*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/vzabel/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/sort_by_last/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/10
Review Requests: OFF
1,385 Public Reviews Given
1,714 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 6 7 8 9 -10- 11 12 13 14 15 ... Next
226
226
Review of Melted Butter  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
*Reading* Ahhh, a real love story. I enjoyed this very much. Of course I know some readers wouldn't understand that a person's perspective can change that quickly, but we both know that it can happen, and does.

*Idea* What does a wide open tire wrench look like? I guess I've never even heard of a tire wrench.

*Idea* In the following the single quotation mark should be before the question mark, with the double quotes after the question mark, as you have it: “Did you say, ‘melted butter?’" "Did you say, 'melted butter'?"

*Flower1* I did enjoy this story very much.

Viv
227
227
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*Snow1* Oh, how true - a baby is a life changing experience and a test of a couple's love. You put this into your storeom so well.

*Snow2* Writing things that happen in the past compared to other places in a writing in present tense, then things afterwards in present tense, confuses. I don't care of most things written in present tense anyway, but in this work, it doesn't work for me at all.

*Snow3* Again, you present the reader with truth in rhyme.

Viv
228
228
Review of In The Past  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*Reading* This free verse contains soooo much truth that I can feel it. Oh, guess I can feel it because I'm living it. *Laugh*

*Idea* I'm sure you repeated "past" as often as you did for effect, but some places the word just seemed repetitively uncomfortable.

*Idea* I learned that numbers under 100 should be written as words in literary items.

*Flower1* Thanks for putting into words what too many of us already know.

Viv
229
229
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*Laugh* I'll have to say I enjoyed this humorous verse. I think if I were he, though, I'd become a bachelor for sure.

*Idea* A comma shouldn't be used to set off a clause or phrase that is needed for the meaning of the sentence. For example, in the following line, a comma isn't needed to set off the phrase:
I ate a goodly portion, by cleaning up the loom.

*Smile* This was enjoyable.

Viv

230
230
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Reading* This article has some interesting material and information.

*Idea* I let my twelve-year-old grandson read it today, and he found it rather below his reading and interest level as written. He said it was for "a little kid." The grandson in second grade thought it was great.

*Idea* As an Enlgish teacher I would suggest it be written in regular essay style rather broken up with the sub-titles and numbers.

*Idea* Too many exclimation points distracts from the writting.

*Smile* You give younger children information to help them understand the purpose of trees.

sig by Pass It On

231
231
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Reading* I can feel the sorrow, the loss in this poem, but I can also sense the peace and hope. Watching a loved one slowly die is difficult, tearing a hole in the heart of the one waiting.

*Reading* I like the way you end the poem on a note of hope, the hope we have that life doesn't end when a person moves from this relm.

sig by Pass It On
232
232
Review of Thomas' Pain  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*reding* You took the prompt and turned into an interesting and ironically funny story. I enjoyed the twist at the end very much, but I like stories with twists.

*Idea* Periods and commas should go inside the end quotation marks, not inside. At the first of the story, you put them outside, and then you change them inside as required.

sig by Pass It On
233
233
Review of The Old Boyfriend  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*Snow1* This is a wonderfully loving love story. I like the message and the ending very much.

*Idea* To strengten this, you might want to avoid using to be helping verbs when possible. For example, The rain started as I was reaching inside my mailbox. You might rewrite "The rain started as I reached inside my mailbox."

*Idea* Titles of magazines should be italicized rather than in quotation marks.
234
234
Review of The Fire  
Review by Vivian
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
*Snow1* This story has wonderful glimpses of scenery and detail. The concept of the story is excellent, holding much promise. The idea of online romance is very valid and modern.

*Idea* I'm left feeling as if only part of the story is here. More is needed about the meeting, why they didn't connect in person, maybe more about how their relationship developed online.

*Snow2* If you revise, add to the story, please let me know. I'd like to re-evaluate this item.

Viv
235
235
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Snow1* A rather unusual poem from you, Harry, but it's entertaining. You really get into alliteration with Big Bad Black Bart and a unique rhyming of every line except one (and it was a sort of rhyme).

*Snow2* You manage to tell a complete story in your verses as usual. Very good.

*Idea* The last line of the first stanza doesn't really rhyme with the other lines since it's plural. If you could use part rather than parts, you would have the rhyme.

sig by Pass It On
236
236
Review of Dear God  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Reading* This poem has such a powerful message that my heart is touched. You use poetic language and rhyme to write a soul searching prayer.

*Idea* A few places the sentence structure needs work because you have fragments that don't add to the poem but distract. For example, in the following lines, you really have just one sentence:
Please take my hand.
Bring me to You.
So I'll be surrounded
By all that is true.

You need to eleminate the period after You.

*Idea*Paid is the correct spelling rather than payed.

*Smile* Thank you for sharing this moving prayer in poetry form with us.

sig by Pass It On
237
237
Review of Why Bother???  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Reading* Yes! Your article is soooo right on. (Excuse the slang, but the idea of someone addressing this problem excites me.) You expressed the problem clearly and kindly. I hope that people who write disparaging descriptions of their own work will read this article and take careful note.

*Star* You use correct grammar and punctuation as far as I could tell as I enjoyed your writing. Your tone is more conversational than formal, but that fits the need of your audience.

sig by Pass It On
238
238
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Reading* Okay, you present your position very clearly and honestly. Anyone who doesn't understand is in deep mental difficulties. (And I can't spell tonight, please forgive me.)

*Idea* The only suggestion I have is to avoid so many commas before conjunctions that don't join independent clauses.

*Smile* Oh, you may review any of my items that you want to read.

sig by Pass It On
239
239
Review of Rhapsody In Blue  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Flower1* You have matched a priceless photo with a poem that really matches the imagery of words with the visual imagery of the picture.

*Flower2* I can't find anything to change or to suggest revisions. Both the writing and the photo go together wonderfully well.

*Flower3* Thank you for sharing.

sig by Pass It On
240
240
Review of The Sandy Shore  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Reading* The imagery of this poem takes the reader right down to the sea shore. Lovely, lovely work.

*Idea* The only suggestions I would make concern punctuation. There are some places that need commas, and at least one stanza needs a verb to avoid having it be a long sentence fragment.

Commas could be added at the ends of lines 1 and 11.

In the last stanza, a quick revision idea will help. Please know that this is just one possible way (please note the punctuation, too):

How peaceful this scene,
The hazy air soon turns crystal clear,
An artist’s conception of a wonderful dream,
A priceless treasure to behold
When painting at the sandy shore.
241
241
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Ah, Harry. First of all, Happy Birthday! *Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3*

*Reading* You do cover a lot of ground and time in this poem, but you do so with your usual flair to detail and poetic imagery.

*Idea* One line seems a bit awkward: I have a step-son – being a good step-parent is the hardest job I know of

I know you ended the line with "of" for the rhyme, but, to me, it seems to stop the flow.

*Balloon1* Again, Happy Birthday *Balloon4*





242
242
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Okay, can I just copy and paste my last review, for the section before this? The saga continues, and the reader is left wanting to know how it ends.

*Idea* Okay, why can't you make mistakes like the rest of us mortals?

sig by Pass It On



243
243
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Reading* Okay, Harry, I'll admit I read all the parts of this continuing saga before I started reviewing this section. I had to know how it all tied together and ended. You keep the story going and the suspense building with this chapter.

*Idea* Okay, except for the continuing use of first person, which you kept consistent, I have no ideas for improvement.

sig by Pass It On
244
244
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Reading* You have many valid truths in this p;oem. I like the repetition of "What did you do to me?" but you might want to use it a bit less often.

*Idea* I owuld like to see some poetic language and/or maybe some peotic devices used. For instance, My fears have disappeared like fog beneath sunshine.

*Idea* After each "What did you do to Me" there should be a question mark.

*Idea* Writing the title in all capitals makes it seem that you're yelling at the reader. You might want just to capitalize the first letter of the main words of the title (don't capitalize the, an, and, if, etc, unless the first word in the title).

*Idea* This is just a suggestion: You might want to ask the question and then give a couple of the answers before asking it again.

*Smile* You have the foundation for good poetry.

sig by Pass It On
245
245
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Reading* So the saga continues, good. I like your warrior and hopes he finds some happiness in his life soon. I am enjoying your multiple chapters in his life.

*Idea* I still do not like the changing of tenses while writing. It disrupts the flow of the poem, of the reading. The mind recognizes that it's not correct.

So I have to take off for something that is so grammatically wrong, sorry.

sig by Pass It On
246
246
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Reading* Ah, the continuing story in poetry I see.
What new adventures can there be?
A damsel in distress, no less,
joins the brave one in his quest.

I enjoy your stories in poetry form.

*Idea* One thing bothers me, though, the switching of verb tense. You start in past tense, then switch to present. I don't care for the present tense much anyway, but the switching really isn't something I like.

*Smile* So the story will continue more, I assume? Good, then I'm off to read the next chapter.

sig by Pass It On
247
247
Review by Vivian
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Reading* As usual, Harry, you manage to write a whole story in verse, and use rhyme while doing it. Amazing, absolutely amazing.

*Reading* Hmmm . . . I can't seem to find anything to suggest or find any errors or . . . Come on there has to be something that needs revising or changing or something.

medium size
248
248
Review of Sunset  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Reading* This poem has the concepts needed for a very, very good one. The beach, the ocean, a loved one all combine to make an excellent love poem.

*Idea* Your title (which by the way doesn't really need to be all caps, does it? I feel as if I'm being yelled at *Smile*) states the poem is about suset, and the last stanza talks about sunset, yet the first verse says you're waiting for the sun to rise. I'm confused.

*Idea* In the second stanza, I'm left thinking you look to see the sunset's face and remember why you fell in love with the sunset. I know that's not right, but the only noun before the pronoun her is sunset. You might want to change the wording a bit, maybe to something like

*green* I see the sunset come
and look at my love's beautiful face.
Now I remember
why I fell in love with her.
I also corrected some punctuation in that.

*Smile* Love is such a hard subject for a poem because of the clichés, but you did a credible job.

sig by Pass It On
249
249
Review of Of Angels Wings  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Flower4* The repetition of the phrase "angels' wings" ties this whole poem together. I like the way you use it to show the different stages of life.

*Flower3* I coudln't find anything I would want to change aobut this poem. It's lovely just the way it is.
250
250
Review of The Perfect Poem  
Review by Vivian
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Flower4* I like the use of questions in this poem. Their use works in this case.

*Flower3* I assume the perfect poem you want is for the one you love, the perfect love poem. Am I correct?

*Flower4* You have many very good poems. I'm impressed. Good job.
504 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 21 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/vzabel/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/sort_by_last/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/10