*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/cometo1999/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
221 Public Reviews Given
274 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- ... Next
51
51
Review by IchigoSakamura
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi!

I see you live in Japan. This story is set in Akihabara, so, I presume that this person who picked up the fetus is a Japanese man. From what I understand, the Japanese are honestly fearful of the dead, especially the dead that have not died well (e.g. in war). A fetus to them, is like an angry soul, especially if it has been aborted. Often, they would perform rituals to appease the angry spirit. So, I would in the story write about him doing some simple rites or rituals (even if he can't afford the stupendously expensive fees the priests charge). That way, the spirit will not haunt him. Perhaps you can ask your Japanese colleagues about it. Of course, it might also differ from religion to religion.

Having said all that, this is well written. =) Beautifully described.

Keep up the good work.

がんばってください!
52
52
Review of Kulgash  
Review by IchigoSakamura
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi! =) I read this twice, and I don't think it's crap at all!

General Plot: I like this fresh perspective, from the "bad guy's" point of view. =) Interesting beginning, and has a potential to develop into something much greater. Nice bit about the orc training, too. Gives a background to their general culture.

General grammatical observations: You mix past and present tense. At the beginning, you used present tense to describe the training, but later, you start to switch to past tense. It is a bit confusing. If in doubt, just stick to past tense throughout. Also, instead of using arabic numerals, spell out the number. For example, 13: "thirteen".

"while the other orcs where fighting" - typo: were

"the begin their brutal training" - typo: they

"that is one thing that has never been, at least overtly, lacked by an orc" - "never been lacked" is an awkward way to phrase things. Perhaps consider, "Let's face it. This was one thing that no orc, at least overtly, lacked"

"second in command" - hyphenate: second-in-command

"These are put through" - vague: who are "these"?

"experience leader" - experienced leader

I hope I've helped. Hope to read more of your stories.

Cheers!

53
53
Review of Joe the Paper Boy  
Review by IchigoSakamura
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is such a sweet piece. I can visualize the scene right in front of me. You brought the characters, the neighborhood to life. I must say, you did a pretty good job! I especially love the part where you said, "trike prison". That was so utterly adorable! Very nicely written!

Just some very very minor grammatical and spelling issues:

In general, you make very little use of commas. Commas can help to separate actions. Imagine if you had to read an entire sentence without a comma, out loud. That'd be kind of tiring. So, for example,

" Joe became Joe again in a few weeks and everything was back to normal except on the weekends when he would get help from his family delivering the Sunday papers." - This could be written with commas: "Joe became Joe again in a few weeks and everything was back to normal, except on the weekends, when he would get help from his family delivering the Sunday papers." Makes for better flow.

"in his fifty’s" - the spelling for fifty's I think is fifties'.

"His ratty winter jacket was lined with them, police, fire, military, and anyone else who had a badge he could get his hands on." - this sentence reads a little awkwardly. Perhaps you could consider revising it. I didn't really understand "anyone else". Did you mean any other professions? If that's the case, then, "anything else he could get his hands on" would suffice, I think.

"out of site" - typo: out of sight

"2nd hill" - instead, use the spelling "second"

"One day we were building a ramp to jump some cement blocks with our bikes and surely kill ourselves when we saw Joe walk by. " - the last part is difficult to understand. I might consider rewriting it as: "One day, we were building a ramp to jump some cement blocks with our bikes when we saw Joe walk by. It was a dangerous activity, and surely, there was a high chance of us killing ourselves, but we were children. Invincible."

"I though about the trike" - just a simple typo: "thought"

"across the street from Joe" - put a possessive 's because you're referring to Joe's house, right?

Why I gave the rating I did:

I loved the piece, like I said, but some spelling and grammatical errors marred my enjoyment. Overall, kudos to a job well done!
54
54
Review of Dragonscout  
Review by IchigoSakamura
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi! I enjoyed reading this piece, though the ending was kind of sad. I understand that this is a contest entry, so there might be some word limit to it and the amount of description possible. Despite that, the chase was described well. Very fast paced and quite exciting to read.

A few points to note:

1) Possessives, for example, "Dragonflyers arm" (when I presume you meant "Dragonflyer's arm") and "clans" (where I presume you meant "clan's"). In the later paragraphs, there were also similar mistakes, for example "a sly ones fire dart"

2) When referring to a group, perhaps you could capitalise the word. So, instead of "the clan needed", it would be "the Clan needed".

3) "They would revel in chaos" - would suggests the future. The sly ones currently revel in chaos, don't they? So, "would" is unnecessary. Instead, "They reveled in chaos"

4) "bought forth" - brought forth

5) "emptyness" - emptiness

6) "Gliding along the currents, alert, yet relaxed, scanning for trouble. A glow in the distance." - the sentence structure reads a little staccato-ish, seemingly disjointed.

7) "The sly one had trained with Scouts, teaching fighting skills." - so this is a recognizable sly one, who was actually some spy? Is this a hint of espionage?

On general sentence structure: You seem to connect sentences with commas. While this is a common thing to do, too much of it makes it seem very disjointed. For example: "The giants of the underworld became graceful, dancing with indescribable beauty, it was a sight he would never forget." The first two parts are to do with the giants, but the last to do with the dragon's awe. So, I suggest to break off "it was a sight he would never forget" into a separate sentence.

Suggestions: I feel that this can develop into something more. Instead of letting Malafi die, perhaps you could consider letting him live, and have him as the main character of many more adventures. In particular, I did not get the sense that Malafi was attacked very viciously by the sly one. Instead, it was just a chase, without Malafi suffering from anything other than exhaustion.

I always like a story with a twist, so, perhaps in the later stories, you could show why it's not a good thing to be telepathic. That it is destructive, that the other dragons actually have a reason to be wary of this unity. Perhaps an evil, corrupt dragon at the head of the Clan? Perhaps an evil sorcerer? Or perhaps just the collapse of such an intricate system (an analogy I can think of is: we're all connected to the world wide web. but, a virus once introduced can cripple the entire system.)

Nonetheless, this is a good attempt at writing after 25 years! =) I like this story, and I'm hoping you'll write more about the dragonscouts. =) Cheers!
55
55
Review of Lost Dream  
Review by IchigoSakamura
Rated: E | (4.5)
General Impressions: Beautiful piece. It captures the essence of dreams.

Grammatical/Spelling Issues: None that I can pinpoint. So hat's good.

Concerns: This isn't a concern, just disagreeing with this part of the poem.

When Fear and immense Happiness intertwine,
Making the series of Confusion somehow make sense.


Are you saying that Fear and Happiness makes Confusion make sense? But, even in the absence of fear or happiness, every single event in a dream, no matter how illogical it is, makes sense. So, it's not a cause and effect thing.

However, the above is only my opinion. Art is always subjected to different interpretations. =)
55 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 3 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/cometo1999/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3