how this night mare nightmare began ("night mare" would be a female horse in the dark *Wink*)

*Idea* You should put a blank line between each paragraph. This will not only give the reader's eyes a break, but also the whole piece will look more inviting at first glance.

2nd *Paragraph*
*Bullet* quite sometime some time now ("sometime" is an adjective meaning "occasional" -- you mean "some time" which is an amount of time in noun form)
*Bullet* father had come running in, in; he was overjoyed (Both sides here are complete sentences, so use a semi-colon. Combining two sentences with a comma is called a "comma splice" *surprise*)

3rd *Paragraph*
*Bullet* The only thing Zemirah felt was, confused was confusion.


The names are solid, evoking images of Arabian characters. I especially remember "Mujahideen" from the Dune series of books. You have a promising prologue here. Keep going! and when you have chapter 1 ready, put a link to it at the end of this piece. *Smile*


My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
52
52
Review of Hey Jealousy  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
I hoped you would put a name to Lane's ex-girlfriend. All we get is she, she, her, she. *Frown*

*Bullet* he became angrier and angrier more and more angry

*Bullet* ambulance got there , there was nothing (comma = natural pause to split up these confusing "there" twins)

*Bullet* last thought was not how much he hated (The rest of the sentence leads me to believe you forgot this "not"! hehe, a forget-me-Not)

*Bullet* don’t expect to too much from me

*Bullet* you might not be let down (missing song lyric)
53
53
Review of Stay With You  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
*Bullet* was a bit flirtier than (Usually the comparative form of a 2-syllable word uses "more")
         was a bit more flirty than

Other than that, only 2 simple suggestions:
1. put a blank line between each paragraph. this makes it easy on the reader's eyes
2. maybe put an indent at the start of each paragraph. this is less important but also helps readability
54
54
Review of Scripted  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hrm, the punctuation all over the first stanza confuses me, as you're not using complete sentences to relay thoughts. I see verbs without subjects and objects without actors...

loose our soldiers (Do you mean "loose" - the opposite of "tight" - or do you mean "lose"?)

Sinful drives / the knife within. (Sinful what drives the knife? Or what sinfully drives the knife? By itself, "sinful" is an adjective modifying nothing apparent...)

55
55
Review of One Journey's End  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.0)
Pretty good write-up. No obvious typos (spell-checker, anyway!).

I can think of 2 suggestions for instant (though minor) improvement.

1. Put blank lines between each paragraph (and maybe indent at beginning of each). This makes it look good on a reader's poor eyes.

2. Turn up the heat on the first sentence. Putting a clause into the first sentence slows it down. Take it out! "Sevas's heart was restless" has much more punch. That grabs the reader right away. You can explain why in the 2nd sentence, after they're hooked. *Smile* (btw, "Sevas' heart" is also correct.)
56
56
Review of Eclipse  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.5)
I realize a typo and a piece of punctuation aren't much in the big picture, but let's iron out the last 2 wrinkles in this otherwise perfect piece :

*Bullet* for on him rest rests the day

*Bullet* too weighty , ; they starve

At first I didn't like the repetition, but at least you stuck to a pattern. Add in the pleasant (and, as you say, "folksy") tale, and suddenly the piece grew on me. I'll raise to 5.0 once corrected!
57
57
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.5)
I love the topic (as told in the item description), and the execution is pretty good. My main suggestion is to add line breaks so that this long thing is comprised of shorter stanzas.

See how it would look (with 2 corrections) :

To lay lie alone at night
Wishing you were beside me
That I could hold you close
And feel your warmth inside me

But reality has a tendency
Of contradicting dreams
The truth plagues me
Infecting romantic themes

I try to convince myself
That I am in your heart
But then painful logic
Sends me back to the start

Go directly to jail
You’ll never be kissed
Do not pass GO
You don’t even exist

But that frigid honesty
I cannot help but admire
Addicted, I inject it into my veins
And set my heart on fire

Yet I still imagine you in my arms
Letting me look into your eyes
Memorizing your smile
I indulge in my lies

I beg you to speak
And savour every word
So come and watch me swallow
This double
-bladed sword (hyphenated)
58
58
Review of Birthday Party  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.5)

*Bullet* Little known fact . : Birthdays are only

*Bullet* first was Pharoah's Pharaoh's birthday

*Bullet* chicken wings isn't going out of Babalon Babylon

*Bullet* it never would have occured occurred to me

Strong ending line ('silent = disagree without standing out')
59
59
Review of Bishojo  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Bullet*autumn ; , the time

*Bullet*forest at dusk , ; I was taken

*Bullet*everything you’ve know known

"all too pleasing so I lost myself in the scenery" - (This is an excellent transition from narration to description!)

*Bullet*The silence sharply broken by thunder thunder sharply broke the silence, and birds fled.

*Bullet*in the water ; , though

*Bullet*Who was I at that pointing point in time?

*Bullet*plagued me ; , many options

*Bullet*bragging and teasing , for they were

*Bullet*continueing tommarrow continuing tomorrow

----------------

Promising start... keep going!
60
60
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
First things first - let's get rid of the typos (surprisingly few for a piece this huge!)

*Bullet*reminiscent of the Brittish British Sentrymen

*Bullet*stray commentary on your mammeries mammaries

*Bullet*by some vague extention extension NIMH

*Bullet*leak, probably within your facilites facilities

*Bullet*A uncomfortablly An uncomfortably warm, moist

*Bullet*scuba dive in the Mediterranian Mediterranean

*Bullet*assignment as one that was asnecessary as necessary

*Bullet*girls were alive and pertrified petrified

*Bullet*knealt knelt and kissed the backside

61
61
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Bullet* man feels self-sufficient (need hyphen)

*Bullet* He only wants to help offer you (by replacing "help" with "offer" you can remove the awkwardness of the next line which features contorted grammar for the sake of rhyme... read it now with "offer"*Smile*)

62
62
Review of Weight  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (3.0)
*Bullet* unheathy unhealthy state of being

Hrm, I suppose I didn't enjoy this much because you basically asked a question with the 2nd stanza without proposing an answer. That leaves me wondering: what's the point? We all know there's an obsession over weight, but you fail to cast new light on the subject or drag us into emotional sympathy...
63
63
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
*Bullet*As if my touseled tousled hair

*Bullet*I bit back a smart-assed comment (Need a hyphen in there)

*Bullet*he was, a friggin’ genuis genius

-------

As for a title, how about "One Less Genius" ?
("the double-butcher-knife mystery" seemed a bit harsh)
64
64
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
*Bullet* Devils Devil's threshold

*Bullet* his bloody interstice pores
("interstice" is a gap between nearby objects, not a hole in a body)

*Bullet* last breathe breath

65
65
Review of A Summer Storm  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (3.5)
I found it strange that you alternate between ABAC and ABCB rhyme every stanza, then have no lines rhyming in the final stanza.

storm rages, ;
(Use a semi-colon or period here; otherwise you're splicing 2 sentences together with a comma.)

of thunder,
(Don't need a comma here, since your sentence continues without pause in the next line.)

clouds asunder, ;

rains collect,
(Don't need a comma here, since your sentence continues without pause in the next line.)

66
66
Review of Poetry Forms  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Money in the bank $$$$ *Smile*
Nice quiz. I might do one in the style of "recognize this format" instead of defining it so they can look it up ...

I noticed in the Carmen question, one answer could be cleaned up and shortened: "each line in a different color" (omit "printed" and insert a space into "ina" -- this will make the answer fit on 1 line)
67
67
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
top that only coverd her

pink mached matched her tub tube top

Tonight were we're all going to the movies ;

in front of the beutifel beautiful girls

scince since I was young Reankea had alwase always said

he dropped his books ; I nelt knelt down

I eventuly eventually withdrew my hand

-----------

You have many typos that the spell-checker would catch. You also have a serious problem with run-on sentences, so I assume you're a young writer.
If you'd like, I can rewrite this piece using your words, to show you what it looks like all cleaned up. Let me know and this service is free to you *Smile*
68
68
Review of Inside this House  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (3.0)
This piece is labeled "poetry" but it reads as a piece of Prose. If you want help making a poem out of this, let me know *Smile*
For now, let's get rid of the typos so everyone can get straight to your message without distraction. Isn't it weird how everything is in the eyes, if you look deep enough?


I know people alot a lot more then than they think, ; I hear the things they say.

where I am , so judgemental judgmental they do befor before they think

smart but the they don't use their bains brains

for people to know I know though ; this is cause I watch

see then What what I realy really am
69
69
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.0)
Ha, quite a tongue-twisting tale-wagger you've got here. I was impressed with the variety of p-words used. It's like you crossed off words from a dictionary list once used *Wink*

One recommendation: put both the preamble (copyright, other books in the series) and the postscript (series info) in italics to separate it visually from the main body of text. That way people can skip straight to the text if preferred.
70
70
Review of Divorced  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
"feeling sapling new" is awkward in the first stanza. It does introduce the imagery you'll be using, but it sounds grammatically disjointed from the other lines.

Overall I can easily see how this parallels divorce. I just think your lines are, for lack of a better word, stunted in their growth.
71
71
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (3.5)
You have this listed as an item of type "essay" when it should be of type "poem" *Confused*

Better with out you

The "make a world glow" refrain is interesting, but there is a problem throughout the poem: your phrases are too short. You often leave out subjects, so we have no idea of who is acting or what is going on, other than some vague puzzle pieces of description.
72
72
Review of The Traveling Man  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hiya, thought I'd give this a quick look:

*Bullet* You might want to put a space between each paragraph, and/or indent the beginning of each with an { indent } (no spaces)

*Bullet* Strange thing was that it was only the locals that was were affected.

*Bullet* the supplies they had brung brought

On the other hand, this whole tale was told in a colloquial way, so maybe the narrator naturally has these grammatical inconsistencies?
73
73
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
The double-spacing makes this seem like it is written for a class...

----------------

Title: My Mothers Mother's an Alien

arrived at my Mums Mum's

the latest anti ageing aging treatment

I leant leaned forward and grabbed

----------------

No other misspellings. The spell checker coughed about many words, but alas it has never been to the U.K. or Australia *Wink*

74
74
Review of Love Letter  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Bullet* neither one of us afraid to show ignorance
(How about "admit" ignorance since showing it is not really a positive thing?)

*Bullet* I dont don't know where we will end up

*Bullet* I let myself love you knowing it wasnt wasn't right

-------------

This is indeed a very romantic and praising love letter. I was expecting a "Dear" at the start, but oh well *Smile*
75
75
Review of Blood of Brothers  
Review by John~Ashen
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Bullet* in the description: We die to keep are our friends alive

*Bullet* “Old Glory’ - you have a double-quote and single quote here. Best to pick one and be consistent with it

*Bullet* “For our country 'tis of thee,”
I think you mean For "Our country 'tis of thee,"

80 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 4 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/johnashen/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3