\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED ITEMS
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/my_feedback/action/view/id/4810100
Review #4810100
Viewing a review of:
 
Polka Dots and Sunshine Teardrops Open in new Window. [13+]
a child with a disability, a mouse in polka dots, and the kindness of strangers
by foxtale Author Icon
Review by Prier Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Access:  Public | Hide Review (?)
Polka Dots and Sunshine Tear Drops

Review By Prier


Summary
         The narrative, Polka Dots and Sunshine Tear Drops, recounts a poignant personal experience at Disneyland that rekindles the narrator's optimism and gratitude. Initially consumed by self-pity over his life’s disappointments, the narrator observes a young boy with cerebral palsy struggling to navigate his walker toward Minnie Mouse. Moved by the boy’s determination, the narrator intervenes, prompting Minnie Mouse to pause and interact with the boy. Strangers work together to clear a path, enabling the boy to meet his hero. This act of kindness transforms the narrator’s perspective, replacing his melancholic mood with a renewed appreciation for life’s small miracles and the shared humanity of strangers.

Strengths
         1. Theme and Meaning: The story beautifully conveys themes of hope, kindness, and the power of small, meaningful gestures to restore faith in humanity.

         2. Character Development: The narrator undergoes a clear emotional transformation, making the character arc compelling and relatable.

         3. Prose and Style: The writing is vivid, with descriptive language and emotional depth that effectively immerse the reader in the narrator’s experience.

Grammar and Spelling Errors
         1. Apostrophe misuse:
Example: “...squeezed the boy’ shoulder” – Should be “boy’s shoulder.”

         2. Verb agreement:
Example: “I’ve got to go, I stammered awkwardly…” – Should be “I stammered awkwardly, ‘I’ve got to go…’” to match proper dialogue formatting.

         3. Repetitive phrasing:
Example: “sunshine and L.A. smog!” is closely followed by “sunshine tear drops,” which may weaken the impact of the metaphor.

Constructive Criticism
         1. Pacing and Tension: While the story’s emotional climax is impactful, the buildup feels slightly uneven. The reflective opening is engaging but lingers too long before transitioning into the Disneyland scene.

         2. Setting/Worldbuilding: While Disneyland is described well, the surroundings could be more vividly detailed. For example, describing the atmosphere of Main Street or the sensory experiences (sounds, smells, etc.) would enhance immersion.

         3. Dialogue Authenticity: Some dialogue, such as Calypso Man’s lines, feels slightly exaggerated and could be toned down for greater authenticity.

Suggestions for Improvement
         1. Streamline the Introductory Section: Condense the opening reflection to quickly establish the narrator’s emotional state and transition into the Disneyland setting more efficiently.

         2. Enhance Sensory Details: Incorporate richer descriptions of Disneyland’s ambiance to ground the reader more fully in the world of the story.

         3. Refine Dialogue: Simplify and naturalize the dialogue, particularly for Calypso Man, to make it feel more realistic while retaining his unique voice.

         4. Clarify Emotional Shifts: Expand on the narrator’s internal realizations and make the transition from despair to gratitude more gradual and detailed.

         5. Tighten Prose: Eliminate minor redundancies and tighten sentence structures to improve narrative flow.

Overall Judgment
         This is a heartfelt and meaningful story that explores the transformative power of kindness and shared humanity. The vivid emotional arc and relatable themes make it an engaging read, while some minor adjustments to pacing, dialogue, and sensory detail could enhance its impact. Overall, it’s a touching and memorable piece with the potential to resonate deeply with readers. Keep up the excellent work—this is a truly good day of storytelling!

–Prier
R.O.A.R. Signature 2


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
   *CheckG* You responded to this review 04/08/2025 @ 12:35pm EDT
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/my_feedback/action/view/id/4810100