Hi there, H.M. Godwin! I couldn't resist reading this after I saw the title and description. Which, by the way, fit this piece perfectly!
Initial Impressions:
Wow. "Noble" was a very detailed and emotional account of one young man's struggles growing up. The last two years of high school, or in this case, prep school are full of transistions, growth, and unexpected surprises, and you chronicle that very well. I think this is the phase we truly start turning into the adults we will become, and Noble finds himself hating what he sees. The good news is, it's never too late to change.
Characterization: You poured a lot of detail into your cast. I felt I had an excellent grasp on Noble because you did such an amazing job conveying his thoughts and emotions to the reader. He's a complex character, driven by fear, loathing, shame . . . all of the things we feel when we are uncertain of ourselves or our surroundings. I also felt I got to know James quite well, though Noble's eyes, and I, too, fell in love.
James was quite remarkable. He possessed a fortitude not many people have at that age. He was selfless in his actions, concerned more about the happiness and well-being of others than himself. He reminds me a lot of the few people who seem too good at heart, to pure and tender to really make it in this world. Despite his best efforts, he caved beeneath the constant torture and harrassment of his peers . . . but even in that, he still tried to protect the one person he loved. Beautiful. As beautiful as his physical description!
The others---wow. What can one really say here? We all know people like this. We either grew up watching or receiving their cruelty, or saw them dish it out on a daily basis. The sad thing is, kids like Evan gather a following, not because they are great, but because they are feared. I'm willing to bet more than one kid felt bad about the way they treated James, but they were too afraid to speak up or go against the flow, lest the "mob mentality" shift in their direction. It's the same quandry Noble faced, but for different reasons. Guilt by association is an awful thing at that age.
Plot Pretty soild here. I loved this coming of age and recognition tale. It draws you in and envelops the reader in a platitude of emotions. Fear, anger, betrayl, guilt, love...this story has it all. It shows how we are capable of growth and change. It also shows the harmful,lasting effects intolerance and cruelty can have on a person.
Setting was also well done. The prep school was the perfect backdrop for this tale and you gave enough details to make it easy to see.
Thoughts/Suggestions
The only thing that I really didn't care for, and even that is a stretch, was how the view points changed so often in the beginning of the story. It felt like I was always being jarred out of one point of time or one person's head into another. Honestly, if it were at all possible, I would try to keep the story written entirely from Noble's point of view and divulge the bits and pieces about James and Evan through dialogue and the story. Everything else was very polished and amazing!
I loved your last few lines. James just was. Perfect wording and it really conveys the message I think you were trying to convey with your story. I also really liked the part where you said in a perfect world, they could have been together, things could have been different. It really makes one stop to think about the state of affairs around them and some struggles others might have that we don't even stop to think of.
Overall, this truly was an amazing read and I would definitely suggest it to anyone looking for a well-developed and well-written story. I look forward to reading more of your work in the future!
~Best wishes and happy writing!~
Adriana
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
|
|