*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/leila_oa/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: OFF
131 Public Reviews Given
149 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- ... Next
26
26
Review by Leila
In affiliation with The Lucky Leprechaun's Gro...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
*WitchHat* A Witch-Killer Review by the Grand General Rose of Iron *WitchHat*

*WitchHat* Thanks to my cunning and experience, I have been ordered to assemble an army to kill the Green Witch. *WitchHat*

I have been trained since youth to be a witch slayer. Now, to get an army, I have to bestow on selected writers my infinite wisdom. You have been awarded a witch-killer review because Experimental Plot Challenge has been very useful.
As a general, I am strict, but I am also fair. I will not give you a 5 star rating if your piece does not deserve it. Please remember, I just want to help, and I will help you most if I am honest.


*WitchHat*Overview*WitchHat*

This review is my goodbye from the challenge. Please, I would like to receive the remaining emails. A challenge is not meant to be easy. I will continue to use the prompts to plot my novel. Don't get me wrong; they are extremely useful.

I started this challenge with a rough notion about my novel. It is hard science fiction. I had solved the science problem, but I had no idea how to get from a science discovery to a full blown novel. Step by step, following the prompts, the story started to build up. Many of my decisions from the beginning of the challenge proved wrong. On Day 13, you wrote: "What takes place to allow the protagonist to overcome these obstacles of complication?"

I started to answer:
Paula overcomes the complication, the danger over her live, by conquering Patrick's heart. He starts to care about her and to fight for her.There is a lot of at stake; a dangerous technology has spread through the world, and everyone wants it.

I noticed that I was wrong about my protagonist, and that I knew almost nothing about the real protagonist. I could not go on.

Now, my novel is coming alive, and I do not know what will happen! I never understood it when I read authors commenting about their work in the past. I really do not have that control over the story.

*WitchHat*Congrats Writer! You got it right.*WitchHat*

I just loved the prompts. They are helping me to build the plot of my novel, and I am sure they will help other writers.

*WitchHat*The WDC Academy waits for you.*WitchHat*

Your challenge deserves a special place at the WDC Academy Library. The librarians are suggesting that you add links to the challenge prompt forum posts. The daily posts are getting buried among the students' assignments.

{post:2306698} *Right* "Invalid Post"  


*WitchHat*A few pearls of my wisdom*WitchHat*

Please, keep up with the great work!

*Pointright*This review helps me recruit a creature to bring damage against the Green Witch! *Pointleft*
*Pointright* ** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** *Pointleft*


Disclaimer: The Grand General Rose of Iron is a character who will be reviewing in the place of a fellow writer known as Leila until November the 5th. This is a Halloween themed review.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
27
27
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Please, remember I am only a fellow writer. This review is only my opinion.

I felt... happy. Your poem made me smile; I might have laughed if I were alone. I felt some bitterness into your words.

I liked... the flow, the rhyme, and the motif.

You can improve... hum, it is hard to say. You might improve your feelings towards the reviewers.

A few comments
I believe it is possible to give constructive reviews towards poetry. Sure, poets open their hearts and souls; they give a bit of themselves in each line. Some poems do not read well; others just tell their emotions without causing them.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
28
28
Review of The Cave  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (3.5)
Please, remember I am only a fellow writer. This review is only my opinion.

I felt... confused. I had to read your story twice to understand it. It is so dense that you need to pay attention to every word; the kind of attention that is hard to achieve after a day of work.

I liked... the plot of the story.

You can improve... your story by extending it. You might make Eric's journey through the cave more nerve-racking if you give us more details.
         In the first paragraph, you have a group of sentences with approximately the same size. You should vary it.
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1777654 by Not Available.

         Lastly, you should also put each speaker line in one paragraph.


A few comments
I found many grammar errors. For example:
*XR* After catching his breath and feeling more energetic, he stood up and entered the cave.
*CheckG* After catching his breath and feeling more energetic he stood up and entered the cave.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **




My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
29
29
Review of Steaming Mug  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (4.0)
Please, remember I am only a fellow writer, and certainly no artist. This review is only my opinion.

I felt... curious. I was reading the reviews at the public review page, and this image did not show, so I decided to click on it.

I liked... the smoke going up. It gave the image a nice effect.

You can improve... the shadows and the inscription: they don't seem quite right.

A few comments
It is a very nice signature.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

30
30
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I liked it. The POV of the first part was perfect. I could feel the hatred of the nazist man. I got curious about Thomas. Is he going to get a job? I could feel he swallow his pride, because he needed the job badly. I guess it must be hard to work for the former enemy. Keep writing!

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
31
31
Review of The Bench  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (5.0)
It was a sad story. You have captured well the father's pain for his son death. He had built a heir by his image. Now, he has none.
32
32
Review of A VIEW ON REVIEWS  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (4.5)
I read this article some time ago and checked the reviews I haven't answered; there were some, but they are all fixed now. I did the math: I received about 58% answer for all my reviews. Most of my reviews are from the review request pages; they have asked for it. Another annoying point is expecting reviews without given out any - not a single one.

Your article is short and to the point. I haven`t noticed any grammer problem (this one was hard to write - my iPad kept correcting me *BigSmile*).
33
33
Review of Mesothelioma  
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Very informative article. I haven't known that. It is not the first time the mankind uses a substance that has very good physical properties but is harmful for the health or environment. I was not happy to find out that Brazil produces and uses this substance. I live in Brazil... At least, they are talking about forbidding it, and it is already forbidden in four states.
34
34
Review of Lumas - Prologue  
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
You wrote well crafted sentences without any obvious grammar mistakes (as far as I can tell). You would get a more strong prologue if we could sense the fear. Many authors use the character's body reactions: fast beating heart, sweat, back stiffing, and so on. The thoughts are important too; you may transcribe them directly into the text.

Your prologue needs some work, but you are on the right path. Keep writing!

   My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
35
35
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I could almost see a happy spirit wandering through the world. The poem reads nice. I liked the way it rhymes. The ideas and the rhymes goes together, that makes the poem easy to read. The only exception is the line: "For sadness knows this spirit not". Divide it in two lines, and you will have: each four lines, two rhymes, one idea. Great Work!


         My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
36
36
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (2.5)
The content is great, but you should write it using more metaphors. It is too direct for a poem. Some images that you used are old: they have already been used too many times. Keep on writing!
37
37
Review of Come To Me  
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (2.0)
I liked the theme and the form of your poem. The rhymes are not perfect, but they help the reading sound well. You should use more metaphors. You tell us your feelings; try to show them.

Keep working! Please, remember this is only my opinion. I try hard to give honest reviews and ratings.
38
38
Review of The Tech Guy  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (4.0)
I liked the way you compared the Tech Guy with a magician. Yes, tech-savvy people can often let the others wondering. I likes the character Mitch and the plot.

You repeat words and syllables in such way that it gives your story rhythm. I like a lot this sentence:
The copier hummed, the light came on, the clear sound of paper rattled through the internal mechanisms, and a piece of 8 1/2 x 11 paper smoothly, eloquently and perfectly floated into the outbin of the copier.


I noticed that you use too many alternatives to "said," you don't need to do that. You can eliminate many dialog tags by putting each speaker in a paragraph (you already do that) and describe some kind of his/her actions.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
39
39
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (1.5)
You tried to deal with a complicated subject. I'm sure your text can become very interesting if you spend more time revising it. First, you should give us a small introduction, stating the importance of your analysis. Second, you should divide your text in paragraphs. Third, you should summarize all your points in a conclusion.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
40
40
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (3.0)
When I read it aloud in my broken Spanish, it sounded nicely. The imagery of the second part was good; I specially liked the thought of belonging to a family, of being loved by a family. However, I missed some deeper emotion on your poem.

Rhyme: N/A
Flow: *Star* *Star* *Star* *Star*
Imagery: *Star* *Star* *Star*
Mood: *Star* *Star*

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
41
41
Review by Leila
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
Please, remember this is only my opinion. I have tried to give you a helpful review.

Your story was easy to follow and understand. Keep on writing!

Plot: I don’t think you developed the plot well. I didn’t feel my heart racing.

Character: We know little about Mike. You tell a little about his feelings. He doesn't have a distinct voice.

Descriptions: You should use more senses in your descriptions. Add a few bodily reactions.

Point of View: You don’t have a consistent point of view through the tale.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


Some suggestions of edits that decrease the word count:

to calm down the horse
to calm it down

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


Mike an outlaw on the run, his gang went off with out him and robbed a bank killing the local sheriff as the rode out of town. As soon as he found out what they did he took of on his own. Hoping to avoid the gallows. It didn’t take long for them to catch Mike’s former gang members, or try and execute them. They were still looking for him, and he wanted to avoid their fate. So headed for someplace no one, in their right mind, would go, a place people feared.
We already know Mike is an outlaw. You may suppress this paragraph and add some of its information somewhere else.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


As they went deeper into Congaree forest, the forest itself seemed to get darker, as if the vary trees seemed as though they wanted to reach out strangle them.
The deeper they went into the Congaree forest, the darker it got, as if the vary tree wanted to reach out and strangle them.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


It's just some old man, mike thought, “What are you doing here old man?”
He saw a man. “What are you doing here old man?”

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


They spent a few more hours talking before mike went to sleep for the night, though uneasily with the new found knowledge of what lurked in the shadows in the forest.
As Mike slept the old andreal kept watch, walking around the campsite keeping and creatures away.

In the darkness slowly one shadow creature, in the twisted shape of a dog sized spider, crept towards the camp. As it creeps closer to camp its flesh twists in ways it shouldn’t. Reaching the each of the forest it instinctively scans for threats and pray. Once it spots Mike in starts creeping towards him but then from the trees the andreal pounces on it quietly driving his espada ropera through its head killing it with out a sound. Not going far from the camp, he drags its carcass back into the woods tossing it out of the way.


The verb to crept already implies slowly. The three paragraphs needs editing. Mike couldn’t see the creature, when he was sleeping. You changed the viewpoint from Mike's to andreal.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


The old andreal just smiled listening to Mike open, ...
You changed the viewpoint from Mike's to andreal.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


“Consider it a good luck charm.” he said smiling, “also you might need it,” he said looking at Mike’s Bowie knife, “the extra reach might just save your life.”

“Consider it a good luck charm. You might need it,” he said looking at Mike’s Bowie knife. “The extra reach might just save your life.”

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


As Mike climbed onto Traveller he scratched his head, What have I gone and got myself into? Well lets see these “creatures.” Time seemed to advance slowly as they traveled around the lake. As they approached the temple Traveller grew more apprehensive, so Mike tied him to a small tree and approached the rest of the way on foot taking what he needed.
Mike climbed onto Traveller. What have I gone and got myself into? Well lets see these “creatures.” Time crept as they traveled around the lake. As they approached the temple, Traveller grew more apprehensive, so Mike tied him to a small tree and went the rest of the way on foot.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


Reaching the entry he used the magic stone as instructed, it created a small glowing light the floated just above his head. That’s useful. Traveling into the halls it didn’t take long for him to see the first creature. It started shambling towards him attracted to his light.
Reaching the entry he used the magic stone, it creating a small glowing light that floated just above his head. That’s useful. Traveling into the halls it didn’t take long for him to see the first creature, shambling towards him.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


Reaching the temple’s center and large altar room, he could hear movement, but what ever was making it was smart enough to stay in the shadows away from him.
Reaching the temple’s center and large altar room, he could hear something moving, but it was keeping itself in the shadows away from sight.

The room had a small half foot shelf filled with something. Keeping one eye on the shadows he checked it, they put ground up coal in here, I wonder if? Reaching into his pack he pulled out a small box of matches, opening it he dumped them all into the base of the shelf at the entrance. Taking one he lit it tossing it with the others the flames soon illuminated up the room.
The room had a small half foot shelf filled with something. He checked it. It was coal. He pulled out a small box of matches from his pack. He dumped them all into the base of the shelf. He lit one, tossing it with the others. The flames soon illuminated up the room.

*TulipB* *TulipR* *TulipP*


I think you can really cut down a lot of the part he meets with his escort.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
42
42
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (3.5)
I liked the tone of your writing. I felt passion.

When you repeat words, you sometimes get the effect of adding rhythm to your piece. You get it right in the first paragraph with we and cool. The last paragraph has too many that. You could get the desired effect in the second paragraph with the word picture; however, its ideas are not well exposed.

There are some grammar mistakes. You would benefit from an automatic grammar checking tool. They are far from perfect, but they do help a lot.


I reviewed you, because you requested it. I have just added a item to be reviewed: "Brazilian Kids' Birthday Celebration.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
43
43
Review of Moment  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (3.0)
Your story was very emotional, poetic even. I'm certain it has a great potential, but there's still work to be done. You should break your text into smaller chunks, adding blank space among them and review the comma usage.

You must have meant "in every pore" below.
"(...)a profound presence in every poor of her fifty-five year old skin."

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
44
44
Review of Polynomials  
Review by Leila
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews*Candlev*


It was an easy game to solve. I could get most of the words without looking at the list. I would use fewer words, though. Near all letters were used. I guess that would give the algorithm more room to work with, making the game harder and more interesting. The algorithm could only put one word next to the other, with few random letters in between.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
44 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 2 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/leila_oa/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2