“How about we let HIM pick who he likes more?” Alex suggested as she folded her arms, shifting her foot as she felt you squish between her toes.
Creeper puffed her cheeks in annoyance, but figured that it'd at least be better than fighting over you.
Besides, you'd HAVE to pick her! She was the first and best friend you'd made! Alex had only known you for maybe… a little bit!
“...fine.” Creeper-Chan said, holding her hand out to shake. Alex looked at her with a bit of concern, before grasping the mob's hand and shaking it.
“Good. Lemme just pull the little guy out first…” The orange haired giantess chuckled, sitting down and working to remove her shoe!
“What're you doing?” Skella asked hushed as she pulled her explosive friend aside.
“It's fine! He'll pick us! Then we'll have our house back and go back to having fun!” She whispered confidently. Skella pursed her lips, not too sure about that…
Alex, not paying too much attention to the hushed conversation, slid her foot out of her shoe, looking down it to see the smushed lime green insole coating the interior. Reaching her fingers in, the player scraped you free, setting you down atop a chest.
“It's okay little slime…” Alex whispered, “I know you'll pick me…” She giggled before stepping back as the four giant girls looked down at you slowly pulling yourself together.
“UGH!” You gasped as you felt yourself over as your arms and limbs reformed, “Finally…” You groaned as you stumbled to your feet, “Stupid slime body…” You muttered. If you were still… solid, you could deal with this a bit.
“So…” Zoe asked, leaning over you, “Who are you picking?” Alex glared at her before pushing her back.
“Give him some space!” She demanded. You paused, turning to look at the four faces staring back at you.
Alex and Creeper were both looking confident, Skella looked like she was pouting at the idea of letting you pick, and Zoe was… licking her lips.
“And… whoever I pick, the other will be fine with it… right?” You ask, not too sure this would be the ‘peaceful’ resolution the others thought it'd be.
“Absolutely!” Creeper and Alex said in unison. Pausing to look at the other, frowning a bit.
“Yeah… if… if you wanna stay with HER,” Creeper-Chan said, pointing to the orange haired player beside her, “I'll be… okay. I'll just… leave, and be a little sad about it…” She admitted.
“And I'll happily be on my way if you pick her.” Alex said, “You pick me though, and we'll head right back to my base…” She said.
That sounded… interesting. You glanced back and forth at Creeper and her friends, and back at Alex, trying to think.
You HAD known Creeper-Chan more, and she DID seem to like having you around, even if she was a bit more rough and playful. It was just… glancing at the Zombie and Skeleton girls, you shuddered. Those two were much more of a handful… glancing at your wet green hands, you frowned. They had ALSO accidentally made you into slime, and probably would go right back to playing with you…
Staying with Alex was two-less people to deal with, and she was a player, so she could actually pick up and place things. But she had been happy to crush and use you as an insole, and probably wasn't too concerned with actually helping you regain your height or normal body…
This wasn't an easy pick… You bit your lip nervously as the girls grew more expectant and concerned the longer you stayed silent. Running over the pros and cons of each decision, you shut your eyes and yelped your answer.
“I pick…