*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ninotchka2/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/5
Review Requests: OFF
574 Public Reviews Given
694 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Impulsive, honest. Trying to be helpful.
I'm good at...
Spotting 'telling', typos, superfluous adverbs, cliches, verbosity; I'm really good at re-writing, creating examples of how to fix things, especially how to get deeper into the character and how to provide a fuller sensory experience
Favorite Genres
Flash fiction, slice of life, literary, anime, fantasy, young adult, mystery, horror
Least Favorite Genres
Spiritual, Romance
Favorite Item Types
Statics
Least Favorite Item Types
Interactive Items. Images.
I will not review...
Pornography, anything involving cruelty to animals. Items of people who do not return reviews.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 3 4 -5- ... Next
101
101
Review of The Stage  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi,

I think I have not reviewed you before.

I wish many people will have a look at this short item. For the first time ever (I think) I am stumped for the rating. I’ll err on the positive side and give a 5 for sheer gutsy inventiveness and the intense poetic ‘feel’. (If it’s joke you accidentally are on to something good here.)

The psychedelic style (I mean that in a good way) reminds me of what you get with random generators—full marks for mastery of vocabulary and playful juxtaposition.

Only I would caution you not to sacrifice grammatical correctness and clarity of meaning.

Some examples from the first paragraph:

“silent mania” – this does not really convey a picture of the audience, as mania can take many forms; “manic silence” might work better in my view

“with scorched anxiety”—I think it should be “scorching” here –otherwise what’s doing the frizzling?

“I had to meet my delusions of inadequacy half way” –this ‘russian doll’ of meaning is too difficult to disassemble...”delusions of inadequacy” is reverse for “reality of adequacy” or something like that, so we get that the performer has to deliver (at least?) half of what he/she can do? But in that case the strong need expressed by “I had to” [my emphasis] makes little sense, as that should be easy. Do you see?

“Blind it with the glare...” – blind who or what? It is not clear what “it” refers to in your context.

Overall, I read your word experiment with growing astonishment and amusement. It gave me a fresh perspective. Thank you for writing and sharing.

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
102
102
Review by Nok2
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
I saw this item and read it to learn what Guillain-Barre Syndrome really is, I'd heard the name and had a vague idea.

Your writing is superb. You write with such honesty. The observations are so--fresh and clear. I was about to say raw, but that's not quite it, even though the horror you experienced comes through, honest is the closest I can get.

I'd recommend this to anyone to read, and you even got me to laugh out loud at one of the episodes you described.

Excellent stuff, I bet Hemingway would approve.
Keep on writing!

love
Nok
103
103
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Different and Cool FT- Tale 1, Ch 1, by Risan F


Review:

Hi,

First off my usual cautionary words: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line (see specific comments below), and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: Different and Cool FT-Tale 1

Chapter: 1

Author: Risan F

Plot: good fight scene and dramatic appearance (introduction scene 1+2). Good introduction of presumably again the main character, Andrew Champion first in his ‘normal world’ (scene 1) and through his reaction to a presumably new world (scene 2)
Lots of action and surprises, Tarah revealed as having stonishing ancestry, mission and power, and you end on a note of suspense. A questionmark was for me how the introductory 2 scenes relate to the end scene and to Andrew & Tarah’s story, but undoubtedly that will eventually become clear

Style & Voice:

Since I read the story of Andrew, Tarah and Mari, I think your style has evolved, it reads now both mature and more ‘fantasy’. It’s fluent and makes for great reading.

You are certainly aware that the use of adjectives/adverbs is normally frowned upon, as it’s considered ‘telling’. Since they seem to be a characteristic of your style, I’m not going to comment further about it.

Some passive voice—could be easily reworded to strengthen the impact.

Not a criticism-just an observation--Point of View (POV) was unclear to me, we were seeing the characters both from cameratic point of view as well as third person deep POV, adding I suppose up to omniscient narrator? Not sure...

Some typos.

I think overuse of “like”, “that”, “was”/”were”—but don’t take my word for it: I highly recommend to everybody the use of this wizard (part of which is freely available online), check out http://www.autocrit.com/autocrit/editing-wizard-fo...
Formatting-why center the last scene?

Setting: Some outstandingly beautiful description of scenery, both alien and familiar, great job; fabulous diverse creations of the alien plants; the world of Broodring is fantastical and believable

Characterization: Park and the demon are well introduced in Introduction scene 1; in introduction scene 2 I’d suggest to name the “man” as soon as possible. To use the word “sustained” struck me as out of character for Andy, but I could be wrong. Andrew, Tarah and Mr Clark are well characterized and likeable, I particularly liked Cornflower and Chompy

Grammar: no problems that I could see (not my strong point though)

Just My Personal Opinion:

The explosion in Introduction scene 2 and the appearance of the wiry nude man on one knee seemed to be straight out of Terminator, no offense; I suggest to change some of that as the association doesn’t help you in my view..

Overall-great story! Thanks for writing and sharing.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

FINALLY: (A) Specific comments see in line review below

SPECIFIC COMMENTS

In a world parallel to the norm, the sky shone as an aurora of purple and black, like a priceless, yet ominous stone. A small formation of bony, avian creatures soared through? the eternal night, their wings catching the eery eerie colors to create a sparkling, streaking sheen above. The ground was nothing; only a hovering pink haze told where one could safely stand, as footing here was like the most invisible of glass I think “the most..of” implies one of a number whereas “glass” is singular. Rephrase?. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] the few landmarks that humanized this land were not comforting, and only reminded the observer that they were out of this world.

This was Dreamscape, a haven for the beings beyond our consciousness...and the dementia of nightmares.

A distant sparkle could be seen [try and avoid passive voice?] through the aurora, slowly taking its shape as it came into the world's notice. It was another figure, just to the side of the fiendish flock of fowl, larger and moving downwards at a fantastic pace towards the mist-covered non-ground. Though the figure was nowhere close to the other creatures, they cleared out of the way regardless due to the interloper's impressive speed. Its dive was like perhaps better “as”? lightning compared to their own modest skills, and its manner was like the most dangerous of sky hunters.

The figure, now recognizable as human, turned a flip to right itself from the head-first [one word, no hyphen] dive, arranging its legs for the landing. The baggy green jacket and slacks it wore flapped roughly in the gales, and the yellow scarf wrapped around its neck created a dramatic counterpoint with the ethereal skies. This new person landed gracefully in a crouch, its hat miraculously staying in position above spiky red locks that hung over the face. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] as the person stood upright, the hair shifted upwards to reveal the features of a young, not sure about this comma teenage boy, with emerald green eyes and a fierce aura to belie his gentle frame.

Park stood for a brief moment to eye the empty world before him, his face carrying both trepidation and purpose [‘telling’-‘show’ us instead?]. Though his movements were not cold [what’s a “cold” movement?], they were businesslike, comparable to that of a warrior who knew how to handle that dreadful time before actual battle. Already he stood before his destination, a fuchsia pyramid of light not half a mile from where he stood. Not taking time to dawdle, he proceeded in a steady gait towards the structure, preparing to steady himself with a light-footed journey.

As Park took each step, a soft clanking sounded out as dark fanfare for his arrival. He came into the realm armed, after all, with a sheathed sword on his back as well as another on his hip. The armaments [because of the double meaning arms/armed forces perhaps better “weapons”?]did not burden him, as he carried himself as lithely as the naked [I found this distracting as it made me start to think whether it is a correct term for a furry animal-delete?] panther. Indeed, he was now a scant few yards from the pyramid, and able to make out the dark shape frozen within.

His eyes narrowed to see beyond the barrier of light, as he felt the dread of ultimate truth fill his heart. The creature contained in the pyramid could not quite be described as a figure, for it was little more than a violet cloak draped as if over an invisible man. An intangible smoke poured from the bottom of the cloak, and the seemingly-empty hood concealed sinister, glowing eyes that appeared to be slightly closed if the hood conceals they eyes one can’t see that they appear to be slightly closed? Check?. In response to its visitor, they opened up into a sinister stare, and soon its cold, masculine voice could be heard, though it emanating emanated not from the being, not even from within Park's mind, but from Dreamscape itself.

"So, the boy hero returns to seek the High Dream Demon," the wraith said, in a manner that could be described as slightly taunting [stating the obvious]. "Has it been four years, or five?"

"The legend says that you would awaken to the world this month in the year 893 A.S.." Park responded softly, staring impassively at the creature. "It was a bit of a problem getting to Dreamscape, but it looks like I've managed to arrive just in time."

The wraith did not regard [consider?] this reply, instead looking over the boy's apparel. "I see you have found new weapons. They are for the Two Heavens Style, aren't they?" Park let his stoic eyes silently confirm the testimony, and the demon's own eyes narrowed, the pretense in their conversation fleeing fast. "Will you make those two heavens my hell, Park?"

He answered this by reaching both behind him and to his side for the blades. "I'm not going to let you ruin my life again," he said fiercely, and he swiftulled the weapons up to bear. The one in his left hand was a pearl-white wakizashi short sword; this he had in front of him. The other, held behind the first, was an ornate long sword with a bejeweled hilt and a blade that flashed with a self-contained cerulean light. The image of glowing blue angel wings formed from his shoulders, and he was now shouting, his eyes becoming as sharp as his weapons. "Prepare yourself!!"

With the aid of his angel appendages, the youth leapt an impossible ten feet into the air to bear down on his opponent with his dual blades. The wraith was prepared, and phased out of pyramid to prepare for his dive-bombing enemy. In front of the dark being formed a translucent polearm composed of pure magical energy, adorned by a blade as long as its haft. As if held by the wraith's invisible hand, the polearm rapidly spun into position and almost calmly received Park's attack, though the two blades slammed against the one with titanic force.

Park was not deterred by this missed opportunity and sprung back, propelled by his hologram-like wings [not sure-a hologram can’t propel something, and even visually the comparison doesn’t really add something, as a hologram looks like the real thing? Check?]. As he fell into a defensive stance on the slanted side of the pyramid, the wings dissipated by the boy's own volition, leaving only a few glowing feathers behind to break apart like dust particles. His time was short, as the wraith was closing in from above with his polearm. Park responded to this assault by quickly moving back into battle, bringing up his short sword to meet his opponent's blade with a metallic-sounding [obvious, in my view] clash.

Park attempted to take advantage of his two weapons and thrust his long sword towards the cloaked figure, but the wraith simply spun his weapon to deflect the strike. With another deft twirl, the wraith swung the polearm upwards in a half-moon slice that threatened to bisect the boy. Park danced away from the deadly scrape in a stylish maneuver that gave him a shot at the wraith's unprotected side. But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] when he took another swing with his long sword, he found that the wraith was skilled at regaining lost ground, and the attack was blocked with another smooth motion of the polearm.

The battle was well underway by now, and the two combatants quickly added more intensity to their attack routines [I get what you mean I think, but still: the sense of “routine” in the sense of boring/well-known etc. lessens the impact of your fight scene, as though they’re just going through the motions-reconsider?]. The wraith was wielding his polearm in a series of expert swings that forced Park into a pattern of parries, keeping both swords moving to intercept the blows. But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] though he was on the low ground, his two weapons still afforded him an opportunity every now and again, and he made sure to fit in a strike to keep his foe on his non-existent toes. This kept Park from being pushed back too much, and therefore from letting his opponent lead the fight.

With an impassioned cry, the youth soared above a swipe at his shins to deliver a spinning strike with his flashing long sword. The wraith barely managed to inch away from the attack, and was even at a loss for deflecting Park's subsequent short sword swipe. Nevertheless, the wraith blocked the attack with his polearm, and the next attack from the long sword, bringing the three weapons into a deadlock. "You've become quite skilled in the time since our last meeting, Park," the wraith said in a manner mimicking paternal pride.

Park ignored him, and broke the lock to attack with a spinning onslaught of his two swords. The wraith likewise twirled his weapon to turn away the strikes, and somehow managed to keep speaking in his wrathful [deosn’t that mean angry? Isn’t that a contradiction to stating just above he is mimicking paternal pride?]voice. "But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] you're still a weak child, with a weak body and mind," he crooned, jabbing high and low with his polearm. Even as Park evaded these attacks, the anger was building up within his heart, and he swung with both his swords in a wide double-slash. The wraith avoided this by jolting up into the air, where he stayed hovering for the moment, looking down on his opponent as if he were an ant.

"I can sense your need to prove yourself," the wraith said from his position in the skies [seems exaggerated – unless he is several thousand metres up?]. "But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] no matter how far you've come, you're always going to be too weak for anyone. You were meant [passive voice] to be weak, and you know it deep inside yourself. Leave the heroics to the greats."

Park's face contorted into a sour grimace unbecoming for his soft features, and knelt down. "You, shut up!" he roared, his voice echoing across the barren tundra as he bolted skywards [difficult from kneeling position? And why kneel down in the first place?] in a furious strike at his hated enemy. The wraith's eyes flashed, he raised up an "arm", the sleeve of his robe now revealing a heavier concentration of smoke in the shape of a clenched fist. With a small grunt, the wraith unfurled his "fingers," and a wave of darkness poured from his hand at the boy, shooting in-between his dual swords to strike his chest.

"AAAAAHHHHH!!!" Park hollered in agony, feeling like his very soul was being sucked [passive voice] away. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] if it wasn't his soul, it was something in the ballpark, for globs of red energy were pouring from his chest like blood clots. The darkness the wraith continued to emit siphoned up the red globs like a pipeline, and he groaned in pleasure as each one sunk into his "hand." The laughing [you haven’t told us he laughs?] demon's form seems ed to grow more tangible, and he closed his hand to cancel the wave of darkness, letting Park's prone body fall like a ragdoll [2 words] to the ground below.

"Your insecurity is as fruitful as ever," the wraith taunted him from on high. "In this Dreamscape, misery is my lifeblood, and now I have enough to break free of this sleep within sleep." He regarded Park with an invisible smirk[so how do we know about it?], who even now was trying to raise himself upright, holding onto his swords as if they were handrails. "I have much work to do in the world of the waking, so I will take my leave. For even as skilled as you are now, a weak spirit like you has no hope of stopping me."

"You...stop..." Park muttered, coming up into a pained crouch. He then let out a few ragged coughs, and struggled not to fall again on his face.

The wraith paid no mind to the boy's suffering, and brought his polearm long-wise [jargon acc to my spellchecker-reconsider?]. With a stellar-sounding [what do stars sound like?] twirp [is that a word?], the weapon vanished in a sparkle of light, leaving only the cloak to define the demon's appearance. Slowly, and yet faster and father, the wraith rose into the air like a messiah returning to heaven. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] yet, by the pain of the weakened lad, and the wraith's low muttering snickers that still felt like they came from Dreamscape, he would not be delivering people from evil, but unto it.
*****

In a deserted wilderness far from the reach of civilization, something strange and dark was happening. good opening Though the locale was like Death itself, it was not considered to be fantastical, and yet the magics from the otherworld began to gather here. With a crimson sunset already hanging on the horizon like a portrait of whom?, the small grubs and scorpions that lived here became witness to another great show in the form of fushia energy beams gathering into a ball on the apex of a cliff side. The energy ball was building up like a water balloon, pulsating and swelling, ready to burst.

It did perhaps clearer:”It burst”?.

In an explosion of light, the energy spiraled out in red/pink rings like a violent version of the ripple effect created by dropped stones in the a river. The insectoid creatures all dove for cover in the shade of boulders and underbrush,period instead of comma? In truth, the effect was relatively harmless, just a discharge from the rip between worlds. This time, it was that which [perhaps better “what”] the explosion left behind that held malice and evil.

From [do you mean “For” as in antiquated for “because”?] where the conflagration began was now a man, crouched down on one knee. His nude muscles were wiry and strong, his frame tall and imposing. I am seeing Terminator A violet mop of hair hung over his eyes, but didn't disguise the menacing set of his jaw. His lips were twisting into a small smile, like the civilized demon prepared for its [can you perhaps avoid the switch from he to it?] latest debauchery.

"So the plan of madness begins," the man said to himself, his breathing calm and measured. "Right...Tarah?"
-----


In the fall of 893 After Starlight, within the alternate world of Pangaea, a boy named Andrew Champion found something special in the outcast Tarah Reichardt, and in the end accepted her friendship. Now, he'll have a chance to find out just how special his new friend really is. A magical world of danger and heroics awaits him as he skydives through the rabbit hole. For the valiant can never rest, even as this journey twists and turns from Hell to Heaven.

These are the Different and Cool Fantastic Tales.
Different and Cool FT

By Reid M. Haynes

Tale 1: Look What Tarah Can Do

December winds shook through the quiet Starlight City neighborhood, the skeletal trees taking the brunt of the assault. Fall was officially over, and the nights were as stark and cold as could be expected. A single brown leaf remained on a branch of a ciper tree, testament to the season of beautiful dying. That leaf, too, snapped off from the branch and wafted to the concrete below, soon to be crushed underfoot by the lone boy wandering the streets at this hour. beautiful setting description

Andy walked along the sidewalk at a brisk pace, as if trying to keep one step ahead pf of the frigid [perhaps because of double meaning better “freezing”?] air. His green jacket was his only guardian against the wind, and it rustled slightly like a flag at a colonial fort. Strangely, his hands were not gloved [passive voice] nor were they in his pockets, but were instead throwing shadow punches that whipped and shredded the air. His manner was much like a boy who had just seen a particularly exciting martial-arts flick; the white bandanna he wore below his green bangs could be an indication of this.

In aActually, the reality was a bit more exciting.

Andy worked the ball joint in his shoulder with wide, circular movements of his arm, trying to recover from the stretching and yanking he had been doing to it a scant twenty minutes ago. His latest martial-arts workout with Mari had pressed him a bit further than previous sessions?, and the long walk home was again the sour, overly-ripened cherry on top. It was almost as if his instructor was one of those die-hards from the infomercials that trained on five different machines a day.

In any case, he felt good. Andy smiled and exhaled a soft breath through his nose, which quickly turned to fog in the chilled air. This past month, Mari had shown extraordinary support for someone who previously didn't even enter her social circle, all because he had asked for her help. Her words to him today had shown him where she stood.

"Hey, it's no problem Andy!" she told him, with the confident, playful smile he had begun to associate with her. "I'mve been looking for something worthwhile to do with my time, and I don't care what people think of me hangin' with you guys."

The other one referred to by "guys" was Tarah. It was still like a blast of ice water to Andy; only a few months ago he had avoided the girl like she was the bubonic plague, and now he was walking over to her house right now to hang. He hadn't even bothered to call, but had just set out knowing he would be received with open arms. It was something he finally learned he could expect from his new friend: being appreciated, for being there and being him.

Turning the corner, Andy arrived at Mimic Drive, where Tarah's residence [but when she answers the phone she’d say “Mr Reichardt’s residence”? I’d say “where tarah lived”?] was. The houses that aligned either side of the road were mostly one-story jobs, with huge backyards filled with trees and underbrush how does he know about the backyards?. His mind wondered wandered to? on whether the Reichardt's no ‘ here had chosen this neighborhood for their daughter's benefit. Tarah had once told him that her folks had done a lot of moving before coming here two years ago, so he hoped this eco-lover's dream of a subdivision meant that they was were ready to give her a permanent home; there was still so much he had to learn about her.

A slight glare blasted Andy's eyes, and he averted his gaze to safely view its source. One baby ash tree was shining with what looked like holiday lights, and he realized a moment later that it was in Tarah's front yard. It must've been one of the family that who had decorated it, since Tarah would've said the tree was beautiful as it was. Still, he had to admit: it gave the leafless tree some character.

But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] as he proceeded towards Tarah's house, he began to rethink his assessment that the lights were those that came on strings. Not only were there no electrical cords, but each one seemed to be moving by its own power [do you mean “on its own”, “independently”?]. All of them were spherical in shape, soft green, and seemed to be made of cloud-dust. They hovered around the tree like pixies inhabiting a sacred place, never straying too far from their focus point.

(Fireflies?) Andy pondered to himself, raising an eyebrow in confusion [telling the obvious].

He slowly started proceeding towards the tree, his eyes slowly [duplication] following the sprite-like entities' patterns. Tarah never hesitated to tell him of her interest in bugs, and he was wondering if somehow, he could deduce what they were from memory. It was difficult, since the bright glow they emitted completely concealed their bodies, assuming they even had them. A weird, surreal feeling was growing in Andy's gut, and he was starting to wonder if reality had left his port for a land far away.

His apprehension didn't keep him from noting the beauty of the scene. It was like he was living a scenes [duplication] from a cartoon movie, where the animators would struggle to capture a once-in-a-lifetime phenomenon. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] the tree, truly, didn't need holiday lights after all; in a way, it had the same gentle pride that Tarah herself possessed, so he had learned. He felt his worries face [do you mean “fall away”?] away with the soothing atmosphere of the scene and put his hand on the tree's trunk as if giving it his approval.

A ripping sensation clawed at Andy's heart, and his entire being felt like it had been grasped by a titan. "W-whaaat...?!" he stammered out, the word sounding less like it wwas being spoken and more like it was being pitched into an abyss. His lungs were sucked [passive voice] dry? Empty? of the air that sustained [rings false for a boy, at least in my view? reconsider] his being, and he felt his world blacken around him.
*****


Andy's next sensation was the hard impact from falling face first on cold earth. He felt the rough taste of dirt in his mouth, its unsavory flavor coating his tongue like a second skin. He sputtered a bit, spewing large globs of spit in an effort to expel the what? from his mouth. Like a blind grub, he wallowed on the ground, trying to bring himself to his feet again.

Then, he felt his balance shift as he tumbled back over on his side, and tumbled again. He was rolling, rolling, as if a barrel on a steep incline. The somewhat painful experience ended a few seconds later with Andy on a lower altitude and dealing with groaning bones and muscles [they can’t groan-he can]. He felt like he had just woken up late on a school day, by someone pulling up the mattress and dumping him on the ground.

He moaned, letting the pain pulse through his being, bringing a second sensation of relief in its wake. His senses were starting to flare up, and he exhaled a small breath, trying to get adjusted. A bright, yellow light was beating down on him, and he felt warm, June warm [nice touch]. He could feel a few insects run though the openings in his clothes, their feelers tickling and irritating his skin.

He didn't rush to wipe the bugs off his body. In fact, up until this moment, his eyes had been closed [passive voice], and closed hard. Deep inside himself, he knew that he wasn't going to be looking at Tarah's lawn when he decided to accept the reality of his situation and look upon the world. He could feel it beckoning him like a train wreck, and like all present to a train wreck, his inclination to view it overtook all other instincts.

The first thing Andy saw before him was a brilliant blue sky, covered with an outcropping of snow-white cumulus. Birds of the like he'd seen fluttered overhead, He could see the treetops form a canopy in the corner of his vision, along with a few large red objects that he couldn't quite define. He realised that he would need to stand in order to get a better view, and as he did so, he mentally prepared himself for any shocks that his surroundings might cause him.

What needs to be described [passive voice] here could be called a forest, or perhaps an oversized lawn that had never been cut. Everything about his surroundings indicated that it was an exaggerated what?, Small fungi common in Starlight City suburbs were present here at ten times their unusual don’t you mean “usual”? size; the red objects he noted earlier turned out to be a even larger variety of 'shroom. All kinds of botanical life was can you avoid the conflict between plural “kinds” and singular “was”? within sight, some of which did not co-exist in the same season.

The trees were all gigantic, like the century old oaks one finds? every now and again, only with dozens of them within? eyesight all competing for his attention. Strange animal noises could be heard coming, a great deal of them unfamiliar. A small brook a little to the west added a small amount of tranquility to the setting, the one thing relatively normal about his surroundings. Nevertheless, the whole thing came across as a belabored artist's drug-induced idea of nature, and it was sensory overload for Andrew Champion.

The boy's heart-rate 2 words, no hyphen? was through the roof, and his green bang flared like fire as he turned this way and that in a panic. What had happened? How did he get here, and what was here exactly? Was he asleep now? Did someone slip him something?

(Calm down,) a sharp voice from his rational half interjected, like the banging of a gavel in the rowdy courtroom of the consciousness. He responded quickly to this and willed his body to stop shaking, quietly reminding himself that he was not in immediate danger before he could start to panic again. He gritted his teeth and sucked in air through them, feeling his heart beats slow to a more regular rhythm. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”], through the special Courage Training that Mari had given him, he began to methodically go [split infinitive?] over the events that led him to this point, trying to mentally file them all into a proper place.

(Okay, it's obvious this isn't Starlight City,) he told himself slowly, closing his eyes to free himself of the exotic imagery. (The last thing I remember is walking up to the ash tree in Tarah's yard, and then...all this. I need to find out where I am, and for that, I need to find someone to tell me. A signpost, a map, anyone or anything that speaks my language, it's all good right now.)

Andy felt his determination grow, a calling for the quest settling deeper than the fear in his heart. His hands went to the bandanna that still covered his forehead, the familiarity of the cloth between his fingers comforting. (This bandanna is the symbol of my personal accomplishments. It's my sign that I can handle what Destiny throws at me, and throw it back. If something strange is happening to me, then I have to be strange myself.)good fight theory here

He reached for the twin tendrils of his bandanna, which hung loosely in the warm, June-like [first time was great, repeating it here to me lessens the impact?] weather. With two hands, he tightened the bandanna around his forehead, and his eyes opened once more to his unusual new setting, this time with courage.

With his mind set on what?, he began walking.
*****


A hour or so ran by, and the sun had moved to the three o'clock position, behind a few clouds as though? to make the light and heat more bearable. Time seemed to pass normally in this realm (Andy had been referring to this place in his head as a "realm"), even if nothing else was normal about this place. The jungle-like canopies generally kept things cool for any being under their gentle shade, and there was also a small amount of dew left over from the night before. Once you got used to the gigantic man-eating plants that popped up every now and again, it was quite the pleasant place.

Andy wiped a bead of sweat from his head as he trudged up another small hill between more gargantuan oaks. Though he had managed to find a relatively walkable pathway through the mysterious forest, he found he had to periodically swipe foliage out of the way. Aiding him in this manner was a fallen ciper tree branch that currently substituted as a staff. Whatever bizarre creatures that inhabited the forest had not yet revealed themselves, but he could always hear the noises, and thusly felt more secure with a weapon.

His spirits were generally high, considering the circumstances. It was nice and warm here, warm enough to prompt Andy to take off his jacket and tie it around his waist to keep from sweating all over it. The fresh air revitalized him, and he now felt like the main character of an adventure story. As he grew more comfortable with his surroundings, he took the time to examine his surroundings more closely, picking out any oddity he could find.

Of which there were many.

Those of note:

Flowers with buds that continually opened and closed in rhythm. Each time they opened, they made a small musical chirp, and since each flower opened at a different set time, they managed to create quite a little tune.

Long, vine-like growths that hung and perhaps even grew high up in the treetops. Again, they were vine-like but not actually vines, for at the end of each was a small tulip-like bud that indicated it was another strange type of flower.

Again, giant man-eating plants. Open maws big enough to fit a human up to his or her hips, and with "incisors" sharp enough to chomp that human down to size. (he steered clear of those)

Large, rocky monoliths covered with moss. Certainly not strange in of itself, but there was the fact that they seemed to somehow be moving very slightly.

There was another thing odd about the mobile boulders. Andy scrambled over some bushes, and then carefully edged up to one of the boulders to examine the etchings in the rock face. There were some crude pictures of plants and animals, obviously those native to this realm, judging by their unfamiliarity. There was also a small, smiling stick figure, carrying what seemed to be a staff in its hand, with a crude speech balloon above it encasing the words: "PLANTS ARE OUR FRIENDS!"
great creations of plants!
(So there's at least one person here) Andy thought with a satisfied smile. (I'll find this person)

He quickly turned away to set about on his journey again, but then on a sudden thought whirled back to the boulder. The unabashed, earnest attitude coming from the stick figure's message had struck something inside of Andy, and he appraised the drawing more carefully, a wild hunch forming in the recesses of his mind. Yes, there wasn't a doubt. That stick figure has glasses, twin pigtails, and an unmistakable passion for nature that he could not help but find charming.

(Then this means...)

Any revelations that Andy was going through were cut short by the menacing growl coming from his rear. He turned around, and felt the color drain from his face as he caught sight of the first creature of the realm to reveal itself to him, standing outside of a thicket like it had always been there. It had the body of a tiger, but its stripes were green and brown, and it bore a snake's head in place of the standard feline mug. To add just the right touch of fearful oddity, its tail was also a snake, hissing and snapping like live wire.

A chimera of a creation, apparently brought him just to give him a violent death. Sent from Hell, perhaps?

Andy followed his first impulse immediately, and took off for a dense cluster of trees to his right. Looking behind him, he could already tell the action was pointless, for though the beast was still a ways off, it hasd ample reason to be confident of its ability to catch its prey. It moved at a steady pace, obviously not wanting to overexert itself for what it thought was an easy meal. It hissed calmly through its fangs, as if licking its lips with blood-hunger.

Andy felt a terrible frustration building up within him, tearing apart any memory of his once-chipper attitude. Just one second after finding something in the same vicinity as an answer, his life was to be fodder for some monster. He felt his hand tighten around his ciper stick, still held firmly in hand. All of a sudden, he just stopped and turned to face the creature, mentally turning it from an unstoppable force into his sworn opponent.

"You hungry, friend?!" he yelled at the beast, as if trying to dampen its spirit with his barbed tongue. "I'll make you choke on that appetite!!" Feeling more and more ridiculous by the second, he decided to throw all pride to the wind and adopted a mock martial-arts pose with his weapon. "Ho-choi!"

Andrew Champion. Died in cheesy martial-arts fight with fantasy demon. A very exciting epitaph, he supposed.

And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] that's when he caught a small blur, uindefinable in shape, streaking from the lower branches of the oak trees. It started out moving from branch to branch, then moved onto the side of a large trunk, sprung off that to another branch, and started sliding down a root that had somehow something missing here?. This shape, now recognizable as a very familiar young girl, moved with the sharp grace of a stuntman in a martial-arts flick, with all the acrobatics that it entails. It reached the end of the root at an almost inhuman pace, and sprung off it to perform an upside-down mid-air corkscrew, spinning upright to land in between the beast and Andy, with bent knees and an outstretched palm at the beast to keep it at bay.

Tarah's expression was as serious as Andy had ever seen, and yet there was a certain serenity to her manner, not unlike Mari's zen when she practiced her Double Helix Style. She neither retreated nor advanced on the beast, but kept her curiously calm eyes trained on the beast, straightening up with a subtle pride. He had trained under the Double Helix style long enough to pick up on the distinct signs of competence and technique in the girl's posture. She was a martial artist, possibly on the same level as Mari herself.

What she did next wasn't an exhibition of martial skill, but perhaps an indicator of the "maybe more." Slowly, she moved toward the beast, and her outstretched arm slackened a bit. Losing the sense of urgency, a small smile appeared on Tarah's lips, gentle and sympathetic. To Andy's shock, she went right up to the beast and put its hand on its cobra-like crest, and he felt at a loss at what to do.

No screaming or shouting for Tarah to move turned out to be necessary for her to avoid danger, as the situation was quickly going from tense to surreal. Tarah was gently talking to the beast with closed eyes, and it seemed to be responding, nodding its head as if in understanding. Both their eyes were closed, and they shared a certain synchronization, like a psychic mind meld. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] then the beast opened its eyes, turned around, and slowly started walking back into the thicket, its camouflage allowing it to quickly become unnoticeable in the expansive forest.

Andy stared with astonishment at his friend, who seemed to be an amalgam of the familiar and extraordinary. The worry that she had obviously kept bottled up was surfacing on her features, and she was taking some rather large heaving breaths. The boy walked up to her, dropping his ciper stick on the ground. "Tarah?" he said, his face curling up in confusion.

She turned to him, her expression unreadable. "Andrew, what are you doing here?" she asked him, staring with large protrubant protuberant? eyes.

Tarah was dressed in a tank top and a pair of khaki cargo shorts; he had sometimes seen her in this getup when she had gotten through tracking bugs. However, there was were a few notable additions to her ensemble. Strapped to her back via a sling was a long green staff of sorts, and her wrist was adorned [passive voice]with a coiled vine that wrapped around like a bracer. Though this youth was known [passive voice] to accessorize strangely, Andy wondered if these items had some sort of special use in this realm.

He had taken too long to respond to her, and Tarah was walking up to him, a strange urgency in her manner. "Andrew, you can't tell anybody about this place." she said, gripping the front of his shirt. "It's a secret to everybody! Please Andrew, you can't tell anybody about this place!" She was getting frantic, speaking faster and faster, her eyes filled with some unrevealed fear. "Don't tell!"

"Okay, okay!" Andy broke in to keep her form hyperventilating. "I won't tell." Tarah's breaths were short and shallow; Andy had no idea what could scare a girl that never showed much fear to begin with. On a sudden thought, he placed his hands on her shoulders to steady her shaking frame. "I won't tell anyone, Tarah," he told [duplication] her, trying to put her worries to rest.

Tarah blinked a few times, her breathing slowing down to a more regular pace. Then, she smiled. "Okay, I believe you," she said.

Andy stared into her honest eyes, and couldn't fight the blush coming to his cheeks. The trust he had won from Tarah had a way of embarrasing him sometimes. He broke away from her and coughed a few times [duplication] in his hand. "Uh Tarah, what is this place exactly?" he asked her, peeking at her from the corner of his eye.

"This is Broodring," she said conversationally, smiling pleasantly at him. "It's the birth point and distributing center for all mana energy in the world."

"...huh?" The previous statement struck Andy with the same clarity as a koala quacking love it!, and he didn't get much out of it other than the name of this strange locale. "Birth point...what?"

"The birth point of all mana energy in the world," she repeated. "Come on Andrew, it's Chapter 7 of Rizenfort's Big Book of Nature Mythology! I thought everybody knew about mana distribution!"

"Uh, I only skimmed it at the bookstore," he said, turning away and rubbing the back of his hair. A part of Andy still grounded in his world of Pangaea wanted to point out the significance of the word "mythology" to Tarah, and the fact that the book was regarded [passive voice] as a flop by many vendors, though it was true that he had skimmed it. In the end, he decided that any argument on the book's validity was futile, especially after what he had experienced on this night. (or day as it was; there was obviously a time discrepancy between Broodring and Pangaea) He was in Tarah's world, and he would just have to let her lead him by the hand.

Tarah was smiling again. "It's okay," she said. "I can tell you on the way, when we go visit the jaggerflies in the Great Prairie." Her face lit up with excitement and zeal, her fists clenching. "Just think about it, now we can have all sorts of adventures now with the plants and animals. Oh Andrew, I'm so happy you found me here!" She stepped up and hugged him, and Andy cautiously put a hand on her back, still a bit bewildered by this experience.

He suddenly felt her stiffen up like a ramrod. "Oh, I'm late!" she cried, backing away from him and turning around in a flurry of pigtails. "I gotta go!" She stepped into the middle of the clearing, where the mobile boulders had just departed from, and put her cupped hands to her mouth. The girl then made a high-pitched shrieking noise, like a kazoo modified with a computer sound editor. Afterwoards, she folded her hands behind her back and waited expectantly, rocking back and forth on her heels.

Andy refrained from cocking his eyebrow, somehow knowing that his questions about this seemingly random action would be answered [passive voice]. Sure enough, a small lizard darted from the treetops and right up to Tarah's feet. She giggled at as the agile amphibian hopped onto her clothes and crawled its way up to her shoulders, where it perched like a pirate captain's parrot. "Do you remember Cornflower?" she asked him, stroking the animal's neck with her finger.

"Yeah," he responded, recalling the last time he had seen the creature: lying in a fish tank in Tarah's room. The creature looked at him with glassy eyes, and made a noise that was something between a guffaw and a grunt. He winced a bit; Cornflower never really took to Andy, even though he had befriended its master. He could feel a grudge radiating from the supposedly simple creature; could it somehow be angry at the shameful way he had once treated Tarah in front of his former friends?

By now, Cornflower had leapt off Tarah's shoulder onto the grassy clearing. The girl was poised in front of the lizard and appeared to be chanting some sort of witchcraft; at least, with her eyes that's was how it appeared. Her right hand was thrust palm-out towards Cornflower, with her left gripping onto her wrist. Cornflower seemed to be responding, twitching in comprehension.

Then, the lizard suddenly jumped ten feet in the air, spinning around like some sort of aerial top. Its arms and legs became like putty, sloppily stretching out to ten times their usual length. The body and head soon followed in this transformation, as the form of the creature bulged and fluctuated in an attempt to become a scaled-up version of its original form. When Cornflower had landed, it crowded the clearing at around twenty times its former girth, with a new neck frill resembling the creature's namesake, and a certain underlying strength in its limbs.

Andy looked slackjawed 2 words? at the giant lizard, shook his head, and went back to looking slackjawed again. He had thought Tarah would provided some semblance of normalcy to this fantastic realm, but the issues had once again become further complicated. Cornflower regarded him with a casual, yet powerful stare; almost patronizing, if a lizard was capable of being so. 'Yes, Mr. Peer Pressure, I can kick your ass from here to Pangaea' is what the creature seemed to be saying to him; the boy could believe that.

With an accustomed manner born from practice, Tarah leapt an impossible five feet upwards to land on the lizard's back, straddling it as one would a steed. "C'mon, Andrew!" she called from atop Cornflower, offering him an arm up.

Andy hesitated a moment at the proffered hand, regarding it as his ticket to another world. She would only drag him down deeper into this wonderland he had stumbled into. But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] again, he was in Tarah's world. He had always known, deep down, that any association with her would involve throwing away reservation and throwing himself headlong into the dark unknown.

And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] after his previous trials, he had learned not to fear the darkness.

With a confident smile, he gave his trust to Tarah and let her pull him up onto Cornflower. The lizard grunted at this unwelcome passenger, while Tarah rubbed its neck in an attempt to soothe it. Andy adjusted himself on the lizard's back, straddling it as Tarah had before him. Instinctively, he braced himself as if he had just slid into a circus cannon; somehow, he knew he would soon be moving very, very fast.

"Hi ho, Cornflower!" Tarah cried out, raising a fist in the air. "Let's go!"

With a massive leap, Cornflower bolted upwards through the canopies, and Andy could feel the leaves and small branches breaking against his back. He had time to hold one more breath from the clearing as the lizard sprung from the branches to bound across this mysterious land called Broodring.
*****

The open skies stretched like a tarp above the world, covering everything with a veneer of snow-white and liquid-blue. It encompassed everything up to the horizon, but unlike much of the "real" world, there were no buildings or other man-made constructions to break up the natural splendor. Broodring proved to be just as fantastic a place from on high as it did at ground level, with the giant orange mushrooms standing like grand monuments among the more subtle earth tones. And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] just ahead of the horizon, with leaves like green fire and a trunk easily half-a-kilometer in diameter, was a grand ash tree, large enough to make the oak trees look like broccoli tuffs.

Andy stared with mouth agape at the beastly ash dwarfing him even as Tarah's steed Cornflower traversed the treetops like a super-human frog. He had heard about such a marvel of nature existing in the parallel worlds in his old childhood fairy tale books. It was Yggdrassil, the World Tree. A staple in all adventure stories, but now right in front of his eyes, solemn and grand.

Andy shook his head a few times to clear the webbing tying up his faculties. He was already in the middle of a conversation, and she was talking again. "So, the Green Vines style, right?" he tried to confirm, going back to the last topic he could remember discussing before he had spaced out.

"That's right!" Tarah said cheerfully, turning around in her seat to smile at him. "It's the ancient style used by druids to protect the satellite ash tree from Hitory Rancha's developers in 432 A.S., who wanted to make the world's first overcrowded subdivision."

"And so...you're druid?" he queried, trying to keep track of all the new information as he tried [duplication] to keep his lunch down with all the jumps Cornflower was performing.

"Well, I'm more dryad than druid," the girl corrected, carefully guiding the lizard to the east. "I have about 10% dryad blood, so the masters of Broodring thinks that makes me ready to get some druid training anyway, even though I'm not directly related to them. I wish I was through. They live in such nice gardens, with the most beautiful insects and animals."

"Dryad...?" Andy pondered, lowersing his head a bit to look at Cornflower's riveted skin underneath him. His mind was wracked [passive voice] with trying to figure out how to phrase this, to get at the hidden nature of his mysterious friend. "Tarah...what do you do here?" he asked her, knowing he would have to be specific with her.

Tarah looked at him strangely. "Didn't you get to Chapter 15 in Rizenfort's Big Book?" she asked him, taking her hands off Cornflower's neck. "I'm the Yggdrasseer, of course. I protect Broodring and the World Tree from any force that wants to use their power for evil."

This statement had only a brief moment to sink in before Tarah quickly turned her attention to a large meadow they were currently bounding over. "Oh look, the jaggerflies are out now!" she called out, looking at the distant grassland as if its blades were grazing her cheeks. "Cornflower, land here!"

"J-Jaggerflies?" Andy gurbled, squinting hard at the mosaic pattern the grass seemed to create.

With a few quick hops, Cornflower moved from the canopies to the shorter maple trees until it was able to move to the meadow without injury. The lizard took a moment to adjust itself on terra space firma, its frill ruffling and fluctuating. It lowered its neck a moment later, and Tarah gracefully slid down and hopped over its head, landing upright on the plains like a gymnast trying to earn her 9.6. Andy was left [passive voice] to stumble off the creature from the side, as Cornflower decided to continue its obstinate attitude towards him and raise its neck the second Tarah jumped off.

Andy took a brief moment to catch his breath, and followed his friend, who had moved towards the center of the field. Among the tall grass and marigolds, she waited like a pigtailed scarecrow, with arms outstretched to the light gales. The boy stood and waited just a few steps shy of Tarah, somehow feeling he was intruding. It was almost like she was some sort of goddess in this place, and one needed special permission just to speak in her presence.

"They're coming, Andrew," she said, as if to calm the tension in Andy's bones. Although the atmosphere felt as a church to him, Tarah's mouth was uplifted in a small, knowing smile. The mystery surrounding her actions was a bit unsettling, and Andy folded his arms in a small gesture of insecurity. That was as far as he would go to chickening out, though; the things Tarah did would always form into some semblance of logical reason, given time and patience.

The flickering of eleven small insects caught Andy's eyes, which followed them as they popped up through the grass. They were some sort of odd dragonfly creatures, with bodies that curved like fishing hooks and wings that made odd clicking noises as they waved through the air. Each one of them alighted on either one of Tarah's shoulders, making an uneven formation; five on the right and six on the left. Tarah's eyes had opened up now, and she was excitedly glancing between them as if they were a litter of newborn pups.

By her next actions, though, it was more likely they were her friends, not her pets.

"Is everybody doing okay today?" she asked the one closest to her, just as if addressing one of the classmates she never talked to. "...that's good," she responded a moment later, in cue with a small twitch from the creature she was 'conversing' with. "I hope you guys managed to keep away from the hawks this time around." She laughed airily. "That was a rough one!"

"Oh Epheredora, you're hurt after all!" she suddenly cried, staring past the jaggerflies to the one on the end, who seemed to be favoring its right leg. "I told you not to tempt the hawks with a bad attitude! That's okay," she ended her lecture with a shrug and a smile. "I know you're strong! You guys are the best!"

In appreciation of her approval of them, the jaggerflies all departed from her shoulders and began to buzz around her. They flapped their translucent wings in her face, stinging her cheeks with small zephyrs. "Hey, that tickles!" she giggled, shielding her face in mock protest.

Andy smiled, walking up to her. "Looks like you're a little more popular here than at Starlight City," he said wryly, folding his arms over his stomach.

"Yeah!" Tarah replied, favoring him with a cheerful smile. "I really love it here!"

They both chuckled as the jaggerflies formed a ring around them in a sort of impromptu festival dance. "So, this Yggdraseer thing, it's pretty tough, right?" the boy asked.

"Oh, it's a very serious occupation," she replied seriously [duplication], nodding her head vigorously. "Not only do I have to defend Broodring from the forces that want to use it for evil, but I also have to manage the balance of mana all the time. But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] that's okay, because I get a lot of neat powers to help me. I'll show them all to you soon..."

Her eyes suddenly shot open. "Oh, I almost forgot about Chompy!" she exclaimed, looking off from Andy and into the distant trees. "He's been causing a lot of trouble again!"

As Tarah dashed back to the resting Cornflower, Andy desperately scrambled to keep up with her. "Tarah, where're you going?" he gasped, the jaggerflies dispersing around him like a sparkling mist. "Who's Chompy?"

"A giant man-eating plant," she said, reaching a hand out to him. "Come on!"

A scant few seconds later, they were flying once again.
*****


"I don't see what the big deal is." The wheezing voice cut through their earlobes like a barbed wire. "I'm just sitting here by myself, drinking up what's right here waiting for me."

"But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] you're hurting the rest of the plant life around you and disrupting the delicate balance!" Tarah insisted, gesturing broadly with her hands. "You need to stop that!"

Before Andy and Tarah, shrouded in the darker depths of the forest, was an oversized venus fly-trap, straight out of a science fiction B movie. The bestial bulb was gifted [passive voice] with an elaborate root system, wrapping around the neighboring flora and obviously very capable of choking the life out of it. Its head was as round as a cabbage, with a very human-like maw sporting a set of curved fangs. Right now, that maw seemed to be twisted into a very human-like expression; a smug grin, to be exact.

"What's the big deal, anyway?" Chompy drolled on lazily, waving a vine at them in an expression of lazire fare laisser faire?. "I'm just going by the rules of cause and effect. I'm hungry, so the other plants get a little less food than normal."

"I changed my mind about that during a class assignment!" Tarah shot back, waving her arms frantically. "If you can talk to me, than you can control yourself and reach an equilibrium with the environment like all the other plants!"

"Bluh, you're a little baby Yggdraseer," the plant crooned, once again showing off his odd imitation of a smile. "A little brat playing at being grown up. What do you really know about the balance of nature anyway?"

The blood ran hot in Andy's veins at the insults. "I don't know half of what this Broodring place is all about, but I think we can both see when something's being a weed," he blurted out, stepping up to Chompy in an act of defiance. "Why do you deserve more than your fair share?"

If Chompy had eyes, they would have narrowed at that moment. "Who the heck are you?" he barked, regarding him contemptuously. "Some sort of puffy dandelion?"

"I'm Andrew Champion," the boy replied, subconsciously running a hand through his fluffy, dandelion-like hair. "Both me and Tarah know what to do with people...er, plants that push others around."

"Little sap, I could smack your roots clear across Broodring." A dangerous lilt entered into the tone of the sentient flower, his protruding vines thrashing with anticipation. "What do I have to be scared of?"

"Why don't you just try it?" Andy barked out, feeling his temples throb with adrenaline. "I'm been trained in the Double Helix style, buddy!"

"Dandelion!"

"Weed!"

"Andrew, Chompy, stop it!" Tarah cried out, thrusting herself between them. She escorted Andy off to the side. "Andrew, what's wrong?" she asked, her face flush with concern. "Chompy isn't that bad!"

"I'm sorry, I'm guess I'm getting a little hyper today," he relented, shaking his head. A small part of his brain balked at the absurdity of arguing with foliage perhaps better ‘greenery”, but it was quickly drowned out by how darned irritated he was with that plant. Going with the latter feeling, he approached the plant again, trying to keep his temper in check. "Look, Chompy, why do you need all this extra nourishment, anyway. Moderation can be fun, too."

"I guess I'm bit of a sinner," Chompy confessed unabashedly, his bulb retreating back into its nest of roots. "Lust doesn't do it for me, so why not a little Gluttony."

Andy sighed, slumping his shoulders in defeat. "He's pretty stubborn." he said, going back over to Tarah. "Kind of like humans in a way."

"Chompy likes the human world a lot, and he sends a lot of spores out there," Tarah explained. "Chompy even sides with the housing developers sometimes when I talk to him."

"Ouch," Andy winced with imagined pain.

"You're funny, Andrew!" Tarah added, giggling lightly. "I've never seen someone get into a fight with Chompy before."

Andy blushed slightly, wondering once again if this mysterious land was playing a joke on him. (But [avoid “But” at sentence start, if you must “However,”?] if it makes Tarah happy, why not?)

Andy and Tarah smiled at each other gently; Chompy regarding their moment with a cynical air about him.

And [It’s normally suggested not to start sentences with “And”] then, all of a sudden, a shadowy swath broke from the darkness and plunged onto Andy with the force of a flying shoulder tackle. The blow knocked the boy clear to the hard earth, and he struggled amongst the leaves as the mysterious form pushed him into the dirt. Something sharp and slick with saliva was shining in front of his face, and he instinctively recoiled from it. "W-whug...?" he choked incoherently, the fight-or-flight instinct within him flaring up frantically.

"Andrew!" Tarah cried out desperately. Sparing no second, she reached behind her for the staff still bound to her back. Bringing it up to bear, she swung the implement in a wide arc, knocking the shadowy form off into a hardwood tree. She quickly shifted the staff in her hands and went to tend to the boy, who was gasping desperately for air.

"What...what's going on?" he managed to get out, leaning lightly on Tarah for support. His eyes darted surreptitiously to the weapon in the girl's hand. The staff appeared to be formed [passive voice] of a large, green rose stem, with a cluster of thorns on the bottom and a crystal blossom on the top. A small green light seemed to be radiating form from within the closed petals.

"Bed Bugs," Chompy answered him, a strange anxiety in the twitch of his vines. "They've been attacking Broodring for a good while now."

"Bed Bugs?" Andy groaned, his eyebrows furrowing in wild confusion.

"They're nefarious Dream Demons that appear when people sleep," Tarah said quickly, her eyes darting about like fireflies. "Sometimes Dream Demons take the form of neat bugs, but I don't know anything else about them."

Andy and Tarah's attention was drawn [passive voice] back toward the shadow form, which had regained its footing on the forest floor. The Bed Bug, as it were, appeared as a pitchblack cross between a louse and a cockroach, as large as
104
104
Review of Blood Feud  
Review by Nok2
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Review: Blood Feud, Chapter 1, Tye

Hi,

Thanks for letting me know what you would like reviewed. I’ll start with Blood Feud (good title).

First off my usual cautionary words: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line (see specific comments below), and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS

Title: Blood Feud

Chapter: 1

Author: Tye

Plot: You start with drama and suspense, great pacing and end with a terrific hook. Well done!

Style & Voice: Gosh, I can’t believe the same person wrote Gavriel’s return and this. You’re a master of different styles, it seems. You got the ‘hardboiled’ style down to perfection, the “I narrator”s voice is entirely believable. A little bit of ‘telling’ and some passive voice.

Setting: Good descriptions, involving most senses and some new senses, which normal people don’t have

Characterization: Very good, only I’d name the POV character earlier? Perhaps “...cubicle with my tag ‘Agent Spicer’, on which some wit had scrawled an “i” making it “Spicier”, or the name is on his badge which he takes along...

Grammar: no problems that I could see, some missing commas

Just My Personal Opinion: Great writing. I’ll definitely read on.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

FINALLY: (A) Specific comments see in line review below

SPECIFIC COMMENTS


Chapter 1
On most days, I sit in a little six by six cubicle with my nose deep in musty old tomes or reading over various reports. Generally, I like days like that. It’s got three perks to it. The first being: it’s easy. It’s easy to sit and read and find out how this officer messed up right there. The second is: it’s quick. I read at an accelerated rate so I chew through files, reports, and tombs [tomes?] like there they’re no more then than a few pages long. Lastly, nothing tries to eat your face, pound you into a pulp or generally kill you.
See comma like I said comma easy.
Sadly comma today wasn’t one of those days. I walked out of the office and glowered at the cloudy skies. New York was having a storm fit (fancy that) and lately all the days had at least some clouds to all out rain or snow. I snuggled deeper into my trench coat and mumbled a few choice words about the weather, when the door behind me opened how does he know? Does he perhaps hear it creak open? and I was temporarily re-warmed [passive voice is generally considered weak and therefore best avoided. Rephrase? Perhaps “and a gust of hot air washed over me from...”?] by the heater blaring inside. I turned in time to see my partner finish slipping into her leather trench coat.
Shelly Fields was a slender woman leaning more towards a swimmer then than anything. Her dark chestnut hair fell just past her shoulders and always seemed to frame her face so that you stared at her appealing smile and hazel eyes. After that killer sight comma you tended to notice her tan complexion that she had naturally and “never from a cancer booth”. She smiled and stared rather pointedly at me until I recovered enough to speak words coherently.
“Why Miss. no period Field you are looking lovely as ever on this gloomy day.” Yep. Suave, that’s me. I’d try to separate his and her actions/words etc by paragraphs? Here a paragraph breakShelly only rolled her eyes and nudged past me just hard enough to make me stumble a bit. I turned with the stumble and used momentum to catch up with her. She stared up at me, which wasn’t much to brag about. She was only 5’5 where as [one word?] I was 6 foot nothing. We walked in silence towards our Toyota Camry, dutifully named Sheila. I got in the passengers seat and Shelly jumped into? the driver seat. We buckled up and tore out of the parking lot.
I waited a good five minutes before asking, “So you going to fill me in or am I going to wait and see the surprise?” paragraph breakShelly smiled and shook her head. “Well Agent Spicer if you must know, they’ve found a third body in the past three days with the same cause of death.” Her smile immediately died and mine followed soon after [weakens the impact in my view]. I sighed loudly, “So they waited until a third body [perhaps better “guy”, “person”?] died under “mysterious” circumstances,” I air quoted, “before calling the Spook squad.”
The Spook squad or more formally B.P.D, Bureau of Paranormal Development was the newest branch of the government. We were the collection of freaks the government sanctioned to handle anything deemed unusual. See most people believe that the nightmares and monsters aren’t real and the B.P.D are the ones who make sure it stays that way. As the newest branch most police departments or senior agencies tended to look down there their noses at us. I mainly ignored them because when things got weird everyone called the Spook Squad to save their prideful asses.
“So what’s the cause of death?” I idly questioned. Shelly took her eyes off the road long enough to arch an eyebrow. “You don’t think I’d honestly ruin all the surprise comma? did you?” She smiled wickedly at me and glided through morning traffic. We pulled into a dinky run down apartment complex deep in the heart of the Bronx. I noted the graffiti coloring most walls but couldn’t discern which ones were more prominent [“more” implies here a comparison “more ...than”; perhaps better “which ones stuck out most”?. The building was in desperate need of renovations. [‘telling’ and its obvious from what follows] The brick was a dull copper color and cracks presumably? [unless he knows for sure?] from a faulty foundation were spreading rapidly. I followed the building until my eyes caught the police cruisers, ambulances, and coroner hearse idly waiting. Two uniforms were quietly taping off the scene.
I hopped out of the car slipping my B.P.D badge around my neck. I walked towards the building carefully noting where the fire exits were comma? and which side of the building the fire escape was on. I lifted my badge at the uniform, a young kid no older than twenty-two sitting behind the yellow tape, and slipped under it while he frowned after me. Me, carry a grudge? Never. Shelly was more polite, she stopped and told the kid who we were then jogged to catch up with me.
“Wow Jack, your diplomacy skills never cease to amaze.comma instead of period here I think” she growled. I grunted in answer comma which set her off even more. “Look, you know we’re already the black sheep of the government comma or period? at least attempt to make friends with the locals.” I dutifully kept my mouth shut and stopped at the elevators. I pushed the button and waited, feeling the building around me. I say feeling because I’m not your average Joe. I’m one of the many supernatural things shanghaied into the Bureau. When I say “supernatural things” comma? most people immediately think fraud, con artist, and generally mistrust anyone claiming supernatural abilities. But I really can use psychic powers and general unexplained things.
So, naturally I could sense and see things most regular people couldn’t dream of. I slowly extended my mind through the building. The first floor was clean and neat to the naked eye, but underneath, it was stained with sludge from drug exchanges, murders, gang wars, and everything else that underhandedly went on in the building. I pushed past the aura of the building and touched on the two uniforms and clerk in the back room talking, and then when I touched on Shelly I couldn’t help but smile. Her power was a deep thrum that set off my warning bells even though she wasn’t actively doing anything. I reveled in her taste: mints, powders, something all together [altogether?] sweet with an undertone of spice. I never got tired of reading her aura.
Shelly swatted me, gently, with her power and I moved up the building sensing each floor. The second and third floor were as normal as it got with a handful of people lounging in there their apartments. The fourth floor was a different story entirely. At first comma it was pretty dull and bland until my sense touched on a room . The room , which was humid and hot like a sauna. It felt sticky to my sense and I pulled back frowning. Shelly waited patiently for me to get my bearings before guiding me into the open elevator.
“Fourth floor,” I grumbled. I rubbed at my arms where phantom sensations played along my skin. We hit the floor and I hesitated. I knew something wrong had happened here. I could feel it downstairs and even now in the elevator I could feel the resonance of what happened further down the hall. I steeled myself and stepped out of the elevator willing myself to be calm. I stopped at the door just as a techie came barreling out of the room holding a fancy camera.
“Jesus Walter comma watch where you’re going man! I almost plowed over you!” I barked. Walters jumped and then scowled at me. Pete Walters was the resident Head Tech over at the NYPD and coincidentally my friend. I chucked him on the arm and smiled real big. Pete was 5’8, and far too tan for someone who worked in a hole most of the day, with sandy brown hair and a? smile to die for. He worked out regularly and you could tell, even through his jumpsuit. paragraph break “Jack,” he said by way of greeting, “Shelly.” paragraph breakShelly nodded at him and we both slipped on the little slippers rephrase to avoid the duplication? to keep from tracking anything into the crime scene.
Pete stood up after putting the camera in its case. “Alright, scene is yours period I’ve got everything I need out of it.” I nodded and slipped in the door careful not to touch anything. The apartment was pretty standard: a one room, one bathroom, half dining room kitchen with a small nook for a living room. Pictures on the wall were of a pretty young blond with big green eyes, killer dimples and award winning smile. The T.V set in the corner of the living room droned with static. I checked the kitchen and found noodles burnt to the bottom of a pot obviously overcooked. I looked around the house flat and stopped dead at outside the girl’s room.
Up until her room comma the house apartment was particularly bland of any distinguishing emotions or “vibes”, but the girl’s door absolutely pulsed with energy. I took a cautious step back and sent my senses out to probe the door. I paused debating, then decided why not and shoved my sense into the door. It was a mistake. Suddenly I was flooded with a range of emotions: hate, love, lust, anger, pain. I stumbled and fell on my ass as images started flashing behind my closed eyes. I could see the girl alive and well, talking to a shadowy figure. She had been cooking for a date when the shadow showed up early. They had talked, drank champagne, and then drifted into her room. There they “talked” quite vigorously.
I tore my mind away from the scene before anything else reared its ugly head. I swore quietly under my breath until I felt Shelly’s presence at my back. She touched my shoulder and I relaxed under the touch [stating the obvious]. She did more then lay her hand on me, she radiated calm that I sucked in like a drowning man just coming out of the water gasps for air. I drank until I could breathe normally, and then tapped her hand to let her know I was okay.
I wiped sweat off my upper lip and then threw up my mental shields so I could function in the next room. I gestured and Shelly opened the door for me. She shivered as she passed through the lingering wisps of psychic imprints. I barely noticed them through my shields and paused in the doorway. The room was…cutedelete space . The walls were a pastel pink with faux clouds painted on the ceiling in a complimenting lilac. The bed was another variation of pink and overall the room radiated “girly”.
The body didn’t. The blond was propped on the pillows, nude as on the day she was born. Her face was set in the form of someone dreaming peacefully. [‘telling’, and duplication of what you show afterwards] A small smile touched her lips and she appeared like she was sleeping. The sleeping image was shattered by the slightly off coloring of her skin due to the two neat holes in her throat where something had drunk her blood. Avoid passive voice; perhaps better: “The slightly off coloring of her skin due to the two neat holes in her throat where something had drunk her blood shattered the sleeping image.” I stepped closer to the body taking mental notes, her stomach was slightly distended and her lips were slightly blue. Strangely comma the girl was free of all the normal scents of decomposition.
Shelly was the first to touch and move the body. Her its arms moved stiffly when Shelly looked for any marks of struggle. She didn’t find any, not that I was surprised. The girl was clueless from what I had glimpsed. Whatever had been with her had clouded her mind comma made her think and feel like she was in euphoria rather then chilling death.
“Were they all propped up like this,” I asked. paragraph break Shelly nodded and stood turning and turned to leave. Her hand brushed the girls’ body slightly dislodging her and I glimpsed something. I frowned and shelly mirrored me. She followed my gaze then stepped back to the body to lift the girls left arm. I peered closer and I could feel my frown deepen. A small cut just on the inside of her torso leading led straight to her heart. I moved to touch it when I felt the buzz of Power lingering over the cut. I froze just before touching the lingering energy and glanced up at sShelly.
“Don’t look at me,” she said. “I didn’t feel anything.” paragraph break I shook my head. “I know the Power is focused on the cut,” I noted. paragraph break Shelly sighed, “Here let me period? you might hurt yourself like with the door.” She pushed lightly and I moved, taking a couple small steps back. I watched as she settled down on her knees and concentrated. About a minute went by before she actually moved. Her hands hovered lightly over the cut and a small shimmer rose to meet them. She gasped and bowed her head as the Power coursed into her.
After thirty seconds or so comma the shimmer faded and sShelly sighed heavily. I watched as she went through her mental exercises to calm herself before she looked back at me.
“Well,” I pressed.
She stood and gestured for me to follow. I did, frowning comma while she led me to the hallway where she leaned against the wall. “Well,” she finally said, “it wasn’t a spell that’s for sure.” I could feel my frown deepen, at this rate I would leave permanent lines on my face. “Okay, so what exactly was it,” I questioned. Shelly just shook her head and smiled grimly. I started getting a sinking feeling in my stomach. “Well Mr. Psychic if you have to know it’s a rote.” I stared at her as the bottom fell out of my stomach. “Only it felt wrong, cold, and I couldn’t figure out what it was meant to do,” she sighed.
Crap. This changed things. Rotes were to psychics like as spells were to magic users. They were powers psychics implemented. Through force of will comma a psychic would cast a rote and have whatever he imagined come into reality. Most weren’t extremely powerful or even what you would call supernatural. Mostly they helped with luck, karma or chance period those were the easiest rotes to cast period otherwise you had to put more will into what you wanted. So the fact that the rote was powerful enough to be focused around the wound meant that whoever had attacked the girl had done it with a powerful psychic attack.
“Well I’ll be damned.” I growled under my breath. I sighed, a little relieved to be away from the girl, away from the death and lingering imprints coating the room. I shivered despite how warm the room was and then leaned against the wall with sShelly. “This definitely changes things comma Shell.” I whispered. I stood up and started pacing. “Who was she?” Shelly took out a little notepad and flipped it open, PeriodhHer name was Kristin Belford, newly turned twenty two year old in her third year of college.” paragraph break Something nagged at me. I tried to peg it down but my brain didn’t seem to be cooperating with me [stating the obvious]. I could feel a headache rising from thinking about what I was missing when Shelly broke my concentration. “She’s the exotic dancer up at Dante’s,” and suddenly I knew what I had been missing.
Dante’s was the hottest vampire club in Manhattan. It was the largest wellhyphen known place regular vanilla folks could go to be close to a real live monster. What most people didn’t know was that for a little extra cash you could have one of those sexy monsters take a bite of you and or oblige in your darkest fantasies. It was also conveniently owned and run by Dante, and from what I knew about him comma he was a noble in the vampire clans, which meant I was now ankle deep in alligators and rapidly sinking. Not only was Dante head of Dante’s but also Prince of Manhattan and, consequently, one of the powers that be in the supernatural community.
“You’ve got to be kidding me.” I moaned. “Dante won’t stand for one of his girls being poached, which means Kristin isn’t the last body we’ll be seeing.” I closed my eyes trying to focus my thoughts. “Well,” sShelly interjected, “that means we need to pay the Prince a visit.” I shook my head and smiled, “Hail Caesar.”
105
105
Review of Ch 4-6  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.0)
Review: The Adventures of Marty Mask,Chapter 4, by Micaiah

Hi,

First off my usual cautionary words: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line (see specific comments below), and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: The Adventures of Marty Mask

Chapter: 4

Author: Micaiah the Slayer

Plot: A beautiful Siamese, who impresses David greatly, engages Marty to find her missing husband. Right after she leaves a large Persian cat tries to scare Marty off the case.

Style & Voice: A bit of passive voice, sentence fragmnts, words considered weak and generally overused by many authors are marked in pink-consider rephrasing to delete a few, some typos

Setting: a little more would have been nice

Characterization: David and Marty acted in character, and good job with description and voice of the two new cats

Grammar: no problems that I could see

Just My Personal Opinion: I don’t know why but it felt a bit long to me, or perhaps not long/detailed enough, not sure...other than that a quick and easy read, well done

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

FINALLY: (A) Specific comments see in line review below (posted on the fantasy novel workshop forum)
106
106
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (5.0)
Thanks again for the review of my Prologue. I thought I’d return the favor :) and take a look at your portfolio.

Having read this poem I can only say it left me stunned.

I am not a poet but even my ear could hear the amazing rhythm pulsing in your short text (and I didn’t even read it aloud). Yet despite this the choice of words felt totally unforced, they were just beautiful natural choices and the words felt so right. Sorry for gushing, but I find poetry often painful to read as you can frequently feel words forced to fit rhyme or rhythm.

The beginning drew me right in (I’ve been to Sydney), you made me stay with you throughout and at the end there was excitement, suspense and a sort of sudden rush of emotion that I’ve only ever experienced with haikus. I don’t want to say more so as not to spoil the effect for others.

Superb!
Write on.

Love

Nok
107
107
Review of Good or Evil  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.0)
It's a really interesting poll, but you could improve it by running a spell-checker, there's quite a number of typos.

You write: ..."don't bother if you wont to make a case about good and evil just being a point of view. I believe in objective morality. Otherwise I'd love to hear what you have to say."

I don't know whether this is what you don't want to hear but I'd say this:

the cute killer would agree whole-heartedly that it's wrong to kill people. The crux is that HER definition of 'people' and that of ME?YOU?OTHERS? may differ.

It is a well known fact that it's easier to kill people if you demonize them/declare them as subhuman first.

Also most people have no problem eating beef but would be very reluctant to eat horse, and horrified to eat pet animals, like a dog or cat they personally know. and love

So the moral code is in fact the same - a taboo to eat "another one of us"-but the group can be very differently defined

and therefore we can objectively say that the cute killer is NOT evil, as she applies HER rules correctly

in the same way as you cannot call a cat that kills a mouse evil

only if she killed HER FRIENDS-then she would be evil (if she's not ill, deranged, starving or whatever...you get the idea)

That's at least my bit on this little brain teaser
thanks -it's been fun.

Nok
108
108
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello newbie, and well done for biting off such a big chunk (more than i can chew)

It's an interesting position towards an interesting problem.

May I paraphrase what a character playing devil's advocate says in an as yet unposted chapter of my fantasy novel:

“Intelligence, character, discipline, strength that enable men to rise, to make an effort …are themselves accidents of birth; therefore the learned and capable do not deserve their positions and the claim of meritocracy fails in a democracy.”

and then there's the whole debate whether there is really such a thing as free will...

food for thought?
best of luck to you

Nok
109
109
Review of Raindrops Ch.1  
Review by Nok2
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hi,

You asked for a review-here it is. :)

First off my usual cautionary words: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line (see specific comments below), and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: Raindrops

Chapter: 1

Author: Petroc

Plot: Raphael seeks treasure in a ghost town in the desert, and finds some, including 2 swords

Style & Voice: Your style is really pleasant to read; some passive voice, typos and a little ‘telling’ instead of ‘showing’

Setting: You describe the setting brilliantly, I could really picture it

Characterization: Well done; I have only two small concerns – I’d suggest to name the character right away- and I was not sure whether we are in Raphael’s POV or camera POV, but perhaps that’s just me

Grammar: no problems that I could see

Just My Personal Opinion: Good read, thanks for sharing.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

P.S. Send me a review of one of my chapters and I’ll gladly review your next chapter

FINALLY: (A) Specific comments see in line review below

SPECIFIC COMMENTS

CHAPTER ONE Okay—nit-picking here: in Ch#1+2 you have Caps, Ch#2=3 you have Font style bold, and Ch#1+2 you have the number spelled out—harmonize over all chapters?
"As children we are taught to follow our dreams, that nothing is impossible. The world is as vast as our imagination and that there is always hope, but as we grow up we learn to tell the difference between childhood fantasies and reality. We lose faith as we realize the horrible truth; that the world doesn't [spell out?]want our dreams"

The sword slid into the sand with a slight [telling, and diminishes the effect] grating sound, the bearer of the weapon carrying it as much for support on the slippery dune as he did just to hold it. The blade was old, its sheath long lost, and though it was well-cared for, rust had still claimed some small parts of its guard.
Around the young man's shoulder was a brown, patched up canvas bag. Some small parcels at its bottom pushed out bulkily, but it was mostly empty, the result of poor findings. Like his bag, the young man's wardrobe was patched, from his thin jacket to his dark undershirt, semi-colon? all of his clothes were worn and frayed. Only his high boots, crafted from aged [telling, and awkward as the leather was presumably newish when the boots were made] leather, had any remnant of their original appearance [telling and too unspecific].
This young man, whose name was Raphael, took another step, his foot again sinking several inches into the parched sand. Had he been wearing the traditional footware [typo] footwear, his boots would be full of sand and blistered feet, but foresight had kept this from happening.
He reached the crest ot[typo]of the dune and surveyed the waterless land below him. It was an ocean without water, for the dunes were like waves and flowed across the desert at the mindless march the wind set for them. Instinctively, he squinted his eyes [telling the obvious] against the sand's unrelenting glare. A warm breeze swept up the dune, hurling sand into Raphael's face. His eyes teared [is that a word? pricked with tears? Welled up?] at the stinging touch of the sand, sending the world into a blurry mass of shapes and costing him a couple of drops of [can you avoid the duplication?] precious water.
Grimacing at the pain, Raphael turned against the wind and wiped away the grit with his jacket sleeve. By the time he could see again comma?the breeze had shifted elsewhere, giving him the chance to return to his seeking.
It was a few seconds before his attempt was rewarded [avoid passive voice?]. Half buried by a sand dune was a small group of buildings, which appeared to have once been part of a larger collection, perhaps even a town, but Raphael had never heard of a town in this area. For him, and many who had been here ahead of him, it'd always been the desert and its ruins.
Determined to make it back with the sun still in the sky, Raphael slid down the sandy slope. His momentum continued as he broke into a run at the dune's base. When he came closer to the ruins he slowed his pace, weighing to [the?] prospects of each of the five visable [typo]visible buildings. Deciding on the one closest to the sand dune looming over the ruins, but not yet buried, he shifted his pack as he walked.
The air inside the stone building was much cooler than the air outside, and the only source of illumination was the light streaming through the open doorway and paneless windows. The floor was made of stone but Raphael couldn't see it through the three inches of collected sand covering everything.
In the back of the ruin were the remnants of a wooden table, the legs on one end broken. Along the wall on Raphael's left was a lowhyphen lying cabinet-shelf combination made of the same dark stone that all of the ruins were made of. The wood of the doors were rotten, just like the wood of the table proved to be upon closer inspection. Some of the doors had weakened so much that they had fallen right off their hinges.
Raphael frowned, he knew that wood could dry rot, essentially turning into powder, but the rot that was eating the table and the doors was more like the rot he'd seen back home. Without water, it shouldn't have rotted in peeling strips.
Such thoughts could be considered [passive voice-consider revising?]later, he reminded himself. He leaned the sword against a stone block and pulled his bag off his shoulder. From it comma? he retrieved a wide-headed spade and began digging through the sand on the floor around the table. Whenever and object of decent quality was found it was placed in a pile. Mostly, the objects were pieces of bronze silverware comma? and clay comma? and porcelin [typo] porcelain plates. When at last the pile of treasures had grown to a considerable size, Raphael took a break. He wrapped the silverware together in a single piece of canvas, but the plates were wrapped [passive voice-rephrase?] carefully in several layers of a much softer material I’d suggest naming the material, otherwise it feels like a slip from Point of View?.
With only a little room left in his bag, Raphael glanced at the cabinet. He rose to his feet, removed the stopper out of his mostly empty water bag and took a drink. The bag sloshed with every motion, and Raphael didn't waste a drop of the precious liquid it contained. When he’d drankdrunk what he could afford, he returned the stopper, making sure it was securely fixed before he slid the bag back to its place at his side.
He pulled at the bronze door handle on the closest cabinet that still had its door, but intsead [typo} instead of opening, the wood cracked and fell apart.
"Oops..." He said, imitating a young child. Inside the cabinet was the gleam of metal, the prospect of which made Raphael's heart skip a beat. He reached for the gleam, but stopped as the sound of steps in the sand that came from the nearest window. He slid soundlessly to where he'd left his blade and gripped the cracked leather wrapped around the hilt, waiting.
The sound moved towards the door, then stopped. Like a phantom, the wind moaned through to {c;green}the? windows and the steps continued.
Fear seized Raphael's heart, he had no idea what could be lurking outside. {telling] He discovered that the hand holding the blade was shaking and willed it to stop. Beyond the stone walls [one word?]the steps were almost to the door [awkward-rephrase?]. Raphael was certain that his heart, with each booming beat, was going to betray him.
But However, nothing came, no figure, human or otherwise, moved into the doorway. As the wind moaned again comma? a large tumble weed rolled into view not far from the door. The sound was made [passive voice-rephrase?]when it struck the sand with its uneven weight.
A sigh escaped from Raphael. He slid back across the sand to the cabinet and reached inside. The metalic [typo] metallic gleam was neither tool nor jewelry, rather, it was two gracefully curving short swords [awkward switch from singular to plural] perhaps say the gleam came from...?, each worth its weight in gold. He wrapped these in seperate [typo]separate cloths, and then used the remaining cloth to hold the two together. When the treasures had been securely bound, Raphael tied the package to the cavas[typo]canvas bag using several lengths of leather cord attatched[typ]attached to the bag's outer layer.
Satisfied [telling] with his haul, he left the ruins. He walked up and over the dune he'd come from, then followed the valley formed by the joining bases of several dunes until he reached a long vehicle covered in a dusting of sand.
At the press of a button, a hatch opened near the center of the vehicle. A rough net was in place to hold any objects found in the ruins away from the motor.
He eased the canvas bag into the hatch, and then closed the cover with a mild slam. Once in the seat, he slid the brake latch down its bar, causing the whole machine to shudder. The three turbines on the vehicle's bottom began to spin and Raphael leaned back.
The four stands lifted into the vehicle, but it stayed in the air, floating just over a foot over the ground. A ring of sand formed around the vehicle, pulsating with the turbines. Raphael eased to the? craft forward, then hit the accellerator [typo] accelerator. Around him the world blurred, he placed the sun on his back as he headed home.
110
110
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi

Thanks for the review of my first chapter, good comments. Here is your review in return.

First off my usual cautionary words: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing. While my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line (see specific comments), and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

Title: Empire’s Ashes Chapter 1 , by angeljack

GENERAL COMMENTS

Very interesting and well written blurb/teaser.

plot: I liked that you took your time to introduce the main character and then increased the pace and ended, leaving the reader wanting more

Characters: good introduction of appearance and back story, only I would name the character right away?

Grammar: not my strength, but the only thing I could see were some semi-colons where the sentence could not stand alone see specific comments below

Style/voice: Very good writing, nice style, well crafted and I’d say well polished, ready for publication except minor typos, some commas etc see specific comments below

Setting: good detail and genre appropriate

Overall: Excellent read, I especially liked your description of two (presumably opposed) types of magic. Your story is definitely interesting. If I picked it up in a store, I’d want to read it.

Definitely keep writing!
All the best

Nok

SPECIFIC COMMENTS

Empire's Ashes
Part One: Freedom Fighter

CH-1


... In particular, one ordinary boy with nimble fingers and a quick hands out to lift a few money pouches.

Rhidh's Factory District wasn’t the richest neighborhood in the city. Even though most of the money made in the city came from the factories, which produced the parts for the Empire’s massive mining and irrigation projects, it was not readily shared with anyone outside of the Royal District. They took more than their share from all of the districts; including the Merchant district, which housed ...

Even sStill, he couldn’t help but feel a tinge of guilt in the back of his mind as he slipped through the crowd looking for the telltale bulge under a cloak that would signal his time to act. These people were not rich and he tried not to think of what would happen when they reached their homes only to find that all that was left of the little bit of money that they had been working for through the long day was the frayed ends of purse strings.

...

... Pretending to trip, his fingers expertly slid under the cloaks of two of the men and by the time he had passed them he had slipped two fairly light pouches purses?into the concealed pouches within his cloak. ...

... Sighing, he slipped back out in the crowed and moved along the street, occasionally stumbling into a group of workers and unburdening them of their wages. As he worked the rain fell steadily harder and harder. He could tell that he wasn’t going to be able to work for very long. The harder the rain fell the faster that the workers fled back to their homes. ...


In front of him were the district gates that separated the Factory District from the Slums. It was They were closed, ...He took a moment though to think about how nice it would be to simply walk through that gate and go home rather than have to take the long way home. It had been a long time since these gates had been opened and judging by the rust covering the giant brace;, it wasn’t likely that it would be opened anytime soon.

...
The Patrol was already there. At least ten of them, their shining plate mail breast plates streaked with rain. But instead of talking to an irate factory worker as he had thought they would be, they were standing, with swords drawn facing down a tall man in an expensive-looking black cloak. The boy could not see what the man looked like because his back was turned. He was facing the Patrol and the boy could see their faces. Every one of them wore an unusual expression that he had never before seen on their faces as they did their rounds. ...

What was different in this case was that the Patrol seemed unwilling to come closer than ten feet to the man in the cloak. ...

His thoughts were interrupted abruptly [telling the obvious] as he felt the tip of a knife press into his lower back and a big hand wrap around him from behind him and cover his mouth.

...

Realizing who it was and taking a moment to move his heart back to his chest from where it had climbed to in his throat;, the boy twisted from his crouched position, simultaneously moving his body away from the razor sharp tip of the knife and planting his elbow in his attacker’s side. ...


... Lowering himself as low as he could get hr and slowly peereding out into the street. ...

...Behind the Patrol the last of the factory workers was were scattering to their homes. None of them even glanced back, ...

... Without stopping he continued his ark arc? and cut through the third and forth man, felling them all in one smooth movement. ...

...


... Though he had never left the city of Rhidh, Kalen had seen many of the travelers, traders and people from all corners of the Empire who came looking for the abundant work in the cities city’s? Factory Districts.

... With all of the stories that he had heard throughout his life about sorcerers and magic users, he would not have been surprised. ...

The wavering air in front of the men began to draw into itself, becoming smaller and smaller until it was no bigger than the pinpoint of light that had proceeded the strangers magic fire. ... No matter how hard he tried, he could not take his eyes off of the swirling vortex. He tried to close his eyes, but it was still there. He could see it still, in his minds eye.
111
111
Review of A cracking life  
Review by Nok2
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
You write very well, I enjoyed reading this - wow, the prices and the hard work / hard play fast life, Docklands, Canary Wharf, Canada Square etc, the suits...The details are very good, you are clearly very observant and have an eye for the 'telling' minutiae. If you ever try your hand on a novel that should come in handy.

I'd suggest though to write the text with a word processing system first and run the spell-checker - typos add nothing and look careless and stop the flow of reading, such as eg "aan hour " and "Embarrasing" and "wnats"... But perhaps that's just me.

If you want to return the favour please review my short text that 's currently up for review -
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1427777 by Not Available.
- be my guest to have a good laugh at my expense, it's something else than your blog entirely. But it takes all kinds of writers doesn't it?

Good luck with your blog and thanks for sharing
112
112
Review by Nok2
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi,

Have just returned to the site, still consider myself a newbie at writing and reviewing. So please take anything I say as suggestions for consideration, not as gospel truth. While I mean to be helpful obviously you as the author know best. So here goes:

Review of "The All-Kingdoms War, prologue pts 1 & 2"

Good book title.

Prologue Part 1
Nice job with the setting at the beginning, I can really picture the landscape. Excellent job of introducing Aldemar's amour by giving him a reason to think about it. The introduction of Greven is good but feels a bit like infodump? Can you intersperse perhaps a little with dialogue? Nice work in general with the first scene - establishing the fantasy genre, introducing the characters and their goals, and ending with suspense.
Reading on...

Prologue Part 2
Cellestina's dream is a good way to introduce her backstory but I'd keep some of it perhaps for later... Great names for the 5 dragons. Cellestina's goal is well established.
Overall I really enjoyed this - your clearly vast knowledge of this world gives the story tremendous depth and creates a fantastic sense of magical realism..

The only thing I wonder about is why the two prologues instead of one? But perhaps that will become clear as we read on...

Minor points:
"the glint of sunlight off of metal" - better perhaps "the glint of sunlight off metal" or "reflecting off metal"?
"if they kept hunched down" - why not introduce here what the Draconians look like eg "if they kept their ugly, scaly, 9 foot high forms hunched down"? just a thought...
"The man took Aldemar under his wing almost a year before, sparing the boy from a life as a filthy rogue on the streets of the dusty border town of Tusk. Since that day, Greven has honed..." - in my view the tense should be "had taken ... had honed..." etc - applies generally - I won't comment on it every time. Perhaps an RPG convention? I'd change it for a novel, though...
"He spoke, "All the supplies are in order. ..." - I don't think you need the speech tag here
"consideres" - should be "considers"
"a slight that would deaden relations between" - perhaps better "...destroy relations between..."?
"He heard the Kingfisher, a very distinct bird call." - Gotcha, that's ‘telling'. Show us instead, please?
"thumbing the Draconians into submission" - "thumbing"? Just checking...
"It's calls" - should be "its"
"There was a few more, enough to confirm his suspicions, but it discontinued" - decide on plural or singular and keep to it, would be my feeling
"caravan wagon" - one space too many
"in he past" - should be "in the past"
"to pompus" - "too pompous"
"Her and her followers were coming to terms" - better "she and her followers..."?
"downtrodden faces" - doesn't work for me, I'm afraid. Perhaps better "faces of downtrodden people"
" of potent magical" - one space too many
"Beyond that, the Trackless Oceans; endless miles of open sea." I'd prefer a "-" instead of semi-colon
Keep up the good work!

PS if you want to return the favor two of my pieces are currently up for review
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1418645 by Not Available.
and "Invalid Item, but no pressure :)
112 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 5 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ninotchka2/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/5