*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/tjalio/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
550 Public Reviews Given
612 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I give my overall impression of the story, quote my favourite part, correct any mistakes in the grammar, then point out characterization flaws and plot holes. Style varies if any of the above is uncalled for.
I'm good at...
Rectifying grammar, i.e., pointing out errors in spelling, punctuation, tense, sentence construction, etc. Also good at substantive review, i.e., assessing the plot for completeness, consistency, and clarity.
Favorite Genres
Thriller/Suspense, Crime/Gangster, Drama, Experience, Relationship, Romance/Love, Erotica
Least Favorite Genres
Fantasy, Sci-fi
Favorite Item Types
Short stories
Least Favorite Item Types
Poetry
I will not review...
Full-length books
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- 4 5 6 ... Next
51
51
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Dykie.

That's love alright. The common complaint by married women is how the man starts taking them for granted after marriage. To make such little sacrifices (little, ha!) goes a long way in avoiding a domestic world war three.

I like how you bring out the romantic message with so much humour. My favourite part was:

"The water in my shower was so cold, I wouldn't have been surprised to hear tentative scratching on the shower curtain, and then opened it to face a massive polar bear looking for relief from global warming."

Thanks for sharing.

Cheers,

TJay
52
52
Review of A Shadow of Guilt  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi, ~

The story is riveting thanks to the suspense of Cheri being followed and delayed revelation of the cause of his guilt. The single-sentence paragraphs in the second half of the story helped, too.

My issue with the story is in the portrayal of that guilt. It terrifies Cheri beyond the capacity of an emotion. It seems to become more than just an obsession, as the blurb claims. More like a hallucination. But when the story is told from its own perspective, here: “As the creature oozed from the ground beneath Will’s feet, it began to follow him; discreetly at first, dodging in-between gravestones and cypress trees, and then as Will headed out the front gates it pursued him in earnest.” and here: “His guilty conscience fell on top of him, twitched for a moment, and then realizing it had been tricked, followed him to Hell.” — it implies that it’s not even a hallucination, but an actual being, more so since in the last scene, it is seen to be active after the narrator has died. That leaves me baffled as to what it really is.

Other than that, I enjoyed the story. Thanks for sharing.

Cheers,

TJay
53
53
Review of HoJo Memories  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi, Judity.

What could be wrong with getting addicted to milk? *Wink* I love milk. A lot of it makes my stomach feel funny though.

Seeing as this prompt calls for sensory immersion, I think you could have done a bit more to describe your childhood delicacy. Also, it’s good to have some background info, but you kind of buried the meal too far by not really talking about it until the fourth paragraph. Perhaps if the build-up had been more tantalizing, that would have been okay, but you kind of kill the excitement with this two lines, which imply it’s become something of a staple food and not so special anymore: “As I follow my parents and older sisters into the HoJo restaurant, I already know what I’m going to order. In fact, Mum no longer hands me a menu.” Also, by saying that "I realize that meal doesn’t sound special to you," kind of defeats the purpose. You should make the reader feel its special however ordinary it sounds based on how you describe it.

But it’s in the details that you could most improve. For example, in the line:
“I still can almost taste every bite.” – it would’ve been better if you described that taste;
And in the line:
“The delicious aroma rising from the croquets” – what makes it “delicious”? Describe its effect on your sense of smell.
Also, in:
“the two cones tasting just a bit dry” – it would help if you used an analogy or simile for that dryness, just as you likened the colour of the peas with those that came out of a can.
"the hard roll" - How hard? Hard like what?
Basically, avoid using adjectives. They tend to summarize where giving details would be better.

That’s all. Hope this helps.

Good luck with your quest to rediscover that meal.

Cheers,
TJay
54
54
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi, Wharton.

My question from the previous part's review about Jace’s residency has been answered here, though I think it should have been made clear earlier.

“I haven’t gone to the Police yet because they won’t do anything until seventy-two hours have passed.” Is that so? I didn’t know. Also answers my concerns, though.

I like the back-and-forth approach you use sometimes, especially in the build-up to Jace’s murder. Gives the suspense a dual perspective and, through the brevity of the bits, a fast pace.

My question now is how James thinks he’ll get away with his crimes. He may have disposed of of Bill in some way that’ll be hard to trace, but Jace’s execution was a bloody mess, which belies the clinical nature of his two-week surveying and planning. And how does he expect himself to just waltz back into Shannon’s life and start living with her again? Maybe he plans to bide his time, but if so, he wouldn’t have given the forensics so much to think about in the case of Jace. I don’t imagine cleaning up the blood will be enough to let him off the hook, or that’ll he manage it flawlessly considering it splashed everywhere.

Anyway, I’m sure you’ve taken these into consideration and will have the answers in the subsequent parts. Just ensure they’ll be convincing.

Cheers,

TJay
55
55
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hi, Wharton.

So the culprit is an ex of Shannon’s? He had me fooled with that talk of a conspiracy with her, but Shannon’s manner has implied otherwise. Interesting. Love how the plot thickens.

Top marks for the description in the scenes involving Bill. James could have been introduced better, like through Bill’s reaction to seeing him, rather than being named out of the blue like that.

While the Bill and James dialogue develops the plot, Bill talks a bit too easily for my liking, considering the condition he’s in. I figured he wouldn’t talk so much and would struggle a lot just to get the few words out, but the injuries seemed forgotten once the conversation started, and he was not only wordy but argumentative despite being under the mercy of a captor who was planning to kill him. That’s unnatural. You could either edit to heighten his struggle or to show that was numbed by the extent of his injuries and resigned to his fate. He could even be dragging the conversation to buy time as he figured a way out or hoped help would come.

Also, the phrase “what she wants or needs” is used several times in this dialogue in some shape or form. That’s a bit redundant; do edit.
The grave-scene dream implied some bad memory. Not sure what to make of it so far.

The phone conversation between Shannon and Steve answered questions I was going to ask, about calling the cops; convincingly enough, though the cops are bound to bring it up later—why she didn’t call sooner.

So I was wrong about Jace? My bad. But I wonder who he is to Shannon. Seems to be living in the same building, or something.

Cheers,

TJay
56
56
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hi, Wharton.

The aftermath of a near-fatal beating hooked me into the story, and the division of the plot into different phases of time ensured there was no monotony. The bits and pieces of background info, introducing the characters around Bill and the circumstances of his disappearance, made for a great transition and proved the intro wasn’t just some gimmick to get my attention. By the end of this part, the mystery of what happened to Bill lingers, plus the flowers to Shannon from an anonymous source, lure me to the next part.

The title hasn’t gotten tied into the plot yet; does it by any chance refer to the finger that was seemingly chopped off Bill?

No clear suspect thus far, but I suspect Jace knows more than he’s letting on. Or at least the butter knife he was holding reminded me of the chopped finger.

Shouldn’t they be worried enough to call the cops by now? But I guess this is accounted for by the assumptions Shannon makes.

Nice bit of humour in the flower scene. They sure put that delivery man in his place. *Bigsmile*

Punctuation is a bit off here and there, but since this is a work-in-progress, you can work on that later.

Cheers,

TJay
57
57
Review of Running  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Short and sweet. I instinctively feared a rape case, but it turned out to be a trap, thankfully. The “You won't have to run anymore” statement left me wondering though what there had been to run from in the past, especially considering this is a wooded trail and the culprit had a knife. Sounds to me like more than just a stalking, jilted ex. All in all, an intriguing hook to the continuation you’ve linked at the end of the story.
Regards,
TJay
58
58
Review of Letters  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi, Matthew.

There are people who maintain their innocence to the death but all evidence points otherwise. I remember in the movie Shawshank Redemption, the inmates all claimed to be innocent, so it’s hard to distinguish self-preservation from fact; but it’s always a bitter truth when it emerges too late that someone really was innocent. I expected such a twist in your story, but I got more than that—the resignation of the narrator to his fate. I like how you wove the story such that initially I didn’t even know he was on deathrow; just a love story with a tragic ending.
My favourite quote was:

Both of them had been in relationships where the word “love” was batted back and forth, like a birdie in a badminton game - one person always trying to score with it by landing a well-placed shot.

The story was well-edited, so I don’t have any grammatical issues to raise. Thanks for sharing.

Cheers,
TJay
59
59
Review of My first Marathon  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi, Daren.

I loved how your observations mentally carried me to the marathon experience. I especially liked this part:

"At long last the starting gun went off. The race had begun but there was one problem. No one was moving. All the empty spaces had filled in and the road was too narrow for 2,000 people to start running. Soon people in front of me started to move and worked into a jog. Before long, there was plenty of space and I was able to run. The road ahead could not be seen. Instead, it was a sea of people moving but mostly bobbing up and down. The sound of hundreds of feet pounding the pavement and people chatting filled the air."

That said, I think you took too long to get to the part about the race. It's like describing a tourist site and using too much space talking about the trip there instead of focusing on the destination.

Your paragraphs were too long. Split them up into smaller ones for ease of reading.

Do proofread you work. I came across such errors as "staition" and "fininshed" and "Finnish" which a quick spell check would have caught.

There was also the problem of mixed tenses. Present and past. Edit for consistency.

I liked the ending. That sense of achievement is well captured. My favourite parts were these two sentences:
"Whether I run a marathon everyday for the rest of my life or never run one again, I knew I would never have this feeling ... A memory was made that would last a lifetime and remind me to never give up."

I'm a five-time half-marathoner looking to take part in my first full marathon next year. I want to experience this feeling, too. *Smile*

That's all. Hope this helps.

Cheers,
TJay
60
60
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, Designce.

I agree with you about this rivalry and Brazil's superiority. It's a pity they've never met in a World Cup final. That would really be exciting, don't you think?

It's not just Brazil's success but their flair that has won them fans all around the world. Their dip in form in recent years is what has allowed the likes of Spain to get away with winning a World Cup with 1-0 wins all the way up to the final, and the Argentine Messi to be the world player.

I hope they bring their Samba best back by 2014. The return of Kaka and Ronaldinho to form and thus to the starting eleven is hopefully a sign of things to come.

Thanks for the statistics. I've enjoyed reading them.

TJay
61
61
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
Hi, DS.

I love, love, love how you've written this! I'm a runner who writes about his experiences as well, but I belong to the class that "run as if their lives depend on it", so I tend to miss out on some of these fan facts along the way.

I also loved the moral you derived from the story:
"It was upon reaching the finish line that I realized that life itself is like a journey. If we all strive to move forward, and if we all make the move forward our only option, then yes our world would be a better place."

Otherwise, the following gave me food for thought vis-a-vis my own experiences:

"When I say walk, I mean walk, as I am not really the athlete, and I had no intention of running 1km let alone 10." LOL! *Bigsmile* This reminded me of the few friends I've convinced to join me in a race only for them to go walking.

"People pushed and shoved those in front of them at the start line, probably thinking that they had a better chance of winning if they started a fraction of a second earlier."
Yeah, that starting line rush is crazy!

At the humiliating speed I was going, I had a chance to see some very entertaining sites along the way. Being slow has its positive points too after all.
*Bigsmile* Lol. I guess everything has its advantages.

"Runners, had every justification to do that, after all they were keeping time."
This figures. I noticed in my race that there were actually bins right after the water stations, but hardly anyone bothered with them; they just drank the water and threw the bottles on the ground. Environmentalists would have a heart attack if they saw the runners at it. *Wink*

"They were probably on a mission, a mission to prove to anyone, unable to join them at the event, that they had a blast."
Lol. I've come to realize that this is one of the pet peeves of non-runners.

"There were the amazing people who put us walkers to shame. These were serious senior citizens..."
Oh yeah; they are as inspiring as they are a source of humiliation for younger folks.

Grammatically, I noted the following errors:

push and shove towards the "busses" - this is an acceptable variation of the plural of bus, but since you use the more conventional "buses" later ("buses" parked on the sides), I think it's best you edit the first plural to buses also.
We ran at the start signal ,all - comma misplaced; should be: signal, all...
while the other had her hair straightened - while another, not the other, as you haven't indicated you were referring to two girls in particular
In contrast, their were others - there, not their
...and ran as if their life depended on it - put a full stop after "it"
by taking off their shirts , - delete space before comma
the bottled drinking water . - delete space before full stop
revealed their urls in Wet hair strands - did you mean curls? And why the capital W in wet?
Um kalthoom’s ballads - Shouldn't the K in Kalthoom be capitalised?

That's all. I hope this helps. I really enjoyed reading this, all the way from the lazy waking up to the proud finishing.

I recently wrote an essay about the attitude of some non-runners towards runners, with a similarly humorous approach. Care to read? Here it is:

 Invalid Item 
This item number is not valid.
#1816428 by Not Available.


Cheers,
TJay
62
62
Review of Steve Begins  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi, Ironworker.

Your tense is all mixed up. Choose either present tense (preferable here) or past tense, and stick with it.

And make the following corrections:
clinched his teeth - clenched
road with him - rode
Then changing the subject, So, lets go eat. - put speech marks before So
And, by the way, you are, going to have - remove the comma after are
griminess-ed - I wonder if you meant grimaced or were using literary license?

Otherwise, it's an interesting snapshot into parent-child relationships when dealing with a discipline case. Since drama is what makes stories interesting, perhaps you could stretch the tale a little bit back to include an account of the accident that got the son in trouble.

That's all. Hope this helps.
Cheers,
TJay
63
63
Review of The Promise  
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi, Simple.

There's nothing simple about your poem. The first time I read it, I got confused by the I-He changes in perspective. I figured there were two people, but with both assuming the first person narrative, I got confused again. It's only after at third read with back-and-forth references that I figured who was talking when, and the plot sunk in. The "dad" bit though was a shocker, though. There was nothing to prepare me for it. I just thought it was one good Samaritan lending a helping hand to a homeless man.

So while I was touched by the narrative in your poem, I think you could make it clearer by having one man stick to the first person narrative and the other to the third person narrative, and you could flesh out the nature of their relationship by giving hints that show there is more than just a promise at stake.

Otherwise, the rhyming is great and the grammar is flawless.

Thanks for sharing.

Cheers,
TJay
64
64
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi, Cianter.

I guess doubts are part of the process of learning.

Not bad for a first poem.

Just felt the title and blurb were contradictory, yet they should complement each other. I think you should let the reader get the lesson learned at the end of your poem instead of highlighting it in the title yet it's not the focus of the poem; just the conclusion of it.

The rhyming is good, but it's kind of obscured in the general flow. Perhaps splitting it up into stanzas would help it stand out better.

The grammar's fine, though in the twelfth line there's this error:
alway - always

That's all. Hope this helps.
TJay
65
65
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (3.0)
Hi, Edgework.

There are grammatical errors in the review, which point to a lack of concentration in the reviewer. I don't understand what exactly the reviewer doesn't understand; the fact that s/he adds "I think" to the suggestion that "it needs more work" says a lot. And hiding behind the mask of anonymity also puts their credibility to question. If you don't understand something, it's better to not review it at all.

This for me is a case study on how not to review.

TJay
66
66
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hi, Butch50,

I was going to say something about the repeated mentions of Grandma's displeasure, but your last line stopped me in my tracks. Indeed, you never know what you have until you lose it.

All in all, it's a nice snapshot of an idyllic life for kids. Made me want to roll back the years.

I noted that there are double spaces in between sentences. Reduce that to single spaces.
Also correct the following:
They took turns trying to stand on it and get it to rolling - get it to roll, or get it rolling
out speed and out maneuver - delete the spaces between out and the words

That's all. Hope this helps.
Cheers,
TJay
67
67
Review by Madridista
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hi, Butch50,

You may not have had a picture of that last scene, but you sure created one in the reader's mind, of that and all the frustrations you experienced with Chena the puppy and its boundless energy.

There was a tendency to split words that should be one:
up stream - upstream
down stream - downstream
along side - alongside
will power - willpower
half way - halfway

Other than that, I noted the following errors:
I was able to make exactly 5 casts – five casts; spell out all numbers before 10
She was churning up a wake of white water behind her all the way. , - delete the comma and extra space
after about 5 minutes – five minutes
distance Chena covered in 5 minutes – five minutes
made the smartest move I had seen all day, - use a colon, not a comma

Lastly, you should leave it to the reader to give an adjective to your story. I noticed you judged it for the reader in your blurb as "humorous". Not all readers may agree, you see.

That’s all. Hope this helps. Thanks for sharing.

Cheers,
TJay
68
68
Review of The Chase  
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hi, Dyke.

I thought this was going to be the defining moment of the story: "Hearing a commotion up ahead I increased my speed. I had learned from experience that when Chaser was running and barking, there was usually trouble" But after it turned out there was no drama in it, I thought it was a disappointing turn of events. But then you started reflecting on the futility of Chaser's chases, and drawing a parallel with life, and it all started to make sense. I like how you draw the reader into that realization.

My favourite part was:

"All of us are always chasing things. Some we catch, and some we don’t. What’s important is the realization that the secret to true happiness is not to get caught up in our chases. We must learn to enjoy the moment. To understand and appreciate life as a gift. Tomorrow will come soon enough. Live for today, not for what lies around the next bend."

I didn't see much that needs to be improved, save for the following:

After an hour drive – an hour’s drive
we were greeted with what was soon to become our new dog – this gives away any suspense on what the visit to the dog owners would result in, such that by the time you say, “Before we knew it, we were saying our goodbyes and loading our new dog into the car for the long drive home”, the reader already knew it.
We would soon find out that those were the last quiet moments we would spend with Chase in a very long time. - Same case here. Avoid giving away the story too early.

That's all. Hope this helps.
Cheers,
TJay

69
69
Review of Dead Steps  
Review by Madridista
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Hi, Lyons.

I love the twist at the ending. It's a classic horror-story twist.

The rhyming is good except in the second, third, and fifth stanzas. Edit for consistency.

Otherwise, I felt some parts needed clarifying:

From dream to dream, I rise and wake,
Annoyed with want to end it. - I know you're referring to the noise in the first stanza, but here it sounds like its a recurring bad dream your persona wants to end.

I scurry to my window pane
With thoughts some fools contended. - "thoughts some fools contended" is as vague as you can get.

The fourth stanza sounds like a rant to the neighbour. This contradicts with the fifth stanza, where the persona is planning to give the neighbour a piece of his mind (as the 'will' in "I'll teach his dad" implies).

I'll go back home... We haven't heard him say he's left the house in the first place.

The above issues left me wondering if I'd missed something. I noticed from the blurb that you're talking about a psychotic man, but still, I feel there are holes in the story.

That's all, hope this helps.

Cheers,
TJay
70
70
Review of African Regalia  
Review by Madridista
Rated: ASR | N/A (Review only item.)
*UmbrellaR*This review is given on behalf of "Showering Acts of Joy Group*UmbrellaR*


Hi, Sherrys.

I was drawn to this story on the new items listing after coming across a feature on witches in Africa in this week's Newsweek magazine. It covered women who were falsely accused of being witches and persecuted for it. Being an African, I know that this happens a lot, and that many people believe in the existence and power of witches. However, I suspended disbelief for this short story and could picture what such a culture shock it would have been for the foreigners.

That said, there were a lot of grammar errors; you should catch them if you reread the story. Also, I wondered why the women would stick around for another day and night after one of them died so mysteriously. And I didn't understand that last line.

Some of the grammar errors include:
only camels, and donkeys - no need for a comma
Her of all of us - She of all of us
we went to sleep where we slept - and we slept...
The goddess of the hills, spared you - no need for comma

Otherwise, I enjoyed the story. Thanks for sharing.
Cheers,
TJay
71
71
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (5.0)
*UmbrellaR*This review is given on behalf of "Showering Acts of Joy Group*UmbrellaR*


Hi, Audrey.

I absolutely loved this piece. I have a girlfriend I'm having a long distance relationship with, and she keeps telling me how she likes to meditate at the beach (she lives at the Coast; I'm inland). I wonder if these feelings you've shared are what she had before we started dating; if she still suffers those loneliness pangs, in light of the distance; and if the beach has the same soothing effect on her as it did to you. I feel inspired to write her something that touches on the subject...

Other than that, I just like the picture you've painted of the beach and how it's such a therapeutic experience hanging out there.
I loved the intro, but my favourite part was:

"Beaches provide the serenity that we all crave, whether alone or with someone special, or with friends and family. For me, watching sunsets alone provide the serenity to keep me calm and my quiet self intact."

Thanks for sharing this. I felt calm just reading it.

Cheers,
TJay
72
72
Review by Madridista
Rated: E | (4.5)
Short and sweet. You make great use of the five senses. One pictures the setting and gets a therapeutic sense from it all. You almost go, "Aah, heaven can wait!" *Smile*
Given its brevity, perhaps you could format it as a poem?
Anyway, it was a pleasure to read it; thanks for sharing.
73
73
Review of The Blooper  
Review by Madridista
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
*UmbrellaR*This review is given on behalf of "Showering Acts of Joy Group*UmbrellaR*


Hi, George.

I knew I was in for a treat having read and loved Skipper's other story, The Knockout. We've all made a gaffe now and then, but nothing's as bad as saying it on air, I guess. The letter Skipper was getting in the intro got me thinking he'd really pissed someone off, and so it appeared until you revealed at the end his lucky escape.

You captured Skipper's internal turmoil at his blooper very well. I can just imagine how the blood drained out of his face as he realized what he'd said, more so after that lengthy session with the grannies of the player in question. It's the kind of thing one bangs their head on the wall for, though you avoided this cliche with an even better description: "I wished I could rip my tongue out and stomp on it for punishment."

All in all, it's a wonderful tale of another misadventure that could have ended a lot worse than it did. *Smile* Didn't see anything grammatically or substantively wrong with the narration.

Cheers,
TJay

74
74
Review of The Knockout  
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hi, George.

This is one hell of a story!

I thought Skipper would storm out with Theresa after the boxer flashed his sick idea of a knockout at them, but he braved it out, and to his credit, the boxer opened up – in a more decent way *Wink* – to him. I've heard of crazy beginnings to relationships, but this one tops the list for sure. Not many women would have stood working with Skipper after suffering such indignity, let alone dating and marrying him. Perhaps the bonus she got for her troubles helped smooth things? In which case, it would help if you said Skipper campaigned for her to gain that bonus.

Anyway, apart from the ingenuity of the plot, I liked how you described the environment and happenings at the boxing arena. You captured the training of the boxer, aptly named 'Bruiser', in details that showed a good grasp of the sport and created a vivid mental picture for the reader. You varied from the use of similes, like this:

“The sand-filled bag jerked and jangled at the end of its chain like a condemned prisoner dangling from a hangman's rope.”

To the use of the senses, like in these paragraphs:

“Contrasting with the bright lights and noise of the exhibition hall, the small dressing room seemed particularly dark and quiet. The sounds of training fighters vanished - The clang of heavy, free weights, the whoosh of jump-ropes cutting through the air and clicking rhythmically against the concrete floor, the grunts and groans accompanying thrown punches, and the smack of gloved hands against human flesh.

Sweat and liniment lingered in the still air. One dim light with a dark green, metal shade hung from the ceiling, providing barely enough illumination to get around.”
I also liked the analogies to an animated film, a sleazy film, and a cartoon to describe situations and reactions. I also like this analogy to a childhood memory to put things in perspective:
“The bizarre sight inspired feelings of awe and inadequacy, conjuring memories of being a young boy at the zoo with a peanut in my little hand, reaching through the metal bars towards the extended trunks of the giant elephants. However, in this case, I didn't have a peanut to offer, and I didn't want to be anywhere near that trunk.” Lol!

Through these descriptions, and light moments like when the reporter answered the boxer only to be told, "I ain't talking to you, sonny"; you put a light note to an otherwise horrifying experience for the poor receptionist. You also captured the hunger journalists have for that career-moving scoop, the challenges they have to deal with, and the lengths they can go to sometimes, though in this case it was a lot “longer” than expected – pun intended. *Wink*

The editing was great; I've seen no errors.

Characterisation was okay, too. The inflated ego of the celebrity, the macho camaraderie in the dressing room, the desperation of the journalist, the naïvety of the receptionist...

Perhaps mention of some previous impression the journalist had made would explain why he got the chance at this break. Mere bugging of the boss surely isn't enough to get a rookie reporter an interview with a whole Heavyweight Boxing Champion of the World; especially one that's to be fed to over two-hundred stations!

And perhaps Theresa should have been more inquisitive of what exactly Skipper meant by her helping him get the interview, since she was no expert on matters boxing. Upon which Skipper would cook something up, like needing an extra hand to beat the deadline. Or you could say that she obliged out of the sense of obligation newbies have to impress their colleagues, since she was “the new receptionist”.

That's all. Hope this helps.

Cheers,
TJay
75
75
Review by Madridista
In affiliation with Showering Acts of Joy Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
*UmbrellaR*This review is given on behalf of "Showering Acts of Joy Group*UmbrellaR*

Hi, Shayla.

Winter has never sounded so sweet. It's something those who can afford to run away from to the sunshine of equatorial countries, but you've given it a warm, desirable touch.

My favourite part was:

She seldom grants us mercy, yet her beauty is for free.
A wondrous gift of blinding white, angelic purity.
Our time with loved ones is often more, nothing now seems dire.
All these things and more denote winter’s soft desire.

The lack of rhyme in the first two lines stands out from the pattern in the rest of the poem, more so now that you repeat it at the end. Other than that, I found nothing wrong with the poem.

That's all. Hope this helps.

Cheers,
TJay
150 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 6 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/tjalio/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3