*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ninotchka2/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
574 Public Reviews Given
694 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Impulsive, honest. Trying to be helpful.
I'm good at...
Spotting 'telling', typos, superfluous adverbs, cliches, verbosity; I'm really good at re-writing, creating examples of how to fix things, especially how to get deeper into the character and how to provide a fuller sensory experience
Favorite Genres
Flash fiction, slice of life, literary, anime, fantasy, young adult, mystery, horror
Least Favorite Genres
Spiritual, Romance
Favorite Item Types
Statics
Least Favorite Item Types
Interactive Items. Images.
I will not review...
Pornography, anything involving cruelty to animals. Items of people who do not return reviews.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 5 ... Next
51
51
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Review: Ch 1 The Dream, by Sierra

Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line, and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.
So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: The Dream

Chapter: 1

Author: Sierra

Plot: You succeed well to establish the plot right away with this first chapter. War is looming and a prophesy of the seer Elizabeth tells of a woman. Now Alex, a vampire, has had a dream about her. He sends for his grandson Damien and tells him to find the dwarf Doc to locate this woman, of whom, luckily, the evil Andreas is as yet unaware. Once Damien has found her, Alex' faline wife Anita will train her in witchcraft. There's only one snag--Anita reveals her powers are weakening.

Referencing: The references established clearly that this is a fantasy world (vampires, witches, dwarves, the place names) with fairly modern technology (phone, microwave)

Style & Voice:
Your style is appropriate for your genre, the use of abbreviations and contractions in directly reported speech (I'm, it's etc.) underlines the modernity. The writing flows and is easy and pleasant to read. It is pretty 'clean', has clearly been revised and edited carefully.
There was one recurrent mistake though: Only speech tags that are synonyms of "say" take a comma, Example: "...If Andreas gets to her first we may be doomedcomma” Alex stated grimly. Otherwise the sentence ends, because you can only say/speak words. Example: “Grandfatherexclamation mark” Damien cleared his throat.
Overall, I had only few comments or suggestion, see below

Setting: I liked the setting with its strange birds and flowers, and you used not only sight but also sound (bird song) and smell (coffee, rain) to good effect

Characterization: The characters and their (to us) alien features were well introduced. Exceptionally good the gorgeous woman's appearance in the visionary dream. A question mark remained for me regarding what age Damien appears to be, boy or man? And is he the grandson of Alex or was he a vampire fledgling who's been adopted by the couple?

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: A good first chapter. I'm guessing there will now follow Damien's quest to find this woman, letting us experience some areas of your world. I'm looking forward to reading more of your novel.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

IN-LINE REVIEW

CHAPTER 1 THE DREAM


After eighty years of? the war of Montula, residents of the land knew the newly forged? peace would not last forever. All had heard of the prophecy whether from Elizabeth herself at the ball or from their parents and grandparents. It was apparent another war was coming in time. For now however everybody was happy.

In the small village of Elmgate, Spraymints, magnificent birds of blue and orange, stretched their wings inviting the morning sun. A lone crainhorn sang a song of eternal bliss. Smoke could be seen as it billowed from red-brick chimneys of a hundred and fifty log cabins. Ranchester bushes held magnificent blooms of all colors. A noak tree stood in front of the cabin at 4255 Maple Avenue. Its gigantic limbs hung over the driveway as if it stood guard of over the home.

Inside the cabin Alex lay next to his wife of a hundred years. “Anita my darling.” He laid a hand on her shoulder.

“What is it honey?” Anita switched on the bedside lamp. Due to a chill in the morning air she pulled their floral down comforter over her chest.

“We are going to need some coffee. We’ve a long day ahead of us.” His voice sounded rough with sleep.

“Yes dear.” Anita threw on her purple cotton robe and headed for the kitchen.

Alex dialed the phone on his night stand. He knew what had to happen know now, the only problem was he didn’t know how to tell everyone else. After the vision he just had everyone feels repetitive had to be put on full alert. Andreas would be back soon, and a lot needed to be done in preparation for what was to come.

“Hello,” a sleepy voice answered.

“Damien, it’s your grandfather, I need you to come over right away. We have an important matter to discuss.” Alex stood and stretched the sleep out of his muscles.

“Grandfather,exclamation mark” Damien cleared his throat. “What time is it?”

“It’s five o’clock in the morning; I want you here in no more than twenty minutes. I wouldn’t ask this of you if I had any other choice, however I need you now.” He hung up.

Alex stood in the doorway of their kitchen and watched as his wife made coffee. She was the most beautiful creature he had ever laid eyes on. Her once long blonde hair had turned silver over the years, her smooth pale skin was now wrinkled with age. The only thing about her looks that hadn’t changed was her mint-green eyes. They still made his legs turn to jelly when she looked at him. Age had not taken away from her beauty, it just increased the love he felt for his witch.

“Alex, what are you staring at?” Anita gave him a shy grin. It amazed her that just a look could still make her giddy as a school girl.

“I’m just watching the sexiest, most stunning faline that ever existed.” He wrapped his arms around her thin frame.

“Oh, Alex.” Her blush went to the bone literally?. “You always know just what to say.”

“Please, prepare a place for Damien; he shall be joining us in about ten minutes.” He released her, and sat at the oval table. He dreaded the look on her face when he told them the news about Andreas and his followers.
superfluous empty line here in my view?

“Damien? He never gets out of bed before seven in the morning. What’s going on Alex?” Her angelic voice held a hint of concern.

“I’ll tell you everything after Damien arrives. I’d rather explain it to both of you at once. Trust me, it won’t be long.” Alex kissed his wife. “After I enlighten you as to what’s going on, I need to call the rest of the Watchers, and have everyone put on full alert.”

“This has to do with Elizabeth doesn’t it?” Anita looked up at her husband, his face wrinkled with age, eyes gray and full of knowledge. He was six foot three, a little tall for 170 years old, but normal for a vampire. His ghostly do you mean ghostly white? skin still held a sparkle in the light. She wrapped her arms around her vampires’ vampire's neck, and pulled his mouth to hers for deeper a deep kiss. It was obvious she had guessed right. They heard a knock at the back door.

“That must be Damien,” Anita said pulling herself from the whirlwind of thoughts the kiss had brought her.

“Good morning,period” Damien‘s tall muscular frame entered the kitchen. “How are you this morning, Grandmother?” He kissed her cheek.

Anita watched as her grandson made his way to the kitchen table. Still as handsome as ever, long black hair pulled into a neat little ponytail at the nape of his neck. The dimples when he smiled made him look angelic and innocent. His eyes were ice blue, his skin held the same ethereal sparkle as his grandfatherapostrophes. ‘Someday this man is going to catch the eye of a worthy woman,’ she thought to herself.

“I’m fine sweetie, please sit down. The coffee is almost ready, I have breakfast started. Would you like some?” She gave a quick smile and turned toward the stove.

“That’s what smells so good. Of course, I would love some of your home cooked breakfast. Microwaves can’t cook the way you can.” His deep laugh echoed through the house, as he pulled out the chair across from his grandfather. “What is so urgent Grandfather?”

“I am sorry to have troubled you so early. Alas, time is of the essence.” His tone was serious.

“I have many talents, however mind reading is not one of them, semi-colon, hyphen or period tell me what could have you so upset.” Damien knew his grandfather well. He also knew that Alex wouldn’t disturb anyone without good reason.

“Alex, we have been patient long enough.” Anita placed the coffee tray on the oak table. “Why don’t you tell us what happenedquestion mark.”

“Last night I had a dream,period” Alex put his hands together as if in prayer. “The dream started off in the middle of Witch Lake, I was flying over the green-blue water headed for a brilliant white house. It had a wrap-around porch, and on that porch sat a luxurious woman with hair the color of fire. Her eyes looked like emeralds shining in the sunlight, her skin;no semi-colon here pale as a ghost. As I came upon her the scene changed, from her sitting there alone, to her being in the middle of a forest filled with enormous red-green leaves from the Blogg Bone trees. Surrounded by werewolves, goblins, and demons, her entire being was lit up with the violet rays of her power. As I woke I heard her speak,” he ended solemnly.

“So what does it mean?” Damien was not around when Elizabeth the great seer had foretold of this moment.

“It means my dear grandson that the time of the prophecy is upon us. It also means that I have to ask you to take on a very difficult and dangerous task.” Alex stood with coffee in hand.

“Why? Why must it be Damien,question mark” Anita turned with a look of terror in her eyes. She gripped her pink apron in an effort to stop the faint crystal-blue light of power from getting brighter.

“Because my sweet Anita, as I woke I heard this woman call out to Damien Duates. Is it not a sign, that he should be the one to find her?” He smiled at his wife.

"I owe my life to both of you, so I shall do as you ask. Where can I find her?" Damien couldn't help the memories that flooded his mind. The strange man who attacked him and left him for dead, Alex finding him lost and alone in the forest, only to bring him back to this wonderful cabin and help him with the transformation. It was a long and painful process, but with the assistance of these two exceptional people he was able to make it through without taking any innocent lives.

“I know I was on Witch Lake in my dream, for that reason I would assume she lives in Serenity. It’s a small town discovered by a dwarf named Doc. Find him and ask if he knows of any woman that fits the description I gave you.” Alex gave Damien’s shoulder a quick squeeze. “I know I haven‘t given you much to go on, but I‘ve complete confidence you will succeed.”

“I’ll do everything in my power to find her, but how will I know when I have?"

“The feeling of truth will hit you like a ton of bricks. You will have a strange need to protect the woman. She is the faline whom the prophecy speaks of. If Andreas gets to her first we may be doomed.comma” Alex stated grimly. “So far we are in luck; he and his followers know nothing of the girl.”

Anita watched the two men in her life as she set the table for breakfast. She knew Alex would want her to train the woman in witchcraft, but her powers were weakening. She would do everything she needed to do, however she would have to tell these two men what was going to happen before it was too late. She crossed over to the kitchen window.

“Alex dear,” She opened the window only to have a gentle breeze make the delicate lace curtains dance in the window. “Am I right to assume that you want me to train this woman?” The smell of rain drifted in, a storm had started to develop in the west.

“I wouldn’t ask anyone else. You are the best faline I know.” He beamed a brilliant white smile at her, only to realize she was preoccupied with a thought of her own.

“I need to tell you both something important.” She watched as the storm came closer, unable to look at them as she continued. “We have another issue at hand. I wanted to wait a while longer before I told you, but…” she stopped herself. “My powers are weakening.” A single tear ran down her cheek as the rain began to fall. lovely last sentence
52
52
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Overcoming The Odds Type: a poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: someone special

This is a short biographical poem in five stanzas, all of which have four lines each.

The rhymes follow the pattern abab. All good rhymes, best read aloud as some of the rhymes work only when read with the right accent e.g. romance / dance.

Some wonderfully poetic phrases, like for instance chalice of kindness.

Once again--well done! Another heartfelt poem about life and love.

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
53
53
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: A sense of Hope..., Type: another poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: bowling

This is a poem in four stanzas, all of which have four lines each. The rhymes follow the pattern aabb. All good rhymes, if I am any judge, only I confess to having some doubt whether men/again really works? But once again read with the right accent it does work. Other than that once again--well done!

Another quirky poem about bowling and the life lessons it can teach us. Very enjoyable!

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
54
54
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Not so boring that I'm snoring, Type: another poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: sport

This is a poem in seven stanzas, all of which have four lines each. The rhymes follow the pattern aabb. All good rhymes, if I am any judge; I am a bit doubtful about learn/yearn but I think it passes muster if spoken with the right accent,; once again some of your rhymes strike me as truly inspired, such as for instance tries/disguise--well done!

Another quirky poem about sports as a mataphor for life. Very enjoyable! Not boring at all :)

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
55
55
Review of Now That’s All  
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Now that's all, Type: another poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: ...just life, I guess :).
A poem in three stanzas, all of which have eight lines each. The rhymes follow the pattern ababcdcd. All good rhymes, if I am any judge; some of your rhymes strike me as truly inspired, such as for instance the awesome kitchen//bitchin'--well done!

Another quirky poem but with at the same time a slightly melancholy feel to it. Good work!

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
56
56
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Bowling, never want to strike a lot, Type: another poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: as the title suggests: Bowling.

A poem in four stanzas, all of which have six lines each. The rhymes follow the pattern aabbcc. All good rhymes, and some really interesting like e.g. lesson / worsen--well done!

From the title I was prepared for something light and quirky. And I was not disappointed. Though as a 'lay-person' I didn't 'get' all of the references, there was enough wit and wisdom from life experience shared for me to enjoy reading this poem.

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
57
57
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Love's in my soul, Type: a free-form poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: love.

A poem in two stanzas, of 13 lines each.

I had to read this several times. I half expected a conventional love poem and, I guess, half of me expected a devotional prayer to God. Interestingly I'm left with a feeling as though I'd read both.

This is a truly spiritual love poem about a bond that probably many good marriages share but few people are blessed with the gift of poetry to express.

A very moving poem, which (like many poems) works best when read aloud. I'm definitely reading more of your poetry! Thanks for sharing.

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
58
58
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with WDC Frontliners Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: The Daredevil Lady and the Watchdog Man, Type: a poem, by Author: Tim Chiu , a work about Subject: a couple's (not lovers) adventures.

This poem has 9 stanzas, all 4-liners. The rhyme-scheme follows throughout the pattern aabb, all good rhymes in my view.

The title was intriguing, the characters Lizzy and Brad well drawn and engaging. The 'story' ended with a surprising twist, well done! The quirky style reminded me of Limericks (not meant as a criticism--just an observation).

Thanks for this, I enjoyed reading your poem.

Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
59
59
Review of The Bitter Rose  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

So here goes:

Title: The Bitter Rose; a Type: Poem, by Author: Brian Chase

This very short poem consists of 4 stanzas. Each of these stanzas has 4 lines. The rhyme follows throughout the scheme aabb and all the rhymes work well in my view.

Both rhythm and rhyme flow beautifully. Congratulations for not violating either grammar or sentence structure. The only tiny flaw I could find is flowr’, which in order to be short for flower i.e. the rose of the title should be flowr.

Beautiful language, reminiscent of... perhaps John Donne? (just a hunch, I really don’t know my way around poetry that well)

Just My Personal Opinion: Beautiful title, lovely, lovely poem.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok
60
60
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: With these loving hands, Type: another biographical free form poem, by Author: C.E. Thieroff, a work about Subject: prayer to be of service

This free form poem consists of 8 stanzas with 4 lines each. For once they're not presented tightly packed but oddly spread out, which--at least for me--made reading somewhat more difficult. I also wondered about the extra space dividing the last two stanzas from the rest.

The rhyme scheme appears to be abcb. The rhymes are all good.

Small gripes:

The line To take quiet moment and pray is grammatically wrong, it would have to be "a quiet moment"; for the sake of syllable-count and rhythm, how about: "To take quiet moments and pray"?

"someway"--two words?

A truly heartfelt prayer.


Keep on writing!
Love

Nok
61
61
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line, and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: Poetic Torch Scorches NEO-Tyranny Agenda

Type: Poem, which aims according to the by-line at Deconstructing the fascist trajectory of our NeoDem-RepubliCon dilema one rhyme at a time! Note: should be dilemma I believe

Author: Armadillo

Referencing: Lots of present day references, not sure whether all of them would be understood outside the US and perhaps even outside certain groupings

Style & Voice:

7 stanzas plus an image.

This is quite a visual work. There is apart from the image some use of strike-through, caps, bold type and italics, as well as the replacement of S in some words with a dollar sign—all devices that you wouldn’t be able to hear in a reading. This tendency to visual messages made me wonder whether the text shape was meant to convey a message but if so I didn't get it.

The rhyme scheme varies. The first stanza follows the scheme aa etc. for 8 lines, the second stanza attempts this feat for 14 (!) lines, and most of the rhymes work except this one Seers which is pronounced differently though it looks as though it might rhyme with say jeers. In the third stanza the scheme changes to aabb, but eyes and despise doesn’t quite work either. All the other rhymes work (with some good will of the reader).

I won’t comment on the content, but I'll say that as a political opinionated piece it's pretty cleverly done. Having said that I think the image might be considered offensive by some and it doesn't really add anything to the poem.

Just My Personal Opinion: In my view the rating should at least be 18+. As a poem a good effort.

Keep on writing!

Nok
62
62
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Mouthing the Words, Type: Lyrics, by Author: Glavin V. Thryash, a work about Subject: heartache

Seven stanzas (mostly 4-liners), of varying rhyme-scheme. Some rhymes were quite clever in my humble opinion e.g. this one notice / useless and this: words / worse . Stanzas 3 and 6 are identical (they contain the title line) but as the song unfolds they have different impact. The last stanza with 3 lines drives the point home so to speak, and is absolutely beautiful. I had just one question--why is "Mine" capitalized?

I enjoyed reading this, very musical!

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok
63
63
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: A tight knit family

Type: Short story

Author: Darlene Spanel

Plot: John brings his new wife Margot home to his family. They don't get on but there's a surprisingly happy end with a twist.

Referencing: no problems that I could see

Style & Voice: Good and easy to read. It is somewhat unusual these days to read something where the Point-of-View constantly shifts, even within paragraphs, but you did it well, so it felt natural. I noticed some repetitions in the same sentence, e.g. John was incredibly nervous while Margot was incredibly self-assured. [my emphasis] but they were not too frequent and used to good effect. A formal point: I think directly reported thought should be in quotes or italics e.g. this passage They don’t even have to like her, just accept her. Otherwise I had only minor comments regarding typos and the like, see in-line review below.

Setting: You set the mood and setting nicely in the opening sentence and added later brush-strokes to the picture, good job! I liked that you used the season (autumn) to enhance the feeling of foreboding, something ending...Lovely the family's traditional home, I could really imagine it.

Characterization: for a short story you did an outstanding job at characterisation, both character 'voices' and outward appearances. The shifting POV was well-used as it enabled us to see characters through another character's eyes. Best example in my view is this observation by Margot of her in-laws: She never thought she’d be related to a man that wore overalls and a woman that wears appliquéd sweaters.[I'm in awe--how did you manage to create the accent aigu on Writing.com? I can't do that?]

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: Already the first sentence drew me right in with a life-changing event. Good foreshadowing in the first paragraph of conflict between the newly-weds and Margot and his family. Good escalation of events and a nice twist at the end. I enjoyed reading this.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

In-Line comments

...to his parent’s house --should that be plural parents'?
...He just realized how she never asked him for anything, perhaps better semi-colon or period? she told him.
...and checked her hair--perhaps give us here her hair color?
...Tears of joy streamed down their faces; they were overjoyed to see one another. --can you avoid the repetiton of "joy" here? perhaps "happy", "delighted"?
...and sheet sheer hatred...
...This woman was not what who she had planned for envisaged as her daughter-in-law.
...than with others' feelings
...onto it’s back --its
...and saying goodbye like any no paragraph break here
64
64
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
And another review for you :)

Again, before I start reviewing, the usual cautions apply: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

Title: Memories of Christmas Past

Author: J. A. Buxton

Plot: Good opening and build-up of suspense, after the best and the worst Christmas, what can be so specially memorable about another Christmas? Once again a nice twist at the end

Referencing: no problems that I could see

Style & Voice: A quick, easy read, I have only one minor comment, namely that the numbers one to (I think) twenty are normally spelled out?

Setting: Good job, I could imagine the layout of the rooms very well, the fireplace, the tree...good sensual detail too.

Characterization: the action centres on the I-narrator, I liked the juxtaposition of the child's thoughts and feelings then and the narrator's grown-up perspective now as she remembers the events of her childhood

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: After reading your thanksgiving story I enjoyed your Christmas offering too, it took me right back to my own childhood Christmases expecially the beautiful passage about decorating the tree. Thanks for sharing

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok
65
65
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line, and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: The Year My Boss Gave Me The Bird, a short story written based on the Prompt to 'write a story where Thanksgiving is the setting, but the story isn’t just about the characters being thankful'

Author: J. A. Buxton

Plot: nice drama with final catastrophe and a twist at the end, well done

Referencing: no problems that I could see, only I wondered whether Swanson’s should be marked as a registered trade mark? not sure, but perhaps better err on the side of caution

Style & Voice: a nice, easy read, and a very clean text, I didn't find any typos to moan about

Setting: not much, but it's not necessary in my view, and it is after all a very short story (only 700+ words)

Characterization: The I-narrator Judith, her mother and even the boss came to life by the dialogue and their actions; there wasn't much about their appearances but again I think for short stories other rules apply

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: I enjoyed reading this funny story, being cooking-skill-challenged myself :)

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok
66
66
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with Novel Review Group  
Rated: E | N/A (Review only item.)
Review: The Dome, Prologue, by Wrath of Kkan

Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line, and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.


So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: The Dome

Chapter: Prologue

Author: Wrath of Khan

Plot: Uh--nothing much happened? a couple driving on a highway in Kansas...

Referencing: no problems that I could see, the mention of "Red Bull" might constitute a problem later (also I think you need to put "TM" next to the brand name)

Style & Voice: impressive command of language and nice job on the setting; I've been told that only when using dialogue tags containing synonyms of "say" and its forms there's a comma, e.g. "Hey," she said. But "Hey." She laughed. Some other minor comments see in-line review below

Setting: I liked how the opening sentences conveyed the mood and landscape, and the car "heading toward the rising moon" was just beautiful!

Characterization: Good description of the characters' appearance and behavior

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: Not sure whether this functions as a prologue? I always thought a prologue supplies a context or a hook? not sure...But I'll read on.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

IN-LINE COMMENTS
...A car softly hummed along the otherwise empty single-lane highway, ...

Her piercing blue eyes met his does he also have piercing blue eyes?

“Huh huh.” Do you mean "Uh-huh"=yes? Huh-huh means no I believe

“You know, I doubt this road is well traveled,period instead of comma” she put the can down...
67
67
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi.

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am no poet and still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

This poem consists of ten short stanzas conveying very deep and profound thoughts. I'm not sure I got it all, despite reading the poem several times. Each reading revealed new angles and layers of meaning. Here's my rather crude summary of what struck me most.

'Fire' takes on a variety of meanings, fire outside (stars? the whole cosmos?) is contrasted with fire inside (words and thoughts? self, the microcosmos?). Looking at (contemplating) the outer world can motivate to turn inwards (to work towards self knowledge?), and reflection on the inner world can motivate to turn outwards (to action?).

There seems to be some Buddhist thought, e.g. the stars circle 'nothingness', and the use of the term 'loving kindness' as well as the feeling that the wish to be forever again and again is misdirected (?); also the claim that inside and outside are not really opposites.

With the idea of Buddhism to guide me I interpret the 'fire of now' as the Zen-moment and the 'sudden death' as the death of self, however I am uncertain as to the meaning of the stage 'fire of love' as earlier (subordinate? inferior?) to the 'fire of now'...desire? not sure.

Just My Personal Opinion: Certainly a deep poem that rewards careful reading, thanks for sharing

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok
68
68
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

I'v'e reviewed and rated it before, but could not resist to read it again and cannot resist to send you a couple of additional observations:

The case against which you argue "You say 'God' exists. Yet to date not one shred of scientific evidence proves your claim. If God is present everywhere - as you say - then science ought to be able to find some evidence of Him." is arguably not the strongest one. Why would the 'scientist' put himself in a position to argue for proof of a negative by exclusion of all available evidence i.e. all that exists? God could after all be a very 'rare phenomenon' or like radiation difficult to observe until technology evolves.

But I'll not go into that, because I can finally lay my finger on what bothers me about the whole thing:

The failure to define what "God" and "to exist" and "nature" and "supernature" mean in the theist's position which I understand for your argument to be "God is (=exists) everywhere (=in nature and supernature)"

Formally that are 2 claims "G exists in N" and "G exists in S-N"
The scientist could argue only about the first i.e. "G exists in N"

Now there are logically 2 possibilities
1) G in N is in principle scientifically observable/demonstrable (we just haven't managed it yet)
2) G in N is in principle scientifically NOT observable/demonstrable

1) leads to the concession that it's possible that G is in N until such time as science covers all of existence; however it raises the question how meaningful such a rare or subtle phenomenon can be and what interaction if any it has with our lives

#2) according to my gutfeeling will lead to a contradiction with any definition for "is" and "N" and "G" you care to plug into the sentence.

In both cases you get an objectively irrelevant God, because of extremely limited physical interaction. That leaves the believer by all means with an idea, a concept or ideology he can hold dear etc. but the scientist can safely 'bet' that God is either non-existent in N, or irrelevant, or so utterly different (eg if you equate say BigBang with God) that he does not fit the theist's definition (e.g. of God as thinking, moral, caring etc)

I did not entirely follow the attack on logic itself, I think you're falling into the Cartesian trap of thinking you're perhaps 'deceived', but I think you'll find that, too, is caused by using undefined and vague terms. As a kid I used to play a game "all is egoism" of which the no free will claim reminds me. After exhausting everyone you come round to one fact: we perceive in a certain way and act a certain way, we cannot act as though we were a brain in a vat, we cannot act as though we had not got free will AND function in society/the world. Whether true or not it wouldn't be the adequate response. Example: Say you're playing a character in a play. What help is it to consider that you are in another existence a human who might act differently? Zilch, right?

Finally this sentence is dubious "...thinking itself is one of the least natural things you can do. It is a connection point with something beyond Nature"
a) by definition everything occurring within nature is natural
b) even if you employ a more narrow definition of "nature" it is most definitely man's nature to think, he is a 'thinking animal'

In summary I think you're still fighting a weaker than possible strawman and use vague and undefined terms. But full marks for trying so hard, I enjoyed putting my (slightly dusty) thinking cap on again
Keep going!
Hope that helps a bit
love

Nok
69
69
Review by Nok2
In affiliation with Novel Review Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Review: City of Sin, Ch 6, by Fallen for Grace

Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text and comment as I read line by line (see specific comments below), and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:


GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: City of Sin

Chapter: 6 The Place d’Armes

Author: Fallen for Grace

Plot: Going to see their sister’s newborn baby, Crystal and her sisters in their coach get stuck in traffic. Dawn talks them into walking the short distance. Excitedly they make a short detour to the Place d’Armes. There Crystal sees the man on the belltower. Next a vodoo practioner prophesies difficult times ahead for Crystal and gives her a broken compass that will help her choose.

Referencing: no problems that I could see

Style & Voice: good, but some long sentences and typos, see in-line review

Setting: excellent the street, market, church, sister’s house

Characterization: all acting in character as far as I could tell, the creepy old woman was fabulous

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: Good chapter, good build-up of suspense

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

FINALLY: (A) Specific comments see in line review posted on the Forum
70
70
Review of Why I Write  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi,

the title of your article really stood out. With so many people on this website, most of them writers, it's really interesting to me to see what makes them write.

After reading your article I feel that you certainly have put forward your argument very clearly and concisely. I was very surprised to read you want to put Brecht's ideas on theatre into literature. It's how shall I say--quite high-minded and ambitious, kudos to you.

I liked especially that you really addressed possible counter-arguments e.g. replied to the arguments of past reviewers.

I think there's always a divide between cerebral writers and those who write emotionally, instinctively. Definitely over the ages fashion in writing seems to favor sometimes the one, and sometimes the other. I'm not sure whether it can be definitively decided which is 'better', but you've made a very good case for your style.

Thanks for a thought-provoking read
love

Nok
71
71
Review of Weird Book-Buying  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi,

I read your interesting and thought-provoking article with great interest. I started thinking about the problem. Why DOES the original edition keep on selling more? You don't say what the covers look like. Perhaps that makes me shallow but between books it's really sometimes the cover that informs my choice (I've never chosen between 2 editions, though). Also perhaps there' s more advertising and promotion and hype surrounding the first edtion? Perhaps bookstores ordered the original edition, so there's more of that available on their shelves?

Thanks for an interesting read
love

Nok
72
72
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hmm,

it's difficult to review this without getting into the subject matter of your article. Kudos to you for grappling with a problem that many have struggled with (and to my knowledge no one has ever managed to deal with successfully).

From a purely stylistic point of view I thought your prose quite difficult to follow, some very long sentences especially.

From an argumentative point of view I don't think you give the counterposition(s) of the atheist and the agnostic (to say nothing about people who believe in different god/s) the 'best shot' you possibly can. It sounds a bit as though you're preaching to the choir of those that already share your beliefs.

From a philosophical point of view the big formal flaw I can see immediately is that you fail to define "existence" (and "supernatural", and "God", and "nature" etc etc)

You have statements there that are unproven and quite disputable. One random example :"thinking itself is one of the least natural things you can do." If you come from the scientific viewpoint that statement is absurd -- everything occurring in nature is per definition natural.

In my view you argue for a mix between the remote God (who does not or not anymore interact with physical reality) and the god as a gap-stopper (god as the ever-receding explanation for the things science cannot explain yet).

Now in the first case your requirement for proof is so 'soft' that your argument can equally be used to prove the existence of shapeshifting reptilians and the easterbunny, Brahma and the Christian God, Allah, and any other 'supernatural' entity you like. You 'win' the argument formally, because you made sure that it's non-falsifiable but the result is meaningless.

In the 2nd case you have to defer to such a time when science stops the gap--and you're free to believe that won't happen, but then you're back to square 1 i.e. belief without /in the absence of scientific proof.

Nice try though
keep writing!
love

Nok

73
73
Review by Nok2
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Hi,

I absolutely loved this. I don't know whether it's your natural style or whether you wrote like that specifically for this scene, but it's the perfect 'voice' for a dream. A haunting and unpleasant dream with that feeling of strangeness and yet acceptance of the weirdest things happening, like flesh shattering, and a human (?) transforming into an animal. Your descriptions of the old ladies and child and animal were excellent. And you're the first person I've read that does not only use second person point of view (!) but actually pull it off.

What a great start to a novel.
Keep on writing!
Love
Nok
74
74
Review of A Leap of Faith  
Review by Nok2
Rated: E | (4.5)
Review: Reaching up to find courage, by Redtowrite

Hi,

Before I start reviewing the usual cautions: I am still relatively new at writing and reviewing, and unpublished. So bear in mind that while my comments are helpfully meant, they are in the end only suggestions for your consideration. Feel free to ignore them as you wish –the author normally knows best.

How I review-I first read the text, and once I’ve read the whole I write down my general impression on the categories plot, character etc. under general comments.

So here goes:

GENERAL COMMENTS


Title: Reaching up to find courage good title

Author: Redtowrite

Plot: Warning plot spoiler Beth suffers from anxiety attacks and the other kids tease her about it, especially at sports. A counselor gets her a job at the library which she loves. She tutors kids and has her first crush. In high school she makes a friend in Kim, and then Lisa and Dwayne join the group. They all love to write. Two of Beth's stories get published. Beth puts her life in danger as she helps arrest meth-dealers. Her story about it wins her an award and a scholarship. She graduates with honors and wants to study journalism. She meets the love of her life, Tony, and his grandmother. Tony and Beth's lovemaking results in a pregnancy. When Beth forces herself to hike in the mountains despite her fear Tony proposes. They marry. Beth wants to study as long as possible, Tony takes a job as a firefighter. Trying to save lifes in a fire Tony is trapped and injured by a collapsing wall and dies. Beth scatters his ashes in the place where Tony proposed to her. She moves in with his grandmother, together they will raise Tony's son.

Referencing: isn't that Oliver Sacks?

Style & Voice: good, easy to read, I hardly found any typos. The only thing perhaps to watch is that the Point of View wavered a bit, from Beth as was to perhaps a grown up Beth commenting in retrospect or even omniscient

Setting: nice and clear, enough for the chapter in my view

Characterization: good work introducing Beth, except I couldn't 'see' what she looks like--good character 'voice' though; the descriptions of her first love and her true love and grandmom were nicely done

Grammar: no problems that I could see (but it’s admittedly not one of my strengths)

Just My Personal Opinion: your story is clearly heartfelt; one cannot but feel for your main character as she despite her anxiety attacks bravely faces many threatening situations, 'reaching up to find courage', as the title says. Inspiring.

Keep on writing!
Love
Nok

...two of her best stories away
...Usually there is an off duty cop
75
75
Review by Nok2
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi,

sorry for reviewing sort of backwards, but I didn't realize part 1 is up for review too.

It's very good, very promising. The character voices especially are brilliant. The only two complaints I have concern the following:

If you could find a way to give us the basics of Jai's appearance that would be great.

Plotwise too little happens...show us at least what difficulty the character faces already in his life and/or at the end of the train journey?

Great story
Keep writing!

love

Nok
112 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 5 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/ninotchka2/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3