*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/falling_rain
Review Requests: OFF
21 Public Reviews Given
311 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
1
1
Review by rain
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
This was one contest I felt really got me into the habit of writing daily. All it took was 15 minutes a day but it got me accustomed to sitting down and actually penning out something. The prompts were always interesting and usually the problem I faced was having too many ideas to know which one to pick! The prizes are awesome too - daily AND an overall prize!

All in all a very useful contest and one I think everyone who has 15 minutes to spare for just 15 days should join!
2
2
Review of Texted  
Review by rain
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
*Heart*Hello there!*Heart*

OVERALL RATING:*Star**Star**Star**Star**Halfstar*

*Flower3*What I liked*Flower3*


*Thumbsup*I think this was a very good start. It caught my attention and made me laugh throughout. I thought it was brave of you to attempt to toggle the narrators' points of view here. Normally that could either go really badly or really well. I thought it went really well here.

*Thumbsup*I love the internal dialogue that's going on. It really brings out the sense of humour of your two main characters and I find that really helps me relate. Plus it makes me giggle through the entire piece.

*Cut**Paste*What I Felt Could Be Changed*Paste**Cut*

*Exclaim*Some of the internal dialogue seems to be a little bit redundant to the piece (even though it IS madly funny), however this is a rough draft and I think with editing, and with more chapters getting written, you'll be able to organise everything and take out whatever doesn't need to be there and put in new things.

*Exclaim*It's tricky when you use real brand names like Halo. Maybe you could come up with a pretend-video game and allude to the fact that it's a huge game.

*Balloon5*My Thoughts*Balloon5*

*Note1*I sincerely think this was a good read. I would definitely read all the other chapters you have up. Romance novels can be borderline cheesy once in a while but with all the humour you've injected into this, I think you've managed to make this very good indeed. I'd recommend this to anyone who was into comedy or romance, or both.



rain
3
3
Review of Chapter 1  
Review by rain
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
*Heart*Hello there!*Heart*

OVERALL RATING:*Star**Star**Star**Star*

*Flower3*What I liked*Flower3*


*Thumbsup*Good storyline, it's interesting and I'd definitely like to read more.

*Thumbsup*I like the way you've developed the characters. It's early on in the story, but I can see how they work, what they're like, already. Good job!

*Thumbsup*The dialogue is funny and witty. I liked the banter between Peter and Lucille when they had that bet going on about the beer rounds. :)

*Cut**Paste*What I Felt Could Be Changed*Paste**Cut*

*Exclaim*Some spelling/punctuation/grammar errors but very few of those in the first place. I'll pick 'em out for you in an email if you want me to, but since this is a NaNo novel, i think you weren't looking out for those nitpicky things anyway.

*Balloon5*My Thoughts*Balloon5*

*Note1*I felt this was a good start, like I said earlier, it was interesting and I really would like to read more of it. Congrats on the word count again!

Good job, and write on!

rain
4
4
Review of Monsieur Pierre  
Review by rain
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Heart*Hello there!*Heart*

OVERALL RATING:*Star*(e:star}*Star**Halfstar*

*Flower3*What I liked*Flower3*


*Thumbsup*This is a cute idea for a poem, you've formed the character of the cat well. Given you're looking for this to be an introduction for a children's book, I have to say this is interesting and innovative and something kids will probably love.

*Thumbsup*Nice description, which makes this poem very humourous indeed.

*Cut**Paste*What I Felt Could Be Changed*Paste**Cut*

*Exclaim*I was very let down by the fact that in the middle of the poem, suddenly, a line didn't rhyme. It seemed jarring and out of place. "This time travelling cat never failed" and "He solved his case every time" are examples of two such lines.

*Exclaim*Also, you need to add some punctuation like periods to denote the fact your sentences have ended. For example, "No one could tell" should have a period or an exclamation mark at the end. There are many such sentences left open in your poem.

*Balloon5*My Thoughts*Balloon5*

*Note1*I like the concept of this poem, it is appealing, amusing, Monsieur Pierre is extremely personable, but I feel you have to be consistent with the rhyming and the punctuation to make this a really good poem. Having a consistent rhyme scheme is specially important since it's for a children's book and they will respond to something like that better.

Good job, though, and write on!

rain
5
5
Review by rain
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Heart*Hello there!*Heart*

OVERALL RATING:*Star**Star**Star**Star*

*Flower3*What I liked*Flower3*

*Thumbsup*I like the perspective you took with this poem, how the rain has no prejudices, doesn't discriminate, falls on everyone.

*Thumbsup*Nice use of personification, especially of the rose and the grass, I liked those images.

*Thumbsup*No grammatical errors, nice layout.

*Cut**Paste*What I Felt Could Be Changed*Paste**Cut*

*Exclaim*The title doesn't cut it for me, it seems to simplify the meaning of your poem, at least to me, as the all-encompassing influence of the rain goes beyond politics.

*Exclaim*I liked the way you made comparisons between the poor and the wealthy, the white man and the black man, but I felt it was too obvious, too stark a contrast. Something more subtle might have worked better here.

*Balloon5*My Thoughts*Balloon5*

*Note1*This was well written with many personal touches added that helped me appreciate this poem. As I mentioned above, I like what you brought out about the rain, I think it's something we should all think about. Lots of imagery, most of them were nicely added, but some parts were forced in to show the similarities between two extremes, I felt.

Good job, write on!

rain
5 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 1 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/falling_rain