*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/chicochica/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
254 Public Reviews Given
355 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
It's important for writers to know what's working and what isn't, and as a reviewer, it helps to know if you have a specific concern as the writer. I'm an English teacher, winner of my university's fiction contest, and received honorable mention in 2019's Popular Fiction contest by Writer's Digest. My review will likely be specific but holistic, kind but honest. I'll let you know what truly grabs me or loses me. During the school year I won't be able to review much, but definitely hit me up over the holiday season or the summer months (North America) or during this COVID mess.
I'm good at...
Discussing structure, characterization and dialogue, literary merits, style, tone/voice. I can be very thorough. I'm also very good with grammar and spelling, though I'd like to avoid that in a review unless it's specifically for that.
Favorite Genres
YA, lgbtqiap+, romance, satire, contemporary
Least Favorite Genres
Religious, children's, fantasy, sci-fi, fanfiction
Favorite Item Types
Short stories and poetry; non-fiction pieces
Least Favorite Item Types
I don't have time for novels (including chapters) and other lengthy texts.
I will not review...
I'm uninterested in any works that discuss rape, racism, violence, etc. . These are topics few can handle responsibly. If your work is rife with basic grammatical and spelling errors, I won't read it. Do the grunt work first, then ask for that help. Also: religious works aren't my thing. Growing/Shrinking, vore -- whatever the weird genre du jour is, I won't read it.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 ... Next
51
51
Review of The Phoenix  
Review by chicochica
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello! I'm chicochica and I will be reviewing your work for "Invalid Item!

First of all, I LOVE your title. It is incredibly fitting, and incredibly inspiring. Perfect choice.

My favorite stanza is definitely the last one. You leave the reader with optimism and hope for not just yourself, but for anyone else who may have had a more than rough start to life.

How wonderful and such a blessing that a true, loving husband can be. I am so grateful you found someone who loves you and wants to help. I only wish everyone could find their other half who treats them so well. *Smile*


My only concern with your poem is that I had a difficult time really understanding what it was about. I had to go over it a few times. The note at the end helped, but I think you can put some more into the poem to really help the reader understand. I'm still confused as to what the beginning is really saying.

I also have a few suggestions to improve flow, if you don't mind. Please take this as you will, you won't hurt my feelings at all if you disagree :)

*Reading*
A child born
Unwanted, alone
Just a burden
No place to call home


Maybe
a child is born,
unwanted, alone;
She's seen as a burden,
and has no place to call home.


See what you think.

*Reading*
The itching, the pain
Alone in the room
Scared in the hospital
It seems like a tomb


Try reading this one out loud to yourself. The flow just doesn't work for me. There's a lot of "in the" that throws me off a bit. I almost want to suggest "Scared in the hospital
it seems like a tomb"

Other than that, I think it works fine.

I know it must have took some bravery to write about this, and I imagine I've only begun to see it. I'm glad you've discovered writing as it can be quite cathartic. Thanks for posting this for others to see. You might help someone else in the process :)

Good luck to you. I'm looking forward to reading more.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


52
52
Review of The Zone  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
I think you nailed it. The idea, at least.

And she disappeared
into her song.


My best pieces are written when I'm in the "zone" Unfortunately, that doesn't happen often enough...but I'm sure everyone could say that.

You do become one with the music, the story, the poem, the idea. You become the characters, the scenery. You're not directly involved, and yet you're everything at once. It's almost spiritual that way, I guess. Definitely an experience to be had.

But when everything collides like that, your emotion exudes in the piece for everyone to feel. I don't know. It's an amazing phenomenon as far as I've experienced, both with my own stuff (I think I've got one piece) and with the works of other artists.

Thanks for putting this to words.

The 4.5, btw, is because (if you care, I'm not so sure it matters that much) I think you could do better with imagery. Throw in a metaphor, simile, something else. I didn't *quite* imagine the scene, just connected with the idea. That might be enough, though. Your call *Smile*

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
53
53
Review of Dear Dad  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (5.0)
I am hardly going to nit-pick here.

This plucked at my heart strings. It made me reflect on my own relationship with my dad. He and my mom divorced when I was about four years old, and my mom always has sugar-coated hateful comments to say about him. As a result, I avoided him for almost twenty years.

The line that hit me the most in your letter was That was the beginning of me, really.

Isn't it amazing how much impact the love of a father can have on a daughter?

It is for that my husband and I are bent on our daughter having a good, solid relationship with him, her daddy. My husband's father and his sister's aren't close, and I see the effects of it every time I see his sisters. It's awful. (did that make sense? ugh, I'm getting sleeeeppy)

Thank you for sharing this letter. I'm sorry for your loss, but I believe, too, that your Dad will get your letter and one day you'll be able to chat about it *Smile*

It was a pleasure to read.
54
54
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (3.5)
Welcome to WDC!

Thought I'd roam the Read a Newbie page for a moment, and thought your story looked interesting. *Cool*

This is a story about a couple's first date which, while awkward, seems to be working out for the both of them. Anyone who's gone through the nerve-wracking experience of a first date will relate.

I think you've got the beginnings of a good story, here.

I want to get this out of the way before I move on to the other things. Your first line should "hook" the reader. What you have here didn't hook me. You shouldn't need to explain the situation beforehand, unless you're writing a screenplay. I think you could just move on to "Sit. Stare. Smile. Repeat." and that would be good :)

*Reading*
You've also got the word "nosiness" here, but I think you mean "noisiness" (as in, the place was noisy, right? nosiness means being nosey *Smile*)

*Reading*
Also, I appreciate your attempts at simile. I resisted them for so long, but they are an integral part of great writing. Good job with that *Thumbsup*

However, I think the similes you've used could be rewired a bit to have more impact.

*Reading*

"Just a coffee," both of them said simultaneously, as if part of a church choir.


This could be me (remember, I'm a novice at this), but this didn't seem quite right to me. Did they sing it? Perhaps a better idea would be something to the effect of a class saying "good morning" to their teacher (do they do that anymore?). I don't know, but you get the point. With the church choir, I got the singing image, and I'm not sure if that's what you were really going for. If it was, then don't let me get in the way!! Just wanted to throw something out there.

*Reading*

"The world is a massive pool of fire, and only those with flame resistant clothing get out alive."

He was lucky he laid out his fire-proof t-shirt and pants the night before.


This threw me off. I didn't "get" it (maybe I'm dense. I didn't sleep much last night), but it seemed out of place.

*Reading*

He felt a strong urge to hug her like he had known her for ten years.


This worked very well--good job!

*Reading*
Hmm. I'm not sure the cursing is warranted here. I don't know the character enough to know if it is or not, but generally speaking you want to be deliberate in your use of curse words. It should add to the character, the story. I don't feel that this does. I see the emotion you want to express here, but I think good narrative would be enough.

*Reading*
The kind of kiss you gave your grandmother, only I don't know many people who kiss their grandmothers on the lips.

*Thumbsup* I hear this one all of the time "the kind of kiss you'd give your grandmother," but I always think...hmm. I never kiss my grandma on the lips. Thank you for that. *Laugh*

Alright, so other than that, this piece is littered with typos and grammatical problems. I would point them out to you, but I'd rather not at this point. Take this to a good word processor (MS Word is good) and see what pops up. If you have any questions, go ahead and email me, but I think you'll be able to catch the majority of the problems with a processor.

I hope your experience here at WDC is a good one. I've learned so much in the few months I've been here, and I trust you will too. Good luck to you and your writing, and please feel free to post on the Request a Review page and the Plug page--both great venues to get some exposure and excellent feedback on your work.

Thank you for posting your story!
55
55
Review of life or something  
Review by chicochica
Rated: 18+ | (3.0)
You said you're a new writer. Yay!! Welcome! *Delight*

My impression: This is a story about a young girl who has recently moved from Michigan to....Camden (not sure which state) and has a history of prostitution. The new city she finds herself in is less friendly than the one she left, and things aren't looking up. She's forced to take whatever money she can get. I'm not sure why she's doing this, or for how long. I don't have any sense of sympathy/empathy for her, or any feelings at all...yet.

Moving on...*Smile*

I'm going to ignore grammatical errors here for this first review. Having said that, you might want to go back and proofread a bit. Try reading from the last sentence backwards. That helps break up the flow and expose problems.

Anyway. I think the first sentence has "hook" potential. You want that first sentence to draw the reader in without saying what the story is about.

You could use a bit more description, more imagery, etc. You also need to "show" more. You do a good job with the basic premise of what's going on--you make it clear what this girl is doing, but you don't tell us. That's good. Bring that into the smaller things. I'll explain.

Imagery: In the first sentence, you mention that it's cold, but it doesn't bother her. What is the cold doing to her? Does she ignore it/is her mind somewhere else? Is it a crisp kind of cold, a snowy/wintery kind of cold, or a rainy kind of cold? What is around her? You don't have to mention all of this in the first sentence, but you see the point (I hope!)

You say A chill ran down her spine, she was out of place,; Camden was not for the faint of heart.

Describe Camden: This can tie in with the cold, which can and probably should have a double-meaning, here. You do write She's been offered $1,000 before and turned it down, too good for such things, and now $40 was the going rate.. That's a good start. We get a sense of Camden by reading that, but I'd like to see the city, too.

You can even describe the kind of car: is it a run-down 1970's whatever (I'm not good with cars)? What does the man look like? Sound like? You don't have to go nuts with the description, but imagine the place and the situation in your mind and write down what you see, what you hear. Every movement of the characters and the surrounding scene can be important.

Just be careful to say it once and leave it alone (repetition and redundancies have a way of sneaking into everyone's sentences). Be aware of adverbs (-ly words) and adjectives (words that describe nouns--sorry if you already know this). Those two things tend to weaken sentences and descriptions rather than strengthen them.

You also want to keep track of what your character is doing, where they are. The particular instance I found in your piece here is petty, but something to watch out for. In the first paragraph you mention her eyes darting around. Then, in the fourth, you have her eyes snapping open. At what point did she close them?

Just a tip: something I've learned and love is using italics when dealing with inner dialog.

Example:
I hate this, she thought as she walked walking toward the car, steadily sucking in as much smoke as her little lungs could handle.

Another tip is to read your sentences aloud to yourself. You catch sentences that are too long, read wrong (lack rhythm), etc. This particular sentence reads a little long to me. I think you could place a period after "car" and then begin another sentence. She sucked in as much smoke as her lungs could handle... **Avoid modifiers like "little"--they don't tell the reader much, and serve to weaken your work.

So, this is a good start. I enjoyed this. I'm interested in reading more, so please let me know when you do and I'll get to it as soon as I can (kids and general craziness keeps me busy at times). You have an opportunity to make the reader care about a girl most people don't care for.

It takes a lot of courage to post your work for everyone to see, and I think it's awesome you did. Good luck to you. Writing is an amazing thing, and it will change your life. This site will help you become a great writer, as well.

56
56
Review of SWEET MEMORIES  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
This had a really nice, calm flow to it, the imagery was fantastic. It reminded me very much of being on an empty beach on the ocean. I love it there. It's very calming. I haven't been with my husband alone yet, and this is how I would imagine it to be like. It felt nice to think about that.

There were a few areas where I felt your soothing flow get thrown off a bit, though.

*Reading*
See me wave and hear me say
reluctantly, goodbye.


I think it's the "reluctantly."

Maybe "See me wave, and hear me say
a reluctant goodbye"

Ack, even that I'm not sure of, but I hope you see the point.

*Reading*
The only other place where the flow got interrupted for me was in the last two lines:

I would love us to cling on to,
these sweet memories much, much later.


Maybe too many syllables? The rhythm just didn't work for me. Read it out loud to yourself, and maybe you'll see my point (that's a good trick for discovering rhythm problems in any piece of writing, by the way :)

Other than that, nothing wrong that I can see. I'm so glad I read this. Thanks for posting it, welcome to WDC, and don't be afraid to show us more of your work! It's amazing what this site can do for a writer.

Good luck to you :)
57
57
Review of The Fifth Quarter  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hmmm.

The twist. I can see what you're going after here, but I don't think it's alluded to enough that the guy wants the other to stay as...uhm, more than a friend.

You might want to insert some subtleties within the poem , a rising tension that doesn't necessarily have anything to do with football, but could. Sweat. An inadvertent touch. You know, that sort of thing.

I don't know. But if you want that twist at the end to work, you're going to have to do a little more work.

Friends hang out and "stay" all the time :)
58
58
Review by chicochica
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
I often find the best pieces of writing are written while immersed in emotion.

While I hardly think you wrote this for public viewing initially, I'm glad you found it and decided to post it. These kind of pieces do a port good *Smile*

What's nice is I can relate to it as well. I know what it's like to come across completely different from who you really are inside. It's frustrating, but you know, my husband and I found each other. He was able to see/break past everything. It's amazing. He's amazing.

I hope you have found your happiness, your missing piece since writing this.

Thanks for sharing this :)

59
59
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
I love this poem. It has fabulous potential.

The voice is clear, full of emotion and passion. It starts to take a life of its own. I love your original way of expressing that first kiss, equating it with the wonder of eternity.

One of my favorites:

A rush, like a bird flying
inches from the ground


My only comment is on flow. It seems to start out with some sort of rhyming scheme, but after the third line it quickly fizzles and at some point got confusing for me. I think it was in the first stanza, starting with But she thought she had an idea...

Is this alluding to the girl wanting more than the kiss, and the guy wanting to hold back a bit? That's what I get from it.

The other part that caught me a bit was the word "moisten"

Ah--but it's not my poem. Just my thoughts! I like it any way you decide to go.

This also seems like it stems from personal experience. That is a mark of great writing skill--whether it is based on personal experience or not, the fact I can't tell is great.

*Delight* Thank you so much for sharing this!
60
60
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (3.5)
Well! You certainly caught me off guard. You're right, the beginning is a little...well, normal. But I don't know about boring because I got an immediate sense of the man and then....well, I didn't see that coming!

Then we get blindsided. The story isn't what we thought at all! Fabulous!


I want you to know, before I begin with the rest, that my suggestions are made with the best intentions at heart: to help you see with fresh eyes what can make this good story great. Hopefully you'll have other eyes to help as well.

That all said, what I'm about to suggest and comment on will act as a bit of a spoiler, so read the story first if you're interested in the twist *Smile*

So, you asked for this thing to get ripped apart. I will mention the things I saw that you might want to consider rewriting.

*Reading*
“Honey,” he said. “Do you know how to get to the hospital?” He turned to her, but she didn’t return his glance. She kept staring out the windshield, her face didn’t change, her eyes didn’t move.

So, there was a mere typo with "He turned to her," but then I also was jarred a bit by the last sentence. It might read better as "She kept staring out the windshield. Her face didn't change. Her eyes didn't move."

See what you think. As it stands, it almost reads as a run-on.

*Reading*
He was afraid, confused, and Claus phobic all at once.

I think you meant "claustrophobic" No capitalizing, one word :)

*Reading*
Anger said to punch one of themthe aliens

Unless you're speaking in the main character's voice, and this is how he speaks, you want to rewrite this. "Them" in this context is incorrect.

*Reading*
An alien approached him, allowing him a moment of opportunity for his anger. He let it build, reminding himself that what they had done to him.

*Reading*
Not knowing what their devices did meant he feared being caught.

Did you mean to write "Not knowing what their devices meant, he feared being caught" or "Not knowing what their devices did mean, he feared being caught"?

Either way, you need a comma before "he" *Smile*

*Reading*
The aliens were coming up to get him and he had to get away. So He gathered his energy and started sprinting again.

But It wasn’t long before he came to another room (i}(no comma) filled with computers. The only inches of wall that weren’t covered with some sort of technology waswere the doors and a large window in the center. Out of the half dozen aliens working, only a couple noticed him at first. They didn’t react, just stared in shock. All of them eventually noticed him, and none of them did anything.


You have a bit of a wordiness problem, especially in this paragraph. Beginning sentences with "And" or "But" can be tricky, and is best avoided. I'm not saying you can't ever do it, but more than not it weakens a sentence, especially when you're dealing with tension. The same goes for the word "So." If you ever catch yourself doing this, just omit the word and read it without. If it works without it, then leave it out. Less is more. Your last sentence smelled too much like redundancy. You basically said that in the sentences before, and I thought it worked better without it entirely. See what you think.

Other words that are just filler are words like "that" "only" and "even." Watch it when you write like you speak. We're not the most well-spoken people, and it always manages to get on paper. I am still learning this as well. I've learned that running a "find" in your word processor will catch these words, and you can reread it and decide if they're necessary or not.

*Reading*
There was a quick decision to make; go to the computer and try and figure it out or go to the window and see what they were looking at. The window drew him near with curiosity.

First, the rule with a semi-colon is that you use it when you have two independent clauses that you want to join. You can either join it using a comma and a conjunction (and, or, so, but) or use a semi-colon in place of the conjunction.

The wordiness comes back here as well. See what you think of this:

He had to make a quick decision: attempt the computer, or see what they were looking at through the window.

Something like that *shrug*

Then you have:
The window drew him near with curiosity.

This sentence brings up another issue. You've got a lot of passive sentences here. One way to pick out a passive sentence is when you use the verb "to be" coupled with a past tense verb (Example: The wall had been painted instead of He painted the wall). Another way to know you have one is when the object of your sentence is doing the action, and not the subject. In your last sentence you have the window drawing him near with curiosity. Besides that being an awkward sentence, a little confusing, it has the window drawing him near. Instead, you could write "He drew near to the window, curious to see what he would find."

If you have a word processor, you can program it to catch whenever you write a passive sentence. I've got good ol' Word 97. Go to "tools--options--spelling and grammar tab--settings button" It's great.

Anyhow, active sentences are much stronger. The passive voice does have its place, but it should be used rarely and deliberately.

I hope this helps. I understand that you want to send this in to a publisher, and I wish you all the luck in it. With that in mind, I appreciate your wanting some killer feedback. It's great that you want to be careful and make sure it's ready to be sent in.

Good luck to you with this. I really think you've got something great here. You got my attention! And I don't even particularly enjoy such stories, but I couldn't stop reading. I had to know what the heck was going on, and THAT is the mark of a good story. Please keep working on it. It's worth it.
61
61
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
Much as I like a good vampire romance (I assume you've read the Twilight series? *Smile*), I've heard at least one agency specifically request people to not send in any vampire stories *Laugh*

So, I mean, that's up to you, but it's being done. I think the challenge is to come up with something new and just as yummy.

again, much as I enjoy that Twilight series!

You could always try merging these genres together, you know. *shrug*

And this is hardly a stupid question. You are the envy of so many on this site right now! But I don't want to diminish your problem at all. I've had it before and it does suck. Good luck to you
62
62
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (3.0)
First I want to say
*Balloon1**Balloon2* Congratulations on your pregnancy! {e:balloon1){e:balloon2}

I thought about the time I was pregnant with my oldest daughter when I read this. It was a very easy pregnancy for me, and then I had the time to really think and consider all of these things.

The second and third time, not so much. *Laugh*

That doesn't mean I didn't have the same thoughts and fears and concerns, but things aren't so easy when you've got one or two crazies running around.

Anyway. I was glad to read this part:

How to see,
Good in everyone...


I think it's so important for people to learn how to see the good in everyone. It was nice to see that sentiment here.


There is so much possibility when a woman becomes pregnant. A baby is, for the most part, pliable, who can be molded and taught. They come with their own personalities that challenge and help them, but in the beginning there's so much possibility! It is never too late, but the slate will never be as clean as when the baby is in the womb.

Possibility is a wonderful thing, and that resounds here.

So enough babbling. *Blush*

I've never written formal poetry. I know nothing about it. When I did write it, it was freestyle and a little confusing :) But poetry in whatever form it comes is generally subjective. So please, take my comments as suggestion only. It will NOT hurt my feelings if you hate them and ignore them. Really. I'm only saying these things because you have this posted on the request a review page.

I'd like to think that this could be more "flowery"? Use your feelings to come up with words and phrases that imply meaning, rather than coming right out and saying it. Describe your feelings. Show, don't tell. This could be fabulous if you wanted to work on it a bit. If you don't that's okay too. Sometimes it's just nice to write it out however it decides to come out.


Consider writing everything down, especially if this is your first time. You forget so much. I did, and it's so much fun five years later to read back in my journal.

Finally, welcome to WDC and good luck to you with your pregnancy.
63
63
Review of Afraid 3-29-02  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.0)
Your post caught my attention because it's a love poem with my wedding anniversary date *Bigsmile*. It was a good day.

That said, Welcome to WDC! It's been such a blessing for me to have discovered this site. I've been able to improve markedly, and I know that if you take advantage of it and are open to other people's reviews, your writing talent will increase as well :)

This is a sweet, simple, real poem about falling in love. It's what everyone goes through. Fear is what keeps us from being with other people, and yet we're always afraid. Even after marriage, there's the fear of having children. It's scary, but just like anything else in a relationship, always a wonderful addition to the couple.

I'm not giving you a 4.5 or a 5.0 because...well *Blush*, I love poems that have imagery and words that GRAB you. This doesn't grab me so much. So it's more personal. However, I think you've got a great starting off point here for something even better (if you're so inclined).

Then again, maybe you don't want to change that. That's fine. This is a nice, sweet poem, and I'm glad to have read it. Not all poems are flowery, but that doesn't make them terrible, either. Some are tooflowery. It's a fine line at times.

Anyway, good luck with your writing, and again--welcome!
64
64
Review of Party Pooper  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Laugh*

Any parent in the world has to crack up at this.

I don't have twin girls, but I've got a girl and two boys. My oldest is 4 1/2. I imagine its much like having triplets.

Potty training IS HORRIBLE. It's marvelous when it is finally over (and it does end, I promise), but ohmygoodness it sucks in the meantime.

I've been thinking about writing such a piece lately. My boys have given me plenty of material alone.

Anyway, thanks for the laugh. It's about time more parents admitted that they long for the days of the diaper while potty training.


Bedtime is another treat. They figured out that we would let them out of bed to use the bathroom. Laura and I haven’t slept since.

Yeah I hear you. After a while our hearts grew cold and we told them that five times in an hour was plenty. You learn when the kid is manipulating you and when they're not. (It sucks when they're not).

So...oh to mechanics: *pbht*

I handle all areas of conflict and confrontation in my life the same way. I ignore them and hope they disappear.

Don't be afraid to stick a colon after "way" and before "I." Double check it if you are, but I'm pretty sure it would be safe.

And, sSince we have twin girls, it is twice the fun.

A bit cleaner that way, I think.

My girls have re-defined the phrase “going to the potty”.

Period inside the quotations. See the last paragraph, because you've got the same problem there. *Cool*

Oh how I long for the diaper days.

I hope I don't confuse you here, but after the "Oh" you need a comma. I think the "Oh" is good here. It shows the exhaustion--but it does need a comma.

Now, wWe convoy to the bathroom before we go anywhere and as soon as we get to where we were going. And, mMost times we don’t make it out of the driveway before someone utters that dreaded phrase yet again.

Any time you feel compelled to start a sentence like this, try it without the "And" or the "Now" and see how it reads. Personally, I think it's a lot stronger without. Up to you.

Laura and I haven’t slept since. (Unless you count the nap I took in the tub during the World Series).

Ah, I wouldn't make the sentence in parentheses stand alone. Put it in with the first one, make the "u" lowercase. In this sentence you have the period in the right position; punctuate it as if the parentheses weren't there.

While I'm thinking about it, I wanted to tell you about this great little book I got. Apparently it's quite well known, but I only discovered it this summer. It's Strunk and White's the Elements of Style. I learned all about punctuation there. It was really easy.

Well, I wish mechanics didn't matter because the content was highly entertaining. Thanks so much for sharing! I'm sure if you clean it up a bit your ratings will jump :)
65
65
Review of Why?  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
First of all, welcome to WDC!
I know you will find, as I have, that the people on this site are amazing and, if you let them, will only help to make the level of your writing skyrocket.

So, on to your poem *Cool*

I think this off to a great start.

You had me in the first three lines of the first stanza. It had an amazing groove; the rhymes were so unique and they kept a consistent, even beat.


Then I hit the fourth line and everything came to an unfortunate, screeching halt. It happened again in the fourth and fifth stanza.

Perhaps this was done on purpose. I don't quite understand formal poetry, and for all I know this is following a certain style, but I'm pretty sure that if it were every stanza would have the same formula.

But what do I know?

Then I hit the second stanza where you broke back into that really great rhythm. It didn't read the same, but I swear you've got a beat going, and it's great. It's a blast to read.

So I think this poem is highlighting the fact that relationships, at least in their beginning stages (even pre-stages) wreak havoc on each person, escalate when love is declared, and only sets the stage for heartache.

I'm so glad I ran into this poem. *Delight* Thanks so much for posting it--it was a trip. Good luck to you with your writing, and keep on posting!
66
66
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.0)
lol.

Okay, okay, I get the point.

But I think it's slightly hypocritical to post this and then reward those who gives longer reviews with GPs

:)

Anyway, my answer would have been that I don't mind it as long as it is helpful and encouraging (and makes sense) and free of fluff. But I didn't see that there.

Ah well.
67
67
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (3.0)
Now this is only my opinion, given in the best spirit.

I'm about to say to you what nobody ever said to me (except for my husband, who always has the guts somehow). It is something that needed to be mentioned.

Again, only my opinion, but it opened my eyes.

I think, for the most part, your word choice distracted me from the feeling of the poem. While having to re-read poetry to get the meaning isn't a bad thing at all, I was just having to get the definitions in my head as I went. It took a while to "get it"--not because it was complex, just full of big words.

Now, I want to tell you that you had two lines that I thought were fantastic

Days engulfed by a tidal wave of ardor,
Nights spent aloft in a dream so warm,


The line after that almost had me, but you lost me with the word "barter." It didn't fit for me.

Besides the big words you chose, there were some that didn't seem to fit with the mood/motive of the poem. The word "inept" to describe the girl didn't seem to put her in a great light, although perhaps that's what you meant to do.

Just consider it; take and leave what you will (really). I did enjoy those two lines immensely. If you could keep that feeling with those simple but powerful words, this would be a great poem of unrequited love.

Thanks so much. I hope I've been helpful.


68
68
Review of Halloween  
Review by chicochica
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
Welcome to WDC! I hope you find everything you want and need at this site. I've been here for about six weeks and it's already helped my writing grow immensely. The reviews I've received are priceless. I trust you'll have the same experience (though not necessarily because of me!)

I wanted to read a piece by a "newbie" and was interested in what you had, so I thought I'd take a look. Please know that I want to help the best I can, and that whatever I say you need to compare with what your gut says. In the end you know best what you want to say and how you want to say it.

So I'll start:

I'm a little confused.

I'll show you where you lost me:
I've always been typical. I wasn't in love with her...I didn't feel anything. That drop in your stomach. Love. I just knew...Our hands found each other in the dark. She held it tight and I felt nothing

Do you see the problem? Or is it me? Is he in love with her or not? Just something I wanted to point out in case there was a discrepancy you weren't aware of. The way you have it written, I get confused as to whether or not this guy is in love. It is in the second sentence I highlighted where you confused me. If you want to consider it, you could fix this by a simple reword.

Okay, enough of that.

Typos: (nothing huge, btw *Smile*)

Young, sexually frustrated, and lonely is how I would describe myself back then.

They talked about having sex with theretheir boyfriends. They didn't like their boyfriends very much.

We stood in line and made fun of the carnie type red necks working there.

I'd stick a dash between "carnie" and "type" and I'm pretty sure (might want to double check) the words "red necks" should be merged into one.

I appreciate your story about how the beginnings of a teenage couple. The girl doesn't sound like much, and the boy sounds rather...well, I'm not sure *Laugh*

By the way, I did really enjoy the lines Our hands found each other in the dark. She held it tight and I felt nothing. We never let go.

I've had that experience, and no, I didn't really care either :) Not the best situation.

Good luck with this and with your other writings. It's a fabulous thing to write, and wonderful to know that there are so many out there who share the same passion. I hope I've been helpful.

69
69
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hm.

I know I say this often, but maybe my reaction is due to my fatigue and swimming mind.

I didn't think this was horrible. I don't agree with the two star rating myself. I will say that I am hardly a poetry expert.

I liked the flow of this poem. I appreciated the different structure. Without reading your description, I THINK I understand what you are saying, though only after a couple of re-reads (not necessarily a bad thing when it comes to poetry, if you ask me).

I read your description and the poem and get it. It's a little convoluted, but nothing terrible. I can see from this that after your ordeal at the dealership, you feel disheartened, disappointed, and a perhaps a little more than angry.

We've all had such experiences, unfortunately. It always helps to write a cathartic poem.

I hope I've been of some help. Thanks for posting this on the request page *Cool*
70
70
Review by chicochica
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
I enjoyed this immensely.

Your words are clear, well-chosen, and concise. They consistently carry the voice of a young black soldier who unfortunately finds himself in Vietnam, discovering who he is and how he feels about his country.

I'm not sure if I'm meant to feel sadness after reading this, but I don't. I don't feel happiness, either, but I feel somewhat...contented (?), despite the topic, if that makes sense.

I am amazed at how well you carried this out. I wish I could write this well--Really, the attention to everything floored me.

Great job!!
71
71
Review of Dance  
Review by chicochica
Rated: 13+ | (3.0)
So you've got a 100 words

(if I don't delete that, forgive me: sometimes I forget)

The first paragraph didn't do it for me, personally. I did like the line "the laughter dying into silence." That was descriptive for me; I liked it a lot.

So I got the impression in the first paragraph that we've got two people sharing some drinks (perhaps a few too many?) and that leads us to some tension, which the characters are relieved of in the final paragraph.

Really, I think the second paragraph was much better. What jarred me a bit with the first was that it seemed to lack flow. Consider making them less passive (have the subject of the sentence do the action, rather than the object. For example: the couple clinking the glasses together vs. the glasses clinking together).

A cool night breeze rustled the curtains through the open patio doors

I can see where you're trying to create the atmosphere, give us a sense of the surroundings, but I might ditch it completely. If you've only got 100 words to work with, focus on the couple entirely. If they're working up to going to the bedroom, then try to show us the growing tension leading up to the inevitable and leave the rest out. When you're in that situation, you don't notice much else than the other person anyway :)

Good luck with this and with submitting it! I hope I've been helpful. Please, (I think I've said this to you before) don't take my word for it, but consider it; go with your gut and the suggestions of other readers.



72
72
Review of If I Could Break  
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
This contained strong emotion to me. I especially liked the opening and closing lines and the way you used the shatter/glass/pain/break/loud words. It brought it all together for me and confirmed for me what the poem is all about before I even read the line "you would know the pain you've caused" You said a lot in a few lines, and that is difficult to do.

I enjoyed this immensely. Thanks so much for sharing it *Smile*
73
73
Review of Bullet  
Review by chicochica
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
You're right--very unique.

I enjoyed this, but I have to say that I would have enjoyed it much more if there were fewer paragraphs. Perhaps you want the jarring effect, but it tired me after a while. If I wasn't interested, I probably would have given up. It was just a LOT of two to three sentence paragraphs to get through. If you want to, you might want to consider merging some of them together.

Other than that, I liked the concept of the story and the POV. The voice was believable. I do, however, have a difficult time reading stories that are written in the 1st person that end with that person committing suicide or otherwise dying (it doesn't seem believable to me), but perhaps that's just me.

I used to write odd things such as this. It's a lot of fun and I'm just glad I'm not the only one. It's been a while since I've done it, but I know it's in me somewhere *Smile*

Thanks for sharing your story!

74
74
Review by chicochica
Rated: E | (4.5)
OK, so this *completely* cracked me up.

Having three kids of my own (all under 5), I totally relate to your sense of humor/dread...and your wife's. Reality is funnier than fiction (most of the time), and your honesty was both refreshing and hilarious.

I'm not so sure the whole "home office" thing would work for me either. The kids would have to be grown and out of the house. I don't know how people do it. Maybe they just pretend to.

Thanks so much for the laugh; I really need a good one often throughout my day.

The only thing I'd watch is your use of the "-ly" words, especially when they begin a sentence. They tend to weaken things.

Oh, and if it matters, this spoke a lot like a Dave Barry column (to me at least). Keep it up!!
75
75
Review by chicochica
Rated: 18+ | N/A (Review only item.)
Hm. I'm not so sure I'd call this a horror story--disturbing, maybe, but not exactly horror.

I'm under the impression that the boy gets thrown into the basement with every full moon because he turns into a werewolf and the parents don't like it and abuse him for it...?

I would wonder why they would hit him. Something almost doesn't fit there, but maybe with some expansion on the story it would make sense later...?

All that aside, telling this story from the boy's point of view, in his young voice, brings a whole new feeling to it. You can hear his fear, his uncertainty, and sadness that I don't think would be as powerful without the words that little ones use.

Good job. I'd like to see what you do to expand on this, to tie things in. I wonder about Mr. Wolfson's puppy (the name alone might be a hint, yeah?). As of yet, though, I wouldn't yet call it a horror story, just a sad and disturbing one.

My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
77 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 4 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/chicochica/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3