*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/drawerwrite/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: OFF
97 Public Reviews Given
98 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- ... Next
26
26
Review of Sirenblade  
Review by Einav
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
hello,
the very accurate (almost mondane) details are the best thing in this work, really getting into the cool, calculated head of jasmin, its apparant you've a lot of knowledg of what you're writing, wether it's fire kindling or fighting.
the fighting scene is funny and convincing.
yet with all those details, you did'nt describe what jasmin looks like- at the begining i didnt know if she was young or old, beutiful or ugly, if she has scars, what she is wearing.. i dont know why, but in the begining i was sure she was a veteran of at least forty years old.
i've read recently a good tip which applies to this chapter in my opinion-
don't give away too much information in a plain way, but give the reader hints. i could've got it on my own that:

"Most of the farming villages tended to be quiet and isolated, and so their young people had a tendency to catch wanderlust and leave at a fairly young age, with the army being a popular destination. Odds were these boys had decided that they were mature enough to leave the nest, and so they’d set out in search of honor and glory. And, odds were, they’d probably be back home much humbler before spring."

just descrive they are dressed like farmers, have tan skin and rough hands, and let them talk and brag the rest. let jasmin think quietly to herself that they'll be much humbler by spring.
plot transmitted through actions, or through dialog, or otherwise, is more interesting.
for example, when the lord dog and prince arrived, it was far more interesting and read much easier, as the dog told his story and jasmin responded. that dialog was funny and informative and interesting.
also, youve done a great description at the apearance of the prince and dog. including the funny fall.

thats all i can think about.. i'm not much of a writer myself, i never wrote a whole story, short or long, this is but my opinion as a reader. i hope you found my review helpful.

good luck with the book, im waiting for the next chapter..

drawerwrite.
27
27
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
i cant imagin the colorful and happy universe in which that dounut shop exist, so i have to reason it with an infatuation that makes everything as shiny as in the Teletubbies world.
that tension between real and will makes the poem in my opinion.
28
28
Review of Bridge Mix  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
yuck. is it a true story?

well written :)
29
29
Review of rag bag  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
cool poem, reminds me i should do the same in my closet... i think you just gave me the inspiration i needed for that mission...

other then that,
the poem has a large veriety of interesting adjectives and a thoughtful notion for the meaning clothing holds as personality makers..
30
30
Review of LOVE SONG  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
hi,
liked the rhyming..
31
31
Review of Confustication  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
so cooll how did you do it?
32
32
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
funny!
33
33
Review by Einav
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
hi harry,
i never read a free verse poem so prosaic, to turn it into a short story all you have to do is connect all the lines.. it's very interesting, i like it.
the subject of the poem is also interesting. the reduction of the need for manial workers in westren society by moving overseas, persumably raise lifestyle, but really deprives people of getting a job they love doing. life is odd.

drawerwrite.

34
34
Review of The Angel Lounge  
Review by Einav
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Hi there,
i just came to say hello angels... and have a nice day :)
35
35
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
hi,
just did a littel read over the Wardenclyffe tower on wikipedia and learned something new..
very cool subject.
very cool poem.

but the link does'nt work.

write on!
36
36
Review of The Chair  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (5.0)
neat :)
37
37
Review of The Beholder  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (4.0)
hello :)

the poem's visual shape is pretty, it lookes sort of like a tulip...
the poem's atmosphear is very warm and dark, the way we feel when there's someone safe and reliable to give protection.

you repeat the main subject in many words.
-on the one hand, i did'nt want the repetition to end, because you've managed to emphasise the subject while never repeating a phraze.
-on the other hand, the poem is very heavy. the heaviness does emphasise the subject of security and comfort, but in my personal opinion, it's also a bit daunting.

the title is beutiful.

write on!
38
38
Review of The Meeting  
Review by Einav
Rated: E | (4.0)
hi,
that was so cute! and unexpected..
the poem is very clear, easy and fun. i loved the personification.
it's difficult to write like that, to get it all neatly, but you did an awsome job. on the whole, i got the important bits at the first read, but at certain parts the rhyming's uncouth, specially at the first stanza of the apple, i've had to read it three times till i got it. that's just my personal opinion.


write on!!!

((drawerwrite))
38 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 2 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/drawerwrite/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2