*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/elle/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/6
Review Requests: OFF
562 Public Reviews Given
612 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I generally give an overview of the item, then point out any corrections, suggestions or highlight favourite lines. I am a captain of the "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group. See my reviews below for examples.
I'm good at...
Proofreading and catching typos, spelling mistakes and incorrect grammar.
Favorite Genres
Romance, fantasy
Least Favorite Genres
Horror
Favorite Item Types
Poetry.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 3 4 5 -6- 7 8 ... Next
126
126
Review of The Wishing Place  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | N/A (Review only item.)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi Nikola,
I found your poem via the Random Review tool.

It's a beautiful little poem. I really enjoyed reading it. The rhythm and flow is perfect and I can't think of any suggestions for improvement.

I like the reference to 'misty spirits' and 'mossy hiding place'. I also particularly liked the dancing sunbeams. *Smile*

Thanks for sharing!
Elle
127
127
Review of The ANZAC Spirit  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


I'm reviewing your poem as one of the judges of the "Invalid Item contest. Please note that I'm only one of two judges, so my opinion isn't the final say. *Smile*

Your poem says all that I wanted an entry to say - it speaks of the horrors of war, the ANZAC spirit, the bravery of the soldiers and that we should honour and respect them now. I couldn't have said it better myself. No, really, I couldn't, and I am VERY impressed at your skill with words. This is an excellent entry, and I really enjoyed reading it.

Even hell could not compare the trenches, gas and mud,
And fires of damnation drowned them in their blood.

Those two lines didn't work well for me. I think I read them too literally! How does one drown in fire? *Smile*

It's impossible to pick a favourite line or even a favourite verse. I tried to and thought 'I like verse 5, verse 6, verse 7 and verse 8, but 9 and 10 are good too.' *Laugh*

Excellent work and thanks so much for entering the contest.
Elle
128
128
Review of The War We Won  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi SoLost ,
I'm reviewing your poem as a judge for the "Invalid Item contest. Please note that I am one of two judges, so my opinion isn't the final say. *Smile*

I really enjoyed some parts of your poem, and others I found a little depressing. War is never a pleasing topic of course, but I got the impression from your poem that you felt we forgot the price our soldiers paid. To me, ANZAC Day is all about remembering the price they paid.

The third stanza was my favourite. The lines 'drowning in the infinite abysmal sea' and 'some moaning wind, ever fading in the mind' are beautiful. Sad and haunting, but beautiful nonetheless.

I also liked '“Goodbye, brave soldiers,” mumbled those left standing' and the word mumbled is a perfect choice there, it gives a real mood to the line.

It was 'With the help of the losers we left out there' that bothered me the most, and I feel uncomfortable with the word loser. I'm not sure if you did that deliberately or not.

A great entry and I really appreciate you participating in the contest.
Elle

129
129
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with P.E.N.C.I.L.  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Pencil* A "P.E.N.C.I.L. Review *Pencil*


*Bursto* Note: As a reviewer, I only offer my opinion, hoping you will find it useful: you decide what to keep or throw away! *Smile*

We get a lot more background information on the character in this chapter, and the budding relationship between the two main characters makes good progress. Once again, we have some major issues with telling instead of showing, particularly in regards to Christina's background and teaching. It's a lot of information just thrown at the reader, not really woven into the story. You might hear people call that an 'infodump', which tells you how common it is - they've got a name for it! *Laugh* It's hard to get the balance right, but there's definitely too much information being given to the reader in one big chunk, instead of little snippets here and there. As well as holding your reader at a distance, it slows the pace of a story quite dramatically. If you can keep the reader in the 'present' for 90% of the story, and show instead of tell, they'll start to care for your character and cheer her on.

I'll point out any errors or other suggestions for improvement below, but it's not a matter of fixing a few words. You need to take out everything that's not happening NOW and just weave bits of it back in as the story goes along. And the NOW story needs to be shown instead of told. If you want to write about some of her students, you need to take the reader into the classroom and show us her interaction with her students, instead of just telling us about them. I know, I'm repeating myself a little, but it's the most important feedback I can give you as a reader/reviewer. I'm not saying that the plot isn't good or isn't worth telling - I'm just trying to help you tell the story in a way that will win your reader over. *Smile*

I like the idea of including the emails, but suggest the ones that say 'You've received a new message' aren't necessary. Show the reader the messages Christina sends, and the ones she gets in reply, but the automated messages showing that she's received a response don't need to be written out in full. I've always loved the inclusion of letters and notes in books, especially when they're copied (not typed in as part of the story) or even placed in envelopes for the reader to take out. So keep the personal emails, just not the automated ones.

*Cut*"Inacreditável!" she though and this is what she read:*Cut*
You're missing the t on the end of 'thought'. Also, it would probably be helpful to have some way of letting the reader know what that meant, although we can assume it means 'incredible' or similar.
You could probably get away without 'this is what she read' and just put the email afterwards - we can deduce that she's reading it too.

*Cut*Somehow, she had slept 9 hours non-stop. Like as if she was free.*Cut*
This doesn't tie in with the first sentence which tells us that she woke up earlier than normal. You could remove this sentence altogether and just extend the first one to say 'Christina woke up earlier than usual, refreshed from a surprisingly restful night's sleep, and went straight to her computer to check for new messages.' Something like that.

*Cut*Also, she wanted to keep this treasure, this feeling of success, this h-o-p-e thing to linger on during the day, until she returned home later that night.*Cut*
That line gets her enthusiasm and excitement across to the reader. Good work!

*Cut*She was a free spirit and had always been one maybe because she was a GEMINI.
She never believed in astrology, though.*Cut*

Those two sentences contradict themselves. Either she believes in astrology and thinks that being a Gemini (which doesn't need to be all in capitals) has something to do with it, or she doesn't believe and it doesn't need to be mentioned.

*Cut*As a Wicca she was a lonely, solitary and good "witch" but she honestly hated cats, especially black cats.*Cut*
This idea of Christina being lonely and solitary doesn't seem to fit with the idea of an 'outgoing' person who 'loves to help and make a difference in other people's lives'. How can such an energetic and enthusiastic person be described as lonely and solitary? Perhaps you need to explain this to your reader, or show us what you mean.

*Cut*She was a dog lover (and a canary lover, a small, green and yellow turtle lover, a Beta fish lover, an orchid lover and she respected little spiders very much).*Cut*
The spider comment made me laugh, but a list like this could be delivered in quite a different way. Let us see the turtle, the fish and the orchids in her apartment as the story goes. Perhaps she talks to the turtle or the fish?

*Cut*She knew that traffic would be terrible at this time in Brasilia but she would listen to Dire Straits and probably arrive home earlier.*Cut*
I'm confused. Why would she arrive home earlier because she listened to Dire Straits? Or is she arriving home early because she has no afternoon class? If that's the case, it doesn't need mentioning, we can deduce that ourselves. I do like the detail of the music though, which could be a great addition when showing and taking the reader from the lesson back to the apartment.

*Cut*When she got home, she took a long bath and had some wine, checked her mail - mostly bills, and appreciated the silence and sweetness of her apartment.*Cut*
As a reader, I want to know why she delayed reading her email. What was her motivation behind having a bath first? Tell me. This is a great opportunity for a scene with lots of showing (not rude showing, but letting us see the candles (or smell that cinnamon scented one you mention later!), luxuriate in the hot water, hear her explaining to her turtle why she's putting off reading the email).

*Cut*She had bought it with her own money, money given to her by her Dad and that she had invested so wisely, not her Brazilian diplomat Dad but her American Dad that died because of the 9/11.*Cut*
You can't just casually mention something like that and then carry on with the story. This is the first we've heard about her dad, but you mention it like we should know she has two dads. That's actually pretty unusual, and if you're going to let us know it, then it needs additional explanation. HOWEVER, this chapter is already way too heavy on the explanation which is overpowering the action, so I'd suggest this information isn't necessary. We don't need to know where the money to buy the apartment has come from. Most readers will assume she earned it. Is it important that we know otherwise?

*Cut*She checked her e-mail and then she carefully read about that charming man's profile:*Cut*
I'm sure he is charming, but neither Christina nor the reader know that at this point. If anything, he's probably mysterious right now!

My only comment about the profile list is that a) you need to explain those readers who have never used a dating site what is meant by an 89% match, and b) put your comment about Christina's thoughts on sailing seperately.
For instance 'Christina reviewed the list and liked what she saw. Except for the sailing, she hated sailing and threw up easily when onboard a boat of any description. Maybe that was why the site said it was an 89% match. They had most things in common, but a few differences. If they liked everything the same, presumably the site would have rated them as 100% match. Hmm, would it be a good thing to like all the same things and have no differences? Christina mused over the idea as she reviewed her own profile, refreshing her memory of what he would have read about her.'

You probably don't need to list Christina's profile in full. Some of those things we already know about her, and others we should learn through the 'showing' that needs to be done. I think the questions she asks herself afterwards are far more telling and more interesting to the reader.

The musing needs to be worded so that instead of Christina TELLING the reader what she thinks, we hear her thoughts. Would Christina think 'On her way to the USA, last year, she had seen an article in a plane magazine: "Fall in Love Again! Join eheart.com." It was a relationship site.'? Or would Christina think 'It had been a risk, signing up for that relationship site she'd seen advertised in that magazine...' Christina knows she saw the article on the plane, she would hardly 'tell' herself that. You're telling the reader, but we need to either learn it from Christina's thoughts or speech, or see it in her actions or her vision.

*Cut*And so she answered his questions with all her heart and soul. After a week of messages and after he called her in Brazil she was head over heels in love with him! In love with a man she had never touched or seen; not even imagined existed before. It wasn't a blind date or a lunch/dinner date; it was just a fantastic-pure-deep-cyberspace-interactive-self-directed-alternative-modern way-Internet love.com relationship!*Cut*
You need samples of their emails after that sentence 'And so she answered his questions with all her heart and soul.' Show us her emails to him. Show us his replies. Show us them falling in love. Because without any proof whatsoever, we go from panic, confusion, worry and determination to 'head over heels in love' and your reader simply won't believe that. Take us along on that ride. Share those emails. Share Christina's growing emotions with us. Include us in a conversation with a trusted friend or family member as she giggles over something he wrote or she panics over what he'll think of her reply. Make us want to know how he responds. Have her lie in bed, trying to sleep but unable to because her mind keeps replaying what he wrote. I would have expected this part (the part between her reply and her being in love) to be the main focus of the book/story. THIS is the romance, the falling in love. Share it with us.

I hope this feedback helps you. I think this could be a great modern romance and I sincerely hope I don't put you off sharing this story with everyone, I only want to help you tell it in the best way possible.


*NoteO* ~ Elle

*StarO* WRITE ON! *StarO*

** Image ID #1918914 Unavailable **




*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
130
130
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi Em,
I think you've got an awesome challenge here. It's complex enough to be interesting, but not so complicated that it's difficult to follow. It's well organised, has fantastic prizes and people can give their own creativity and personality to their entries.

I think the use of dropnotes in the forum is excellent - it allows the forum to remain as uncluttered as possible and yet all the information is there if it's needed.

All the information is current and up-to-date. There's nothing worse than seeing the details for a previous month and wondering if a contest is still going and what the details for the current month are. I've stopped by your forum several times and every time it has been perfectly up to date.

You've managed to find a way that basic and free users can participate, which is very generous of you. I think I'd have made it a requirement to have a blog on WDC, but you've made it so everyone can join in if they want to. That's impressive.

I like the different themes for the different days of the week - it helps to keep it interesting. I'm curious how you get so many prompts in your 'war chest'!

All in all, a fantastic challenge. I'm very impressed. You seem to have covered all the bases, and I can't think of anything you've missed.

Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image created by YellowWitch!
131
131
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with P.E.N.C.I.L.  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Pencil* A "P.E.N.C.I.L. Review *Pencil*


*Bursto* Note: As a reviewer, I only offer my opinion, hoping you will find it useful: you decide what to keep or throw away! *Smile*

*NoteB* General Comments & Reader Reaction:
This first chapter is all about the arrival of the message and Christina's reaction to it. We spend a lot of time in Christina's head, and very little 'action' takes place. We do start to get a feel for the situation and Christina's character.
This chapter is is almost entirely 'told' and not 'shown'. I'll go into that further under 'writing style' below, but there's quite a bit of work to be done there.


*NoteG* Plot & Pace:
The plot so far is that a 56yo woman has placed an ad on a dating site, and received her first reply. She is nervous, unsure that this is the best thing for her, and worried about whether she made the right choice to end her prior relationship.
The pace is slow, as we spend a lot of time in Christina's head, mulling over things. While I appreciate that receiving the reply to the ad is the 'start' of the story, this chapter possibly doesn't have the pace, drama or action to pull in a reader. I wonder if this chapter could be shortened (to speed up the pace) and merged with another chapter where more action happens. It usually pays to start a story with action, not with introspection. Readers will happily read a slower chapter like this, but not until they're hooked on the story.


*NoteO* Characters:
So far we've only met Christina. She comes across as indecisive, but willing to try new things. She is independent and doesn't rely on anyone else, but is mindful of other people's opinions, even the way strangers view her relationship with a younger man. She believes strongly in love and 'happily ever after' and is willing to take a risk to gain that for herself. So far you've done a good job with her character.

*NoteR* Setting & Imagery:
You've given us quite a lot of setting information, but it is 'told' to us, not 'shown'. Again, I'll go further into this below under 'writing style'. However, the apartment setting is good, and you include enough description that we can visualise where Christina is, and what she's doing.

*NoteB* Writing Style & Grammar:
Okay. Showing instead of telling is something that most writers struggle with, including me. It's the most common refrain in reviews - show don't tell.
Here's an example:

*Cut* It was raining heavily and it was surprisingly windy in Brasilia - DF, District Capital city of Brazil.*Cut*
Rain drummed on the roof and wind whipped against the windows of the little apartment in Brasilia.

Do you see the difference? It was raining vs rain drummed on the roof. You can tell us it was raining, or show us what was happening. Describe the rain to us so we can imagine it.


*Cut*She turned the computer off and went to her bedroom.*Cut*
How did she turn the computer off? How did she go to her bedroom? Did she dance her way to the room? Stroll? Prance? Stomp?
'She stomped to the bedroom' is quite different from 'She wandered to the bedroom', yet in both cases, she went to the bedroom. Instead of telling us, show us how she did it.
'She leaned down and pressed the button to switch the computer to sleep mode. With her mug still warm in her hand, she padded noiselessly to the bedroom.'


*Cut*She switched the TV on to watch her favorite programs and spent the day in bed because she also wanted to finish reading The Kite Runner.*Cut*
Picking up the remote, she changed the channel to her favourite talkshow and settled comfortably against the pillows to watch. When the program concluded, she glanced at the dark skies visible outside her bedroom window and made a face. She reached past the phone on her bedside table and picked up the novel that was resting there. Opening it to the caterpillar bookmark her youngest daughter had given her, she lost herself in the world of The Kite Runner.

It's about writing the information so that the reader can SEE it, visualise it. If it's a smell, describe the smell. Don't tell us what it smells like, but how it smells. Or tastes. Or feels. How does she move? What does she see? It's not about knowing it's blue or white, but how the character sees it.

It will add length to your chapter to rewrite it with showing instead of telling, but it'll be worth it. And there are some parts you can trim down. Her thought processes are quite disjointed, and I think you could make it a little easier on the reader. Remember - the reader doesn't know what you know. We only know what we read on the page.


*Cut*While sipping her hot, favorite Brazilian coffee brand from her green, yellow and blue I Love Brazil mug and wearing her warm, comfy blue chemise, Christina went to the computer room in her little apartment, located in Guaraville, fifteen minutes from Plano Piloto, to check her e-mail messages.*Cut*
That sentence is really long, and could easily be broken into two. For example, why do you mention how far the apartment is from Plano Piloto, when we're in the middle of a sentence about Christina sipping coffee? To be honest, your reader doesn't need to know the exact location of her apartment. And if we do, that can come much later, perhaps built in to a trip from her apartment to another location.
'Christina blew softly on the hot Brazilian coffee in her green, yellow and blue 'I love Brazil' mug as she wandered into the computer room of her apartment. She sipped the hot beverage, closing her eyes briefly as she savoured the taste, and checked the computer for new email messages.'


*Cut*She blushed. She screamed in delight again. Yes!*Cut*
I'd be wary of using the word 'screamed' especially in this context. Your character screams twice, alone in her apartment, over an email. I would reserve screaming for times of terror, and I suspect her neighbours would agree! *Smile* Perhaps a squeal of excitement would work better?

*NoteG* Overall Impression & Conclusion:
Please don't take this as a negative review. As I said, 'show don't tell' is the most common issue for authors, and I am someone who struggles with it. It's always easier for me to point it out to someone else and much harder for me to do it in my own writing. Your character is good, and you have a great setting. You have the details, they just need to be 'shown'. Sorry to sound like a broken record repeating the same things over and over, but it makes a huge difference to a piece of writing.

I think the chapter doesn't contain the 'hook' needed to grab a new reader and make them keep writing, but that doesn't mean you should abandon the chapter. You could start with a chapter that has more action and work this in as 'backstory', you could combine this chapter with another one which has more action in it, or you could add more action to this chapter. You could easily add more action/conflict to this chapter by bringing in either a daughter or the ex-boyfriend. Instead of Christina discussing it all internally with herself, she could argue it with her daughter or her ex-boyfriend. Or both. All those reasons she's not with the ex? We can learn those by having her argue with him. All those reasons why she's not too old to look for love? We can learn those by having her explain them to her daughter. Instead of telling us, bring in action and conflict by showing us. Perhaps start the whole story with the end of the previous relationship. Have the breakup scene at the beginning of the story, then move to the scene we've got in this chapter. That might work as a hook.
These are only suggestions of course. You have to do what suits you, but as a reviewer, these are my recommendations.

Let me know if you have any questions on what I've said. I'm happy to help.


*NoteO* ~ Elle

*StarO* WRITE ON! *StarO*

** Image ID #1918914 Unavailable **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
132
132
Review of Matthew's Letters  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi Shadowpup!
I just wanted to stop by and say that this folder of letters to your son is brilliant. I am so impressed. It's one thing I always wished I had done for my kids. They're only 7 and 11 now, but when I found out about this neat idea of writing letters on their birthdays, it seemed too late to start and backdate. I do annual 'surveys' with them though, asking them the same questions every year. I love seeing their answers change. I've also kept a journal since I was expecting my son, so all the memories are in there somewhere!

I have no criticism, other than that it looks like you've stopped and that seems a real shame. These letters will be treasured by your son. Maybe not now, maybe not as a teenager, but later in life he will treasure these. I hope you will keep them going.

Thanks for sharing,
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image created by YellowWitch!
133
133
for entry "Creamy Slaw
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hey, I just had to check out your recipe book when I saw it. I love cooking, and I'm working on my own family recipe book - "Invalid Item.

Your recipes are clearly laid out with the ingredients listed first, then the method in simple, easy-to-follow terms. The flavours are interesting! Raspberries with mushrooms, blueberries with dijon mustard and chicken... Definitely interesting! I'll withhold judgement until I try! *Smirk*

I like the fact that you note which brands of various products you use. Quite often the brand affects the flavour as well as the necessary quantities, so that's really helpful.

I'd love to see some photos of your food. *Smile*

Thanks for sharing your recipes. Gluten-free ones are always in demand these days.
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image created by YellowWitch!
134
134
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi DarthVada , I just stopped by to read your work.

I wasn't sure where it was going, but once I started reading, I couldn't stop. A sign of excellent work!

*Cut*I handed it over to him, flinching at the frightening excitement flushing his face.*Cut*
That line is brilliant. I can absolutely picture it.

*Cut*Blood splattered the beige wall, and brains covered us.*Cut*
I thought the 'brains covered us' was a bit simplistic and seemed to be in there for shock factor more than anything else. Even if you removed that part and left the bit about the blood splattering the beige wall, it would work better I think. You definitely have the talent to write something a little better than 'brains covered us' because you have shown that in this piece.

It feels like you've taken more time and care with the beginning, and then just tried to finish it quickly. I'd like to see the same skill you've shown in the first half carried on through the rest of it. The beginning is excellent.

I did NOT see that twist coming! Ha! You definitely got me there. Very clever! *Delight*

I don't normally read this genre, so please just take what you can from my comments. Overall, a great little piece, but I think you've shown moments of brilliance and you can bring the whole piece up to five stars.
Thanks for sharing your work!
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image #1924187 over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
135
135
Review of Winter  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi Amanda , I'm just popping by with a wee review of your poem.

Your poem is very well done. As I read it, I thought the rhythm worked really well, and I didn't notice any errors. Some of the words don't 'technically' rhyme, like 'winds' and 'skin' but I don't think they detract from the poem at all.

The poem isn't particularly strong emotionally, and that's due to your choice of words I think. There aren't strong emotional words, but it is easy to read and the reader gets an understanding of your situation.

The third stanza was my favourite, and I liked the line about the stars the best. *Smile*
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image #1924187 over display limit. -?-
136
136
Review of Dear...  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi Ruwth,
I'm not sure how much help I'll be, but you asked for my thoughts, so here goes...

Despite what you said, it does read like a poem. I actually like that it does. It has an almost melodic feel to it as you read it. Very easy to read, and I think it would be easy to read aloud.

You start off questioning yourself. Do you like the person you are now? You WANT to like the person you are, but do you? And then it comes down to what I believe is one of the important issues in this letter - do you need to change in order to like yourself, or can you accept yourself as you are? That's not a question I can answer, but only you can. There's nothing wrong with needing to change in order to like yourself more...so long as that change is good and realistic. Believing that you need to lose 20kg before you can like yourself is not healthy. Believing that you need to stop looking at all the negatives in life and start counting your blessings - that is healthy.

Then you resolve to accept yourself and be at peace with yourself this year, knowing it will bring happiness in to your life. I hope you stick to that, Ruwth. No one is ever 100% happy with themselves. Every single person has flaws and weaknesses. But we are all unique, we are all wonderful and as a Christian you should believe that God LOVES you and you are living the life he chose for you. Small changes for the better are good and healthy, and we should never stop striving to be better people. But believe that you are worthy. If God believes it, who are you to argue? *Smile*

Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image created by YellowWitch!
137
137
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


This is my review as judge of the "CLASH! .

The first thing I noticed is that you ‘tell’ the reader a lot of information, instead of ‘showing’. This is something that a lot of authors struggle with, including me. I’m doing a course at "Invalid Item at the moment and I’m learning about ‘showing instead of telling’ and also ‘passive voice’ – both are things I struggle with, and both are used heavily in this item of yours. You do have moments where you ‘show’ us.
An example of telling:
*Cut*She goes to Blanket and cuts him loose from his binds with the sharp dagger she owns, and saddles him up again.*Cut*
An example of showing:
*Cut*Besa startles, jumping to her feet and whipping around to see Heavy drawing out a sword, slashing the offending air as he approaches her as quickly as his stumpy legs will allow.*Cut*

It’s hard to explain (because I’m not a teacher!) but you’ve said ‘she goes to Blanket’.
How did she go? Did she stalk to Blanket? Did she scurry to Blanket? 'Goes’ is a passive verb. Yes, she went, but how? Use a more descriptive verb. An ‘active’ verb.
‘She raced to Blanket’.
Instead of ‘and cuts him loose from his binds with the sharp dagger she owns’, you could say something like ‘she withdrew her dagger and sliced the bonds holding him tight’. Same action, different voice – one is telling, one is showing.
Like I said, this is very much a learning area for me too, so please take my comments in respect of one writer to another. When you do ‘show’, you do it very well, as evidenced by the excerpt above. There are moments of brilliance in your writing. You definitely have the potential to make all your writing come alive like that.

I loved the fact that you put Besa into conflict and allowed us to witness her at her best and worst in this short item. I also really appreciated the fact that Besa fought not for herself, but for her son. That’s a more powerful motivator.

Thanks so much for entering, I enjoyed reading your entry.

Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image #1924187 over display limit. -?-
138
138
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi, this is my review as a judge of the "CLASH! .

I like the fact that I can visualise your character physically, I have a good idea of her temperament and character, and also an idea of her skills. Excellent work. BUT I am most impressed that you have given her realistic weaknesses.

You’ve gone into brilliant detail – she doesn’t just have olive skin, she has olive skin from soaking up the sun atop the merchant’s caravan. That really helps us picture her.

I was actually sad when I read that her son was fatally ill! That’s how much you have gained my empathy for this character!

Thanks for entering, and congrats on making it through to round one!

Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Are you "WDC Addicts Anonymous? So are we! Join us!
Image #1924187 over display limit. -?-
139
139
Review of Spring / Acrostic  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Click to go to the WDC Power Reviewers


This item is being reviewed as part of the "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group SPRING raid!

This is a neat little acrostic, which manages to cover a few different aspects of spring. There's the sunshine, the stormy weather and the extended daylight... I'm curious what fireworks you let off at picnics. What are the fireworks celebrating? I'm familiar with Guy Fawkes, which is in Spring if you're in the Southern Hemisphere. I'm in New Zealand, and we celebrate Guy Fawkes in Spring, so it works for me!

There are no corrections or changes required to this, and you've done a great job with it. The only problem (if it can be called that) is with the presentation. Currently you have the title, your username, a space, then the title again, then the acrostic. I would put the title, a space, then the acrostic. I'd also consider using a colour for the title, if not the acrostic itself. If you do something like {c:magenta} before the title and {/c} afterwards, you'll get this beautiful colour I'm using now. If you want other colours, there is an icon (looks a bit like a square rainbow) above the text box when you edit the item or create it, and if you click on that it brings up all the possible colours you can use. Just hover your mouse over one to see what word you need to use, then just do {c:colour} where you want the colour to start and {/c} afterwards to stop using that colour. You could use
{c:pink} or maybe {c:hotpink} or any colour that appeals to you. *Smile*
Another suggestion would be to center the whole thing, including the title. You can do that by typing {center} at the beginning and {/center} at the end.

Those are just my suggestions, you certainly don't have to use them. The actual acrostic is well done and I enjoyed reading it. *Smile*
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Image #1922496 over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
140
140
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Click to go to the WDC Power Reviewers


This item is being reviewed as part of the "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group SPRING raid!

I was drawn to read this by that first line that you so cleverly used in your intro.
*Cut*Glimpsed through naked branches the memory of you in Springtime wavers.*Cut*
My imagination was immediately captured. I could suggest a comma after branches though. *Smile*

*Cut*May in the year I turned 11, the year I dreamed of living in Tennessee and following Thor Heyerdahl around the world. In December I sang "Stille Nacht" in class ...in German.
The year you turned 11 too, before the leaves turned yellow in September.*Cut*

I think these lines could use a little reworking to bring them up to the same standard as the rest of your lines in this piece. They are right near the beginning, and I hate to think that people might form a poor first impression of this piece when the remaining lines are so well done.
I'm trying to think of suggestions for you. The part that bothers me is the 'in the year I turned 11' and The year you turned 11 too', because they don't seem to hold any imagery or emotion or.... They're just facts, and they stand out. Could they be restated in a more emotional way, or told in a less factual way?
I'm trying desperately to come up with a suggestion, so how about this:
'Glimpsed through naked branches, the memory of you in Springtime wavers. That was the year I dreamed of living in Tennessee and following Thor Heyerdahl around the world. I sang 'Stille Nacht' in class that December...in German. And you turned eleven, before the leaves turned yellow, in September.'
Have a play with it, and see what works for you. If you change nothing else, I would suggest writing the number 11 as 'eleven'.

*Cut*I had nothing to offer and even looking back through the kind eyes of time ...I had nothing to offer.*Cut*
I love that line!

*Cut*walked past through quiet snowfall and the quieter fog of May.*Cut*
I love the imagery you've used there too. Quiet snowfall and quieter fog. Beautiful.

*Cut*Their cold bare branches still cast shadows through my thinning hair.*Cut*
That's such an unexpected ending after the talk of turning 11, and yet we're given just enough warning with 'and every November since'. It's a bit of a slap in the face to the reader, but oh, you've done it so well. I wouldn't change it at all.

On the whole, an excellent piece of prose and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. Thank you for sharing.
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Image #1922496 over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
141
141
Review of Novel Butterfly  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Click to go to the WDC Power Reviewers


This item is being reviewed as part of the "WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group SPRING review raid!

This poem is beautifully written. Your rhythm is perfect, and the rhyming is excellent. Some might argue that 'spring' technically doesn't perfectly rhyme with 'wing' or 'thing', but they work for me!

The first time I read it through, I stumbled slightly on the line 'Spun within cocoon for sleep' but I reread the poem several times and it worked, so perhaps that was just me!

A wonderful theme of spring, change and reaching full potential - thank you so much for sharing.
Elle


Check out the "The Kiwi Review Challenge! - closed! You could win 100,000 gift points and a merit badge!

Image #1922496 over display limit. -?-
142
142
Review of Lasha Thornhook.  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


This is a review from "Invalid Item as part of your Nuclear package.

Image #1729365 over display limit. -?-


The first thing I noticed about this piece is that you start off by insulting your readers. It doesn't read like Lasha is talking to a specific third party, it reads like she is talking to the reader. And while I am personally very happy with my family, it is unbelievably insulting to be told
*Cut*I don't give a shit if you were beaten and raped. Honestly, you got off lucky if that's all your daddy did to you.*Cut* I know for a fact that there are people here on WDC that HAVE been raped by family members. While Lasha may not care about hurting and offending them, I think it's better for you as a writer if your readers keep reading after the second sentence! *Smile* I get that Lasha is strong, confrontational and dysfunctional, but I believe you can get that across without insulting your readers.

Remember that these are just my opinions and my suggestions. You can take them or leave them as you choose. I see that you have bought six reviews for this one item, and that's an excellent idea - you can get a broader view, not just one person's opinion. *Smile*

My suggestion would be to take out much of the first and second paragraphs and then leave most of the remainder. I think that way Lasha still comes across with all the force of her personality, but without being as personally insulting to the reader. Here's how I would change it:
I don't care where you came from or who your parents are, my family is worse than yours. I don't give a shit if you were beaten and raped. Honestly, you got off lucky if that's all your daddy did to you. I was raped growing up and it's happened to most of my siblings as well. If that's all that happened to me maybe I wouldn't have to be telling you why my family makes everyone else seem functional.

So yeah, I'm pretty tired of hearing how bad it is for everyone else. I recognize that look, you're thinking wow this girl is really fucked up, listen to what she's saying. Honestly, this is nothing.
Maybe I should start from the beginning. I am the first born of the Thornhook nobles, Lasha Reille Thornhook, and in case you are wondering, no I am not a halfling I am a gnome. If you big folk actually paid any attention you'd know. If I hear any slave joke even murmur from your lips, I'll make sure you know what it's like to be a slave.


After that, it's mostly technical errors that are easy to fix. I do think you need some explanation of why the father was such an awful gnome (especially if you remove the reference to rape as above) because you blame the siblings' issues on him but give no reason for placing the blame on him. You can bring back the reference to rape, by saying that he raped and/or beat his daughters, I would just suggest you don't have Lasha telling the readers she couldn't care less if they've experienced such tragedy or not.

Okay, a few technical errors:

*Cut* I am the first born of the Thornhook nobles, Lasha Reille Thornhook, and in case you are wondering, no I am not a halfling I am a gnome.*Cut*
This sentence needs a comma after no and after halfling.

*Cut* If I hear any slave joke even murmur from your lips, I'll make sure you know what it's like to be a slave.*Cut*
Joke should be plural (jokes) and murmur should be murmured.

*Cut*Oh yes, I have six siblings, three brothers and three sisters.*Cut*
This almost sounds like she has six siblings AND three brothers AND three sisters. Perhaps a dash (-) instead of a comma after siblings would make it clearer.

In the third paragraph, you need a space between your fifth and sixth sentences.

*Cut*Yeah that Kilanna.*Cut*
I would use a comma after yeah.

*Cut*she does it just to spite me too.*Cut*
That sentence needs a capital at the beginning.

In the fourth paragraph, you need a space between your fifteenth and sixteenth sentences.

*Cut*but I'm not going to take her left overs.*Cut*
Leftovers should be one word.

*Cut*She actually calls them her Vassals, like she's some feudal lord or something. Shit, she even calls our butler her Vassal. Our Butler!*Cut*
Vassals, vassal and butler don't need capital letters.

*Cut*it took her months until she stopped, and who knows if it wasn't just because she wasn't talking about the damn dog anymore.*Cut*
This doesn't quite make sense. It took her months to stop talking about the dog, and maybe it was just because she stopped talking about the dog? I think you might need to reword this slightly to make your meaning clearer.

*Cut*Lanni thinks it's because of dad.*Cut*
Dad needs a capital in that sentence because it's being used as a name.

*Cut* It just gets me how dad thinks he can do whatever he wants.*Cut*
Same with this sentence - a capital letter for Dad because it's being used as a name. If you say Dad, you need a capital, if you say my dad, you don't.

*Cut* although. I don't know if he'll ever be able to talk.*Cut*
Although needs a capital, and then it should be a comma and not a full stop before I.

*Cut*Honestly, he' one of the reasons I stay here.*Cut*
You need an s on he's.

*Cut* He's mouthy,*Cut*
That should be a full stop, not a comma.

*Cut*He's always trying to do what's right, even after the amount of times he's gotten beat up because of it.*Cut*
This sentence isn't technically correct, but it suits Lasha's way of talking, so it probably doesn't need correcting.

*Cut*Once, when Lanni and I were out in Morato; we wandered too close to the Slave Market, and he had tried to free the slaves.*Cut*
That should be a comma, not a semi colon after Morato. I think! *Smile*

*Cut*If Lanni hadn't been there to talk the guards*Cut*
There's a missing word there. If Lanni hadn't been there to talk TO the guards...

*Cut*I mean when he finds out what kind of monster our parents are.*Cut*
How can he possibly not know? This needs more explanation.

*Cut*And when I take over; when dad retires and leaves the town to me. I'm going to run it better.*Cut*
Dad needs a capital letter, and these two sentences should be linked, with a comma after 'me'. Otherwise it says 'when I take over'. When you take over, what? It makes a lot more sense if the two sentences are linked.

You obviously have a very clear understanding of this character - her personality comes through in every sentence. Her personality is very strong, very forceful and you manage to convey that to the reader without any doubt. I think if you can fix that top part, and get people reading the whole piece, you'll have a much stronger piece. Maybe not a 'nice' piece, because I don't think Lasha IS nice, but a strong piece.

Elle


Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
143
143
Review of God's Telephone  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


I found this story in the nominations for best Young Adult/Children's work at "The Quills. I'm not sure what I was expecting...something like the first half of your story, I think.

The first half made me smile - we've all known kids like that, and you made Max so engaging that it was impossible not to love him. I loved the idea of his mum writing his adventures down. Then, wait, what? I was as shocked as his mum when the twist in the story arrived. I gotta be honest, you brought tears to my eyes...and I was reading this on my lunch break at work and that's just plain embarrasing! I loved the way you finished with her starting to write his adventures.

A beautiful work. I am in awe. You say in your bio that 'Most of my readers end up laughing or crying, so I guess that makes me an emotional writer, or something.' I'd have to agree with that, wow, you do it so well. Thanks again for sharing.

Elle


Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
144
144
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


I was reading some of the nominations for "The Quills so I could vote for some. Your item was nominated for Comedy. I must confess (shh, don't tell anyone!) that I haven't been doing reviews as I've been reading, but oh, I just couldn't resist with yours.

I am a mother of two children, aged 11 and 7 (boy and girl respectively). I couldn't help but laugh at your story. I just have to share this quick story in return...

Mum: You have to eat all your soup before you can eat your Easter egg. Lunch comes before chocolate.
*some time later*
Miss 6: Mum, he poured some of his soup in my bowl!
Master 10: No, I didn't!
Miss 6 cries, because she doesn't eat big meals and is worried she won't be able to finish all the soup in her bowl and won't get to eat her Easter egg. Master 10 insists he didn't do anything and she's trying to avoid having to eat her lunch first. It takes AN HOUR, including sitting the two (now crying) children in front of each to watch each other cry (we had the idea that the one lying would take pity on the upset one) before we finally find out that Master 10 was lying. He loses his Easter egg for lying (not for the soup incident!). Drama indeed!

So I couldn't help but laugh at your story, and indeed, it inspires me to write my own. I should give it a go. I might achieve what you have, and that is to make some other mother laugh, and know she is not alone.
Thank you for sharing, and you definitely get my vote for best comedy item!
Elle

PS. I didn't notice any errors. If there were any, I was too busy laughing and reading to notice them!


Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
145
145
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
WDC Contestants Power Raid


It seems only right that for my 10th 'contestant' review of this raid, I review this group which has been nominated for 'Best Group' in the Quills. If I was judging, you'd win!!

Firstly, everyone is welcome. That is so encouraging to a newbie looking to find acceptance and feeling shy and nervous about joining a group.

Secondly, you guys are so welcoming and full of encouragement. I won't forget who sent me my first merit badge just because I had none!

Thirdly, you keep in touch regularly. The emails don't always have a lot of new information (sometimes just a new member activity we might be interested in), but you touch base, keep us all up to date and we all feel like we know what's going on with the group.

Fourthly - I love the fact that we can review ANYTHING. Yes, there are 'review lists' and there are raid themes, but in the end, it's 100% our choice - nothing is off limits.

Fifthly *Bigsmile*, if we need to disappear for any reason, we are not questioned, we are not penalised, and we are welcomed back with open arms.

I LOVE THIS GROUP, and if I was judging, you'd definitely get my vote for best group on WDC! Thanks for having me!
Elle


Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
146
146
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
WDC Contestants Power Raid


I saw your entry at "The Humorous Poetry Contest.

You have excellent rhythm and your poem is enjoyable to read.

*Cut*Reviews are always helpful, thank you one and all.*Cut*
This was the only line where I stumbled. Your poem doesn't rhyme exactly, but I felt that if that line ended in an 'ee' sound, it would read more smoothly. Something like 'Reviews are always helpful, providing clarity', or 'Reviews are always helpful, thank you all from me'. Anyway, have a play with it and see what you think.

Other than that one tiny word, I enjoyed your writing, and yes, I think you are a poet, a good one. Great work, and I look forward to seeing your work round the site.
Elle


Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
147
147
Review of Hi Daddy  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Argh, I made the mistake of reading this on a break at work, and I had to get a tissue because it made me cry! I was sitting here at my desk, tears pooling in my eyes, trying to be really inconspicuous so no one would ask what was wrong!

This is a beautiful, heartfelt, touching tribute to all children who have lost a parent in war. It was unbelievably touching.

*Cut*You said that you would always watch over me no matter what ever happened.*Cut*
I think 'what ever' should probably be 'whatever'.

That was the only error I could find. I wouldn't change even a single word of the rest of it. It is very powerful stuff. I am in awe. *Smile*
Elle


Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
148
148
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi Jellyfish-Vote Green on May 2! ,
Firstly, thank you so much for entering the "Invalid Item run by the "Kiwis on WDC! group. We appreciate your support.

The theme was 'Christmas in Summer' and other than being a static item, there were no other restrictions on length, type or style.

Your poem fit the theme perfectly, describing a Christmas vacation far from England in sunny, summery Portugal. Your poem had excellent rhythm and rhyme. I am curious to know if it a specific type of poem or if you just set it out how you felt it worked best.

I thought the fifth stanza was a little strange and it didn't make a lot of sense to me. I wasn't sure what you were trying to say there. When I reread the poem, I felt that you could easily remove the fifth stanza without any loss to the poem.

The first stanza was my favourite, but I also liked the fourth and sixth stanzas. Overall I enjoyed reading it very much and it was a wonderful entry.

Please remember that I am only one of the four judges and so my opinion only counts for a quarter of the final decision. I wish you all the best in the contest and thank you again for entering.

Elle

Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
149
149
Review of Fourth of July  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi KerrieAnnS ,
Firstly, thank you so much for entering the "Invalid Item run by the "Kiwis on WDC! group. We appreciate your support.

The theme was 'Christmas in Summer' and other than being a static item, there were no other restrictions on length, type or style.

While your item was interesting and informative, I could not see anywhere that it was about Christmas in summer. It was about a summer celebration, being the Fourth of July, but not about Christmas. For that reason, I cannot recommend it to win a prize in the contest as it does not fit the required theme, but I thank you for entering anyway and will gladly give you a review.

You have a great writing style, and the item has pace and action. You use a lot of descriptive words that allow the reader to imagine the sights and sounds of the fireworks displays. I also like how you describe where your audience sits (in the pool!) and how you set up the show with your sons, and all those little details.

*Cut*Where ass the best spot? The best spot has the Gateway Arch in full view.*Cut*
'Ass' should be 'was'.

*Cut*The finally was massive and everyone knew the show was over.*Cut*
'Finally' should be 'finale'.

Please remember that I am only one of the four judges and so my opinion only counts for a quarter of the final decision. I wish you all the best in the contest and thank you again for entering.

Elle

Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-
150
150
Review of A Warm Christmas  
Review by Elle - on hiatus
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
A dragon reading a book by candle light


Hi Magoo ,
Firstly, thank you so much for entering the "Invalid Item run by the "Kiwis on WDC! group. We appreciate your support.

The theme was 'Christmas in Summer' and other than being a static item, there were no other restrictions on length, type or style.

Your poem caught my attention because it wasn't what I was expecting. Instead of celebrating the beauty and difference of Christmas in summer, you were lamenting the lack of snow. It reminded me of that old song 'I'm Dreaming Of A White Christmas'. All those things you missed, I've never done. I loved all the details - the children learning to ski, ice fishing, sand trucks and mistletoe. We have none of those things (and it sounds like you don't either now!) so each mention was like a glimpse into another world, a different life.

The poem was very well written, it flowed well and had excellent rhyme and rhythm. The last line was humourous and an excellent finish to the poem.

The only hiccup for me in reading your poem was the rhyme of lawn with gone - but I suspect that might be an accent problem. When I say lawn, it rhymes with storm. And gone rhymes with swan. So lawn and gone don't rhyme, but like I said, I suspect that's an accent issue, so I won't hold it against you. *Smile*

The fourth stanza was my favourite, especially the part about the ice hanging from the eaves.

Please remember that I am only one of the four judges and so my opinion only counts for a quarter of the final decision. I wish you all the best in the contest and thank you again for entering.

Elle

Image #1894613 over display limit. -?-

Image #1894637 over display limit. -?-


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
199 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 8 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/elle/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/6