*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/icefairy/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/4
Review Requests: OFF
2,753 Public Reviews Given
2,800 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 3 -4- 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... Next
76
76
Review of Blood suckers  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with The Coffee Shop for the Fantas...  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Darkfairie,

Poetry is hard for me to review. I never have figured out the patterns for the different types.

I just read your wee poem, Blood suckers.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about vampires will like this creepy tiny poem.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The vividness of the words.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: a bit unnerved.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: Blood suckers -- either make blood suckers one word or you need to capitalize suckers.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.

*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
77
77
Review of The Nightmare  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Tobias,

I found your tale on the What's Your Nightmare? Round 11 contest page by BBWOLF Wants Premium 2/15/13.

I just read your wee poem, The Nightmare.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about dreams coming true will like this.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: That his dream came true.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: I’m not sure. This poem doesn’t make me sad, yet not happy exactly either.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*OTHER THINGS OUT OF PLACE:

*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: and silent moon eclipses (the) sun.

*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.

*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
78
78
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi fxsnowcloud,

Nice user name.

I found your tale on the A Flicker of Madness contest page AliceNgoreland (179)

I just read your wee tale, The Stairs Dark Wood.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read creepy tales will love this one.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The mystery of what was under the stairs.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Curious like the kid, I wanted to know what was under the stairs, too.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*Characters: The kid come across quite believable. He had to satisfy his curiosity.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: When I entered, cold chills trickled down my spine like rain dripping off wet hair. -- what a vivid description, I actually felt the chill.

This has the potential to become a longer and scary tale. I realize word limits that come with a contest can stunt creativity. I would love to know just exactly what was lying under the twisted tree. Was it his grandmother or something else? Who or what was wailing? This story has lots of possibilities.


*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.

*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
79
79
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


Hi Sarah,

I found your tale on The Bard's Hall Contest page by StephB 2013 Busy Bee.

I just read your wee tale, Meeting Strangers in Familiar Places.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about a possible love connection after meeting a stranger will like this tiny tale.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: That the gent kept coming back over a period of weeks before he asked her out.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Hopefully that they make a love connection.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*NAMES: Laura was a good choice for the lady baker. I like the mysteriousness of the fact that the stranger’s name wasn’t given.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*OTHER THINGS OUT OF PLACE:
She saw him step in just before noon, unwinding the soft grey scarf from his neck -- there’s a great big gap between the and soft.


*Cat*DIALOGUE: The dialogue sounds natural. I know who is speaking without the overuse of dialogue tags.

*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
80
80
Review of The Clean Up  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Gayle,

I found your tale on the Nothing Fancy contest page ran by Iva Lilly Durham.

I just read your wee tale, The Clean Up.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about traumatic problems for teens to endure will like this tiny tale.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: Elizabeth had to confront an adult issue that could very well destroy her family and she handled it extremely well.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Sad. Elizabeth’s world was turned upside down by her father’s betrayal.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*NAMES: You used a nice variety of names for your characters.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

OH DRATS!

Mom and dad (Dad) are at grandma’s.”

Why wont (won‘t) Kaye tell me?

She cannot (could not) remember a year her family didn’t go to Bear Lake.

Her mother wasn’t at most of the activities that her father arranged like the swims on saturday (Saturday) afternoons, horseback rides, and the sleigh rides down the mountain trail only to go home bruised and sore.

The sound of running water behind the closed bathroom door makes Elizabeth wonder what her father can (could) hear.

“What’s going on (comma) mom (Mom)?”

Elizabeth stands (stood) stiffly by the doorway, arms crossed in an ineffective attempt to protect her from the answer.

“What happened (comma) (Mom) mom?”

The scent of her mothers favorite body spray draws (drew) her to the bed.

Reassurance came with the warmth of her mothers (mother‘s) hand on her leg.

“What? With who? -- missing quotation marks

Words spewed out (of) a newly formed crater in her mind.

Regardless of the painful pin pricks, her mother will (would) protect the family.

Loyalties to her father are (were) unhinged.

Elizabeth skips her dads (dad‘s) homemade wheat bread.

The protection and cover of her mothers love will (would) continue to protect and heal the crater, that was left by the deception of her father.

And one day, all of this destruction will (would) be cleaned up and forgiveness will be the balm that heals the hole.


*Cat*LINE BY LINE:

*Cat*OTHER THINGS OUT OF PLACE:

*Cat*DIALOGUE: The dialogue sounds natural. I know who is speaking without the overuse of dialogue tags.

*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: She spoke slow as if there was a weight inside that held the words from escape. -- nice vivid description

She straightens her shoulders to face the volcano when all she wanted was to cram the lava back into the crater. -- nice description

She wanted to send words like daggers to his heart and tear a chasm equivalent to the one lacerating her. -- nice description


*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.

*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
81
81
Review by Ladybug
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Skip,

I just read your wee tale, The Padlocked Treasure Chest.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about curiosity getting the better of one’s self will enjoy this.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The girl learned a valuable lesson.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Glad nothing serious but getting scared silly harmed the girl.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*Characters: Both characters are believable.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

OH DRATS!
Once again I placed my hand on the key and and turned it. -- remove on of the ands


*Cat*DIALOGUE: The dialogue sounds natural. I know who is speaking without the overuse of dialogue tags.

*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
82
82
Review of Sea of Stars  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Daddy Ziok,

I just read your wee poem, Sea of Stars.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about warriors coming to realize that dying in a war isn’t worth what they left behind.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: You told a story in the form of a poem. Nicely done.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: Sad. So many wars are fought for no good reason.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

OH DRATS!
I lyed in the grass, with the sun on my face, -- lyed should be lay


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
83
83
Review of The Last Dragon  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Kaya ,

I just read your wee tale, The Last Dragon.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about dragon and the Loch Ness monster shall like this wee tale.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The tale is about dragons, one of my favorite mythical creatures.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Sad that Kreylures ended up all alone in the loch.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*NAMES: Kreylures is an unusual name, yet is fitting for a dragon.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

See line by line


*Cat*LINE BY LINE: Moonlight skipped across the water of Loch Ness. Cold wind blew over the surface causing the reflected light to dance. The only sounds were the lapping of the water against the shore and a low keening sound. Anyone who chanced to hear it would attribute it to the wind. No one would ever guess that what they were hearing was the lonely cry of the last dragon. This is her story. nice desciptive opening paragraph

Her name was Kreylures. She had lived with her family in the Loch for as long as she could remember. It was the only life she ever knew. By the time she was hatched her family had been in the Loch for thousands of years. But she knew that dragons hadn't always been there. Once, dragons roamed free.

Her mother once told her a story; when the earth was new, her kind lived in the sea. Water that reached beyond ever. Ancient dragons, traveling as a group deep into the Loch chased a large school of fast, tasty fish. They filled their bellies and climbed onto the shore to bask in the warm sun, just enjoying the day. As they napped the earth began to shake; in just a few moments the Loch was closed off from the sea, trapping six dragons inside.

At first they tried to find a way back to their beloved sea. Two of the swiftest set out together trying to find a way over the land. They were to return as soon as they found an escape route. Ungainly, they walked across the land, hind legs carrying most of their weight, using the elbows of their small, gray wings for balance. The group could hear them for several miles, but eventually they moved to far away to even mindspeak. Every day, one of the dragons left behind would go to the farthest point of the Loch, yelling with all of their mind...no one answered. The four dragons waited many years for them to return. They never did.

The two oldest dragons died when pale tall-walkers came. Being very old they enjoyed warming themselves on the shore. The tall-walkers attacked them with hurting long sticks, even though the dragons screamed at them with mindspeak to 'STOP!' They refused to listen and killed them both! Her parents watched them carry off the dead, dark gray bodies stained with death blood.

The loss of the two eldest left her father and mother alone in the Loch. Freeze moved over the land and water, white and bitter, food became hard to find. Nothing changed for a long time; Always cold, always hungry. Eventually, the sun came to warm them once again and so they had Kreylure. They taught her to swim fast and dive deep. They showed her how dragons
can could glide over the water for long distances. They taught her to avoid the shores during the day. Most importantly they taught her to never let the tall-walkers see her.

It was a good life for many years, but uneventful for the little dragon. Until the day the tall-walkers began floating on the Loch. They came in large groups, floating on giant wooden leaves. They hunted the fish of the Loche and they hunted the dragons. But dragons were smart and learned to avoid the tall-walkers. Eventually they were left alone except for the occasional times they came upon one of the tall-walkers by accident. If a tall-walker did happen to see them they would point and jabber incoherently, sometimes they would make a high call that hurt their ears. Sometimes they would even throw things! Kreylure thought it was a shame that the tall-walkers didn't make more sense.

As time passed her mother and father grew old and feeble. Their backs stiffened and bowed, it became harder for them to catch the fast fish. One day her mother fell asleep and never woke up. Her father followed her mother by only a few years. Their bones were soon covered by silt on the bottom of the Loch. Kreylure was left alone.

The only company she has now is her reflection upon the water. Her skin is gray, her neck is long, her scales shine like the color ribbon that crosses the sky after it waters. Her eyes are large, brown and gentle. She can dive to the very bottom of the Loch, but she can't find her way to the sea.

Now she sits at night, basking in the glow of the moon, alone. Maybe, someday the land will shake and open the Loch of Ness to the sea again. Maybe she will find others like her. Until then she will wait.


*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: You have a nice wee tale here, yet it‘s told more from the author’s point of view instead of from Kreylures‘.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
84
84
Review of The Locket  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with The Central Bank  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Shaara,

I just read your wee tale, The Locket.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about gypsies will like this tiny tale.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: It held my attention even if it was very short.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Wishing there was more to it.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*DIALOGUE: The dialogue sounds natural. I know who is speaking without the overuse of dialogue tags.

*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: She was an enchanting young thing, this Gypsy maiden, her hair streaming with wet. Her lips were touched by cherry wine, her eyes like the mists over a cold, dark lake. -- I love this description. It’s very vivid.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
85
85
Review of Epiphany  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Charlee,

I just read your wee poem, Epiphany.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read poetry will like this.


*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The vivid images the words create.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: A wee bit sad. I can hear this soul‘s loneliness.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
86
86
Review of Rainy Night  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Stormy Lady,

I just read your wee poem, Rainy Night.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about making love before a fireplace will love this tiny poem.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The rhythm of the words.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: It made my pulse stand up and take notice.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
87
87
Review by Ladybug
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Prosperous Snow,

I just read your wee tale, On the Pier at Lake Lune.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about mysterious happening in the fog will love this wee tale.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: That something sinister didn‘t happen to Rhea.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Wishng there was more to this tale.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

OH DRATS!
“Because Pop always said that fish bite better in the fog,” he cast the fishing line into Lake Lune. -- the comma should be a period, then capitalize He


*Cat*DIALOGUE: The dialogue sounds natural. I know who is speaking without the overuse of dialogue tags.

*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: On the pier that day, the fog crowded around us like last minute shoppers on Christmas Eve. Noises emanated from the fog. They sounded like voices whispering to me. I could not understand precisely what they said, but their tone sent chills up my spine. -- nice description

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths. {/size

*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
88
88
Review of The Promise  
Review by Ladybug
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Shannon,

I just read your wee tale, The Promise.


*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: How brave Liliane tried to be.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Angry and outraged that the Jews were rounded up like cattle, taking to camps, experimented on or killed because of a madman.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.

*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
89
89
Review by Ladybug
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Powdered_Toastman,

I just read your wee tale, The Night Of Broken Glass.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about a young person’s dreams of a save future will find this a heart breaking tale to read.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: All the wonderful descriptions you used to create a picture in the reader‘s mind.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Angry and outraged that folks hate other folks simply because of their religious faith.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

See Line by Line


*Cat*LINE BY LINE:
The howling wind turned the drops of rain into icy daggers that were whipped up into spirals, endlessly seeking out victims to saturate with their piercing cold.
nice vivid description I slowly edged my way forward along the cobbled street, arm in front of face in a futile effort to ward off the waves of water thrown up from the pavement. Leaning forward to compensate for the buffeting wind, I pulled my pathetically small raincoat around my neck and wished that I lived closer to my school.

Not that we had much choice. We being Jews. There were only a handful of places that we could go in the city then, let alone schools. Even then there were the stares. Those sideways glances and narrowed eyes that follow your every move, waiting for you to do something wrong, to step out of line. The ever-wringing hands just waiting for an excuse to grab you by the neck and shake you, shake you until all the wickedness, all the potential wrong doing, everything that makes you Jewish is left on the ground. Until all that remains is a perfect, pure, Aryan citizen.

Well that won’t happen. Mother says that we are all put on this earth for a reason; I think that if that reason is to be constantly trodden on by the Germans like dirt then I’d very much like to meet the person who put us here.
need a space here
The warm and yellow, yet sparse beacons of light provided by the gas lamps fought a losing battle against the inky and oppressive blackness of the already mature night. The driving rain blurred everything, making colours run together until the yellow of the lamps threatened to bleed into the surrounding black. nice description

The ever-increasing lateness made me nervous and I increased my pace to a speedy walk, punctuated with continual glances behind me. I reached the street where my father owned a shop, increasingly rare for a Jew. He would still be working and although he would be angry that I was out so late I was looking forward to a respite from the rain. Along the way I passed other, grander shops, each with intricately patterned curtains and beautifully hand painted signs. While the colours, lettering and borders differed, the messages remained quite the same: ‘Jews not admitted’, ‘Jews enter at their own risk.’ Or perhaps the simple, foolproof and ever-popular; ‘No Jews.’

Faint sounds of shouting seemed to drift down the street, accompanied by louder, more ominous sounds such as crashing and low thuds. Up ahead a German mother and her son hurried through the rain in large, expensive leather coats. Upon seeing me, she pulled the child closer to her as if I was going to somehow infect him. I felt like crying out with all the force of an entire lifetimes’ worth of oppression, to collapse in front of her begging to know what I had done wrong and what I could do to make it better.

But I didn’t. I kept walking, head bowed, tears mingling with the rain until they were one and the same. I kept walking as the pair crossed the street to avoid me. I didn’t stop, as I passed the signs glaring down at me, daring me to enter, to test their wrath. I never faltered, as I thought of that boy and his potential, his future and the wealth of decisions and experiences that lay before him.

I thought about what I would do if given those same opportunities, what I could make of my life. For an instant I forgot about the numbness of my limbs and lapsed into my favourite daydream; a classroom full of young chattering pre-school children and me in front reading them stories and pointing out all the wonderful things that Jewish people had done for the world.

As quickly as it came the image faded; washed away by the insistent rain. I imagined what would happen if people found out what I was thinking. There was nothing more absurd than the idea of a Jewish teacher; what better way to poison the minds of precious young Germans.

Wrapped up in this impossible reality, I didn’t notice that the door to the shop was open, or that most of the front window was missing. It wasn’t until I walked inside and saw a tableau of utter chaos that I realised something was horribly wrong. Through the darkness I could see the dim outlines of broken jars and toppled tables. The floor was strewn with everything from flour and salt to tomato soup and fruit. I started backing out of the shop but slipped up in the doorway and landed on my back with a thud. The sudden breaking of the silence was all I needed to rush out of the shop in a blind panic, uncaring of the tempest that awaited me.

I headed nervously towards home again, a thousand explanations running through my head, each more disturbing than the last. Before I had made it to the end of the street I stopped dead in my tracks, the colour draining from my face and into my shoes. Not wanting to more than anything else in the world but knowing that I had no choice, I slowly raised my hands in front of me.
bring My father up behind in front of me
My father didn’t sell tomato soup.

The crimson wet that stared back up at me was like a stab through the heart. It took all my willpower not to throw up on the street as I fought to swallow bile. There was no rain now, nothing to wash it off, nothing to do except run, run for home faster than I ever had before. My legs were as lead and my head a feather, threatening to float away and leave my body to deal on its own. Still I ran, as fast as I could, faster than I could, not noticing or feeling anything but the rhythmic pounding of my feet and heart and the distance to my home that stubbornly remained the same no matter how fast I went.

The sounds grew louder and more threatening until I could hear individual voices rising over the others. They seemed passionately angry and hateful but I could not guess at what could make so many people so furious. Now accompanying the frightening sounds was the acrid smell of burning, the smell from fires that burn indiscriminately through wood, plastic and rubber. Perhaps worse things. Completing the almost surreal environment was a red flicker that grew over the horizon, reflected in the clouds and pillars of smoke now rising on all sides of the street.

Confusion, fear and paranoia swelled up inside; the closer I got to my home the more I knew deep down that nothing could prepare me for what I would find. The streetlights went by in a blur and the wind, now void of water, tried its hardest to deter me from my destination. I noticed nothing, one thought and one thought only burning in my mind; to reach home and to reach home before…before anything happened; I just needed to get home and be with my family, nothing could happen before then.

I found myself praying as I ran, surprising myself as I had given up on it a long time ago, after all how could a merciful and loving God prefer one race over another? Stupidly and inexplicably I thought of my grandmother and how proud she would be if she knew of my regained (if circumstantial) faith. I did not even know who or what exactly I was praying to, just that I wanted my family to be safe, for everyone to be safe. I made up for a lifetime of stubborn atheism by devoting my entire being and belief into this moment.

“Please God may my parents be waiting for me in the doorway. Please grant speed to my failing limbs so that I may reach them in time.”
My home was just around the corner now and the background noise had risen to a climactic cacophony of violent sounds that caused violent images in my head.
“Please let my father scold me for being out before telling me of his accident in the shop.”
Suddenly there were people everywhere, running to and from my street; some yelling and others crying
“Please let me get there, I have to be with them, I have to be there…”
Ten more strides and I would round the final bend, in sight of my home; seven…six...five…
“Please God let me reach my family, I need to go faster, please let this be a mistake, I have to get there, I must…”
this block of the story needs to be spaced

I was much too late.

*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*WHAT I DIDN’T LIKE: That this is written in 2nd person. This could be a much more powerful tale written in either first or third person.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
90
90
Review of CLASH!  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Novalyyn,

I love your user name. Nova is the first four letters of my last name. My middle name happens to be Lynn.

I just took a peek at your contest page, Original Character Tournament.

*GlassesB*APPEAL: Those who like challenges when it comes to creating characters will find this an interesting way to create a new character.

*UmbrellaP*WHAT I LIKED: You’ve made a challenge out of creating characters.

*UmbrellaP*The rules are easy to read and understand.
*UmbrellaP*Due date is clearly posted.
*UmbrellaP*Word count is stated.
*UmbrellaP*Rating is stated.
*UmbrellaP*The contest tells the reader how to post her entry.

*UmbrellaP*GRAMMAR AND PUNCTUATION: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
91
91
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi I am me,

I just read your wee poem, We Flew Once, Wilting Rose.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about dying will find this an interesting poem to read.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The emotions the words invoked.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: Sad.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
92
92
Review of Ghost's Linger  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with 30 Day Image Prompt Contest Co...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi evening_star,

I just read your wee poem, Ghost's Linger.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about lost love will find this an enjoyable read.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The longing I could hear in her voice, wishing her man was still there.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: A wee bit sad, she lost her man.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
93
93
Review of On Goldenrod Road  
for entry "Blackjack Creek
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with Novel Review Group  
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Milhaud - cat's too busy,

*Key*Title: Blackjack Creek

*Key*Author: Milhaud - cat's too busy

*UmbrellaP*APPEAL: Those who like to read about young men and their fishing holes will enjoy these two tiny tales.

*UmbrellaP*WHAT I LIKED: Gary‘s determination not to get wet again and to capture the unknown critter of the creek.

*Key*Plot: Fast moving.

*Key*Referencing: modern-day

*Paw*You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Key*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view I’m in.
*Paw*Did point of view change without any warnings?

*Key*Characters: Gary comes across as the typical teen-year old.

*Paw*Grammar:
My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

See Line By Line


*Key*Line By Line:
Young and green and growing up in the country, I lived in a kid kid’s paradise. It was the best of all possible worlds. I didn’t have many worries; I liked to fish; and Blackjack Creek was just down the hill.

At ten years of age and living in a more secure and less complicated world, my parents allowed me to take the mile long hike down the hill to fish. I wasn’t an expert fisherman, but I did okay – a half dozen trout from six to eight inches in length – not enough for a feast, but enough to fry for dinner. After all, who cared if we ate them; the fun was in the catching.

But, alas, like a minnow breaking water when catching a bug, a flaw surfaced in this perfect world. Every time I fished Blackjack, Blackjack claimed a victim . . . me. I could never quite complete a fishing trip without falling in. Wet to the hips, wet to the knees, wet to the ankles, my fate was sealed. Unfortunately, my mother never let me forget it. “Wet again, Gary? It seems like you can’t ever come back from that creek without fallin’ in.”

“But Mom! I really didn’t fall in. I just slipped on an old mossy log and got my pant leg wet.”

“Just like I said, you fell in and got your pants wet. Now, go ahead and change in the utility shed. There’s a dry pair lying on the old steamer trunk.”

“But Mom!”

“You heard me! No 'ifs, ands, or buts' about it. Go ahead and change.”

Like a broken record, the scene repeated each time I returned from fishing the creek. How humiliating! Ten years old and still treated like a baby!

Finally, one warm, June day, I resolved not to “fall in” while fishing Blackjack Creek by planning caution in advance. Returning home, I would even put on a public display of dryness in front of my mother. It was a challenge, and I resolved to win. My trip home would be totally and undeniably dry. So, my facial muscles taut with determination, down the water-filled, potholed road
comma (it had rained the night before)period (It had rained the night before.) I marched with my fishing pole propped against my shoulder.

The word that best described my fishing trip that day was “careful.” I was careful when crossing logs, careful when stepping from rock to rock, careful when traversing the slippery banks, and careful when casting my line. So careful, I avoided some of the best fishing spots. I only caught two fish during that expedition, but looking at my watch that read four o’clock, I experienced the warm glow of triumph. I wasn’t wet. My mother couldn’t accuse me of “falling in” this time.

So, triumphantly homeward I trudged up the bank, through the trees, across the meadow filled with fragrant, flowering blackberry vines, and up the potholed, dirt road. My pace quickened as my house loomed before me.

The picture in my mind came into focus: strutting through the gate, making a full turn in front of my mother. “See! Dry, Mom!” I could imagine my mom’s slack-jawed, surprised expression.

Prancing along, I performed a quick, practice turn, a little jump in the air, and “splash.” I landed in an ankle-deep pothole and managed to soak my trousers all the way to the knee.

Crestfallen in defeat, only one course of action remained. Slogging the rest of the way up the road, I quietly opened the gate and sneaked into the utility room to change into the dry pair of pants awaiting me. Why make excuses?

After all, my mother wouldn’t believe a story about falling in a pothole anyway?

2

The Mystery of Blackjack Creek

Blackjack Creek always seemed predictable. I could count on the area surrounding the stream to be darker than normal – sunlight filtered by broad-leafed foliage, spreading its umbrella over the flowing water. During most of the year (except for fall when the salmon were running) I caught an abundance of rainbow and brook trout. A lingering dampness saturated the air even on the hottest days, and moss always hung like blue-green beards from the tree branches and dressed fallen logs in frayed, green overcoats. Mud and decomposing leaves drenched the air with the musty scent of decay. Just the percolating sounds of the creek and the swish of the breeze in the tree leaves kept me company. I would pretend that I’d stepped back in time to a solitary life where hunting and fishing meant survival.
nice description

One day, however, something mysterious happened that changed the predictable pattern of Blackjack. I trekked down the hill for a few hours of fishing one day when I was about eleven. Along a familiar stretch of creek, I began casting my line into some swirling eddies that often produced a decent catch.

I used an old pole equipped with black, rayon fishing line, weakened from too many years of use. Slow fishing described the day – some nibblers, but no takers. Suppressing a yawn, I padded my way across a mossy log to a new pool formed by the surge of spring runoff.

Tossing my lazy line into the water, I allowed the current to carry it near a huge submerged log. My mind drifted like the haze in the trees above the creek. Like a robot, I retrieved my line and cast again. A water bug skipped across the pool, and in the shallows near the bank minnows darted back and forth at flashing right angles. Ready to move farther down the creek to the next hole, the tip of my pole twitched and then dipped. My muscles stiffened. That feels like a big trout, I thought. Much too soon to prepare myself, with a tremendous yank the pole bent double. It nearly flew out of my grip. Before I could react, the line slackened, and the pole rebounded to an upright position. Hoping that the creature was still attached, I reeled in the line, my hands shaking. But there was nothing. I gazed at the limp line in amazement. Absolutely nothing remained. No bait. No hook. No sinker. No swivel. All gone!

Trembling with excitement, my frantic fingers worked to repair the shambled line. Fumbling through my fishing kit, I moved in slow motion. In twice the time it should have taken, I readied myself. With great care, I attached the worm and cast my line once again onto the calm surface of the pool, causing only a slight ripple. I readied myself for the big strike. I turned the reel knob, watching the leader crease the surface of the pool. I gathered my line, and cast again. Then again. After several more attempts – nothing.

The furious fish that had seized my bait a few moments before had either fled the scene or lurked in hiding. Daydreams and a lack of preparation had robbed me of my chance to catch the submerged giant. But a chance at what? Was it the granddaddy of all rainbow trout that ever lived in Blackjack? Was it a migrating salmon that had lost its sense of time? Or was it some unknown lurking monster of the depths? Only one certainty remained. Every time I cast my line into Blackjack I hoped and prepared for a big strike of a skulking creature that never happened.

Author's note: while true that the identity of the creature still remains unknown, with time and knowledge, I can now make an educated guess. Most likely the “monster” that had dismantled my fishing gear that day was a steelhead trout. At the time I had never heard of a steelhead, a sea running species of rainbow trout. Like a salmon, this large sleek, fish returns to spawn in the same stream where it hatched and can grow to a weight of nearly twenty pounds. But, unlike a salmon, a steelhead continues its voracious feeding in its home waters. After spawning, it survives the ordeal to return to the sea.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*


Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
94
94
for entry "Day 1: Banana Casket
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with 30 Day Image Prompt Contest Co...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi A*Renewed*Faith!,

I just read your wee poem, Day 1: Watch and Bananas.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read Haiku poetry will like this tiny one.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: It‘s short yet the words paint a nice picture.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: It made me smile.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
95
95
Review of DragonWrites  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi DragonWrites~The Fire Faerie~,

First, I love your user name.

I just took a peek at your images and signatures, and decided to take a peek at DragonWrites.

*TieDye1*WHAT I LIKED: The dragons and the colors used create an inspiring image.

*TieDye1*APPEAL: Those who like dragons will adore this image.

*TieDye1*The image matches the title quite well.
*TieDye1*The colors used are eye catching and appealing.
*TieDye1*The words stand out nicely against the background and do not block the image.
*TieDye1*The image is easy to see and I know what this signature is.

*ThumbsUp*Great job.


*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
96
96
Review of The Gift  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi A*Renewed*Faith!,

I just read your wee tale, The Gift.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about mysterious orbs of magic will like this tiny tale.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: This tale sets up a mystery to be solved.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE MADE ME FEEL: Curious about what will happen.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this tale was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*POINT OF VIEW: I know who's point of view the story is being told from.

*Cat*OTHER SUGGESTIONS/COMMENTS: I wish there was more to this tale. Why does everyone want her gift? Just exactly what does this gift do? Can she trust Angelo or not? There are so many possibilities with this tale.

*Cat*FLOW: This story is told in a logical order. You didn’t overload this tale with a lot of foreign words and used a variety of sentence lengths.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
97
97
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Dr Taher,

I just read your wee poem, The Death of An Ex.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about putting on a brave face when you have lost someone you loved to death will like this poem.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: That Mrs. Atkin was grieving for her ex-husband.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: A bit sad.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
98
98
Review of Clouds in the Sky  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with The Coffee Shop for the Fantas...  
Rated: E | (5.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Tim,

I just read your wee poem, Clouds in the Sky.

Cloud watching and letting the imagination run wild with whatever the mind conjures within the clouds is a fun way to spend an afternoon.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about clouds will love this tiny poem.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The hint of magic within your words.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: Free and flyaway.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
99
99
Review of Time for me to go  
Review by Ladybug
In affiliation with The Coffee Shop for the Fantas...  
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi Ida,

I just read your wee poem, Time for me to go.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about completing suicide will like this tiny poem.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The sadness the words created.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: Sad and lonely.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

OH DRATS!
I was born in lately sixties -- I think late sixties would be better, just a thought


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
100
100
Review by Ladybug
Rated: E | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

Hi super sleuth,

I just read your wee poem, All Hallow's Eve.


*Cat*APPEAL: Those who like to read about Halloween will love this tiny poem.

*Cat*WHAT I LIKED: The vivid pictures your words created.

*Cat*HOW THIS TALE OR POEM MADE ME FEEL: A wee bit scared.

*Cat*TITLE: Your title caught my attention and drew me in. It made me curious to discover what this poem was about.

*Cat*FORMAT: This is easy to read and understand.

*Cat*SETTING: You used a nice balance of imagery and well written words that made me feel as if I am there.

*Cat*GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION/SPELLING: My editing skills are not the best in the world, yet I try my best to let the author know if something looks out of place, misspelled or missing.

Seems to be alright.


*Cat*FLOW: This poem moves smoothly from beginning to end.


*ThumbsUp*Great job.

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams -- Eleanor Roosevelt

*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*My review is only my humble opinion, and is only meant to be helpful to you, not discouraging. I don’t wish to offend or upset anyone. If you don't agree with something I said or suggested, that is your right as the author. No matter what though: Keep unleashing your imagination and let it fly where it wishes! -- Janet Novak
*ConfettiV* *ConfettiP* *ConfettiB*

Ladybug

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
874 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 35 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/icefairy/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/4