*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sothach
Review Requests: OFF
5 Public Reviews Given
5 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
1
1
Review by R.O. Phillips
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
This chapter brings alive past times in an evocative way, painting a picture of a world that has disappeared.
Elsie grapples with personal grief amid the backdrop of wartime challenges. The emotional turmoil she experiences is palpable, and the author conveys her inner struggles. The narrative takes an unexpected turn when Elsie encounters a railway fireman, Bobby, who brings a spark of hope and excitement into her life. Their brief interaction adds a touch of romance to the story, offering a glimmer of happiness in the midst of difficult times. The chapter concludes with a mix of emotions as Elsie faces the news of the war's end and receives an unexpected weekend pass. The story captures the complexities of wartime life, personal relationships, and the impact of historical events on individuals.

It might help to introduce subtle hints or elements of mystery that will keep the reader curious about what's to come. This could involve Elsie's family, Bobby's background, or the impact of the war's end will on their lives.
2
2
Review by R.O. Phillips
Rated: E | (4.0)

A nostalgic reflection on the wild days of youth. We are taken back to the vibrant atmosphere of rock gigs in a Soviet cinema turned nightclub.
The vivid descriptions of the unconventional crowd, complete with demonic nicknames, metal, leather, and towering platform boots, paints a picture of a subculture united in a quest for uniqueness.
Amidst the camaraderie, the menacing presence of tracksuit-clad "ghouls" is introduced. These, in their pursuit of conformity, become the antagonists in this drama. The author captures the chaos and exhilaration of youth, where moshing and music are juxtaposed with the real-world threats lurking outside the club.
The piece reflects on the passage of time and the evolution of perspectives, acknowledging that what once seemed like harsh confrontations were, in essence, childish quarrels that many eventually outgrow. Ultimately, it serves as a poignant reminder of the transient nature of youth and the choices one makes on the path to maturity.




3
3
Review of First Snow  
Review by R.O. Phillips
Rated: E | (4.0)
This story paints a vivid picture of the winter scene. The narrative lensing, seeing the world through the young fox’s eyes, is effective. The reader is forced to see snow for the first time, from the viewpoint of a kit.
4
4
Review of The Attack  
Review by R.O. Phillips
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Wow. Great action to kick things off. The series of questions that follows forces the reader to write their own story, to fill in the blanks. What happened? Powerful.
5
5
Review of Amy  
Review by R.O. Phillips
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is an emotionally-charged story, of love, hope and the magic of Christmas. The reader is left wanting to know more about Amy’s life, her past, and how she adapts to her new situation.
The rich descriptions create a poignant atmosphere. Amy's festive attire. The busy mall, with its lights and decorations. The contrast between the happy, laughing children enjoying themselves and Amy's silent mood is striking.
The story effectively explores themes of acceptance, belonging, and the unspoken bonds within family. The mother's internal fear, that Amy might wish for something beyond her reach, adds a relatable and emotional element to the narrative. There is a subtext there that what she really fears is that the child will reject her.
Palpable tension builds as Amy approaches Santa. The way she regards everything in silence. This is nicely resolved when Amy returns to her step mother, grabbing her hand.
The final line gives the reader a sense that things will indeed improve for the child. That her life with her new family could be a joyful one.
From a story telling perspective, it might be better to defer some of the description in the first paragraph, instead sprinkling them in as the story progresses. For example, “her abundant curly red hair” is well described later with “smell of shampoo was strong in her curly auburn hair”.
This would allow the story to start later with something like: 'She clutched “Aggie’ tightly in her right arm'. Starting with action and leaving questions in the readers mind (who is Aggie, why is she clutched tightly?) is a good way to hook a reader from the very start.
5 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 1 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/sothach