______________________________________________________________________
DISCLAIMER
I am not a professional editor or critic. All the opinions in the following review are just that; opinions.
______________________________________________________________________
Hello!
This is my first review for the MHWA Challenge, and what a piece to kick it off with.
This was well-constructed, heart-breaking, and so beautifully written despite the very upsetting subject matter. It's not often that I read a poem on here that tugs so violently on my heart-strings, but you did an exceptional job.
You illustrated the torment of the "special" kid (as he was described) and the horrors that he has to experience without going into too much detail -
but what really impressed me was how you were able to pull the reader into the struggle of the narrator's dilemma about taking action themselves.
There were two stanzas in particular that really got to me:
The Prayer ▼
“God, help me find the strength
to do what I know is right.
Let me practice what I’ve been taught
to stand for the weak and fight.”
Having a prayer in here, especially one that is going unanswered despite being so pure and selfless, really adds something to the piece that I found I could relate to even as an adult.
and
The Conclusion ▼
I know that his small bruises
will all heal with time
but the wounds that I have witnessed
will last OUR whole lifetime.
This was really heartbreaking. In this moment you can almost read the defeat in the narrator as they realize that they're probably not ever going to find the courage they need to step up and do something, even though they know that it will haunt them in the future.
It touches on everything I liked about the poem, the implied bullying in the first line, the justification that can happen in the second, the acknowledgement in the third, and the haunting message in the fourth. This was a great conclusion to a great piece.
I also just have to mention that I love you included notes at the bottom, the quote almost served as a PSA about bullying, without coming across as trite - and the best time to make people care is after they've read a piece with a strong impact like this.
I do have one, tiny, nitpick of a suggestion, and it's for the final line.
Suggestion ▼
will last OUR whole lifetime.
^^ I know that "our" was done in all caps to emphasize it, but it's my personal opinion that the writing was strong enough you didn't need to do that. I think your words speak for themselves in this case, and maybe not capitalizing it would have looked cleaner.
Thank you so much for writing this, sharing it on the site, and submitting it to the MHWA Review Challenge.
Sincerely,
-Cat
______________________________________________________________________
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
______________________________________________________________________
My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!"
.