*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/pennywise/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3
Review Requests: OFF
187 Public Reviews Given
443 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... 1 2 -3- ... Next
51
51
Review of Mistaken Identity  
Review by Pennywise
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
~~Image ID# 1403151's Content Rating Exceeds Item Content Rating~~


Overall Conclusion


This story got me right at the beginning paragraph. Not many do that, so a BIG thumbs up to you *Thumbsup*. And the pace keeps constant throughout - except for a couple of places, which I mention below. That said this is a good story and well written, I'd nearly figured out the twist, though came up with the wrong monster.

And let me say, I am so happy you didn't make this a love story *Wink* .

Kept to the Prompt - 10/10

Cannot fault you here - spot on.

Kept to the Rules - 10/10

I thank you.

Originality - 9/10

I've read another story similar to this, as it takes place in a tunnel, and our supposed hero follows the monster inside, though the similarities end there - and that one didn't have a twist. So, good job.

Grammar - 8/10

*Star* Nice use of the word "gaiety" - hats off for that *Wink*

*Exclaim* "It seemed that I walked for hours"

*Question* Though this sentence is not incorrect there is a "Pesky Word" here which can be eliminated to help safe much needed words and make the sentence flow better. Try - "It seemed I walked for hours" - I also think it falls nicely with the style you're using for your narrator.

*Star* "tunnel of death" - I love this - I think I may put this up as the next prompt in the contest, or use it for a story myself.

*Exclaim* "His voice, not what I expected. He spoke with an ancient tone, powerful and eloquent."

*Question* The way you have these two sentences set up is a little awkward, when they would work so well when joined. Try - "His voice, not what I expected, spoke with an ancient, powerful, and eloquent tone."

*Exclaim* "His dark eyes seemed to be able to stop time."

*Question* At this point in the story, we're at the exciting finale and you're doing well until I hit this sentence, and the speed of the roller-coaster takes a dramatic brake.

It's the "seemed to be able to" part that is very passive and caused the brakes to come on - try to keep it sharp and powerful as with your opening paragraph. Try - "His dark hypnotic eyes stopped time."

*Exclaim* "his voice beckoned but his lips did not move."

*Question* You used "but" in the previous paragraph and this one doesn't feel right to your narrator or the style you're writing in. I would try - "his voice beckoned though his lips did not move." I think this is more like they way your narrator speaks.

Dialogue - 9/10

I do think you could've drawn out the conversation at the end of the piece to give the reader a little more insight, but apart from that - another good job.

Characters - 7/10

Writing in the first person narrative is difficult to fill out characterizations within the story. I do think you could've added a few more personal (and probably, paranoiac) points to the narrators character - after all what causes a man to take up arms and hunt down a terrorist in a city - is he police, army, security. That said the story works as is, but I think it would make a great "Full" short story.

Pace and Flow - 9/10

Apart from the parts mentioned above, which slowed me down, this story was one hell of a coaster ride - the kind that starts with a 0-100 in 3 seconds blast. Then picks up speed right to the end. *Thumbsup*

Feeling / Emotion - 9/10

The feeling and emotion are brought to the reader via the sharp, succinct, and descriptive sentences. The only thing which suffers is that you don't really get to know the main character, as mentioned above.

*Star* GREAT OPENING PARAGRAPH - well written short powerful punches of sentences, drive your message across and the end sentence made me stop and think, OK now we're getting into it.

Please remember any opinions which are given, are given in the spirit of helpfulness - If you do not agree with my opinions then please feel free to ignore them - after all this is YOUR story (be true to it and yourself) *Wink*

Thank you for taking part in the contest - hope to read more from you soon.

Please feel free to check the new prompt,

"Absolute Horror Flash Fiction Contest"   by Pennywise

and the Monthly Contest with more GP's to give away.

"Absolute Monthly Horror Contest"   by Pennywise

Come join me - We ALL float down here.
PENNYWISE
52
52
Review of Coin Toss  
Review by Pennywise
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Cover & promo for Absolute Horror Writing Contests.


Overall Conclusion


This is a good little story which has the premise to be slightly extended and "filled" out. I know you have a penchant for psycho's, this time a doctor, but I would've so loved to see some form of the Occult, Paranormal or Supernatural in here as well. Or at the very least, the reason for his foul deeds - Most psycho's are created.

Kept to the Prompt - 10/10

Kept to the Rules - 10/10

Originality - 7/10

Psycho Doc's aren't that new, though the cattle prod was inventive - but surely the leather straps would leave a mark?

Grammar - 9/10

Early on in the story a few of the sentences feel quite passive and a little long winded (but that could just be me *Smile* ) - However, in the second part of the story the pace picks up nicely and keeps going 'till the end.

*Exclaim* "Leonard body convulsed"

*Check2* Should be "Leonard's body convulsed"

Dialogue - 10/10

Right length for the piece and realistic to boot - good work.

Characters - 7/10

Not much in characterisation in this short piece as you have four characters portrayed in so few words. I would've cut the other two's parts down and built on the main characters of the Doc. and Leonard, trying to get the reader to empathise with either of them a little.

Pace and Flow - 8/10

As I stated above the first few paragraphs are a tad bit slow, where as the second part steams ahead.

Feeling / Emotion - 8/10

I think you did right to go with the shock value in this story - though a little more fright on the kids behalf would've gone down well.

Please remember any opinions which are given, are given in the spirit of helpfulness - If you do not agree with my opinions then please feel free to ignore them - after all this is YOUR story (be true to it and yourself) *Wink*

Thank you for taking part in the contest - hope to read more from you soon.

Please feel free to check the new prompt,

"Absolute Horror Flash Fiction Contest"   by Pennywise

and the Monthly Contest with more GP's to give away.

"Absolute Monthly Horror Contest"   by Pennywise

Come join me - We ALL float down here.
PENNYWISE
53
53
Review of The Groupie  
Review by Pennywise
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
Cover & promo for Absolute Horror Writing Contests.


I enjoyed this story, though when the syringe came out I knew kinda where we were heading with the plot. And when you mentioned the mannequin, I knew the dreaded truth (When I become a Rock God - leave the girls with BIG boobs alone *Smile* ).

This is a very well written piece which deserves more Ratings and Reviews.

Overall Conclusion


Kept to the Prompt - 10/10

What can I say, it is a Rock Stars Nightmare.

Kept to the Rules - 10/10

Everything's there as I asked for, thank you kindly.

Originality - 5/10

This was the only let down in the whole story - a psycho groupie (I understand there's lots of them about *Smile*

Grammar - 10/10

Didn't find any errors or typo's anyplace - Good work *Thumbsup*

Dialogue - 10/10

Even though there's very little of it, you used it well to add to your Groupies character.

Characters - 9/10

As I said above, you used the dialogue well with the groupie, though I think the Rock Star would've been pleading a little more, with fear.

Pace and Flow - 10/10

Well written throughout, and was an effortless read - *Thumbsup*

Overall Feel - 7/10

In the "captive" second half, I think you need a little more fear, especially where the Rock Star is concerned. Maybe a little more sycophantic love from the groupie wouldn't go amiss either - though it would probably take you over the 666 word limit, if you added everything I said - unless you did a major rewrite. *Wink*

Please remember any opinions which are given, are given in the spirit of helpfulness - If you do not agree with my opinions then please feel free to ignore them - after all this is YOUR story (be true to it and yourself) *Wink*

Thank you for taking part in the contest - hope to read more from you soon.

Please feel free to check the new prompt,

"Absolute Horror Flash Fiction Contest"   by Pennywise

and the Monthly Contest with more GP's to give away.

"Absolute Monthly Horror Contest"   by Pennywise

Come join me - We ALL float down here.
PENNYWISE
54
54
Review of Lab Boy  
Review by Pennywise
Rated: E | (5.0)
~~Image ID# 1403151's Content Rating Exceeds Item Content Rating~~


Overall Conclusion


A job well done - I liked this piece a lot, and though there are some strands of horror and sci-fi, I think the character and the drama would make this a great read for anyone.

In fact I ask anyone that reads this review to read the story - I don't think you'd be disappointed.

You got the tone and narrative for your narrator down, right from the start; and the opening line sets everything up.

The only drawback was that I missed you usual descriptive text - which wouldn't have gone with this
story - so good job. *Thumbsup*

Kept to the Prompt - 9/10

"Those nasty diseases can't kill us all" isn't exactly "They can't kill us all" but what's life without a little writers "artistic license"?

Kept to the Rules - 9/10

About 590? You're telling me, you didn't count them *Wink*: There are actually 582 words (not including the title) - but what's eight, tiny words, between writers *Smile*.

Originality - 9/10

What with the setting and the simpleness of the character I couldn't help myself from thinking of The Stand and "M. O. O. N. That spells Tom Cullen" - thanks for those memories, I loved that book and especially that character.

Grammar - 10/10

Nothing found and nothing noticed in my read throughs.

Dialogue - 10/10

Since the entire story is a monologue and you pulled it off splendidly.

Characters - 10/10

Only one character her, and you did a great job in making him realistic within the wordage limits - very good job.

Pace and Flow - 10/10

Easy and steady pace to this one. It doesn't meander and it doesn't race - it kinda keeps time like a trusted grandfather clock, from the start to the conclusion.

Overall Feel - 10/10

It's loaded with a happy sadness, the feelings portrayed by the narrator keep the story strong and alive, while everybody is dying around them.

Please remember any opinions which are given, are given in the spirit of helpfulness - If you do not agree with my opinions then please feel free to ignore them - after all this is YOUR story (be true to it and yourself) *Wink*

Thank you for taking part in the contest - hope to read more from you soon.

Please feel free to check the new prompt,

"Absolute Horror Flash Fiction Contest"   by Pennywise

and the Monthly Contest with more GP's to give away.

"Absolute Monthly Horror Contest"   by Pennywise

Come join me - We ALL float down here.
PENNYWISE
55
55
Review of My Plea  
Review by Pennywise
Rated: E | (4.5)
Dear Lady Joy,

I enjoyed this short and succinct poem and I wholly agree with the sentiment.

More people should read this poem and take heed; for the consequences are dire should our Earth die.

Thank you.

Come join me - We ALL float down here.
PENNYWISE
55 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 3 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://www.writing.com/main/profile/reviews/pennywise/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/3