Evelyn - Writing on Fire's (meg3450) Reviews

Review Requests: OFF
377 Public Reviews Given
389 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
26
26

Review of The B25 A Tale of Two Scales  

Rated: E | (5.0)
Another great piece of writing! You are multi-talented. I really enjoyed this piece. It was perfect. At first, I felt sort of depressed with the beginning. But, you took it and turned it into a humorous account, though exciting.

I could just feel the pride and excitement throughout the account.

There were no errors in grammar or otherwise. You did an excellent job.
Evelyn
27
27

Review of Haiku - Dying Bud - Version Two  

Rated: E | (5.0)
This one was harder for me to understand, but I still loved the imagery. Your poems just flow with a wonderful rhythm. I love the way they sound.

Again, though I don't usually enjoy Haiku, I really did this one.

You write an excellent poem. There are no errors that I see. Your rhythm, imagery, and form are excellent. You must have worked hard to perfect this form.

Evelyn
28
28

Review of Haiku - Deep Sea Change  

Rated: E | (5.0)
Again, and excellent job of expressing a thought using a Haiku. You have a special knack with this type poem. I enjoyed it immensely. Gulls are my favorite bird. I love watching them soar, so free. You have really portrayed the way I feel they look. An excellent job. Keep up the writing of Haiku. You might even convince me I love them.

Evelyn
PS I forgot to add gps to the last review, so am adding it to this one.
29
29

Review of Haiku - Singing Leaves  

Rated: E | (5.0)
Another great job of expressing a thought in so few words. Again, you do it excellently. I really enjoyed this one. I could just feel the hope and joy expressed.

I don't usually enjoy Haiku because of the length limits. However, I have enjoyed both of yours that I have read so far.

You did great, again!

Evelyn
30
30

Review of Haiku - Rose in Crystal Vase  

Rated: ASR | (5.0)
What a great job you have done in telling a story with such a short amount of words. I can feel the emotion you express. That is a hard job with a Haiku because of the limit to length. You have done it well.

I expecially love your imagery. I read it several times, just to get the feel. It has wonderful rhythm and flow. You did good!
Evelyn
32
32

Review of Expecting The Unexpected (Chp 4)  

Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Another excellent piece of writing, as I find all yours are. I am anxious to see where Seamus and Treasa end up, and what their fate will be.

You tell an arresting story. Even though I usually don't enjoy foreign settings, this one is super.

I especially like the way you show your characters, not really describing and telling, but just letting us learn of them.

I am anxiously awaiting chapter 5. Please don't be too long with it.
Evelyn
33
33

Review of Condo-lences:  

Rated: E | (5.0)
This is an excellent portrayal of the angst of facing the empty nest. I have done it once, then adopted a new family and am now facing it again with the adopted children. How can one face it twice? The same way as once, I guess.

You very accurately and pointedly showed how it feels, the mixed feelings. It is a great piece.
Evelyn
34
34

Review of The Game  

Rated: ASR | (5.0)
This was a very intriguing story. It caught and held my attention throughout. I had no idea the ending would be like it was. It added to the story. I started thinking it was a game, then thought it was real, then again thought it was a game. Interesting!

I didn't note any punctuation or grammar errors. It was very well-written, and very well-organized.

I especially like the way you gave the explanation at the end. It makes the story even more interesting.
Evelyn
35
35

Review of "Ain't No Misunderstandin'"  

Rated: E | (4.5)
This was a wonderful story, catching my attention from the very beginning and keeping it all the way through.

I especially like the way you used the active voice throughout. It is not always easy to do that.

Your characters were portrayed very graphically and clearly. I feel I know each of them.

I did notice a few minor punctuation errors, like no comma before a direct address. They did not detract from the story, though.

I wouldn't change anything except the punctuation errors. It is perfect as is.
Evelyn
36
36

Review of If Blackbeard Was President  

Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
This is a very interesting perspective. I really liked the message. Your rhythm/meter was good. I was a little stumped at first with the change to 2 line stanzas at the end, but on reading it again, I was okay with it. It really didn't interrupt the smooth flow of reading. Keep up the good work. Glad you found us.
Evelyn
37
37

Review of Ink & Paper (Chp 3)  

Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Again, an excellent read. I don't usually enjoy foreign-set stories, or ones with political overtones, but this one is very captivating. I think it is because the characters are so vivid. I'm not reading a political/historical novel, but am reading about the characters.

I noted no grammar or spelling errors. An excellent job. I am awaiting the next installment.
Evelyn
38
38

Review of All in Due Time  

Rated: E | (4.0)

This is a very thought provoking piece. It asks the same questions I have asked myself time and again on different occasions. A few places I found the reading a little hard to understand, due to word order or such. I have included one such instance:
"What is with all my this suffering and horrible pain?"
Still, it is an excellent piece, just needs some polishing. I think it asks the age-old question we all struggle with at times.
Evelyn


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
39
39

Review of Bumble Boy  

Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
This was well-written with a surprise twist. It is impeccable in grammer, punctuation and spelling. I think you developed your characters well for a short story.

I did have one thing that I did not particularly like. I thought it was just a little gruesome, which may be okay for the purpose, but the ending seemed to leave little hope. I thought it was rather depressing.
Evelyn
40
40

Review of For The First Time For A Long Time  

Rated: E | (5.0)
A great poem. It is so rhythmic that is reads like a song. I especially love the repetition of the last two stanzas - it sort of ties the whole thing together.

It appears that you have found the way to return home. It is said you can never go home again, but I beg to differ on that. True, things will be different, but you CAN go home - at least, I hope so. I have attempted to do just that.

A good, thought-provoking poem.
Evelyn
41
41

Review of The Eyes Have It  

Rated: E | (5.0)
An excellent poem. You address almost every type/condition of eyes that could be imagined. I love eyes, they are the favorite part of the body to me (too bad my are so bad).

The rhythm flows very smoothly. Rhyme is perfect, nothing forced.

I really enjoyed the glimpse into the "windows of the soul." I firmly believe eyes are such.
Evelyn
42
42

Review of West Brookfield, MA - chapter I  

Rated: E | (4.5)
An interesting account of the origin of the town, when it was an Indian village. I was confused by a few of the terms, possibly Indian words, and would have like to have seen them explained. These were: steatite, seethe, sachem. I can make an educated guess as to their meaning, but would love to have an explanation in the essay.

Again, I really enjoy your writing. I have read most of it, and will continue to do so.
Evelyn
43
43

Review of West Brookfield, MA - 1660 to 1960  

Rated: E | (5.0)
This is an excellent introduction that makes me want to read on. I expecially liked the short introduction to the Indian words that you gave.

You have covered the content of the upcoming essay very well. I am curious as to how the town got the name change to Brookfield. I want to read on and find out just how.

Though I am not a history buff, something about the introduction makes me want to read the entire thing. I think it is the explanation of the Indian names, and my desire to learn how they applied to this town.
Evelyn
44
44

Review of Smoldering Dreams (Chp 2)  

Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This piece is excellent. It is well-written with no grammatical errors. The characters are very well developed. I can about anticipate how they are going to react in the future as they escape.

I would suggest that you maybe show the depth of emotion that they two of them must be feeling at the moment, or at least indicate they are emotionless due to the shock of the recent events. This can be a very emotional story, and you may be going to develop it further, but I wanted to "hear" the despair they must be feeling.

It is an excellent story, and I can't wait to read more.
Evelyn
45
45

Review of Baby Monitor  

Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
An excellent, eerie story. It took me some time to discover what was going on (if I really did) but it was intriguing.

I noted a few usage/spelling errors. Just probably needs going over again for such editing.

The story flow was excellent, keeping me involved throughout the whole thing. In fact, I was late leaving work as I was reading the story after work and didn't want to leave.

Evelyn
46
46

Review of Why do I write? Who am I?  

Rated: E | (5.0)
What a wonderful commentary on your life! I love Home of Red Fox and Home of the Gray Dog. I have read and reviewed all the episodes you had online before my computer crashed. I plan to catch up over the weekend.

I started reading the autobiography because I loved you novels. But, once I started, it was so gripping I couldn't stop. I loved it all the way through.

I did not see any grammatical or spelling errors, either.

I plan to do a similar autobiography for myself, as I think it will help me understand myself better. Thanks for another good read.
Evelyn
47
47

Review of Monday Ministers (a christmas story)  

Rated: E | (5.0)
This is very good. I love the way you tell the moral without seeming to be doing just that.

I did not note any grammar, spelling or punctuation errors.

The thing I liked best about this was the way you fleshed out the various characters, a difficult task for such a short piece.
Evelyn
48
48

Review of RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  

Rated: E | (5.0)
What a wonderful idea. I have been the recipient of an upgrade, and it is wonderful. Not only does it make it possible to stay a member of this wonderful group, but it also gives inspiration to be an ACTIVE member. I mean, if someone believes in me enough to gift me with an ungrade, then I must believe in myself as well. Thanks, for a good group.

I am attaching a donation to help with upgrades. I don't know if this is how or where to do it or not. I know it is not much, but will do more when I can.
Evelyn
49
49

Review of Forever Loved: Of An Autistic Child  

Rated: E | (4.5)
I have an autistic son, one with Asperger's (a form of autism) and I have taught a number of autistic children. You have really captured the joys and frustrations.

The only reason I rated it 4.5 instead of 5.0 was the "choppiness" in places, where the meter didn't seem to be consistent. Also, some places were confusing to me, such as, at the beginning talking about three words. I wasn't sure what you meant.

All in all, this is a very poignant piece, done well.
Evelyn
50
50

Review of I Will Never Forget 9/11 2001  

Rated: ASR | (5.0)
What an excellent tribute. I, too, remember the day very vividly. I have long felt the need to recognize those victims in some way. I think you have done that here. Thanks for sharing a memorable tribute to so many, and in the process keeping us aware of the dangers we face if we forget. The writing is excellent.
Evelyn