Technical Support Forum

The item itself is group only. The access restrictions on the item note that restriction... as far as I can tell.
If you are seeing this item as public, please send a screenshot so I can debug why you're seeing something different.

Outside of that...
Review access restrictions always follow an item's access restrictions.
People who can't access an item should not be able to access a review of an item they can not access.

Items that are restricted to Group-Only access are not listed on any public listing pages because of the Group-Only restriction. This is not new and has been in place since Group-Only restrictions were released close to 20 years ago.

And since reviews follow the restrictions of an item...
If an item is private, the review is private.
If the item is group-only, so too is the review.
Group-only items and reviews both are not shown on public listings.

Again though, if you're seeing the item showing as "public" with no restrictions, please post or email me a screenshot. None of my testing is showing this item as public nor showing it displayed as publicly accessible.

Hope this thorough explanation helps and I appreciate any screenshots you can send to help me debug your view...
~~SM


A Few Helpful Tips...
  If your problem is with an item, please include its Item ID!
  New member? Start here!   "Getting Started: Table of Contents" 
  Find answers in our FAQ...   http://www.writing.com/main/faq
  Need Non-Technical Support?   "Non-Technical Support Forum"