*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/acme/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9
Review Requests: OFF
2,953 Public Reviews Given
3,697 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Honest. I give my overall impressions, let you know what worked well for me and what didn't, and when that happens, I like to try and offer suggestions--totally up to you if you want to take any notice; it is your writing, after all. I am just glad to have the opportunity to read and review. I rarely think anything is perfect, so please do not request a review if you value ratings over review content.
I'm good at...
...being interested. I take time over reviews. My reviews are intimate, informal and honest. They aim to help, offer insight, and celebrate the graft of craft. I love commas. Punctuation is a personal passion.
Favorite Genres
Comedy, supernatural horror, sci-if, fantasy, thriller, detective, slice-of-life, history.
Least Favorite Genres
Dystopian glumness, romance, personal.
Favorite Item Types
Scripts. Fiction. Essays, especially academic
Least Favorite Item Types
Free form poetry. Other than that, little offends.
I will not review...
Unless previously agreed, novels and chapters are a no go with me. I am sorry to say that I haven't the time.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 5 6 7 8 -9- 10 11 12 13 14 ... Next
201
201
Review of ACTIUM  
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

*Star*AN ACME REVIEW

This review is part of an initiative to spread positivity through reviewing. While it may not be a technical edit, my thoughts here are honest, and I hope you find them helpful and encouraging.

Thanks for entering the History Contest with this take on the battle of Actium. First person 'there-at-the-time-as-a-bystander' POV is a great way to view history as immediate and fresh. I remember reading Robert Graves book, I, Claudius and loved the gossipy feel that it created. You've managed to pull off the same level of intimacy and intrigue in an informal tone, and in a way that moves the plot along and gives information at the same time:
I was hanging out at the palace when Octavian came to see Antony a few weeks later. Instead of greeting him like he should have, as equals, Antony completely ignored Octavian. I told him that it wasn’t a smart thing to do, but then again, I’m only a lowly Centurion and generals don’t take the advice of Centurions.


There are a couple of places where you could review your punctuation to make your delivery a little smoother. Particularly look at comma use. If you open a parenthetic comma, be sure to close it, or you'll leave your reader mentally hanging there:
Marcus Antonius, one of our good generals and a friend of Caesar[,] was also there at the time and he asked me to work with him in memory of our beloved Commander.


It's great that you manage to make the whole tone of this informal, but do be wary of directly addressing the reader, as that level of intimacy can distract them from the story:
finally decided to form a second Triumvirate (that’s where three guys rule at one time) and they picked


If you see yourself using repetitious descriptions, odds are it is an area of text that could use a broader vocabulary in future edits:
of massive quinqueremes, huge ships ... plates and massive timbers making them difficult or almost impossible to ram ... His ships also had massive rams

Do watch out for spelling. As well as running a spell check, you should proofread for any errors too:
climbing on to their decks ... ordered by Antonyto bring the


Just one other small not about small gods: when typing about the gods, treat them to a lower case 'g'. They don't carry the noun as a name like God.

Oldwarrior, I did like this account of Actium, because it's a naval battle I've often mulled over myself *Wink* A bit of spit and polish and I think this a good edition to other fictional accounts based on the histories.

*Star*Thank you for sharing. Write on and take care! *Star*
202
202
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item

What are my overall impressions?

As I'm so often fond of saying, down the funeral parlour, "There's nowt wrong with a bit of silliness." The brief description of this item made me want to read it. I can't say that I would have known what to expect without it, because you have not chosen to highlight any genre choices. It is worth your while to use all three of the genre fields, because your poem is more likely to show up in the right place for a reader looking for a certain item type/genre to read.

What are my favourite parts?
Silly? A little, but it's actually rather romantic *Blush* Golly, I must be getting soppy in my dotage. That said, one of my favourite aspects of this poem is the intimate and courtly language used by the narrative voice *Thumbsup*

What are my suggestions?
Thanks for popping in an author's note regarding the Rondel form, but you should know that you have not met the requirements that you show as: ABba abAB abbaA. The final stanza's fourth line is a b rhyme, and not the a rhyme that you say it should be.

I think, due to some of the content suggested by tone and language use, you might want to think of increasing the rating to ASR. I leave this up to your own discretion and understanding of the Content Rating System.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
203
203
Review of Jam Packed  
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item

What are my overall impressions?

Still a sonnet, but I decided to move from comedy to angry rant. To be fair, there can be a bit of a cross-over between the two, and your final couplet proves that to be the case here, too. You may want to use one of your genre fields to reflect this humour, as humour certainly seems a larger part of your poems content than, for example, 'business'.

What are my favourite parts?
All that anger wrapped up neatly in a well executed form. What's not to like? I'm pleased to see you entered it into the Angry Rant contest too. Please let me know how it did *Laugh*

What are my suggestions?
Other than better classification to attract potential readers, I have no suggestions on the poem itself.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
204
204
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is the first of four reviews on behalf of "Invalid Item

What are my overall impressions?

Oh, I had to start here *Bigsmile* I'm a fan of form, of fiddling about with it, and poets challenging themselves to 'see if they can'. Of course, the added bonus was the 'comedy' genre tag that comes with this Abcedarius. Good use of title, brief description, genre classification and author's note describing the form: all these things make your work so much more accessible to a passing reader's interest *Thumbsup*

This poem is funny. I love your word choices, and thought the whole thing a great way to get your point across in a clever and witty way.

What are my favourite parts?
The argument! By that, I mean your counter argument and the way you have delivered it. Top notch stuff. I really enjoyed the melody that the following words created:
Quitting this whole argument
Really makes much more sense
Since more agreement we'll find
Than reasons to dispense


What are my suggestions?
Anything a man can think
Beware, they're other views
I stumbled here with the contraction, as 'they are' doesn't make as much sense as 'there are'. If you did mean 'there are' the contraction would be 'ther're'.(bit of a mouthful on the page, admittedly, but the right one to put across that there are other views from whatever another man could think if you're sure a contraction is worth it here.)

Sure, the rhythm sometimes gets lost here and there, but to say you've managed a comedy poem with a well argued point, a solid rhyme scheme, and a solid (love the e-Xtract!) form requirement, heck, it's a small price to pay *Laugh*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
205
205
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


I found this item and wanted to read it for a number of reasons; not least of which was the fact that I've re-written my own version of red riding hood, because it's such a cracking story that allows you to follow so many different threads and themes.

I love the observations you come up with. Especially this one:
And why can’t you just live with mom and the rest of us so we don’t have to come here anymore?
I mean, I know that old folk need their independence, but if they're going to go around getting relatives killed whilst delivering groceries, surely it's time to look at the bigger picture.

I loved this clever reworking of the original tale and can see why it has an awardicon. There are a couple of things you might want to look at:

Usually the wolf would always make...
using both 'usually' and 'always' is a little over the top and repetitious. You can make a smoother tense identifier and cut out one of the superfluous words with a quick change to:
Usually the wolf made...
and "But this time, it would circle around her..." becomes "But this time, it circled around her...", and "She would fool it..." becomes "She fooled it..." etc.

Inside was a site no human would ever want to see
sight
206
206
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review for Ink Blot *Star* *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This review is part of the [insert package} package gifted to you by in
Ink Blot Hall of Fame  (E)
Recognizing talent all across WDC!
#1522315 by Riot


Overall impressions and suggestions

After visiting your '100 Years From Now' forum, I had a hankering for some sci-fi/fantasy. Thankfully, your beautifully organised portfolio led me here *Bigsmile* Your brief description added to my intrigue and I chose this fanfiction piece.

This might only be a flash fiction piece, but small as it is, it is perfectly formed. Your opening paragraph grabbed my attention and took me straight into the scene, the dark tone, measured pace, and the protagonist's personality. I loved this:
Sipping on dark ale, he yearned to become a part of the life that surrounded him. But the part of his soul that longed to be filled stayed deep and empty.

And had that lovely moment of jealousy ('I wish I'd written that...') thanks to this fab simile:
Flames licked along the floor reaching for the walls. They began to wave out of the windows, like beauty queens.


Just a couple of easy-fix typos:
like bullys' on a playground
bullies
watching until she was out of site
sight

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*
207
207
Review of Mastermind  
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
*Star* Acme's Bazaar Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This review has been gifted to you from your friend live4

Overall impressions and suggestions

The idea behind this story is a good one. It's sufficiently creepy and reminded me of 'learning lessons the hard way' that was one of the themes in Saw. The train of thought is simple enough to follow, and developed well through the protagonist's philosophy as he struggles to comprehend the puzzle. I did get lost a few times, as some of your execution isn't very clear. This story deserves any time you can afford to spend on it, because I do like the clever twist at the end. With that in mind, once you've edited it to your own satisfaction, you might want to consider entering it into this Writing.Com competition:
FORUM
Twisted Tales Contest  (13+)
A monthly contest for stories with a twist. Get 500 GPs for entering! Apr round open!
#1269187 by Arakun the Twisted Raccoon


I hope the following suggestions are useful when you do edit *Smile*

Think of the item's brief description as the strap line to a movie; it should encourage a passing reader to come and visit the item. Make it story orientated in it's meaning to hook their attention *Thumbsup*

He looked at his “puzzle”; a tightly clad spin of string into one larger, thicker strand.
Do you mean 'strand of string'? And what was it clad in? Show the reader exactly what to see to avoid confusion.

The cramped little tube was illuminated by a red light and had nothing but a small fan behind him – the metallic walls easily converted the prison into an oven.
This looks as if you are personifying the tube. If you are using and to join two independent clauses, pop a comma in before it. Subtle changes will add clarity to your meaning:
The cramped little tube was illuminated by a red light, and he had nothing but a small fan behind him – the metallic walls easily converted the prison into an oven.

“You were told at the beginning that you would have exactly three and one half days until you’re failure begun.”
Spell checks will not catch everything:
you're is a contraction of the two words they are
your is a pronoun
It is good to check tense use, to avoid distracting your reader and make your meaning clear. As the failure has not begun, it should be referenced as 'until your failure begins' or 'until your failure began' -- depending on the intent of your meaning.

Most of the story is in past tense, which makes any present tense uses pop out of the page, along with suddenly changing narrative perspective. This story is in third person, so suddenly addressing the reader (you) upsets the flow:
perhaps an enemy that causes trouble, ruins your plans


In order for your reader to suspend their belief they have to believe the world you give them as a substitution. Check for inconsistencies like this one:
The cramped little tube. . .
this original image conflicts with:
This first victim; a bloodless, emotionless, faceless, and pointless head looked up at him blankly. He pushed it aside with his foot; it had no meaning to the puzzle, nor any purpose for his attention. It rolled across the floor and he returned his stare to the rope.

It, much like those who had prevented him from reaching his level of knowledge and wisdom, would need removed from the picture . . . if the knot were to be removed, it would need untied
would need to be removed, or, would need removal, and, would need to be untied, or would need untying.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
208
208
Review of Don't Tempt Me  
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review for Ink Blot *Star* *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This review is part of the EBB package gifted to you by kiyasama in
Ink Blot Hall of Fame  (E)
Recognizing talent all across WDC!
#1522315 by Riot


Overall impressions and suggestions

Hey Nicki *Smile* I've gone in for the official contest too, and I know how hard reviews are to come by at the moment, so I wanted to stop here first. The deadline looms! Because this review has been gifted to you, please do not consider my returned auto-award as bad mannered.

First of the bat: this is funny. Good observational humour. I like the way that people don't change; the remembrance of youth in the older women reflects that of the teenagers *Thumbsup*

It's a good story and spot on for plot and character development, so my comments are based your desire to cut it down a bit for the contest *Delight*

Typos:
A little motivation for the first week is exactly what we need. ”
unneeded space before quotation marks.

They settled in on lane nineteen. Tammy lowered her ball to the ball return rack and drew a sharp breath. “What’s the matter with you?” Cheryl snapped, following her stare.
put a double return space before the dialogue to avoid it following Tammy's action, and thereby looking as if it belongs to her. I had to reassess the scene when I got to Cheryl's tag.

Nicki, it is so hard to review your writing objectively because I'm a huge fan of your style. In fact, this piece is as well tailored as I expected it to be, so the following suggestions are just that: suggestions. Predominately, they are given to help reduce word count *Thumbsup*

she said, “No thanks, I’m not cheatin’ on my diet with only two week until the reunion.” She shouted, “Memphis and Hailey! Y’all get in here and clean up this mess!”
I know tags are necessary, but you can still liven them up if you have to use them. Personally, while it does add to your word count, I'd take time to set up the shout, because it just seems a little too choppy as it is. The exclamation does the shouting for her, and so the tag should only serve to point the reader in the right direction of the recipient. The best way to solve it (and no extra words) is:
“Well go on, Tammy, have a cookie.”

“No thanks, I’m not cheatin’ on my diet with only two week until the reunion.” Tammy tilted her chin, gave her head a shake, and with a resolute grin shouted (where ever the girls where), “Memphis and Hailey! Y’all get in here and clean up this mess!”


A great way to cut words is to get rid of telling what you've just shown (redundant words) [-8 words]:
Cheryl took another drag on her cigarette and reached for a cookie. She exhaled the smoke and took a bite. Tammy cringed. “Can you even taste that cookie while you’re smoking?”
Cheryl took another drag on her cigarette and reached for a cookie. She exhaled the smoke and took a bite. Tammy cringed. “Can you even taste that cookie while you’re smoking?”


[-9 words]
Tammy was used to this response which first replaced a reciprocal smile two years ago when Memphis turned thirteen. At first it broke Tammy’s heart, but she soon accepted that teenagers will be teenagers. So she’d adopted a retort that did wonders to cheer her up. Before Memphis turned away, Tammy shot her tongue out at her.
Tammy was used to this response which first replaced a reciprocal smile two years ago when Memphis turned thirteen. At first it broke Tammy’s heart, but she soon accepted that teenagers will be teenagers. Sobut she’d adopted a retort that did wonders to cheer her up: before Memphis turned away, Tammy shot her tongue out at her.


[-7 words]
using the right tense for words can cut out an extra word, here or there, as can getting rid of 'weak' words (just, seemed, almost, etc.)
a shade she began using when she was just a little older that Memphis. Tammy had always been self-conscious of what she saw as a her short forehead, and her coif just didn’t look right until she’d given it some lift on top


*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*
209
209
Review of Mitten Mayhem  
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review for Ink Blot *Star* *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This review is part of the TS Eliot package gifted to you by kiyasama in
Ink Blot Hall of Fame  (E)
Recognizing talent all across WDC!
#1522315 by Riot


Overall impressions and suggestions


Yes, I do remember when mittens weren't cool; I think I was wearing them at the time the warrant was issued *Laugh* That is a good brief description, as it certainly captured my imagination! I think you sum this vignette piece up well with this pivotal piece of action:
“Sorry, Mom. But you have no idea how hard it is being twelve,” she whispered dropping the mittens in the snow.

While you capture the moment well, and Natalie's obvious unhappiness at trying to fit in, it would be great to see a bit more of her emotions. Perhaps you can use metaphor and simile to help show her emotions, and allow the reader to connect to them. My only other advice is to replace entertainment with 'comedy' as this really has all the hallmarks of a good one *Smile*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*
210
210
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review for Ink Blot *Star* *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This review is part of the TS Eliot package gifted to you by kiyasama in
Ink Blot Hall of Fame  (E)
Recognizing talent all across WDC!
#1522315 by Riot


Overall impressions and suggestions


Hi Audra *Delight*

This is a cracking story, and I just loved it. Your writing, as always, was nice and tight. In fact, the only suggestion I could find to make is a minor style preference: too many uses of the word that, when it wasn't particularly needed. That's it, Honestly! My only other suggestion is too change the nature genre for inspirational, as this story's ending is very moving an powerful. Everything else is wonderful, inspirational, and joyful writing. I can't believe that you could say so much in so few words; you captured the essence of their relationship and personalities in this flash fiction. A joy to read *Bigsmile*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*
211
211
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*

For information on reviewing, please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

Overall impressions and suggestions


A more thoughtful comedy piece... sounding pretty much like a declaration for standing for Boris's job. I'm sure your ideas would garner you a large proportion of the London vote *Delight* Kudos on the use of 'ilk' -- it's a lovely word.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
212
212
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*

For information on reviewing, please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

Overall impressions and suggestions


A fellow trolley rage sufferer, I see *Smile* Yes, it's a shame that folk don't know how to traverse a supermarket and think about their fellow man at the same time. Another funny observational comedy piece. Apart from the 'i' instead of 'I' use, I did note one other thing:
HOW DARE THEY TEMPORARY PREVENT ME FROM GETTING MY STRAWBERRY MULLER CORNERS?!?
I think you mean temporarily? Also, have you tried the new black cherry and chocolate?

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
213
213
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*

For information on reviewing, please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

Overall impressions and suggestions


Hi Jay *Smile* Welcome to Writing.Com.

This is funny. John Cleese's character, Basily Fawlty, proved that when it comes to comedy it takes a lot to beat an angry man on the verge of losing it. You have an American counterpart to your dry and direct humour, and I suggest you go and visit his portfolio: RufusTFirefly Thanks for the smiles, but there are a couple of formatting issues you should take into account when editing:
*Bullet* The pronoun 'I' should always be capitalised.
*Bullet* WDC is an international audience (erm, Manchester counts for this advice, too), so you should use the full written text rather than abbreviations that might not be instantly recognised.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
214
214
Review by Acme
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


For more information on reviewing please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

What are my overall impressions?

Thank you for entering "Rising Stars Shining Brighter [E] *Smile* I found this a delightful present tense narrative to read. You convey Alice as a very real person, and not a character. I would have liked to have seen more about her day, environment, experiences, etc., but think you have captured something that rings with truth.

Due to inference of violence (the man's predatory intentions and the theft), you should really make this ASR.



*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
215
215
Review of Tomorrow  
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


For more information on reviewing please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

What are my overall impressions?

Hi Jyo! Thank you for entering "Rising Stars Shining Brighter [E] *Smile*

You've made my day. This is the funniest thing I've read in a while. The fact that it's based on truth makes it even funnier. Oh, you're a *Star* Your vocabulary added to the imagery and the humour. It's also good to see you move away from the 'rules' and embrace a bit of literature abuse: making up your own words like, sockses *Thumbsup* I hate it when I get serious reviews for daft items that say I can't make up words. When not a complete nonsense, it's one of the ways that language evolves.

I did find the internal rhyme started to get a bit hit and miss toward the end. I think it's just because it works so well with the rhythm in the earlier stanzas.

Smite yourself! *Shock* Those two sips of wine in the second stanza mean that this is 13+ content rating, not E. Also, the way it is worded makes it look as if you've sipped them at ten to nine in the morning. Now, that's comedy, but is also behaviour guaranteed to lose sympathy for failing exams, if that's your morning tipple! *Laugh*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
216
216
Review of Eye  
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


For more information on reviewing please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

What are my overall impressions?

Thank you for entering "Rising Stars Shining Brighter [E] *Smile* Good use of metaphor and simile in this unsettling poem. I felt a little lost at times, but responded to the distinctly disturbing images some of the stanzas (particularly the pivotal middle stanza) conjured.

Punctuation can change meaning so easily, and so can capitalisation of line starts that don't seem to correspond with it. You might find that your readers gain greater clarity by appropriately matching it.

The eye is shuttered,
it's photographic chamber recording only the pink insides,
You don't need an apostrophe to show possession for 'its'

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
217
217
Review by Acme
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


For more information on reviewing please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

What are my overall impressions?

Hi, Oldwarrior *Smile* What a refreshing change to "Rising Stars Shining Brighter [E], to see an essay posted! Thank you for that. I thought your argument was clearly sided, but well argued. I also thought the included quotations were pertinent and added colour and weight to your central argument. I did get the impression that the introduction was separate from the rest of the essay: as if you had started writing in one direction and ended up somewhere else. This is because your main argument/examples, and your closing are strongly connected to Vietnam, while your introduction makes this seem more coincidental, ". . . American national conscience that to think otherwise is considered unpatriotic and immoral. But, is this the way the rest of the world sees us? Is our government living up to our self-proclaimed and cherished belief? I can only reply through my personal love of journalism and factual history. Take Vietnam for example."

You may want to run a spell check as there were a few errors. Be sure to be consistent in name spellings.
Ho Chi Mihn's soldiers (aided by American OSS fighters) fought for two years to expel the occupying Japanese, and after Ho Chi Minh



*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
218
218
Review of The Rose  
Review by Acme
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


For more information on reviewing please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

What are my overall impressions?

Hey Ken, I'm reviewing this poem as your entry in "Rising Stars Shining Brighter [E]

Ghost? Western? Ooh, two of my favourite genres *Delight* I loved my welcome with the strong illustration. It really helped set the mood of the poem to come.

The story is a good one, and so is the simple rhyme scheme and quatrain form. I did have a little trouble with the rhythm; it wasn't the smoothest. No sooner had I got into my stride than I was thrown off it. I suggest you ask a 'cold' reader --a family member or friend who hasn't read it yet-- to read this out loud to you. Listening to them will give you a good indication of where you can focus future edits *Smile*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
219
219
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions.

Want to join a group which will encourage and support your writing, as well as making new friends? Please visit
The Holding Pond  (E)
Currently not accepting new members - group under redesign. Thank you for your patience.
#1360711 by Brooklyn



What are my overall impressions?


Wow! This is a really thoughtful and well composed item about why you write. If you do get a chance to edit it, there are a couple of typos to tidy up:
before drawing,and even before
Spacing typo.

My poetry often remains for my eyes only, or for the eyes of strangers, I still wanted the reader to understand the struggles, fears, and even triumphs that I experience.
Period, not comma, after strangers.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
220
220
Review of I'll Meet You  
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*


This is a review on behalf of "Invalid Item

What are my overall impressions?

Dear Kaya, this is one of 6 reviews that your good friend, Brooke, has requested for you. I told Lornda that finding 6 items of yours that I had not previously reviewed would be hard as I love to spend time in your portfolio. Happily, you are a much more prolific writer than I am a reviewer! I hope you find these reviews useful *Smile*

This is a tender and touching poem about loss, longing, and loving beyond the grave. There's also a lot of hope here. The rhythm and rhyme pattern are almost musical, which adds to the ethereal tone of the piece, and, as per usual, your language choice is wonderful; kudos on the apt use of 'gloaming' *Bigsmile*

What are my favourite parts?
There is so much to like; the strong, concise narrative, alliteration, assonance, word play, imagery and metaphor. One of the best aspects was how you kept this simple. Traditional quatrain and consistent rhythm are expertly done. You present the poem with very little WritingML, but what you do use is thoughtful, such as the muted colour for text, simply centered and no need for illustration. Subtle and effective *Thumbsup*

What are my suggestions?
None -- Write on!

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
221
221
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*
This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions. This is your work, and I'm just happy to have had the chance to review it! *Smile*

For information on reviewing, please check out this informative, simple and easy to read link:

http://utminers.utep.edu/omwilliamson/two.htm

Overall impressions and suggestions


Welcome to Writing.Com! This thoughtful piece is well written and uses an extended metaphor well. Not only is it a good opinion piece, it is also a good insight into wider mindset of modern culture. I have no suggestions to improve your argument and note no typos, but there are a couple of WDC preferences that you might want to consider.

Content rating: You touch lightly on the horror of war and death, so should consider an ASR rating instead of E.

Format: The majority of items on WDC have double return spacing between paragraphs to make reading from the screen easier on the eye.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
222
222
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions.

Want to join a group which will encourage and support your writing, as well as making new friends? Please visit
The Holding Pond  (E)
Currently not accepting new members - group under redesign. Thank you for your patience.
#1360711 by Brooklyn



What are my overall impressions?

I've mentioned it numerous times before, but neglected to do so in a review, until now, but I love the concept of this Adult Fairy Tale Collection. I've only juts got around to seeing the Spanish classic Pan's Labyrinth, and think there is such a market out there for new fantasy folklore. These stories haunt me, especially Pumpkin, and my only criticism would be that you need to write more! I'd love to see a full collection *Delight*

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
223
223
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions.

Want to join a group which will encourage and support your writing, as well as making new friends? Please visit
The Holding Pond  (E)
Currently not accepting new members - group under redesign. Thank you for your patience.
#1360711 by Brooklyn



What are my overall impressions?


Aaarrrggghhh! Clown! Ooh, you should have more than a title to warn folk *Laugh* Seriously, your illustration for this folder certainly match the creepy expectations I had of opening this folder to your darker side of poetry.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
224
224
Review by Acme
Rated: E | (5.0)
*Star* An Acme Review *Star*

This rate and review is offered in the spirit of assistance. Please feel free to ignore any, or all suggestions.

Want to join a group which will encourage and support your writing, as well as making new friends? Please visit
The Holding Pond  (E)
Currently not accepting new members - group under redesign. Thank you for your patience.
#1360711 by Brooklyn



What are my overall impressions?


As it has been too long since I hunkered down in your portfolio, I thought that this was as good a place to start. This may just be a lowly folder but it hosts a prolific amount of work, and I can't wait to get started! Folders don't need to be boring organisational tools, they can be portals to other worlds, and your time spent adding a welcoming illustration and note is a great way to encourage your reader to feel at home.

*Star* Thank you for sharing your work! Write on and take care *Star*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
225
225
Review by Acme
Rated: ASR | N/A (Unratable.)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

*Star*AN ACME REVIEW

This review is part of an initiative to spread positivity through reviewing. While it may not be a technical edit, my thoughts here are honest, and I hope you find them helpful and encouraging.

Thanks for posting this poll in the fantasy newsletter -- it certainly got me thinking about sub-genres and how they can swiftly become the main genre. Your poll question is clear, even if the answer isn't, but I would have liked to see a few more options. For example: 'I don't see it as a problem when finding something suitable to read.'

I think there's a place for cross-overs. Sometimes I want horror with my sci/fi & fantasy, sometimes I want it pure. I guess I'm saying that there's no poll choice for me as I can usually find what I want to read, with or without horror *Smile*

*Star*Thank you for sharing. Write on and take care! *Star*
776 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 32 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/acme/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/9