*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/harryg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/13
Review Requests: OFF
1,432 Public Reviews Given
1,595 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 9 10 11 12 -13- 14 15 16 17 18 ... Next
301
301
Review of Just Hold Me Now  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Image ID #1467580 Unavailable **

Greetings, Dr. Taher ~

This poem addresses the love of a couple for each other. It struck me as strange that in the first stanza he gives her a diamond ring and she falls in love with him in the second stanza.

The grammar/punctuation needs checking. For instance:

Then(,) when I fell in love with you,
Your response was starkly daring(.)
You hugged me that day so lovingly[,](.)
Your kiss was so unsparing(.)

Having all lines 2 and 4 end with -ing words makes for some weak rhymes.

Overall, this reads well enough to be an enjoyable poem.

Cheers!

Dr. Harry
302
302
Review of Never forget...  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Image ID #1467580 Unavailable **

Greetings, Ms. Magi ~

Excellent shaped poem. It must have been hard to get the letters/words aligned correctly to make the front of a church. I'm impressed!

You might want to refer more directly to the church bombing itself in the summary. I, for one, am not familiar with "The Watsons Go to Birmingham-1963". Others probably won't be either.

Cheers!

Harry
303
303
Review of Ponderings...  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Nila ~

I like the message here, and the way you delivered it. Nicely done!

I liked the repeat of "as I often do," as the second line in the first three stanzas. The build up for the message delivery in stanza four
worked well. Good job...

Cheers!

Harry
304
304
Review of Letting Go  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Elizabeth ~

This poem is soft and gentle and reflective. The switching between 2-line and 3-line stanzas seemingly at random was a tad offputting. Otherwise, this is nicely written.

Cheers!

Harry
305
305
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, ShiShad ~

Song writing (and song reviewing) lies outside my expertise. I'll just say I liked this effort, and it must be good as far as songs go since it won a prize in the contest. So, keep up the song writing!

Cheers!

Harry
306
306
Review by Harry
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Cissy ~

This is a highly emotional subject that must be difficult to write about. You handle it well here. I have a few minor technical items for you to consider:

when the police were involved[, a](. A)ll the abuses were

do completely[, a](. As time goes by and you've become a hermit(,) the memories

They say that " time heals all wounds "(.)[..... but] I say with time, it becomes

will cause these memories to resurface [themselves].

in your mind as well[. A]( -- a)lways too scared

piece of this story[.](,) " with more to come."

Cheers!

Harry
307
307
Review of The Cat's Meow  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Feather Duster ~

You obviously are a cat lover. This is a wonderful tribute to Princess. May you have her a long, long time.

Here are a few points for your consideration:

at a pet store, a four(-)week(-)old kitten, for [ten](a) whopping (ten) dollars!

and at the temple like a widow’s peak, ??? Confusing. Maybe "and white at the temples..." or whatever is the correct color of her temples.

and a raccoon tail. Very beautiful markings. Maybe make into same sentence:
and a raccoon tail(-- v)[. V]ery beautiful markings.

for many camera shots(,) and they always are

for her head[, ] (;)she peeped out

as a young(,) growing cat.

He gives her Friskies tartar control treats >>>>> Who is "He"?

have improved. (She g)[G]oes in her litter,

But look out when she is about to get a shot(. H)[, h]er body shakes(,)[ and] her ears primp up, she hisses(,) and (she) is ready to say goodbye immediately. To vets(,) of course, this is normal for a growing cat.

a large(,) plastic mug

her pink(,) wet nose.

It takes her into >>>> What is 'It'?

Brought to North America, European settlers came here with cats. >>>> Sounds like European settlers were brought to North America. You mean cats were brought here by European settlers.

Cheers!

Harry
308
308
Review of Malice Intended  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Joy ~

Overall, this story appears to be nicely told. However, it doesn't hold up to examination after one learns the ending. That is, the statements made are not logical for what she would actually be thinking. For example: They shouldn’t be accepting guests here if a crime had been committed. >>>> She knew no crime had been committed.
“Was there a murder here?” I asked quite shaken. >>>> Why would she be "quite shaken" when she knew exactly what was going on? She might be acting and appear to be "quite shaken". In retrospect, it appears these lines were written to fool the reader but are not an honest representation of what she would be feeling and thinking under the circumstances.

I also have a few other suggestions for your consideration:

with blood on them,” the detective said[. ](,)“[A](a)nd don’t let anyone

seemed to be friendly here[. S](, s)o unusual for a Florida

“Ma'am," the detective yelled[. "P](, "p)lease[,] stay away from

“Sorry,” I said[,](.) “Was there a problem?

“Nothing to worry,[ M](m)iss,” the groundskeeper said.

“No, [M](m)iss. Nothing’s missing

“Well, [M](m)iss[. T](, t)hat nothing is something.”

the detective said[. ](,)“I need you

buy out Pilgrim’s Inn(,) and he set you

a cow(,)and the maid said she

“Now I know what it is[,](.)” The detective reached

You are a good writer, but I feel you might could rework this story a bit.

Cheers!

Harry
309
309
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Kay ~

I found this to be well-written and to hold my interest throughout. It is a nicely told story. You convey your feelings at the events quite well.

I have only a couple of small things for you to consider:

taken their seats(,) and the two of us had

old-fashioned; nevertheless(,) those words were

Cheers!

Harry
310
310
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Judy ~

These seem like wise words to this parent/grandparent. As long as a child knows his parents will always love and support him unconditionally, things usually have a way of working out okay...even when he/she pulls the stupidiest stunt on earth.
*Smile*

This piece is well-written, I found no errors (a real rarity for me).

Cheers!

Harry
311
311
Review of Dead End  
Review by Harry
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Joy ~

This is an entertaining read that held my interest throughout. Overall, it is tightly and well written. I enjoyed it.

Just a few items for your consideration:

at Marge, a pretty(,) young blonde, telling

aims for[ the] first place. >>>> ?? Either 'for first place' OR 'for the first place award/prize/etc'

where is your [G](g)randfather?"

By mistake, I open a closet to find >>>> How does one open a closet in someone else's apartment by mistake if one is a private investigator?

He was in pain(,) and he didn't want to suffer

Marge blurts out[. "B](, "b)ut out of love

Cheers!

Harry
312
312
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Jane ~

This dream should help you handle your emotions from the death of your father and provide you with some comfort thinking your parents are now together and happy. It is filled with personal memories and feelings. As such, it belongs to you.

I did have somne suggestions for improving the technical aspects of the writing:

If he hadn't [of] died,

house[, i](. I)t is the house I grew up in, the house

I broke my collar bone[, ](;)thankfully that was all.

a [3](three-)bedroom(,) ranch house with [3](three) full bathrooms. >>>> Write out small numbers.

step into the 4 season 'porch' >>>> 'four-season porch'

used to get along(,) but(,) when he built this room, the animosity

game is flahsing on the television >>>> flashing

or [feel] (make) me (feel) better on days when I am missing him and [m](M)om.

sense of humor[,](.) I look like his paternal

"[h](H)i, Dad(,)"

work shirts there were stained yellow ?? >>> shirts. They were OR work shirts that were ??

gleaming with tears[, ](;)he is hurting[,](;) he is regretful[, ](;)he looks old

The wood still [lays](lies) across the rafters,

guilty(,) but at least I know

Cheers!

Harry
313
313
Review of Cats  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Pat ~

Modern Cinquain Structure

Line 1...one word
Line 2...two words
Line 3...three words
Line 4...4 words
Line 5... one word

Line 1 is a noun
Line 2 is two adjectives describing the title
Line 3 is three verbs/actions related to the title
Line 4 is a complete sentence of four words that describe a feeling about the title
Line 5 is one word referring back to the title

Your poem meets all the specified requirements. Indeed, it is very much like the Cats example provided with the directions. Your poem does capture the essence of cats well.

Cheers!

Harry
314
314
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, gypsyrose ~

This poem captures the many sides of music and what it can represent in people's lives to heal and soothe them and bring them joy and peace. It is a lovely piece.

Just a couple of suggestions:

I am the tires squeaking,ambulance (siren) screaming. ??

One day I will sound the trump as Angels escort Jesus >>>>> trump OR trumpet ??

Cheers!

Harry
315
315
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Jyo ~

This was a cute tale that fulfilled the prompt well. Talking cockroaches, eh? Quite entertaining.

You may wish to consider these points:

In (the) sudden assault of light that flooded

[n](N)o sooner was the thought

upright(,) and I could make out

I stammered in bewilderment(,) “I keep

house is off-limits(,) buddy;

was an empty threat[;](,) but what did cockroaches

Cheers!

Harry
316
316
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, NickiD89 ~

This appears to me to be an excellent poem written in pantoum form. It flows well and meets the specified requirements. Nicely done!

of free(-)willed thought, >>> in two lines

Cheers!

Harry
317
317
Review of Winter's Breath  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (4.5)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Shannon ~

This poem evokes great images. It has a lovely feel to it.

– ethereal flakes descending ever so slowly to greet me[.](,)
[A](a) hint of sound as their tiny bodies reach the earth.
>>>> My, you have great hearing!
>>>> The last line is not a complete sentence; so use comma and no capitalization.

I close my eyes and fall asleep[.](,)
[M](m)y lover’s kisses on my cheek.
>>>>> Same comment as stanza above.
>>>>> Falling asleep in the cold and snow might be dangerous!

Cheers!

Harry
318
318
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
A Simply Positive Group Sig For Reviewers.

Greetings, Isiterra ~

This is simply wonderful writing! It completely captures the reader and carries him along with your story. The flow is great. The story is entertaining. Of course, you must finish it! I enjoyed it immensely.

I have only a few minor items for your consideration:

“Yes(,)Lisette, it’s me, but

“Avast(,) ye currs!

barrel of ale[,](;) I’ve matters of importance

red(-)haired woman elbowed

“Unhand me this instant(,) kind sir,”

The half(-)wit drunkard

hat on her door[,] and locked it behind them.

equality of every man(,) and this belief had led him

after you left[,] and was planning on adding

Cheers!

Harry
319
319
Review of I Wonder  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Image ID #1447415 Unavailable **

Greetings, Diane ~

This poem is poignant in its message of feeling sorry and a bit guilty about not giving someone another chance and their ending their life. A word of advice to the person doing the wondering: You cannot be responsible for the actions of the other person. No need to have any guilty feelings, just sorrow over his actions.

The punctuation is amiss in several places in this poem:

I didn't have the energy[,] [ ] = delete

So I said no[, ] and shut the door,

I wasn't there to stop you[,]

The bullets spun in the chamber(,) ( ) = insert
and(,) this time, one had your name on it.

Other than these minor commas changes, I have no suggestion to improve the poem. It is quite good as written.

Cheers!

Harry
320
320
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
** Image ID #1447415 Unavailable **

Greetings, jmpdk3:on vaca 'till 7/21 ~

This is a wonderful dream you had. It is touching and poignant. You do a great job of recounting it here.

I have a number of grammatical suggestions for you to consider:

Use a semicolon instead of a comma to separate two sentences, as here:

I feel at home[,](;) I am home.

The floating is serene, habit forming[,](;) it makes me happy.

with my mother[,](;) I thank her. Aunt Hettie smiles(,) and she is radiant.

Her hands are empty(,) and from this, I know she

we are reminded of her[,](;)sometimes we smile[, ](;)sometimes we cry, but we are reminded(,) and that is our peace for now.

It is not an old, decaying smell[, ](;)she is fresh,

not be doing this(,) but it feels too good

was a rusted(,) old, five(-)foot(-)long handsaw blade with pointy teeth

swaying(,) but my mother lifts

want her to go(,) but I know

again(,) but heaven does not

back my tears(,) but they overpower me.

Cheers!

Harry
321
321
Review of My Plea  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Image ID #1447415 Unavailable **

Greetings, just returning home ~

This delivers your plea extremely well. Your message is clear. Poignant writing!

The main suggestion I have for this piece is that it cries out for punctuation throughout. Punctuation would guide the reader as to correct reading of the lines.
Additionally, I suggest not capitalizing every line but to only capitalize the start of a new sentence. This would also help the read also.

Still(,) I’m terrified to no possible end
[T](t)hat(,) with stability stolen, I left unable to bend(.)
>>>>> I left unable to bend?? Unclear & awkward wording.
So(,) baby, please try to see from my red. swollen eyes(.)
Strain if you must to hear my muffled cries(.)

Something so repulsive and repelling must dwell here(.)
Yet, no where I get(,) as calmly I peer >>>> No where I get??
[D](d)eep inside your soul to make sense of what haunts you(,)
[T](t)o learn what it is that feverishly grabs(,) drawing you

[T](t)o pick up that glass of bitter sick whiskey(.)

Please put an[d] end to my anguish(-)filled sorrow(,) >>>>>an end
[A](a)nd we will live to see a million tomorrows(.)

This would be a much more powerful read if sentence were clearly defined by appropriate capitalization and punctuation.

Cheers!

Harry
322
322
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Greetings, Megan ~

As another outstanding poem of respect for fallen soldiers, this poem is quite moving. Your descriptions paint the scene so well one can see themselves there paying tribute and listening to the "clear dulcet tones as the bugler sounds
echoed strains of the oft heard Last Post." Excellent writing!

Cheers!

Harry
323
323
Review of THE MEMORIAL WALL  
Review by Harry
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Greetings, Megan ~

This is a very well-written, well-rhymed poem with a wonderful message of tribute to fallen soldiers. This is really quite excellent!

( I can see now why the title of my poem caught your eye.)

Cheers!

Harry
324
324
Review of Alone  
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Image ID #1447415 Unavailable **

Greetings, Sophy ~

Perfect! Truly a perfect poem, one which I have nothing to suggest in the way of any improvement (a real rarity for me!). Excellent writing!

Cheers!

Harry
325
325
Review by Harry
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Image ID #1447415 Unavailable **

Greetings, Legerdemain ~

What a sweet moment to be reminded of every year. I much enjoyed your story. It captured well the joy of having a small child. Nicely written!

I have only a few items for your consideration:

set him down(,) and he crawled up next

the flower had faded(,) and the huge red petals had fallen

looked at me with sad(,) little(,) brown eyes.

then said, “Could we blow up another one? (") >>> end quotation marks omitted

The sight of tulips every year[, ]brings to mind this moment in my life.
>>>> omit comma

Cheers!

Harry
485 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 20 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/harryg/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/13