*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/lynncar/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
512 Public Reviews Given
557 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Next
51
51
Review by Gunny
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Winnie,
Thanks for the chuckle this morning. I enjoyed the story very much. Nice set up for the surprise ending. I thought your imagry was excellent. I could see myself in the setting. At first, I didn't understand why the woman was running out of the elevator waving her hand in front of her face. *Bigsmile*. Good story. Gunny
52
52
Review of An Exiled King  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.5)
An interesting way to tell a story, through a letter. It's like the reader is eavesdropping by reading someone else's mail. There are many different things all going on at once which makes it more interesting for the reader. We are going to be classmates in the Sunrise class. I'm looking forward to reading more of your work. Gunny (Lynn)
53
53
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
A heart-warming piece. You wrote from the heart and the messge is quite clear for all to see. There's an old saying that if you want to send a message, use Western Union, but if you want to show emotions, write from the heart. Your little essay shows how grateful you are for all your family and those around you. Thank for sharing.
54
54
Review of The Intersection  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.5)
This would have been rated 5 except for one thing, the unusual words being used in a common place scene. They are very distracting and that's the last thing you want to do to your reader. I commend you for trying out these new words, but, if I may make a suggestion: you shouldn't use words that people don't normally use in everyday conversation unless you are trying to make a particular point, such as a character who uses those words to impress someone, or you are using those words in a formal treatise or essay. It's always good to know new words and to try to fit them into your everyday vocabulary, but that's for your own benefit. Remember, the task of the writer is to communicate to the reader exactly what she wants them to know. You fail in that communication effort when you use high-falutin' words that most readers will not understand. Personally, I like to read books where I have to have a dictionary handy, but in today's world, words with more than three syllables are likely to be a turnoff to a lot of folks. I'd like to suggest a small booklet that will help you tremendously: "The Elements of Style" by Strunk and White. Packed within only 95 pages is probably the most valuable information any wirter could have in his arsenal of knowledge. It costs about $8.00. I always keep it within reach. Good luck and good writing. Gunny
55
55
Review of Zip-Locc Demon  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.0)
A really cute piece of poetry. I had to chuckle as I was reading it. Thanks for throwing a little humor my way.
56
56
Review by Gunny
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
A great piece of writing that mirrors my sentiments exactly. I cannot find a thing to critique or suggest. Thanks for sharing this superb gem with the rest of us. I hope this will be read by many on WDC and they take to heart. We need more writers like you my friend.
57
57
Review of Death Stalkers  
Review by Gunny
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
An interesting story that moves at a good pace. There are some spots that I can see need work. It has to do with wordiness or reduncancy if you will. In the opening sentence, cut the word "shut". This is because the door has to let out its noises before it can slam shut. Next. "Holding her tongue" can be cut because by refraining from saying anything, we already know she is "holding her tongue." Telling the reader what they already know or can assume by what they read, is the sure sign of an amateur.

You can cut "The male voice on the other...." because we already know there's a male voice speaking. If you replace that line with "Good, now listen up. There's..." It keeps the story moving, yet doesn't repeat the "male voice." (Also, when each character speaks, you must start a separate indented line.)

Instead of having her refrain her smart assery, why not have her do it again? Now you have the reader involved thinking, "Oh no, if she keeps that up she's going to get fired." After all, if she's the only one who can get stuff done, why should she care what her bosses think of her? Let her be the pain in the boss' ass and have him give up in exasperation every time he tries to straighten her out. Readers enjoy a character who can thumb their nose at authority. They can easily identify with her.

Only one other point. You need a transition right before "Awww, give us more credit" I understand as a writer you want to keep the story moving along, but as a reader, I'm jolted out of the world you have just created by putting me somewhere I'm not sure of. My feet are dangling out here in space so to speak. Always keep me, the reader, grounded and comfortable with the story's setting. All you need is something simple like, "At the Poison Ice, Sakira met with "Awww, give us more credit," whined (character's name).

I think the story has a lot of potential, but the best part of writing is the editing phase which can never be ignored. Remember to cut as much dead wood as possible from dialog. Most of that is due to reduncancy and just plain filling in too much detail. Don't worry, most beginning writers do the same thing. I hope my suggestions will help and please don't think that I am being too picky. A good writer can never be too picky with herself and must have the skin of a rhino when it comes to suggestions and opinions of other writers. Good luck.
58
58
Review by Gunny
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I liked the pace of this story. I also like historic fiction. As you probably know, I am not a very tactful reviewer although, God knows I try to be. I loved this story, but I have some points that I think will really smooth out some rough spots. My only suggestion is to cut obvious reduncancies and over-descriptions that detract from the story. I have copied your piece and will attempt to indicate what I'm talking about by stricke-outs and underlining in red. Please have patience with me and do not take any of my suggestions as criticising your wonderful work, just as an honest appraisal which I'm sure good writers appreciate. ALMOST ALL OF THE STRIKEOUTS indicate too much verbage, over-description, or redundancy.


The gray military truck rambled down the dirt road. A tire hit a rut, but the vehicle didn’t stop. I sat on a bench in the truck bed, my eyes drifting past the canvas walls. It was twilight, that time of day when the sun and moon were on opposite horizons battling for control.

“Look at the floor!” Was this coming from a friend? At this point, I as a reader, don't know he is a prisoner. Maybe you could add: my Soviet guard shouted?

My eyes cut from the outside woods and greenery, to the Soviet soldier who sat in front of the truck’s gate, back to the floor. was he lying down? or did you mean to say, "his back was to me."? I could take him. He held his rifle loosely and his pistol was holstered. The smug, confident soldier was the only thing between me and the truck’s gate. Freedom was a breath away.

I shivered. The sun sank lower past the horizon. My need to escape was raw, like a jungle cat I flexed for the attack.flexing control. I had to make my attempt at just the right moment, when the moon’s dim light took over from the sun’s orange and red shadows.

It was 1950 – five years after the war ended in Europe. The continent, including Hitler’s capital, Berlin, had been divided by the four winning allies – the British, French, Americans, and Soviets.

Soon after the war ended, the Soviet's true desires came to light. They partitioned their territories off from the rest of theworld, but they couldn’t keep everyone out.the rest of the world from tip-toeing in – especially in Berlin where only a physical,a concrete wall was the only thing keeping the West out and the East in.might be the only thing that would keep those unwanted out.

Oh, the Soviets tried to keep us out. They surrounded the city and wouldn’t let the British, French, and Americans in. They threw up barbed wires, created “no-man” lands, and established heavily fortified checkpoints. That didn’t stop us. The Americans spearheaded an airlift campaign, dropping needed items into those areas of the city occupied by the three remaining allies. It worked. The Soviets had to give us access to the city whether they liked it or not, and they didn’t like it. They put up checkpoints on every block and requested travel papers authorizing one to cross into their section of the city, which had to be signed by their military commandant.

Despite thisall the Soviets attempts, Berlin still thrived. The Germans were a resourceful people. The western part of the city was booming in reconstruction projects.

My eyesI dared to look at my Soviet guard again. He wore a thin expression; his eyes began to droop. I’d have my chance soon.

My name was Alstair Kent and I wasa British officer taken prisoner at Checkpoint Charlie when my travel papers were deemed inappropriate. They were taking me outside the city to Potsdam to rot away in their military jail. We skirted the Wansee woods, still untamed by modern inventions. The Wansee Lake was the in the American sector of the city and on the border of Potsdam. The lake was now to the right of the truck as it weskirted the dirt road alongside the water. If I was going to escape, I had to do it now. The Americans were my last hope.

“Look at the floor, Captain.” The soldier’s halting English was firmer, icier, more demanding.

“Screw you.”

He cocked his head, as if not understanding. I bolted from my seat. He spun his rifle around, as if to head butt me. I dived for his feet, knocking him off balance. We collapsed on the floor of the truck bed, grunting and groaning from our struggle His rifle flew across the floor. Lunging for his holster, I grabbed?withdrew his pistol. He caught?grabbed my wrist. The whites of his eyes pierced the growing blackness of night like a star.

Using the palm of my hand, I shoved the palm of my handit into his face, forcing him off me. Then I stood up and dived over the truck bed’s gate, landing face first into the gravel road. I tumbled over and over, and myribs felt as if they'd been prickedpierced by a knife.

“Halt! Halt!”

I stumbled to my feet, ignoring the pain to my face and chest, willing myself to run, spitting out mouthfuls of dirt. My side hurt, but I limped into a full sprint. The truck screeched to a stop and I heard the Soviets scrambling to get off the truckrattling around.

Foot over foot, I ran as fast as I could, drawing in deep painful breaths. My destination was Wansee Lake and the American checkpoint. Boots scrambled behind me. Loud orders in Russian filled the air. I spied a wooden dock on the shore of the lake. It waslooked to be old and fragile, the wooden beams splinting as if the dock had seen its best days ten years pastago. Across the lake on the opposite shore some 500 meters away, the American checkpoint was ablaze in the moonlight..

I pumped my arms, drawing in deep lungfuls of air. My boots struck against the creaky planksof wood, as I made the decision to swim the length of the lakefor it.

GunshotsBullets whizzed around me. The oldwooden dock groaned under my weight. With one last desperate gulp of air, I dived off the dock, slicingthis brings to mind an olympic diver gracefully entering the water. Maybe "splashing" would be a better choice.into the water. More bullets zappedflew around me, splashing into the lake. Loud Russian curses tore through the dusky night.

The lake caressed me as if I were familiar being in its boundaries. My arms grew tired. The Soviets’ bullets were out of range, but I was determined not to fall prey to the lake’s now challenging vast width.

I had to push harder – push faster. My body moved like a lithe dolphin coursing through the water. A foreign soldier with binoculars stood on the shore looking through binoculars.

“He’s going to make it!”

Arm over fatigued arm, my body moved in synchronized rhythm, drawing and exhaling air, focusing on the not so distant shore. I saw two men wade into the water. Finally exhausted, my limbs stopped. I gasped for breath.

“I’ve got him, Sergeant!”

Two arms grabbed me. Another pair of arms wrapped around my waist. My shaking legs touched the muddy ground. I looked up at the American soldier.

“He’s a British officer!”

The sergeant looked directly at me. “You’ll be okay now, Sir.”

I nodded my head. The men dragged me out of the water. The moon smiled down us like a proud cat. I had escaped.


59
59
Review of Fire  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
Outstanding! The one nit-pick I have is flames don't "arouse" they "rise" or "arise" The only people that flame "arouse" are the arsons who START the fire! I liked the way you used the shape of the sentences in the poetic form of wiring by using the t-r-i-c-k-l-e and the "down, down, down technique. Very powerful little piece.
60
60
Review of Diary of Eve  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.5)
Overall impression was wonderful. A well paced short, short story. There are some minor grammatical and punctuation errors but, I won't go into that. More importantly, you told the story with the voice of one who was enthusiastic and interested. That is what kept my interest from beginning to end. Emotions and boldness, along with a sensible knowledge of grammar and puncuation make for very powerful stories. Please keep writing. This was a beautiful story and made me think. After all, that's what a good story is all about.
61
61
Review of Spring Creek  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.5)
A beautiful vignette of something you saw while "zooming" past a pastoral scene that obviously impressed you. I suggest one minor changes which I believe would make your piece really powerful. First, only use "Whom" when you would use "him" or "her" or "them" . So that, "God( him) created" would not sound right at all. "Who" and "Whom" depends on the verb that follows those words. So if you used "God(he) created" then you would use the Who form. Whom=him, Who=he. Actually , to avoid all that crap, I would write, "God created." The piece moved at a good pace which kept me involved until the end.


Gunny
62
62
Review of Nightfall  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
A wonderful tale. I liked the way you kept me waiting until the very end to find out who the mysterious figure was. The story was very well paced and ends on a sad, but thoroughly intriguing note. The little subplot was funny as you purposely scare the old gossip away. She won't be bothering the protagonist with those pesky donations any more. Very well edited. I think this story is ready for publishing if it isn't already in print.
63
63
Review of Genie  
Review by Gunny
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
A cute story. I think it has a lot of potential. It is obvious that you have a talent for telling a story and I hope you keep working at it.
You have learned a lot about dialog and I was glad to see you used that knowledge. Your choice of point of view was a good one and you
seemed to stay within one POV throughout. A lot of beginning writers have trouble with that. A good story, keep writing!
64
64
Review of Quick!  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.0)
I think that you found a pretty good faculty for expressing your thoughts in this piece. A lot of truth in what you say. We all have an inner editor who tries to thwart any efforts to express our thoughts in words. I envision mine as a cigar chomping, green-visor-wearing, no nonsense bully. He tells me that I'm good enough, not polished enough, that no one wants to hear what I have to say. I've learned to tell that inner editor of mine to take a hike and I'll call him when I need him. He comes in handy when it's time to rewrite first drafts written without his stifling interruptions. I enjoyed the piece. Keep writing!
65
65
Review of Unnatural Sights  
Review by Gunny
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
As usual, some nice writing. I think you have a good feel for telling a story. With your blessings, I have some points I'd like to cover. First, a small matter, but very important. I missed the reason that the professor changed his mind on the phone and decided to meet with the stranger. It didn't make sense to me because he was so adamant not to meet with the stranger. It was late at night and cold and he'd had a long day. The only clue you gave was that the stranger's voice changed. Maybe you meant to add the reason later but it slipped your mind? The other point is about your descriptions. Although they are well-written, many are unnecessary. Always ask yourself "If I left this word, phrase, or sentence out would it change the story in any meaningful way?" If the answer is "no," delete it. This will tighten up your writing and help to keep the story moving forward. For instance, the fact that the sidewalks were cleaned and snow was piled 30 cm deep is nothing but eye-candy and does nothing but pause the story for a moment. Try to get all the fluff out of your stories. Normally, your tempo is good, but some of the narratives and descriptions seem to be working against you.. Any unneccessary descriptions or dialog stops the forward movement and the reader has to struggle to stay with the story. I just want to mention something that you may not have thought of. All dialog, like descriptiions and narratives should serve a definite purpose. It should be describing a character, a scene, or what is happening between two characters. No talking just to fill in awkward moments. A lot of character can be revealed with dialog instead of narrative. I liked the story and it can be improved a lot with through the application of simple mechanics.
66
66
Review by Gunny
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
The story has a good beginning, middle and ending. Good descriptions of characters. Mr. Event was quite a character. Work on the setting. I felt as if I were floating in space, not able to find solid footing from which to get comfortable and read about the characters. More similies and metaphors would help with clarity of descriptions. Also, it took me a while to figure out that Mr. Event wasn't kidding about traveling to other worlds. I thought he was just being a smart-mouth. You might want to clarify all this with a definite setting of place and time up front.
67
67
Review of The Flood  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.0)
This was a well written piece and I know a lot of work went into it. My suggestions are meant to help you improve your story telling using what you already have. If you have been into writing for any time, you will have heard the expression "Show" don't "Tell." What that means is when you write a story, don't make it sound like a news article where the reader is told what happens, and where there very little dialog or action. In story writing, the author must engage the reader on more than just a reading-of-words level. Long descriptive passages tend to bore readers, no matter how well-written they are. An example copied verbatim: "A half living cow clamoured to submerged slip rails. The crew couldn't do anything for it, and had to leave it with rifle shot." These two sentences could have been written into a riviting scene by having the children spot the cow, and have them point it out with dialog. Then one of the men would take aim to shoot it and the children beg him not to shoot it. This could be done mostly with dialog which would engage the reader's emotions rather than just reading along with matter-of-fact statements. What you have is a supurb story line with a beginning, a middle and and end, but it needs to be livened up with dialog. One or two characters need to be fleshed out so that the reader can identify with them. Make those your main characters and have the story revolve them so that reader can follow along with their lives, their wants and desire. Make it so the reader can feel their joys, fears and dissappointments. Readers want emotions and action. There had to be arguments and disagreements. If not, make some up so that you create conflict. The readers want to feel good or bad about your characters. They need to care about them. When the crew arrives at four o'clock, the reader needs to know how they feel about what they see through their inner thoughts and external dialog. Work more of that into this story and you will have a wonderful piece of work. I hope my suggestions have encouraged you to think on a different level, and I hope you will take my suggetions in the spirit in which they are given. Overall, the piece is very well written, I've no problem with that. If the story is how you wanted to portray it, then let it stand.
68
68
Review of Loneliness  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
Very sad. I'm sure there are many people who struggle with the meaning of it all and come to the conclusion that there is no good purpose -- it's all sorrow and sadness. You can easily see a person sitting alone in a darkened room contemplating putting an end to his/her suffering. Very moving and graphic in a minimum amount of words.
69
69
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
The truth of this little vignette shines through for all who read it. A wonderful sentiment yet so few people take the time to just listen to someone. You can learn so much from listening. As Yogi Bera suposedly once said, "You can see a lot by looking."
70
70
Review of Heart or Head  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
While poetry is not my forte, I really enjoyed this little vignette. And we all know that the heart always wins, although sometimes not to our benefit. The struggle between logic and emotions always make a good story. Good job. Gunny
71
71
Review of My Psalm  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
I myself am a reader of the Psalms and I can tell you this is an excellent example of a modern day praise of God. I enjoyed reading this and if I were GOD, I'd say that was pretty close to the old testament stuff. He'd probably only give you 4 1/2 stars, but I'm going to give you five. Gunny
72
72
Review of De hired  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
Although I personally was very fortunate no to have been outdated, I was very close to it by the time I retired. I had thought about what I would do. You have described the feelings and I'm glad I didn't have to go through being phased out. It's hard enough losing you job due to down-sizing, but to tell you are are no longer relevant has got to be a blow to one's self-esteem. You described it very well. It's a shame that these companies don't take advantage of their senior employees. Thirty years of experience has got to count for something.
73
73
Review of Some Tsunami  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (5.0)
Excellent imagry once again. I've spent many a day on the beach and I can tell you, your description is dead on. Keep up the good work. I enjoy reading your writing. Good choice of words, none are wasted and there is good pace and tempo.
74
74
Review of Father's Day  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.5)
Very good imagry. I was able to connect with the verse; "Our childhood Everest..." I recall the recent viewing of my father's body and it struck me how old and wizened he appeared. Good writing like yours does that to those who read it. Thanks for sharing.
75
75
Review of The Wall  
Review by Gunny
Rated: E | (4.5)
A heartfelt poem about how you can block out the blessings and the joy that all people should enjoy. The ending is satisfying in that the narrator knows that the only way to break the wall down is just to do it or you will be miserable forever. Keep writing from the heart. It always makes for good reading.
214 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 9 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/lynncar/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3