Louis Williams's (lu-man) Reviews

Review Requests: ON
64 Public Reviews Given
125 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
2
2

Review of Enjoy the Ride!  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
A good poem.

Using the Ferris wheel as a metaphor for love itself, that's a take I hadn't considered before. It's a unique view that will leave me looking at a Ferris wheel completely different from now on.

The poem stays just long enough to relay the imagery and make its impact, and leaves at the most impactful moment. A very good job on this one.
3
3

Review of The Broken Cup  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
A very entertaining short.

Stories with a bit of the natural world in them seems to always feel more fleshed out. The fact that this story was based on an actual event seems to confirm that suspicion with me. (Or is it a conspiracy?)

Millie's reaction to the cup firing at her is priceless and frankly, probably something I would have done as well. The addition of the ghost at the end also made me smile. I could imagine one of my late relatives doing something like that.

A very relatable story with a very relatable situation! I enjoyed this one a lot.

Thanks,

Louis
4
4

Review of Snowday  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
Very well done.

This poem reminded me of snowball fights as a kid in New England. Well, as everyone's walking target in New England.

The visuals pulled you right into the environment. The writing was clear and concise. The font color made my eyes hurt on occasion.

Over all, quite enjoyable.
7
7

Review of Ambush Bug  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
A good poem with some good imagery. It got a little confusing in the middle for a moment, but I kind of like them that way, allows the reader to apply their own interpretation.

There is a good flow and bounce with the language here as well. Overall, a good job thanks for sharing this poem here.
9
9

Review of The note  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
Lol, now I have a sudden urge to visit my mother!

A good story. Like the letter nature, the emotional impact. You begin to question whether its a son or daughter. Whether this person was their spouse or parent.

That's a sign of a well written story. When we come away intrigued, desiring more. To spend more time with these characters.
12
12

Review of A quiet evening  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Great pacing. Action ramped up here like watching a good horror movie. I got the impression that this is a dinner they've sat through countless times before.

Not a great fan of ambiguous endings but you make it work here.

The language in the beginning of some of the descriptions are slightly clunky at times but it still works. That's the only real advice I can give you here with this one.

Good job. This is a good story.
14
14

Review of Stranger  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Interesting start here. Have good scene descriptions and the villain is unique. Can't wait to see what happens next, you have me intrigued.

Be careful on some scene descriptions they are venturing a little close to 1st Person.

All in all a good start! Can't wait to see what's gonna happen next.
15
15

Review of The Devil is You  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Some good advice here. The old adage of "Inside you is two wolves".

It's hard to develop good habits to replace the bad ones, to develop good things to break the bad, but worth it in the end.

Trouble is, most of the time people rarely acknowledge how difficult changing and breaking habits can be. It all seems easy for most self help things to say.

You do acknowledge a bit of this here. Which I like. We are who we choose to be, after all.
16
16

Review of Clair De Lune  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
A very beautiful and poignant slice of life piece about loss. Normally, I'd take a minute here to offer some advice in how to improve. However, any real advice I can give would simply be nitpicking.

The home was described well, leaving the atmosphere feel empty, as if it was missing something. The characters felt real, not like characters in a tale. This is done with idiosyncrasies and habits that reveal their nature, but also adds to the melancholy of the piece.

It's a very good story, one I rather enjoyed.
17
17

Review of A Distant Cafe  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
When work reaches a certain age I try not to review things, but I couldn't help myself here.

Within this poem is a full day of fun and enjoyment. Not only can I see you and Emily there, I can feel myself along with you, almost feel the heat upon me, taste the cold root beer. Quite an accomplishment, especially for such a short poem. Great work!
19
19

Review of E- letter  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
This has some good pacing. Some odd changes in rhythm here and there, which I like. It forces you to pay attention rather than getting lulled into a comfort that would let the poem fall into background noise.

The only nitpick I have is a repeated word. Granted, it is a nitpick, which is why I held it to last.

Great poem. Great poignant point.
20
20

Review of Plums  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
A good flash fiction that small children can enjoy. Simple motivations, simple word choices, even simple scene descriptions to give you a vision of the action without over complicating things.

Given that it's also a flash fiction, simple scene descriptions work best, too. It does work as a small joke especially the "you're both plumb foolish" at the end. I struggle to see if anymore could have been done with this. I really enjoyed this story.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
21
21

Review of Honey Bee  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (3.5)
I like this poem.

It has a musical quality to it that I most enjoy. I can almost hear the guitar in the background of this one. It's simple, and in this format quite effective. If you do record this one day, I hope you'll link it here so we can hear it.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
23
23

Review of So Blessed: A Mischievous Masterpiece  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
I like the unique words chosen here. They paint a picture of a grand, yet strange design.

It leaves a person feeling uncomfortable, as if beauty has been kiltered, cracked.

The only criticism I can offer is this: I can tell you wrote this in Microsoft Word. Every letter that starts a new line is capitalized, whether it begins a new sentence or idea or not.

It's a great poem and makes one think - as all great poetry should.
24
24

Review of Bird Plant  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (3.0)
A bit of a slice of life here. I know some would knock it for not having a real conflict or a tough dramatic change, but not all stories require that, especially if they can bring a smile to your face.

It's a good short bit over all. Though a stronger conflict and twist would make it more engaging, it makes me wonder if it would make it better or not?

I quite enjoyed this one. Hope you won the contest this was for.
25
25

Review of Waiting for me  

Review by lu-manMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
A bit of darkness in this one. I did enjoy it, and though I hope this was an exercise and not a real event!

If this wasn't a real event, then that is a very good mark for you, written in a style and manner to make one think that you're speaking from the heart.

I'm not a huge fan of the last line, it makes me think that there is more to the poem that's left unsaid.

Good job over all, I like this one.