*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/liseli/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/8
Review Requests: OFF
952 Public Reviews Given
1,570 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 4 5 6 7 -8- 9 10 11 12 ... Next
176
176
Review of Celestials  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hey there!

Thank you for requesting a review from
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1307093 by Not Available.
.



Lovely poem. I love the parallelism within the piece itself. The imagery is beautiful also.

The stanzas were nice and neat the organization complements the words themselves. I couldn't find any typos of any sort - you've looked over this more than once, which is always encouraging to know. *Smile*

I had a question, though.

Why is 'Driving' the only word without a comma after it? Personally, I didn't like any of the commas after the one word phrases, but I think you should be consistent.

Hope this helps!


Thank you for your consideration, and please stop by our forum again!


--Emerin

** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
177
177
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello!

Humming Bird has gifted you six reviews from "Summer Review Forum as your prize from "Invalid Item.

This poem is very cute. *Smile* I like it. It reminds me a bit of Walt Whitman's "Song of Myself" albeit his is free verse, of course.

The language you employ complements the word itself and I think the rhyme scheme you chose is also nice.

I do, however, have a few suggestions for improvement.

You use more archaic language throughout the piece but not consistently. I would either stick to one or the other. For instance, every time you say 'you', I think you should substitute in 'thou' instead of being inconsistent.

'Markith' should be 'Marketh'. *Smile*

Hope this helps!



Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin




** Image ID #1323816 Unavailable **
178
178
Review of alone  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Humming Bird has gifted you six reviews from "Summer Review Forum as your prize from "Invalid Item.

What an interesting and simple poem! I like it and I like the way you play with the visual space in this piece to really accent your meaning. *Thumbsup*

A couple suggestions that you might want to take in mind:

I'm not sure if all those commas are really necessary. There's already a caesura there because of the line break and the comma looks clunky in a poem so sparse.

The last two lines were especially poignant. *Smile*

Hope this helped!




Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin




** Image ID #1323816 Unavailable **
179
179
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hello!

Humming Bird has gifted you six reviews from "Summer Review Forum as your prize from "Invalid Item.

I can definitely tell why this piece won! *Smile* The emotion is fantastic and I love the flashbacks.

Of course, I do have a few suggestions for improvement...

Again, line break! It'll really help readers, I promise. Just having that space between paragraphs makes the piece so much more accessible.

A couple grammatical notes...

“Cancer, are you sure?” [,]he asked the oncologist desperately.

No comma necessary here!

“How long…to live.

If not a period, you need some form of punctuation where I put the period.

“Okay, maybe thinking wasn’t so good.

Same note. Careful with this dialogue punctuation! I know it's tricky, but with a little more carefulness it'll give your writing a more professional feeling.

Hope this helps!

Hope this helps!




Thank you for your consideration, and happy writing!

--Emerin




** Image ID #1323816 Unavailable **
180
180
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hi there!



Another fantastic piece! The use of writing mL complements the prose itself, and the narrative is strong and is full of your personal voice. *Smile* The figurative language adds to the story without overwhelming it. Overall I enjoyed reading this piece immensely.

Just one note for improvement:

My search had come to a halt for weeks;[,] however, there was a woman that had a search of her own going on and it lead her to me.

I believe a semicolon is more appropriate here.

Hope this helps!




All the best,

Emerin

** Image ID #1311761 Unavailable **
181
181
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi there!



A wonderful tribute and a wonderful piece about 9-11 that exalts and appreciates those that have given their lives while still expressing your own opinions. Very tactfully and beautifully done. I enjoyed reading this piece immensely. *Smile*





All the best,

Emerin

** Image ID #1311761 Unavailable **
182
182
Review of The Magic Cat  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Thank you for entering
The Unofficial Fantasy Contest (CLOSED)  [ASR]
Contest is currently closed.
by The Messenger
.



Adorable, absolutely wonderful tale! I sincerely enjoyed this piece! *Smile* It's very cute, and you did a great job telling the story. I love the description and the way you bring the cat to life. *Thumbsup*

I only have one nitpicking:

Black fur rimmed her eyes like kohl, and above those great green eyes which sat above a pink nose.

I just thought it flowed better this way...But it's entirely up to you, of course!

I hope this helps! Thank you for sharing this piece!

Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin



** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **
183
183
Review of Unearthed  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hello!

Thank you for entering
The Unofficial Fantasy Contest (CLOSED)  [ASR]
Contest is currently closed.
by The Messenger
.



This is an interesting piece, and one that I enjoyed. I like the idea behind it and think that you have a good, strong narrative voice throughout.

Blake is developed well as the main character, and I liked Tevon, too. *Smile*

I do, however, have a few suggestions for improvement, and they have to do mostly with tense shifts and other grammatical errors that really did hinder this piece. Consider the following sentences:

He was a seasoned veteran and very skilled with the spear, even if he has though he had never earned a promotion.

Watch that tense. This sentence starts with past tense; I would keep it in past tense.

Blake felt the energy within the earth aspect and decided to see what his new found weopon weapon is was capable of.

Since the beginning on this sentence was in past tense, I would keep it so.


I also found a few more miscellaneous grammatical errors.

The excitement was almost overwhelming. After a full days journey they were finally closing in on their destination.

Run on. I would change it as so.

Legends stated that giants live in these woods, but every intelligent being with some since sense about them knew they were nothing more than just that, legends.

Just be careful.

This trip use used to be undertaken alone as it is a personal matter, but the dwarves’ border was simply to too close.

Again, just a matter of proofreading.

Hope this helps!


Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin



** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **
184
184
Review of Fun with Friends  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello!

Here's your first review in your mini-port raid. *Smile*

What an entertaining piece! I enjoyed reading it. I especially liked the dialogue between the friends; it felt very real and college-esque.

The main problem I found with this piece was with the dialogue punctuation/grammar. Here are a couple suggestions for improvement.

I shouted from the third floor balcony of my apartment, "Hey you putz, is that how you're dressing tonight?"

You'll need a little more punctuation there.

"I'll buy you a beer if you go up and tell her that,[.]" I said jokingly to goad him.

Comma instead of period is better here.

"Really? Well then, I think I must actually tell her this,[.]" he said as he left his stool and started walking towards her.

Same comment.


Hope this helps!







Thank you for your consideration!

--Emerin



** Image ID #1307066 Unavailable **
185
185
Review of Kid Politics  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello!

Humming Bird has gifted you five reviews from "Summer Review Forum as your prize from "Invalid Item.


What a hilarious piece! *Laugh* I enjoyed reading this. I don't blame ya for getting all defensive about your kids...parents tend to do that! *Smile*

The grammar was very, very good in this piece, and there isn't really much for me to suggest for improvements. But here I go to nitpick:

Please paragraph space. This is the biggie, I think. It'll help readers a lot if you space this piece.

I felt that parentheses were a bit overused, especially in the beginning. Five long parentheses phrases in the first half sort of overdoes it. I would cut those down to maybe two.

I also felt the dashes were used too much, too. This is mainly directed toward the third paragraph.

Ack! That's my only nitpickings. This is a really great piece. The narrative is strong and clear and you've chosen a subject matter many can relate to. Great job! *Thumbsup*






Thank you for your consideration, and happy writing!

--Emerin


** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **




My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
186
186
Review of Playing With Fire  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

What a sad, sad, poem, but still a wonderful tribute to those poor workers. It's great that you're writing about something that really happened, getting the word out. The dedication is touching and the poem itself quite good, too. *Wink*


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Eek. This was hard. *Laugh* I would take the comma out after 'tank collapsing under'. I think it's inappropriate there.

*Balloon1* Final Notes:

Great poem. Best of luck in the contest!




All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
187
187
Review of Towards the Light  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

A lovely poem and a pleasurable read, Sue. I sincerely enjoyed this piece. The presentation was nice and neat, and I like the use of writing mL and think it was a good choice. The stanzas make it easy to read and complement the words themselves. The rhythm was great, and though I spotted a few imperfect rhymes, overall you did a great job with them, too. I like the message behind this piece and think you did a great job with it!


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Ooh...this was hard...

First stanza, second line: I would take out 'out'. *Laugh* I think it throws the piece off a bit.

That's my entire nitpicking! *Blush*

*Balloon1* Final Notes:

Great poem. I enjoyed it immensely.






All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
188
188
Review of The Night Sky  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

The imagery was abundant and just absolutely beautiful in this piece. I love the descriptive phrases! The rhyme scheme and rhythm was also good, and I enjoyed reading through this poem. It's very reflective and has a soothing tone. Great job! The image at the end is great, too, by the way. *Wink*

*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

I would change 'hope and sadness' to 'hope, sadness'.

I think the punctuation is weird in the latter half of the second stanza. I wouldn't have a period on the third to last line in that stanza.

'silver threaded clouds' should be 'silver-threaded clouds' or 'silver, threaded clouds' depending on what you meant.

'those flying dreams' throws off the rhythm. I would make it just 'flying dreams.'

*Balloon1* Final Notes:

A great poem. With a little tweaking, I think it will be even better! Best of luck in the contest!





All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
189
189
Review of Path Not Taken  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

This is a lovely poem with a good rhyme scheme and short phrases that do create a 'drop by drop' feel. *Smile* The imagery was good and I like the presentation - neat and centered, with clear stanzas. There were no blatant spelling or grammatical errors, and I can tell you put some thought and time into this piece! Thank you! I sincerely enjoyed the images you used and think you have a great poem here.

*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Ack! That's hard. *Cry* In the first stanza, spills//will is not a perfect rhyme. But it's just a nitpicky thing, really.

*Balloon1* Final Notes:

Wonderful poem. Thanks for the read!





All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
190
190
Review of Don't Blame Me  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

*Laugh* This piece is hilarious! The rhyme scheme is great, the rhythm is great, the subject matter is great. I sincerely enjoyed reading this and laughed out loud several times. I think this is a poem we could all relate to, and for once the grammatical errors actually work. *Smile* I love the use of the word 'me'.


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Because I don't know whether the errors were purposeful or not, I thought I'd mention them anyway.

I won't let me['] self fail I don't think the apostrophe is appropriate here. I get the effect you're going for; I just don't think it works. I would take it out.

There's views, and ports, and graphs here I'm not so sure if you meant to do it or not.


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

Overall a fantastic poem. I really enjoyed it. Thank you!





All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
191
191
Review of I MISS YOU MOM  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

This is a lovely tribute to your mother and to all those who suffer from the loss of a loved one. I love the format you've taken to convey your message; the couplets are nice and the rhyme scheme is almost perfect. You have great word choice and a poignant emotion behind the words themselves. I couldn't find any typos or blatant errors, proof that you've looked at this more than once. Great! *Thumbsup*


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

First line: I would add a comma after 'Mom'. I also think the first two stanzas might look nice italicized.


The last two lines don't rhyme perfectly. I would just change it to 'Heaven's shore' so it has a better feel.


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

This is a great poem. I hope this review helps! Best of luck in the contest!





All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
192
192
Review of Song of the Day  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

Wow! This poem is fantastic. The rhyme scheme was great, the stanzas were good, the layout was neat and organized. There were no typos or grammatical or spelling errors, and you definitely put some thought into this! I thoroughly enjoyed this piece.

*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Eek. This is really hard. *Laugh*

For me, the last stanza just didn't feel as 'polished' as the others. I might take out the word 'while'; this way, the two parts of the stanza are grammatically correct as sentences. I think that might flow better.


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

A really awesome poem. I enjoyed reading this! Best of luck in the contest!




All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
193
193
Review of Elizabeth  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: ASR | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

Awww...this was a very sad poem, and just loaded with emotion. The image of the paper crane on the grave is one that I will remember for a while. The presentation is neat and I couldn't find any typos or blatant errors - very good!


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

I kind of wanted that paper crane to mean a bit more. Is there any reason why it's a paper crane? Was that an inside joke? a hobby? Just wondering.

Consider not capitalizing the first letter of every line, and instead capitalizing as one would naturally in prose.


*Balloon1* Final Notes:


This is a great poem. I enjoyed reading it! Best of luck in the contest.



All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
194
194
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Humming Bird has gifted you five reviews from "Summer Review Forum as your prize from "Invalid Item.



*Star* What I Liked:

I enjoyed this poem. I like the use of onomatopoeia, and the unique descriptive phrases throughout. The figurative language wasn't stale, and contributed to the piece instead of just 'being there' like figurative language often does. I like the repetition, and think that it sets a nice back-rhythm to the pulse of this poem.

The presentation of this piece is nice and neat, and again, writing mL is used well and without overdoing it.

*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Consider italicizing the repetition of 'thud, thud, thud'.

After the word 'change', I think a semicolon might be more appropriate.


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

Another fantastic poem. Hope my review helps!





Thank you for your consideration, and happy writing!

--Emerin


** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
195
195
Review of What I Want Most  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hello!

Humming Bird has gifted you five reviews from "Summer Review Forum as your prize from "Invalid Item.



*Star* What I Liked:

This is a lovely poem, with a beautiful rhyme scheme and rhythm. You've done a great job pouring out your emotions in a way that others can relate to and understand. The presentation of this poem is neat; writing mL is used thoughtfully and not overdone. The stanzas are carefully constructed to complement the rhyme scheme.


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

I'm not sure if referring to your child as 'it' is too good of an idea. Even if you're trying to convey the idea that the child could be a boy or girl, I think you should stick to 'him'. *Laugh*


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

Really a wonderful poem. I enjoyed reading this!






Thank you for your consideration, and happy writing!

--Emerin


** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **





My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
196
196
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello!

Thank you for requesting a review at
 Summer Review Forum  (E)
REOPENED FOR SUMMER! Come in for a review from two talented reviewers....
#1213582 by emerin-liseli
.

Your requests are always appreciated because they give us the chance to read works we might not have found on our own.



So I'm back for the final review of a massive request! *Laugh*

I enjoyed this chapter, and I'm glad to see that you've broken up the chapters into shorter increments. I think that'll lead to easier reading. Good choice!

So here we continue with the Clerics of Kant...I saw that you have the sixth chapter posted up, and I couldn't help it! *Blush* I checked to make sure Theminor was alive. Anyway, I'm glad to see the two stories intersect...because I think we can assume the guy the Clerics found is our favorite barbarian!

Notes:

“I just wanted to, uh…” he stammered, “To to thank you for the great lesson you gave us today. I never thought that you would be the one to actually teach us the Song of the Trees."

Should be like that.


I'm not sure if all the recalling works. If really distracts from the main plot and leaves the narrative fragmented. Maybe you should limit yourself to just one memory: either The Forester's planting ceremony of Guelah's past, not both.


Unlike the majority of new acolytes, Guelah had not struggled at accepting Verdigris, which was? [;] unlike even some of the Voices.

Incorrect semicolon use.





Thank you for your consideration, and happy writing!

--Emerin


** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.

Proud Member of "The WDC Angel Army!
197
197
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (3.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

I love poetry with a purpose, and I enjoyed this piece. It's a bit abstract, and took me a couple reads to get 'something' out of it.

Your personal voice shines through the words, and reading this poem made me feel like I was actually hearing from you, perhaps in an intimate conversation setting.


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Consider not capitalizing the first letter of every line, and instead playing around with it. I think that could lead to a few interesting results...

I'm not sure if bolding text within the poem works. I think it's just a bit too blatant. I would stick to just italics.

That's news in blaze

Missing an apostrophe here.

And he chucked chuckled...

I think that's the word you meant.

*Balloon1* Final Notes:

A poem that could benefit from a little more proofreading. You have some great material, here, though. If you ever go back and look over it once more, feel free to let me know. I would be more than happy to change the rating.




All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **



My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
198
198
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.5)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

What a lovely poem! I love the descriptive phrases and the longing that runs throughout this piece. I think you did a very nice job transporting the reader back to the days of classroom waiting, and this was definitely a pleasure to read.

The presentation is neat and error-free - I like how this poem is centered. I couldn't find any grammatical or spelling mistakes - you definitely proofread this over once or twice more! *Laugh*


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

Consider not capitalizing the first letter of every line, just to play with the visual presentation.

I don't understand how one would be looking at the moon if this is during the day in school. I think a rhyme with the word 'noon' might be interesting...*Smile*


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

A great pleasure to read, and a lovely poem! I enjoyed reading this. Best of luck in the contest!




All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **




My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
199
199
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: E | (4.0)


Hi there!

Thanks for entering "Invalid Item!


*Star* What I Liked:

This is a lovely poem with great imagery and a nice rhyme scheme that works quite well. I have to say 'into my earth' is a phrase I've never heard before, but it works nicely in your poem! *Laugh*


*Cut* Suggestions for Improvement:

I felt that there was a bit too much punctuation for my taste. For example, if this piece was prose, there wouldn't be a comma in the first line, so I don't think it's necessary in poems where there is a natural break already. Does that make sense? The same goes for the first line of the second stanza.

I was a bit disappointed that the last stanza didn't follow the rhyme scheme. Could that be fixed? I think that would improve this poem a lot.


*Balloon1* Final Notes:

You have a great poem here that has the potential to become even better with a little bit of tweaking. Thank you for sharing it with me here on WDC, and best of luck with the contest!




All the best,

Emerin



** Image ID #1312370 Unavailable **
200
200
Review of Remediation  
Review by emerin-liseli
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hello!

Thank you for requesting a review at
 Summer Review Forum  (E)
REOPENED FOR SUMMER! Come in for a review from two talented reviewers....
#1213582 by emerin-liseli
.

Your requests are always appreciated because they give us the chance to read works we might not have found on our own.


This is an interesting piece, and kept me entertained the entire time. *Smile* You have a good dose of wry humor (birthing a laptop, ha ha...) that's not so overly sarcastic it overwhelms the piece.

A few suggestions:

With the amount of cursing in this piece, I would make this 18+, just to be on the safe side.

When you change speakers in dialogue, you'll need to put a line of space between the changes.

I wish my laptop were was lighter . . .

Should be 'was'.

I would italicize thoughts in this piece, because it does get a bit confusing at times.


Ok, so the body...[,]”

The body?

“...Has been in there for six months. . . .

I would format it as shown.

“Sir, is that your bag?[,]” she says while pointing to my carry-on.

Question mark instead of comma.


Hope this helps!



Thank you for your consideration, and happy writing!

--Emerin


** Image ID #1289992 Unavailable **

288 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 12 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/liseli/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/8