*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/troubadour/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11
Review Requests: OFF
882 Public Reviews Given
2,600 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 7 8 9 10 -11- 12 ... Next
251
251
Review of Clocks  
Rated: E | (2.0)
Well, you have an idea, you've put it into black words on white paper. Now you need to finish it. The "to be continued" will be a promise kept, I hope.

However, I quote:
"...surface tckeld [TICKLED?] his fingertips, it was as if an unknown ghost had entered his body an [AND?] filled him..."

Revise, edit and revise again. I notice you are a brand new member. We have a spellchecker available in the item toolbar at each editing session and you may copy/paste from your computer. It is not necessary to write directly online as one does in a chat room.

These are silly errors and writers should not count on their readers to correct them. That's a sure way to have a very low rate and for people not to comment about your literary content but only on the form which is lacking.

Keep writing. It's the only way to learn how to do it.
alfred
252
252
Review of Beautiful  
Rated: E | (3.0)
I don't know how many views you've had. The story doesn't work because you have described Fiona as non-human. There are no humans with three eyes and four noses. If you want us to take your story seriously, you, as an author must be serious.

Make her fat, give her a bulbous nose, make her flat-chested, make her eyes be crossed behind thick glasses, make her poor and poorly dressed in rags, and we will recognize her. You do not need to spoof in an exaggerated fashion her bad looks in order to make your point.

As for the morale, I did not get it. Don't expect your readers to have your intelligence - i.e. to know automatically what's going through your head at the moment you write your words. All authors know more about their characters than their readers do, simply because they are the products of their imaginations. Without treating your reader as a moron, it is always best to spell out too much than leave out details, assuming incorrectly that your reader is following every train of your thoughts.

The idea for your story is good. No, it cannot be presented to the public too many times for we have been educated to only look at the outer beauty. You have not told the reader about Fiona's inner beauty. Just that Eli sees it. Does she collect flowers, does she take care of wounded animals, does she know the answers in class but is too timid to say them? These are all things which will establish her inner beauty for the reader. As you have her described, we can only feel sorry for her ugliness; you haven't given her many qualities to admire, inspite of her ugliness.

There are many details which, once added to this story, will make it stronger and hopefully give you a few kindhearted readers who will review or rate it.

alfred
253
253
Review of Shadow  
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a nice poem, maybe a tad too short, but you say everything with simplicity and sincerity.

I have only one change to offer :
"but neglect, it is"
The IT IS is awkward here. Since you want the extra emphasis, not having written "but neglect is", why not try "This is" or "That is"?

Keep writing!
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
254
254
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
You've written a poem of love and longing and it worked very well until the mega-line:
As they buried me underneath the ground where I lay.
This marrs the visual, rhythmic and poetic aspects of the poem you set into motion until that moment.

Can you not take this sentence and build it into its own stanza, the surprize stanza, so that it matches the rest of your poem? Then, you'll have a great poem.

Keep up the good work.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
255
255
Review of Iron and Ore  
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is a lovely poem, about nostalgia and reviewing one's past. The word choice is excellent, colorful and your imagery is striking.

You do all of this with a simplicity and conciseness which makes the poet in me jealous. Bravo.

One tiny detail - if I have understood the poem correctly, would it work to write the following?
"It took years to RETURN here."
I think this would be a better verb. Your original "get" implying "get back" is a weaker word.

An excellent read and one I would recommend to my fellow poets here on WDC.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

256
256
Review of The scarechosis  
Rated: E | (2.5)
Even if you are trying for some dramatic effect to heighten the terror your character feels, you must write proper English. That means a space after periods and commas. Beginnings of sentences must have a capital letter. This lack of respect for the reader's comfort makes your story (which I didn't understand anyway) impossibly hard to read.
I wonder if you took the time to proofread this?

Here on WDC we are not obliged to write online like one does in chat rooms. We can copy/paste text into windows from our computers and take advantage of spellcheckers. Although we have one here at our disposal.

Keep writing, but make sure you have a text which says exactly what you want it to say, with proper punctuation, capitalization, spelling and presentation. If you are serious about your writing, readers will take you seriously.

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
257
257
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is excellent. Your grandmother had a talent with words. It is moving and the pastoral descriptions in the opening are sublime.

It is common practice here on WDC for the reader's comfort to single space between the paragraphs. There are several other places where you need to go back into the text and realign the lines so that there are no line breaks in the middle of sentences.

Thank you for sharing this story. Unfortunately, there are many women in the world, millions too many, who could write the same elements, if given the chance to express themselves.
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
258
258
Review of 7 days of sorrow  
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a beautiful poem, maybe about suicide after a lost love, maybe about not finding God's promise, there are possibilities for interpretation.

You have many little details which could be revised.

*Bullet*On the day of love,
I saw sun rising

You write THE day in the first line, I would keep the form constant with THE sun in the second line.

*Bullet*Even birds are falling from the sky.
I will fall in temptation

Personally I tend to avoid repeated words preferring the richness of synonyms. "Even THE birds plummet from the sky..."

*Bullet*Escaping, and leaving ashes behind.
All without a sound.

Death falling from a cliff will not leave ashes. "Escaping, not even leaving ashes behind..." would be one solution. "Wet ashes" might be another.

*Bullet*Iron hand doesn't know mercy.
Neck will break in half.

I don't like your lack of articles here. "AN iron hand, or Iron handS DON'T" and then "MY neck..." Although these words are more or less understood, such abbreviations of the proper syntax make your poetry flow a bit unbalanced.

*Bullet*He's breaking my wings for a long time now
"He's BEEN breaking.." is the correct verb here.

*Bullet*What asleep, shall be brought to daylight.
I do not follow your use of "asleep" for dreams. At least that is how I read this line. You need to be precise with your word choices if you want the reader to follow the path you have in your mind.

*Bullet*On 7th day, sanity is gone.
Locked in walls of hidden castle,

Once again there are three articles missing here. In free verse, without a restriction in line length, you do not need to eliminate the "obvious" words. Poetry is all about line flow.

*Bullet*Glowing, while breaking us up.
This line still needs work. I do not follow your path.

*Bullet*But not touching ground.
Even mud on my face can't hide happiness

Here is an example of where you may choose to eliminate the articles. Mud and happiness are plural and abstract words, and the lines read just as well as if you had written "Even THE mud on my face can't hide MY/THE happiness." Although between you and me, I don't follow this line either.

*Bullet*Thousand doves can't erase, Here though, you need either "A thousand doves" or "ThousandS OF doves..."

Aside from these details, and many are related to your desire (at least it seems to me) to reduce the word count in an attempt to be more poetic, the body of your poem is well constructed and you express your emotions with a limited scope, but I personally like the restraining.

Keep up the good work,
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
259
259
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
From the title, the reader guesses what you are going to write about. I would have preferred a surprize. What you have written is powerful. You make no judgements, you just show. Excellent work.

You have changed the title once on this poem. I am not sure you have found the right one yet. The line "suffer the little children" is a good one, although for me it also has a connotation that big people just have to suffer through having little children. In any case, I would end the poem with this line, or some revision of it. Doing so will plainly state your position as part of the body of the poem and not just the title.

I wonder, yet again, about finding a more neutral title. I agree, 27 reasons that make me angry" was not right either. But "suffering 27 times again" might be another answer. Titles are so important. (And just for the purists, there are not 27 acts of suffering mentioned in your poem.)

In the body of your poem, only one stanza really bothers me:
a tub
filled with scalding water and one
tiny
unprotected
arm
I don't like the spacing of the last three lines. The tiny burned hand in the following stanza is just as hideous, yet you don't give it the over-punctuation you do with "tiny unprotected arm." I would write these three words on a single line.

And true to myself, I am sure you could find a substitute for one of the two "tiny" which in my opinion are too close together at the end of the poem.

There is still a bit of work to do, but you have nine tenths of an excellent poem.

Keep up the good work,
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
260
260
Review of Tiananmen  
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a beautiful poem. There is not much needed to make it perfect.
In Tiananmen, there was a real need, for defiance. This need was clear worldwide. The need you evoke here in your poem needs explanation. I am hard pressed to understand why the sister was taken out of a stable family environment. As it is stated here, it is an aberation. Unless the child was going back to her natural parents. A stanza explaining what happened before the poem's drama will strengthen the link you want to make with Tiananmen Square, I think.

At the end, you mention a specific time. This bothers me because it is an unnecessary detail. Since you are using free verse and not hampered by line length, you could use something like "after dusk" or "after dinner." Or the other solution would be to place the defiance in the driveway at a specific hour of the afternoon therefore balancing the "At 9" at the end. I would also write out nine.

Lastly, I'm not sure of the end. I like that you have broken the couplet rhythm for your conclusion. My first reaction was that I would not personally have brought the poem back to HIM in Tiananmen, but said something like "why didn't this tank stop for me?" But now I'm not sure. But that was my gut reaction.

A wonderfully poignant story about the love that takes place even when there is no blood bonding sisters.

Keep up the good work,
alfred
261
261
Review of Do you notice?  
Rated: E | (4.0)
This is a well written poem about marriage. You have used a form in the first three stanzas that places your question in the first line. I would have maintained the form throughout the entire poem opening your fourth stanza with the question. Your rhyming scheme was perfect.

I personally tend to avoid the laziness in repeated words. In your opening lines you write:
"This powerful and safe feeling,
The feeling you feel in my company,"

While this represents typical conversation, poetry is a way to express ourselves in a more colorful way, using synonyms, meter and rhyme, things we do not do daily when speaking or when writing certain types of fiction where dialogue is more important than descriptive passages.

So I would get out my synonym dictionary, if no words come to mind, in order to replace at least one of the "feelings."

Other than this very personal detail, you have a well crafted poem.

Keep writing,
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
262
262
Review of Sensing You  
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
Wonderful, Darth. Intellectually poignant and very well thought out. It's been a while since I've read any of your poetry, and you always have the knack of surprizing the reader with your diversity.

I tiny thing bothers me in your line :
"And love is all of this".
In my opinion it would be stronger to write
"And all of this is love."

Excellent work,
alfred
263
263
Review of Heaven  
Rated: E | (4.5)
You've written a very moving poem about the simplicity of life as you knew it as a child.

For me personally, your poem goes two stanzas too far, for the force of your fourth stanza coming to a halt with the words "welcomed us to heaven on earth." is hampered by the busier stanza about life in the city and the sadness of your return home, to find everything gone astray. The choice of a decrescendo at the end is of course yours, but when your crescendo leads brilliantly to the most peaceful moment in the poem, I question the utility of the rest of the poem.

But that's only one man's opinion.

Thank you for the sensitivity you employ, through carefully selected words, which do indeed take the reader along your path of calm memories.

Keep up the good work
alfred
264
264
Review of What Not to Write  
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
As is usual, an excellent selection of good sense, well documented and well presented. Your articulate thoughts are well worth consideration and I think most of us have something to learn from the ideas you put forth so convincingly.
An excellent read, and the articles you plug, many of which I was not yet familiar, perfectly complement your ideas.
Bravo
alfred
265
265
Review of Dreamer  
Rated: E | (3.5)
What I liked
I like this poem. The general form is good and you succeed in saying what you want.

Your first stanza is fun, almost light and airy. It did not lead me directly to your second stanza, which was something completely different, and, I must admit, a certain disappointment. Although it too is well written, I am uncertain that the two belong together.

*Idea*Suggestions
There are, however details which bother my aesthetic sense.
*Bullet*"if I tried harder than anyone before me." The before me sounds forced. I would simplify with the obvious anyone ELSE.

*Bullet*muscles forged to hardened steel
born of iron will and lava hot desire.

Hardened steel is a catch all phrase. Iron will is too. Both of them right next to each other are too much, in my opinion. And since I'm here, I would hyphenate lava-hot. Unless you want the meaning to be lava like hot desire, in which case I would write it that way.

*Bullet*I dreamed that when I solved and cured
the sickness of bigotry and hatred,
all those around me treated each other

In the second part of this sentence, you need the same tenses - 'all those around me WOULD TREAT each other"

*Bullet*I imagined a place where differences
held hands warmly with the norm,

Here I don't like the common word "norm." Sure we all say it, but it's not a very pretty nor poetic word. Since you're not hampered by meter, I'll let you find your own substitute.

*Bullet*There is a noticeable difference in the quality of writing in your last stanza when comparing it to the preceding ones.
But that was a long time ago,
another life, certainly not mine.
Perhaps I was born a dreamer
with more imagination than common sense
silently searching for hope and goodness
in barren and hostile lands.

This is the kind of writing I would prefer to see throughout the poem. It flows and is not hampered by catch-all phrases or abstract words. It more resembles the opening stanza in its freedom.

Overall impression
There are many good things happening in this poem. I think maybe a bit more conscious control of what you want to occur in each part of the poem would help its overall layout.

Keep up the good work!

** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


266
266
Review of A Single Tear  
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Sensitivity, sincerity, simplicity. Three supporting elements which help you write a good poem.

I especially like the repeat phrase used at every couplet - so many young poets give up the formula at one moment or another and it ruins the poem. You have known how to use the technique to your advantage and you have done so in a convincing manner to create a poem with unity and balance.

Good work. Keep writing,
alfred
267
267
Rated: E | (3.5)
As a professional pianist, I appreciate this homage to your violin. It is sweet and sincere. The comparison with your beloved is not complete in my opinion. It is a tad too discreet.

I do, however, object to the following lines:
"within hollow chambers
of past failures"

for they don't seem to have any justification here. The rest of the poem is upbeat and although these are lovely lines, maybe they have their place in another poem.

And again, I have a good guess why your last line uses such a strong term of endearment, but I would not do so if describing the violin. We love our instruments and the joy they give us, but our "beloved" is a human being. In my mind, if you decide not change the ending of the poem, the last line should read "MY beloved."

And if, as I suspect, you are speaking about your beloved at the very end, you need just one more detail, well placed so that we are sure that you are speaking about the love of your life and not the violin. I am all for mystery in poetry, and write much myself which can be interpreted in many ways, but here your final line seems incomplete.

"Beloved song of my heart," is still vague, if that's what you're looking for, but there is enough in that phrase to point us equally in both directions.

All in all, you have written an interesting poem in which I discover more depth as I reread it to more accurately comment it.

Thanks for sharing,
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
268
268
Review of The Window  
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is superlative in my mind.

It continues to send shivers down my spine. Beautifully written in a concise and sparse manner, but the emotion is overflowing and it has connected to some place deep inside of me that I do not know but makes me ponder.

The power of words is extraordinary and yours have done their job of catching ahold of this reader and not letting go.

One tiny error:
"The doctors ran tests. They pocked." You want to write POKED.

Without hesitation, I recommend every reader out there to take the time and read this small story.

My sincere compliments to the author
alfred
269
269
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Kay has undergone a marathon of poetry, written from prompts and using different styles for each one. There are many good pieces here and three excellent ones. Here we have a poet interested in trying new forms, not afraid of experimentation and on the way to becoming one of our new Preferred Authors.

My highest compliments for the thirteen poems in this folder. More of us should do the same thing, if not as a learning exercise.

Keep writing
alfred
270
270
Review of Untitled  
Rated: E | (3.0)
For the time being you have nothing original in your list poem. It tells us nothing new about a subject many of us are familiar with. You use "dreams" twice and "wishes" are too much like dreams for us to get involved with your poem. What your poem needs is seven extra lines describing your list. Here is my example, and this is in no way a means of re-writing your poem, simply showing you what might, in my opinion, make it better.

So many stars
         I never make wishes
so many places
         where is my adventurous spirit
so many dreams
         how to make them come true?
so many faces
         when did I last say hello?
so many wishes
         may Grandpa die without suffering
so many dreams
         may I live a good life, like him
so many times
         I should have said I love you
too many wasted.


This poem now tells us what I mean with your SO MANY lines. Find your own intermediary lines and I'm sure that you will start to have reads AND rates on this poem.

Keep writing,
alfred
271
271
Review of The Twirling Ends  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
I like this poem a lot - your organisation is wonderful and the story unfolds well. But one detail is missing - how and why did the cage get stuck?
A good read,
alfred
272
272
Review of Lurking Raven  
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
The technical aspects of this Sonnet are mastered beautifully. Each stanza is independent of the others, the progression from the beginning of the poem to the final couplet works very well.

But I am not drawn into your poem.
Phrases like "bloody battlefield", "overflowing hospital wards", "flickering flame", "deadly disease" and that's just in the first stanza, are too pat and typical. Your word choice is frequently very standarized and lack the tinge of original colorful description which makes good poetry.

From what I've read of your port, you have a good command of the language so finding less traditional synonyms every now and then should be no problem, even within the constraints of your Sonnet's form.

Keep up the good work - you're on the right path
alfred
273
273
Rated: E | (5.0)
This is an excellent poem, in spite of the free verse- or because of it -- you imitate a former style exceptionally well. You have said everything which needs to be said so that the reader discovers what must be discovered, and you have done so with much mastery.

Two tiny details, however, bothers my musician's ear:
and ask no favor of life: for in my old, ugly age,
The adjective "ugly" is a hard word to use in an otherwise elegant poem. Your choice of vocabulary is refined and this word sticks out like the proverbial sore thumb. Can you not find another one to replace it?

The second of my hesitations concerns your title. It is just a tad too intellectual for my tastes, and I must admit that even after a hasty research on Alcibiades, it is not still clear to me. Perhaps an authors note explaining briefly your choice?

I am in admiration of this poem and look forward to reading more of your poetry,
alfred
My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
274
274
Review of Tonight  
Rated: E | (4.0)
There is a lot I like about this poem. I think, however that the beginnng episode with the mouse is not essential to a poem which describes an encounter.

I like your unifying idea of a rhyming scheme, but often it does not work. I counted four pairs which do not form full rhyme.

I also like your attempt to organize your poem into four line stanzas, but you rarely finish a stanza so that it stands on its own, using too frequently wrap-around lines between lines inside of a single stanza and, even worse in my book, between two different stanzas, for my personal taste. They work well in free verse. As part of the structure of your poem, aabb rhyming scheme and consistant wrap-arounds between the stanza, I feel you have tried to do too much.

In general, dividing up a long poem into multiple stanzas helps the reader find his way through the poem. It is also a way that a poet may seperate his ideas, or, as is frequently the case with free verse nowadays, play around with space which in theory is supposed to accentuate certain words

or ideas

so that the reader grasps
a

better hold
of them.

I agree with the theory behind the new poets' experimentation with space within a poem, I do not agree that it has a consistant place in a formated poem which has a rhyming scheme.

So, the upshot would be, yes for a wrap-around line every now and then, they are useful and show that a poet is "with it." But in my opinion you have overdone it here.

My suggestion for the visual aspect of this poem would be to write three large stanzas, as follows:

We meet. Somehow I see your stoic face.
At the same time, you see mine, through the race
Of grumbling lightning storms. Bodies twist violently,
Spin like compasses in a magnetic frenzy,
Needles unsure of which direction to go.
You scan for a smile, a point you know
Will secure you in space for awhile. And you stop
At a familiar door. I answer your knock,
Having been cooped up too long in my cluttered house.
You notice I'm quiet, obsessed with the mouse
That scratches a riot in my walls. I keep
Trying to trap him. He nibbles my ear as I sleep,
Slowly gnaws the small bones that rush the world in.

We cross somewhere between heartache and sin
To settle for this madness. We sit down to rest,
As travellers do now and then. It is best
Not to let our eyes lock too often.
Such gestures raise questions, what it would mean
To speak of peculiarities or subtle honesties. We agree,
However, that love is a dream. As we leave,
We'll reminisce of past nights like this, and might even touch.

But we will say nothing that reveals too much
Of the secret of why we come here. It's a place
We roam for reasons unknown. The embrace
Of the music and sweet honey drink blacks out the fear.
The chilled air and calculated charms will endear
Me to your unaccustomed arms. I will sink
Into them, as rage gives to screams. The thick
Fog lifts at the instant of an accidental kiss.
From the start all signs were leading to this
Clearing. Tonight we revel and smoke and sing
Into the startled morning. The day will forget the whole thing.


This gives a unity to the three blocks of your poem, maintains your rhyming scheme which is hidden, but nonetheless evident upon reading (and which better hides the occasional lopsided rhyme) and thus your poem becomes an exercise in overlapping lines, but not stanzas.

Keep up the good work. Although I object to the present form of your poem, its contents pleases me (except for the mouse part) and in my opinion would benefit from a different presentation.

alfred
My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
275
275
Rated: ASR | (4.0)
It's a great story, but you left out the most essential part - why did you stop performing?

As a professional musician, I hear your involvement, your love for music, and your enthousiasm. It's not just any kid that goes through school performing in all the ensembles available to him. So what happened?

Even if you didn't have what it takes to become a professional musician, in every university there are amateur groups, especially if the school has no formal music program, so why did you stop?
That to me is the most interesting part of your story - you mentionned in its beginning that your performance days had come to an end, you said "retired" -- but you do not tell us why.

When you do, in my opinion, your story will be finished.

On a purely technical level, your paragraphs are frequently too long - I would advise cutting them up. Since they are so full of information and not purely descriptive mood-setting paragraphs, it would be easier for the reader to find out where you said this or that in smaller units.

A very good story, filled with all sorts of adventurous details and a pleasure to read.

Keep up the good work
alfred
My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Go Noticed.
293 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 12 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile.php/reviews/troubadour/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/11