*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/scottiegaz/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2
Review Requests: OFF
890 Public Reviews Given
961 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 -2- 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Next
26
26
Review of Chloris  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
I am reviewing your story as a judge for "Quotation Inspiration: Official Contest Thanks for entering!

Wow, this is certainly a very interesting take on the quote! Definitely unique. I like the story idea. A few things that stood out as I read.

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: I found no spelling errors, but you had a couple of punctuation problems. These are a few that stood out, but you may have some more.

I also don't understand the title and its relation to the story. I would also suggest you revise the brief description to draw more readers in by telling about the story; this will encourage more people to read it.

see she was cleaned up, and fed no comma

of the City. lowercase 'city'

An hour later April was in custody comma after 'later', no extra space

She sat on the bed in a hospital gown watching something invisible, as it moved around her little room. no comma

She was murmuring, or perhaps chanting something just this I would use - - to seperate 'or perhaps chanting'; if you don't, then you need a comma after 'chanting'

That was good, she was still relating to the world outside of her own mind Runon sentence; I would either break it up, or use a semicolon instead of a comma

Either she didn't know, or refused to answer questions related same with the hyphens from before; either dashes or commas after 'questions' to seperate the clause

and said, "don't worry, it'll be alright in the Spring." capitalize 'don't', lowercase 'spring'

Blond and blue lowercase 'blond'

April had moved in the hour, or so since I last saw her no comma needed

firing Babs, and me no comma

*Leaf5*In terms of content: This was a very intriguing piece, but it felt more like you summarized than actually told a story. Try to give some more details and some action. You catch a lot of the surface, but it doesn't draw us in because it doesn't feel like we are part of the scene. You also have several awkward lines and transitions.

They brought April, no last name, to our facility during the middle of the graveyard shift. I work the graveyard most nights, and I was there when the cops brought April in. This is a little repetitive. You've repeated both the time and the fact that they brought April in.

Someone reported a naked woman Your transition between paragraphs is a little jerky. In the last paragraph you were talking first about her admittance, THEN about what would happen to her, and now you are back to her admittance. I would suggest moving the section about her being a 5150PC to a seperate paragraph, and moving this information into the first.

At our facility patients dumped on us by the police This is a very confusing sentence. I think it's the 'at our facility' startout. I would consider another way of phrasing it.

She was as clean, perfumed and powdered as a baby. This is awkwardly phrased.

I introduced myself, and asked if she'd mind answering a few necessary questions Your story feels very summarized, more 'show' than 'tell', and this is a perfect example of it. You need to give us more details of the exchange here, more of the action. Give us more details, let us actually see her. *Laugh*

knew her name was April. April's responses Repetition

the characteristics we've come to associate the 'we' is awkward here. Who is 'we'?

"Wish I could help you, This begins a long block of dialogue. Aren't you a bit more conversational on the phone? Speaking to each other? It just feels a little awkward, especially since it is basically the only 'speaking' in the story.

As we walked down the corridor it suddenly struck me how quiet the facility had become. It's a short corridor, so we arrived at C-12 before the quiet completely registered. This doesn't make sense. Wait, first it 'suddenly strikes' that it is quiet, but it doesn't really register? This doesn't quite make sense.

It didn't seem dangerous to leave April with hair full of flowers, so I opted to leave her alone...I put away my textbook and went back to have another look. This is another place where you really skipped around. She went from standing in the hall to going back in to look.

I looked into April's room and almost collapsed. The room was filled with flowers; maybe enough flowers to empty out a couple of florist shops. I called Babs from her station, and together we went into the room. April was no longer in the room. Repetition

*Leaf3*Overall: You have a great premise here, but you leave us wanting a lot more. I'd love to see more details, to feel more attached to April and the narrator. If you put us into the scene, we will care more about April and the results.

Keep up the great work!


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

27
27
Review of Chick Flick Quiz  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Chick flicks! I bet I fail! I am browsing quizes, for some light reading, so of course the reviewer in me always comes out, LOL. I hope you find this review helpful!


*Leaf1*From a technical perspective:

for spidey is computerless's Getting to know WDC contest I would consider adding two links here. Use a suser link for spidey, and then a ritem or litem for the contest. It looks a little neater, and changes with whatever the new names are.

Again, I'd suggest choosing a consistant method for titling your movie titles, either italics, underlining, or quotes.

In "How to Lose a Guy" this character comma after 'guy'

*Leaf5*In terms of content:

Johnny Castle says, "Nobody puts Baby in a corner." Would you believe I didn't know that Castle was his lat name? LOL.

prepare to die Truly one of the best lines - the whole thing!

Hey, I think I actually did okay on this chick flick quiz! 13 out of 15! Let me see what I missed...Breakfast at Tiffany's and My Fair Lady. Oh, *Blush*! I guess I'm more of a modern chick flick chick!

*Leaf3*Overall: Thanks so much for the great quiz! I had fun taking it!

Quiz on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

28
28
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
I was looking for some neat quizzes and found yours! I don't know if I took your other Disney quiz or if that was a different author; it was about a month ago. Still, I have four kids, so of course I had to check this one out!


*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: There were a couple of technical errors I spotted.

i will give a quote capitalize 'I'

I would either underline, italicize, or put the title of the movies in quotes in each question.

from Mulan says "This comma after 'says'

from Cinderella says "There same

a *real* storm I would use italics for 'real' instead of stars

*Leaf5*In terms of content: There were some good quotes. Most of them I knew, some were vauge. (How long has it been since I saw The Black Cauldron? And I couldn't remember which stepsister was which in Cinderella. *Laugh*)

This is a pair to my Disney movie quiz. I'm not sure referring to a single quiz as a pair is correct. Seems like it would make more sense to call it one of a pair. As a side note, I would consider adding a link - litem or ritem - to your other quiz, which might lead more folks to that quiz, as well. Since it pops up when the quiz is finished, it would be a good way to keep 'em going.

In my movie quiz, I originally switched back I would move 'originally' to earlier in the sentence. In my original movie quiz

If you get stuck, feel free to use google or imdb.com to find the movies I give. A little awkward; I would change 'the movies I give' to 'the answers'.

All of your questions start 'This character...' Since you've already started off by stating that every one is a character quote, you could just put the quote in with the movie. You could either put the movie title where you currently have Name that character , or you could say, In "Tarzan," who said...

*Leaf3*Overall: I had a lot of fun with this quiz. I guess I guessed good! 14 out of 15! Woohoo!


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

29
29
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
Hi, and welcome to Writing.com! I hope you enjoy your time on the site. Here are a few thoughts I had as I read through your item.

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: This was a fairly polished piece. I found no spelling errors, and only one puncutation problem here:

we returned sleepily, to our den. no comma needed

*Leaf5*In terms of content: You have some great images here, but you rely too much on 'like' and 'as' to include them. Try to write them into the piece a little more smoothly. But in terms of description, I think you have the soul of a poet.

As the moon rose like a diamond in the sky at night I love this image, but I think the 'at night' is unnecessary; you wouldn't describe the moon in the daytime as a diamond.

when the sun came up. The sun was as yellow Repetition of 'the sun'; I would consider replacing the second one with 'it'.

The blue sky had almost no clouds at all. The sky was as blue as the sea. Repetition

We were terrified by the sound and the destruction they were making. Who was making? This is randomly introduced. You need to clarify this. You also need a paragraph break here and throughout the piece.

people were coming towards us at a high speed. This starts moving too fast. You need to clarify what is happening. You need to clarify and explain some more.

You have compressed too much information into too short of a time here. I think that if you describe more details into what is happening, this will be even more heart-wrenching. Also, you need to break this item into paragraphs as needed.

*Leaf3*Overall: This story has a lot of potential, and if you take the time to further develop it, I think it will be truly awesome!

Welcome to the site, and write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

30
30
Review of The Cottage Door  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (5.0)
I was on my way through to your fiction and found your folder. This has to be one of the best folder intros I have ever found in my life. And now I see the graphics have a source! <evil laugh> This is great organization. I like the idea of the diamonds in the rough, as well. What an intriguing way to get people to page through your port! I like the way you use the graphics as links to the invidual folders. This is an awesome folder!

Write on!

SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

31
31
Review of What If  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
 *Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3*Welcome to Writing.com!!!*Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1* 


Hi, and welcome to the site! These are some very interesting questions you pose. I found no punctuation errors, and just one spelling/word usage problem: everyday we had every day in this context is two words, not one.

One thing that was sort of inconsistant was that, sometimes you provide answers to your questions within your questions, and sometimes you don't. It breaks the flow of the piece. !And somewhat passive-agressive! *Laugh*

These are certainly something to think about. However, other than the answers you give within the questions, I'm not sure what purpose you are striving for. I think you might be able to find another way to make your point.

Thanks for posting, and welcome to the site!
SG



** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

32
32
Review of Disney Movie Quiz  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hi! I found this poll via a review on the public reviewing page. I've got way too many kids, so I just had to check it out! *Laugh*

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective:

soon she stars getting starts

Wish I could be, part of that world no comma

Name that Movie!: no exclamation point

Because a cat's the only cat, who knows no comma


*Leaf5*In terms of content:

I have always been a big fan of Disney movies. This quiz will test your knowledge of Disney movies. Repetitive

(*sung*)"We're clearly soldiers I'm not sure why you include 'sung' here, when you didn't put it in other instances from song lines. I would omit it here, as well. You also have the same problem in #12

Also, you alternate between "Name that movie" and "Name that Disney movie". I would pick one and be consistant.

This is a really cute quiz. I think I recognize the majority, but let me scurry off and take it...Woohoo! Count me in the 100% list! I had to guess #3, but it was an educated guess. By the way, this is my favorite line...Though we adore men individually, we agree that as a group they're rather stupid. *Laugh* I just watched that movie Saturday night

*Leaf3*Overall: This is a great quiz, very funny! I really enjoyed it. I'm starting to worry, though, because I scored 100%. Ugh.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

33
33
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
I saw the public review you received of this item, and so of course I had to drop by and take a peek. This is a great way to shrug off those low R&Rs.


*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: I found no spelling, punctuation, grammatical, or other technical errors in this piece. Very cleaned up and well polished.

*Leaf5*In terms of content: I liked the humerous look at the low rates. I think this is definitely a preferable response to some of the low rates given on the site.

There was only one thing that bothered me. Mind you, this is not a flaw as much as a notation; I would be remiss not to share. Some of the low rates on this site are deserved. I realize that this poem is aimed at the undeserved 2 on a good piece, but unfortunately there are times when a 2 is deserved but the author thinks a 4 or 5 is. They might also receive far too many inflated rates that convince them the 2 is a "mistake". After reading this, I could see them feeling (further) justified and not paying any attention to anything helpful in the review. --> Okay, I had to put that in, although I know that wasn't the readership you were aiming for. *Wink*

*Leaf3*Overall: This is a funny and reassuring response to those uncalled for low rates. I'm sure you've had many good review of the piece! *Laugh*

(But did you get any 2.5s, that is the question?!)

Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

34
34
Review of The Maze  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! A very desolate poem. You do a good job of capturing a lot of painful emotions. I only saw four technical problems:

You dont look don't
A furocious beast ferocious
Theres nothing to save there's
Is all i want. Your capitalization is normal elsewhere, so I would capitalize 'I' here

You do a great job of setting the mood. The tone is dark and daunting.

Side note: I wouldn't sell yourself short in the brief description. It turns away readers and reviewers. Use it as an attention-getter to bring readers into the piece.

Welcome to the site, and write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

35
35
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! This is a cute story and the identity of the thief surprised me. On a side note, I'm not sure what the 'moaning' part of the title is; that part doesn't fit the story. But otherwise, I think you did a good job of creating an interesting title and brief description. They both drew me in. Also, I always recommend that you double space between paragraphs. You will quickly find that reading things on the computer is hard on the eyes, and those extra spaces make a world of difference. A lot of people skip items with large blocks of text and no spaces for that reason.

A few things that stood out as I read:

What ever one word

along while a long while

It also was for the whole family but it was also good for one person or animal. This sentence was very long and vague; it's tough to know what it means and it feels unnecessary.

Especially the father ,who no space before the comma; you do this several times

not just only plain cheese Too wordy; either 'not just' or 'not only'

mouth watering pizza mouth-watering

Before we get too far lets back up comma after 'far', let's

In the kitchen where the mother is cooking. Incomplete sentence; either join to the previous or flesh out to make a full sentence.

mother had token out taken

the thief made its move. He grabbed Since you are going to tell us the sex of the thief, and since it is a person, don't use 'its', use 'his'

You get jumpy with the time. Why not just start with the thieving and omit the first paragraph all together? It is unnecessary and doesn't give any different information than the recap.

The mother got cooking another pizza started cooking

I just could take a bit of it right now bite
You interject the narrator here, when he/she wasn't there before. This changes the point of view of the story and is a little awkward for the reading. Either you need to put the 'I' perspective in at the beginning or cut it from the rest.

I was reminiscing about the new pizza Wrong word. You can't reminisce - fondly remember - something that is new. Perhaps you would with the old pizza, but then again, you don't usually use that strong of a word for a piece of food you never even saw. Also, the transition from this to 'when I heard' is awkward; you have two different actions occuring at the same time AND one after the other (as, when). NOTE: on the initial read, I thought you used the wrong word but now I see it is right. I still think it is too strong because you are trying to be subtle, and this blows subtle out the window.

the dog is licking the crumbs off the floor,” said the father with a sigh. Man, the crumbs were good Ah, at last, now we know who the narrator is. You need a few more clues a little further back that support this.

You do not need people food,” He said, “your getting lowercase 'he', you're

I have date with a pizza and no one’s going to get in the way. *Laugh* Hysterical!

I really thought this was a cute story. It could have used a little more fleshing out, and it needed to be polished, but the narrator was funny and somewhat unique, and I liked the twist at the end.

Welcome to the site, and write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

36
36
Review of She can  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! We're glad to have you aboard!

One tip that I like to give newbies is to double space between paragraphs. It's amazing how hard on the eyes it is to read stuff on the computer, and double spacing between paragraphs makes it a little easier on the eyes. You'd be surprised how often folks will skip reading something because it is a big block of text on the screen. Indenting is good, too; I just realized you did that. However, not all of your paragraphs are indented, so make sure you are consistant.

You have a couple of technical errors that need to be cleaned up.

the teachers eyes teacher's

the words seems to blur seem

Looking up she sees her teacher comma after 'up'

The teacher's voice booms over the hall, "And this starts period after 'hall'

And she walks away, and Christa breathes a sigh of relief. Don't start your sentence with 'and', especially if you are going to repeat it so close.

Focussing now focusing

She smiles round at them, "OK, around, period after 'them'

25 minutes later When a sentence starts with a number, you need to spell out that number ('twenty-five')

Christa smiles at her teacher, "OK miss, onceyou shut up!" And runs off laughing Period after 'teacher', space between 'once' and 'you' and period after 'laughing'.

This is an interesting story. I was wondering how the title fit in with the story, but by the end, I got it. I like the message here, and the way you communicate Christa's uncertainty. I think you do a good job of setting the scene here. It is very realistic. I'm, um, not completely sure I follow her comment at the end, but I definitely got the idea that she was far more relaxed and lighthearted. Maybe it is a cultural difference, but if my kids talked to the their teacher like that, they would be in trouble for being disrespectful.

Welcome to the site!
Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

37
37
Review of Unspoken  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! This is a very interesting poem. (Incidentally, I would consider labeling this as poetry, not prose.) I only found one technical error:

Her shear force sheer

This is an interesting poem. I didn't realize until I looked again at your brief description that this is something you observed. You don't quite pick that up from your poem. I like how you take it from two perspectives, although I have a difficult time seeing how they merge.

You make some interesting points and ask good questions in your poem. I like the compass parallel.

Welcome again to the site. Keep up the great work!
Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

38
38
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! Normally, I keep my reviews for new members a bit briefer. However, I feel that this is a very clean and well-written piece by someone with obvious talent, so please know that my feedback is aimed at helping you to make a good piece even better.

I really enjoyed this story, although it is obviously not finished. It did leave me wanting more. If you choose to sign up on the site, I would consider putting this into a book and breaking it up into chapters. That said, it works fine as is. Following are my thoughts as I read through the story thus far. It was very enjoyable.

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: I always recommend that you never select 'other' as an option for either the genre or the type, because this limits where your writing is listed. Instead, pick three genres to maximize your visibility. I'd label this a 'short story', as well.

Valen tried to fix is gaze his gaze

His eyes turned to the soldiers further to the north and along the choked ravine, they were just silhouettes in the last of the days light and like him, moved wearily. This is a run-on sentence. I would personally recommend breaking it in two and starting a second one with 'They were just...', but if you want to keep it as one thought, the comma should be changed to a semicolon.

his Grandfathers sword lowercase 'grandfather', and it should be grandfather's

for the reason you think man. comma after 'think'

the man had put it to him Capitalize 'the' at the begining of the sentence.

He considered the question before giving his answer, “It’s my period after 'answer'

he had added “My Grandfather was a warrior”. your punctuation is off. he had added, “My Grandfather was a warrior. You do this a couple of other times. Make sure that you put your punctuation inside the quotation marks. then find me again”. again." There are several other places.

Behind him the dull comma after 'him'

“Shields!” without thinking he called the order. This is two sentences, so capitalize the 'without'. You have a similar problem with the punctuation around your sentences. A great reference piece for help on punctuation and formation around dialogue is "Dialogue.

He then stayed by the horse leaning on it heavily comma after 'horse'

The boys had just finished their archery competition, on the edge of the forest no comma

we wont be back home won't

*Leaf5*In terms of content:

Snowflakes hung suspended in the late afternoon air; not seeming to fall but just dance lazily in the faint breeze as if unwilling to relinquish their individual beauty to the endless carpet of their fallen comrades. Wow, what a great way to open the story! There are some great images here, and you really capture the moment. However, for a sentence, it is a bit long. I would consider breaking it into two; end the first one at 'air' and then make the second read They seemed not to fall but..., or something to that effect. This makes it not quite as confusing and much easier to follow.

You have several sentences that tend towards being too lengthy. The problem isn't wordiness, because you have some wonderful images that I don't think need to be trimmed or cleaned (which is what most people need to do). Instead, it is just too difficult to follow them from one end to the other. Simply cutting them into two (or maybe three, depending on the sentences) would make them flow easier, allowing the reader to enjoy what you have painted far more completely. I have listed a couple of examples here as noted, but it is always possible that <gasp> I may have missed something, so read back through it yourself. A good tip to check on flow is to read your work out-loud; you'd be amazed what you catch when you do that. So, anyway, what I noticed:
He threw another snowball...
As Orn turned his eyes uneasily back
We need to head for home


He threw another snowball at the outcropping of rock Wait, he has yet to throw the first snowball, so a second is a bit premature. I would just change 'another' to 'a'.

It was hardest on the old and the very young, Valen reflected, not even being allowed fires added to the misery if that was possible. Runon; start a second one with 'not', and I would cut out 'even' to clean it up. My opinion - which of course is the majority of this review *Wink* - is that you should clean up the phrase "not even being allowed fires" and try to make it a little smoother. I am trying to think of an example way I would clean it up, but I think it can only be done with the addition of more facts. (I am writing this before reading further, so I am unsure yet why they could not have fires, but this is for purposes of example.) Fires would attract unwanted attention, and so they suffered through the miserable cold without even the hope of warmth in the evening. Hopefully this gives you the idea of what I am trying to convey. *Smile*

At least he couldn’t actually remember the last time he had been anyway. The combination of 'at least' and 'anyway' makes this a bit wordy; I would cut one or the other.

Snow fell from Valen’s cloak as he stood up with the last group of refugees. At this point, I am finally understanding what is going on. I see that he is not a soldier but a refugee. I'm trying to decide if this information should have come sooner, but I don't think so. I think this information comes in very well placed, and I like the fact that you have done it so subtly. *Thumbsup**Thumbsup*

Orn neither liked nor disliked the Captain but he had developed a respect for him over the last couple of days. Prior to that Orn had had no contact with him. This information, while pertinent, does not fit in this section. Here we are in the middle of action. This information might better be given a little sooner or later, so as not to break the flow of the action.

I think we’ll have a very heavy blizzard, but it should only last about 20 minutes or so This doesn't seem to make sense to me. One would think a heavy blizzard would last longer than 20 minutes. Now, a heavy snow might only take 20 minutes.

As a final note, this is obviously incomplete. I recommend a couple of things. At a minimum, I would label it as a draft. However, I would consider waiting to post until you are finished. Otherwise, you will get 'half rates'. People will rate you, for instance, for an inconclusive ending because it's not finished. You'll wind up with lower rates than you might have received with a finished piece. Anyway, just something to consider.

*Leaf3*Overall:
I really enjoyed this piece. You have some great images, and do a great job of describing the scene and setting the mood. You have quite a way with words. There are a few technical points you could hit on to clean this up, and I think that you could make the transitions between sections a little cleaner (the first and second chapter seem unrelated but I realize you are not yet finished), but overall you do a great job.

Welcome to the site! Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

39
39
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! As a mom of a 6 year old who loves to dance, I can see this so very clearly. Just your title and brief description are so charming and well defined that images come from them alone. The two of those just draw you in!

Once I opened it, I really liked the way you managed to paint with words. You capture the different aspects of the dance very well. Just a note: most of your phrases are shorter and jerky, so this one stands out because it is so long:
Mind and body become one with the music and it is clear the natural grace comes from within.
I would consider breaking it into two.

From a slightly advanced writing perspective, something to consider. You are writing a piece about grace and smooth movements, but your sentences are somewhat jerky and don't quite flow. I think that would really give this piece an added kick. Mind you, that's a very technical piece of writing and somewhat difficult to pull off, but it might be soemthing to consider.

Otherwise, this is a very descriptive piece. Welcome to the site, and write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

40
40
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! This is an interesting piece, very introspective and insightful. Here are a few thoughts I had as I read through.

I couldn’t help but wonder. You draw us in with this but then do not tell us what, precisely, you are wondering. Which leaves us wondering!

The nature of the fog was nearly that of a liquid; a thick, impenetrable wall that offered no suggestion of a world beyond. use a comma instead of a semicolon. I really like the image of "a thick impenetrable wall."

At first I was tense, fearing I would be stumbled upon by some unseen traveler, then relaxing, realizing I was in no danger, I fell into a state of meditation. This sentence is a little hard to follow. I think it is the use of 'then' with the relaxing/realizing combination. I also think that you should put the idea of relaxing AFTER you realized you were not in danger; otherwise we wonder why you are relaxing, and it just gets a bit confusing. I would consider breaking it into two sentences, but if you want to keep it together, perhaps, but as I realized I was in no danger, I relaxed and fell into...

“My son” the voice said. comma after son "My son,"

A few things that might help you get more readers and reviewers, things you might not know as someone new to the site. I think your title is great, but I would suggest a different brief description. Think of the bd as a tagline, like on a movie poster or the cover of the book, the aim being to draw the reader/viewer in. You want something that catches attention, rather than being blase or talking about the writing process. I would also consider double spacing between paragraphs, as many online readers will skip a whole page of text with no blanks between it; double spacing between paragraphs is just easier on the eyes for computer readers. Finally, I recommend absolutely never selecting 'other' as a type or genre. When people are browsing for things to read, by type or genre, you'll note that there is no list for 'other'; they cannot browse through your piece. Also, if someone is using the search function, they might pass yours by, not sure if it is a story, poem, essay, etc. Genres and types give people a better idea of what they will get when they read through. I would suggest 'short story' or 'fiction' here, although 'nonfiction' might also work if you would prefer it viewed as such. I would also select three - the maximum number of - genres, making it more available for browsing. Some to consider are 'inspirational', 'religious', 'emotional', 'personal', 'philosophy', or 'spiritual'.

I think you have a good directional aim with this. I like the message behind it, and I think you have a way with images. Keep up the good work, and welcome again to the site!

Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

41
41
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


LOL, it's me again! I actually just opened the "read a newbie" page, and this item was at the top of the list. As a runner (okay, an ex-runner), I was already going to read it, but seeing my favorite newbie author simply ensured that!

Another great piece. As I told you before, you have great talent as a writer. You have a great sense of humor, and a good eye for images. This piece was no exception. I really enjoyed reading it. Following are some of my thoughts as I went through it.

New Year's resolutions for me are a brilliant measuring stick to keep track of the year's failures. Ugh! What a horrible way to look at resolutions! Now I know why I don't ever make them! *Wink*

I can't believe I paid forty bucks just to run Whew! That is a little high for a 5K. I think most of the ones I ran in - I only did a couple road races, mind you - were in the $20-25 range. Then again, it's been a few...five...okay, I admit, nearly ten years, so I guess they could be up there. But still, eep!

I read something interesting. The book is called Discipleship Essentials by Greg Ogden I would combine these two sentences. For instance, In Greg Ogden's Discipleship Essentials, it says: This makes things a little smoother, in my opinion. It also cuts out the passive voice in the second sentence, and of course is less wordy.

This running thing for instance. comma after 'thing'

Shaved my legs. You're welcome. *Bigsmile* Hysterical!

to stock up on Runner's Essentials I'm not sure this needs to be capitalized, although you could put it in quotes, like "Runner's Essentials", which I think might give you a little more of a tounge-in-cheek feel for it. That's definitely my opinion, of course, not so much a "serious grammatical change," LOL.

Took two aleve Aleve is a proper noun so needs to be capitalzied. The same with Snickers.

But I guess they can't really call them choclate peanut butter tree bark, or vanilla nut chalk, or berry berry tasteless. ROTFL! You have a fantastic sense of humor!

I have only been running for 3 weeks. Before that, it had been like three years You need to be consistant in how you are utilizing numbers. Personally, I prefer to spell them out, but I think you would be grammatically correct in using a '3' in both cases. Either way, you need to pick a consistant usage.

I think I bought defective power bars, because I never felt any surges of power. ROTFL! I think they are all defective...

Six year olds were passing me. A girl wearing a shirt that said "It's my first race!" passed me. I thought, "It's my first race, too. Can I have a piggyback?" Speaking of piggybacks, a guy carrying his 7 or 8 year old daughter on his back passed me. Oh my goodness! I about died through this whole paragraph. And even though I read it in your blog last night, it killed me again reading it today! It is very well written and quite humorous!

As I was running in the middle of it, I had the strangest feeling of buoyancy - like I was in a small fishing boat on the ocean. When you are watching a thousand heads bob up and down, and you are bobbing along with them, the simultaneous movement gives the effect of a restless sea, both visually and physically. This is a fantastic image.

I think that's what I was lacking in the Groundhog's Race...a proper reward at the finish line. Oh my goodness! *Laugh*

All in all, a great piece. Welcome, again, to the site. And let me add this note at the general audience on the public review page, as this is being posted there: Hey, folks looking for something good to read?! Check out erinjonesphotography 's portfolio! *Wink*

Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

42
42
Review of Soul For Sale  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (4.5)
There were several public reviews of this item that really drew me to this piece. As soon as I opened it, I was glad I did.

“Who the hell allowed that soul to be bid on?” The manager glared at those huddled in groups on the eBay lawn. “For heaven’s sake ROTFL! This is a great piece of subtle irony.

both Raphael and Jophielcalled Gabriel need a space btw 'Jophiel' and 'called'

Many eBay employees fell to their knees in supplication Ooh, a missionary bidding!

went down to Beelzebub that his last bid was trumped You forgot to bold Beelzebub.

From a logical perspective, it looks like there were 3.5 hours between the time the manager ran inside and the time Beelzebub entered his next bid. So not quite minute-to-minute. The time gaps you use actually seem to contradict the fast pace of the story I originally read it as. Now, granted, the battle for souls is more long term than a minute-by-minute thing, and I may easily have missed somethign. It just feels like the pace of the story is a lot faster than the time clicker reveals.

This is a great piece of writing, very enjoyable. I like the unique modern perspective.

I know this is for the Cramp, and maybe less likely up for revision (and also under word count limitations). That said, from a Christian perspective, it might be interesting to see a little more behind the scenes. In "real life," bidding wouldn't be the way to go; the behind-the-scenes parallel would make for an even more intriguing story.

This is a fantastic story for the Cramp, for a 24 hour period and a short limitation. It's an awesome story otherwise, one I'd love to see fleshed out a bit more.

Keep up the great work!
SG
43
43
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Hi, and welcome to the site! Your title and brief description really drew me into this piece. The very idea cracks me up! One of the reason I love cats is because they are so durn independant! *Laugh* Incidentally, I would not label anything with a genre type of 'other'. When people are browsing for a type of item to read (story, poetry, essay, etc), they cannot select 'other'. By labeling this as an essay (or whatever it is, for otehr pieces), you give your writing a wider audience base, thus increasing the number of readers and reviewers.

This is a very polished piece. I really enjoyed it. Most of what I spotted was very tiny and nit-picky, little things that break up a great article. Very well written!

giving kitty a lot of time You either need to make this 'a kitty' or 'Kitty' (capitalized, as a name)

your cats needs cat's

Cats do not like to eat or drink near where they are expected to eliminate, make sure to keep those areas separate. This is a run-on sentence. Either you need to break it into two sentences, or change your comma to a semicolon.

If it is too tall your kitten may not comma after 'tall'

Use treats or praise when your cat uses it and this will save your furniture quickly. Repetitive

These posts can be stand up types, ones that lay on the floor, and even ones that hang from a doorknob. The use of 'ones' is a little awkward. Consider trimming it down; the easiest way is to make your noun into a verb. These posts can stand up, lay on the floor, or even hang from a doorknob.

your cats paw cat's

Howl, ignore him, and let your hand hang limp as if it is hurt very badly. ROTFL! *Laugh* I know you didn't mean this as funny, but I can just imagine sitting there, howling at my (imaginary) cat. I wonder if this would work when my 2 yo bites me?

This helps both to be a little calmer I would specify both what; both roommates, housemates, pet and owner, what-have-you.

You have done a fantastic job with this. Welcome to the site, and I hope you enjoy your time here!

Write on!
SG
44
44
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*



Hi, me again! I told you I'd be back! I'm giving you a little bit "tougher" review, because you seem to have some talent; my newbie reviews in general are not so nit-picky, but I don't think this is too severe. However, I will let you know that this is my opinion, so take it with a grain of salt. *Wink*

So these were the things that stood out as I read through:

This may come as a shock, but I have made it to the age of 28 without, to my knowledge, EVER having a tick on me. First off, as a Southern girl, I am amazed! I don't think I even made it to the age of 5! Maybe not even 3! *Laugh* That said, this sentence is a little awkward; it's the 'to my knowledge' insertion. It might run a little smoother at the end, such as without EVER having a tick on me - at least, not to my knowledge. Just a thought.

I may have escaped ticks, but I did not escape the girly predisposition of being seriously disgusted by bugs of all kinds. This is a great sentence, but it doesn't stand so well by itself. I would do one of two things: either cut the first part and add the rest (from "But I did not escape..." on) to the first paragraph, OR (my suggestion) add it to the next paragraph.

my filthy 4 yr old boy spell out 'four year'; taken 10 men 'ten'

when I saw it, latched onto his innocent little shoulder, but I think tanner No comma, capitalize 'Tanner' (you have a couple spots where Tanner needs to be capitalized)

Thus, began the hysteria. no comma

Tanner took one look at the tweezers and they may as well have been a chainsaw. You change tenses; from 'took' to 'have been'; 'they might has well have been'.

feeling very alone in this big bad world full of ticks *Laugh* Hysterical!

Next time, though, I'm calling 911. You are killing me here! *Bigsmile*

This is a great article. I love your title, although I might suggest a little more more intriguing brief description. Think of the bd as the tagline for a movie or book, to encourage you to pick it up. "It was a standoff, him or me." *Wink* I'd also suggest again that you label it as an article rather than a documentary.

I really enjoyed reading this! I'm glad you are posting on this site, and I hope you post again and again! And good luck with your Mommy misadventures. I think this will make for a great blog or series!

Write on!
SG
45
45
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


Oh, this is funny! It's like the story of my life - and I'm a SAHM, even! I consider it a good day if I can get all my kids out of the house. And we had a Valentine's day mishap of our own with our Girl Scout troop, LOL.

You have a great voice, and I felt like you were sitting next to me telling me these things. I like your introduction; it really drew me in. And I peeked at your folder; it looks like you have another iteration. It looks like you are creating quite a journal here. If you decide to stay with us - and I hope you do! - I would consider compressing these all into entries in a book, for easier reading. As is, I would consider linking from one to the next, using a bitem link (let me know if you don't know how to do that, and I'll send you quick instructions).

From a technical perspective, however, your writing could use some cleaning up. You will get more reads and more reviews if you use correct capitalization. Your punctuation and writing style is very good, so I can only surmise that you intentionally put everything in lowercase, but I'll go ahead and tell you that this will actually keep many readers away. I'd also consider classifying this as an 'essay' rather than a 'documentary'; this will also bring in more readers.

This is a great essay on being a mom! Like I said, it hits home despite the fact that I'm a SAHM (never fear, I can't manage to show up with my makeup on at any point in time, LOL). Best wishes, and I'm off to check out your other misadventure!

Write on, and again, welcome to the site!
SG
46
46
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hey Viv! Someone asked me for a piece on point of view, and yours came up in the search. I know it is a newsletter so you may not be hankering to go back to it, but, you know, I can't read and not review! *Laugh*

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: No spelling, punctuation or other technical errors. This is very clean and polished, as I'd expect from you *Wink*. Good work!

*Leaf5*In terms of content: This was very helpful, and I really enjoyed it. A few thoughts as I read.

we have to force ourselves, if needed, to take those extra steps to write better stories. Ugh! Too true, too true! That's one thing I like about reviewing. It's easier to find errors in someone else's work, but as I become better at identifying the problems elsewhere, I get better at noticing them in my stuff, too!

the reader being confused. And a confused reader is vewy vewy bad! *Laugh*

Also not following the guidelines for the genre can result in readers who expect certain elements that are missing or misused. This sentence was a little confusing. I know what you are trying to say, but I had to reread it. I think the problem - for me - came from the changeover in subject midway through. I know this sentence is technically correct but *Blush* it was a little confusing.

*Picks up article and reads it.* This line was also a little confusing because I was thinking of your article. Maybe the original article?

It might have been interesting to have some links to articles regarding these subjects, or some examples for those who are less "in the know". Not a must-have, just something that might have been helpful for those seeking more...er...help.

*Leaf3*Overall: This was a great article. I think you made your points clearly and concisely, and did a good job of backing them up.

Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

47
47
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
*Balloon1**Balloon2**Balloon3* Welcome to Writing.com!!! *Balloon3**Balloon2**Balloon1*


This is a very interesting story. It has a great deal of possibility in it. I hope you find my feedback helpful; remember it is my opinion (the only kind I know how to give! *Bigsmile*).

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: Based on your brief description, I assume it is not yet finished so I would consider labeling it 'draft'. As a side note, I don't recomend posting unfinished pieces online, simply because you get rated on them while they are incomplete and then only a few folks come back to re-rate them once they are finished. I would suggest keeping it in a word processing file (Word, Works, Notepad, etc) until you are finished writing, and then posting. But that is just my suggestion. When you are finished (not before), I would recommend listing this as a short story. Also when you post, I suggest selecting three genres, which will give your item more exposure. More exposure = more readers = more reviewers.

There were a few technical errors I saw.

Harry Drake said, as he packed a bag. No comma here
Charlie asked, in a bored voice No comma here, either
parents evenings parent's
wondering if she'd been to harsh too

*Leaf5*In terms of content: You have a great premise here, and I'm interested in seeing where you go with it. A few errors that stood out...

Your sentences do a lot of as/in following the dialogue.
Harry Drake said, as he packed a bag.
Charlie asked, in a bored voice
her father said in a threatening voice.
he said as he switched off his laptop

It becomes very repetitive. Especially watch the "in a **** voice". Try to find another way to convey tone.

"Can we talk about this later?" he said as he wrote a list of things she wasn't supposed to do. This is very blase. Also, very unlikely. He could not write a whole list while making this statement. He might start on one, or finish one up, or continue writing, but he couldn't do a whole list unless he was just very very fast.

Or as she liked to call it This statement makes it sound like she gets this list a lot. So why would he bother writing it down?

At around 6 o'clock Mrs Greene came around to see if she needed anything. Charlie liked her and didn't like to put her to any trouble so she said she'd make herself something for dinner. There is a lot of 'telling' going on here and not so much showing. I would work on that some. A great article to demonstrate what I mean is "Invalid Item . I think you'll find it helpful.

Along those lines, I would like to see more action. You have a lot of dialogue-only segments that are difficult to follow. I would like to see a little more movement and description packed into those conversations.

*Leaf3*Overall: You have a great start here, and I am interested in seeing where you go with it. It has a lot of possibilities in it.

Welcome to the site, and write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

48
48
Review of LOVE & HEARTACHE  
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Hi! I found this contest through a link on the public review page, so here I am! I think this looks like a great idea. I think the review I actually found it through was yours; I followed a link in the review.

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: I found no spelling or punctuation errors. Although it is not an error, I would consider putting a space between an item of WritingML and the next word. For instance, instead of *Star*this, I would try *Star* this.

*Leaf5*In terms of content: I love the message and idea behind this forum. What a great way for newbies and near-newbies to come together and win some great prizes. You are to be commended for encouraging folks new to our site! *Thumbsup**Thumbsup*

That said, I noticed a couple of rough patches in your forum. The ones I spotted were:

For this contest we bend a little into 90 days old. Awkward. I would bend the rules a little

One poetry per round please. Either one poem or one piece of poetry

Out of weekly winners we will pick 1 as monthly winner. This reads a little awkwardly. I would also spell out 'one'. Consider something like We will select one weekly winner each month as an overall monthly winner. But without the repetition; that is the seat-of-my-pants suggestion to give you an idea of the structure I mean.

Post entry in BITEM FORMAT In a newbie item, I'd seriously consider a link to a bitem primer, just because a lot of these newbies don't know how to post. "Invalid Item is a really good one, I think.

GRAB TO BE WEEKLY PRIZES I don't understand the 'grab to be' part. It doesn't seem to make sense. Why not just list 'weekly prizes' and 'monthly prize'? (By the way, since there is only one monthly prize, the caption should be singular.)

PRIZES will INCREASE as DONATIONS will increase too. Also an awkwardly stated sentence. I would either cut out 'will' before 'increase' or change 'as' to 'when'. I would also delete 'too' in either case, as it is unnecessary and confusing.


*Leaf3*Overall: You have a great heart, and a wonderful way of motivating newbies. I am sure you have encouraged a lot of folks in their writing. With just a little cleanup, you can make this forum really sparkle!

Keep up the great work!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

49
49
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (3.5)
This is a very interesting work. I found it through the public reviewing page. The title caught my eye, and so I had to come and read.

*Leaf1*From a technical perspective: I found no spelling, punctuation, spacing, or other technial errors.

*Leaf5*In terms of content: This is an interesting thought, but I'm not sure it is all the way developed. I think you can stretch it a bit more. The introduction and conclusion take away from it, in my opinion. I don't think they are necessary, since most of your readers will have heard the "time is money" statement. Also, I'm not sure it is a pun as much as a play on words; they are two different things. I also don't quite get the principle/principal - not sure what the school dude has to do with it.

I think you make some good points. I really like the play in the second stanza about losing interest. Very sharp.

The other problem is, once you have our "interest", you don't really engage us. You just say we should take you at face value - but what, exactly, are we taking at face value? There really isn't a definitive statement made.

*Leaf3*Overall: I think with some real polishing, this has a lot of potential. You have a great nugget in there.

Write on!
SG

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

50
50
Review by Scottiegazelle
Rated: E | (5.0)
Wow, I can't believe I have never R&Red ya'll! It's rather mindboggling, you know. I've visited so often...*Bigsmile*

I found no spelling, spacing, punctuation or other technical errors. Your use of WritingML is well chosen. I really like the way you used the '=' as a line break! That is very cool and rather unique. I also like the fact that you don't have an excessive number of pictures or the like. Hmm, I did notice that you deleted/moved the list of folks who either contributed or who you gave merit badges. It makes the forum look very clean.

The message behind this forum is great. It was wonderful to recieve so much support from this group when I was doing long and in-depth reviews. It made me feel appreciated and encouraged me to review more. Not because of the gps (although those were cool) or the status; it was the recognition that really made a difference. I knew someone was noticing all of the work I put into the R&Rs. This was especially great when the author didn't like the review! *Laugh*

I am glad to see you guys helping so many folks. I am sure you will continue to help many others. Thank you so much for all of the support you have given me in the reviewing process. Keep up the awesome work!

SG

*Balloon5*It's my birthday!*Balloon5*
*Gift1*Have some gps!*Gift1*
*Balloon5*Hope ya like 'em!
*Balloon5*

326 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 14 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/scottiegaz/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/2