*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/power_unit/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: OFF
162 Public Reviews Given
168 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- 3 ... Next
26
26
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Thank you for this inspirational guide. I bet many writers can relate to this person. I certainly can. It's me to a tee!

This is a quick review. Your grammar is generally good. There's a few complicated structures that you should research: "Undependable never! " Many fragments like this don't read very well. The ideas are great, but the smithing needs refinement.

I like how you divided it into sections. This is probably not appropriate for an article this short, but it really helps the reader along. I think for a publishable article with headings, you need more words per section. Add examples and expand on the discussion. I don't think that's where you were going, but you could.

Overall it flowed and felt tight, even with the grammar snagglets. I felt the passion, and I felt inspired.

Good job!

John
27
27
Review of Things to do  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Welcome to WDC Power Reviewers. I hope you learn a lot from this experience. I have.

This is a fast poem that tears at you, It doesn't leave you any pause for ponder. It certainly is a writer's todo list.

I felt like this was telling me something about you. I'm going to make some wild guesses here. You like fantasy - Rocs and dragons. You are female since you want to marry a villain. Sorry but I'm sexist; males are the villains. Of course you might be gay too, but I'm going to guess female.

I love a couple of them. "explore the mind to become its pet" really caught my attention. I'd probably have skipped reviewing this altogether if I didn't read that line. Wow! Also "Crest the wave to see the depths" is very deep *sorry* You obviously have a literary streak in you. You do not seem to care much about punctuation and captialization, and this tells me you are young.

So my young, female, fantasy loving, literary minded, lofty goaled reader, very well done! WriteOn!
28
28
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
I love it!

I like your first person narrative with a few thrd persons thrown in. You do a great job at showing and not telling. There are a few minor problems such as "the humans." "Humans" is a plural word and "the" is singular. If you want to edit it again, which I suspect you might not as this is a prep for NaNo, I'd re-read it aloud.

Good luck in November, and WriteOn!
29
29
Review by Power Unit
Rated: E | (1.0)
$25 shipping fees to Canada for a $15 t-shirt is outrageous. There are no excuses for such high charges. I don't want to hear about your hardships. I can buy a t-shirt on eBay from anywhere in the world for $5 shipping or less. You might sell a few if you charged at least close to a reasonable fee.

Don't bother replying. This is a rant.
30
30
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (2.5)
I need to comment on your cadence. Not one stanza is constructed the same. Unless this was your intention, a contest maybe, it is very disconcerting to read.

Stanza 1 - 7,7,8,8
Stanza 2 - 9,5,8,7
Stanza 3 - 6,9,7,10
Stanza 4 - 9,8,8,9
Stanza 5 - 6,7,7,7

That aside, I really like your subject matter. It might be because I'm reading "The Stand" by Stephen King where dreaming of the dark man is a powerful thread. This topic has lots of potential.

"Dreams fading like a tan" is a cool simile. Tans linger for quite awhile, so It strengthens the idea that these dreams might fade, but they stay with you a long time.

Your 4th stanza might be best, and it might be the format you are looking for. I actually really like your choices here.
         The sound of footsteps walking away,
         more pain with every coming day.
         Forgetting who you used to be,
         the future and present, now I see

The last stanza sounds a bit like Dr. Seuss. Be carefull with this one.

My suggestion is for you to revisit this poem, settle on a format, and make changes to fit the format. When you're done, keep working at it to find those special words and meanings. Good luck.

Note: my rating is my opinion on readiness for publishing.

*Quill*WriteOn!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
31
31
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
A powerful, emotional poem. Thank you for posting it. It helps me appreciate the plight of sufferers.

A few side notes; I'm not much of a poet.

I thought the phrase "To be at your beck and call?" was a bit cliché. Maybe something original here can be more powerful. Ponder it please.

The phrase "Your barks make me blush" creates powerful imagery. It's very showing and not telling, what we strive for, eh?


*Quill*WriteOn!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
32
32
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Overall I enjoyed this piece. It's by no means ready for publication, but it's hearfelt. It triggered thought in me. Isn't that its purpose? I'll go through problems I have with it as well as good points. Please consider these my opinion only, and please use them to advance your writing.

Spelling & Word Choice

The word common should obviously be come on instead. Such a glaring error in the first sentence screams a lack of editing. I don't know where you are in the life cycle of this piece, but sooner or later you need to do some serious review and revision. I try to do this before making it public, and of course I still make mistakes. This is not a hand slap but a hand hold, a reminder that editing is necessary for all published works.

Other misspells and misuse:
- In and its the time instead of just listening its should be it's. Its is possessive
- Formulae is plural of forumula, but you use it in a singular form.
- Never use double question marks in formal writing. This isn't Facebook.
- ecsatsy means what? *grin*
- I always shoot down starting sentences with conjunctions. You've done it too many times, which to me means more than none. Of course I do it sometimes.
- Suppose you have performed a sexual act with a prostitute and your girlfriend. Are you meaning to discuss threesomes? Did you intend it to be two separate events? An act with her and her means one act. I played catch with Joe and Bob. It's kind of a radical, off-the-wall example for such an otherwise tame and feel-good piece. It's taking your girl out for a nice dinner, a chick-flick at the local theatre, then dragging her into some porn bar. It's just not consistent 8~

Your writing is very passionate and poetic. I get jealous when I read writing like this; however, it can detract from the message. Readers can get easily lost. I did. I had no idea what you were talking about. You can't rely on me reading the title and carrying that thought into your piece. You need to reintroduce it with some opening remarks. Consider starting with an example of following your heart.

I love some of your imagery such as it has become a fashion statment made by every person right from celebrities to all the eminent personalities around the world. Equating following your heart with a fashion statement is very powerful.

You also ramble, a general weakness of writing poetically. You are trying to make a point here, I think. You might want to consider toning down the wordiness and get to the point faster and clearer.

I consider the whole topic to exist on a continuum with practicality on one extreme and spiritualness on the other. One can live at either end for short periods, but not permanently. There's a balance between the two that always seems to change.

Good luck with your writing.

John

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
33
33
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
I'm assuming you are attempting a novel or at least a short story.

Believability

18

There's scrolls in this story, so we're talking a distant past, a time before people cared about children, a time when 12 year olds were sent out to be married and start their own farms, a time when "if you were old enough to bleed ..." Asking age took away from the story; it put it into a modern age. Maybe put some thoughts in the master's head about how he thinks the person looks too loung and puny and will probably get splatetred all over the field, a little more than the skinny remark.

I was trained to protect my people,

I find this is telling too much too early. It releases tension. Find some hints at importance maybe, but don't tell us about grande motivations, not yet. Hint at it with some encounter maybe, but don't tell us.

Too much!

What you have is good, but it's rather thin. I don't yet have a feeling of who your characters are, what this place is like, and what's happenning with these races. I think this is way too much to do for a single chapter: you introduce the characters, select a snake, then race it. I'd expand on these ideas and put each one in their own chapter. Each chapter can push 5k words no problem. Use it to expand on the characters. Use some inside and outside perspectives to bebuild a 3D view. You need some more tension, some more fear from Anouk, some apprehension at breaking from her safe places. Build a relationship with this snake. Build a long, slow scene that lets the relationship simmer. Remember that empathy comes out in details. Keep the tension. Find the balance, The race itself should be long and tense. Perhaps use it to also build the scenery. Make us feel a part of the crowd; make us feel we belong.

I'm not rating you for what you have but for what you don't have! What you have is more like 4.5.

*Quill*WriteOn!

You write very well. You have a "feel" for writing which cannot be learned from books. I like your use of dialogue. It draws us in immediately. I do suggest you keep studying it though. I think your use of tags can be more effective at drawing us in. It's something we all struggle with. I like to try and really become my characters when I write. Try it ;)

I wish you the best at tackling this story!


*Cart*Notes: This is not an edit. I very likely won't ding you on every punctuation error. If I see a pattern, I'll give one example and maybe point out there are many more problems. My rating may not make sense to you, but it's my assessment of the readiness of your work, not so much quality of your words but readiness for publication.5's are rare from me, but they do happen.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
34
34
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
This is an interesting piece of work. I assume by automatic writing you just sat down and wrote what came into your head. It's a great exercise!

I don't want to get into a religious or philisophical debate, but I think you make some assumptions, namely, that naturists are all about sexual relations. Perhaps you needed to state what your perception of a naturist is. I really do not know what their motivations are, but from what I know, they seem to be more about trying to achieve that pre-Adam's Apple state than a modern swinging orgy state which your words suggest, at least to me. I appreciated your note before diving into the religious texts. It helped frame you as the writer as being open to ideas rather than preaching to the reader. You did cover many points though, and they made me think about my own values. So you did succeed.

Your language and grammar show that English is not your first language. I can only encourage you to keep working at your writing and reading. A number of spelling and punctuation errors are likely due to the style you chose. These are things you are not supposed to worry about when writing automatically, so I give you more marks for mistakes rather than less *grin*

Thank you for your honesty and openness. WriteOn!
35
35
Review of Random First  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.0)
Welcome to WDC. Glad to see you jump right in. It took me a long time to post my first peice; now I can't help but write something every day.

I'm going to sound critical of your work, but please take it as constructive, a roadmap for improvement. What I say to you I can say to almost everybody.

You need to work on spelling. Writing is comprised of words, and we need to not only use the best words but spell them correctly: "break through" should be breakthrough; "gradual" should probably be gradually; "Normaly" is Normally; and finally "basque" is a region in Spain; you want the word bask.

Punctuation goes without saying for new writers. Learn the five sentence constructs and practice them.

While these things may seem minor or picky, they are important. Your piece is quite motivational and encouraging. You don't want people to stop reading because you didn't capitilze your "I"s or leave our necessary punctuation. A well constructed and correctly spelled piece of prose is much more powerful than one with errors.

Again, welcome to WDC. [Write On!] and watch your confidence grow!

John
36
36
Review of The Smoke Ballet  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Excellent effort. I really like the imagery, the metaphor. You compair those smoke circles my grandpa used to make to a ballet. Fabulous!

There are some words I think can be improved. I felt you were telling rather than showing.

perform their melancholy dance

Melancholy is a strong adjective, and dance introduces us to your theme, but I didn't care for the word perform. It's telling us too much. Maybe, maybe not, but that's what I feel when I read it and say it. Is it weak? Is there a stronger verb or a better construct? Explore it; work it.

Then curtains close,
and reality returns


These lines also sound like telling to me. Then is a word I'd try to avoid altogether. Such connectors are tough to make work in poetry. And the verb returns bothers me. Is it something about verbs and poetry? I'm no poet, so I really don't know. But I think these lines can be improved.

The rest of it rocks! Wishing I could fade away really takes me into an open-ended emotional and visionary world. If only I could whisp away from my troubles with the smoke. I also like the word temporary. It's long and dangerous, but I think the meaning and the way it makes us realize our dreams are fleeting is powerful.

Very well done. Keep at this piece; it might take awhile to find the right words to really make it pop, but I know you can do it!


37
37
Review of The God Factory  
Review by Power Unit
Rated: E | (3.0)
I understand this is flash fiction. It was probably more an exercise than an attempt at creating a polished piece of prose.

Overall I liked your idea, but really, it falls flat in a few areas. Storywise there's not much tension and not really any plot. There are some interesting techiques here that are worthy of discussion. They've probably already been addressed by others, so this may just be for me *smile*

The "it read" after the door sign came right out of the blue at me. In my opinion it belongs in front: It read "blah blah blah." Afterwards is weak sentence structure. Of course we usually want active constructs.

You then lead off the next sentence with the present participle phrase Finding his key ... This is not a gerund as it doesn't act as a noun. A couple of things to watch for with these phrases. First they are frowned upon. I know it's not a valid reason not to use them, but we do have to understand why. It's often a sign of a lazy writer. When I use them, I know I need to revisit and find betetr words. I still use them though. The second, and the more difficult to uncover, is that present participle phrases are happening at the same time as the rest of the sentence. They are not precursors. So what you are really saying is he let himself in, turned on the lights, and walked to his desk all while finding his key. Nope; ain't gonna happen.

Your one-sided dialogue is very difficult to follow. I think if you are going to use this technique, you might need less dialogue and more narrative describing the other person and maybe the conversation. It's tricky business that probably needs a professional editor. Personally, I prefer all narrative for such scenes. John LeCarre in Absolute Friends does a marvelous job at this. It's one of my default models.

I'd like to conclude by saying this is an educational piece. I don't like saying I learned from your mistakes, I'd like to say something really positive about it, but I do think this is the big value of it. We write to get better, and you, me, and the host of other readers all benefited from it. I think we need to celebrate our "junk." Craftsmen don't become craftsmen by not destroying a few thousand pieces of wood, and writers don't become good writers until they muck up thousands of pieces of paper. I seriously celebrate this *Smile*

38
38
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (2.5)
This was an interesting read.

There are problems with your grammar and spelling; work on it. It's a life journey. You also have a larger-than-desired amount of weak and pointless prose, for example you run home form school every day. So what? Does it add to the story? We have cars crashing, explosions in the street, people running for their lives, zombies attacking us, and maybe even aliens attacking earth. This is the scene for your missing Molly, but it needs more detail and tension. Maybe a piece of shrapnel explodes into her room and you run in to rescue her -- build some tension. Search the house in a frantic panic -- keep the tension going. Extend such ideas further and make us sweat a bit more. Interact more with this outside confusion. Throw another hint of blood.

You do show lots of creativity and fearlessness as a writer. You see the basic needs -- character, scenery, and plot. I sincerely commend you for taking us as far as you did with enough structure that we can get an overall sense of story and a feeling of loss at the end. I was on one hand stricken with a desire to simple click the next random story and on the other hand a desire to finish it. I hope you continue your writing. You will improve. Work on the technical but let your obvious creativity run wild!

WriteOn!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


39
39
Review of Weather or Not  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
What an intense piece!

I'm not sure if it's a love letter or a phylisophical blitz. I wonder if that's a problem. I feel some passion is lost in your wonderful thoughts; the prose is somewhat aloof and distant.

Some of your writing really stands out. My eyes don't lie even though my heart may decieve, that the reason why sometimes my soul may cry and bleed but yet and still I'm like, "Never say die!". You contrast the vision of your eyes with the feelings in your heart. Without saying as much, you tell us of the endless struggles we face as humans, a very strong idea. Then you echo your feelings with this comparison -- a comparison echoing a comparison. This is the type of sentence that one can spend hours thinking and writing about. Awesome! However, you tail it off with the word like. Like you're a teenager struggling to find the words to tell his girl, and like, you know what I mean. It's week and immature. Maybe like your woman likes it, but I don't, and it like, takes away from the piece, if you know what I mean.

I have to point out one major snafu: Even though hard times make hard people, I refuse to be bitter, in fact I think you're so sweet I'd just like to taste you once again and sample the delectable fruit of life that can only be bore from your love. Read it again. You are telling her that she bores you. Such misspellings are not good! It doesn't detract from my opinion of your work, but please change it before you give it to her *grin*

You do have a voice shift. You start off talking about her then swing to talking to her. Maybe that's where I feel the disconnect came in. Try making the whole thing to her and not about her. Make it a stronger love letter. I suggest reading Song of Solomon before revisiting it.

You write with strength. You have an admirable ability to put complex ideas and feelings to word. Like everybody else you do have some grammar and spelling issues I didn't even tough on. Don't be afraid to work at editing it and seeking help. The voice meander is also common. Overall I was very moved; it was a powerful read, but it didn't quite knock me over.

WriteOn!

John

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
40
40
Review of I wish  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a down to earth, granular poem. It eats at us because it's real. You take us from your wishes to reality then leave us with a thought of hope. This poem draws me into your feelings, your life. I believe you were able to make us feel so deeply because you yourself do, at least that's what I feel. I find myself worrying about you, but I also find myself hopeful because you understand your situation and see the path out. Not many amateur works do this. Well done!

I'd give you full marks, but I'm a stickler for proper english. I can live with no capital letters and coloqialisms. I can even live with slang. But u, ppl, &, livin, culd, wuldnt, etc are in my opinion mangling the language for the sake of mangling the language. A piece like this doesn't need to be written like a street punk would to add value; it can stand on its own!

Very well done!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

41
41
Review of Untitled  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.0)
*Key* Show Don't Tell!

This to me is the most important thing a writer should strive for. It ranks above grammar, style, plot, or any other word you like to categorize prose with. I don't want to read that the sunset was beautiful or any other adjective. I want you to tell me how the warm falling sun warmed your soul and made all your problems sink with it!


Your narrative is pretty good, but you have very little dialogue. I think it's too little. There's no right or wrong amount, generally. It's a feel thing, but the dialogue in this piece is obviously too thin. It needs much more.

When deciding to insert dialogue or not, one rule is to follow emotion. If you are describing emotion, you probably shouldn't. Take this example from your work. "Bye, mom," Kathryn said as she picked her bag up from the ground, and she groaned as its weight was suddenly on her back. She reached for her pocket, and turned her iPod on once her headphones were in her ears. The loud music blasted through the plastic headphones, and she jumped a little having been caught off guard. "She groaned" suggests there's emotion as does "she jumped a little." PErhaps something like this.

"Bye mom," Kathryn said. She groaned as she picked her bag up.
"What's wrong dear?"
"Too many books. The teachers are really laying on the homework."
Kathryn reached in her pocket and turned on her ipod.
"Damn!" She jumped up on her toes and yanked the headphones off.
"Kathryn!"
"Sorry mom. My ipod was turned up all the way."

You use "she" 65 times, yet we find out very little about Kathryn -- her feelings, desires, and her motivations. I don't want you to tell me she's lonely; I want you to show me.


*Tools*MechanicsThe mechanics of writing are important. Your ideas are tainted if the reader has to fight through sloppy construction. Otherwise uninspiring words can also be brought to life with grammar choices. I include the full armada of grammar here. Please don't assume I know it all though; I don't.

Sentence structure -- there are a couple of dependant clauses written as sentences. You wouldn't go up to somebody and say Or the sweet scent of autumn that permeated in the air. It doesn't make sense on its own. Sentences always make sense on their own. Another is ; the adults to work and the kids to school. A semi-colon is as strong as a period and colon. They separate complete sentences. You probably want a colon or an em dash here. The rest of your work is mechanically fine, so I think this was justa lapse when you started writing it. ; loud enough to drown the noise. fits the same mold.

concern This misspelling tells me you didn't read your work very well. So does this phrase she turned the little device I her pocket off


and yet -- I don't know if you understand what you did here or not. And and yet are both coordinating conjunctions. Technically this is redundant construction. Only one conjunction is needed. It is idiomatic though, and pefectly acceptable in informal writing and fiction. Research idioms.


*Yinyang*Clarity
Humans assume. Very often when we write, we assume the meanings of our written words match the ideas in our heads when we wrote them. I will tell you when they don't, and I may tell you when they do, if it was relevant and weighty. I cover both macro and micro -- structure as well as misplaced words.

I have to call you out on the plot. I read this three times, and I still have no idea what it was about. I know it was an exercise for school. I'm going to suggest you spend some time on plot structures.

You refer to two songs. Are the names relevant to the story or are you showing off your musical tastes? When I hear a song name, I want to know why you mention it. Perhaps the lyrics reflect the character's mood or echo a storyline. When there's nothing there, my attention is pulled away but not handled. It's distracting.

You use eleven semicolons. I think they all link independant clauses. This is techniocally fine, but the clauses need to be closely related. I automatically question the need for so many. Melville uses them excessively, but generally writers use them sparingly.


*ThumbsUp*Likes
Here I try to give you a pat on the back for those magical words. Usually the whole stands out from the individual parts; I find many works at WDC that are very poorly written, yet the passion of the writer shines through. I much prefer a passionate piece full of holes than a perfectly written piece that says nothing! While it may seem I'm trying to balance positivies and negatives, I'm not. I tell it like I see it.

While I did comment on mechanics, you actually have a good grasp of grammar concepts. Your error rate is much lower than typical new writers I see at WDC.

You are not afraid to write. It's sad how few people actually put ideas into words, and fewer look for feedback. These are not trivial qualities of a good writer!

*Quill*WriteOn!
We all need help with our writing, all of us! This is where I tell you what I think you need to work on the most.
My list of recomendations may seem daunting, but really, everybody here has much the same list. These are all on mine.
- continue studying and practicing grammar.
- continue studying and practicing dialogue. Read up on showing vs. telling.
- continue studying and practicing plot construction. Think tension.

*Cart*Notes: This is not an edit. I very likely won't ding you on every punctuation error. If I see a pattern, I'll give one example and maybe point out there are many more problems. My rating may not make sense to you, but it's my assessment of the readiness of your work, not so much quality of your words but readiness for publication.5's are rare from me, but they do happen.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Writing is called a medium; because that is what it is.
42
42
Review of the light of love  
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
First, I am very new to poetry, so take my comments witha grain of salt.
*ThumbsUp*Likes

This piece has feeling. It wasn't constructed; it came out of the heart. That in my opinion is the most important impression any writing can give. You also create some interesting imagery. Light of love -- I will be seeing light as love for quite awhile because of this.

*ThumbsDown*Dislikes

I don't like the its and buts. I think it reads much better if you leave the first it's but remove the next three and the but. Experiment.

The use of punctuation in poetry is intended to direct the voice. A comma is a pause and a period is a longer pause. I think you need a pause after love is love in the last line.

*Cut*Trash-can

its should be it's. Of course its is possessive, and none of these are.

Heart should be plural in in the hearts of all All have more than one heart.

sand should be stand

*Quill*WriteOn!

I really encourage you to keep writing poetry. Yes there are technical issues with this, but you've done a great job creating imagery and feeling.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

NOTE: ASSOCIATE WITH GROUP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Writing is called a medium; because that is what it is.
43
43
Review by Power Unit
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
*ThumbsUp*Likes

Generally you SHOW, DON'T TELL. Good job!

I liked your ending :)

*ThumbsDown*Dislikes

I like to minimize beginning sentences with conjunctions. I'm sure somebody came up with rules for this, but keep it down is all I can recommend. You do it at least four times, twice in the first paragraph.

You use some strong premonitions. It's a bit much for such a short story. I think they need to be removed or toned down. Of course something is necessary, but these are too strong.

A mistake they would regret.

deserved every ounce of what they were about to receive.


Your other prose provides more than enough forshadowing:
I baited him, drawing him in


Bones break, ligaments tear?
breaking ligament


I don't think so. Remember the human wore this. She would not wear something in her hair capable of falling a male. Think about it. Try it yourself.
the weighted jade ring at the end of my hair cracked him across the cheekbone and dazed him.


You are missing some important tension or conflict. This is a straightforward slaughter. We all know what's going to happen, you're extensive foreshadowing told is. Readers want to be dangled. Is she going to get out or not? Can these three overtake her? Can ...? With no questions, there's no interest.

*Cut*Trash-can

Your grammar is good enough for me. Your sentences are generall long and elaborate, but I think that's what you want, even though in my mind an Eternal uses short and sweet prose. Consider whether the mood, tone, and voice match your characters. I think you could find room for improvement.

*Quill*WriteOn!

You have some writing talent. You know grammar. Keep working on story construction!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

NOTE: ASSOCIATE WITH GROUP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Writing is called a medium; because that is what it is.
44
44
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
*ThumbsUp*Likes

I enjoyed your story. At the end, it made me wonder about my surroundings. It made me think where I came from. When a story ignites wonder, it's a success, regardless of any failings.

*ThumbsDown*Dislikes

This is where I discuss items I think have problems. Author's choice always overrides this stuff. It's your choice. I only want you to consider what I think.

The following lines were contradictory to me. This star is born "beyond all traces" of "matter," yet is was birthed from the "subterranean reaches" of an imaginative mind. My problem is that subterranean is a very matter-oriented word. It makes us think of the underground, of lost recesses below the surface of a planet. Conceptually these contradict.

It's not enough to ruin a story, but it's enough to pull my attention, enough to make me want to write about it.

beyond all traces of light and energy and matter

vs

birthed from the subterranean reaches


In the following lines, you describe a light that is both "a piercing, envoloping wave of luminosity" and as "less a sight than an experience." These two ideas clearly contradict. Is it a blinding flash or merely a sputter? You're pulling me in two directions.

The light of that star was not the flickering flame of a candle, but a piercing, enveloping wave of luminosity. It was less a sight than an experience, a sensation of overwhelming intensity.


Ok, first we were beyond all traces of light, energy, and matter, but now were merely in the corner of the galaxy. Last I heard, galaxies were well within traces of such things. I'm not clear how we got here.
For millennia, the star ruled that corner of the galaxy.


I do not believe a stone can form in the center of the sun. You should probably have it develop after the supernova.
It began with the failure of its molten heart. The long ages of roaring energy had taken their toll; the core of the star hardened into firm stone, and little by little it began to die. Its brilliance dimmed, its head faded, until it was but a shade of the giant it had once been. Finally, lacking the energy to sustain itself, the star collapsed inward, drawing all its mass into a single, concentrated sphere. There was a moment of absolute stillness, and the universe seemed to hold its breath.

A massive concussion shattered the void, and the sphere erupted into the awesome splendor of a supernova. Colossal shockwaves ripped through the reaches of heaven, propelling with them a single fragment from the heart of the star.




*Cut*Trash-can

This is where I put bad stuff such as incorrect grammar.

I do believe you've punctuated this sentence incorrectly.
It began in the deep reaches of space, past swirling galaxies of stars and dust, beyond all traces of light and energy and matter.


You have two lists. I'll itemize to make them clearer.

1.in the deep reaches of space
2.past swirling galaxies of stars and dust3.
3.beyond all traces of light and energy and matter
3a.light
3b.energy
3c.matter

I would punctuate this sentence as "It began in the deep reaches of space, past swirling galaxies of stars and dust, and beyond all traces of light, energy, and matter."

*Quill*WriteOn!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

NOTE: ASSOCIATE WITH GROUP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Writing is called a medium; because that is what it is.


45
45
Review of The Mistake  
Review by Power Unit
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*ThumbsUp*Likes

I love the concept. Lots of potential here.

It's a whimsical story. You write from an omniscient pov, and I like how you effectively give each being their own unique tone. It adds up nicely.
Eulidos brings his fist down upon his thigh as he speaks “Bare Hands”; great rumbling ripples through the white-flecked sea of darkness.

“Quit shak’n the heav’ns, you nit!” Tanis pauses.

yet her voice lingers to finish her words before it too follows suit, fading

The youngest of the eternal beings then speaks, calmly.


I really like how you use commas to pace the story. I read it the first time with my standard approach of thinking they were wrong. The second time through I used your commas for beats. It felt much better. Good job!
There, beyond the cloud of stars that play at staring and winking after one another, they three boom and shout


I love how you show us and don't tell us. In this sentence we find out they are huge beings with magical or god-like powers and are intelligent enough to speak. You've done it through describing actions and not exposition. Good stuff!
Their colossal forms materialize and vanish at random, flirting with the thin veil of reality. One materializes, speaking.


I liked the consonance here.
Eulidos brings his fist down upon his thigh as he speaks “Bare Hands”; great rumbling ripples through the white-flecked sea of darkness.


*ThumbsDown*Dislikes

Can gods whip their arms as they materialize or do they have to finsih first? This sentence says it happens simultaneously. Be careful of -ly and -ing traps like this.
Materializing, Tanis whips her thousand arms across at Eulidos;

'Eternal' seems to fit here, but I'd remove it. You are telling us instead of showing us, but I also have to ask if it adds value. Do we really need to know they are eternal? It seems an adjective that merely pulls our attention away from the real meaning of the sentence.
The youngest of the eternal beings then speaks


This was embedded in another god's paragraph. Paragraphs should have a single pov.
Tanis vaguely listens, now staring wide eyed at Orin’s little planet.


*Cut*Trash-can

Not one spelling or grammatical error hit me.

*Quill*WriteOn!

Good stuff. Really enjoyed this :)

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
46
46
Review by Power Unit
Rated: 13+ | (2.5)
I'm giving you a 2.5 because this isn't nearly ready for reading. I don't have huge problems with it technically; there are a few conjunctions missing commas -- but, and.

My problem is I don't know who these people are or where they are. I assume it's in a school, but readers shouldn't have to guess at the scene. Are these seniors or freshmen? Are they athletes or drug dealers? Are they into math or english? Do they get along with each other? The teachers? The principal? The coach? You have lots to add. Please go back and paint some of this for us.

I'll also recommend my favorite dialogue novel. You can actually download a txt version if you want, but be careful of viral stuffs. Read the first chapter of "Dune" by Frank Herbert! [google "dune.txt"]


And Write On!

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
47
47
Review by Power Unit
Rated: E | (3.0)
*ThumbsUp*Likes

You did a good job of giving each person their own character and voice. That's a tough job. Well done!

*ThumbsDown*Dislikes

I disliked all your grammar errors. Ya, grammar is important. It hinders your impact. I identify some below from the first section only.

Are you supposed to stick with one paragraph? They really need to be broken up some. Using a long paragraph that combines several thoughts and ideas doesn't work.


*Cut*Wrong

Needs a comma after gun.
ski mask. “I’ve got a gun" I warn


Google meant

The following sounds like a comma will do, but it needs a semicolon before somehow. Google "conjunctive adverbs."
still smiles, somehow, even though


The first "and," between obeys and I, connects two complete sentences. It needs a comma before it.

The "and" after expenses is not. Take out its comma.

She obeys and I demand $10,000, just enough to cover some medical expenses, and keep my baby healthy for a little longer.



I believe the comma here needs to be a period. The "its" doesn't sound possessive, so it needs a comma. You might want to re-read this sentence; because I'm making assumptions about your intentions. You may be trying to say something like "Its silver and small blue gemmed wings shone under teh fluorescent lights."
butterfly barrette in her hair, its silver with


Another "and" that needs a comma. It joins two sentences.
somehow know it’s me and I



*Quill*WriteOn!

You succeeded in the impact part which IMO is the big thing, but you have work to do on your techique - grammar!

Write On!


My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
48
48
Review by Power Unit
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (3.0)
Overall

This is written as an expositiy message: you tell us what happened. There's no dialogue or character building or scene describing. It's simply telling us what happened.

Specifics

Expositions such as this are usually necessry in fiction, but they come with pitfalls. The largest is they are boring, and your piece doesn't dissapoint. It doesn't matter what the subject matter is. You could describe wars, crimes, love scenes, or simple histories as you've told. They will all be boring, even with the most crafted words.

But they are necessary. We need a certain amount of backstory. We want to know our characters motivations and obstacles. We need to know where we came from before we find out where we're going.

I'm currently learning and exploring myself these backstory issues. We need to make them interesting. Telling the knitty gritty details of the story describing personal feelings, using dialogue, and building tension, plus much more, is usually needed to drive home these points without losing the reader.

Another pitfall of backstories is that we can tell the reader too much information. Yes these facts are all important, but ask yourself if the reader really needs to know them and whether he needs to know them now? Try to spread out the message throughout your novel and let the reader squirm over whatever you hold back. We have lots of words to write, and the reader wants to spend lots of time reading them. Space them out and build tensions and expectations.

None of this is easy, but it's why we're all here!

No grammatical errors hit me i the face which was refreshing!

Recommendations

- utilize other techniques to create your backstory in addition to expositions.
- reconsider what you need to tell your reader now.
- try to weave in your main characters. At least ensure that the content is relevant to their character and motivations in the story. Try to build some empathy towards him or her.
- Find ways to create tension in your prologue. Leave your readers wanting more!


My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
49
49
Review of Dead battery  
Review by Power Unit
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Overall

I am impressed with the impact of your piece. It feels angry and spitefull. It's refreshing to feel tones such as this, and in such a short story. Well done!


Structure

You work your plot with some fine words.

There goes the warden. I hate him.

Here you build the scene, your character, and some tension. In seven words you tell us you are in prison and you are full of hate.

Last meal? PB & J with a glass of milk. What better meal to greet forever with?

I really love this paragraph. It tells us a lot about the character of this person without saying so directly. It's a common man's meal. This is a common man, a man that enjoys the little things in life, and a man that knows his place in the universe.

Saying so much with so few words is what writing is all about!



Grammar

Grammar is where you need some help. Often it seems trivial to discuss, but it is important to get things right. It does detract from your message if the reader has to fight misplaced punctuatiion.

Tomorrow I die. By firing squad if you must know and I know you just gotta. <- this needs a couple of changes. The following is the correct form. Tomorrow I die, by firing squad if you must know, and I know you just gotta.

I recall telling you people this last time but nobody listened, did they? <-- I think this should be written as I recall telling you people this last time, but nobody listened. Did they?

That’s all we ever hear from you and I gotta tell you, we’re all kinda sick of it. <-- This also needs a comma. That’s all we ever hear from you, and I gotta tell you, we’re all kinda sick of it.


I am of course going to recommend studying grammar. We all should. This is a great site. http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/... But there are many resources. Don't expect perfection anytime soon. It takes time to learn this stuff and put it into practice error free.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
50
50
Review by Power Unit
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a very endearing piece for me. My grandparents owned a farm just south of Sparta, just past the Rod & Gun Club. My dad is from Sparta. Cripes, you may even know him :)

You have a few problems with sentence structure and punctuation, but overall you did much more right than wrong. Your characterization and setting were ok, and your story kept me hooked till the end when you let us off. This is a down home feel good story!

Understand I'm easy to pull ino this setting. I can easily visualize Wisconsin farmland and nights on the farm. Others will be tougher. You give us an idea of the land with a single paragraph:

The hillsides leading down from the Michelson Farm toward the Kelly farm contained clean, well tended pastures, which were rotated with dairy cows to ensure pasture recovery in cycles. At the bottom of the hill, across from the Kelly homestead, spread a wide forested area, surrounding a thick, boggy marsh.

You tell me what the farm is like, but most of us know this already. Tell us what it feels like, what is smells like, what it reminds you of. Evoke our sensations not our logic. That's a challange for all of us!

Some problems I found

While I was not expected to replace this stepson, I was assigned to Mr. Michelson’s sponsorship by my mother to assist him in taking care of a great many chores on his farm; in exchange for room and board, of course.

A lot or two south of that intersection lay the Kelly homestead, sharecroppers who worked for Mr. Michelson. Included in their care were a small herd of dairy cattle, a sty containing 30 to 40 enormous hogs, and a variety of barnyard fowl; chickens and geese.

These two sentences above end in participle clauses. Such clauses are incomplete and need to be set off with commas, not semi-colons. Semi-colons are as strong as periods and colons. They can separate two complete sentences. The difference is that sentences have to be closely related to form a consistant thought.

Actual cash I earned from doing odd jobs for other farmers in the local area, as my spare time permitted.

This is not a complete sentence.

When I tired of tramping though these forest paths, I would head towards the gravel road leading back to the Michelson farmhouse, and begin walking towards the bright yard light, shining at the hill top, illuminating my way.

This line has too many commas. the ones after farmhouse and light should be removed.

Bookmark this reference site for more help. http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/607/02/...

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
67 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 3 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/power_unit/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2