*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/storytime/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/10
Review Requests: OFF
3,108 Public Reviews Given
7,053 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 6 7 8 9 -10- 11 12 13 14 15 ... Next
226
226
Review of Life  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi again, wolfepack

This is written pretty well. The message and the imagery are clear and easy to understand.

As a reader, I believe some of the lines could be smoother. Specifically, these two.

Then life shall prevail
In your heart the truth lies


The rhythm breaks here.

You're doing good, writing good poetry takes a lot of practice - keep writing!

If you'll go back into the Edit Page for this item and enter a Content and Intro Rate of E, more people will find it. When it's left blank, it stays inside your port with little exposure. Enter some genres too. Each genre has its own list for members to search. Promote your writing as much as you can.

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
227
227
Review of tomorrow  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (2.5)
Hi, Joey

Welcome to Writing.Com!


Other >> Other >

If you'll go back into the Edit page for this piece and enter the type and choose some genres from the boxes, you'll get more readers. Each genre has its own list, and the more you use, the more exposure you get.


I suggest you visit this forum, introduce yourself, and ask for links to tips on writing this type of poetry. I don't write poetry so can't help you, but writing an accrostic is difficult for anyone. I like the word you used here, Tomorrow. It holds good possibilities for emotion.

Noticing Newbies  [13+]
A warm welcome to our newbies; come meet new and not-so-new members of Writing.Com!
by The StoryMistress


Good start!



Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.

"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


228
228
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello, Dreamer73

I was roaming today and found your port. I'd forgotten how good of a writer you are. This is a beautifully written story, the emotion and imagery truly brings it to life.

I believe it's publishable in a collection of short stories, it's a good read.

I did notice a typo in the title, it's -E--instead of -A-. correspondence
These are always confusing to me. *Smile*

Well done!








** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **







229
229
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (2.0)
Hello, Mithandriel

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

Looking for detailed feedback on the content of the story focusing on flow, characterization, dialogue etc. I'm not overly concerned with specific grammar or punctuation issues as these can be caught once I work on the second draft.

Your story is interesting and it has some good emotion. Good tension in the fight scene. I do suggest you add a little more clarity on the altercation between Erin and her father though. Was all this actually physical, or mostly yelling? Somehow, I can't see a daughter who cares for her father to actually hit him more than once. The shock would be great for both of them.

My mouth is dry so I take a sip of the soda that’s been diluting in the glass resting on the pull down armrest of the couch.

There is a lot of information in this line. I wonder if it could be shortened to more than one sentence? It might sound better if we read this as his thoughts, instead of him just telling it. Play around with the gist of what you want to show and say, and see what you can come up with. Readers won't care if it's on a 'pull-down armrest' for instance. The line could stop with ...glass.--and still say the same thing. Extra words always slow the pace of the story, and you lose tension. This leads to 'boring' and that's a place no one wants to go.
*Smile*

I make it to the store and pull up to the front. I don’t see Erin so maybe she’s still shopping.

All this time I thought she was working. So why was he at her house?

A question: Did he take her shopping; and if so, why didn't he wait for her? Did she shop after work? That would fit if she worked close by. A Mall?


My car’s been broken for weeks and I’ve got no money to fix it. Erin lets me use her car which is fine. It just means I need to drive all the way over to her parent’s house every morning to take her to work, then back to pick her up in the afternoon. It hasn’t been that easy working to juggle but what choice do I have?

Why does he need the car if he isn't working and isn't in school? A few details would clarify his need. What is he juggling? And, it is important because this is the main point of the story.


“Mrs. Collins. I can understand your upset

Grammar: --you're--
I know you asked for no editing, but I can't help it. Bad grammar affects the read. This is only one - I restrained myself. Actually, there aren't many errors.
*Smile*

the boring review book. I need to pass this test to get certified. I really need this job.

The readers will be able to know him better if they know more about him. What is the book; what is the test and certification?


those are from Richie’s dinner last night.“

Why does he know this? It would be clear if he'd said 'breakfast', but dinner? Was he there for Richie's late snack?


I’m twenty years olds and I shouldn’t be working some crappy retail job. I know I didn’t make it through college but I’m smart enough to make better then minimum wage.

I found parts of the beginning narration difficult. It sounds odd to hear him think of himself like this. Since it's needed for the character's background, it would sound more natural if it could be shown in dialogue form. Perhaps in a conversation with Erin?


It's pretty good and the second draft will be better. They always are. *Smile*

I hope this helped a little.







** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **







230
230
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hello, Gerard Muller

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

I liked this very much. You're good with imagery and emotion, and they were the hooks that kept me reading. Good writing.

I found some technical issues for you to watch for. Watching for these and avoiding them will make the writing much tighter, and you'll be able to notice the difference when you read it aloud. They are issues we all have until we're told of them, so don't think they're unique to your writing. *Smile*


Harvey Keel slanted his brow and regarded the woman with growing curiosity

This word doesn't show well. I think you're trying to say he frowned, but 'slanted' shows something else. Try something like: furled, frowned, or wrinkled. There are probably other good words, too. Try the Thesaurus for ideas.


“And while were at it you can drop that sarcasm from your tone.”

The apostrophy was lost.


Other families had threatened to impose legal action if they felt that the funeral home had either treated them unfairly or was engaged in illegal or unethical business practices. But, unlike most other businesses, the funeral business acted in accordance not only with standard business regulations but with regulations dictated by the state’s cemetery board.

Read this para for accuracy. It sounds like he was going to say 'legal action on other businesses', but never on funeral homes. I'm just not quite sure what he's saying. Is this info important? Can it be cut way down to only one line?


strike. She reluctantly—though wanting to follow the rules—returned it to the box without a word.

This is another bump for this reader. I suggest cutting the bolded piece to smooth it out. Read it without and see what you think. --though wanting--are the carriers of confusion here.


“I’m sorry if I seem a bit worked up. I know your trying to do your

---you're--


his
He
him
porch


The first three words are used numerously and are more noticeable at the beginning, the first half. That area is moving slow and these words are bogging it down slower. Do you know how to to use the 'find' option in your word processor? You can check for words and see how often they're used. It's a great tool.

--Porch-- is only used five or so times, but the problem is they are all bunched together in one para. Try not to repeat too often.


“Are you sure, Andy? It’s pretty cold this morning and you can’t go getting sick, you.”

Take another look at the last word in this line. If you find you really don't need it, I suggest cutting it. It causes the reader to stop and wonder what it means.


Besides, he is wearing his faded blue superman shirt, as always. He likes the way this shirt feels—the thin clinging cotton—but more importantly he likes the way it makes him feel; the red “S” curving against his chest empowers him and elicits a sense of safety.

There is too much content between the first bolded line, and the last bolded line. I believe the --Besides,--relates strictly to his sense of safty, but with all the extra in between, they don't tie together tightly. A slight rewrite would fix it; if you agree.


swoops down from the lines and snatches a mouse—or was it a small rabbit?

There is a pretty noticeable difference in size between these two. I suggest choosing one and making it a definite image that the readers can see. He may not be close enough to 'see' what it was, but he can guess. Can a hawk pick up a small rabbit? I don't know, but it would have to be bigger than the ones I see where I live.
*Smile*

dimly lighted memorial showroom.

Try --lit--to see how it sounds to you.


with a motherly glow that seemed not imprudent like her previous demeanor but somehow discreet and graceful.

As a mother, I don't like this. Either this guy knows nothing about grieving in spite of his years of seeing it, or he is awfully cold. Her previous actions were normal and not out of place at all. She wanted what she wanted and she asked, that's all. There is nothing for you to change, I'm only saying how this character is affecting me, as a reader and mother. I don't like him, and she immediately draws my sympathy.


who was beginning to wonder what other bizarre characteristics this woman possessed.

Again, I saw no bizarre behavior from her. She was acting natural in her position. If you wanted the readers to see her as the funeral director is describing her, you'll need to work on it some more as far as I'm concerned.


“Beautiful, Mr. Keel. This is wonderful news. But I still want this casket, this one right here,” she said softly, pointing at the inferior casket. And then she said something quite unusual. “Does this casket have a lock on it, Mr. Keel?”

The bolded line is extra and could be cut to avoid some wordiness. --but I still--is questionable and distracting. Why would she have changed her mind? Readers have already seen the casket so it doesn't need another mention. Following the --wonderful news--with the line, --then she said--would work perfectly.
By the way, this is a great hook-line to keep readers reading. I want to know why she wants a lock. *Delight*

The crew would then a dig a hole and set a
He then he donned his white gown

Only a couple of extra words.


They had dug a whole in the backyard, wheel barrowing

A typo I believe. --hole--


He turned and pointedto vault,

A missing word here. --to the vault--


He eagerly carries and rolls, rolls and carries the items to the front counter, where Mr. Ardoin is picking up the dripping cases of beer.

I suggest naming what he is rolling to the counter. I assumed it was the beer, but Mr. Ardoin is doing that. The other items weren't thrown to the floor: the jerkey, etc. and they can't be rolled. Perhaps having him clean the sugar that he was already told to do, would avoid a bit of confusion.


company were scarcely sufficient to ensure a financially secure future for her and Andy; although not having to continue living in an abusive relationship was, in its own, compensation enough.
Life went on, however, and the change was indeed welcoming and relieving, despite the financial challenges in the wake of her husband’s death.


This is an issue of repetition. The lack of money and the relief of the absense of an abusive husbacd is told twice, back-to-back. Say it once and it'll be remembered.


Such had been life for mother and son; it had been a hard life. It was even harder now that

The bolded line could be cut easily. It is only 'telling' again what readers already know. Cutting it would also avoid the repeat of --hard--


glanced at the stove clock: 9:50,

I was so caught up in the emotion and imagery of this window scene, it seemed like much time had passed. I was surprised it had been only twenty minutes. Well done!

For the ease of your readers, space between paragraphs is a requirement for online reading, especially on long pieces. Indents don't help much here. Presentation counts too. I looked at your port work and see that some does have space, so I wonder why the longer pieces don't.

The story content is good, it's interesting and has a hint of darkness coming. It would keep the reader turning the pages.

I found the first half moved too slow. Though the imagery of Andy leaving the porch was wonderful, and the opportunity of describing the setting was well taken, I couldn't help but become impatient. Andy is described clearly. In fact, each character is seen vividly.

Take care to cut the extra words such as I've mentioned above, and look for more as you read aloud. They really do bog a good story down.


I hope this helped as you continue to write.






** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **








231
231
Review of 11 - 19  
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi, Pennywise

I found this item featured on "Review This! from the "Please Reviewforum.

Wow, for a 500 word limit, you've covered it all. Good work!

I found only one grammar error, if you're allowed to edit while the contest is open. If not, it can be done later. The other issues are for later, if you decide to do any revising. I think you should, it's has a good beginning and could go further.

A week later, I kissed my ass goodbye

The piece is just too short to carry two of the same statements. This one has no impact on this reader, but the first one did. It's funny.


I was more alive then ever

Grammar. --than--


within a brick building.

This is distracting because I knew he had to arrive in the same spot in which he left. This sounds like it's different on first read. Perhaps a few words clarifying it was built on the old foundation would avoid this small bump.


my bullet

I think a better word is needed. The narrator is from the modern, internet era, he could think of something more descriptive. Don't use the same word twice though: apparatus, appliance, contraption, device.

The story is complete for its purpose, and easy to see and understand. You've shown it well. The narrator didn't interfere at all, even though he was the MC. I saw the action through his eyes, not by standing beside him. Good job!

Sci-fi genre would work well.

Good luck in the contest. It's a good read.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
232
232
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
Hi, SwordPen

I found this item featured on "Review This! from the "Please Reviewforum.

You've a good, strong opening that will surely catch the attention of your targeted audience. Well done!

prison they never open a cell the door to release a free man,

An extra word.


As we arrived right in front of the steps up to the gallows the townspeople started to gather

Examples of unneeded words that tend to make a piece 'wordy' and bog it down.


As I was lead up the stairs I took one last look at the people’s faces around

Spelling for this context is --led--


The music stooped and the whole world was silent --A typo--

Not even a word was said by anyone before he swung

Extra and unnecessary.


As soon as I had died a rush of feeling shot into me.

Extra


as he picked up his axe and headed over to the rope holding me up.

This is pretty light in image intensity, for me. Try, for example: ...his axe and stepped toward me. You want the readers to focus on the character and his feelings, not about the rope, they know it is where he is.


Not even a word was said by anyone before he swung the axe and my neck snapped. Right before it happened I saw the old man that had been sitting on the bench. His eyes were dull gray and peering straight into mine. The second before the rope was cut he winked one eye and everything disappeared. It was over quick just

I was alive but I couldn’t move except open my eyes.
I struggled to move or make a sound but I couldn’t do anything but look around me. There was no pain or feeling just nothingness.

Right in here I think will need more work when you can get to it. I suggest cutting the first two lines in bold because they are inconsistent with the next line in Blue. This makes the writing awkward. If the para was begun with the line in blue it would still say the same thing and give the same imagery, but it would be much less wordy and repetitive.

The reader is told more than once that he can't move anything but the eyes.

The reference to winking one eye is distracting since a wink does involve only one eye. Perhaps, --an eye--?

If you get into the habit of printing the work and proofreading from the hard copy, you will more easily find your issues.

I listed one example each of several issues, you will find the rest as you read through it. Too many extra words such as some of the ones mentioned here, will cause a read to slow down too much, and that always leads to boring. Be aware and look for these when it's time to rewrite.

The character is seen well and the readers sympathy is immediately given to him. I can see the setting clear enough to know it's a dismal place. I can feel the warmer air that can only be felt by being close to the window. Your descriptions are excellent, and they help pull the reader along. It promises horror and evil. It isn't determined yet on which side of good and evil the character will play.

To find the answers to more of my questions, I suppose I'll need to wait and see. I'm curious about the timeline, where men are kept for thirty years before execution on the gallows, is a big one for me.

Good beginning!



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
233
233
Review of cottage  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (2.5)
Hello, Megs

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I love the country - I used to live in a place like this and you've described it well. Good work!

I've listed the spelling issues for you so they can be fixed, if you want to.

air floting --floating--
the erley --early--
relfeting of the rideau lake --reflecting--
all hiped up --hyped-up--
in to the night --I believe you mean --into--the night.
pooring --pouring--
I thank!!

I wonder if you mean --I think!--? You think of the place and go there in your mind? Or, you 'thank' whoever takes you there? It isn't clear.


Your descriptions show the imagery wonderfully!

Well done, good luck and enjoy the site!

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
234
234
Review of ex-love  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (2.5)
Hello, Tanacka

Welcome to Writing.Com!

You've shown the emotion very well, it's sad and resigned. Good work.

The message is a bit rambly, but it's all there. It's understood clearly.

Rated:
------
Intro Rated:
N/A


You can add a rate a E to both these boxes in the Edit pages. Without a rate, it won't show to everyone.


You thought me that it was ok to trust -- spelling error--

The best that I could say i that i have

This line needs some attention for clarity.

I believe punctuation would enhance the piece, allowing the words to flow smoothly without the reader having to stop and consider them.


Good luck and enjoy the site!



Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
235
235
Review of Magic Man  
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hello, invisible man

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I liked this, it's a good theme. Especially the first lines.

He
Would connect things with
His magic thread.


What a vision this gives me, it's real.

I found a spelling error I wanted to point out. Otherwise, no problems that I noticed.

Tying up all of lose ends

--loose--


Well done, enjoy the site!

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
236
236
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hello, Gildor

Welcome to Writing.Com!

It wasn’t before the walker abandoned it for the lush grass of the park, and he made his way toward a stone well that rested among a grove of pine.

This line needs clarifying, something is missing. Abandoned what?


It was a deathly silence that shrouded the place, all except for the cold breeze that swayed the grass, and the gentle pulsing of the sack at his waist.

This could be tightened by cutting the bolded words and beginning the line with --A deathly silence--


earthen passage beneath the city. An ancient road, a thousand years old. {b{A road that harbored secrets darker than ever imagined.

An incomplete sentence. If it could be combined with the next it might be smoother. I like the descriptive words and hope you keep them, only cutting 'a road that'


Torches light the giant hall, held by brackets upon the stone columns. Set into the walls were hundreds of arched door ways, leading into secret locked rooms.

The amount of doors is unbelievable to me. Does there have to be this many?


Finally, he came to smaller doorway near the back of the hall.

A word is missing.


Inscribed upon the arch was a message:
Here lies what only the goddess may reveal.

Have you discovered Writing ML yet? In Site Navigation under Site Tools. I think italics would show this as a inscription clearer. {i}here lies what{/i} here lies what


Soon, an eerie black light began to radiate from beneath the skin of his fingers.
The eerie light reflected upon
an eerie black light faintly began to glow from it

I suggest using the word only once to avoid losing the power of it. It's a good word - keep it strong. A couple of substitutes would be --
uncanny, unearthly, weird.--though I advice against --weird--. I believe it's too modern for this story.


Upon that small pedestal, there laid a simple, black leather bound book.
It was madness that threatened to consume him as he brushed his hand across the leather cover.

Avoiding too many repeats will avoid a piece becoming wordy. In this line, the first bolded could be cut easily since the second shows the leather binding.


The blackness gripped him, and as it did he grasped tightly the edges of the book and in a lustful fury flung open its pages----

With a shaking hand he drew the sack from his belt and held the throbbing vessel before him,

Good examples of 'showing' his emotion. Body language is perfect.


and a black voice boomed inside his head and shook his being like a mighty earthquake.

I suggest you do a 'Word Find' to avoid using any word too often. This one (and) is used numerous times and causes the lines to slow which reduces the tension that the words invoke. An example on how they can be cut without losing clarity: ---...boomed inside his head --that-- shook his being like a...


lust
lustful
madness


Repeated often enough to become noticeable. Try to find substitutes.


and the once bright steel turned as the black as midnight and it was that blackness that twinkled in his eyes.

The first bolded word is extra, to be removed.
--twinkled--gives a cheerful, happy tone that he doesn't have. I suggest something more fitting his evilness. Maybe just --shone--would work?


The black energies began to infest within him and feed his madness.
At last, his human soul was gone. A lustful desire drove him now,

How was this accomplished? A few details describing it would make a strong scene.


“My resurrection, has begun.”

This was a good, exciting scene. Well done.


Chapter One:

through the flame that lit the solitude of his dank barracks quarters.====
==
A small flame leaped from the solitary candle. It danced in the night, illuminating the darkness, a black, joyless shade that enveloped the drafty stone walls of the barracks.


These lines are redundant. Repeating info will cause a piece to become wordy and boring.


and a small golden ring hung from both ears. He wore no beared, choosing instead to remain clean shaven as a sign of a

--beard--
Since I had to copy this line for 'beard' anyway, I want to mention the bolded word --both-- would sound smoother if it was changed to --each--ear. It's not a major thing.


The two men locked there gloved hands together at the chest and tilted slightly toward the

--their--


Matthew’s pipe hung from his mouth as he stretched his arms into the air, giving a yawn.

This really isn't possible as I visulize it. I think having him hold the pipe with teeth would show clerer.


And that was true. Since the night Matthew had saved him in the woods, Becken had not said a word regarding the terrors they had faced

When I read this I thought the names were written wrong. It would avoid a readers distraction to include Becken's name when the incident is first mentioned. Not much is needed, just include it.


He had seemingly grown up normally, as if the ordeal had never occured. Matthew wondered

This is passive writing and will affect the read if used too often. I suggest being concise and confident so the readers will know if this is true or not. Perhaps he 'showed no signs of being affected by the ordeal'. He could definitely grow up normally in the phsical sense.


Matthew wondered what Becken hid from him and why he would not discuss.

A word is missing at the end to complete the line.


So Beck, did you finally decide to compete in the tournament tomorrow following the ceremony.” Becken’s agitation from the moment before left him and a grin crossed his face.
“Now Matty, why on earth do you think I ‘de do a thing like that.

These are both questions and need the question mark.

--I'm not sure if the --'de--is a manner of speech or if it means --I'd--


name from the stands and throw flowers and handkerchiefs down to my feat,

--feet--


The other two men rolled there eyes as Becken continued on.

--their--


“Well Beck, don’t get to caught up on yourself,” Mortimer chimed in.

“Ha! That I did, and I stand by it to.

This happens a few times. --too-- (also)--


clouds. He’ll bust you up real good if your too busy waving at wenches.”

Grammar issue. --you're-- (you are)


“My dear captain,” he said. “I’ll have you know I quite fancy a miss Leneia Sommerton, and I

as part of her name, it requires a capital too. --Miss--


Becken glared at them with disapproval and sucked on his pipe in silence.

A very well shown scene! I could see and feel Becken's aggravation clearly.


from his mouth, placing it on the table. His eyes darkened.
The mood of the room had suddenly grown humorless.


Good work! 'darkened eyes' changed the mood well.


Mortimer leaned over the table towards the other two men, his became airy and merely a whisper.

A word is missing.


“I do not know what is happening, but these new commanders are not to be trusted, and the

The tension is becoming strong, but these formal words almost stopped it. I suggest you try --don't--to keep the tension moving. I think you're trying to show the seriousness of what he's about to say, but it doesn't work like this. (for me).


Matthew skin went cold, fear shown in his eyes betraying him.

--Matthew's--skin. --possesive.


Becken shared that fear as well, for he to had been there that night in the woods, among the shadow walkers.

The room went still, rank with fear. Matthew filled with terror as the memory of that night resurfaced in his mind.

--repetition. I believe there are three --fear--pretty close together.


He could feel the mans blade as it pierced his flesh

--man's--because the blade 'belonged' to the man. Possesive.


Becken spoke out. “Do you believe that those men have something to do with this plot?”

Nothing was mentioned of a 'plot'. It needs to be discussed before this line.


The captain turned to him. “This is all to true my friend,

--too--
I suggest you study the difference of --to and too--to avoid these errors.
--too--means --also, more, very, --once you understand the meaning, this issue won't happen any more.
*Smile*

He smelled the aroma of the fern leaf, trying to clear his mind, to reveal the secret that lie beneath it all.

--lay--


pain consumed him, threatening to over take him

This is one word. --overtake--


Suddenly he was torn from the nightmare by a strong outside force, and he thrown to the stone floor,

This is an extra word to be cut.


The stool fell to the ground, clambering upon the stone.

He kicked off his boots and stripped off his tunic,

I've never seen a pair of boots that can be 'kicked' off, unless they're too big. I suggest --pulled-- for a better image.


“Thank you Mort, your very kind.” The two men managed a smile.
“Well, off to sleep than lad. We’ll see you in the morning.”

--you're-- --then--


Suddenly the large wooden doors
through the great wooden doors

He was flanked by the royal guard. With dozens to each side, he walked between the flanks, his head held high as he

--He walked between the --rows--?


They carried their heads low towards the floor, their hands held inside the opposite sleeves.

I wonder about the visual of this. --heads down--would say the same thing, wouldn't it?


“Devoted servant, do you swear to protect the king that she has chosen to rule her people in the land of Leodoria, as long as he serves her in earnest.”
“I swear to protect the king, as long as he honors Her name.”
“Devoted servant, do you swear to protect the warriors of faith with your life, to draw your sword against those who would bring harm to them, and thus dishonor our goddess.”


Separate each paragraph and each speaker with a space. It's needed to make the piece more reader friendly, and it's the way to format for online reading. Large hunks of text are hard to read.

Reading your work aloud from printed copy will allow you to find issues and errors that you won't see by reading on the monitor. Simply the change triggers your brain to 'see' things differently.

The story is good. It's interesting and tense. The characters are coming along and becoming real. I have no suggestions there, it's good. Mystery is being raised as the plot is laid out. I wonder about the King's loyalty.

It's a good beginning.


Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
237
237
Review of school madlib  
Review by esprit
Rated: ASR | (2.0)
Hello, smartypants

Welcome to Writing.Com!

This sounds like an creative madlib, but it's in the wrong format. If it's intended to be joined by other writers, you'll need to go back into 'Create a New Item' and choose the Interactive. no one can add to Stactics.

Good luck and enjoy the site.

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
238
238
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (2.5)
Hello, Alexis

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I noticed this hadn't been reviewed yet, so I decided to try to see why. I see you probably didn't write this, but are only posting the information.

I believe if you'd add a note to clarify the State in the piece, you might catch some attention. I know it's in the brief description, but not noticeable. Also, if the links were workable, it would be easy to click over and check it out. Since the prizes are good and time is of the essence, I suggest getting it out there to be noticed. That is, if that's the purpose of the post. *Smile*

I hope you post some of your own writing here.

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
239
239
Review of Is It A Sin?  
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hello, geloquence

This is a lovely piece, perfect for Valentine's day. 'Personal' isn't included as a genre, but anyone would love to receive this.

It reads easy with a good, gentle tone. Friendly and good vibes are felt by the reader. You're a good writer.

Subtle glances are exchanges

This may be intended, but it doesn't sound right to me, and it doesn't fit with the next line. Perhaps it's a typo of --exchanged--?


I enjoyed the reading - well done!








** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
240
240
Review of The Planet-Eater  
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (2.5)
Hello, Nosebleed

Welcome to Writing.Com!

What a writers imagination you have! I found so many interesting surprises, I had to keep reading. I liked the story. *Smile*

It begins and ends with interest and reality. It was believable, and that's not easy to do with this amount of fantasy. Good work!

My suggestions are to do with writing in general, so I hope they help in this and your future work.

And then

*Bullet*A tip: --then-- is a word used to make lists. Using too many will bog the story down and make it appear to be one long list. 'then he did this', 'then he did that' doesn't allow the lines to read smoothly and naturally. This leads to wordiness and boredom follows quickly. Stay aware of overusing and repeating any word or phrase. This word is used over thirty times and is very noticable.

the boy

Did you realise this is repeated 21 times? You could sub once in a while with 'he' and anything else descriptive of him. 'kid' - 'young man'. Variety is the goal.

Then he lights the candles. It takes it a few tries, as his hands are shaking a fair bit now. He lights each candle, one at a time, and then looks over the pentagram again. Then he looks down at the book, and opens the dusty pages,

This is a very vivid scene, I can even smell the dust. Well done!
Take a look at the bolded 'then' and read the passage without using them. Do you see how you really don't need them? Removing them will change the first word of the sentence so don't forget to vary them or you'll wind up with too many beginning with 'He' and have another problem.
*Smile*

but finds that his hand cannot reach it; it is quite high up. He utters a shaky moan, and then looks around him.

I thought, uh oh, he's in big trouble. Good imagery.


The bloody passages inside the giant are still planet sized. The boy feels like an ant as the passages flow by.

I can follow him along and see what he sees. Good job.


“Edgar Allen Poe? Uh… The writer?”
“Possibly one of his many guises


I laughed out loud here, it's funny! I like humor so I might be a little biased, but they are good lines.


“Yeah, I’ll help you find him even, if you just help me home, I-

“Destroy Earth? Please man, don’t-“


The dialogue is natural and fits the age. Very realistic and audible, I can hear the emotional desperation in his voice.


That is when he notices the object that was emitting the light that he saw from the other side of the portal.

This should be --noticed--

I suggest cutting the redundant phrases that are used mostly in the beginning. You should have to say something just once in a piece this short. Readers will know what is meant because they read about it just before. That happens quite a bit with the pentagram scene. If you can print the story and read it from the hard copy, you can more easily see where these things are and fix them. Trying to proofread from a computer screen hides things from the brain, and you miss them.


I really enjoyed how you handled the issue of 'perception' I think this is one of the most interesting and vivid pieces I've read dealing with time and perception. The end brought it all together in a creative and surprising way. Good work!

The main character is stuck in his predicament without resolvement, and I don't like that much. But, it fits the theme well. A second chapter to bring him back might be fun. I wonder what his original purpose was for trying to do a spell? Curiosity probably. *Smile*

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum

I hope I've given you a few ideas you can use. I've named quite a few things, but I believe you'll be pleased after a little rewriting.

Well done!


"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
241
241
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hi, betiscute

I found this item featured on "Review This! from the "Please Reviewforum.

I love memory stories, and I love to write them. Yours is vivid and emotional and pleasureable to read. Good work with the content.

I have some suggestions on how it can be tightened and polished, I hope they help as you continue to perfect this piece and write others.

In back of the building I lived in, there was a large, grassy field with a large hill that stood opposite our apartment.

Repetition of important words are something to avoid whenever possible. Choosing another is the best thing to do to avoid wordiness which leads to boring. Avoid boring at all costs. *Delight* Don't worry, yours is not quite at that stage, but it is slowed down.

The first bolded phrase could be cut easily without losing any clarity. Readers will already know this. Cutting the bolded 'large' would be easy too, it's tighter because it cuts a repeat. You could find a humourous substitution if you wanted to describe it. --humongous--?


Ready, Set, Go! We would roll down the hill

This whole scene of play is beautiful! I can see the children and hear their squeals. Good imagery!


emanating off of the metal, the wooden planks under my feet,dirt crunching as I walked.

Lists of three will require a connector before the third. --and the-- dirt...


We weren't allowed to walk down the tracks. There were hobos further down the tracks, my

This phrase could be cut to avoid three repeats very close together. It's what is called an 'obvious statement' Readers will already know because they've already been told.


They lived in a shack in the woods on the other side of the tracks

What about this one? Do you think it's really needed or will the readers be able to figure it out, since they're walking the tracks to get there? I suggest cutting it. If something else is needed maybe something about how far off the shack is. A mile or 'hidden back in the woods a bit'

The woods surprised me. I thought only the buildings could be seen.


To the right and to the left, across the street, and as far around me as I could see,

I suggest adding the 'woods' in the description here.


to each other, both of us just a little frightened but never admitting it

There seemed to be more friends on the hill, so I expected more than two here. It caused a small bump in the smoothness of the read. It can be fixed easily. --A friend and I--? One of my friends and I--? My best friend? Lots of possibilities.


excited and scared, we defied my mother and started walking, nervously whispering to each other, both of us just a little frightened but never admitting it

I think it was just admitted. *Delight* Perhaps rewording a bit, --more frightened than we would admit--?


we lived in a second floor apartment in an old, red brick apartment building that housed four apartments.

I highlighted because it's easier for the writer to understand what the reviewer means when we say repeats aren't a good thing. You have one more line with the word used too. It can be fixed though. ---we lived on the second floor of an old, red brick building that housed four apartments.

*Bullet*A tip: If you print your story and read from the hard copy, these things will begin to pop out at you once you're aware of the issue.


red brick buildings. There was little lawn in front of my building, just a small patch of green

in pickle jars with holes poked in the top of the caps
would be able to breath.

I suggest cutting either 'in the top' or 'of the caps'. It's redundant. They mean the same thing.
A typo of --breathe--


socks and mittens soaking wet, my hands and feet red from the cold.
into warm, dry ones
We would pick wild berries and eat to our heart's content
We'd pick wildflowers and bring them home to our mothers.


You're a good writer of description. These can be seen, tasted and felt. Well done!


There were hobos further down the tracks, my mother told me.

One more thing about this sentence. It's structure seems a little awkward to me. I suggest you play with the words a little. I thought something like; --My Mother told me there were hobos further down the tracks.--What do you think?

Repetition is something that sneaks in on all of us, and it takes a reader to find them. With practice, you'll notice fewer and fewer. Don't worry, it's a good piece, it's in it's editing stage now. The content is vivid and fun, the wordiness is a big issue.


Well done!



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

242
242
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (2.5)
Hello, gtausif

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review
Is my story too preachy? predictable? boring? Honest critique requested

It's a good story, but I found several things that are bogging it down and holding back the tension that the words express. The main issue is passiveness and repetition. But, yes, they lead to the other issues that you asked about.

other girls. They invented cruel nicknames for their class-mates and did not care if someone's feelings got hurt. Other girls

Notice the repeats? The words are used in other places too, 'girls' especially. I have left a list of words below that I suggest you try to cut. Some you won't be able to take out, but remove as many as possible.

The bolded --did not--would sound more natural as the contraction --didn't--

rest of the day but they did not care. --another--

They were always together in school

Since the story clearly takes place at school, this could be cut as obvious.


her head in exasperation and went off.

This sounds awkward, but it also could be misread. The phrase is slang for becoming angry - yelling. –Did you consider –left– or –walked away–?


She was extremely polite and intelligent. She had a strange sing-song voice and moved with a quiet grace

The character is too perfect. A Saint. She won’t seem real, or she won’t be liked or sympathized with. [by kids] Adult readers will love her. To get to the kids she’ll have to have the same feelings as they do. She can be as she is described, but somewhere she has to show some normal emotion. My suggestion:


approached Laila's family with a good natured smile

Instead of doing this, which is not a natural act, she could avoid looking a Laila. Showing a bit of anger in her thoughts, wishing she were somewhere else. Then, she could rescue Ali the same way, except running from her own position on the beach. Make Laila have to approach her with humility. Laila is having everything too easy, which kids will resent, along with Mbabwe’s perfection.



Mbabwe then looked up and waved to her.

The word is among the list below, but I want to explain the why. Read the line without the word. It says the exact same thing, but it’s tighter. Wordiness leads straight to boring, and we all want to avoid that place. But, as I mention elsewhere, the line could be cut to enhance the realism.


noticed his daughter lack of geniality

possessive –daughter’s–


She then saw somebody swimming in the water in quick graceful strokes.

This can be cut as obvious. If you do, don’t forget to add –with–quick, graceful...

This caused another issue for me with credibility. In her state of mind, would she be admiring the strokes?

Why isn't she running to the water, screaming and crying? I can't believe she would be still be sitting with her mother - it's not natural.


She saw the person then submerge again and change directions.

She started coming in shore with the limp body in her

This is awkward and lacks emotion and tension. Consider maybe –She hurried as fast as she could. Something.
So they were in shallow water, but she dived? Is she swimming and pulling the boy or in fact, just walking and carrying him? The scene needs clarifying just a bit more to raise the tension.


Some jumped in the water but where

The bolded word is in the list. Try something else, such as: ---A few men—


a wet, squealing, splattering, thoroughly disheveled, but still chattering incessantly__

Credibility issue. There would have to be a time of reviving. He’s been under water too long to be this active. A good area to build tension and emotional involvement with the readers.


Laila went up to them and hugged them both.

This holds no excitement or emotion. A couple of suggestion would be: –rushed–ran–anything to show movement and tension.


She then looked around and saw Mbabwe

Again, needs emotion and movement. An example: She turned around to find Mbabwe. This could be a great turning point for her. Can you find words to show her thoughts went to Mbabwe and she was anxious to find her?


She had learned that physical beauty

I don’t like stories that lay out the moral like this. The moral is seen within the story, the point should be clear enough without ‘telling’ the readers what they just learned. The paragraph isn’t needed.


Laila stood in front of the class and apologized to each class mate for her
to apologize to her for her past behavior,


A credibility issue. This couldn’t be such an easy thing for her to do. This is too pat and sugary. Where is her emotion of shame and regret? Where is her fear of not being forgiven? Would she stutter a bit, wondering if the kids would understand? Give her a deeper problem and kids will like it. They’ve been there and like to see how others handle the it. This girl is about to do the hardest thing ever, make it hard.



to show her over whelming –This is one word.–

went
some
then
people
had
There are others that will begin to notice now that you're aware of avoiding repetition. I suggest printing it out to read from. It looks different on hard copy and you'll notice areas that need to be worked on.

for a second and then screamed
For an agonizing second

There was a resounding splash

Credibility issue. A spash wouldn’t be heard from her position. The sea is a noisy place.
One more point. If the child is that close to the water, he wouldn't spash, he would only be pulled along.


She saw the person then submerge again
Other people gathered around them

--the crowd--? A crowd rushed–


As she approached the excited people, her feet slowed.

This doesn’t focus on what she would be doing, which is going to her brother. I wonder if she would even notice the crowd?


This was a fun one to review, a lot of interesting scenes to deal with. You've done a good job of pulling it all together. I hope my time was well spent and you find some good in all this. *Smile* It was a pleasure.



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



243
243
Review by esprit
Rated: ASR | (1.5)
Hello, Angst Mysterium

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I'm roaming the pages at random today and the title of this one caught my eye. I found it an interesting piece, but a little confusing. I believe if you continue to work on it, readers will enjoy it.

A few questions I have after reading.

will be answered, and interpreted here in ---herein--

the question of the gravest importance

Was this a bit of a 'pun' for humor? It worked with me!
*Smile*

contain little or perhaps none of these ingredients stated to begin with.

You might consider cutting the bolded phrase. The structure is awkward and caused this reader to have to read it several times to understand. I believe cutting it would cause no problems.


The first stage of the said process is the administration of a potion known as the Coup Padre. ====
The process begins when the victim is injected with, or perhaps is forced to inject this substance.

I found it confusing to follow. How can there be 'two' first steps'? Can it be clarified?


turn is replaced by a lao that is controlled

I suggest you explain words that may be unfamiliar to your general audience. I don't know what this is, so probably other readers won't either. The definition I found wouldn't apply to this.


soon after the victim’s burial, an ancient voodoo rite is performed.
Two days prior to this, the corpse is unearthed.

These lines don't seem to be in the correct order. I suggest staying in order so the reader can follow along.


which in my opinion is where the idea and creation of this process and myth originated.====
===It is a small island nation in which the origins of voodoo are also said to have begun

Does the first line mean your 'opinion' agrees with your research? If this was said just once, it would avoid reader confusion.


which in my opinion is where the idea and creation of this process and myth originated. Scientifically most logical minded people would find this idea preposterous, although perhaps not entirely.

ritual has nothing to do with the real process. It is thought that it is simply the substances used for this ghastly ritual, that cause the state of zombification mentioned.

I suggest defining what is meant by 'ritual' since the substances are a necessary part of it. One part may do nothing, while another will. This seems like nit-picking and leaves the reader wondering.

At times I felt like I was reading a satire, meant to confuse; at others it was a serious article to inform. Whichever was the intention, I suggest making it as clear as possible by cutting unneeded words and phrases. Keep it tight and in order.

Spaces between paragraphs would help the reader tremendously.

I'm not quite able to define the main purpose of the write, whether to debunk or to back-up the reality or myth.

I didn't find the answer to a question I've had before, but you may have answered in a round-a-bout way. The person is injected or given a potion while living, then he 'dies'. Is there another rite taken place after digging him up? Or is the process finished?

It's a fine topic, especially with so many stories written of the zombie. A good article would be useful to the genre writers on the site, so I hope you continue to polish and finish this and perhaps write a series of these especially for writers. It's not a 'bad' piece, it's only need is clarity.


Read it aloud, printed on paper. Reading from hard copy allows you to read as a reader and you'll be able to grasp an area of confusion.

I hope this helps to see from another's view.

Enjoy the site!




Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
244
244
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (2.0)
Hello, Tilly

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I hope you're finding your way around the site by now. If you have any questions, don't hesitate to click on the envelope beside the blue case and ask. We're here to help.

As a beginning to a story, this item needs work. Introducing a lot of names doesn't help the readers know who they are, and they'll forget them. I suggest introducing them as they appear in the story with dialog and action.

If this is the first page of the journal, why is the character listing them since she already knows who they are?

It'll come easier as you begin the story.

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum

Good luck with it, and enjoy the site!



"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
245
245
Review of Usefull tip  
Review by esprit
Rated: ASR | (3.0)
Hello, Kerdonkulus

Welcome to Writing.Com!

I see you've been doing your homework. This is a good tip. I've read through many pieces that are so full of adjectives, the plot is missing! *Smile*

You know what you could do to make this more interesting? Make a list of these tips and maybe write a line or two alongside each one to say why you agree with it. Longer pieces aren't any harder than short ones, they just take a bit longer to write. Tips are always needed and useful to those who are serious about wanting to learn.

If you have any questions, don't hesitate to click on the envelope of a blue case and ask. Welcome and enjoy the site!

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
246
246
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hello, Allen James

My goodness, Allen - this is good. The imagery enhances the emotion, and the emotion enhances the message. Wonderful!

I stood and watched the scene as if I was there, and I felt so sad. The reality of it is fantastic.

I noticed no issues with the rhythm, the flow is perfect. I did notice a couple of things though. Consider them, then decide if any changes should be made. No one knows your work like you do.

Squinting hard through the blue-gray haze
where sawdust coats the floor,
his dreaming eyes, too slow to escape,
are snared by her stare, want more.

Did you consider --wanting more--? It seems to fit better to me.


Slender wings soar midst silent storms
in search of the easily lead.

Spelling/Typo of --led--


Her empty arms, her tired soul,
both ache for something real.
They rarely give, mostly take,
beg, borrow, or steal.


All of the verses show vivid images and strong emotion. Excellent!


she remembers back to school.

She takes her leave like they always do,
another loss in the same old game.
You're left all alone to shave in the dark

I wondered about the point of view. Man or Woman? Most of it seems to be shown from her viewpoint because her thoughts are given. But, the reference to shaving alone is from him. This is the only bump I found, but it's pretty big.

I really like the writing; (you are truly talended,) and intend to place this in next weeks Newbie Newsletter if you don't mind.



Well done!



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

247
247
Review by esprit
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hello, Adriana Noir

I liked this and the showing of hurt and anger is real. The ending was a pleasant surprise to this reviewer. Good for you. *Smile*

I don't like to see reviews that only praise the writing as perfect, yet don't have a perfect rate. 4.5's irk me the most. Why is it so hard to push that last .5 point into the little box? 4.5 on a perfect piece is frustrating. I feel it is the most discouraging rate of all, if given with no explanation.

I'm going to include this in next weeks edition of the Newbie Newsletter since it fits the theme. I think it will help encourage and show new members that low rates aren't the end of a piece, they are the beginning and sometimes they are misplaced.

Well said!








** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

248
248
Review of Forever  
Review by esprit
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
Hi, Alex

I found your request for feedback in my mailbox, thank you. *Smile*

Woo! I see your imagination is still going strong. This is a wonderful story idea. The idea of living forever is something thought of by most people, but actually wanted by few. Still, the possibility is captivating to the imagination.

I found some issues to talk about, but as I finished the read I wondered if you really knew what you had here. You, my friend, have the outline of a novel. As the character listed all the things he knew would happen, I thought what an interesting piece that would be. This could go in new creative directions. I hope you consider expanding this into a full-length story.

In the mean-time;

Set out to destroy his brother’s killer.
since then to finding a cure for aids.


This is good. I thought I'd caught a topic out of sequence, then got the relevance.


John’s brother

A name would be better since you've already said these words. Readers will know who it is. This sounds awkward where the first use was natural.


white blood cells

This phrase is repeated too often, too close. I became annoyed at reading it. Perhaps using it only twice, and shortening the others to 'cells' would still be clear, you think?


not only did it divide more rapidly than normal cells, it also didn’t try attack its daughter cells

Cut this extra word. It's passive and isn't needed. These cells apparently didn't have to 'try' to do anything, they were always successful. 'try' hints at the possiblility of failure.


But when he tested the serum on rats

An extra word that could be cut easily. Read it aloud without it and decide if you really need it.


Cuts he intentionally made into my own arms healed before his eyes, it was like magic.

This made me look around to see who else was in the lab. A typo, or is the narrator another character?


At first he had ran to the phone ready to call

Awkward. --he ran-- or --had run-- --he ran--is better. Try not to use 'had'.


miraculous discovery. Felt obliged to share his knowledge

This is an incomplete sentence and doesn't flow well. Finish it by adding -----He--to the beginning.


Would it be best to release the elixir upon the world? If everyone could live forever, no one would ever have to die.

This line gave me a 'duh' moment. It's an obvious statement. I suggest rewriting to something sharper and more creative.

As the story is now, it feels like much has been left out, it's incomplete. The fact he killed himself is really an easy out for authors, kind of cheating the readers of a real ending.
*Smile*

I am serious about using it as the idea outline for a longer piece. Many of the details are already there and only need filling in and personalized. What a world that would be. The definition of a real Utopia.

Well done!






** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **



249
249
Review by esprit
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello, Asherman

I found your request for serious feedback on "Please Review

I was impressed with this piece. The theme is interesting and realistic, I enjoyed the read. I like the small bits of horror told in narration style; just enough to hook the reader. Well done!

I have a couple of suggestions for you to think about.


hand any first hand knowledge of the Wittlesy lynching.

--Only a typo--


had been
had only been


This phrase is used five times and became noticeable enough for me to point out. Try to say it differently each time.


Constable Miller had only been eight years old at the time Amenity Wittlesy was lynched, but he had been Tolliver’s law enforcement since returning from Vietnam.

None of this has anything to do with the story and this is the only mention of Miller. It could be cut easily to tighten.


A rope tied into a noose was found hanging from the limb of a tree in the front yard.

This line is rambling and wordy. If you read the line without the bolded words, I think you'll find it says the same thing, but is much tighter. The redundency and the obvious will be cut.


Inside the ruins arson investigators found a badly burned headless corpse,
but the head was never recovered.

Overtelling. It's obviously 'badly burned' since the house burned for over twelve hours. I wondered how it was possible to burn that long? I suggest cutting these words.

I also suggest making a separate sentence for the head. The word --but--doesn't fit smoothly because nothing is said about a search for the head. Cutting --but-- and using a period would fix it.


All the evidence had been consumed in the burning the house.

I wondered about the competence of the investigators. What other evidence could there be inside? It took place outside.

Try reading this line without the bolded, substituting --fire--. You would avoid redundence and wordiness at the same time.


The fifth was an old man named Nate Richardson,

It's obvious any witness will be old, so this description is overtelling.


I though, with dollar signs dancing in my head, might even be a separate book in this one.

A typo of --thought--


Mr. Gates seemed suddenly interested in the porch ceiling. As I got into my rental car, Mr. Gates leaned down into the open window.

This causes a bump in the flow of the scene. I didn't know if Mr. Gates was looking from a porch window or what. I didn't see him follow the character to the car.


The White folks
the Black community


I don't think you need the capitals.


JW: The towns’ people blamed Amenity Wittlesy for their misfortunes? Why was that?

How did he know this? Nate didn't say anything about it.


It was a dark room with no windows smelling of savory herbs and exotic spices.

You'll need to check the punctuation throughout. This doesn't say what is intended. How was the room lit? I suspect a lantern is used, but I wondered how he could possibly see what was on a high shelf even with a lantern. They only light a small area, the rest of the room will still be dark. Was there no natural light at all?


She wouldn’t name any names, but here is essence of her story.

A word is missing.


Someone untied the rope, and when she hit the

A rope tied into a noose was found hanging from the limb

The first line is found near the end and it seems inconsistent as it is written. The rope was still tied to the tree when the police arrived. Did they only loosen the noose? How were they able to do that without removing it completely?


What a scene that was! A cursing head - great imagery!

I ain’t afraid of no curse, but some of them should have been.”

I'm very disappointed that he didn't see the value of this witness and want to talk to her again. This line by itself shows she is a gold mine for a writer, especially when he'd already thought of a separate book. How could he let this go?
*Smile*

very few women had been lynched in 20th century
That made it important to include at least one chapter
where a woman was the victim.
this story just didn’t fit into the book.


This left me with a question. Did he include a chapter of another woman? I agree at least one should have been there. I wonder if he should mention having another to use? It would tie it up more tightly.


the town has managed to turn things around. It didn’t look as if I would find many left alive who hand any first hand knowledge of the Wittlesy lynching.

These lines need better sequence structure. The first line has nothing to do with the second. He knew the chances of finding witnesses was slight because of the number of years having passed. Rewording or moving the second to a more relevant area is suggested.


The main character and Marie are seen and heard well. I am able to see inside and get an idea of their personalities. I like both of them.

I believe with tightening this will be very good. After letting it sit for a day or two, read through on a hard copy, print it out. You will more easily see any areas that need tightning and clarifying. You're coming along very well already. You've a good imagination. *Smile*

Well done!



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


250
250
Review of My Nasty Habit  
Review by esprit
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hello, Martin Edward Johnson

Welcome to Writing.Com!

You've shown a good deal of imagination in this write. It's enjoyable to read and the message is clear. The rhyme is excellent. The rhythm is off in a few places. I like the long lines, they have a good beat.

I saw a commercial about a turtle and a rabbit.

I don't watch telvision but I suppose this regards the drug spoken of? It sounds off topic.


Second hand smoke was a danger to this land.

This was a bit distracting because I was reading of first-hand smoking all the way through. I see the relevance, but it doesn't quite fit in. It sounds like an afterthought, sort of like he quit for the good of others.


Seems the all actors had gone through this before.

Are these words switched or should one (--all--)be removed?


You've done a good job. You might consider sending to health magazines once it's shined and polished.

Be sure and take advantage of the many review forums for lots of feedback.
"Find a Review Forum




"Invalid Entry
"Invalid Item"   by A Guest Visitor


esprit

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
1,522 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 61 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/storytime/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/10