*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/liseli/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/6
Review Requests: OFF
952 Public Reviews Given
1,570 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 2 3 4 5 -6- 7 8 9 10 11 ... Next
126
126
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi!

Congratulations on being a nominee from "The Kindness Tree. *Smile*

What I Liked:

Lovely poem. I liked the use of repetition and I think that you made a nice ghazal, especially for your first attempt.

Suggestions for Improvement:

I felt that a little punctuation would be nice to lighten this up a bit. A few commas at the end of the first line might make this easier to read.

Final Notes:

Nice start with this! I hope that you can write more ghazals in the future!




I hope you have a wonderful Holiday season! Write on!

Hugs,

Emerin

Kindness Tree Image.
127
127
Review of Leila's Story  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi!

Congratulations on being a nominee from "The Kindness Tree. *Smile*

What I Liked:

Great story and great job inducing sympathy for Leila. I am intrigued and want to know what happens next.

Suggestions for Improvement:

Consider a better title for the story. I know it isn't finished yet, but I think you could perhaps brainstorm something a bit more attention grabbing.

Final Notes:

Great start here. I can't wait until you finish! *Laugh*




I hope you have a wonderful Holiday season! Write on!

Hugs,

Emerin

Kindness Tree Image.
128
128
Review of Lies  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi!

Congratulations on being a nominee from "The Kindness Tree. *Smile*

What I Liked:

Nice sense of rhythm and flow even without a traditional style. Nice touch!

Suggestions for Improvement:

I felt that this ended a bit abruptly. Perhaps there is a way to make it end smoother?

Final Notes:

Nice start here! With a little work, it should be even better!




I hope you have a wonderful Holiday season! Write on!

Hugs,

Emerin

Kindness Tree Image.
129
129
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hey there!

Thank you for requesting a review from
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1307093 by Not Available.
.



First off, I just want to let you know that there's a grammatical mistake in your item description. It should say 'its' fate (without the apostrophe) not it's fate. *Smile* Bad grammar in the description might deter others from reading.

An interesting but sad poem. I like the way repetition is used and how the poem turns out in the end, even though it is a bit sad. *Cry*

A couple pointers:

It Danced!

I was wondering why the 'd' is capitalized in Dance. *Smile*

The shows they'd partake

I believe that there should be an 'in' right after 'partake'. *Smile*

Hope this helps!



Thank you for your consideration, and please stop by our forum again!


--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
130
130
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hey there!

Thank you for requesting a review from
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1307093 by Not Available.
.



An interesting story you've got here! I enjoyed reading your piece. *Smile*

I like the way it opened with immediate action - what a nice way to pull the reader into the story!

I did, however, have a few suggestions for improvement.

Firstly, please space between your paragraphs! It is very difficult to read a very long block of text; breaking it up will greatly facilitate any future readers.

His golden lochs

I believe "lochs" should be "locks".

I found your similes to be interesting and creative; however, I wasn't sure if they really worked in the context. "More wretched than a red sox homerun" might be humorous in a tale about two New Yorkers, but in your fantasy story it seems a bit out of place.

The word 'laugh' and its forms was used WAY too many times. I would go back and take some of the 'laugh's out so it isn't so repetitive.

Hope this helps!


Thank you for your consideration, and please stop by our forum again!


--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
131
131
Review of A Thousand Words  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hey there!

Thank you for requesting a review from
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1307093 by Not Available.
.



What a lovely, lovely piece! I really enjoyed reading this one. You have some beautiful descriptions.

The only suggestion I have for you is to consider not using so many dashes. I felt that many of them were unnecessary and actually stopped the flow in prose. You had around ten of those dashes, and I think you've used about five or six too many. Consider going back and taking out the unnecessary ones and putting in commas. *Smile*

Keep up the great work!


Thank you for your consideration, and please stop by our forum again!


--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
132
132
Review of To My Mother  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello!

Lovely piece, and nicely done. *Smile*

I enjoyed reading this.

However, I have a few suggestions for improvement.

Try to stay away from passive verbs. You can make your piece so much stronger by eliminating wordiness from this piece. For instance:

Not that I was adopted, that I have always knew known.

The same meaning is preserved without the wordy 'have'.

Try to stay away from forms of 'be' and 'have'. They generally just clog up your writing.

Example:

I have grown grew up knowing that I was the someone else's child of someone else, that you had given gave me away at birth.

Do you see how many unnecessary words are in this sentence? Making your prose tighter and more concise will afford you a greater sense of flow in your writing. *Smile*

Just remember that these are just suggestions. None of your sentences are grammatically INCORRECT, they're just dense and wordy. I'm sort of picking on you because you have some great stuff here that can really shine with a little bit of work.

Hope this helps!



Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
133
133
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello!

A thought-provoking essay that I enjoyed reading. *Smile*

I love the subtle humor you employ in getting your point across. You've done a nice job with this piece!

Keep up the great work!




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
134
134
Review of NOTHING TO FEAR  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello!

A wonderful poem with a great message that you tell through your words. *Smile*

I love the flow in this piece and the way it reads so nicely. Great use of repetition of the last lines of the stanza, too!

My only suggestion would be to capitalize the H in 'his' and 'him'. I think it would be fitting since you capitalize 'Maker'. *Smile*

Hope this helps!




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
135
135
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello!


A really lovely bunch of poems that I had so much fun sifting through. You have some wonderful writing here, and I look forward to seeing this collection of inspiring poetry grow! *Smile*

Never stop writing!



Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
136
136
Review of A DREAM DENIED  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello!

Another great poem with an inspiring message! *Smile*

I like the way that you brought the poem to a hopeful message even though you started out with some pretty despairing words. Nicely done!

A few suggestions for improvement:

Consider stanzas! I think they might complement this poem nicely.

I felt that the poem left off a bit abruptly. Perhaps a period at the end of the last line would help...

All the rhyme (even the approximate ones) worked for me - except for love//distrust. Consider this change:

All I’ve ever longed for was [honesty and real love] real love and what was just

This way, the rhyme scheme would work out better! *Smile* I think there's probably a better way to incorporate a perfect rhyme word in; mine was just an example.

Finally, a really little suggestion - consider centering this poem. I think it might look nice that way! *Laugh* *Blush*

I hope this helps!





Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
137
137
Review of BEAUTY  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Another poem employing the use of repetition to get the message across - well done! *Smile* I love the images you've selected to convey your own personal sense of beauty and you pulled off the meaning without becoming too sappy.

I've only got one really nitpicky suggestion for you.

Consider playing with capitalization and italics in this poem. I think if the repeating refrain of 'that's beauty' was set apart in some way through color or italics, the effect would be really cool!

Hope this helps!




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
138
138
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Another lovely poem! I liked the use of repetition of the first line at the end of the the poem - it lent the piece a nice feel of a full circle. *Smile*

I noticed you used a lot of approximate, not exact, rhyme in this poem. I felt that it worked in the most part; however, the very first rhyme, wind//end, didn't really work for me. Instead of:

Born to find freedom, and for the pain to end.

Consider:

Born to find freedom, and to leave the pain behind

which conserves the rhyme. *Smile*

Hope this helps!




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
139
139
Review of IT LURKS  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

A short poem with powerful images that make a big impact! *Smile* I enjoyed reading this poem of yours.


My only suggestion for improvement concerns the second-to-last line, which to me felt a little bit long compared to the other lines in the poem. Could it be shortened some how?

Keep up the great work!



Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
140
140
Review of BLEEDING HEART  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!


This poem is a bit darker than the other two I've read so far, but you managed to pull off despair with aplomb. *Smile* Great use of rhyme scheme and strong words to create an impact in such a short poem.

A few suggestions for you:

First stanza, second line - this concerns those pesky syllable counts again! *Laugh* To make this line match all the others, I would take out the word
'with' because it is unnecessary and the same meaning can be conveyed without it.

“Please help me before I fall apart,”[,]

I believe the comma should go inside the quotation marks!

Hope this helps!



Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
141
141
Review of QUESTIONS  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Another lovely poem! The first two stanzas are especially strong, and I was captivated by the flawless rhythm and flow. I enjoyed the way you built your piece through the use of rhetorical questions that are answered in a unique way! Keep up the great work. *Smile*

Of course, I found a few things to nitpick at for you. *Laugh*

In the first stanza, third line, I felt the comma after 'transcended' was unnecessary because you don't use a comma after any of the other lines preceding the question.

Likewise, in the third stanza, third line, that period felt a bit jarring for me after the stanzas of such nice flow and balance. I think a dash or a comma might be more appropriate.

I hope this helps!



Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
142
142
Review of I DON'T KNOW  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

I'm starting on your reviews. *Smile*

What a wonderful poem! I love the images and use of writing mL. It really complements the words.

I didn't see any problems with rhyme or rhythm, and your intent and meaning is easy to understand.

The only nitpicking I have for you are regarding the number of syllables per line. If you take, for example, the first stanza, all the lines are of comparable syllable count except for the last one, which has twelve syllables. You can make that line fourteen like all the others and preserve the rhythm by adding an adjective before 'eyes' like 'fearful' or some better word you could probably come up with! *Laugh*

This poem is already very good! A little tweaking will make it even better.




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
143
143
Review of First Date?  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello, Maria!

I thought I might just stop by and drop you a review...*Smile*

Cute poem! I can definitely get the feel of the dance jitters, especially as one without a date. *Laugh* I'm not sure that's what you intended, but there's a nice feel of that uncertainty involved.

I've only got one suggestion for you. Consider italicizing the question 'yes or no'. I think that might make a nice contrast. *Smile*

Hope this helps!




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
144
144
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello!

Thank you for requesting a review from: "Invalid Item.

Oh, what a sad, sad piece! *Cry*

You tell it well. I didn't even realize that this was supposed to be a dream until the very end of the story.

I didn't have any problems understanding what was going on. My main nitpickings will be concerning grammar.

It was just like[,] the good old days.

No comma necessary here.

I said[,] to my sister.

Again, unnecessary comma.

We laughed so hard[,] - I had knots in my stomach, cramps in my cheeks and[,] tears streaming down my face[;] while she grabbed her mid-drift midriff with one hand, arched her back, and held a lock of sandy blonde hair[,] straight up in the air[,] in her other hand.

Mostly punctuation issues. Just be careful - you're mostly overusing the comma. Mid-drift is in the middle of a tide. *Smile* I think you want midriff.

I said.[,] I got up, grabbed the hand mirror and stuck it in front of her face.

You'll want to break up those sentences.


I wondered the same thing. "Don’t worry.[;] I’ll help you. ...

Missing a quotation mark. Okay, I took out that semicolon because you used them WAY too much in this piece. Fourteen times within a piece less than 10K long is about ten times too many. I would literally go back and take ten semicolons out. Focus on the unnecessary ones like the one I took out here and the ones you used incorrectly like the one I took out in the example above. The reason I think semicolons bog down your story is because you shouldn't just use them arbitrarily to replace periods. That's not their purpose. The more you overuse a 'special' punctuation mark, the cheaper it seems.

With a little more proofreading, this piece can really shine. I hope my review helps!


Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
145
145
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello!

Here's another lovely poem, Davina. We don't have the problem of this poem being too prose-like. You have a nice sense of flow in the free-verse and I absolutely love your word choice in this piece. *Smile*

I only have a few suggestions for improvement.

First stanza, second line - I don't know if that period is appropriate. I might just take out the period all together or put in a dash. The same goes for the third stanza, third line.

Conversely, in the first stanza, first line, I might use a period instead of a comma. *Smile*

I think you could strengthen a few of your statements in this poem. For example, second stanza, first line, perhaps you could describe HOW you enjoyed those last moments. Did you feel the sun's heat on your closed eyelids? Did you allow the light to tickle your skin? etc.

Hope this helps!




Hugs,

Emerin

** Image ID #1347931 Unavailable **
146
146
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hey there!

Thank you for requesting a review from
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1307093 by Not Available.
.



Mike, you still have a pretty good piece here! I find that your prose is clear and easy to understand. *Smile* I love the way you can pour out your emotions in a touching way without turning sappy. I enjoyed reading your piece.

Of course, I have a few suggestions for improvement. Today's nitpicking is too many commas.

The sound of people laughing as a result of my natural gift[,] is a temporary desensitization of the pain[,] and emptiness I feel inside.

Two unnecessary commas here.


Love is so hard for me to deal with[,] outside of my family circle.

Another unnecessary comma.

It is sad that being alone has become comfortable[,] and acceptable.

If you've just got two words connected by 'and', you don't need that comma.

Hope this helps!



Thank you for your consideration, and please stop by our forum again!


--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
147
147
Review of Brave New World  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hey there!

Another interesting poem.

I love the use of shorter phrases and line breaks to convey your message. I didn't see any problems with grammar. *Smile* That's always a good thing.

Of course, I have a few suggestions for improvement.

I like the fact that the first letter of each line isn't just capitalized for the heck of it, but I don't understand why you do something like 'CiViLiAn' because in my opinion it looks a bit childish and silly. You capitalize a lot of words in this poem. Just keep in mind the more times you put a word into caps, the less meaning it has. Frequency means less significance.

Now rally to this;
my noble cause?

Not sure why there's a question mark or a semicolon. I think a dash - is more appropriate for the semicolon. The question mark might be appropriate but I don't understand the context.

The three exclamation marks at the very end of the piece gives it a childish feel, which is a shame because it's such a mature piece otherwise. Just remember, if you can't express your additional exclamatory emotion in words, don't try to make up for it in punctuation. It looks silly.

Hope this helps.


--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
148
148
Review of The Looking Glass  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hey there!

This is my first review for you as part of Eagle~The Cowboy's Wife 's auction.*Smile*

A sad poem with a lot of emotion packed into it. I like the repetition in the syntactical form. *Smile*

A few suggestions for improvement:

I encourage to play with punctuation. Consider not capitalizing the first letter of each line arbitrarily and instead not capitalizing some lines - it'll lead to some more interesting dynamic within this piece.

Also, I don't think the comma after the single word at the beginning of each stanza is necessary. There isn't any need for it and in my humble opinion it looks a bit awkward. I think it might look interesting if that word was italicized instead.

'Rebegin' isn't a word, and in this context I don't think making up your own word carries much weight because you haven't used a variety of word types within this piece. 'Begin again' or 'are reborn' in my opinion is a better way to end this instead of leaving the reader wondering if you just don't know the English language. *Smile*

Hope this helps!

--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
149
149
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello!


Definitely a helpful resource! *Smile* I like the fact that you included other links to helpful pages. I'm sure this will be a fantastic resource for other aspiring poetry writers.

I picked up on a couple typos here and there that might lower the credibility of your piece, though:

Nothing probably repulses a reader more than ba bad spelling.

This'll be a little ironic. *Laugh*

The importance of pronunciation lies in the fact that, as per my belief, poetry is basically meant to be read allowed out loud or aloud, often as a lyric or song, and that proper vocal rendering of poetry, with flow, necessitates proper pronunciation.

Another little typo.

I believe that the essence of potry poetry is rhythm, which is possibly synonymous with flow.

Again, careful!


The following recommendations are just SUGGESTIONS. This means you don't have to make the changes, unlike the typos listed above. Most of my suggestions come from William Strunk, Jr.'s The Elements of Style, which I believe is a must-read for any serious writer of prose.

Brackets are great, but within prose parentheses ( ) are more appropriate. Actually, I generally advise writers to not use brackets or parentheses at all, as it disturbs flow within prose.

I felt the slash - "/" was used too often in this piece to the point where it felt repetitive. According to most grammatical texts (including MLA style as well as Strunk's reference), the slash is to be avoided as much as possible within prose.

Take the following example:

The point is that even those poetical epics, each verse / and stanza of them, would be found to be rich / and feeling-dense in itself.

Do you see how the word 'and' can be easily substituted for the punctuation mark?

Take caution with passive verbs, especially when using them unnecessarily. Wordy prose lowers credibility. The following sentence above, for example, could be edited down while still keeping its original meaning.

When making lists, I prefer to see semicolons used as I believe they're less clunky. But as I mentioned in my No-No's, semicolons used incorrectly are cumbersome. I also think that it's odd that you started with 'a.' but didn't go on to 'b.' when mentioning punctuation. So let's take into consideration the following passage:

Some factors that influence flow are: a. Rhyme; meter [a definitive, predetermined, repetitive syllabic scheme; pronunciation, by which is meant here the composition of a word by syllables that are stressed / unstressed, and the appropriate positioning of words within a sentence so as to ensure smooth pronunciation / reading of the poem.

This could be rewritten as:

Some factors that influence flow are rhyme or meter, which is defined as a definitive, predetermined, repetitive syllable scheme; punctuation, or the composition of a word by stressed or unstressed syllables; and the appropriate positioning of words within a sentence to ensure smooth pronunciation and reading of the poem.

Do you see how my version uses a lot LESS punctuation? In prose, less is more when it comes down to punctuation.

I hope this helps! Best of luck with all your future writings.


Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin



** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
150
150
Review of House of Wax  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi Lynn,

I wondered upon this piece by chance - and my goodness, what a beautiful piece of fiction. I enjoyed it immensely, and have no suggestions for improvement. You've done a great job with this.

I am guessing the man at the very end is McCartney - it might have been nice to have him explicitly referred to, although I don't think that's absolutely necessary.

Again, what a wonderful piece! Thank you so much for sharing it.


Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin



** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
288 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 12 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/liseli/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/6