*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/topazknight/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
361 Public Reviews Given
391 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 5 ... Next
51
51
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (3.0)
Impressions: Suspenseful and entertaining. A fresh type of tale.

Plot: A recurrent dream which bleeds into the dreamer's waking life. The end is quite a surprise.

Character development:
Angela: The main character of the tale develops strangely but appropriately. This aspect is the story's biggest strength.

Imagery: Very good. The images of the panther and the forest are especially strong. You have painted scenes in your story well.

Grammar/mechanics: This is your downfall.
*The nature still (showing) all -> shows
*An anonymous voice (whispering) -> whispers
*the voice is (becoming) clearer -> becomes
*Suddenly there’s (this) strange smell -> replace with 'a'
*Sweat (running) down all over -> runs
*panther, about 13 (foot) away -> feet
*She nods (at her) reply. replace w/ 'in'
*Hitting the highway, leaving the city far behind.
fragment. Reword as 'She hit the highway, ...'
*There’s a small town visible in the distance(,) she moves towards it. -> use a semicolon
*some evening-post newspaper(s) in front of some houses.
*A small path (leads) to the east. -> needs a verb
*Angela moves towards to what is left
*An axe (lying) on the floor. -> Fragment. replace w/ 'lay' to correct.

A good story. Without these Grammatical errors the story would earn a 4.5! I really enjoyed it as a story.
Write On!
52
52
Review of Garden of Tears  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.0)
Impression: Good words and phrases, emotional and strong.

Theme: I'm not sure what the metphore you're driving at is. Is the meaning behind the words love affairs?

Imagery: Outstanding! Great description of the dying days of a flower as well as that of new growth.

Flow: Very good. The words blend easily from one line to the next. The lines aren't overlong or too short.

Suggestion:
New life springs anew -> This line strikes me a little wrong. Using two forms of the same word so close to each other sounds a little off.

A good poem. I enjoyed reading it. Write on!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
53
53
Review of Beauty Deep  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.5)
Impressions: This work comes across with a lecturing tone. There's nothing wrong with that, but it's different.

Theme: The differences between infatuation and real love.

Imagery: Not many images are used, but the poem still accomplishes its purpose without them.

Rhyme/rhythm: A good ABCB rhyme scheme is worked throughout. The rhythm of each stanza is very good and does not cause stumbling or confusion in the read.

Meter: You may or may not have intended to use one. The poem naturally comes so close to baladic meter (alternation between 8 and 6 syllable lines) that when it deviates from this I can't help but feel distracted by it. Look closer at this idea.

This is a very enjoyable poem which shows further promise. Write On!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
54
54
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Impressions: Highly emotional and murderous!

Theme: A woman poisons her abusive husband.

Imagery: Very good. It is the dominant element used.

Rhyme/Flow: Good couplet rhyming scheme which continues throughout the work. There doesn't appear to be a true meter, but none of the lines appear too wordy or too short. The story itself moves seemlessly.

This poem was written to depict a murder to escape spousal abuse, but the abuse is mentioned too late and too briefly. It almost appears to be an afterthought.
I suggest you mention it sooner to create a reason for what happens next.

Not a bad piece. Well written! Write On!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
55
55
Review of In Paradisum  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.5)
Impressions: Very interesting and entertaining.

Theme: A historical account of a lonely world as told by a resident.

Plot: Recounting of the major events of 'here' and a possible sudden introduction to something called reading and writing.

Imagery: This area is good but could be better. A more full description of the lights might make naming them unnecessary. Also, describe the boy's arrival better. Was there a streak seen in the sky? Was there a loud noise? His sudden appearance is rather abrupt as is.

Flow: The story moves along very well. It doesn't get bogged down or slow.

I enjoyed reading this. You tell a good tale. Write On!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
56
56
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Impressions: Slightly gross, mildly amusing, and amazingly true to life.

Theme: Explanation of a personal dislike of Wal-Mart.

Plot: A desciption of self which, in part, explains the theme.

Imagery: Very good. The description of the bathroom (where the brunt of the story takes place) is perfect. I especially enjoyed the acustical paralell.

Spelling/Grammar:
*nair-do-well -> ne'er-do-well
*an RV
*preferable something monosyllabic -> 'preferably'
*hast -> haste

I lauged at this. The humor, though slightly gross, was not overbearinly so. Well written! Write on!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
57
57
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Impressions: An incredibly funny tale of morals!

Theme: The consequnses of doing ill to others.

Setting: A tavern, in a small Irish town which has a regular annoying patron.

Plot: When drink loosens a man's grip on reason, how far will he go and what will happen to him after?

Characters:
Rusty: A town bully who takes advantage of others as often as he can.

Miche: A simple barkeep who has become frustrated with Rusty.

The Leprechaun: The most well developed of the three. This character becomes a teacher.

I loved the inclusion of the Old Celtic language makes this story very rich and enjoyable. It is, I think, the story's best feature.

I have no suggestions to offer. As the rating states, this is perfect!

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
58
58
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (5.0)
I enjoyed taking the test to find out how to answer the poll. It was rather enlightening. I would never have thought of connecting an outside quiz to the poll itself. It really made me think about who I am. I was partcularly surprised to find that out of 310 votes, there are only four of me!
59
59
Review of Secret Love  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.0)
Impressions: a feeling of detachedness. I've been there and know it.

Theme: Feeling longing for a woman and being unable to express oneself.

Imagery: Most of these are emoitional, fitting the work. They work well to create the mood for the work. The image of the walking angel is somewhat cliche, but not poorly used.

Flow/Rhythm: Most af the work moves along well. It is only at the end that the work starts to lose its impact. The longer lines seem to drag on. The last two lines seem to contradict by wording. Use a final line that confifms instead of denies.

I enjoyed this poem! It reminded me of High school! Write on!
60
60
Review of Cat and I  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.5)
Impressions: Laugh out loud funny. I needed the humor.

Theme: What a cat might say if it could. In truth, I'm highly inclined to agree.

Rhyme/Rhythm: Good couplet rhyming pattern. While I know poems need not rhyme, I enjoy those that do. There is no meter, but a good rhyme aids in flow.

Imagery: Well created if unrealistic. The unrealism is the point though, no deductions here.

Spelling/grammar: just a couple common errors to correct.
while were talking about > add an apostrophe to we're.

‘No your not, your just > use you're instead of your in both cases.

minor point:
‘I have lost the plot and gone insane’
I'm not sure what this line means, especially about 'lost the plot'

I loved the poem! I've had many cats through my life and know they are not so innocent as they look. Write on!
61
61
Review of Understand  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (3.5)
Impressions: slightly meandering, but a definite plea

Theme: A cry for understanding from another

Flow: The piece moves along well in thought flow, but it seem to get hung up at the end of most stanzas. The subject matter is a parent's nightmare, but fairly well handled.

I see promise in this work and believe it could go a lot further. Write on!
62
62
Review by Topazknight
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Impressions: Peaceful and calming, almost religious

Theme: A retreat from the madness of 'civilization' to preserve sanity.

Imagery: A beautiful mix of visual, auditory, tactile, and olfactory images make this a very powerful piece.

Flow: The motion of this piece is smoothe. It moves on regularly. The sunset chorus is very impressive.

Suggestion: Close the work with the chorus. It would give it a better finality.

Great piece! Write On!
63
63
Review of Invisible Tears  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Impressions:Strong and searching, somewhat intraspective

Theme: A search to fulfill personal needs which are not obvious even to oneself.

Rhyme/Rhythm: Has a well established ABCA rhyme scheme. The rhythm seems a little choppy, but the point of the work comes through loud and clear.

Imagery: The image of invisible tears is strong and enigmatic. I'll never know for sure what it means.

Good Work! Write on!
64
64
Review of My Turn  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Impressions: Whimsical yet spiteful. A strange but successful mix.

Theme: Forgetting the past and moving on with life. Also a scathing criticism of a father.

Rhyme/Rhythm: AAB rhyme scheme in tercets well kept. Thoughts flow through each stanza.

Imagery: The brief image of a sunrise makes very definitely past from present. Well placed.

I enjoyed the tone of this. Write on!
65
65
Review of Promise  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Impressions: Powerful and poignant.

Theme: Promises broken and dreams shattered.

Rhyme/Rhythm: AABB rhyme scheme is well constructed and constant. There isn't a definite meter, but the lines grow longer and shorter with perfect regularity.

Suggestion: reword final line as 'lost promises have'

I enjoyed this work. I think I've enjoyed it more than the others I've read. Write on!
66
66
Review of Take Me There  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Impressions:Strong sense of longing here.

Theme: Feelings that only lovers share which are unique to each relationship.

Imagery: By far this work's greatest strength. The continuing image of a journey is very strong here. There are lesser images which are also strong, but do not eclipse the core of the piece. Since all journies end, the final image of arrival is appropriate.

Rhyme/Rhythm: The ABBC rhyme scheme is constant and well written. Paring down some of the longer lines might improve the flow of this work.

I enjoyed this piece. A good piece of poetry. Write On!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
67
67
Review of You Complete Me  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (3.5)
Impressions: A little meandering.

Theme: The appreciation one feels in a loving realionship.

Imagery: There are a few, but not well defined. The work is meant to be (and is) emotional in nature.

Flow: Rough and choppy to me. Your meaning is there and I can almost feel it, but it comes up shorter than the other works I've seen in your port.

Thanks for sharing and considering my thoughts. Write on!
68
68
Review of Heart Broken  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Impressions: Strong and as painful as the subject matter.

Theme: The loss and pain of a breakup and being left alone. We who've been left know it well.

Rhyme/Rhythm: I like the irregular ABAA rhyme scheme. The words tells a story that is definite. It's obvious this work was written while healing.

I feel your pain, that's what makes this work so good.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
69
69
Review of My Online Friend  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.5)
Impressions: Cheerful and upbeat, but bittersweet.

Theme: A representation of an online friendship. Many members of WDC are well acquainted with the feeling.

Rhyme/Rhythm: An AAB rhyme scheme in tercet is unique. The flow is good and the words straightforward.

Imagery: Most are images of things which cannot be. That is the 'bitter' aspect of this work.

An excellent piece! Write on!
70
70
Review of Member of One  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Impressions: Dreary and slightly depressing, but that's the point.

Theme: The loss of friends, always painful, and the realizition that self-reliance is necessary.

Imagery: Images are few, but strong. The representation of time is especially powerful

Flow: Thought flow from line to line is very good. The lines tend to grow wordier toward the end.

Suggestion:
Sanza 3 line 4: reword as 'like apples from a branch'

A well written work on the whole. Write on!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
71
71
Review of Cowgirl boots  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Impressions: Definitely naughty and sometimes funny.

Theme: Sexual romps and a lack of self-control?

Imagery: The descriptions of the three women are very vivid. The bedrooms ae the same to exact detail, but it doesn't matter.

Rhyme/Meter: Good rhymes keep the poem moving along. Some of the lines are a little choppy. I am not certain if meter was intended.

Suggestions: When you use the word know, keep verb tense constant. My suggestion is past tense throughout. The rest of the work is.
72
72
Review of Revolving Doors  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.0)
Impressions: Strong emotions. The end has a definite finality and a good deal of judgement.

Theme: A woman's final angy goodbye to a lover who has mistreated her.

Imagery: Brief but strong. They act like stepping stones rather than painting rich tableau. The strongest of course is the revolving door vs the one which is closed and locked.

Flow: Good. The final stanza is slightly choppy, but otherwise it keeps good cadence.

I enjoyed this work! Keep writing!
73
73
Review of Untitled  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.0)
Impressinos: Quite engaging, the read made me think of myself.

Theme: How time molds a child into an adult and how experience changes that adult into a wisened person.

Flow: good. The shorter lines serve to draw the reader to a specific point. They are crafted well into the work.

Improvements:
Line 3 change to 'perfectly ordinary' it will sound better.

A very good work! Write on!
74
74
Review of Oracles  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (3.0)
Impressions: I may be missing something, but the work does not seem to make the point your description suggests. It also seems too reminiscent of the classic poem 'The Road Not Taken.'

Theme: Choices we make in life along with the question: Do we really make choices?

Flow: somewhat choppy. If your lines were closer to the same length the work might have earned a higher rating. This has nothing at all to do with rhyme.

Suggestions: Use question marks where your work poses questions. Keep working!
75
75
Review of All I Want  
Review by Topazknight
Rated: E | (4.0)
Impressions: Powerful and strong.

Theme: a search for the right life partner. A longing to be with that person always.

Imagery: Thought he images are brief and fleeting, they add strength to the theme.

Flow: Good. The thought presented are usually quick and concise. This keeps the work engaging.

I enjoyed this poem. A good read.
Write On!
105 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 5 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/topazknight/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3