\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/forums/message_id/3273852
Item Icon
by River Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E · Message Forum · Reviewing · #2129067

A reviewing forum for those interested in improving their reviewing skills.

<< Previous  •  Message List  •  Next >>
Reply  •  Post New
Jun 2, 2019 at 7:22am
#3273852
June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little
by River Author IconMail Icon
June Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little

Some reviewers go line by line and correct the entire story.
Others simply say, This is fantastic!

Neither of these examples are reviews.

The first is an edit that does all the work for the author.
The second is a statement that tells the author nothing useful.

What is your happy medium?


Lilli ☕ Author IconMail Icon
Dandelion Man Author IconMail Icon
Alexi Author IconMail Icon
lollycrow Author IconMail Icon
Jayne Author IconMail Icon
queenkissy
Whata WackyBrew Author IconMail Icon
bobturn
Quick-Quill Author IconMail Icon
🌝 HuntersMoon Author IconMail Icon
Dave Author IconMail Icon
The Dark Faery Author IconMail Icon
Emily Author IconMail Icon
Mary Ann MCPhedran Author IconMail Icon

Please remember to reply to this original post so I can easily find your response.
At the end of the month, each participant will receive 1,000 GPs. An MB of my choice will be drawn by virtual dice.
MESSAGE THREAD
*Star*
June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-02-19 7:22am
by River Author IconMail Icon
Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-02-19 8:03am
by QPdoll Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Lit... · 06-02-19 8:07am
by Lilli ☕ Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Lit... · 06-02-19 3:56pm
by Whata WackyBrew Author IconMail Icon
Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-02-19 8:05am
by Lilli ☕ Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Lit... · 06-02-19 8:26am
by QPdoll Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too... · 06-02-19 4:13pm
by Lilli ☕ Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Lit... · 06-02-19 4:33pm
by Quick-Quill Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too... · 06-02-19 4:50pm
by Dandelion Man Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or... · 06-02-19 5:11pm
by Quick-Quill Author IconMail Icon
Re: Re: Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too... · 06-02-19 5:04pm
by Lilli ☕ Author IconMail Icon
Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-02-19 10:33am
by Past Member 'bobturn'
Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-02-19 4:00pm
by Whata WackyBrew Author IconMail Icon
Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-02-19 5:00pm
by Quick-Quill Author IconMail Icon
Re: June 2019 Discussion Topic ~ Too Much or Too Little · 06-23-19 6:32pm
by Dave Author IconMail Icon

The following applies to this forum item as a whole, not this post. Feedback sent here will go to the forum's owner, River.
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/forums/message_id/3273852