*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/acme/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
2,953 Public Reviews Given
3,697 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Honest. I give my overall impressions, let you know what worked well for me and what didn't, and when that happens, I like to try and offer suggestions--totally up to you if you want to take any notice; it is your writing, after all. I am just glad to have the opportunity to read and review. I rarely think anything is perfect, so please do not request a review if you value ratings over review content.
I'm good at...
...being interested. I take time over reviews. My reviews are intimate, informal and honest. They aim to help, offer insight, and celebrate the graft of craft. I love commas. Punctuation is a personal passion.
Favorite Genres
Comedy, supernatural horror, sci-if, fantasy, thriller, detective, slice-of-life, history.
Least Favorite Genres
Dystopian glumness, romance, personal.
Favorite Item Types
Scripts. Fiction. Essays, especially academic
Least Favorite Item Types
Free form poetry. Other than that, little offends.
I will not review...
Unless previously agreed, novels and chapters are a no go with me. I am sorry to say that I haven't the time.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 2 -3- 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... Next
51
51
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it!



What are my overall impressions?

A Comedic Essay is a real treat for the contest. Dating in the golden years makes for a great hook, as does the the title and appropriate artwork. These little things matter: they tell a reader you've taken time to display your work well, which subconsciously invites them in with the assumption that you've taken time to present your work well within the main body of text. Ken, you didn't disappoint *Smile*


What are my favourite parts?
Little parenthetic asides enhance the comedy, as well as creating intimacy between writer and reader: whether parenthetic commas or parenthesis are used, the immediate result is a drop in the narrative voice, making the reader 'lean in' to the read in order to hear the writing. It's a great skill and one you do with perfect comic content and timing here:
One of the nice things about "maturing" (the older you get, the more euphemisms you discover) is that, when you reach a certain age, what you haven't done (or will admit to doing), you've seen before.

Another real treat is your observational humour with touches of the surreal and use of the 'power of three': a comedic rule you're probably very well aware of, but humour me when I go on to explain it is the practice of tripling to make the funny (four items in a list is one too many and two is too few--like an ellipsis with too many or too few periods, it just doesn't work without the triple):
Dating in the 21st century was a conundrum to me, so I decided to approach it like any good mystery and look at means, motive, and opportunity.

Means: Without school, church functions, or friend's parties, the age old problem of how to meet someone – anyone – has been complicated.
*Thumbsup*


What are my suggestions?
Your opening paragraph has to be strong. It's usually the place where people will stop reading if their attention is lost. One of the best ways to tighten your write is to look for superfluous words that can be cut, so that your prose remains punchy and to the point. One of those words is 'that'. You use it 9 times in the opening paragraph. Sure, sometimes it is needed, but, more often than not, it can be cut without changing the meaning of what you want to convey.


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

*Star* If you would like to reward this review *Star*
please donate any gift points to:
GROUP
RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  (E)
RAOK (Random Acts Of Kindness) helps members by Upgrading them.
#398524 by Writing.Com Support


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
52
52
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it!



What are my overall impressions?

This beautiful and tender review of 2013 makes for a poignant read that will resonate with anyone who has suffered the loss of a loved one. The poet lurks beneath the prose and adds a richness and depth to the writing. A small piece, but full of big concepts and observations of dealing with personal loss. Such analysis and reflection through storying is something that social researchers are only just beginning to explore the value of via Narrative Learning Theory (Goodson, 2010). Here the writer narrates the year using the theme of loss to evaluate their journey, learn from it and apply the lessons to the road ahead in 2014. A little time spent editing to tighten the write will turn this diamond in the rough into a precious gem *Smile*


What are my favourite parts?
I am determined that 2014 will be a new normal for me. I cannot go another year living the insanity reflected in the quote at the beginning of this essay.
I adored the above. So simple, yet so hard to do! I also enjoyed the use of 'normal'--a word I often replace with 'typical', on account of having an issue with what 'normal' is. The use of footnotes is in-keeping with an essay, and yet the whole thing is so tenderly written and personal that an informal intimacy is cultivated between writer and reader. Nice *Thumbsup*


What are my suggestions?
... it became my year trapped in the insanity of doing the same thing over and over and over again and expecting the different results ...

... and that was a mistake because [I] wanted different results ...

Think[ing] back over the year, between November 29, 2012 and November 29, 2013, I realize


When editing, it can be good practice to look for frequently occurring words and see if they are either superfluous or indications where your poet's toolbox can be employed to widen vocabulary. Words like 'just' and 'that' are often not needed and can be removed to tighten your write, and removing tense modifiers will do much the same.
... my year of withdrawing into the fantasy that she was not really dead and would be walking back into my life demanding that we go down to the Culinary Union so that she could start...
my year of withdrawing into the fantasy that she was not really dead and would walk back into my life demanding that we go down to the Culinary Union so that she could start...

... instead of just setting them (as if they were just resolutions ...


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

*Star* If you would like to reward this review *Star*
please donate any gift points to:
GROUP
RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  (E)
RAOK (Random Acts Of Kindness) helps members by Upgrading them.
#398524 by Writing.Com Support


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
53
53
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 18+ | (2.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item
and
GROUP
RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  (E)
RAOK (Random Acts Of Kindness) helps members by Upgrading them.
#398524 by Writing.Com Support


Thank you for mentioning that you are editing. As per the contest rules posted in the forum, no editing is meant to take place once an item has been submitted as judges can review at any time from posting to deadline. This does not mean the validity of your entry is compromised, only that this review may have been drafted and stored before the contest end and certain editing suggestions made may no longer apply. Please contact me if you have any further queries regarding this *Smile*

This is a great start to what promises to be an exciting, action-led thrilling story and I look forward to its completion. Already evident are flashes of good descriptive prose that add to the plot and develop character. I particularly enjoyed this:
Marcus returned to admiring her house. The pop of burning wood in a fireplace, then soft humming of a sweet voice to a song he used to know well, reached his ears. A feather-like pang shot through his chest and he growled the sensation away as he stomped up to the little house’s door.

As you are editing, I won't point out all typos, grammar and punctuation errors, but will note a few instances in the text where you might want to concentrate your future efforts *Smile*

He knew why he had come to Chicago. The growing city he had not seen in six long years. Six years since her, the witch who had haunted his dreams every dark night. She had haunted his very soul, plagued his very being all these years. Now, he was here for her. Here to take his revenge for what she did to him years ago. She was in the city. He knew she was her, because it was the last place he had seen the witch. Exactly to this night was the last time he had seen her. Your opening line and paragraph is there to hook the reader and draw them into your storyworld, so it pays to take time in revising and editing it to its best advantage. Starting with action is always a good hook, so maybe concentrate on where abouts he's standing in Chicago, show the cold, show the haunted look, etc. Showing not telling will also help you rid yourself of redundant words, like 'had'. Once past-tense has been established, 'had' becomes an indication of a place where you can widen your vocabulary and show a lot more to the reader.

“I’m s-sorry, m’lord, M-master Marcus.” Jacob stammered. a comma is used at the end of speech, before the closing quotation mark, when your tag goes on to explain who was speaking, or how they were speaking. In this instance, Jacob's stammer is self-evident in the dialogue, making the tag redundant. When only two characters are present and speaking, there is little need to add a tag, unless it is an action tag that corresponds with the dialogue.

Marcus smirks as he catches the scent he was looking for. Stupid witch, you should have known better than to have bonded with a vampire. He laughed softly. Try to maintain tense, to that your reader isn't jolted out of your storyworld. Also, many modern authors indicated internal thought via italicized text:
Marcus smirked as he caught the scent he sought. Stupid witch, you should have known better than to have bonded with a vampire. He laughed, softly.

“Marcus! What are you doing?!” Corvina’s eyes widened when she saw that he is taking her to her barn. Only one end line punctuation mark is needed. As the excitement is established in the first sentence of dialogue and the ensuing tag, I suggest you retain the question mark and remove the extraneous exclamation mark.

There are some large paragraphs of back story given as information. These info-dumps are useful as you are crafting your early drafts, but by the time you finish editing you may want to ensure that they have all been turned either into more active pieces of writing (show, not tell), plot and character development via dialogue, or omitted altogether.

This was his last moments on earth. 'These were his last moments', or 'This was his last moment...'

When you ask a reader to suspend their belief and accept the authenticity of your fictional story based in historical past, be sure not to jolt them out of that time and place by using phrases that would not have been used at the time, such as this one:
The smoke around them didn’t bug him.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
54
54
Review of Zapruder's Reel  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item


I do like it when writers take advantage of the tools available to them on WDC to get their work read and appreciated by readers. The inclusion of the Kennedy picture added a professional polish to this cracking little poem. Great title, apt and concise subtitle with a date most folks will remember. I also appreciated the footnote on form, original contest entry info and short historical context information. All very reader-friendly.

The poem itself uses five tercets and a quatrain as a 19 line Villanelle. Not just any ole Villanelle, this one is two-shades away from also incorporating iambic pentameter (would need a little work on the stressed/unstressed syllables, but the poet's not far off at all!).

As with any poem, a good execution of form is nothing without a matching good content and this poem is a gem. This poet captures the 'in the right place at the right time' 15 minutes of fame of Zapruder, with all the horror of that fame stemming from being in the wrong place at the wrong time. No one could have expected such horror as the events of that day, least of all a clothing manufacturer with a home movie camera. The repetitive lines of the form bend and sway their impact and meaning in a myriad of ways that echo the emotional shock of the assassination. Well-wrought wordsmithying *Thumbsup*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
55
55
Review of Coffee and war.  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item
and
GROUP
RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  (E)
RAOK (Random Acts Of Kindness) helps members by Upgrading them.
#398524 by Writing.Com Support


A pleasure as always to read your work. You hooked and held my attention from the get-go: using action (in this case dialogue between resting soldiers) established the seen, the tone, and introduced the characters and plot. I knew when and where I was straight away from the discourse and deft peppering of historical clues in the vivid descriptions. Excellent writing.

People are people and war's a terrible thing. Snatched moments of sanity when resting up shows us who we are, and in this story's case, better than any battlefield exploit you could have presented the reader with. A short, succinct tale packed full of personality.

“Ain’t that the lord’s truth,” capital L for Lord

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
56
56
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item
and
GROUP
RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  (E)
RAOK (Random Acts Of Kindness) helps members by Upgrading them.
#398524 by Writing.Com Support


Your title worked well as a hook, and you reeled me in with the brief description and eye-catching and apt illustration. This fictional piece captured a part of the horror of Nazi occupation and atrocities. I do like it when authors take the risk of using history as a backdrop for their storytelling. It's very brave, because it can be hard to maintain historical accuracy and authenticity whilst creating believable plots and characters too. You accomplish this well in a few snap-shot sketches of the lost souls of Eibergen. I would have liked to have had the chance to look a little deeper into a few of the victims' stories. After all, if you are fictionalising things, you have the freedom to create characters and not just an inventory, but I do realise that may mean turning a short story into a novel! I thoroughly enjoy reading your work and this is no exception. Thank you for entering the contest *Smile*

Just a few suggestions/typos:

Going twice? Sold! to the gentleman in the third row for twenty-two hundred Euro While I realise starting a new sentence after 'Sold!' with a capital would mean a fragmented sentence, speaking in fragments is part of dialogue. You use 3 exclamation marks in the space of 21 words. Overuse can lessen impact, as readers often come to view further exclamations as the author's alternative period mark. Because of this, you may want to loose it, and keep the informal grammar in the speech to show a connection via an elongated dash. Also, if this auction is in Europe, you may want to rephrase the money:
Going twice? Sold--to the gentleman in the third row for two thousand, two hundred Euros


A similar mischance wiped out the entire Kauffman family of diamond cutters, despite it was one occupation for which the Germans decided to spare skilled Jews for working the Third Reich's fledgling diamond industry. This sentence felt a little uncomfortable for me (I had to read it a few times). It's probably because in the UK we use a few extraneous words, such as "despite the fact...". One suggestion is to cut out further words:
A similar mischance wiped out the entire Kauffman family of diamond cutters, inspite of the the usual German policy of sparing skilled Jews to work in the Third Reich's fledgling diamond industry.
*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
57
57
Review of Tomb with a View  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

BOO!


What the spook are you writtering on about?

Thank you for entering the One Shots poetry section of the Scream Hallowe'en.


Did I giggle with hint of mmmmmwwwwwaaaahaaaahaaa?
What a couple! I had the pleasure of revisiting an old film favourite last night, Death Becomes Her. This poem reminded me of the flavour of that film, because both the victim and the murderer are quite horribly perfect for each other.

My favourite characters have a scent; they leave behind a perfume ghost of themselves that permeates all around them. This spoiled little lady's perfume laced your poem fabulously. Showing this, and so much more, is my favourite, action-packed, character and plot revealing stanza:

Pouting, I held my sweet charms from he.
In turn he slipped arsenic into my tea.
At first it had such a lovely bouquet;
Prince of Wales, Jasmine, perhaps Earl Grey?



Chillers?
You turned this around wonderfully quickly, but there may be areas for you to revisit in future edits.

Pouting, I held my sweet charms from he. I suggest 'withheld'. It shouldn't buck the natural flow and, as you haven't a set meter, it won't affect your form.

Begging mercy, saying "it's all for the best."
Begging mercy, saying, "It's all for the best."

None of them, ever! would fit my needs. Just a style suggestion, but my brain expected a parenthetic comma after 'ever', so, if you want to keep the vehemence behind the sentiment, you could pop in full-blown parenthetic brackets instead, making an aside with impact:
None of them (ever!) would fit my needs.


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
58
58
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

BOO!


What the spook are you writtering on about?

This poetry entry for the One Shots hit the 'There's something out there' prompt wonderfully.

Ghoulish green font was apt for the eyeballs of the season and complimented the green light references throughout--nice *Thumbsup*

Rhyming couplet form was a smashing choice and set a good pace for the reader.


Did I giggle with hint of mmmmmwwwwwaaaahaaaahaaa?
Yup, I giggled and snickered. Your imagery is quite horrid--marvellous! A bit of absurd and surreal humour is quite the tonic for a comedy horror, and the tableau was made all the better for it. Placing fantastic events against the mundane reality of screen doors, bed covers, newspapers and the authorities gave this a fabulously quirky feel.


Chillers?
I thoroughly enjoyed your word choices, especially 'bumpity' in the couplet below, but you may want to edit for tense in the future as little jolts into present tense took me away from the mainstay of the past tense POV:

Bumpity goes my heart
Screaming quickly starts


Not a word did it mutter
As my body shuttered
shuddered?


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
59
59
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

BOO!


What the spook are you writtering on about?

I'm a sucker for a bit of wolfish comedy horror at Hallowe'en, so I was pleased to see you pick this prompt for your poetry entry.


Did I giggle with hint of mmmmmwwwwwaaaahaaaahaaa?
A simple rolling meter contained within a rhyming quatrain was a fab way to establish a rhythm perfect for comedy poetry. That said, you sure did build up the tension and pace via the vivid, dark imagery *Thumbsup* In fact, without too much of a spoiler for other readers, I enjoyed the way you built tension right up to the last perfect punchline. Nicely done.

Smashing use, too, of your poetic toolbox, such as this marvellous example of alliteration: The fangs of fear soon sparkled long

Chillers?
Not many in this tight little write, but I did fall off the natural rhythm in some places, most notably the dialogue in the final stanza: or I'll give you a fright!. While your 6 syllable form remained firm in the second and fourth lines, I think the fact that I hear your words with a northern British accent meant that my mind sounded out the stresses on the meter a little stubbornly.

Also, whilst past tense is used in the majority of the poem (admittedly, via tense modifiers in places: was lurking), you may want to edit to preserve it: Two piercing eyes peruse the room and The lady screams, "Get in the house,


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
60
60
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

BOO!


What the spook are you writtering on about?


Haha! I'd love to say that most of us have 'been there', but I hope to Betsy that that isn't true in this case. This spooktacular poem is full of fun and gross-out comedy horror--a real dreadful delight *Devil*

If only I had listed a prompt along the lines of 'sometimes they come back...'

Ah well, not quite hitting the prompts, but loosely tagged under the prompt of 'There's something out there...' (or in there? heheh), this poem is marvellous. the structure is simple quatrain with rhyming couplets. It's a great form to choose for comedy poetry and helped build and sustain a cracking rhythm. Sure, the meter faltered here and there, but not often. A smashing example of a contest entry (loved the inclusion of a squiggly little piccie). A quick edit is needed to rid yourself of the possessive apostrophe in 'its':
It smoked awhile, then gave it's ghost
To think... that I had been it's host

I flushed it's slippery carcass down
It's face did vanish with a frown



Did I giggle with hint of mmmmmwwwwwaaaahaaaahaaa?

Yes. Yes, I did. I think I may also have wrinkled my nose in yucky glee, too. I particularly loved the action scene with the plunger and the hair curlers.


Chillers?

Yup. You hit my chill spot with the whole 'things leaving the body and then attacking it' theme. Quite gross. Fabulous.


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
61
61
Review of Moses and Curio  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
THIS IS AN S.O.S REVIEW

+ + + reports have come in that note you have requested a review+ + +

Each review is given with respect. If you feel inclined to thanks, please visit this worthwhile group who will use your GPs far more wisely than I ever would:
GROUP
RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  (E)
RAOK (Random Acts Of Kindness) helps members by Upgrading them.
#398524 by Writing.Com Support

AND REMEMBER: BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU WISH FOR, YOU MIGHT JUST GET IT!


Dear Writer,

Waaaaaaaay, back 28th October 2011 you visited my port and requested a review via the 'notes' section. Having been away, comeback, gone away, and come back again only to find that SM and SMS have worked hard to up-date the site and provide lots of new goodies to play with, I didn't see your review request until today. So, late as it is, I'm here to honour that request with a visit. I shall, of course, return the GPs you offer for this review. Should you feel, however, that I've earned them, please forward them to RAOK (link above) who will help support writers on WDC with upgraded memberships *Smile*

Re: Your item

Thanks for the invite. I did enjoy this. I do like erotica, but even better, I like well-written erotica, and, while there are a couple edits in front of this to polish and tighten the writing, you have a strong narrative style, with delightful description and character portrayal that makes me think this rather the gem.

I particularly enjoy the way you advance character through clever description and narrative voice via 3rd person limited omnipresent POV:
The notion of two betrothed souls romantically smelted into one was often lost to the come-and-go whimsy of the lascivious city. People curled up like that all the time when the comforter ended up wadded and kicked away, as theirs was. The air-conditioned room was cold. *Smile* nice *Thumbsup*

Curio's playful (if slightly, and quite rightly, spiteful) personality in the aftermath of the hotel room scene made me warm to her roguish charm and kept me curious and sympathetic to her fate. I did rather wonder at the late-ish introduction to her as 'Curio', so much of her was Lemarie in the introduction. You may want to add the Curio intro sooner, as a foreshadowing and character development trait.

Your intro to Moses was strong, too, but could be made a bit stronger if you cut out the back story you went on to give the reader about his victim, Alvin. The murder is enough, and if you want to show that Moses's victim deserved his fate, there may be a simpler, more effective way of doing so during the action itself, rather than in a retrospective character reveal after the fact. And, as informative as it is, Ellen Prudeaux’s backstory isn't really needed here: it detracts from the immediate action, sending me back in time. If it's important, write it first, if it isn't, then cut it out. Her life path doesn't seem to have much point in the immediate story of joining your two protagonists together in their opening meeting.

It was good to see the young and vulnerable side of Curio via her conversation with Bruce in the store. This dialogue did a lot to advance plot and character, but, when you do revisit to edit, you may want to get rid of a few 'names'--folk in conversation rarely keep addressing each other by name. Also, while the odd exclamation mark is helpful, they tend to lose their impact if overused, and readers mentally start to turn them into periods to avoid characters needlessly shouting excitably at each other.

When Curio and Moses start to develop and explore their budding relationship, you manage to weave a wonderful portrait of each, via the other's eyes. Poignant insights, such as the one below, add a real depth to the characters, making them real people in glorious 3-D:
To hear her speak of her life was to hear a dissertation of random encounters that left her either pissed or happy at the time depending on the outcome. When recollected they were just anecdotes of singular days cherry-picked from years of a harsh life.

Just a few style suggestions:

This may be a tad British, but the single dash seems a little too hypheny here:
Too many times, she had crashed somewhere and ended up losing clothes piecemeal due to making a hasty exit- for one reason or another- and not taking inventory of what was hers.
Suggest either a double dash (elongated on most keyboards, but perhaps requiring two together here on WDC):
Too many times, she had crashed somewhere and ended up losing clothes piecemeal due to making a hasty exit--for one reason or another--and not taking inventory of what was hers.

Watch out, too, for repetitive vocabulary (usually an indication where a change can add a bit more punch to your writing):
Her worldly possessions amounted to piecemeal sprinklings...

Sometimes I wondered if certain information was actually necessary to develop either plot or character, or just an amusing aside:
The contents of the pack, which she had discreetly lifted from a transient who was going to jail for punching a tourist, the worst of sins to the cops in Sin City apparently, were both dwindling and growing at all times.

I like to edit for specifically for tense modifiers, as they are a sure way to tighten prose:
Her black stockings were hanging in a bunch from the gap between the box spring...
Her black stockings hung in a bunch from the gap between the box spring...

Another way to tighten your write is to widen vocab, avoid repetition and cut out superfluous words. I often go 'had' hunting. Once you've established past tense, it's rarely needed, and when you see it hanging around itself, it's usually a good indication to look for an exciting alternative, leading to that wonder of wonders, the show not tell *Wink*:
At least they had had ample weed and the bars were flooding with moist spirits that night.
example:
Still, the weed was sweet and the liquor wet.


You may also want to edit specifically for formatting and punctuation. There are a some fragmented sentences, like this one:
They took off up Decatur, she now remembered. Hit a sandwich shop to knock down his munchies, stumbled into Marie Laveaux’s to buy a gator head…she had way too many fuzzy navels somewhere along the way to ward off the staggers.

And a quick check for punctuation, never hurt:
“What’s it called that for” She inspected the letters as he pointed.


“What’s the difference? She leaned in slowly, setting a joint alight for them to share after the hotdogs were devoured.


Other superfluous words include 'just', most 'that's, and quite often a number of 'the's:
In retrospect, she should have just left and went back to the street
In retrospect, she should have left and gone back to the street

Some parts of the writing seemed a little repetitive, after the fact, dulling the immediacy of action. This did impact on story flow, in effect, making me re-read the same scene again later. If certain character reaction/thinking is necessary to your story, pop it in when the action is happening, not after the fact as what amounts to an info dump:

...Lemarie took a power nap.

And she plotted.

She would have just left the whole deteriorating scene when Jenn started to lose her manners, but she was too drunk to leave and after negotiating doses of the various uppers and smileys to maintain three straight days of clubbing all night to avoid sleeping in the street, Lemarie was practically a zombie. She needed a place to sleep. By the time she realized her legs went less than solid beneath her, the hour was too late to try to hope and pray a couch was available somewhere close by.


While it's intoxicating, I got the impression that sometimes the characters took over from the writer. In the breakfast scene at Houma, Curio has revealed a great secret and Moses begins to confide in her with the promise of 'you've shown me yours, I'll show you mine', leading me to believe he's about to share a secret of his own with her. The characters' conversation becomes so fluid, that this gets lost in their conversation and you may want to revise to ensure good flow. Sure, he eventually drops the bombshell of his career, but the bomb could go off better, and with more force, if their conversational journey to it were were more definitely directed.

Aside from all the little bits in need of an editorial eye, I stayed up way past a sensible hour to read-on. That's good storytelling. I feel like I had an early peek at a real treat. A little time polishing this diamond in the rough will, no doubt, have the same intoxicating effect on other readers. Thank you for allowing me to stumble into your port. It may have taken me a while to arrive here, but oh boy, it was worth the wait for me *Smile*

Write on, that author!

Yours sincerely,
ACME


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
62
62
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



I'm visiting this item because I rolled the dice for a Random Read. Consider this, then, a Random Review *Smile* The R.A.O.K. Group (Random Acts Of Kindness) was created as a way to help Writing.Com members with upgrades, so if you would like to say 'thank you' by way of gift points, please send them to: "RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group [E]


*Question* What is this item? *Question*

This is a contest entry and adventure story, based on experience and set in the mid-sixties.

The 1778 Journal entry is a great way to open the adventure, adding rich history and intrigue to the back-story.

In fact, this story works very well as a tale of two journals; the narrator builds their adventure by picking up the breadcrumb trail of the history around her.

*Thumbsup* What worked well for me *Thumbsup*

Adventure stories always work best when the author takes time to set the scene, and build tension through tone and pace. Fynn, you're a master of this, controlling my reading pace with a good mix of short and long sentences, with snippets of intriguing information about the house and old maps, and by capturing the exuberant curiosity of youth.

Part of that building was now our living room! That map also showed where several of the mines were located. I knew pretty much exactly where one of them had to be and I couldn’t wait to tell Gary the next I saw him.

One of my favourite enticement tools is the 'do not...' command. It calls to the rebel in all of us, which is why I thoroughly enjoyed your narrator's ongoing temptation to explore:

This was another cue for dad to give me the “Stay away from the mines” lecture. I know it is wrong, but the more I hear ‘Stay Away’ the more I want to explore.


*Cut* Some suggestions for future editing *Cut*

Your story is well set out, but I'm not sure you needed to keep the text emboldened throughout.

The double space between paragraphs is a good way to break up the text on a scrolling screen, but there are a couple of formatting typos:

...having a headquarters.
Another house was built though...

... we’d have all day Saturday to explore.
We had flashlights, and sandwiches...


The first person narrative works really well in re-counting this story. I can hear the voice of the narrator well, but you may want to consider the common use of exclamation marks, as too many of them within a short space can lessen their impact and make your narrator seem a tad over-excitable.

The 1964 journal is written in retrospective of the day, this meant that when the 1965 journal entry took me into the present I was jolted out of the story a little. While it's natural to assume the writer has changed their writing style over the course of a year, in a short story like this, it may be best to preserve one particular tense perspective.

Wagon loads of ale up the mountain, drunken soldiers shot and skeletal hands reaching from mine-tombs may mean you want to revise your E rating.

*Star* Final Thoughts *Star*


This is a fun and exciting summer adventure, captured really well in less than 3,000 words. A little time tidying this up, proofing for typos, punctuation use and narrative flow will polish this into a real gem. I feel lucky to have had the chance to stumble on it and hope that it does well in the contest to come, or placed well if the contest has passed *Smile*


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
63
63
Review of The Beginning  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



I'm visiting this item because I rolled the dice for a Random Read. Consider this, then, a Random Review *Smile* The R.A.O.K. Group (Random Acts Of Kindness) was created as a way to help Writing.Com members with upgrades, so if you would like to say 'thank you' by way of gift points, please send them to: "RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group [E]


*Question* What is this item? *Question*

This is the first in a series of 'Detroit' experience tales by the author. It cuts to the chase, starting off by the first person narrative, confiding in the reader.

It works really well as an opener: fast pace, into the action, meeting of main characters, followed by an invitation to the reader to turn the page.

There's probably still a bit of work to do here: the narrator's voice is very different to his dialogue. Dialogue can be a tricky thing, and whilst what he says to his girlfriend is informative, it doesn't sit naturally with the character built so far. A little tweaking, and maybe a bit of internal monologue, to resolve may be considered.

For a short piece, it is intriguing. There's so much more story here, and it's great to see this author has a number of further reads available that look like they follow the same theme. Readers love a serial, if it hooks them. I think, with a bit of a tidy up for dialogue and grammar, this could be a serial that would appeal to a good many 'slice of life' and inner-city mean-street readers.


*Thumbsup* What worked well for me *Thumbsup*


This works really well as a monologue, because the first-person dialogue is so intimate and familiar, as if confiding in a friend or diary.

There are some wonderful moments of imagery, where you'll not only take a metaphor, but run with it. The following is a feast of foodie lust:

We were sitting in my car in front of the house and I’d been sorta desultorily nibbling on her here-‘n’-there. Ears-'n'- eyes, the sides of her neck, etc. And snacking on her fingers.


*Cut* Some suggestions for future editing *Cut*

Overuse of exclamation marks can lessen their impact. A pretty good guide for me is to cut them out if I see more than one within 250 words of another.

Whilst using a conjunction at the start of some sentences can reinforce the narrative voice and conversational tone, it does jolt the reader out of the story sometimes, because they have to mentally re-phrase the combination of sentences. Perhaps you may want to consider bringing out the buts and ands after a comma instead, and that way you'll still have two independent clauses...or you could go punctuation crazy and cut the conjunctions in favour of a semi-colon. Just a thought.

I find your narrative voice a whole heap of fun, but did sometimes stumble over your similes. For example, I wasn't sure if the following supposed to be complimentary or humorous:

I quickly found that she had the sort of sparkling personality and intelligence you'd expect in order to go along with all the other 'goodies'---she was built like a brick pizzeria.


*Star* Final Thoughts *Star*


I love stumbling across a read which makes me want to like it. I like this. You have a raw piece here, but, with a bit of editing, your style pulls no punches and gets right into the nitty-gritty of storytelling wonderfully. It's refreshing to read a writer from the school of 'why use 50 words when two will do'. It's also something I rather envy. Thank you for putting your writing and your stories out here on WDC. It's a privilege to be able stop by and leave a review.

Write on and take care,
Acme


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!.
64
64
Review of MAD COW DISEASE?  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it!

This review is part of
 WDC Power Raid And Chat Forum  (E)
Join our group to help. :-)
#1388251 by Maryann


What are my overall impressions?


Love the poem, Dr Smith *Smile* Sorry I've been off radar since November: hubby of 14 years up and left me and I'm still going through the death-throws of an out-of-the-blue divorce. My time is pretty limited here on WDC, so I'm sorry if it takes me a while to respond. Anyhoo, enough of that: here's my review!

I do think you have a smashing, understated, sense of humor. In fact, your poetry style reminds me somewhat of the short story prose style of super comedian {suser:jackrawlins). Check him out if you haven't done so already *Wink* This is a funny write. I thought certain aspects of it worked delightfully well: you get straight into the moment, the tone, the setting and the comedy backdrop of disaster (true, but those twin masks of drama and comedy work so flippin' well together!) Kudos to you for some fab alliteration:
Yea, peasants, paupers, Kings and Queens
served modest meals to fancied feasts,
most people tired of rice and beans
but few dared munch on butchered beasts.


Here's what may not have worked quite so well:
in Britain spawned, ‘Mad Cow’ disease.
No need for comma to introduce the quote marks in this inst. because it's not direct speech.

But then one day in Yorkshire Moor,
a Gypsy clan from Pyrenees

Okay, so I'm splitting hairs here, but gypsy migration wasn't really Basque country stuff--my family are the original Romany stock that came through eastern Europe via India. But, heck, maybe you know something more about migratory patterns than I do (I certainly wouldn't put it past you!)

a ‘alf-wit, yes, but not insane
Contraction or not, you still need that 'n' to qualify the vowel start to the next word: 'an 'alf-wit, yes,'


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
65
65
Review of Why Not  
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
'cor! I can understand why the Writing Cafe writers found this fantasy tale gripping stuff *Delight* There's a bigger story at play here that hints at oodles of possibilities for an epic action adventure story. The action is fast-paced and electric. I was aching to know what happened next!

There's nothing to fault with your storytelling, but there are guidelines on WDC that you'll soon get used to following; they protect the writers, the readers and the site:

*Bullet* Because there is some moderate violence and mention of torture, you should up the content rating to 13+
*Bullet* To attract more readers, use all three available genre fields and not just 'fantasy'. I suggest 'action/adventure' and 'folklore' or 'mythology'
*Bullet* To entice readers to choose your item, use the 'brief description' area to grab their attention with a good hook/blurb. Something that relates to the story itself. It's fine to tell your reader why and what for you wrote your story, but you can do this in an author's note at the end of the story


Hope those suggestions are helpful, and I look forward to seeing you at the cafe tomorrow *Thumbsup*

Write on and take care,
Acme *Heart*
66
66
Review by Acme
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

*Star*AN ACME REVIEW*Star*

This review is part of an initiative to spread positivity through reviewing. While it may not be a technical edit, my thoughts here are honest, and I hope you find them helpful and encouraging.

I thought this an image-laden, moving moment captured in free verse poetic form. It is chilling to picture something as pure as snow and children in such a setting as Dachau. Well written *Thumbsup*

*Star*Thank you for sharing. Write on and take care! *Star*
67
67
Review by Acme
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

*Star*AN ACME REVIEW*Star*

This review is part of an initiative to spread positivity through reviewing. While it may not be a technical edit, my thoughts here are honest, and I hope you find them helpful and encouraging.

This is fabulously funny *Bigsmile* I loved reading it. The narrator and his father were beautifully crafted so I felt that I was witnessing the moment. The banter between them is priceless; there are so many punchlines before the actual punchline that I felt I was in the ring at a comedy boxing match. Priceless character revealing examples of this included:
“I’d be heartbroken.” He paused for a moment, and I was sure I had him, “but I could live with the guilt if you managed to hook the chain up before you keeled over.”


I laughed out loud at this image:
Here is an interesting fact. A human can run at very high speeds on their bum cheeks.


I'd pop the rating up to 13+, just to cover the mention of the porcupine with a drinking problem, but other than that, I have minimal suggestions to improve this wonderful comedy read, and as they are easy fixes, I won't hesitate in giving this the five star rating that it game my funny bones *Bigsmile*

pig headed
pig-headed

The words “dead man walking” rang in my ears
When you pop narrative phrases into quotation marks, use the alternative form of the ones that you've used for speech. So, as your dialogue uses double marks, use single to mark out the phrasing.

‘When he got to where I was laying he said softly, “I am really relieved son.”
no need for first single speech mark.

*Star*Thank you for sharing. Write on and take care! *Star*
68
68
Review of Burning Times  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with SIMPLY POSITIVE GROUP  
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item


Thanks for entering the History Contest *Smile* You've picked an emotive and fascinating subject matter for your poem! The Witch Hunts span a huge swathe of history in continental Europe and beyond. There are many sources to find material from and it would have been great if you could have quoted a few of them here in your author's note, especially when you quote percentiles. The inclusion of a note was a smashing idea and really set the tone for the poem to follow. I did think there were a few things in it that could be explored further. For instance, a whole lot of societal/political/theological history happened between 1100 and 1700, and most indications from written records in Europe show that before 1400 authorities were unconcerned about witches.
The favorite neo-pagan term for the period of the Witch Hunts is "the Burning Times." The most common form of execution, though, was hanging. Admittedly, burning was important in many of these cases also, since to further protect against any malevolence from the dead witch, authorities often burned the remains afterward. Other popular forms of execution for witches included beheading, drowning, and breaking on the wheel. Witches were rarely buried alive, boiled alive, impaled, sawed in two, flayed, drawn and quartered, or disemboweled, as other contemporary criminals were. Other punishments inflicted on convicted witches included mutilating (cutting off of a hand or ear for example), branding, whipping, dunking, locking in the the stocks, jailing, fining, banishing, or selling into slavery.

A notoriously common myth is that the alleged witches at Salem in colonial Massachusetts were burned. All of the convicted during the Salem Witch Hunt in 1692 died by hanging. Others died by natural causes before conviction or execution, and Giles Corey was pressed to death. In fact, no witches were executed by burning in the English colonies of North America. English law did not permit it.
~ "Ten Common Errors and Myths about the Witch Hunts,
Corrected and Commented"
by Brian A. Pavlac,
Ph.D., Professor of History


I was so intrigued by the history here, and your poem managed to capture the sadness and horror of what those persecuted must have gone through. It was a good poem. I thought it was visually appealing and easy to read. There were only a few typos that I noted. I think the parts of the poem that worked best were those which concentrated on the actual persecution, rather than those areas which attacked Christianity. The reason for this is historical: secular persecutions were just as common as religious ones, and various Christian movements had very different approaches to witch hunts, with some reformation churches taking a very different line from those indicated by papal bulls. Also, while the passion you hold for your religion is commendable, credibility as a writer of historical based literature can be lost when a author choses to raise up their own religion by bashing another. I think the history speaks for itself, so let it.

The Pagan God was depiction of the Christian Devil to scare
'... was a depiction of ...' or '... was depicted as the ...'

Freedom of religion, though it is more a way of life than the Christian’s will contend
plural

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
69
69
Review of Darkness Cometh  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with The WDC Angel Army  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is one of three reviews on behalf of "Invalid Item

What are my overall impressions?

I have to admit that it was your brief description that intrigued me and made me want to read this poem. I've not read any poetry using Quenya, and was excited as to what I might find. As a purely English-speaking person, I'm obviously not qualified to comment on the original, but hope this review will be useful to you for the English translation of the poem. I'm also not ignorant to the fact that there is a little difficulty in reviewing translated text, as certain turns of phrase and syntax can be altered and 'lost in translation'. Poetry is such a musical form of literature, and one that is meant to be heard. I can only imagine how your original words sound *Smile*

I think you capture the fantasy element well here in this poem. The cyclical nature of the poem was a good tool to utilize; the repetition of the first and last line drew the whole moment together and added to the air of expectancy that the meaning provided.

What are my favourite parts?
I like it when imagery gets muddled up. Sure, it doesn't do to go around mixing metaphors, but sometimes a poet can pull it off, and fantasy is a good place to do this. That's why I enjoyed your imagery most of all:
The moon, radiant jewel of the night
flows away, never to shine.
Jewels don't flow like rivers, but I could easily imagine the moon's reflection on water. I enjoyed building my own fantasy world out of little details like that. My advice would be not to do it too often, though, because the exception only ever has the right impact if it remains the exception and not the rule.

What are my suggestions?
As you've chosen to use punctuation appropriate line starts, I suggest you edit specifically with punctuation in mind:
for starlight is cold and fading,
The moon, radiant jewel of the night
You should use a period, not a comma, after fading.

Children of Elves and men weep
As Elves has been capitalised, I wondered why men weren't? It's best to keep both sets of beings on a level footing, so I suggest you use lower case or capitals for both.

It really is worth using all three of the available genre fields, as potential readers often use the site's search engine to find items of interest to read.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
70
70
Review of The Waiting  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with The Holding Pond  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions.

Want to join a group which will encourage and support your writing, as well as making new friends? Please visit
The Holding Pond  (E)
Currently not accepting new members - group under redesign. Thank you for your patience.
#1360711 by Brooklyn



What are my overall impressions?

Hey there *Smile* Thanks for stopping by my portfolio earlier, and welcome to Writing.Com. I thought the concept of this flash fiction piece was a good one. You brought an air of action and expectation to your narrative: I waited with the commuters!

What are my favourite parts?
Your descriptions do not need to be any more detailed than the vague sketch that you provide here; it's part of the charm of the piece and why it works so well in capturing a moment. The scene came into focus as I read.

What are my suggestions?
There are a couple of typos and room to explore alternative punctuation, but on the whole this is an enjoyable vignette. If you did want to make it a longer piece, you could do so by exploring the scene's participants further and incorporating sensory descriptions (the smell of the station, the feel of people pressed together, etc.)

To run a spell check on WDC, click the thin, black bar underneath your item's title information where it reads 'Spell'.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
71
71
Review by Acme
In affiliation with The Talent Pond  
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions.

Want to join a group which will encourage and support your writing, as well as making new friends? Please visit
The Holding Pond  (E)
Currently not accepting new members - group under redesign. Thank you for your patience.
#1360711 by Brooklyn



What are my overall impressions?

I do like reading stories based on real events. This is a good story, that could use a little editing to make it a great one *Smile*

As you've already used 'experience' in the genre titles, I don't think you really need to use the brief description area to highlight this again. The brief description area serves as a bridge between title and story: it's a mini-blurb to grab a potential reader's attention and make them want to read your story and whet their appetite.

I think this story will appeal to adults reading to children, more than to children, themselves. Losing teeth is a coming-of-age story that all children are fascinated by, so this should have universal appeal to four-year-olds+

What are my favourite parts?
I thought the competitive nature between the brothers was a good theme to run through this story. I think it well worth your time to use future editing time to make that theme stand out. Children with siblings will appreciate the nature of the brothers' relationship!

What are my suggestions?
Your dialogue is good, but could be working harder. I say it's good, because I did get a little glimpse of each character's voice and personality, through it. The trick is not to have it simply copy the job of the narrative by echoing what's going on. Let it earn its keep. Dialogue should only be used to develop either plot or character.
Martin and his mother nearly ate a whole basket of peaches. They couldn’t stop biting into these sweet, juicy, sunset-colored fruits.

“Martin,” Jacob said, “stop eating all these peaches. You’ll get sick!”

Jacob sounded a bit jealous that his younger brother shared the same taste as his mother. He ate only one peach, at [as?] it was enough for him.

Martin just smiled and took another bite of his fourth peach. Juice dripped down his cheek. His mother winked at him, wiping her mouth with a napkin.
I don't think that Jacob sounding a bit jealous developed the plot or character that much. If he sounds jealous, why not make him sound jealous, by letting the dialogue do the talking. We know that Jacob is watching both his mother and brother, so you could write something along the lines of:
Martin's brother Jacob looked on as his brother and mother ate a whole basket of peaches. They couldn’t stop biting into these sweet, juicy, sunset-colored fruits.

“Look at momma's little boy, eating all the peaches just to be the favourite."

"Jacob!" Their mother wiped the juice from her chin, amused and annoyed in equal measure by her elder son's outburst.

"You shouldn't encourage him to eat so many. He’ll get sick.”

Martin just smiled and took another bite of his fourth peach. Juice dripped down his cheek. His mother winked at him, wiping her mouth with a napkin.

It's up to you, of course, but I think the example makes the characters a little more solid, especially Martin, because the interaction between Jacob and mother have turned up 'volume' knob of silence, blaring out Martin's actions (smile and bite). It crates a dynamic triangle between the characters and their actions, and it compliments the competitive nature of the brothers later on in the story (bike ride 'faster').

proudly riding the fire red bicycle
fire-red, flame-red.

The reflectors shined in the sun
shone

Readers expect a 'pay-off' for going to the trouble of using their imagination the way you've asked them to. The peach scene at the start was fab, but it seems such as waste not to incorporate it at the end, instead of introducing an aspect of the story that wasn't really developed (Niagara). Why not give the reader a 'pay-off' for all that juicy enjoyment that marked such a difference in Jacob's and Martin's likes/personalities? This could be done simply by Jacob bringing a peach as a gift in the hospital, rather than a postcard of Niagara Falls. If Jacob does that, the ending will carry more plot-satisfied clout, give the reader a sentimental pay-off, and give the story a cyclical conclusion.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
72
72
Review of BCT Graduation  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



I'm visiting this item because I rolled the dice for a Random Read. Consider this, then, a Random Review *Smile* The R.A.O.K. Group (Random Acts Of Kindness) was created as a way to help Writing.Com members with upgrades, so if you would like to say 'thank you' by way of gift points, please send them to: "RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group [E]


*Question* What is this item? *Question*


This is an engaging flash fiction piece about the pride and love of the narrator for their partner graduating Basic Combat Training in the military. It is well written and captures the thoughts and emotions of the moment beautifully.

*Thumbsup* What worked well for me *Thumbsup*


You took me straight to the heart of the narrator via first person narrative and descriptive imagery capturing the moment. This is flash fiction at its best: you say much in few words and left me a satisfied reader.

*Cut* Some suggestions for future editing *Cut*


My only suggestions are not for the writing itself, which is well executed.

It's great that you are writing to prompts, but you can mention this in the item as an author's note. Use the brief description to write a mini-blurb about the content of the story. This will serve as an extra hook to grab a potential reader's attention, along with your genre field choices.

I thought, “This can’t be real. I must be dreaming.”

Thought can be expressed in italics:
I thought, This can’t be real. I must be dreaming.

Some acronyms will be unfamiliar to those outside of military service. I have to be honest and say that I had no idea what you title referred to until I read the piece.

*Star* Final Thoughts *Star*


This item will appeal to a wider audience than those in the military; it speaks of love, honour, duty and pride in one's partner. A pleasure to read.
73
73
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



I'm visiting this item because I rolled the dice for a Random Read. Consider this, then, a Random Review *Smile* The R.A.O.K. Group (Random Acts Of Kindness) was created as a way to help Writing.Com members with upgrades, so if you would like to say 'thank you' by way of gift points, please send them to: "RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group [E]


*Question* What is this item? *Question*


This is a non-fiction item written to a prompt about a car. The author has chosen their own car as their personal favourite. This comes through in the brief description and nostalgic title, and the informal, conversational style of the narrative voice; I felt as if I were listening to an enthusiastic friend as I read. If anyone has ever loved their car, they will enjoy this well written item. The inclusion of an illustration means that even those (like me!) who know very little about cars, can share the same image in their mind.

You may want to consider including genre fields. You can choose up to three, and they are worth while adding because many prospective readers use the site's search engine to locate reading material.

*Thumbsup* What worked well for me *Thumbsup*


The love you have for this car is apparent in your lovely descriptions and reminiscences. It's hard to pick a favourite part, but I think it has to be those moments of nostalgia. I was quite taken aback by the sex-change threat, but in a good way: it shows your humour and personality, just as clearly as the antlers and red nose on Blue Satyr do *Smile*

*Cut* Some suggestions for future editing *Cut*


Your writing is, as ever, tight. That said, there was one place where I faltered and had to re-read:
Last December, at first she fought against the indignity of wearing antlers and a big red nose.
The inclusion of 'at first' made me look for a 'second'. Because your next sentence goes on to detail how she got used to those antlers, there's no real need to include it: 'Last December she fought ...'. Your choice, of course, but I thought you should know my thoughts *Smile*

“What’s your gas mileage?” or “How much did you pay for the car”
missing question mark after car.

*Star* Final Thoughts *Star*


An enjoyable read that left me with a smile on my face. Thank you.
74
74
Review of Restless  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



I'm visiting this item because I rolled the dice for a Random Read. Consider this, then, a Random Review *Smile* The R.A.O.K. Group (Random Acts Of Kindness) was created as a way to help Writing.Com members with upgrades, so if you would like to say 'thank you' by way of gift points, please send them to: "RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group [E]


*Question* What is this item? *Question*


This moving and emotionally charged poem looks at the narrator's restlessness in the face of a summer spent without the person they love at their side. The threat of external forces parting the pair is prevalent throughout and adds a tragic gloominess to the whole poem. Free Verse gives the poet elbow room to go to town on the structure, mixing short, sharp, choppy line lengths with stream of consciousness meanderings and musings that add to the dark and brooding tone of the whole poem.

*Thumbsup* What worked well for me *Thumbsup*


There is some lovely imagery, that works well by placing the reader in the moment experienced by the narrator. From the vague, impersonal couplet at the start to the intimate and personal portrait of a love struggling to attempt the impossible, my favourite stanza's passion strains at the restraints the words put upon it. They are simple words, simple ideas, but show a complexity to the relationship that couldn't help but resonate with me as a reader:
I had great summer plans
for me and you
in the way that sometimes
I plan more than just love
and cuddling,
and can follow through.


*Cut* Some suggestions for future editing *Cut*


This would typically be the point where I would try to offer some useful and constructive criticism, but, really, I thoroughly enjoyed the experience of reading and feeling this poem so perfectly. Well written and delivered, I have no suggestions to improve this poem.

*Star* Final Thoughts *Star*


A pleasure, somewhat painfully, to experience with the narrator. Thank you.
75
75
Review of The Cat's Meow  
Review by Acme
In affiliation with RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



I'm visiting this item because I rolled the dice for a Random Read. Consider this, then, a Random Review *Smile* The R.A.O.K. Group (Random Acts Of Kindness) was created as a way to help Writing.Com members with upgrades, so if you would like to say 'thank you' by way of gift points, please send them to: "RAOK Upgrade Brigade Group [E]


*Question* What is this item? *Question*


Cat lovers are sure to enjoy this personal essay item, which looks at the author's cat, Princess. She really is a princess from the off, as there is a delightful image of her reclining on a sofa with an ice cream sundae. Well written, with engaging image-laden descriptions, this essay flowed well during Princess's story and kept me smiling. Heart-felt nostalgia is woven wonderfully with present day joy, and the loving bond between owner (cat) and pet (erm, owner) is never in doubt. This was a delight to read and took me into the author and cat's world. That said, I did find the inclusion of historical data a little intrusive, as if the two items were written separately and then forced together. There may be a better way to include the information more 'conversationally', to fit in with the informal style of the narrative in which Princess is involved. There are also a few places where the narrative wanders about a bit, and places where the reader is directly addressed. This did detract from the informal intimacy that the author's voice cultivated.

All three genre fields are used well, and the E rating is appropriate. The title and brief description caught my attention, and the inclusion of the photographic illustration certainly held it *Smile*

*Thumbsup* What worked well for me *Thumbsup*


Those places of nostalgic love that leap from your descriptions of Princess are wonderful. Little details go a long way, and some of the short memories that are included are beautifully touching and well-rendered, such as this one:
Princess learned how to drink out of a large, plastic mug on my boyfriend’s vanity. With treats, she regularly jumps up on the bed and to the mug, every night at 7:30 for Wheel of Fortune. She wants nothing out of the ordinary from us, I think. Just love. Petting her pink, wet nose. Calling her a pretty girl, a sweetheart, a dear.


*Cut* Some suggestions for future editing *Cut*


The stories you can tell about cats.
I'm afraid I couldn't tell you any stories about cats, and this direct address as 'you' did jolt me out of your narrative.

She seems to have improved,goes in her litter, keeps it nice, is --again--very tidy.
space typo x 2

which was , at times ambivalent,due to cats
space typo x 2

Both the informal and formal information worked well for me, but not together. I do find it fascinating that so many famous historical figures have such strong, emotional, feelings toward cats (love and hate!). I would have loved to have know a little bit more about the facts you did allude to, such as the first cat coming over from Britain: 'A male orange Tabby from Britain was said to have been here as the “first breed”.' Who said? How did he get here, and who did he travel with? There was a reverent appreciation of cats during the 17th century, in association with a cat’s intelligence and serenity. At some point, ladies decked cats with jewels and bequeathed them their worldly goods. Which European countries was this most prevalent in, was it fashion, court, or wider society? What information leads you to 'some point', and were any of the Wills contested by family members?

*Star* Final Thoughts *Star*


Your addition of links to other items that may be of interest was thoughtful and creative. Readers who have enjoyed this piece have new places to visit!
776 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 32 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/acme/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3