*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/robertholt/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
637 Public Reviews Given
1,194 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 5 6 7 8 ... Next
51
51
Review of ~~ME~~  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Very nice.

sorry for meddling... but.

third stanza? >there is rain in my eyes
that could darken the sky.<
consider... [ there could be rain... that may darken the sky ]
gets rid of 3 rhyming words in a row... the only stanza that has them.

just bob.... sending GPs to offset auto-rew
52
52
Review of GUN-CONTROL  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Wow.... What can I say except a big..YES.. to each and every point you made.
This 'should be'.. Required Reading. in schools across America. **
(wouldn't hurt the Brits and Aussys to read it also)
In our great.."yuck".. Democratic Gov. We The People, are the enemy.

** what would have been the outcome if a few teachers at Kent State, And Colimbine had been (here's that nasty word) ARMED?... think about that you gun haters

just bob... ready to fight for your 'rights'... if we still have any.
53
53
Review of Dog Days  
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
Hi...
You put this out on scroll, so I'm giving it a look.
I see a few..'easy to fix'.. problems.
The story seems to have no resoultion, so I'm assuming it is chap 1 ??

I spotted 3 things...( things I used to do before getting 'hammered' by WDC reviewers)
1... repitition of names. Once named, normally your reader will know who 'he/she is.
2... "yuck" tag-lines. If you let your readers know who is 'about' to speak, and how they sound..(shouted..whispered.. ect) they can 'hear' the voice 'as' they read the line...[action before words]
3,,, action or words by one, and action or words by another on the same line. [ each time one acts or speaks, it is a new line]

>>> my opinion only<<

my comments in blue



>> The Wednesday before the trouble, Liam sat watching a film with his dad, Jimmy. Liam was eating a microwave chicken korma straight from the container. Jimmy was drinking. Their old collie, Buster, sat in front of Liam, ears pricked, eyes on the black plastic dish.

“Give him some,” said Jimmy.
have Jimmy do something [action] Jimmy waved a hand at Buster. "Give him some."

“It’s mine,” said Liam. He pushed at Buster with his foot.
now we know Liam will respond, and we know his name... also, sone 'ing' words bringe it mory 'real-time' not past tense. Pushing the dog away with hes foot, he muttered, "It's mine."


“What’s this, anyway?” asked Jimmy, waving his can vaguely at the portable TV
Ignoring his comment, Jimmy waved his can vaguely at the TV. "Wjat's this anyway?"

“If...” said Liam. “It’s a film.”
now we know Liam will answer, so no tag-line is necessary

“Is it?” said Jimmy. He took a swig from his can and shifted in his seat. “Give him some of your curry,” he said. Liam ignored him, keeping his eyes on the film. Between mouthfuls, his lips moved in time with his favourite lines.
delete 'said Jimmy.. and.. he said... we know who, and he's saying it.
NEW LINE 'Liam ignored him, ...


“Right,” said Jimmy. He pushed himself up and lunged at his son, grabbing for the dish with his free hand. Liam pulled back from him. The dish tipped; korma slithered onto Liam’s jeans. Buster leapt forward, snapped up a piece of fallen chicken.
delete 'said Jimmy'
NEW LINE Liam pulled back (from him is redundant)... onto 'his' jeans

“Great,” said Liam. no space between Liam's action and words, then 'said Liam' is unnecessary

“Teach you to share in future,” said Jimmy. He took another mouthful of lager and burped. “Get a cloth before it stains,” he said.tag-line... we know who's saying it

Muttering under his breath, Liam stalked to the kitchen. He took the cleanest cloth from the sink and wiped at his jeans, water seeping into the denim. They were ruined for tonight, he thought. Typical. He squashed the remains of his tea into the bin, crushing down the empty beer cans. Back in the lounge, he scrubbed at the carpet while his dad flicked between channels with the remote. Buster lay nearby, licking his muzzle.
no space.. no T-L
“That dog eats better than I do,” said Liam.

“You look like you’ve pissed yourself,” said Jimmy.action? Jimmy grinned. "Looks like..



On the Friday morning, Liam was in his room, staring moodily at his school shoe, and at the hole where Buster had chewed it. Liam looked outside; it was raining. He put his finger through the hole, as if to make sure it really did go all the way through. For a second he considered asking his dad for the money to buy a new pair. It didn’t seem likely. Not with the weekend coming up.

After a few moments’ thought, Liam hedropped the shoe, put on his Reebok Classics, and went to school. Tomorrow he’d use what money was left in his own account. So much for the Playstation, he thought. The idea made him smile. His dad would only have pawned it anyway.

The trainers weren’t a problem until Biology that afternoon. Mr Kelly singled him out the moment Liamhe walked into the classroom.

“Jones!” he said, “Those are white trainers.”tag-line .. you just told us Kelly singled him out

“Yes, sir, I know,” said Liam.tag-line He slung his bag onto a table and pulled out a seat. It scraped on the hard floor. Some of the other kids pushed passed him as they took their places. A few glanced his way, in case something interesting was happening.

“And are you allowed white trainers in school?” demanded Mr Kelly.
action before words[ Kelly pointed at the shoes demanding. "And are you...?".

“No, sir. It’s just for today. Sorry, sir.”

“Make sure it is. I dare say even your father can’t have spent his whole giro cheque this early,” said Mr Kelly.tag-line Liam’s face paled. He stared at the table in front of him, clutching at his bag.
NEW LINE.. Liam's face
“Afraid so.” Liam’His voice voice carried over the sudden silence in the classroom. “He spent it all on your wife last night.” Mr Kelly stood up.

“What did you say?” His voice was dangerously quiet.
NEW LINE Mr Kelly stood up. His voice was Dangerously quiet. "What did you say?"

“And you know what?” Liam pushed his chair back and stood up, locking eyes with the teacher. “He said she was well worth his last fifty quid.”

“Why you—get out!” Mr Kelly pointed, straight-armed, at the door, his hand shaking. “Get out of my classroom!”

Liam snatched at his bag and walked out, head up, looking straight at the door in front of him. Thirty pairs of eyes watched him go.
no space.. it's still Liam
“See you, kids,” said Liam, waving theatrically as he left. Mr Kelly shouted at him to wait.
N-L Mr Kelly shouted...
Outside, a large hand gripped his shoulder, fingers pressing against his collar bone. He tried to shrug it off. The hand gripped tighter. Hot breath assaulted his ear.

“The Head’s office,” said Mr Kelly. “Now.”T-L we know who is saying it



The Head watched Liamdelete Liam from across the walnut table, his fingers pressed together in a pyramid shape. Liam waited for him to say something. His chair was plastic, sharp, and uncomfortable, and the room was too hot. Liam’s upper legs itched, chafed by his cheap school pants.

“It’s settled then: two weeks’ suspension,” said the Head, “starting next Monday. I will inform your father.” He picked up the phone and rattled the file in front of him. “I can’t seem to find-“
T-L.. we know who's saying it

“We haven’t got a phone,” said Liam. The Head paused and looked at him for a moment. Liam looked back.

“Ah,” said the Head. T-L He took a fountain pen and started to write.

Liam sighed and looked out of the window into a little courtyard. There was a tree in the middle— Liamhe didn’t know what kind— with its leaves floating from the branches, settling into golden piles on the concrete. The tree was surrounded, trapped even, by the school’s cheap, flat-roofed buildings. It was bare of ivy, nests, or any other obvious signs of life.

“Here.” The Head’s voice brought Liam’s attention back into the room. He took the paper being held out to him. “There’s a reply slip on the bottom,” said the Head. “Make sure you return it tomorrow.”
have him take the slip at the start of the next line
“Yes, sir,” said Liam. T-L It was a relief to leave the office. LiamHe zipped up his coat and set off for his next class, hunched against the cold. He glanced back at the tree. All but a few leaves were fallen now.



Liam gave his dad the letter that evening. Jimmy sat in his chair, holding the page at arm’s length with one hand as he read, idly scratching Buster’s ears with the other. When he finished, Jimmy lowered the letter onto his lap.When he finished, ne lowered 'it' onto
no space.. no T-L
“Jesus,” he said. “What’s wrong with you?”

Liam didn’t answer. He was looking at the dog; at the collar around its neck. It was black leather, inlaid with copper studs. And it was new.
no space
“I can’t afford school shoes, but you can buy Buster a new collar?” he said.T-L

“You don’t need school shoes,” said Jimmy. T-L “Not for the next two weeks.”

“You spend money on a dog and let me buy my own shoes?” said Liam.T-L

“That’s not the point.”

“It bloody well is!” Liam was shouting now. “Ever since Mum died-“

“Don’t give me that!” snapped Jimmy. “Buster’s the only reason I’ve had for getting up every day since then. He deserves a collar.” He shook the letter at Liam. “Think you deserve anything?”

Liam turned away from Jimmyhim and wiped at his eyes. His whole body shook. He took a deep breath; staring at the wall, he said: “You were with the dog when you should’ve been with her.” He heard his dad get up, heard the footsteps coming towards him. He half turned round; the blow caught him on the cheek. LiamHe crashed against the wall and slid to the floor. new lineJimmy loomed over him.
no space.. no T-L
“Get out,” said Jimmy. “Get out of my house.”



Liam spent the night at Steve’s, nursing his face. Steve had been his best friend since primary school. His parents were used to having Liam over, and didn’t mention the black eye during breakfast. Steve’s mother bustled around the table while Steve and Liam sat down to eat their cornflakes. 'Steve had been' is 'telling'.. let this be in Liam's thoughts

Steve's mother bustled around the table as 'they' sat down to eat “I hear you’re going rabbitting today,”delete she said.and Liam nodded. “I’m not a fan of it myself. It all seems so cruel,” she continued, “but Steve and his dad both love it. At least they’re spending time together, a bit of father and son time. Oh.” She caught herself too late and looked anxiously at Liam.

“Mum,” said Steve.

“Right,” she said. She caught her hip on the table as she hurried from the room. Liam carried on eating his cereal.

After breakfast, they went up to Steve’s bedroom. Liam sat on a swivel chair, rifle in hand, while Steve changed into what he called his “hunting gear”: combat pants, khaki top, and deerstalker hat, like he was declaring war on the rabbits.

“That isn’t loaded, right?” asked Steve. Liam didn’t answer; just sat staring out the window.
N L.. Liam didn't

“You see your backyard from there?” asked Steve.T-L “You ready? We’ll be off soon.”

“Yeah,” said Liam. {c:blueT-L} He checked his watch. It was almost noon.

As Steve went downstairs to talk with his parents, Liamhe saw his own back door swing open. Buster bounded out and circled the yard, sniffing at everything. He reached the gate and cocked a leg. Liam swung the rifle so that it rested on the window. Below him, Buster started to pee. LiamHe watched himdelete him through the sight until another movement caught his eye. Jimmy was standing in the doorway, watching Buster, one of his roll-ups hanging from his mouth. Liam focused on him; the rifle pointed at Jimmy’shis chest.

Liam calmly shut one eye. He breathed out, squeezing the trigger. The rifle clicked.
suggest.. Calmly shutting one eye, he breathed out squeezing...
no space.. no T-L

“Bang,” he said. “You’re dead.”

Below, his dad went back inside. LiamHe leaned the rifle against the wall and went to find his friend.

as I said, thease are only 'my' suggestions

just bob... GPs to offset auto-rew
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
54
54
Review of Rift  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi... very intresting concept.... only one typo? egad... good job.

[ I had no knowledge of where the rift led to but I had seen many] 'to' is redundant.. not bad, but unnecessary

[I grasped his hand in mine and heaved and pulled]... 'in mine' is also redundant.. 2 'ands'

[They were only metres away now and ]... meters

[their eyes consumed me and in a second I ceased to be.].... Ah?? then who's telling the story?

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
55
55
Rated: E | (4.5)
Well said, but probibly falling on deaf ears... votes cost money, and the alcohol lobby has scads of it.

We could take the 'Anti-Gun' idiots approach.... BAN CARS... no more drunk drivers... And the best part? Unlike guns, the lawbreakers couldn't hide the cars under their coat.

just bob
56
56
Review of Just a Farmer  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Brillient... Thanks for making my day.

BUT... (you knew there'd be one)
[oohed and aahed and begged.]... oohed, aahed, and
[ tried and tried, ].. delete the 2nd tried, for a smoother read


just bob.. feel free to throw rocks at me for messing with your poem..."grinnn"
GPs to offset auto reward
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

57
57
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Intresting article... I found no fault in the writing.
Do wish you'd use indents though... it's so easy, and looks better... nevermind the fact it SHOULD be indented.

Now a personal comment......
My wife was on my ins. at work... why? Because we were married.
She was a dediction on my Income Tax. Why? You guessed it.. good job.
She was on my SS and Medicare. Why?... Oh-my... we were married.

Good thing, because I would have never been able to pay those Dr. & Hosp. bills.
Who would have picked up the tab??? Tax-payers... YOU!! Think about that one.

I don't care if George marries Sam.. I could care less... Why does it bother you?
Now if they were marrired, George's ins. could cover Sam... Not YOUR taxes.

So does it affect you? It could, but not if they were married.
BTW... It's mostly you guys... bible thumpers... that prevents them from getting married.

just..straight.. bob
58
58
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hi.
This looks like it could be an intresting story. It has a few problems... (ones I used to make before WDC reviewers pounded lumps on my head)
1st is the repitition of names. Once named, just he/she will do. Your reader will know who 'she' is.
2nd... at times the double space leaves the reader wondering who spoke the line. (remember.. no dbl-sp between the action and the words.. [She turned to him and snapped, "Not now.] This not only tells the reader who's speaking, but 'how' they sound.
3rd.. View Point shifts. There should be a clear seperation when you go to anothers VP. I find it best to avoid the dbl-spaces, and just use an indent between lines spoken by the other. Then when you do put a dbl-sp, the reader is warned it will be in anothers VP. The VP character must be named in the first line so the reader knows who's eyes were looking through.
The VP character can never 'know' what the other is thinking... only guess. Only the VP character can 'think' about what the other said.
Egad... I'm starting to sound like that English teacher I didn't listen to... "grinnn"

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
59
59
Review of Truth Or Dare  
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hi... welcome to WDC
As you asked.... A few thoughts
(I've learned more on WDC than I did in Creative Writing Class)(my stuff is 'almost' good now)


(friends were walking home from school. They were playing Truth Or Dare,)... 'were..were'
better... [While walking home, Angle and her frends were playing...]

(The rest of the girls including Angel )... including Angle, is redundant... we know she's included

( went into the shop went by the sweets and they put loads of sweets and crisps into their school bags.)... repitition.. 'went'...'sweets'
[ went into the shop to the sweets isle, and loaded their school bags with goodies.]

( they had lots of party food now but no-one knew they were stealing so they ran out of the shop and all their parents were there and the police.)... Cap T on [ They had lots of party food now'.' 'Thinking no one knew they were steaing, they ran out of the shop '.' They were wrong, because they were met by the police, and their parents had been called.]

(police station and they gave all the party food to the police and they gave it back to the shop keeper.)
[... to the police, who gave it back to the shop keeper.] ' the they' refers to the girls, not the police.

(and Dadstold them)... 'Dads told'

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1196643 by Not Available.

60
60
Review of Bad Girl  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
This is also very good..... but
Some lines seem to have too many words for a smooth read..(cadence)
Just a few thoughts... go ahead and throw rocks at me for messing with your poem.

(she turned and pressed her)...[turned, pressing]
(that she found this a source of some satisfaction.)...
[She found... or... of satisfaction.]
(wouldn’t cause hurt.)... [so it wouldn't hurt.]
(She nuzzled me and whispered )... [whispering, "......]

just bob
61
61
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Very well said.
Too bad the 'antis' will not listen.

I'm still looking for that section of The Bill of Rights, that states. "Equal Rights For All... unless you're gay"

My wife was on my Medical Ins. from work, then on my SS and Medicare. Plus she was listed as a dependent on my Tax Returns. Should not 'every domestic partner' deserve the same?

Get over it you gay bashers..... vote 'yes'... Equal Rights.... for ALL

just bob... didn't look at spelling.."grinnn"
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
62
62
Rated: E | (4.0)
Very good. Rhyming words all worked well.
A few lines seemed to have too many words, but overall, well done.

One comment on the theme... George W. is 'not' running.
You think he was bad? Just wait. If Obama wins... "shudder"... you may want to start composing an ode to him.

just bob
63
63
Review of Back  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi.
Intresting story.
I 'must' thank you for 'not' filling this with needless he/she said tag-lines. (that was the first thing I noticed)
Also, you didn't use the annoying dbl-spaces most on WDC *** use. Thank you for that.

I will do a 'line edit', but in private e-mail, so your story will not be shown in total, on the Public Review Page.

just bob... GPs to offset the Auto-Reward

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
64
64
Review of The Climb  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hi.
Welcome to the 'Group' and WDC.
This is a very good poem... thoughts and emotion clearly expressed.

I hate to mess with someone's poem... but

(ar above now, and growing farther.
and my only chance to joy is fading fast.).. I would suggest delete the 'and' on this line.

(but now it slows beneath me again,
and I am caught, but not in darkness.)... Here the first 'but', plus 'and' could be removed.

just a thought from bob... feel free to throw rocks at me
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
65
65
Rated: E | (4.5)
Very good article... well written.
Some flawed 'facts' but overall good.

A note... This is more of a rant, than a rev. delete 'now' if you wish.

(Alas, we need to make our voices heard about our concerns and demand that they put into effect conservation laws. It is necessary to follow through with checking to make sure that our current leaders are doing everything they can humanly do to make sure that these policies are created, presented, passed and adhered to, by enforcing these laws to the fullest extent of said law.)

(. We need to buy products that are locally produced instead of going the cheap and easy route of environmentally unsafe imports.)...Our laws 'are' strictly enforced.... by idiots
2 examples...
The Chem. Co. I worked for had a very elaborate..and expensive to operate.. vapor recovery system.
The EPA... ( or is that EDA... economic distruction agency) was right there soon after every power failure to check our output of airborne chemicals. Just slightly over the limit, and it was a 50,000 $ fine.
Even though in normal operation it was 0 output, When 'not' in operation, the vapor recovery system still had to be running... thousands of $ per year for empty tanks... or 50,000 fine.
We couldn't operate... we couldn't show it was only a few hrs a year that we lost any vapor, because the idiots checking were only intrested in fining** us whenever possible..(that's why they hit us after power failures... they knew they could catch us 'poluters' and look good to their superiors)
...plant CLOSED... production went overseas... no EPA no Vapor Recovery Systems.. no regulations.
The vapors we used to trap, are now being spewed into the air, while American workers sit in un-inployment lines... good job EPA The 3rd world loves 'ya.
** fining us.. hinting about a bribe, or if the bribe was insufficient?
2nd example...
Co Son workes for. EPA demanded they install a multi thousand $ vapor recovery system over the insole/outsole glueing machine.... THEN they outlawed the glue... but not in China... guess what?
Yea... the boots still have glued soles...that they buy from China (no resrictions...same glue... just not American workers)

The reason ALL tennis shoes are made in China and Banbladesh, is IT'S Illeagle to make them here. They must be vulconized (heated under pressure) and that causes fumes... easy to recover with the machinery sitting unused in closed American plants. Great job EPA... why don't you outlaw beans? That smelly fart is sulfides of hydrogen... think of the air you could clean up... not in Mexico though... sorry.

An oil well operator is fined... you guessed it... $50K if they spill a gallon of oil while loading trucks... meanwhile State Trucks spray Thousands of gallons of used motor oil on the dirt roads to keep the dust down.. that makes sence... I guess. wouldn't want the tax-payers complaining about dust this close to election time.

just bob... sorry for the rant. We need intelligent inspectors, not more laws. And intelligent Senitors making the laws, instead of the clowns in there now.
66
66
Rated: E | (4.5)
Commas, make your words sound like you, want them to sound.
If you hear a pause, that's a comma.
The rules are not set in stone. Or you could say: the rules are, not, set in stone.
A longer pause... is like that.
Placement of the comma, can change the meaning of the line.
[ "We really don't want to do that."] .. simple statment
["We, really, don't want to do that."] .. bad things may happen if we do
["We really don't, want, to do that."] .. but we will if we have to

just... bob
67
67
Rated: 18+ | (2.5)
Intresting concept.

I see a few problems... easy to fix.

( previous life? well it's just sort of speak i guess but i always said that i was a Hippy...)Well just sort of speak?? I guess, but I always...

(my friends-family's best interest, )friends / family's best intrest'.'
suggest... new line..[ Taking pride in helping others as well, is what I do for a living.]

Don't forget the Caps when you write..... (from an old hippy, let me say,'it wasn't that great'.)

My past life? Hummm... I have a fuzzy recollection of a hot day... Looking around, I saw a wagon hooked to me, and someone was hitting me with a whip. Nah... couldn't be... or???

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
68
68
Review of Anguished  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi...
Very good... it is easy to follow the action in the stage directions.
A few omissions... and a questionable line.
I will do a 'Private' line edit under seperate cover so it won't be on the public rev. page.

Also, I'm sending GPs to offset the 'auto-reward'

bob
69
69
Review of THE MEMORIAL WALL  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Great poem, and a wonderful tribute.
I can offer no improvment.
I would love to see it.... "sigh"

Never met an Aussy I didn't like.

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
70
70
Review of Not titled yet  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi Carol. Sorry for the delay.. thunder storms kept me off-line.

Vrey intresting start.... Well written.
I spotted a few problems... some are only my view, so don't throw rocks at me.


(Tomorrow the semi-annual run of cargo ships bringing minerals and rotating crew back from the moon would begin only when they returned to the moon they would be filled with those that were leaving.)...
suggest... [... from the moon would 'arrive.' Only when they returned 'this time,' they would be filled with those^ leaving. ]

( Except for the barest twinkling of the stars that could be attributed to natural phenomena )...
In space they don't twinkle... that's an 'atmospheric' phenomenon.

( "According to the computer we have been in stasis for twelve hundred years," she replied her voice trembling.
"There has to be a mistake," he retorted.
"No mistake," Liam said from behind the Captain, "we aren't even in any space that is known to us.")...
This is only a personal feeling, but I really hate tag-lines. We know he asked a question, and to whome. Now we could 'hear' that trembling voice if you put the action before the words. We are in his View-Point.
          [ Her voice trembled a bit. "According to the computer......."
          "There has to be a mistake."
          Liam came up behind the Captain. "No mistake. We aren't even in..."]


( to find a planet they could colonize. Just another secret to keep he thought as he steered the ship towards a planet )...
Repitition... [,, towards 'one' ]

(fit what they needed and there were no signs of life except animal and vegetation.)
there were... passive... consider [ what they needed'.' They had detected no signs of life, except...]

(Liam watched as they achieved orbit and ran more scans before they woke the first group that would go down. "Looks like we can send the scouts down," he said.
"Very well, wake the scouts and send them down. If all is good then send down the workers to start the building then we'll wake the last of them." Armstrong ordered.
"When do you want to send down the cargo and livestock?" Kyla asked.
"When the workers go down," Armstrong replied )...
Classic example of why tag-lines are bad... confusing even to the reader.
(1) we know it was Liam, so 'he said' is unnecessary. We know he is speaking to the Captain, (2) so 'Armstrong replied' is also unnecessary. HOWEVER... Kila jumped tnto the conversation with a question, but the reader didn't know it was her untill the "yuck" tag-line. (3) If we knew it was her..up front.. then we see the '?' We know by the words and question mark that she 'asked'.
ALSO... repitition ... [ send the scouts down... wake the scouts and send them down... If all is good then send down the workers to start the building then we'll wake the last of them." .. tag-line.. Armstrong ordered... ]


just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
71
71
Review of The Fall - Ch 1  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi...
Intresting start.
I did notice a lot of repitition.

(. So for the most part it only ran for about 10 hours every week. He ran it long enough for the clothes to be dried each week, and when the sun was out he didn’t even use the dryer, )...
sugg...
[..every week; just long enough for the clothes to be dryed, and if the sun was out, not even then.]

( well water that was filtered enough to drink and had enough pressure to keep running water, )..
..[keep it running]

(the 500 gallon propane tank..opposite side as the propane tank...The cabin had..The walls of the cabin...In the shed out back.. The shed was about 30 yards from)..
By grouping these thoughts, you can avoid repitition.
ie.. while mentioning the tank, you could say 'it' was opposite the shed 'where he kept the' Polaris..

( He reached the hill that overlooked the stream and sat down underneath the overhang that gave him a view of both banks of the stream.)..
[..both banks.]

Some of the descriptions are not necessary to the story.. he would not be thinking about the interior of his cabin.. if he brings someone else in, they may mention it. And the placement of the shed? Do we really need to know that? Otherwise 'unless it's necessary' cut it. You can always bring it in later, but a large 'info-dump' distracts your reader.

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
72
72
Review of infertility pain  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Very good...
The emotion is shown well...
However
The spaces between lines makes it more difficult to read, and it should be punctuated (.)

personal note... from personal experence
There are so many kids that need a good home.. consider it. If you think the love won't be the same... YOU'RE WRONG.

just bob
73
73
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hi...
The disjointeed nature of this works only if you point out 'up front' the nature of it. (not in a footnote)

Without knowing the reason, a reader stumbles over the words, and how they're arranged, rather than feeling the message.
Re-reading it 'after' the footnote, I could feel the impact of them much better.
The one thing that jumped out at me was this line
(Like Toxic,)..? .. possibly 'like a toxicant.'

just a thought from... bob
74
74
Review of The Golden Door  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi Bill...
Intresting story. Well written..... but

The constant repitition of 'Duncan'.

Once named, just 'he/him/his'... except at the start of a new paragraph with 2 in the scene, then the first to speak must be named.
also...(think about this) when you are conversing with one person, do you call him by name each time you speak?
(“Duncan, you know how important this is -- )
"John, should we get out of here?" or "Let's get out of here."... John knows who you're talking to.

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
75
75
Rated: ASR | (3.5)
Hi... very intresting story [btw.. I'm a believer]

a few thoughts


(Tucked back in a quiet residential neighborhood on...) this is a 68 wd. sentence... consider breaking it up into 3?? for an easer read.
I also suggest putting a dbl-space between paragraphs.

(light come from somewhere in the dense clouds before disappearing back into.).. suggest..[disappearing.]


normally in a story, all numbers 'except dates' are spelled out... twenty.. not 20. this rule is 'not' carved in stone, just expected in most fiction.

(hit the shower. The shower's steam...) (even if it did mean sleeping alone...hated sleeping by myself,... I usually slept when I was alone... I'd learned to sleep in the light when alone...) (where the noise had been coming from...The noise had stopped) ( Frozen in apperant surprise that I had managed to sit up both were frozen...)
All above are examples of 'repitition'.
Always avoid repeting any word if possible... they sort of jump out at the reader.

consider checking out the 'Novel Workshop..Landing Pad'
"Invalid Item and if intrested, sign up via--
"Invalid Item tell 'um bob sent 'ya.

just bob
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
190 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 8 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/robertholt/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3