*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mcgupta44/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/6
Review Requests: ON
5,852 Public Reviews Given
5,942 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 2 3 4 5 -6- 7 8 9 10 11 ... Next
126
126
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a nice poem telling a great, imaginary story.

MY COMMENTS:

1--It would be nice if you use the period where it is needed.

2--In:

Finnegan's heart was nearly shattered,
He'd come so far, you see
He tried his best to understand,
choose the path to nobility

>>> It appears you wanted to say "chose".

--M C Gupta
127
127
Review of Only In Dreams  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
This is a wonderfully original theme for a poem--"Poem Written For a Story Character". It shows a high level of creativity. The character speaks thus--

Only in dreams, I am with thee,
My heart with yours so wild and free
My love, I see your name, but not your face
It doesn't matter, I've found my place.

Congrats for a job well done. And thanks for sharing.

--M C Gupta
128
128
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is a good poem about an unimaginable theme--Imagination.

What is imagination? It is described as--


You took me to so many places,
where dragons fly,
and mermaids swim.

AND, what happened to it?--

However, things happened,
I grew up,
and we drifted apart.

This is what poetry is supposed to be--brief, poignant and graphic, with flow.

Well written!

--M C Gupta
129
129
Review of Falling  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
This is a nice poem / lyrics that describes beautifully that moment in love when, while a person says goodbye, the other is unable to, in spite of wanting, to say--"Stop, Don't go,I love you."

Those six words, withheld, while expecting that they still reach the other person!

This is the situation described here--

"As you walked away
I asked if you'd stay with me
for a minute---
while I light my cigarette?
But what I really meant. . .
went unsaid---

(It was I LOVE YOU)"

--M C Gupta
130
130
Review of The Right Path  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
This small piece is probably intended to convey the fact that actresses have to compromise with their own perceived moral standards as regards dress and dance etc. so as to satisfy the demands of the director of the movie being made.

If that is the intended message, this write is successful.

Additionally, it conveys a message that children land into such difficult times because they don't listen to their parents.

It is a good write, conveying a lot in a few words.

--M C Gupta








131
131
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is a wonderful poem that holds the interest from the word 'go'. It starts with--

What giant birds are these called trees
with feathers in their arms and knees
that flap and flit and flip and flutter
as to the wind they chirp and sputter?
Although they stretch into the sky
they will not, cannot, do not fly.

Only a poet can portray trees and birds. What an unimaginable comparison, one which makes perfect sense as the poem proceeds!

Keep writing.

--M C Gupta
132
132
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
The following words appear to me to be written in answer to the question--"Are you a poet?"


Do you see
the hand of God
in the craftsman’s wares
and the workman’s toil?

Do you take note
of the fine detail
of an insect’s wing,
or a leaf’s vein?

The poet shows us
wonders of the world
we pass each day
upon our way.

Do you have
what it takes?

***

It is a wonderful poem, in simple words, describing the nature of a poet. He sees what others don't.

Very well written.
--M C Gupta
133
133
Review of Naukar  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
This piece records some ideas that seem to occur to the person here in a haze of memory about someone elder, in an Indian setting. That person is probably the Naukar (servant). That much is clear from the words. However, what exactly is behind those words is not clear. It is the writer's choice to be vague to the extent that she desires.

There are no mistakes.

--M C Gupta
134
134
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
It is a good sonnet with the following comments:

1--It is not easy to comprehend what it is all about. Needs a lot of thinking and imagining. However, that is not a drawback in poetry.

2--Ref: "You're stirred the very core
that gives me every reason to exist."

>>> It expands to -- "You are stirred the very core......"

[This does not make sense. May be you wanted to write--"You have stirred the very core......"

In that case, it should be--"You've stirred the very core......"

--M C Gupta
135
135
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This is a good sonnet. It meets all the requirements. There are no mistakes of grammar or spelling. As regards--"There are no breaks in its structure because that is how Shakespeare wrote them", I prefer to write my own sonnets with breaks after lines 4, 8 and 12. This is more user friendly and makes for easy readability and comprehension.

The content is rather deep, needing a bit of mental exertion. But that is not a fault. It is just a tribute to your poetic mind and style.

--M C Gupta
136
136
Review of Politician  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
Here is a poem, more like lyrics, that describes in true colours a politician as follows--

He may double talk
That’s his style
When in trouble
Turns and gives a smile
A magician, the politician

***

Ref:

What kind of man will take a stand?
For the peoples rights and demands

>>> people's

--M C Gupta
137
137
Review of FAT IN THE SAND  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a nice poem.The following is quite sarcastic but perfectly true--

We marched into that land
and a war we did wage.
Then we offered our hand
& helped ourselves to center stage


It is rather bad to wound someone, for no reason, and then to dress the wound, claiming credit for the "humanitarian" gesture.

--M C Gupta

=================
138
138
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (3.5)
This small article about time has a catchy title--"If I could bottle time!!!". I wish that was possible:)

You need to be a bit careful about spelling and grammar. For example, you have used 'to' in place of 'too' twice in this write up.

[And my children...well they grew to fast.]

--M C Gupta
139
139
Review of Finding Fagan  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a nice little boys' story regarding hide and seek. Yet, I feel the ferocity displayed here is a bit too much--

"His bloodshot eyes illuminated in the darkness. He could just make out a slight movement coming from the far left corner of the basement. One by one his claws extended.

He let out a ferocious roar and hastened towards a large oak cabinet, which he picked up and discarded as though it was made of cardboard."

This is followed by a highly contrasting-- "“Got you!” cried Wolfgang affectionately scratching his cousin."

SUGGESTION--You might bring down the ferocity a bit.


--M C Gupta
140
140
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
This is quite a witty poem, mainly based on the play of words, but carries a significant message also that we should be rooted in the ground rather than be too lofty and away from reality.

OPENING LINES--

The serpent's point of view?
He preys more than you.
His face is on the ground,
ninety -nine percent of the time.


He's awake, he's preying.


Man is standing upright
the entire course of the day,
yet when does he pray?

--M C Gupta
141
141
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a poem of sadness. It is titled--"AS THE CANDLE SLOWLY MELTS". The title and the content of the poem are fully reflected in the last stanza--

So as this burning mass of wax,
Nears the end of its belt.
My life will soon be over,
As the candle slowly melts.

***

Over all, a good poem.

--M C Gupta
142
142
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
It was a pleasure reading this poem. It was written as a pep up message for a young girl by her father. However, I think it has the following beneficial advice for all--

"Remember-
a closed mouth does not get fed.
So tell them what you want-
don't be scared.
Shyness is not a weakness
but it can hold you back."

***

Well written. Write on.

--M C Gupta

====================
143
143
Review of Lost  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is an unusual but very strong and emotional poem that conveys its message very well--the message of two persons who love each other but are unable to communicate.

The poem has a tragic end. The opening and end lines are as follows:


Lost

You stand there
staring at me
torn between love and hate,
torturing yourself on the knife edge
of a sword

wanting, needing, desiring,

speechless.

**

until, trembling
you raise a hand
and plunge the knife
deep into your heart,

And I stand there staring –
lost

**************

It is a good poem.

--M C Gupta

144
144
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Sonali ji,

It was a great poetic treat to read your poem. It is just great.

It is 10 years since you joined the WDC and became a moderator pretty soon. You must be one of the few Indian moderators on this site. It is a tribute to your capabilities.

The item under review is flawless, except that, grammatically, shrotaon needs to be changed to shrotao in the first line.

--M C Gupta
145
145
Review of Murli's Fate  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Dear Dr. Taher,

This is a wonderful write. You have great writing capabilities.

Only one suggestion--It seems that the fine of Rs. 10,000/- is excessive as per legal conventions / practice.You may like it to be Rs. 2000/-


--M C Gupta
146
146
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is an interesting poem about the monster that we have all been afraid of in childhood, who, somehow, seems relevant in this case even during adulthood, forcing the psychologist to render the following advice--

There is no such thing as your monster
Especially not under your bed
It is my opinion that your monster…
Resides only in your head!

***

The poem is well written.

--M C Gupta
147
147
Review of Smell the flowers  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a beautiful small poem with a clear and useful message.

The statement in the poem is--

Life is a Journey.
Along the way,
We may stumble and fall.

***

The message is--

As we pick ourselves up
Remember
that if not for the fall,
We might have missed,
Smelling the Flowers.

*******

Nice thoughts!

--M C Gupta
148
148
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is an unusual and beautiful poem with a novel theme, which is reflected in the end as follows:

You want me to chat with you for long,
Why do you say sorry even when I'm wrong?
You've stolen my heart once before.
Are you making me fall for you once more?
What are you up to girl, what are you up to?

I'm trying to make a guess,
figuring out your next move.
What are you up to girl, what are you up to?

****

>>> Trying to make a guess about what women do or think is a venture frought with risks. Good luck!

The poem has a nice flow.
149
149
Review of A Needed Friend  
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: E | (5.0)
It is a pleasure to read this poem. Its structure is immaculate-- abcb rhyme and 8-6-8-6 syllabic rhythm. A good flow is, thereby, inbuilt in the poem.

The description of the poem is short and subtle--"A mom now understood." It serves its purpose well. The description is softly elaborated in the last two stanzas--

The kitchen light, left on at night,
stirred Mom to be aware.
She peered into her daughter's room
to gaze about with care.

The pup perked up, then lay back down
with blanket as a hood;
a child in pink asleep in peace,
a mom now understood.

--M C Gupta
150
150
Review by Dr M C Gupta
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
This poem is about persons afflicted with suicidal tendencies and addiction to substances, who are not able to communicate with others. It ends with the following poignant words--

A woman talking to herself,
a young child points out.
A child who knows no evil,
just wonders what it’s about.
The mother makes something up
and the child thinks it’s true.
How shocking to the mother
when the child grows up to be you.

SUGGESTION-- It would make for an easy reading if you space your poem by presenting it as stanzas rather than a continuous, non-stop presentation.

--M C Gupta
2,018 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 81 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/mcgupta44/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/6