Hello {huser:
Here's my disclaimer: I'm just one reader--one of many, hopefully. My opinions are my own, and I offer them to you by way of encouragement and support. Please feel free to take any of these observations and suggestions, or none of them at all. And bear in mind that I hope to see you improve your writing to your standards, not mine. If this review helps toward that goal, I am rewarded also.
Approaching your writing, I'm searching for specific elements that I will address under separate headers. (Otherwise I just kind of ramble, as though we were sitting together in a bar swapping notes !)
Characters — Do they fit the story (Are they well rounded, or appropriately vague?)
Bearing in mind that I am jumping in in the middle of a story, I felt the characters WERE well-rounded. Tyollis is portrayed particularly well. I was in the service myself, and I have seen the senior NCOs as tired as us men, but still in charge, and still needing to keep going and keep US going.
Tyollis' strength in the face of exhaustion is the detail that weaves this chapter together so tightly. His momentary lapse of concentration in the end that allows the prisoner to escape is an essential contrast and a very natural and realistic scene.
Pace — Does your story feel like it's going somewhere?
Was I able to follow the cadence of your story?
This chapter portrays an army unit that is close to being stuck somewhere. As such, the story itself is slowed down, with fitful starts and stops. That is important, as it keeps the reader immersed in the frustrations of the men and leaders, but after a few paragraphs of it, I found my eye wanting to skim ahead. Had I been a casual reader, instead of reading to provide detailed feedback, I probably would have skimmed a bit, missed some details, and had to come back to re-read. Now, that's not observed in a negative light: like I said, I understand that's how the chapter has to be. But I think it is worth you knowing about it.
Language and Voice — Was I able to 'feel' the story, to experience it through one or more of the characters?
Tyollis was dead-on, as previously mentioned. Branston, on the other hand, was not. I can tell he is a prisoner, and a proud man, but beyond that, he seems more of a device to drive the story than he does an actual character.
The other soldiers who have brief interactions have equally brief descriptions, but enough to set them apart from the throng. The young soldier with the scruffy beard; the soldier with one eye; and Athern, of the grey hair. (I originally wrote in this review that the characters did not stand out. Going back to check for specific examples of dialog issues, I found these little details did exist, and was pleased. The fact that I didn't grab on them the first time around is probably evidence that I did some skimming after all. Hmm...)
Humorously, our Medical Officer, when I was in the service, did that for real. I almost broke my shoulder, and as I was waiting to be seen, he first asked to see "Knee-Guy."
Then: "Who's next? Oh. Send in Stitches-Guy." Finally it was my turn, and he said, "Okay, now send in Shoulder-Guy."
It's a funny little anecdote, but it does demonstrate how a person (a reader in your case) can keep track of characters by the smallest of details, and how you kept the "extras" in your story from being cardboard cutouts.
Dialogue — Are your characters' voices distinct, and do they add to character building? Was the dialog stiff or stilted, or did it flow naturally?
Again, Tyollis carried the chapter. Branston's speech was not quite contrived, but... I don't know. Not hostile enough? I mean the guy is a prisoner. Reading the first eight chapters might help me more there.
Regarding actual dialog, there is an instance where you use the same word too much too close together. It's just a few paragraphs in, when the soldier with the scruffy beard (good detail, by the way) is telling Tyollis of the sick men. Scruffy uses the words "They say," and then then next time he speaks, he uses "I'd say." It's not egregious, but it stood out.
Faldashir's speech did not flow as smoothly as Tyollis'. I could hear Tyollis in my head; but I was aware that I was reading Faldashir.
Settings — Was I able to really embed myself in a scene, really see and feel the surroundings as written?
Actually, I was TOTALLY able to put myself there. The stalled column, the cold ground the sick soldiers. The weary progress and tired halt at the river. The spooky trees. I think brevity was your strength here. You told us what the setting was like, rather than describing each leaf and twig. Each reader is now able to build the scene around his or her experience. Great job with Setting.
Themes — Was I knocked out by mind-blowing philosophy or originality?
N/A
It's only one chapter. The overall theme is still hinted at: Defeating the Monster. In this case, defeating the Wraith. But as for philosophical arc and journey, it would be unfair to judge one chapter outside the context of the overall story.
Mechanics — Was the grammar and structure such that I did not have to re-read portions, or stumble over certain phrases? Were there conspicuous punctuation errors?
Actually, the only mistake I found was that you spelled "Each" as "Eack" when Tyollis goes back to survey the sick men. Stellar job with mechanics.
Conclusion — A summary of how I personally felt about your story.
I want to read the other 8 chapters! That's how I feel. I was interested in the variables--the sickness, the unseen monster(s). I was immersed in the setting. I was identifying with the characters. Hell yeah!
One other element of this story that really broke through to me was the humane treatment of the prisoners. That really broke the stereotype of this genre, and was rather fascinating to me. I want to find out more about the little details like this.
The only reason I stole that half-a-star was the familiarity I felt to Game of Thrones--specifically the Wraith and the Breach Wardens. The political subtext also lent to that feeling. Now, in no way am I suggesting this is a rip-off. No way. But the little similarities were enough that I had to pull my mental imagery out of Thrones from time to time.
Overall, I thought it was a great chapter in what promises to be a very interesting book. As I read the other chapters, I'll leave some thoughts on them, as well.
Thank you for sharing your story with me, and for inviting my feedback. Good luck with your writing!
Regards,
Jeff Meyer
|
|