*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/improg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: OFF
127 Public Reviews Given
400 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- ... Next
26
26
Review of Popularity Love  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I see that you have done a lot to this since I last read it. Keep it up. *Smile*

I like your dialog. You have a lot and as I mentioned to you before, dialog is good -- it let's us relate to the characters.

The two things I would recommend still working on is setting up your scenes. Let us get a glimpse of where your characters are. You don't need a lot, but give us some description so that we can place ourselves there. It doesn't have to be anything strange, even. But if you mention something that we can relate to, it will be more real for us.

Then other suggestion I have is to add more conflict. We need tension. We have a little, but give us more. Have Tomas do something that turns Kim off after she starts falling for him. Have her battle with whether she wants to go forward. Have Tomas get scared as Kim pulls away. Does he try harder, does he give up in defeat. Have moments like this and then have them get together. *Smile*

You are doing a great job and I look forward to watching your progress and then buying your books. *Smile*

Tom
27
27
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I just noticed that I forgot to rate and review this. I hope you don't mind, but I plugged this on "The Shameless "Plug" Page because I think everyone should read this. I'm not even looking at the grammer or spelling as what I like about this story is how it opens our eyes to an important safety issue.

Good job and here's your five.

Tom
28
28
Review of The Watercourse  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Quick Opinion


*Star* This is an interesting story.

What Works


*Star* You have believable dialog. The kids sound like kids with all the double-negatives and sentence fractures we would expect.

*Star* For the most part, the story flows consistently. There is one part, that I will get to later when I felt it dragged, but other than that it flowed well.

Suggestions


*Star* ...direction enclosing them in an enveloping gloom.

I think you need a comma after direction.

*Star* As the children back backed away,

*Star* It was no more than a dozen yards from him when Zak’s gazed gaze locked ...

*Star* ...her to the dirt like a thin torn sheet.

I think you need a comma after thin.

*Star* You remember me, Beth. Oh . . . how I love you.

Isn't the daughter's name Penny?

*Star* In the beginning of the story where the kids are confused about where they are, I felt you had more conversation than was necessary to bring that point home. That conversation was the only place in the story where I felt it didn't flow that well.

Overall


*Star* I am giving you 4.5 *Smile* The story was interesting and I didn't find too many grammatical errors.
29
29
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (4.5)
Quick Opinion


*Star* I liked this romantic ode to your love. *Smile*

What Works


*Star* Your rhymes are pretty good. Some would ding your for rhyming plane and shame. Now, I'm not one of them, but I thought I'd mention it.

*Star* I love this part:

Our future is carved, in this we rejoice.
Listen to the sound of your lover's voice,
Loud and serene, like the morning dove
“Marry me, live with me, and be my love”.


Suggestions


*Star* Tender moments approaching, seen in your eyes,

You have a consistent meter up to this point. Read your poem fast and I think you'll catch it. It isn't a huge issue, some people like to throw in a different meter here and there for flavor, but I felt it was a distraction.

*Star* “The little death” shows, on your face,

The location of the interior comma throws off your meter once again. I would just lose it altogether as without it, we automatically can pick up the beat.

*Star* First seconds alone, calm and eloquent,

Another loss of meter here. I think it would be good to try brainstorming some small wording changes to keep up the 1/2 beat you maintain through the majority of the poem.

*Star* I would lose the end of line punctuation. You don't have any lines that continue from one line to the next without a natural pause, so the punctuation isn't necessary.

Overall


*Star* I am giving you a 4.5 *Smile* Since most of the issues I mentioned are all related to the same, meter, and since the diction of the poem itself is very nice, I am not knocking off more than the .5
30
30
Review by Thomas
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Quick Opinion


*Star* I have found the story to be interesting. With just the prologue and now the first chapter reviewed, I really don't have anything to mention about plot or character development, but if something either especially touching or especially glaring pops out at me, I'll mention it. For now, you have an engaging story that just has some grammatical things to look at. *Smile*

What Works


*Star* Again, your dialog is very believable. *Smile*

*Star* I like the inclusion of a bit of actual history -- it gives your story verisimilitude.

*Star* Your descriptions are very good. It is easy to picture myself in the forest at night as those two guys approach. *Smile*

Suggestions


*Star* was a hurried march, almost militant as she kept up her pace.

You need a comma after militant.

*Star* In the second paragraph you have five almost identically structured, compound sentences and only one simple one. I would try to break up one more of the sentences.

*Star* The 18th century was an exciting, yet brutal time.

Lose the comma.

*Star* Although the era intrigued Kyla, enough for her to take a job at the University in London to teach history, she never could quite grasp the mentality of the Highlanders…not like her mother could.

You don't need the first comma. This is the second error like this I have seen you made in a rather small amount of story. The key is to read it out loud and see if it would have a pause during conversational speech. If you want the pause after Kyla, you need to use a hyphen or semi-colon instead. *Smile*

*Star* The land could barely grow grain and famine wiped most of them those out even after the battles.

You also need to put a comma after grain.

*Star* your own rule…to live with freedom as they did now.

Replace the ellipsis with a hyphen.

*Star* She found the marker she was looking for. A large boulder jutting...

Replace the period with a hyphen.

*Star* She had been prepared for her mother to die before her, but not like this, not so soon.

Replace the second comma with a hyphen or semi-colon.

*Star* heart wouldn’t come, it never did.

Change the comma to either a hyphen or semicolon, or end the sentence after come and start a new one.

*Star* She was used to talking to her mother still, even though she never got a response. It wasn’t all that much different when her mother was alive.

These two sentences are confusing. Do you mean still as in calmly or as a chronological reference? I think it is the latter, and if so, add a comma after mother and change the period after response to a comma.

*Star* The final resting place of Margaret Marie Logan, as it should be, she thought.

What did she think? Did she think the whole sentence or just as it should be? You might want to itallicize what she thinks or use quotes.

*Star* Kyla said and knelt next to her mother placing the flowers on her grave, “just as I promised you.”

You need a comma after mother

*Star* Biting her nails as she sat next to her mother, she felt the cold ground seep through her jeans freezing her knee caps.

You need a comma after jeans.

*Star* Kyla remembered the names from years gone by, Charles and Emily Logan.

Change the comma to a hyphen.

*Star* Her stomach growled loudly notifying her it was time to head back.

You need a comma after loudly.

*Star* She returned to her mother’s grave and laid her hand on the mound one last time then she stood to leave.

Put a semi-colon after time.

*Star* The fog was thick as she walked up the hill in the twilight, the gloaming as her mother called it.

Change the comma to a hyphen and put a comma after gloaming.

*Star* Tilting her head upwards, she saw the first star appear and she closed her eyes making her wish.

You need a comma after eyes.

*Star* his face and his crystal green eyes glowed in the moonlight.

You need a comma after crystal.

*Star* ...showing long muscular legs and his heavy cloak was wrapped up over his large comforting chest.

You need a comma after legs.

*Star* Kyla sat up and looked into the open closet where her 18th century, maroon gown was waiting for her, another silly tradition that her mother insisted upon.

Replace the second comma with a hyphen or semi-colon.

*Star* The first year she’d be celebrating the New Year alone.

This is a fragment. Maybe start it with This is instead.

*Star* Her stomach growled reminding her that she still hadn’t even eaten yesterday.

You need a comma after growled.

*Star* She took the time to brush out her straight highlighted hair.

Comma agter straight.

*Star* She wanted a change it would just take a little time to get used to.

Either end the sentence after change or put in a hyphen or semi-colon.

*Star* Her pockets held money, lipstick and mascara and, of course, her journal.

Lose the first and and put a comma after lipstick.

*Star* Previous year’s entries usually stared with: “Mother and I…,”

Lose the comma.

*Star* Kyla mourned the loss of her friend, her mother and her confidant.

Also, in American English, which this may not be, I belive the current standard is to use a comma before the last item in a series. *Smile*

*Star* face and freezing her lungs causing her to take in shallow breaths.

You need a comma after lungs.

*Star* The aroma of Meat meat pies and fried herring wafted towards toward her mixed with the smell of the sea.

You also need a comma after her.

*Star* She headed out of the pub when after the bartender shook his head at her after when she ordered one more too many and searched out a new pub, which wasn’t hard to find.

You also need a comma after many.

*Star* She bent over with her hands on her knees breathing heavily watching large clouds of steam leave her mouth.

You need a comma after knees and one after heavily.

*Star* She reached her hand, under her hair, behind her head and brushed them down .

Lose the first comma and place one after head.

*Star* She knew it was a panic attack, Professor Sullivan had told her what it was.

Change the comma to a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* Kyla was fully sweating as she ran faster, sprinting towards Tron Kirk where the crowd was growing thicker.

Comma after Kirk.

*Star* “Maybe somewhere down the line.” She answered glancing at Kyla with an appraising look. “My name is MacFarlane, Heather MacFarlane.”

Your pronouns are a bit ambiguous. In the sentence before the one I listed, She was referring to Kyla and without redirecting the story's focus, it is now referring to the young lady.

*Star* Professor Sullivan always listened and always had the same answer, “seek counseling Kyla,” he would tell her.

Start a new sentence after answer.

*Star* Kyla loved his eyes, more violet than hazel, he always seemed to know the right thing to say to her.

Replace the first comma with a hyphen or semi-colon and replace the second with a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* He had scratched his clean shaven chin and nodded, he did believe in premonitions, but he didn’t think that’s what Kyla was experiencing.

Start a new sentence after nodded.

*Star* He spoke used words like “post traumatic stress syndrome” and “depression”.

*Star* She continued to stroll down the street while looking back up the hill.

*Star* Dim yellow lights encircled with yellow mist from the moisture laden air lit up the street encircled with yellow mist from the moisture laden air.

Comma after lights and after air.

*Star* The crowd thickened into a ball. Like bees returning to their queen, they buzzed looking up to the large wooden cross.

You need a comma after buzzed.

*Star* She rubbed them together bringing her fingers warmth from friction as her focus stayed on the castle.

You need a comma after together and after friction.

*Star* It seemed to pull her to it, as if her feed feet moved without conscious thought.

*Star* She put her face up just in time for a large crystal to float down and land on her cheek melting instantly.

You need a comma after cheek.

*Star* Spinning faster than her vision could keep up with and with the blinding light tearing through her brain, Kyla began to scream.

*Star* Pain seared through her body as she clutched the stone tightly feeling as if her insides were trying to come out.

You need a comma after tightly.

*Star* A narrow tunnel filled with colors came into view filled with colors.

*Star* Kyla fought with her hands and her feet, she clutched the stone harder as the tunnel pulled her into it.

Replace the comma with a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* Her bones began to shatter, her muscles collapsed.

Replace the comma with an and.

*Star* Kyla tried to grasp something, anything but the sides were smooth.

You need a comma after anything.

*Star* She lifted her head still shrieking as the room changed from the castle to a forest.

You need a comma after head and after shrieking.

*Star* “What in God’s name is the matter with ye?” He he asked looking as confused as she felt.

Put a comma after asked.

*Star* “I think I’m a little lost.” She she whispered through her sore throat.

Also, change the period after lost to a comma.

*Star* The next five sentences after the one I just corrected have the exact same error. When you are quoting someone and then using she whispered or she said or the like, you put a comma at the end of the quote instead of a period. Also, if you are using a pronoun with your dialog tag, then you don't capitalize it. It would be he said instead of He said The only time you don't use a comma is if the person made an exclamation or asked a question. Then you would use the proper mark.

*Star* It was the Stone of Destiny, The the stone that...

Overall


*Star* I am giving you a four. I think the story itself, deserves higher, but the number of grammatical issues I found mean I have to knock some off. Keep up the great story-telling, though. *Smile*
31
31
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Quick Opinion


*Star* This is a very engaging story that has A LOT of grammatical errors. Most of the errors are easy to make, but you are doing yourself a disservice by not cleaning up your story a little better before posting it. You are a FANTASTIC writer, so please, take the time to clean up the technical aspects of your writing. *Smile*

What Works


*Star* You maintained the tension from the opening sentence until the final word. Good job! *Smile*

*Star* Your dialog is very believable. I didn't once have to stop and think, "that doesn't sound believable." Another Good Job! *Smile*

*Star* I could see the scenes. You didn't bore me with a plethora of flowery words, yet I wasn't grasping for a glimpse of where this was taking place. Nice work. *Smile*

Suggestions


*Star* Most of the issues I found were grammatical in nature. There were quite a few and I am lowering my rating on account of them. Take the time to clean this up, however, and you will have a beautifully riveting story. *Smile*

*Star* Her palms began to sweat, she could hear her heart beat in her ears or was it adrenaline?

The comma is not strong enough. Use a hyphen, semi-colon, or a period instead. *Smile*

*Star*She was alone, again.

No comma needed.

*Star* There was just something about living in the middle of nowhere on a ten acre lot with nothing but thick brush and lakes that terrified her. she She didn’t know why, but soon would.

*Star* Jim sighed heavily rolling his eyes.

You need a comma. I am guessing it wold be after heavily. Did he sigh heavily and then roll his eyes or did he sigh and the roll his eyes heavily? See what I mean? *Smile*

*Star* “I just don’t feel right about it.” she shrugged feeling the hair on her arms rise like tiny soldiers.

Replace the period after it with a comma.

*Star* She looked around her heart sinking, he never believed her.

Was she sinking or her heart? If it was her heart, put sinking before heart. If it was her, then move the comma from after sinking to after heart.

*Star* “We’ll take it.” he said to the realtor before she could protest more.

Replace the period after it with a comma. You do this a lot. The only time you put end of sentence punctuation before a he said/she sai for a quotation is when it is a question or exclamation point. If it is a sentence that would end in a period, put a comma instead.

*Star* She started to adjust, started her writing again.

The comma isn't strong enough. Use a hyphen or a semi-colon instead. You have an independent clause followed by a dependent one. To connect the two with a comma, change the second started to its gerund form. She started to adjust, starting her writing again. That sounds clunky though. I would just change the comma to a semi-colon and be done with it. *Smile*

*Star* Karin thought the deal was too good to be true little did she know

I would end the sentence with true and then start a new one with Little.

*Star* When she opened the door, the hair on the back of her neck rose arose, feeling as if a million ants were climbing from her hair down to her back.

*Star* A woman stared back at her with black empty eyes.

You need a comma after black.

*Star* The wind had picked up, yet her ankle length, purple dress didn’t move, neither did her long hair.

The final comma needs to be a hyphen or a semi-colon.

*Star* “Not this again!” she said aloud.

Do we need to know this was aloud?

*Star* Karin had what most would call a “second sight,” seeing things others did not.

Put second sight in italics instead of double quotes and change the comma to a hyphen or semi-colon.

*Star* Passed down from her mother, Karin despised it.

This sentence is saying that Karin was passed down from her mother. I am pretty sure that wasn't your intent. *Smile*

*Star* Jim couldn’t understand it, couldn’t take it anymore.

You need stronger punctuation here. Change the comma to a hyphen or semi-colon.

*Star* She was a writer and a good one at that.

Put a hyphen or a semi-colon after writer.

*Star* Physically shaking off the sighting, Karin did the only thing she could. She wrote about her.

I woulud replace the period after could with a hyphen or semi-colon instead.

*Star* The palm trees swayed back and forth sounding like the waves of the ocean.

Comma after forth.

*Star* It was becoming clearer now, more Indians.

Change comma to a hyphen or semi-colon.

*Star* Breaking the trance of the Indian warrior she bent down to put her head between her legs to make the sickness go away when she saw her.

Put a comma after warrior. The rest of the sentence seems to me, to contain too much information. Try revising it -- maybe breaking it into two sentences. *Smile*

*Star* She jumped up spilling her hot milk on her lap causing her to scream in pain.

Comma after up and after lap.

*Star* Karin looked at her mouth instinctively, but again, her mouth did not move.

Lose the second comma.

*Star* She glared at Karin sending waves of nausea through her as her stomach clenched.

You need a comma after Karin.

*Star* Running back into the house she ran right into him in the hallway.

You need a comma after house.

*Star* “We are not wanted here.” she said in fear.

Replace the period after here with a comma.

*Star* Jim sighed heavily having heard this too many times.

Put a comma after heavily.

*Star* She passed by Jackie’s room, she was sleeping peacefully, thankfully no nightmares tonight.

You need to separate the middle clause with hyphens or semi-colons instead of commas. Or, you could divide this into two sentences. *Smile*

*Star* Her face seemed to come alive as it stared from the page at Karin.

*Star* “Murdered on their own land” she read it over and over with the woman staring back at her.

Put an exclamation point after land and start a new sentence with She.

*Star* Pacing in her office, she knew they meant business. They were in great danger here.

You have two uses of they where they each seem to point to a different group. Try to make these sentences clearer. *Smile*

*Star* Obviously this particular tribe did not want them there and she wasn’t sure what would happen to them if she couldn’t convince her husband to leave.

Put a comma after obviously and after there

*Star* Suddenly she dropped to the floor, she couldn’t breathe.

Change the comma to a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* “I’ll…I’ll be right there.” she croaked.

Change the period after there to a comma.

*Star* Not speaking to her mother she sat in the passenger seat with her arms folded in front of her.

You need a comma after mother.

*Star* “The school called me, I couldn’t leave work and I’ve been calling here for hours! Where the hell have you been?”

Change the comma after me to either a hyphen, semi-colon, or a period.

*Star* “The Indians, they want us out of here and one way or another; they are going to win!”

Switch the comma and the semi-colon around. *Smile*

*Star* Karin could see her, Jim could not.

Replace the comma with a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* The slices on Jackie’s face became visible to Jim,; the attacker was not.

*Star* Jim grabbed Jackie into his arms and snatched Karin’s hand as they ran for the car.

*Star* seeing they weren’t all that deep, Karin pressed on the cuts with her shirt to stop the bleeding., seeing they weren’t all that deep.

*Star* “Jesus!” was all she heard from Jim again as he sped off.

The again sounds clunky and spurious. I know what you are trying to say, but try revising this. Just for the record, this is a passive sentence as well. Now, I'm not a stickler for never using passive verbs, but you might want to keep it mind as a lot of editors hate the passive voice.

*Star* Karin could see the trees swaying from side to side but her long dress didn’t move. She smiled holding up her bloody knife in one hand and waved good-bye with the other.

Who was it that was holding up the bloody knife? By the way you have this worded, it seems that Karin has it. *Smile*

*Star* She saw Jim glance in the rear view mirror but could tell he saw nothing, he was just mentally saying goodbye.

Exchange the comma for a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* Karin got up out of bed in the tiny apartment that was much more to her liking. Surrounded by people, she felt safer. She couldn’t sleep, still thinking of that horrible day. Sitting down at her computer, she decided to do some writing. She felt a hand come across her shoulder, making her jump.

You have a lot of very similarly structured sentences, one right after the other. You have done a fine job of mixing up your sentence structure in the rest of the piece, so do it here as well. *Smile*

*Star* “I’m sorry I didn’t believe you Karin,” he said sitting down next to her holding a hot cup of milk, he knew it calmed her nerves.

Put an and before holding and change the final comma to either a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* “Could this price actually be right?” she beamed.

You have her beaming words. I think you should reword this so that she can say her words and then beam. *Smile*

*Star* Tom looked around, he was surprised too.

You need to replace the comma with a hyphen, semi-colon, or period.

*Star* “I just don’t feel right about it.” she tried again.

Replace the period after it with a comma.

*Star* “We’ll take it.” he said to the realtor.

Replace the period after it with a comma.

Overall


*Star* I am giving you a three point five. I also want to let you know that your story is easily a four point five, but you need to clean up the grammatical errors. If you do, send me an email and will renew you anew. *Smile*
32
32
Review of Dishonestly Yours  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Quick Opinion

*Star* This is a very strong piece that isn't as powerful as it could be. With a little tender loving care, this poem would easily be a five in all of it's multi-starred glory. *Smile*

What Works

*Star* The emotions are intense. I can feel the hurt and regret as though I were going through the same.

*Star* Your rhymes are perfect without leaning too much on the cliched pairs.

*Star* This is my favorite part:

Whispered passions of the nights
Tight embraces, lusted rights.
Crows the cock, morning’s here,
Fickled feelings, tainted fear.


The rhymes are good, the meter is tight, and the feelings are rich. I also like the way it looks centered. *Smile*

Suggestions

*Star* My first suggestion is to take a time and work on the meter. You have a rhyming poem that begs for flow -- a beat. The flow is lost, however, by the inconsistent meter. Try saying this fast out loud. Noctice the areas where your tongue trips and see if you can work on those areas.

*Star* Your maliced hatreds in disguise.
Fickled feelings, tainted fear.


Fickled and maliced are not actually words. No problem here, considering the whole poetic license concept, but I thought I should point this out.

Overall

*Star* I am giving you a 4.5 as I really like this poem and I think you are fully capable of tweeking the meter and if you don't you will still have a nice poem. If you do, however, drop me a line and I will review you anew. *Smile*
33
33
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (5.0)
Quick Opinion

*Star* You have accumulated a wealth of assistance for us on the topic of in and outs.

What Works

*Star* You have included a lot of detail along with examples. The two together will help anyone who is confused about in and outs to create one exactly how they want it.

Suggestions

*Star* None.

Overall

*Star* I am giving this a five both due to the time you spent formatting this to be attractive and the effort you expended in making this informational. *Smile*
34
34
Review of Caress  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Quick Opinion

*Star* Hey! I'm in public here. *Bigsmile* Nice poem to get the blood flowing. *Smile*

What Works

*Star* You have accurately described something I wish that I were doing right now. *Smile*

Suggestions

*Star* Repeating three lines in a poem that is only eleven lines to being with seems to me to be a little much. What I think you should do is to expand this. Keep the repetition, those lines are vivid and teasing, but give us a couple of more stanzas. Which leads me to...

*Star* Break this up. Keep the repeating lines as three line stanzas and then the other five lines as a stanza. Then you can add another one or two five line stanzas. *Smile* Am I being pushy? *Smile*

Overall

*Star* I like this poem. I just wish there were more of it. Flesh it out (pun intended). *Wink* I am giving you a 4.5.
35
35
Review of Shhhh!!!  
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (4.0)
Quick Opinion

*Star* I like this poem. I am still smiling about the last line.

What Works

*Star* But that doesn't mean I have to like it!

I love this. You're poem is a bit of a paradox and this line brings it full circle. Let me explain. You start with a depressing theme and then use an upbeat meter. The two would clash, but this final line ties them together and lets us see the darker humor of your poem. *Smile*

*Star* I like this set of rhymes.

But this is life inside my mind,
coupled with these corny rhymes
that torture me and waste my time.


You poke fun at a number of things, but here you are doing it at yourself. A parody of what you are currently doing -- I like that. *Smile*

Suggestions

*Star* or an unavoidable commercial heard.


You lost the meter here. Starting with or is part of the problem. It wouldn't be so bad, but you are losing the meter in the final line of the first stanza. It's going to stick out.

*Star* Background chaos for every task -

Here again you have lost the meter. It isn't as bad as the line above, but the culprit is the wordchaos. To keep your meter, you need a one syllable word here. I was thinking that noise might work.

*Star* The varying stanza lengths is something that I think you would benefit by addressing. Your final line is perfect and confirms the overall tongue-in-cheek tone of this piece, but I think that you could make this an even better poem with a little adjustment. I like the way that you have three lines in a row rhyme in the fourth and fifth stanzas, so I think the best thing to do would be to make the first through third be five lines long as well with the final three lines rhyming.

Overall

*Star* I like the poem, but I think it still needs some work to be a GREAT poem (but I think it could be one). I am giving you a four and the encouragment to spend a little more time polishing. *Smile*
36
36
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Quick Opinion

*Star* OK, I like it. Good job.

What Works

*Star* Your descriptions are so exquisitely written. *Smile* Like this: She screams with laughter -- Dainty white feet dodging -- As his big hands, reaching -- Grab her waist. That is beautiful in it's simplicity and in the vividness of the picture it creates. *Smile*

*Star* I like the juxtaposition between their happiness and your envy. I don't know if it really teaches us anything, but it definitely entertains.

*Star* I always enjoy repetition when used in moderation. You have just the right amount. *Smile*

Suggestions

*Star* Since you have chose to use punctuation mid-line, I think it would be a good idea to add the end of line punctuation where necessary as well.

*Star* I am not sure why, but for some reason I don't like the repetition of the last two lines. It isn't bad or anything, but I don't think it is needed since you already have the line, When I'll feel like that, repeated already. To me, I guess, it distracts.

Overall

*Star* I am giving you a 4.5. I could see raising this to a five if you were to address any of the things I brought up. On the other hand, who am I? If you like it, my complaints are very minor. *Smile*
37
37
Review of Dearest Robby  
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (5.0)
Quick Opinion

*Star* Hmm, what a fun and frisky piece. While, I am guessing that this is fiction, it seems that the writer has a good handle on the whole loving in secret concept. *Smile* Sometimes I think it would all be easier to just love in secret. *Wink* Sorry, I couldn't resist.

What Works

*Star* The surprises. Yes, the wonderful and tantalizing surprises that pop up are what makes this piece shine. When I started reading this I thought it was written by a teenager for the captain of the football team or something, but then...WHAM!...Out of nowhere we find out the fictitious author is married, happily, and has a child. Hmmm, you caught me on that one, and that is good writing. *Smile*

*Star* I like the way the fictitious author never touched the person this is written for. This cavalcade of emotions is based just on sight -- and of course the most powerful sex toy, the mind. Excellent!

*Star* Your name is like liquid honey on my tongue and I have to be careful so as not to say it aloud. Even when I am alone, I dare not speak your name, for fear of the shame that might overcome me.

I like this part a lot. Starting with the first I you portray beautifully, a person who knows that what they want is wrong, but who still wants to want. *Wink* Very well done.

Suggestions

*Star* Hey! Give me a break here. I am trying to find something I don't like or some punctuation thingy to complain about, but I honestly can't see a thing. *Smile*

Overall

*Star* I am rating this a five. If they add sixes to the rating system, I will come back and rate it that. *Wink*
38
38
Review of Anyway  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Quick Opinion

*Star* Wow! What an emotional and moving piece. I would have tears in my eyes right now if I weren't in public right now.

What Works

*Star* This part:
Keep hidden those things that would
Cause you pain. You never said it,
But I felt it anyway.


*Star* And this part:
You loved me in small ways. A hero
That rescued me when the time was right.
Caring for me incognito. No white horse, no
Shining armor. You never told me you were a knight.
But the dragon was slain anyway.


*Star* And this:
Let me give
That which heals you. You never wanted me to love you.
But, I loved you anyway.


*Star* And, especially this part:
I will not walk away from you. I will not
Walk toward. You must slay the demons.


Suggestions

*Star* None!

Overall

*Star* Here, take the five you so adroitly earned. *Smile*
39
39
Review of Beautiful Dream  
Review by Thomas
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Quick Opinion

*Star* WOW! This is a touching and tender poem. I really like this.

What Works

*Star* Normally, I would recommend that you break this up into stanzas, but this looks so good with all the lines together, that I find myself requesting that you don't break it up. *Smile*

*Star* The biggest word you have has four syllables and you only have four words that have three syllables, yet still you paint such a beautiful picture.

*Star* This piece has a very natural flow and the rhymes work well.

Suggestions

*Star* You are little inconsistent in your punctuation. Poetry doesn't need to follow any hard and fast rules on punctuation, but it looks more professional and polished if you make it consistent throughout.

Overall

*Star* I am giving you a 4.5 that I will raise to a 5 if you take a look at the punctuation and fix it up. *Smile*

*Star* Thanks for this beautiful poem of possibly finding one's dream love.
40
40
Review of The Enemy  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Quick Opinion

*Star* This is an interesting poem. I like the theme and I like what you do with it, but since you chose to make this rhyming, I have words of suggestion.

What Works

*Star* I like the small lines that you use. I prefer this type of poem as it gives us information in small doses that we can take and digest at our own speed.

Suggestions

*Star* I think you would benefit from coming up with a consistent meter with this to match the rhyming. The meter is the beats per line. There currently is no consistent syllable count per line, but with a little work, I think you could come up with a pattern. Note: I am not saying that you make each line have the same syllables but that you make all of the first lines in each stanza match and the second and so forth.

*Star* You have some missing commas and such. For example it looks like there should be a comma after the second line of the first stanza.

*Star* No wining winning; just strife.

Overall

*Star* I am giving you a four. I think this could be a five, though, if you spent some time with the meter and fixed up the punctuation and spelling errors. *Smile*

*Star* Thanks for the poem. I enjoyed it. *Smile*
41
41
Review of Old Pain  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Quick Opinion

*Star* You have a nice piece here with quite a bit of emotion. You take an honest look at yourself, or at least are not afraid to show the less attractive aspects. Good job on that. The more honest you can look at yourself in the mirror, the easier you can get that skewed mirror fixed. *Wink*

Suggestions

*Star* You have punctuation some places but not in others. Poetry is more lax as far as punctuation goes, but I think it looks more professional and polished if you are at least consistent. Take at look at the first stanza, for instance. Notice how you have clauses but no commas or periods, but in later stanzas you do.

What Works

*Star* Your honesty. One key that I use to test the honesty of someone's writing is whether or not they choose to show their frail, flawed self. We all are flawed and we all have our frailities so a person that can see them and accurately transmit them is someone who is writing honestly. You do an excellent job at this.

*Star* I like freeform poems. A flow of sentences. Trying to make them fit together as the person who wrote them intended. Sometimes when someone writes, key details are left out, as the person writing has them in their mind and unconsciously assumes that the reader will to. Well, you don't have this problem. We have all the information we need to feel the emotions and follow the flow.

Overall

*Star* I am giving you a 4.5 on this piece. I will raise it to a 5 if you address the punctuation issue and email me that you have done so. *Smile*

*Star* Good job. I enjoy your writing and your style. *Smile*
42
42
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (5.0)
QUICK OPINION: Khalish, I am intrigued by these ghazals. I have read your piece on how to create one, but I guess I haven't gotten up the courage to try -- yet. I'll get the fire going under me before long. Anyway, this is about you and your poem, not me. *Smile* I liked this. I like the rhyming scheme (I guess what defines this as a ghazal), but I like the consistency of theme without appearing forced. Good job.

WHAT WORKS: The rhyming and consistency.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: I really don't have any other than to let you know that your link to your "WHAT IS A GHAZAL AND HOW TO WRITE IT? at the end of this poem is not working due to a space between the colon and the item number. *Smile*

OVERALL: Thanks for sharing this type of poem with us. Keep writing. *Smile*
43
43
Review of Coffee Stains  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
QUICK OPINION: WOW! This is an awesome story. Publish this one.

WHAT WORKS: WOW! I hate that prick and I want to kick him in the stomach. You made me want to kick someone I don't even know for something he did in a fictional story. GREAT JOB! Oh, and the dialog is excellent -- very believable.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: This is an accurate portrayal of what a lot of people go through, I'm sure, but I would like to see a sign of hope that she may one day escape. I would like to see some small justive brought on this prick.

OVERALL: This is a short story that gives us a glimpse. It doesn't end the way I want it to, but then it doesn't have to. It evokes emotions and portrays people accurately, even if I hate one of the people and want to rescue the other. You did a fine job on story telling.
44
44
Review of Smoke  
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (5.0)
QUICK OPINION: This poem makes the reader think. That is good, but the number of typos in such a small piece distract a bit. Clean them up and I will re-review you with a higher score. *Smile*

WHAT WORKS: The contemplative quality of the piece is its strong point.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: I cough and sputter yet it goes unnoticed

I'm choking. I feel it inside me,

oh, the irony to die at another's stupidity.

OVERALL: This is a good poem that will be better with a little tender loving care. *Smile*
45
45
Review by Thomas
Rated: E | (4.5)
QUICK OPINION: This is a sweet little poem. I love the touching glimpse you give into the dad and his son's life.

WHAT WORKS: The poem is touching and sweet.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: Just a couple of things. This is small, but comming should be coming. My only other complaint is that the way it is worded currently it almost seems that you are saying the bond between the father and the son is broken by the tide. This may have been what you meant, as I can be dense at times, but I read it that the moment they were having was being washed away and not the bond itself.

OVERALL: Nice poem. Thanks for sharing and keep writing. *Smile*
46
46
Review of Relapse  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
QUICK OPINION: Wow! This is tough. I have never been here with sex, but with the other things we can get involved in, I can understand fully. Touching poem that flows nicely.

WHAT WORKS: Realism. Oh, I should say more? OK, I could see this happening in front of me. I could feel this happening in front of me.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: This is almost more a short story than a poem, yet still it is poetry. I guess my only real complaint is that sometimes you have quotations and sometimes you are just paraphrasing. It is easy to tell the difference (lack of quotation marks), but I wonder if maybe you should be more consistent with using or not using quotes.

OVERALL: This is a moving and emotional piece that portrayed vivid images of someone suffering a battle between their head and their heart. Good Job!
47
47
Review by Thomas
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
QUICK OPINION: There may be typos but the way you pulled me in and kept my attention from beginning to end is the reason I wasn't able to notice any.

WHAT WORKS: The highlight of this piece is the message. I agree with it, although I have now two failed marriages under my belt.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: My failed marriages is my constructive criticsm for you, because in both cases I was abandoned by my mate. What's my point? Only that I think you should include how important it is for both people to have the same view of marriage and the same dedication to making it last forever. Other than that, nice job. *Smile*

OVERALL: I liked it and I agreed with it. Other than what I feel was omitted, I would consider this recommended reading for those who are engaged for marriage.
48
48
Review of Is It Real?  
Review by Thomas
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
QUICK OPINION: You have a powerful poem that highlights the pain and confusion that come with choice and consequence. It makes me think. Good job!

WHAT WORKS: Your imagry is good. The pictures are created with out the need for any words that are flowery or offensive.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: No punctuation? Ok, but I would put some in, if for no other reason than to show which words you want us to pause on and think about.

OVERALL: Nice job. I enjoyed reading it. I have been on both ends of the POV in this poem and I think you have portrayed the issues and feelings very nicely. *Smile*
49
49
Review by Thomas
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
QUICK OPINION: This is a very emotional piece that TUGS at the heart strings.

WHAT WORKS: The sincerity of the piece is its strongest aspect.

CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM: You have a few commas. I would either lose all of them or put in the ones that are missing.

Same goes for capitalization. I can't figure out why some of the clauses are capitalized and some aren't. It seems you don't like the word to to be capitalized, but you don't mind capitalizing it.

OVERALL: My minor complaints aside, I think you have a rather emotional piece that makes us all feel sad for the little boy or girl in your poem.
49 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 2 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/improg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2