Hi, I found this little treasure in the emotional genre. I am not a poet and cannot review from that perspective.
I write limited poem reviews because they have to be at a very high level in order to capture my attention and want to read them. Your title and teaser caught my attention, your writing kept it.
Truly, all I look for in a poem is cadence and whether it captures an emotion. And this one did. I send e-hugs because the pain experienced is beautifully expressed. Not a happy poem, but you did not let the pain overtake your expression.
I don't know how you got away with a 13+ rating when it seems like it is talking about slicing wrists, or seems to. That aside, it is a beautifully written poem, thank you for sharing. The genre ratings are spot on. I like that you set off some of the stanzas in blood red. It worked to get the point across.
As always, these are just my opinions and should not influence your voice as a poet.
Hi, I found this little gem in the friendship genre. I do not write poetry so I am not the best judge of whether to rate it as poetry or prose. All I know is that it is quite good and that I would not change it.
I selected this poem to review based on the title and your teaser.
When reading poetry, all I look for is cadence and whether the word selection and placement strike a chord in me. The wording and cadence took me back to a more Victorian and innocent time. It is your gift and your talent to lay out the poem in a beautiful and charming way.
Hello! I found your story in the Emotional Genre....Your teaser and title caught my attention and prompted me to attempt to give it a decent review.
What a tremendous tale! It was so good, I forgot to turn the editing button on. This is so well done -- I can see the kids and the layout of the town so clearly. I can see the vibe of the town's people and the arrogance of the town council. My brother found my grandmother when she died and his reaction was exactly like that of the boys -- run to the parents.
There were no obvious oopsies or oh no's in the punctuation and grammar. It helps to be spot on in that area so that there are no distractions for the reader. I cannot pick out a favorite line, but my favorite theme is that the father loved and trusted his kids and acted fearlessly to do what he could to protect them. Small town life is so vivid in this story. We really do look for excitement in every crevice and then when we find it, we have to tell the tale so often until the next excitement grabs our interest, and we really do get bored of the telling really fast, don't we?
My overall impression: I have a limited list of favorite authors and you are on that list. Wow! Simply wow!. Thanks for sharing.
On a more personal note ... Since this is biographical, I will treat it as a truthful account -- I thank your father for his service to your country and your family for the sacrifices in the waiting for his safe return.
Hello, I found this in the emotional genre section. Of course the title got me right off. The award was the second incentive to attempt to give it a decent review.
I was right there in an imaginary trance devouring the chocolates right along with the lady. I would have skipped the dark chocolate but that's just me. I can still savor another person's delight.
The punctuation and grammar was spot on. The word choice was exceptional. This award was well deserved. I don't know if the story arose from a picture prompt or the picture found after the story, but adding the picture was super smart. It captured my curiosity on what was in that box.
I see that this was written a while ago. You should be proud that your work stands the test of time. Kudos.
I found your story in the relationship genre section. I choose this one to review because of the teaser and the title. Could do without the red lettering because i have old eyes. Does it work to get you noticed?
First off, I appreciate the military and all the sacrifices that have to made to make relationships work. Young love is always the strongest, and most impulsive. If this is based on real events, I hope the kids stayed together through it all.
You have a unique writer's voice. Without destroying your voice, I think these things can be addressed without altering the course of the story.
door she, talked to us and took [can take the comma out]
living in the their home [take out the]
to short to go to Vietnam [too short]
The grammar and punctuation are not what I would do, but then the story would go off center if you changed it. I think that's part of the reason why i liked it so much. It really works to show two teenagers trying to figure it out. Times have sure changed, I like the way you showcased that in your story.
Overall this was an excellent work capturing the way teenagers in the 60s behaved, talked, you know? Like that.
found your story in the genre section. It was the first one that caught my eye that was not a poem. Yea, you.
These are just my impressions, use them if they work for you and ignore them if they don't.
I know people who are in the dating game after exiting a not working marriage and being alone for a long time. This hesitancy and nervousness is exactly what it is like.
Keeping the setting vague allows for the story to be any coffee shop, anywhere at anytime. It kept the focus on the drift that was going on with the main character's reminiscing and checking out the new patrons.
When the story is compelling I turn off the editing button. Although you do not punctuate the way I would, it is still acceptable. I did notice one typo...
I started to think about Steve, were did it all go wrong, [where did it all go wrong?]
The next story you post, please do this: highlight the whole thing, look for the icon that says sss and then select 4 or greater. This small print is hard to read. I normally skip stories with small print, but I was intrigued by the teaser and wanted to see where it would go. Making a romance/love story with a comedic subplot is not an easy task. I enjoyed what you did with this twist on the romance genre.
I found your story in the romance newsletter. You don't need me to tell you this is a good story, just know that it is. Other than putting punctuation differently than I would, there is really nothing that I would change structurally.
Only one little technical suggestion that you might want to consider -- help me sort out what is self talk and what is not, maybe put the self talk in italics to set it apart a little. Or you can tell me to mind my own business. It's all choice.
So off I go to other tasks. Looking forward to more of your work.
Oh, that's so sad. Spend your life trying to find your place in the world and there is no place. Living your life with stuff you hate, and only for people that don't treat you well, being laughed at. So sad. Glad the main character found a moment's peace on the earth, even if it was only a moment.
I like your writing very much. I like the way you present the characters, the setting. I like the way you took the time to make sure the punctuation and grammar was perfect.
Would like to have a bigger font for my old eyes.
I am a new fan of yours. Very good job. Looking forward to more of your work.
Saw your piece in the HUB and thought I'd try to give a decent review.
Even though I despise drug dealers, and don't want to like your story for that reason, I found my attention held for the entire piece -- every line, every word.
I got each character and wanted to hate on both of them, but found a bit to like in each character that you have. Not an easy task, but you set that down quite well. I got the setting and the tie in and applaud you for nailing it.
rating and drama are spot on. I have old eyes, would have appreciated a larger font.
I think the place will burn down from the duck being in the fryer too long so Li won't have to worry about police. JMO I like clilffhangers where you get to wonder what happens next.
Overall: I like your work immensely. If they had a sinister story contest, this one would be a good one. Maybe it was and you did win.
Thank you so much for sharing. Looking forward to more stuff. I am a new fan for sure.
I saw your piece on the HUB. I am not a poetry buff and maybe am not a good judge of this. If a layman's opinion is what you want, I can give you that. I prefer poetry that has rhyme and meter, since that is not what yours is about all I can do is give my opinion on content.
The title would not have drawn me to your piece. I am only here because you asked for honest opinions in your request for reviews. Genre and ratings are appropriate.
I get that you are the tree. But unless this tree is on the ocean, it has no way of knowing what a ship on the ocean looks like.
I know why you used the senses, but I do not have a frame of reference to know how the tree has a mouth or eyes. For instance you say the tree screamed. I don't have a frame of reference for that. You say, Missed by inches. How could the tree tell that?
These are just my layman's observations. I hope it helps to see things through my simple eyes.
You are the artist, you can use these suggestions or toss them, it's all choice.
I found this little gem in one of the newsletters. I was laughing the whole way through. It is so good I did not have to turn on the editing button. I see it was written a while ago, thank you for sharing your lessons learned.
You sure can tell a story. I am getting the idea that the only way to stay in the word count limits of these flash fiction things is through dialogue and fast pacing. Nice little twist at the very end.
Looking forward to more of the stuff that sifts through your brain and onto paper.
I found your work as part of the Wodehouse challenge. I normally do not review in this genre, so forgive me if I do not “get” it.
Starting out with positives: You have this fantastic ability to lay out the characters and story in clean unadulterated lines. The story was woven together cleanly and I could follow it most of the time. You have an interesting turn of phrase that kept me interested in where the story was going.
Despite this being a strong story, I turned on the editing button for a brief bit at the following things:
What do you think your [you are = you’re] Just a pet peeve I have…
Your awake.” [you are = you’re] Same pet peeve I have…
about drinkin’. [forgot close quotes] sorry, editing button is overlooking a lot, just not this.
your kinda okay [hint: my pet peeve]
But if your not back I can’t send the troopers [pet peeve]
Sometimes you indent paragraphs and sometimes not, if that is artist signature, leave it == if not, fix it. You do not punctuate the way I would == drop commas all over the place. It does not detract from the story, just interrupts the flow a little.
I personally think this is a little more graphic than 18+, but then this has been around for a long time and I guess smarter people than me are okay with it.
Overall: Strong start, strong finish, and lots of interesting stuff in between. Excellent work.
You know I always like your writing and the direction your stories play out.
I like the character descriptions and the way you lay out the plot. I usually do not question the artist's word choice or punctuation unless it is quite obvious. Here are just a couple items that stopped the flow of the story and you may want to consider addressing in your own unique way.
The smell of his cologne lingered in his nose. [her nose]
She slid her hands up her sides along the same path his warm, firm, hands. [missing word?]
and attempts to seduce her [did you mean attempt to be plural?]
I found this story in the newsletter and loved the title. Read the story and found it really funny. You don't need me to add my five star to the rest of your collection, but this story deserves it. Kudos
cheri
I like your poetry. I can't do poetry myself and appreciate those that have the gift. I like everything from the title to the word choice and laying out the emotions.
I am reviewing this item at the author's request. I usually don't do poetry because I don't get. With that disclaimer in play, I make the following observations.
When you have a short poem the title has to be tight. I probably would have passed on this had it not been for the specific request, only because it sounds confrontational and I am not in the mood for confrontation at Christmastime.
That aside, when I look at a poem, I expect it to lay out much like song lyrics, where there is a cadence and formulated rhyming pattern. I got the cadence and I got that most of the stanzas have some form of rhyme (albeit none of them are the same pattern).
What I liked is that you took on words that would be hard to find rhymes for. You have a good vocabulary. I like that you had a point of view and were not afraid to say it.
What I did not like is that it comes off as self-righteous. I grew up in the 60's, an era that invented self-righteous. If you want to leave the adult reader irritated, you did that.
So you wish all adults were dead? I hope your parents and older family members are out of your radar. I was young once. Probably had the same arrogant smugness you do. If that is the reaction you wanted, you hit your mark. If not, you missed it.
Hello, I found this little gem as part of the power reviewers’ anniversary thingy. Happy Anniversary. Characters: The main character was quite well done. I’ve known a few who have the same resistance to taking chances. The minor characters were pretty obscure, as they needed to be to keep the focus on the main character. Plot Line: The title says it all. The plot paced and expressed at the same rhythm as the main character, which I thought was pretty unique. Technical: Thank you for taking the time and energy to post a clean work of art. Thank you for bumping up the font and choose a font face that allows for easy readability. I don’t get experience as a genre choice, but the ratings and other two genres were well chosen. Overall: I can definitely see your author signature in the way you turn a phrase and present your story. Thank you for not going for the happy ending. All the way through I was demanding that he go back to the cove (it was a silent scream) and that time had somehow stood still. Felt a little deflated at the end that the good guy did not get to win or get a second chance. You hit the mark you were shooting for. Good job.
All Writing.Com images are copyrighted and may not be copied / modified in any way. All other brand names & trademarks are owned by their respective companies.
Generated in 0.27 seconds at 2:13am on May 23, 2024 via server web1.