*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/shylah/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/5
Review Requests: OFF
521 Public Reviews Given
711 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 3 4 -5- 6 7 8 ... Next
101
101
Review of Sydney  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (5.0)
That's a great photograph of her. I can certainly expect that she could do that to a board. It almost looks as if she's just been preening a little prior to the photo being taken and she almost seems to be waiting for it to be taken before returning to that.
102
102
Review of Grandpa's Bell  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
Nice story of an old man recounting a story from the war to a young child. It was really entertaining to read for me.

I liked how you wrote the ending and brought the story full circle to fully explain the situation between the two men. Nicely done, good work.
103
103
Review of Crossing Over  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
I thought this was good and descriptive. Well worded to describe that experience in poem form. I liked how you referred to it as taking off or sailing off in the last line. But the bleakness of the current situation is also evident, and written as a vast change from younger days. Very true. Well done.
104
104
Review by Shylah
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
Nice poem. I thought it summed up the description about blindfolds of love coming off really well. Spoken by the person who put more, or felt more in regards the the relationship.

Although I can hear the tone of anger and perhaps slight irony behind the words, so it's not just hurt feelings being dealt with. Good work.
105
105
Review of Surfing the Waves  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
I thought this was good to read, the reference to a breakup and the experiences afterwards, blending it with surfing was a clever idea.

To me the last paragraph summed it up nicely and provided a type of closer letting the reader know what the current situation was for them. Well done.
106
106
Review of Lady Serenity  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello. I’m reviewing for SFWG.

Reviewer: Shylah

Type: Short Story

Additional Comments: SUGGESTIONS, IDEAS...

I found this story interesting to read. As with your comment at the end, I didn’t find the part in blue affecting it that much in a bad way, if at all. I thought it was good showing the diversity between her imagination and actual reality. The story ended well too, letting the reader know that she wasn’t giving up on her imagination. Nicely done.

NOTE:

The typos I found, I replaced corrected in red text.
The punctuation and grammar challenges I found, I replaced with green text.
All other comments, questions, thoughts and/or plot challenges, I listed in blue.
107
107
Review by Shylah
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Hello. I’m reviewing for SFWG.

Reviewer: Shylah

Type: Short Story

Additional Comments: SUGGESTIONS, IDEAS...

That was really interesting to read. I liked how it ended with them both returning then leaving anything else up to a continuation or sequel. Nicely done.

Spelling, punctuation and grammar challenges:

The morning arrived far too quickly and, needless to say, I was not thrilled with the idea. I’d promised Emily that we would spend the day walking around London, and she was already awake and bustling around the hotel room. She caught sight of herself in the mirror and began tugging at the rubber band in her hair. I couldn’t help but laugh.

NOTE:

The typos I found, I replaced corrected in red text.
The punctuation and grammar challenges I found, I replaced with green text.
All other comments, questions, thoughts and/or plot challenges, I listed in blue.
108
108
Review of The Whispers  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello Smokejumper! I’m reviewing for SFWG.

Reviewer: Shylah

Type: Short Story

Plot and Setting: Deciphering whispers.

Additional Comments: SUGGESTIONS, IDEAS...

Interesting story, I found the twist at the end amusing. Good work.

Spelling, punctuation and grammar challenges:

He was shouting at the top of his voice. “What are you doing boy? Stop shuffling and look into my eyes. I said look into my eyes. The final is just a day away and you’re still good but I need your best. Wake up, damn you!” And he slapped him hard.

He answered and thanked them all. As he was moving towards the team, a
reporter shouted. “Can we call you a whisperer?”

NOTE:

The typos I found, I replaced corrected in red text.
The punctuation and grammar challenges I found, I replaced with green text.
All other comments, questions, thoughts and/or plot challenges, I listed in blue.
109
109
Review of Learn to Fly  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
That was a good descriptive story about a person out in a huge storm on the edge of a swollen river where everything seems like water. Having it emphasised, the aloneness, was well done also. Almost as if they won't be missed, at least not at first. Nicely done.
110
110
Review of The Coffee Shop  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
That was an interesting story that could have gone either way, but to me it seemed that she was responding to a reflection. Nicely done.

There'as only one thing I'd suggest. The sentence below, the last word. Should it read just - behind?

As she walks by me she smiles and nods her head leaving all of her thoughts behinds.
111
111
Review of Flower  
Review by Shylah
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hello. My name is Shylah and I am one of the reviewers for the:

Weekly NEWBIE Challenge  (E)
LEARN - Bitem Format, Emoticons, etc., and receive Reviews
#989394 by ~*~Damiana Returned~*~


I thought this descriptive piece about a flower was nicely done how you portrayed the images of the flower's experiences in all weather and times, daylight as well as night. Good work.
112
112
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hello. My name is Shylah and I am one of the reviewers for the:

Weekly NEWBIE Challenge  (E)
LEARN - Bitem Format, Emoticons, etc., and receive Reviews
#989394 by ~*~Damiana Returned~*~


I found that to be an accurate story of a stressed family under more stress from an accident such as that. The ending was good, I found his muteness at the end amusing. Good work.
113
113
Review of The Last Job  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Hello. My name is Shylah and I am one of the reviewers for the:

Weekly NEWBIE Challenge  (E)
LEARN - Bitem Format, Emoticons, etc., and receive Reviews
#989394 by ~*~Damiana Returned~*~


Yes, I agree, the words, one last job. Never goes well for the participants. I thought the ending was good, how you wrote the attempt at framing that failed. I'm leaving the dialogue alone as I assume that's how Joe speaks normally. Good work.
114
114
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Hello. My name is Shylah and I am one of the reviewers for the:

Weekly NEWBIE Challenge  (E)
LEARN - Bitem Format, Emoticons, etc., and receive Reviews
#989394 by ~*~Damiana Returned~*~


I see what you mean by the twist at the end, good work to incorporated it. I can understand that situation would be as scary to them as a ghost would be. Nice dedication at the end too.
115
115
Review of Invader  
Review by Shylah
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
I thought this was an interesting and entertaining poem to read. Showing that the speaker knows exactly what the situation is and happy to continue, not wanting things to change. Content with thoughts, dreams and imagination. I thought it was well done.
116
116
Review by Shylah
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
Hello. My name is Shylah and I am one of the reviewers for the:

Weekly NEWBIE Challenge  (E)
LEARN - Bitem Format, Emoticons, etc., and receive Reviews
#989394 by ~*~Damiana Returned~*~


That was an amusing story to read in a way, with the partly expected ending. Cleverly constructed though to write it with a sense of humour even though it clearly wasn't funny at the time. Nice work.
117
117
Review of Walk Together  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
That was a nice poem to read, showing a couple fully committing to each other and expecting troubles, but allowing for them and saying how they will approach them as well as describing the good times, accepting all and moving on together. Very nicely done.
118
118
Review of Touch Me  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
I thought this poem was really nice. You described that theme of a light touch that seems to come from nowhere really well. Nice work.

The lines I liked the best were -

What if next time was the last time?
How long would I wait for her return?
Forever?
Forever, and a moment more.
119
119
Review of Lost Dreams  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
Good story of a bad situation they found themselves in and how Jeremy had already decided off his own bat that he was a disappointment to her. The ending made me wonder if she'd expected something else and it stopped in a good place to let the reader imagine on. Good work.
120
120
Review of TRUST, Chapter I  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
That was an interesting start. Having it written in diary form with the dates caught my eye. That's something different for me.

The ending is in a good place. It made me hope that when she does put whatever plan into action, in that case, tomorrow, that she can live with it when and if she finds out what the misunderstanding was. Good work.
121
121
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Interesting story. it appeard to be written completely from his observations some time after the fact. Neat idea, well done.

I just have one suggestion with the part paragraph pasted below. I took out the second to last word - was. See if it helps.

.......and you could only see her disinterest in the way she played with her hair more than usual.


She treated your mother deferentially. She smiled and nodded whenever your mother made an observation about you, and you could only tell when she disagreed by the narrowing of her eyes. She let your mother talk to her at length about the benefits and parties that took up so much of your mother's time, and you could only see her disinterest in the way she played with her hair more than was usual.
122
122
Review of The Sea  
Review by Shylah
Rated: E | (4.5)
That was an interesting poem comparing his fear to the ocean currents, describing how the feelings, when they first sweep him away, he panics. Then after a while, he gets used to it, and prefers to remain as he is then.

That was good, I liked it. Well done.
123
123
Review of When Doves Cry  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I thought this was great to read. Centering a story around a phone call, in this case, devastating and having the woman recieving it have flashback memories as she was given the news.

I thought it was very nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
124
124
Review of The Skirt  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I enjoyed this short story that highlighted what it must have been like then when it came to bucking the trend in relation to school uniform guidelines.

The ending was very good. Showing the reactions of the other girls the next day and leaving it up to the reader to imagine if the authorities actually managed to do anything. Nicely done.


** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
125
125
Review of Sally  
Review by Shylah
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
This story was really good. Complete and entertaining with the small wordcount. I especially liked the question she posed at the beginning of the first paragraph. Having it end when she is emerging into a new future was well placed. Great work.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
185 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 8 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/shylah/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/5