![]() |
A journey of self-improvement - or not. |
|
Sup? I'm Char. You may know me from timeless classics such as
and
I blog for things like
[Embed For Use By Upgraded+] Believin' all the lies that they're tellin' ya Buyin' all the products that they're sellin' ya They say jump and ya say "how high?" Ya braindead, ya got a fuckin' bullet in ya head |
Artist: Radiohead Song: Karma Police [Embed For Use By Upgraded+] This prompt is so deliciously 2019, right? There are a few different factors that play into it in my mind. Societal changes Things that were socially acceptable to say in 1999 aren't socially acceptable twenty years later in 2019. I'm sure some things that are socially acceptable today in 2019 will not be socially acceptable in 2039. That means all of us who have ever written anything on the internet have said something that could be potentially offensive twenty years in the future. There's no way to predict major societal shifts. Some things are harmless, if not a bit off-color, but aren't considered derogatory by today's standards. There's no guarantee of that in the future. When these things come up, it's important to look at the time frame in which they were said. You can't just something from 1990 in 2020 standards. It just doesn't work. Age Another thing to look at is the person's age when they said the questionable thing. I for one don't believe that something an 18 year old said holds the same weight as something a 45 year old said. At 45, you've had many years to mature and grow into a respectful, empathetic, and caring human. At 18 years old, your brain isn't even fully developed yet. You'll still be regularly making mistakes and hopefully learning along the way and growing as a person. It doesn't really work for someone in their 50s to say, "Well, gee, I was really young 10 years ago and I've since matured and grown as a person." But it can definitely be more reasonable for someone in their 30s to say, "Well, ya know, I was really young 10 years ago and my worldview was confused at the time/I was emotionally immature at the time, and I've since experienced more things and grown as a person." Context Of course, all of this depends on context. What was the person actually saying or trying to say? Was it within the context of some larger message or was it just a heinously cruel remark? Were they having an off-color sense of humor that went over well at the time, but goes over terribly now? Or were they being deliberately and maliciously hateful with no remorse? There are differences between these things. Intentions do matter regardless of what anyone thinks. There's a major difference between inciting rage-filled hatred toward a specific person or group of people and making a stupid, off-handed remark that gets buried within seconds. Did the person actively spend time building a following revolving around a cruel ideology or did they one time in 2007 say one sentence that could be seen as potentially problematic? Context is important The Redemption Arc™ And then there's the infamous Redemption Arc.™ People do make mistakes. Even whole-ass adults make mistakes all the time. Life isn't about being a perfect person and I'd readily challenge anyone who says that they have never uttered or written a sentence that could be viewed as potentially offensive to another person or group of people. I fully believe in people's ability to be better than the person they were yesterday. I think a person's ability to admit wrongdoing and attempt to make amends is worth a lot. If we don't give people that chance to improve, then what is the point in improving in the first place? Who is going to have the motivation to put forth effort in being a better person if they're just going to be shunned for their past mistakes anyway? We've all done it I would never call anyone out by name, but I've seen people casually drop some real zingers even here on WDC. Things that you'd totally be vilified for saying if you were in the public eye. I can honestly say that I don't believe anyone could find any history of me saying anything racist, sexist, homophobic, etc... against a group of people. It's just not in my personality and especially not in the 5 years I've been on WDC (which is my only 'social media'). However, I will readily admit that I have said things about religion that could be offensive. I have personal trauma related to my Catholic upbringing and I spent many years trying to avoid anything (or anyone) related to Catholicism and Christianity. I can almost feel myself mentally going, LALALALALA when I hear or read anything related to it. I've said some super mean things about the religion, and religion in general, obviously borne of angst and pain. My point is... people make mistakes and say stupid things sometimes. There is a lot to consider when thinking of accountability for things that have been said in the past. It's rarely black and white. Karma police, I've given all I can It's not enough, I've given all I can |