*Magnify*
    May    
2020
SMTWTFS
     
13
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Archive RSS
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/books/item_id/2181458-Are-You-Listening/day/5-9-2020
Rated: GC · Book · Emotional · #2181458
A journey of self-improvement - or not.
Sup? I'm Char.
You may know me from timeless classics such as
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#2030442 by Not Available.

and
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1974611 by Not Available.


I blog for things like
 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#2146101 by Not Available.

FORUM
30-Day Blogging Challenge ON HIATUS  (13+)
WDC's Longest Running Blog Competition - Hiatus
#1786069 by Fivesixer

FORUM
JAFBG  (XGC)
Because real life isn't always roses and sunshine...
#2094931 by Elisa the Bunny Stik



[Embed For Use By Upgraded+]
Believin' all the lies that they're tellin' ya
Buyin' all the products that they're sellin' ya
They say jump and ya say "how high?"
Ya braindead, ya got a fuckin' bullet in ya head


May 9, 2020 at 12:04am
May 9, 2020 at 12:04am
#983118
Artist: Joy Division
Song: Disorder
[Embed For Use By Upgraded+]


"30-Day Blogging Challenge ON HIATUS Prompt: Choose an event in your life that someone else remembers differently. Describe both memories and debate the differences. Who do you think is right? Why do you think you remember it differently?


So, here's something that happened.

Once upon a time several years ago, my older brother met his now wife. After they were dating a while, he came to me and said, "I really like this girl. I want to introduce her to the family, but I do not, under any circumstance, want her to know anything negative about our childhood. I've made peace with things. I want her to like our parents and be comfortable having her children around them if we end up having children. So, please, please, if you love me at all, don't mention anything bad that happened."

Well, what can you say?

I told him I think this is a very bad idea. I think it's normal to have some negativity in your childhood, and if it ever comes out, she's going to feel like you took away her right to form realistic opinions and then make rational choices based on those opinions.

But still, he said that if he was ever ready to talk about anything related to that, he would share it with her at his own pace. Of course, I agreed to this thinking that it's not my place to tell someone else's story. And also thinking that he would at some point become more comfortable with the relationship.

Well, let me tell you, it has been years now. Married, kids, everything. Not a single negative word about our parents. It's an admirable effort, but it creates some issues.

For example, it's actually very difficult to NEVER mention anything that could be deemed negative. It's not like I met her and said, "Hi, I'm Charlie, so I'll start with some of the lighter trauma as an appetizer before we really dig deep." Of course not. I have also made a valiant effort. But here's an example of how difficult this can be.

Last year we had dinner at my brother's house. I was thanking my sister-in-law for making all the vegetables as we were sitting down to eat because I really love them. She then told me about how her parents made her and her siblings choose 3 vegetables that they'd be willing to eat as a kid and then they'd have one of those vegetables with dinner each night. She hated cauliflower, but loved carrots, so that was often her vegetable with dinner.

She then asked me if my parents were strict about having us eat vegetables, and the truth just poured out naturally. I told here that yeah, my parents were strict with pretty much any food they served. You just took what you got or you'd be staring at it until bedtime.

I didn't mean for this to sound abusive or traumatic in any way. It isn't a gripe I have with my parents. But she said, "Aw, Charlie, you had to eat it even if you didn't like it?"

My brother was sitting across from me at the table, and this was his exact face:
ಠ_ಠ

He quickly said, "No, if you really didn't want it, they would make us something else."

Now, this could not be further from the truth. But I looked at him and he was looking at me like:
ಠ_ಠ

So then I said, "Of course, if you really didn't want it you could just have something else."

The point of my story is that sometimes people believe alternative versions of memories. Whether it's to protect themselves or to protect others, for better or for worse. There have been a few small instances over the years, but what really got me was when my brother and I were alone and he pulled a similar stunt. He kept correcting me on a memory I had to the extent that I went and asked other family members if I was misremembering.

I think he has pushed this shit so far down inside for years that even he is starting to believe his alternative history. I think he started doing it so his girlfriend wouldn't hate his parents when she met them. But I think it has morphed. I think the alternative version is better. It feels better to "remember" it. He so badly wants to move on that he pretends there's nothing to move on from.

That's where memories are finicky. Who's technically right? Probably the person who is remembering accurately. But people do what they need to do to move on in their own way, and it's difficult to call that wrong.

Who is right, who can tell,
And who gives a damn right now


© Copyright 2023 Charlie ~ (UN: charlieabney at Writing.Com). All rights reserved.
Charlie ~ has granted Writing.Com, its affiliates and its syndicates non-exclusive rights to display this work.

Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/books/item_id/2181458-Are-You-Listening/day/5-9-2020